RecordWell Data

_04012026-10805

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Apr 1, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City of Charleston Commission on History April 1 , 202 6 , P age 1 City of Charleston History Commission April 1 , 2 0 2 6 A meeting of the History Commission was held this date beginning at 4 :0 0 p.m. at City Hall, 80 Broad Street. Notice of this meeting was sent to all local news m e d ia . Present: Harlan Greene, Chair, Elizabeth Chew, Peg Eastman, Wilmot Fraser , Brittany Lavelle Tulla, Angela Mack, David McCormack, Ken Scarlett, and Dale Theiling. L in k to m eetin g : h ttp s://w w w .yo u tu b e.co m /w atch ? v= D O eh h IU t5xU & t= 68s A. Call to Order Chair Greene called the meeting to order . B. Minutes 1. March 4, 2026 On a motion of David McCormack, seconded by Peg Eastman , the Commission on History voted unanimously to approve item B1 , as amended. C. Presentation on the Name of Hampton Park by Dr. Hector Qirko Dr. Hector Qirko introduced himself and gave a presentation. He explained that the name of Hampton P ark was an important issue . It was a highly visible, highly valued part of Charleston. It was named after Wade Hampton, Governor of South Carolina from 1876 to 1879, and Senator from 1879 to 1891. Dr. Qirko continued, saying that there were increasingly problematic aspects to that history. First, that he was a Confederate general. Second, that he was from one of the largest slaveholding families in the Southeast, and his own personal slaveholdings were estimated to be between 900 and 3,000 people. Third, that he promulgated the Lost Cause myth of the Civil War, recasting the War to minimize slavery as an issue and recasting it in more morally just and heroic terms. Fourth, that while running for Governor and as Governor, he was a part of the Redeemer Movement, which aimed to reassert White conservative leadership in South Carolina and was affiliated with the Redshirts which attempted to violently repress Black voters. He permitted Redshirt meetings in the Governor ’s Mansion. Dr. Qirko said that for those four reasons, the name was problematic and renaming it was at least worth discussing. He felt there were lots of elegant alternatives from its history. He suggested City of Charleston Commission on History April 1 , 202 6 , P age 2 “Memorial Day Park ” and “Memorial Park ” because it could be argued that the first Dec oration Day (which would later become Memorial Day) occurred there. He said the best counterargument was tradition. He said calling something a tradition merely described it as longstanding and did not describe the content as being good or not good. He asked the Commission to consider reevaluating the name of Hampton Park in light of the history presented. Commissioner Chew asked if the Park had always been named Hampton Park. Dr. Qirko said that it was renamed to Hampton Park after Wade Hampton ’s death. Commissioner Chew asked when the area had been made a park. Chair Greene said that it was made a park after the 1901-1902 Exposition and that it had been privately owned before that. Dr. Qirko said that it was a racecourse first. Commissioner Theiling asked why the four reasons Dr. Qirko cited were not enough to prevent the Park from being named Hampton Park at the time. Dr. Qirko said that the Park was named after him not in spite of those problems, but because of them. He said that it was a part of a movement to name monuments, streets, etc., to support the Lost Cause movement and philosophy. It was named for him exactly because of the four problematic things cited. Commissioner Fraser said Dr. Qirko ’s explanation was interesting and informative. He felt many other names should be reviewed for similar reasons. He said that the Park was used as an internment camp during the Civil War and that many Union soldiers had been buried there and subsequently moved to the U.S. Cemetery in Beaufort. The Park became important because African American children decorated the graves of the soldiers who had brought a greater measure of freedom to their society. He felt “Memorial Day Park, ” though quite formal, was a good example of how to name things to make them have meaning. Commissioner McCormack asked Dr. Qirko where he would draw the line at renaming things in Charleston. He said that without a line, one could d enude a lot of South Carolina history. He said diversity and inclusion includes people one might not agree with. He felt that continuing down this road would leave Charleston with nothing related to the Confederacy, even though much of what happened in Charleston was related to the Confederacy. He felt that doing so was very troublesome. Dr. Qirko said that the initiative was not about erasing history and that it should be looked at on a case-by-case basis rather than a general policy to change all names related to the Confederacy or anything else. He felt that the name of a park was an endorsement of what that name stands for. Some sites and their names would carry more symbolic weight than others. He said that the goal was not to erase history, but he felt they should not be endorsing any set of values that they did not believe in. Commissioner Scarlett said there was a long history in the area. It was Augustine Prevost ’s campsite in 1779 and where the battle of the old racecourse was fought. The Pulaski Legion took about 43 casualties, as well as Colonel Michael Kovats de Fabriczy , and that gravesite had never been found. Commissioner Mack said that several years ago, a report came out of a committee discussing the approach to the naming and renaming of various monuments, streets, parks, etc. She suggested going back to that report to address the issue. Chair Greene said that as State law stood, cities were powerless to change the name of any City of Charleston Commission on History April 1 , 202 6 , P age 3 street, public place, etc. that memorializes a war. Being debated in the Senate that day was an amendment to make it so that nothing could be changed without a unanimous vote of the General Assembly. The City would be breaking the law if they were to change the name of the Park. It was a part of a larger issue. Commissioner Eastman said they were celebrating the 250 th anniversary of the United States. She felt that if they were to change the name of the park, they should celebrate that. Chair Greene said that it would be possible to place a marker or plaque explaining the history behind the name of the Park and its entire history. Dr. Qirko thanked the Commission. Chair Greene thanked Dr. Qirko. Dr. Fraser said that the law keeping cities from renaming places was obviously restrictive of freedom of speech and could be challenged on those grounds. He asked Dr. Qirko not to be discouraged by the recalcitrance of the legislature. D. Draft Resolution: Re-seat the Marion Square Commission (Requested by Commissioner Fraser) Commissioner Fraser explained the below proposed resolution: Draft Resolution 1 Re-seat the Marion Square Commission and establish a public review process Draft Resolution, Commission on History Re: Marion Square governance, transparency, and future monument review Being aware that Marion Square is among Charleston's most prominent civic spaces, used year-round for public gatherings, commemorations, and community events, and Being aware that decisions affecting Marion Square, including the placement of monuments, markers, and interpretive materials, have significant public consequences, including consequences for historical accuracy, community trust, and public order, and Being aware that the City historically established a Marion Square Commission in 1882 , structured to oversee Marion Square in a public manner, and that available records indicate this commission operated for many decades and was active through 1998 , and Being aware that the absence of an active, public commission process creates confusion over authority, reduces transparency, and invites unilateral action in a space that functions as a public square regardless of underlying title, We, members of the City of Charleston's Commission on History, humbly and respectfully propose the following: 1. That City Council re-seat the Marion Square Commission in accordance with the City's existing ordinance framework, including City of Charleston Commission on History April 1 , 202 6 , P age 4 appointments by City Council, representation from the militia side, and chairing consistent with the ordinance structure. 2. That the City direct appropriate staff to provide City Council and the public a clear memo summarizing the Marion Square Commission's ordinance authority, appointment requirements, and recommended operating procedures, including meeting frequency, notice requirements, and recordkeeping. 3. That once re-seated, the Marion Square Commission establish a written, public facing process for review of any new monuments, plaques, markers, signage, or other interpretive installations in Marion Square, including: public notice, an opportunity for public comment, historical accuracy review, and a clear record of decisions. 4. That the City request that the Marion Square Commission coordinate with the Commission on History, the Board of Architectural Review where applicable, and other relevant City bodies so that future decisions are consistent, transparent, and defensible. And, that the Commission on History offers its assistance in developing historically grounded review criteria and public-process standards so that Marion Square is governed by public principles and not by surprise or private discretion . Commissioner Fraser said they lived in a new era, and Charleston should not try to recall and venerate obvious evil that existed in their past. He argued that the agreement between the City of Charleston and the Board of Field Officers of the Fourth Brigade was not legal. On a motion of Commissioner Fraser, seconded by Commissioner Scarlett, the Commission voted unanimously to take a recess at 4:38. The meeting resumed at 4 :4 2. Chair Greene asked Ms. Julia Copeland, Corporation Counsel for the City of Charleston, to provide a historical and legal history of Marion Square. Ms. Copeland said that she used minutes and deeds from the 1800s and Dr. Nic Butler ’s work on the Charleston Time Machine in her research. She said that in in 1833, City Council did deed to the Board of Field Officers of the Fourth Brigade a deed in trust for the initial six acres for Marion Square in trust that it be a public mall and parade ground. Part of that was to demolish several buildings that stood at that time. This was meant to be done within 50 years. By 1882, not a lot had been done to further the condition of the square. In minutes from 1882, Mayor Courtenay gave a great history about the relationship between the Board of Field Officers of the Fourth Brigade and the City and all of the efforts put towards revitalizing the Park. At the 1882 meeting, Council created the Commission on Marion Square. The purpose of that Commission, from what could be surmised from the minutes, was to help the Board of Field Officers of the Fourth Brigade and the City come up with a plan to bring the park up to the condition that was set out in 1833 when the property was initially deeded. City of Charleston Commission on History April 1 , 202 6 , P age 5 One month later, the Commission came back with recommendations, including demolishing some of the structures on the site. The Commission did meet sporadically. The last record of a formal meeting was in 1998. On November 10, 2015, Mayor Riley presented for Council ’s benefit and consideration the Memorandum of Understanding that, according to him, would “serve as the guiding document of our joint stewardship of this wonderful civic space …” “… The MOU ensures that we will continue this wonderful partnership for many years to come. ” Ms. Copeland continued, saying that in the minutes from 2015, Mayor Riley gave a great history about the relationship between the Board and the City and the gradual work that was made on the Park . From the City ’s perspective, the adoption of the 2015 MOU along with the 2021 amendment superseded the Commission on Marion Square. The Commission did still exist in the ordinance, but the delegation of the responsibilities and the duties of both the City and the Board superseded the need for the Commission. She concluded that Marion Square was owned by the Board of Field Officers of the Fourth Brigade as long as it is maintained as a public mall and parade ground, and that the arrangement regarding the management, regulation, control, and special events of the Marion Square property lived in the existing MOU between the City and the Board. Chair Greene asked if the Board also controlled the monuments and structures in Marion Square. Ms. Copeland said that that was correct and that it was private property owned by the Board. Commissioner Fraser asked Ms. Copeland if one could make a legal agreement to do something illegal , such as making a legal agreement to commit murder. Ms. Copeland said that in that context, “absolutely not. ” Commissioner Fraser asked if the City could support the erection of a monument to a defunct, illegal organization on public property. Ms. Copeland said she did not think it was illegal to place a monument on their private property. Commissioner Fraser asked if Ms. Copeland thought it was illegal to place a monument on public property that championed an illegal organization. Ms. Copeland said that Marion Square was private property. Commissioner Fraser asked if Ms. Copeland was saying that Marion Square was private property. Ms. Copeland said that she was. Commissioner Fraser asked if the Board of Field Officers of the Fourth Brigade paid money or brought something else to the agreement. Chair Greene said that the Board owned the property. Commissioner Fraser asked on what grounds the Board claimed ownership. Chair Greene said that the City deeded the land to the Board in 1833. Commissioner Fraser said that he maintained that “all of that is antebellum claptrap, ” that the law did not like vagueness regarding the ownership of real property, which was one reason why he was calling for the reseating of the Commission. He thought the citizens of Charleston deserved to know who owned Marion Square, whether it was a publicly or privately owned property, and that the City should insist on public ownership in order to get their money ’s worth. Ms. Copeland said that the City contributed towards maintenance of Marion Square Park. In City of Charleston Commission on History April 1 , 202 6 , P age 6 exchange, the Board of Field Officers of the Fourth Brigade allowed countless events year-round. They had the farmer ’s market, Christmas celebrations, and things like that. They participated in the Special Events Committee to ensure that everything was fully insured. There was an active relationship between the City and the Board over the relationship with the Park. Commissioner Fraser asked if Ms. Copeland agreed that the law did not like vagueness in the ownership of property. Ms. Copeland said that there was a deed and that she would say there is no vagueness in the ownership of the property. Commissioner Fraser said that given what was presented, there was some question of ownership. Ms. Copeland said that she would say there was not. Commissioner Fraser thanked Ms. Copeland. Ms. Copeland thanked the Commission. Chair Greene said that there had been some change over time as to how the Board interacted with the City, but the basic fact that the Board owned the property had never been under debate since the property was deeded to them in 1833. Commissioner Fraser said that a part of ownership of land involved “the assertion of dominion and control; the right to exclude what you do not want and to permit what you want. ” He said that he had been involved with the establishment of the monument to Denmark Vesey. He said the Denmark Vesey and the Spirit of Freedom Monument Committee initially intended to have the monument placed in Marion Square because the Citadel as an institution began in response to the Denmark Vesey conspiracy. He said the struggle between the forces of freedom and the forces of tyranny had been centered on Marion Square for a long time. Because the Board would not permit the statue of Denmark Vesey to be placed in Marion Square, it was instead placed in Hampton Park, a park named for a Redeemer. Commissioner Fraser continued, saying that his objective was to make sure that people understood that Marion Square was not private property, but public property owned by the people of Charleston that was transferred surreptitiously in 1833 by people who were not acting with public consent, but the consent of the powerful at that time. He said that as a result, the transfer of the property was subject to question. They were empowering the private over the public in the use of what was obviously public property. He hoped that the Commission on History would take that broader view and support the resolution. He said that it made no sense to give a private organization dominion and control over what was obviously a public space. He said that the Board of Field Officers of the Fourth Brigade would have a role in the development of Marion Square ’s history, but that they would not be able to assert ownership. Chair Greene said that they may not be happy about it, but that there were other examples. On the corner of Logan and Franklin Street , where the Work House once stood, when it tumbled in the earthquake, the City sold that public land and now there were private houses on it. When the City of Charleston extended the Battery in 1911 and drew up the lots, the City owned them before selling them as private property. He said the City did have a history of taking public land and selling it to nongovernment entities. Commissioner Fraser said that he agreed that the City had that kind of power to some extent, but not to the extent that involved the main square of the City. Chair Greene said that at that point, it was not the main square of the City but was outside of City limits. The City did not extend beyond Boundary Street (now Calhoun Street) until 1850. In 1833, when the City of Charleston was selling it, it was not a part of the incorporated City. City of Charleston Commission on History April 1 , 202 6 , P age 7 Commissioner Fraser made a motion to adopt the resolution. There was no second. The motion failed. Chair Greene suggested that anyone who felt strongly about the issue could speak during the public comment period at a City Council meeting. Commissioner Fraser said that he was not the only person in Charleston who agreed with the resolution. He said the Preservation Society supported it and that State Senator Ed Sutton helped to draft it. He said that he hoped some on the Commission agreed, because if they were in charge of the history of the City , and if they did not respect the history of the City, then they did not belong on the Commission. Chair Greene said that he thought many on the Commission were sympathetic, but it was a nonissue because they did not have control over private property, and Marion Square was private property. They had no power at all over private property. Commissioner Fraser said they were a part of the government of the City . Chair Greene said they had very restricted powers. Commissioner Fraser said they had restricted powers to make recommendations. That was all they would be doing. Chair Greene recognized Commissioner Theiling. Commissioner Theiling thanked Ms. Copeland for her explanation. He asked that he be recognized not only as a member of the Commission, but as Chairman of the Board of Field Officers of the Fourth Brigade. Chair Greene nodded in affirmation. Commissioner Theiling said his comments would be extensive because the resolution involved detailed aspects of Marion Square, and he wanted the Commission to be informed. He said that passage of the resolution would have had the Commission state that Marion Square is among Charleston ’s most prominent civic spaces. He asked if the Commission knew the current relationship between the City of Charleston and the property owner that allowed Marion Square to be a prominent space. He said the resolution stated that decisions affecting Marion Square had significant consequences. He asked what the Commission ’s awareness of the process was and said that he wanted to help answer that. He asked if it was because he was on the committee, said that was probably not the case, and asked if it was based on recent uninformed and misleading newspaper reports. He said these questions appeared rhetorical, but that they should be given answers by any proponent who intended to continue with the resolution ’s approach. He said that the Commission accepted the fact that Marion Square was private property and that there was a formal, though old, but very well-established agreement between the owners of Marion Square and the City of Charleston as to how their property could be used as a public park for the public ’s use. He said that it was not publicly owned, but publicly used. The 1833 deed simply said two things; that the City and the Board agreed that the property be left open as a military and ceremonial training ground (a parade field, in other words), and that it would also be left open as a public mall. Today, they used the term ‘public park, ’ but ‘public mall ’ was common at that time, and the deed said ‘forever. ’ He said that they were in forever, today, tomorrow, and yesterday since 1833. City of Charleston Commission on History April 1 , 202 6 , P age 8 He continued, saying that the interaction between the City and the Board had changed over the years and had been interrupted by the Civil War, with occupation by Federal troops, and by Reconstruction. Commissioner Fraser said he objected to the term ‘occupation. ’ Chair Greene recognized Commissioner Theiling. Commissioner Theiling said he wanted to address the portion of the resolution which stated, “Being aware that the absence of … public commission process … reduces transparency … invites unilateral action in a space that functions as a public square regardless of underlying title .” He asked why they should accept anything stating, “regardless of the underlying title. ” He said they had just heard from the City ’s highest legal authority that the underlying title was with the Board. He asked why the Commission would take any kind of action in that direction and have no regard for lawful ownership. He said the proposed resolution ’s wording was not rhetorical. The Board did not pretend to own Marion Square, it did own Marion Square. He thanked Chair Greene. E. Miscellaneous Business Chair Greene recognized Commissioner McCormack. Commissioner McCormack said that the Commission should not be dealing with resolutions. That was not really their job or within their purview. They would be faced with more and more, and they should be focused with what their real job was. Chair Greene said that he believed they had the power to make resolutions, but that every resolution that he personally had presented to City Council, which he believed to be about two or three in the 20 years he had been on the Commission, they had been ignored. He felt coming up with a plaque for Hampton Park fell more squarely within their purview. Commissioner Theiling if the Commission was empowered to initiate and propose resolutions to City Council. Chair Greene said they were. He said they did not have a history of doing it, but that it could be done. He said that he had seen no action taken on those that they had presented. He said that looking at the ordinance, the Commission consisted of 13 members, including two City Councilmembers. He said he had not seen a City Councilmember and did not know if any were currently on the Committee. Commissioner Fraser said the ordinance answered those questions and that the Commission acted as an expert advisor to Council on subjects it may not have expertise on. He said that at one time they were just reviewing signs and not attempting to influence policy. Commissioner Eastman called for adjournment of the meeting. Chair Greene said Commissioner Mack had suggested going into executive session to discuss the issue amongst themselves. Commissioner Theiling asked if the Chair of the Commission could call for an executive session. Chair Greene said he had asked, and it was possible, but that they could do it the following meeting. F. Adjournment On a motion of Commissioner Peg Eastman, seconded by Commissioner David McCormack, the Commission voted unanimously to adjourn the meeting. City of Charleston Commission on History April 1 , 202 6 , P age 9 The meeting was adjourned at 5 :18 p .m . Philip E . C la p p e r Assistant Clerk of Council

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.