BAR-S Meeting Results
City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Mar 26, 2026 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Charleston
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
MEETING RESULTS
MARCH 26, 2026 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET
BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Lindsay Van Slambrook, Becky Fenno, Laura Altman, Darryl Cobb
STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: Frankie Pinto, Travis Galli
A. Minutes
1. Review of Minutes from the February 26, 2026 Meeting
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Approve with Van Slambrook edits
MADE BY: Van Slambrook SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0
2. Review of Minutes from the March 12, 2026 Meeting
DECISION: DEFERRED
MOTION: Defer
MADE BY: Van Slambrook SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0
B. Applications
1. 9 Magnolia Street
BAR2026-002410 | TMS# 463-08-03-026 | North Central | Council District 4
Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1935 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting OPT-IN REVIEW for demolition of existing exterior elements visible from the
public right-of-way AND conceptual approval for proposed addition.
Owner: 9 Magnolia LLC
Applicant: Matthew Sanford (Blane Hammerlund)
Site visit on 03/26/2026 at 8:30 a.m.
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Approval of demolition, conceptual approval with staff condition 1-4 and
Board conditions, to return to Board for preliminary
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Altman VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 1
Opposed: Fenno
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | March 26, 2026 Page 2
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• Addition should be stepped in by 6” on either side and retain original corners
• Retain rafter tails
• Eaves at front and rear of existing structure need to remain
• Keep original roof footprint
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Staff appreciate that the carport is being retained in this iteration.
2. Per typical staff condition rear dormer is pulled in from the sides and down from
the ridge
3. Staff could support with less height, exposing more of the chimneys
4. Chimney is a character defining feature and should remain exposed
5. Proposal changes ridge height from 19’7” to 23’7”.
6. Rafter tails should be retained as they are a character defining feature
STAFF CONDITIONS:
1. Front porch columns should remain same height, with the porch ceiling remaining at
the same height
2. Elevate ridge beam by increasing roof pitch, eave height should remain as is. Total
change in ridge height should not exceed 2’6” as was approved at 8 Magnolia.
3. Restudy dormer windows, they should be differentiated from the existing house.
4. Ridge has to stay in same horizontal location
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Deferral for restudy with staff comments.
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• None
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• PSC
o Not supportive of raising entire roof
o Encourage retention of character defining features
o Rear addition should be tucked in from sides
• HCF
o Please to see opt-in option being used
o More sympathetic approach would be rear addition
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Questions for staff about conditions #2. Since change
• Plans not shown stepped as discussed at site visit
• Front porch needs to stay same height, eave height should be retained
• Back addition needs to step in from either side, probably 6”
• Roof material is historic, original features, rafter tails
• Discussion of what was approved at 8 Magnolia
• Don’t agree with proposed design, could agree
• Historic city, entire purview is keeping features. Issue with removing entire roof
• 8 Magnolia, gable form is more significant than
• Losing historic fabric, but overall form is still there
• Important to keep original footprint, eave location
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | March 26, 2026 Page 3
2. 152 Coming Street Unit A
BAR2026-002467 | TMS# 460-16-01-022 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 4
Category 4 | c. 1840 | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval for roof replacement and wholesale window replacement.
Owner: Gina Kennedy
Applicant: Lea Holliday
Site visit on 03/26/2026 at 8:50 a.m.
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Approve wholesale window replacement, in kind to match original 2/2
windows, work with staff on manufacture specifications. Denial of roof replacement
MADE BY: Altman SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• See motion
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Staff cannot approve wholesale window replacement
2. If roof needs replacement and replacing in kind, the roof can be processed at
staff
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• Window material, clad vs all wood
• Colby window specs showed are insulated, SDL
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• HCF
o Unable to support wholesale replacement
o Repair windows instead of replace where possible
o Repair roof unless absolutely necessary
• PSC
o Request in kind replacement of windows, only where necessary
o Replacement of roof only if necessary
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Replacement in kind, should match the 2/2 windows
• Roof needs to be repaired. Ways to repair with fabric and coatings
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | March 26, 2026 Page 4
3. 10 Trapman Street
BAR2026-002445 | TMS# 457-12-01-030 | Harleston Village | Council District 8
Category 4 | c. 1880 | Old & Historic District
Requesting final approval for alterations to previous Board approval.
Owner: Cozy 10 Trapman Street LLC
Applicant: Cozy Studio (Patrick McGrath)
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Conceptual approval of additional height for 2’ above BFE, and stair changes
at entry, with preliminary and final review by staff. Denial of parapet and roof access as
submitted.
MADE BY: Altman SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• See motion
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. While staff appreciate the design, as there is no documentation of a previously
existing parapet, staff is opposed to adding a parapet to a house that did not
historically have one.
2. Height of appurtenance is missing from drawings. The addition feels very tall for
so small an element. Staff is not opposed, if kept as small as possible and to the
rear
STAFF CONDITIONS:
1. Reduce height of appurtenance as much as possible
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial of parapet as submitted. Conceptual approval of
appurtenance with staff comment and preliminary / final review by staff of permit
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• Clarification on request: move stair into piazza, raise additional foot above BFE,
parapet, rooftop access
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• HCF
o Not in support of parapet
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Walls between piers is different
• Submittal not formatted properly, difficult to review
• Understand desire for parapet but the house doesn’t call for that
• Don’t allow remaking of historic form
• Some precedent for allowing additional foot above BFE, which is allow for new
construction
• Base of building needs work
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | March 26, 2026 Page 5
4. 16 Trumbo Street
BAR2026-002434 | TMS# 457-12-01-016 | Harleston Village | Council District 8
Category 3 | c. 1867 | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval to elevate building 2’ above Base Flood Elevation (BFE), shift
building 6” off property line, and change fenestration and balustrade changes.
Owner: Cozy Development – 16 Trumbo LLC
Applicant: Cozy Studio (Amanda Ferzoco)
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff conditions 1 & 2, staff observation 2, and
Board conditions
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Altman VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• Restudy stair riser/run so stairs don’t extend past front facade
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. House retains same relationship to the street while shifting.
2. Balusters should not be changed without evidence for the proposed profile. (Board
made condition)
STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL:
1. The arch at front stairs should have masonry infill, not lattice. Staff appreciates the
arch detailing.
2. Provide detail on custom lattice
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with staff comments and preliminary /
final review by staff of permit
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• Reasons for moving
• Zoning approval
• Will building allow that close, fire safety issue. Not our purview
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• None
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Preservation groups didn’t speak against shifting
• Height change, stair issue cause when raising additional foot
• No dimension on stair detail, tread 10” riser 6”
• Railing doesn’t need to change
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | March 26, 2026 Page 6
5. 2 Kennedy Court
BAR2026-002444 | TMS# 460-07-04-030 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough
Council District 6 | New Construction | Old City District
Requesting conceptual approval for new single-family dwelling.
Owner: Superior Properties SC LLC
Applicant: Neil Stevenson Architecture
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff observations and conditions and Board
conditions, to return for preliminary
MADE BY: Fenno SECOND: Altman VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• Restudy of front porch and third floor walk out
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Slab on grade is unusual for peninsula for non mid mod typology
2. The third floor roof deck is inappropriate, windows and door feel crowded.
3. The enclosed side of the second floor porch is inappropriate.
4. Per the Board of Architectural Review Principles for New Construction and
Renovations and Repairs:
The size and frequency of windows is one of the most significant visual characteristics
of a building. They should provide repetitive rhythm horizontally, but not be too
repetitive vertically.
5. On the west façade, the paired windows are different sized
6. Window should be consistent proportions.
7. Too many window and door types
8. Shutters should be restudied, do not appear sized for the windows
9. There appear to be some drawing errors including the form that pops out of side
of west dormer
10. Dormer windows are at different heights
11. Dormer roof pitches shown as identical but do not appear so in elevation.
STAFF CONDITIONS:
1. Restudy siding pattern, especially third floor deck rail
2. Simplify and unify fenestration
3. Remove shutters from front facade
4. Pull dormers in from edge of roof
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Deferral for restudy architecture direction
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• None
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• None
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Agree with staff on inconsistence of doors and windows
• Don’t have problem with 3rd floor walkout, but needs to decide if it has parapet or not
• Overall form is fine, architectural direction / details
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | March 26, 2026 Page 7
• Stained wood columns do not feel appropriate
• Height, scale, and mass is appropriate
• Cementous siding needs to be thicker
6. 125 Bogard Street
BAR2026-002451 | TMS# 460-07-04-056 | Westside | Council District 6
New Construction | Old City District
Requesting conceptual approval for new single-family dwelling.
Owner: JT Properties SC, LLC
Applicant: Marty Gunter
DEFERRED BY STAFF
7. 38 State Street
BAR2026-002447 | TMS# 458-09-01-111 | French Quarter | Council District 8
Category 2 | c. 1815 | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval to enclose rear portion of piazza and make driveway and
gate alterations.
Owner: Chris Jones
Applicant: Brian Crouch – Architect
DECISION: APPROVED
MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Altman VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 1
Opposed: Fenno
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• None
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. More information on existing condition of gate not provided in packet
2. Proposed infill would still be visible from Queen and East Bay Streets
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial of porch infill, deferral of modification of gates and
piers for more information per previous Board motion
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• None
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• PSC
o Encourage further reduction of piazza infill
BOARD COMMENTS:
• First floor infill hasn’t changed, second floor has changed
• Appreciate reduction of second floor changes
• One new window on back elevation, first an ground floor infill, new and altered gate
• Preservation groups not opposing
• Not in favor of ground floor change, visible from street
• Movement of pier and wall, if original, not in favor of moving
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | March 26, 2026 Page 8
• Can’t tell if it is same gate in 1950s photo
• Visibility of first floor with privacy wall
• Applicant research for gates
• Openness / airiness of first floor, windows
8. 50 Broad Street
BAR2026-002449 | TMS# 458-09-03-040 | French Quarter | Council District 8
Category 1 | c. 1798 | Old & Historic District
Requesting final approval for modification to exterior window sash.
Owner: City of Charleston
Applicant: Evans and Schmidt Architects (Joe Schmidt)
DECISION: DEFERRED
MOTION: Deferral for additional information
MADE BY: Altman SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 1
Opposed: Cobb
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• Applicant to provide sample
• (staff to schedule site visit when resubmitted)
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Since this is a Category 1, staff cannot approve any change that irreparably
changes all the historic windows.
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• Questions on process
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• PSC
o Appreciate plan for comprehensive maintenance
o Category 1, highest standard
o City should model preservation standards, application of clear film or
interior shutters
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Glass is thicker due to laminate, depth of glass is different
• Glass could be reused?
• Seems contrary to replacement in kind / repair. There are other ways to provide
safety
• Is a creative solution but there are other options
• It’s a category 1 building on Broad Street
• Same process has been done with City Hall, and Gibbes with SHPO approval. Has
SHPO endorsed this change
• Need for sample, see if there is a visible difference
• Need for more information, site visit
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | March 26, 2026 Page 9
9. 35 Spring Street
BAR2026-002450 | TMS# 460-08-04-005 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough
Council District 4 | Category 4 | c. 1885 | Old City District
Requesting conceptual approval for new cabana.
Owner: Harrison Malpass
Applicant: Coastal Creek Design – Joel Adrien
DECISION: APPROVED
MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• none
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Proposal will be visible from King Street.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• None
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• None
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Minimally visible, simple
10. 74 Drake Street
BAR2026-002440 | TMS# 459-06-04-034 | East Side | Council District 4
Category 4 | c. 1890 | Old City District
Requesting conceptual approval for rear addition, dormer, and fenestration changes.
Owner: Justin Syms
Applicant: Rockwell Construction (Naseem Keshmirian)
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board conditions preliminary / final review by staff
MADE BY: Altman SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• Restudy front gable window size
• Revert back to shed dormer roof
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Previous Board comments have been addressed.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | March 26, 2026 Page 10
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• None
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• None
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Window at front gable should be smaller
• Visibility of dormer, shed roof was better
• Diagonal sheathing is unusual. Last meeting was asked to be retained
11. 60 Smith Street
BAR2026-002452 | TMS# 457-03-02-056 | Harleston Village | Council District 8
Not Surveyed | c. 1870 | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval to convert existing screen porch into habitable space.
Owner: Clark / Barsan
Applicant: Marsh Bluff Builders – Jeff Partin
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board comments and preliminary / final review by
staff
MADE BY: Fenno SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• Restudy the porch infill based on traditional Charleston porch infills
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. The infill area is on a rear porch of a later addition
2. Windows don’t appear to fit.
STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL:
1. Restudy window proportions and location.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with staff comments and preliminary /
final review by staff
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• None
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• None
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Porch enclosure should be a little more elegant, express that it’s compatible with rest
of building
• Detailing typical of porch infills, more sensitive. Windows fit between columns
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | March 26, 2026 Page 11
12. 44 Charlotte Street
BAR2026-002439 | TMS# 459-13-01-104 | Garden District | Council District 4
Category 2 | c. 1834 | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval for recessed insect screening within existing porch bays.
Owner: William Scott
Applicant: William Scott (Evan Perez)
DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS
MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board conditions and preliminary / final review by
staff
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Altman VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• Screen mounted towards inside of porch
• Must comply with BAR Policy for the Screening of Piazzas and Porches
• Provide trimming details to staff
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Since this is a Category 2, staff can only approve repairs in kind.
2. Per BAR Policy for the Screening of Piazzas and Porches:
a. Screening for a piazza or porch should be installed in a manner that is
completely reversible, resulting in as little damage to the fabric of the
building as possible.
b. The framework of the screening should be as minimal as possible.
c. The framework should be constructed interior of the columns, porch beam,
and balustrade so that these elements remain in the forefront.
d. The color of the framework should generally be flat black so it recedes into
the background or painted to match the columns and balustrade. This will
be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.
e. Aluminum screening will not be allowed.
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• Proposal is compliant with policy
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• HCF
o Easement holder, compliant with easement
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Only screening one side
• Is reversible
• Sitting on top of brick, if inbound would collect debris
• See as sort of temporary structure
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | March 26, 2026 Page 12
13. 6 Orange Street
BAR2026-002454 | TMS# 457-12-04-074 | Charlestowne | Council District 8
Category 4 | c. 1779 | Old & Historic District
Requesting fenestration changes.
Owner: Nicole & James Barnard
Applicant: Lauren Sanchez Design LTD
DECISION: APPROVED
MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• None
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Facades have been heavily altered.
2. The proposed changes to the second addition are minimally, if at all visible
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• Visibility of windows on back side, not from street, only neighbor courtyard
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• None
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Only received support from neighbors, no complaints
14. 11 Elizabeth Street
BAR2026-002455 | TMS# 459-13-03-075 | Garden District | Council District 4
Not Surveyed | c. 1998 | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval for wholesale window replacement.
Owner: Todd Magro
Applicant: Nicolas Cortes
DECISION: APPROVED
MOTION: Final approval
MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Altman VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• Window 4 not being replaced per applicant
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Staff cannot approve wholesale replacement of windows.
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Meeting Results | March 26, 2026 Page 13
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• All SDL, replacing with SDL
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• None
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Thank applicant for excellent packet
• 1998 house and insulated windows
15. 245 King Street
BAR2026-002446 | TMS# 457-08-01-054 | Harleston Village | Council District 8
Category 2 | c. 1840 | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval for alterations to the existing storefront including the
entablature and addition of brackets.
Owner: Raisin Rachel & Mordenai Raisin Hirsch Trust / (Tenant is Alo)
Applicant: Coast Architects (Jackie Ryan)
DECISION: DEFERRED
MOTION: Defer to meet submittal requirements
MADE BY: Altman SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0
BOARD CONDITIONS:
• none
STAFF OBSERVATIONS:
1. Previously denied as condition to previous Board motion
BOARD QUESTIONS:
• What was previous design, not included in packet
PUBLIC COMMENT:
• None
BOARD COMMENTS:
• Submittal did not include previously approved drawings
• Appreciate detail
• Remember it being heavier and darker, need side by side comparison
Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.