_03232026-10783
City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Mar 23, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Charleston
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Committee on Real Estate
March 23, 2026
A meeting of the Committee on Real Estate was held on this date at 3:03 p.m. via Zoom .
Notice of this meeting was sent to all local news media.
PRESENT
Committee M embers : Councilmember William Tinkler (Chair), Councilmember Boyd Gregg,
Councilmember Aaron Polkey, Councilmember Ross Appel, Councilmember Keith Waring, and
Mayor William Cogswell
City Staff and Others : Malena Dinwoodie, Hampton Logan, Elizabeth Dieck, Geona Shaw-
Johnson, Robert Summerfield, Magalie Creech, Shannon Elliot, Matthew Fro h lich, Julia
Copeland, Melissa Cruthirds, Councilmember Michael Seekings, Mollie Conner, Josh Martin,
Christopher Morgan, Katie Dahlheim, Philip Clapper, and Donna Constance
Chair Tinkler called the meeting to order.
Invocation
The meeting was opened with a moment of silence led by Councilmember Tinkler
Approval of Minutes
On a motion by Mayor Cogswell , seconded by Councilmember Gregg , the Committee voted
unanimously to approve the February 23, 2026 , Real Estate meeting minutes.
a. Approval to authorize the Mayor to execute a Management and Operating Agreement
with Explore Charleston, CVB, Inc. for the Visitor ’s Reception and Transportation
Center Garage. (63 Mary Street, TMS# 459-09-03-147). The property is owned by the
City of Charleston. [Ordinance]
Mayor Cogswell said that this was for the Visitor Center Garage. They had a lease with the CVB
for commercial space. With expanded management of the garage, they would put more effort into
the process. When they compared the economics to what they had been receiving, they did not
account for some of the additional costs associated with the fee increases. They had a baseline
of $1.3 million, so the City would get the next $450,000. Anything that went above that , they would
split with the CVB. This would give them an incentive to manage the garage efficiently to generate
more revenue. If they had a big year, earning $2 million to $2.5 million, and gave the CVB
$300,000 that could be theirs, they could terminate the agreement. He asked that, even though
this was a five-year term, both parties have the right to terminate.
Ms. Dinwoodie said yes, for convenience.
2
Mayor Cogswell believed it was worth exploring to see if it would work. The garage has faced
problems before, but having someone in the office would improve management.
Councilmember Gregg asked if they knew what the revenue was for this parking garage for 2025.
Mayor Cogswell stated it was $2 million. The $1.2 million was the average from the years before
2025, but the fees increased, bringing them to the $2 million mark. This amount could change
depending on how the garage is used, so instead of renegotiating the entire deal, which was
nearly finalized, they decided to proceed to see where this would lead, while still keeping the
option to back out if more money was deducted.
Councilmember Gregg asked, since they owned the garage, would be collecting $2 million in
revenue, and splitting some of that with Explore Charleston , who would handle some expenses
and management , if they knew which expenses could be avoided next year or when the lease
started.
Mayor Cogswell stated that this was intended to be revenue-neutral and would be managed by
someone more engaged in hands-on management. That has been the issue with this specific
garage for several years, driving this. It would be helpful to have someone dedicated to overseeing
this facility from both an operational and revenue perspective.
Councilmember Waring said they had a tenant in the garage whom they needed to get rid of
because of the crime they brought to that area. What caught their attention was that Explore
Charleston and their team were next door at the Visitor Reception Center. They could monitor the
income, but it was great to get rid of the previous tenants and take on more management, which
was needed there. If things got too big, they could work it out with CVB.
Councilmember Polkey asked about the relationship with ABM under this plan, including whether
they would be subsumed, become a sublessee, or submanager, especially from Explore
Charleston's perspective.
Mayor Cogswell asked whether the contract would involve the CVB or the City if they decided to
continue with it.
Ms. Dinwoodie said the agreement would be with CVB for this management . T he agreement with
ABM would allow them to add or remove garages from their management scope. Therefore, they
would remove it from their management responsibilities and assign it to CACVB.
Councilmember Polkey asked whether the identified problems created an imperative to seek a
different situation or, because of their proximity, to explore seeking an enhanced experience at
the garage.
Mayor Cogswell said there were several businesses . O ne in particular was problematic in the
space the City owned. The City revoked its business license and went through a process with the
CVB to relet that space to them. They did a buildout and want to continue marketing, posters , and
sponsorship to bring in revenue. It has a pedestrian count around it, and they were looking at
creative ways to drive additional revenue , which would enhance the physical space.
Councilmember Gregg said he would like to see a comparison of year-to-year parking revenues
related to this facility and the projections under the agreement. Because a significant amount of
money is involved, he felt it was their responsibility to manage the facilities to the best of their
ability. He also wanted to compare the financial projections of the new agreement with what had
been done over the past three years.
Mayor Cogswell said they could put this together before it was reported out.
Ms. Dinwoodie said this was being fast-tracked the following day because it was an ordinance.
Councilmember Gregg asked if they were voting on this at Ways and Means.
3
Ms. Copeland said yes.
Ms. Dinwoodie said the agreement would start on May 1st, which was when they would begin
managing the garage, pending its approval.
Councilmember Gregg asked why this was being expedited and if there was a reason it needed
to be completed by May 1st.
Mayor Cogswell said they want to move forward with this and that ABM did a good job, but not
with this deck. Because this was a major entry point for many visitors coming to the city, that was
part of the motivation. They questioned how much they might be leaving on the table and whether
someone better equipped should run this.
Councilmember Waring agreed that reviewing those numbers over the past three years made
sense because it would show an increase in parking fees that didn't exist three years ago.
Chair Tinkler asked if, since the contract was effective on May 1st, the first year's payment would
be prorated .
Ms. Dinwoodie said yes and that there was a specific provision that would prorate the quarterly
payments .
Chair Tinkler asked when the fiscal year starts for Explore Charleston.
Ms. Dinwoodie said she would look into that and get back to him.
Chair Tinkler asked if the agreement required them to report annually on revenue that was
generated at the end of their fiscal year.
Ms. Dinwoodie said it was based on the City ’s fiscal year of reporting.
Chair Tinkler asked if they would have any other insight into how the revenue was doing
throughout the year, other than their annual reports.
Ms. Dinwoodie said they could request quarterly reports, and they would have to make base
quarterly payments as well.
Chair Tinkler said if they were to monitor this to make sure it made sense, it may take more than
a year to figure things out. Also, if they could do a quarterly report on other responsibilities they
had, such as maintenance of the property.
Councilmember Waring asked if they had any of the parking revenue baked into the City ’s January
through December 2026 fiscal year budget.
Mr. Frohlich said not this revenue, based on the agreement, but the expected gross revenue for
this garage.
Councilmember Waring asked how they adjusted for that.
Mr. Frohlich said it was about when the agreement took effect and what the anticipated revenue
was. If they were to go back to what the base rent was for the two quarters expected to be, or
anticipate it during the budget process.
Mayor Cogswell said they could make the adjustments on that. They did not think the intent was
to use what they based the 2026 budget on, which, at that point, they did not have the 2025
revenue , so they would have based their revenue projections on 24, which was $1.2 million. He
asked if they could go up to $1.7 million.
Mr. Frohlich said the 5-year historical average was $1.75 million.
Mayor Cogswell said that what they would provide the committee would reflect that. If, for some
reason, it was below budget, they would all agree that there was a problem.
4
On a motion by Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember Appel, the Committee voted
unanimously to approve Item A.
b. Authorization for the Mayor to execute a Termination and Release of Reservation for
Future 60 ’ Right-of-Way located at property described as TMS# 421-11-00-054.
(Mizzen Mast Road/Ripley Point Drive, TMS# 421-11-00-054). The property is owned
by Ripley Yacht Club Investors, LLC. [Ordinance]
Ms. Copeland stated that in 2004, there was an original application to subdivide a single large
parcel into two. At the time of the subdivision request, the Planning Commission, without a stated
need or requirement, imposed a condition on the approval for dividing the two parcels — specifically,
a 60-foot right-of-way that would extend from Mizzen Mast and connect to Ripley Point Drive. One
owner held both parcels and was preparing to sell to a developer planning high-end townhomes
on the site. The title insurance carrier inquired whether the council could vote to terminate the
60-foot right-of-way that traversed the entire parcel.
Councilmember Polkey asked when the right-of-way was secured and how old it was.
Ms. Copeland said that it was initiated by the Planning Commission in 2004.
On a motion by Mayor Cogswell, seconded by Councilmember Waring, the Committee voted
unanimously to approve Item B.
Councilmember Appel recused him self from voting on this item and completed a Conflict-of-
Interest Form , which is on file in the Office of the Clerk of Council .
c. Please consider the following annexations:
i. 862 Lolandra Avenue (0.25 acre) (TMS# 418-13-00-285), West Ashley,
(District 9). The property is owned by Stephen Luke and Melissa Chiplis .
ii. 164 Wappoo Road (1.27 acre) (TMS# 350-16-00-012), West Ashley, (District
11). The property is owned by Stephen Luke and Melissa Chiplis .
iii. 168 Wappoo Road (0.75 acre) (TMS# 350-16-00-016), West Ashley, (District
11). The property is owned by Paula Keener .
On a m otion by Councilmember Waring, seconded by Councilmember Appel, the Committee
voted unanimously to take all three annexations together for approval.
With there being no further business, the Committee adjourned the meeting at 3:30 p.m.
Clerk of Council ’s Office
Donna Constance
Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.