RecordWell Data

BAR-L Meeting Results

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Mar 11, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE MEETING RE SULTS MARCH 11, 2026 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Trey Watkins, Seaton Brown, Luda Sobchuk, Joel Trantham, Jay White STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: B.D. Wortham-Galvin, Lawrence Courtney, Brad Thomas A. MINUTES 1. Review of Minutes from the February 23, 2026, Meeting DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approval of Meeting Minutes MADE BY: Brown SECOND: Trantham VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 Jay White recused B. APPLICATIONS 1. 649 King Street BAR2026-002443 | TMS #4600802007 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough Council District 4 | New Construction | Height Districts 3.5, 4, 6, 7 | Old and Historic District Requesting approval of a mockup panel. Owner: Evening Post Industries Inc. (Ron Owens) Applicant: Dylan Towe (LS3P) NOTE: The Board will convene at this address on March 10, 2026, at 8:30 a.m. for a site visit. DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Mockup Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions MADE BY: Trantham SECOND: White VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • Much of the building’s ornamentality lies in its brick detailing and is generally acceptable. One exception is that the mortar joints in places appear excessive especially at bed and inside corner – this is partially due to the irregular edges of the brick and the closeness of the mortar to the face of brick. The Applicant should make a sample panel with the mortar recessed. • It is noted that while the porch mockup section will never intersect the brick on the building as it does on the mockup, the brackets will. It was discussed whether a sealant was needed here. It was determined that the joint was too tight for any sealant e xcept at Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | March 11, 2026 Page 2 the black brick band where a dark sealant could be placed around a ¼” inside the edge of the bracket to visually disappear. • It is noted that the GFRP cornice and frieze are of too light a thickness and not anchored at close enough intervals to present a smooth and consistent look. The Applicant is aware of this and is already working toward a resolution involving thicker material and tighter anchorage spacing. • The dryer vent cap shown could be a better match to the brick/mortar, but this can be worked out in the field with Staff. • It is understood that the vertical muntins on the window sample will be the thinner profile of the sample placed directly below the window on site. The smaller sample matches the drawings much better. • It is understood that the drain from the canopy is to be much closer to the face of the wall or may even incorporate a small gutter to address water falling onto the sidewalk. • The light to medium gray sealant color is preferred, although a color a little darker would better match the window frame color. • The precast color is best represented by the keystone form at the head of the window to the north with the cast sill exhibiting an unwanted swirling pattern. • It is understood that the inset marble diamond form will have distinct corners. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. A small sample panel is to be built to explore how the excessive mortar at bed joints and inside corners might be best addressed to be reviewed by Staff. 2. A thicker GRFP profile with more closely spaced anchoring points is required to be reviewed by Staff. 3. Applicant is to explore finding a slightly darker sealant color for windows. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Mockup Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions. BOARD COMMENTS: • Agree with Staff Comments and Conditions. For further Board Discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. 2. 18 Society Street / 320 East Bay Street BAR2026-002393 | TMS #4580104001 | Ports Area | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. early 1970’s | Height District 56/30V | Old and Historic District Request Full Demolition of two buildings. Owner: Buck Investments Applicant: Debbie King (Demolition and Environmental Companies LLC) NOTE: The Board will convene at this address on March 10, 2026, at 9:15 a.m. for a site visit. DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approval of the demolition of both structures MADE BY: White SECOND: Sobchuk VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | March 11, 2026 Page 3 STAFF COMMENTS: • The Ordinance (54-240.b) offers criteria for reviewing demolition requests in the Old and Historic District, asking the BAR to consider, among other things: - the historic, architectural and aesthetic features of the structure; - the nature and character of the surrounding area; - the historic or culturally important use of such structure; and - the importance to the city • Both structures (connected by a party wall) show up on historic aerials in 1973 but not earlier. Therefore, the structures are older than 50 years and technically considered historic. The architectural features are modest. • The structures do not significantly contribute to the nature and character of the architectural fabric on either street and do not contribute to the lively urban realm surrounding it. • Staff are not aware of any cultural significance related to the structures. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff do not oppose demolition of the two structures. BOARD COMMENTS: • Agree with Staff Comments and Conditions. For further Board Discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. 3. 280 Meeting Street BAR2026-002437 | TMS #4580103093 | Ansonborough | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1918,1952 | Height District 3,4 | Old and Historic District Requesting Conceptual Approval of adaptive reuse with an additional story on an existing building and a separate duplex structure. Owner: 280 Meeting Street LLC Applicant: Eddie Bello (Bello Garris Architects) DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions MADE BY: White SECOND: Brown VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • The Applicant received approval from the Board for the demolition of the rear garage structure on 8 October 2025. • At the same meeting related to the request for demolition of the primary structures, the Board noted that the building “contributes to the established urban fabric and varied architecture of Meeting Street […] and its form is still identifiable.” • Staff affirm that the Applicant’s proposal maintains the integrity of the historic forms so that they are easily legible. • The third story addition to the historic structure is deferential in that it sits back from the primary form and does not interfere with making a distinction between the two. • Staff support the height, scale and mass of the third story proposal. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | March 11, 2026 Page 4 • The architectural direction of the third story addition provides a clear distinction from the historic structure with the use of aluminum siding while also complementing it nicely. In the renders (particularly A -22), the cornice and parapet appear to domin ate and interfere visually with the historic structure and the character defining form of its parapet. Staff require restudy to further reduce the additions visual impact to the historic parapet. • The proposed duplex to the rear of the structure is minimally visible from the public right of way. The material choices and composition of the duplex work well in the context. Staff support the height, scale, mass and architectural direction of the rear duplex. • Any pool requires a separate permit and would not be a part of this approval. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Restudy of cornice and parapet on third-story addition to reduce prominence. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions BOARD COMMENTS: • It’s a great pivot for the project as Preservation Society noted. There is a way to give the top a more minimalist form and that can be discovered on the way to Preliminary. • Agree with Staff on the eyebrow on the cornice. It looks much larger in perspectives than on elevations. Agree it needs to be restudied somehow. If the cornice is resolved and we have a material difference and/or different color then it does not need to be set back further as we have the subordination. The railing above the brick on story historic building helps it feel more in proportion and have more presence to the structure behind. • The duplex is elegant and simple. • Not sure if the Juliette balconies on the north elevation add to the elevation at all; if they are not functional and they are not historic then would encourage a restudy of that. • At Preliminary would like to see the renderings from the street from the southern elevation looking north to get a better understanding of what the pedestrian experience is going to be like from that side. • This is a great example of adapting a historic structure. It’s great to see there’s an opportunity for this building to stick around. • Agree with Staff’s point on the cornice and parapet seeming to dominate and it conflicts with the historic building. Whether that’s pushing it back further or restudying the cornice, something needs to be redone there. • Mitigate the railing on top of the one -story building (and get zoning approvals if needed) so it doesn’t dominate. • The architectural direction is spot on, and the penthouse design strategy separates the architectural language from the historic structures. The amount that the penthouse is set back allows the historic parapet to read clearly. • The mass as it contributes to the reading of the parapet, especially at the north and south elevation, makes the penthouse read a little top -heavy. Is there a way (through restudy of window strategy, the form of the parapet, or something else) that will pl ay with the proportions of the parapet on the penthouse to bring down how top-heavy it’s reading. It’s going to be very visible, particularly on the south elevation with lots of blank wall and no articulation. The redevelopment of the cornice might solve that issue. • The south wall is a solid blank wall with minimal texture development. We need a better perspective view of that to understand the impact. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | March 11, 2026 Page 5 For further Board Discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. 4. Southeastern Corner of Radcliffe Street and Saint Philip Street (address TBD) BAR2026-002426 | TMS #4601602041 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 4 New Construction | Height Districts 2.5-3, 4 | Old and Historic District Requesting Conceptual Approval of an apartment complex and public parking garage. Owner: Warren Place Joint Venture Applicant: Evans and Schmidt Architects WITHDRAWN BY APPLICANT 5. 649 Meeting Street BAR2026-002442 | TMS #4631602060 | East Central | Council District 4 Category 1 | c. 1897 | Height District 4 | Historic Corridor District/Landmark Overlay Requesting Conceptual Approval of an addition to a Category 1 building. Owner: American College of the Building Arts (ACBA) Applicant: Sacha Rosen (Architect) DECISION: DEFERRED MOTION: Deferred for restudy and identification of a single pathway option with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions. MADE BY: Brown SECOND: White VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 1 Luda Sobchuk opposed. STAFF COMMENTS: • In addition to being a Category 1 structure, the Trolly Barn is also in the Landmark Overlay as it was used to house the city’s first electric street cars. This submittal is for an addition to the rear north wing of the Trolley Barn and site and thus limited in visibility to the NW side of the property from Meeting Street. • Relevant to this discussion of an addition to a Category 1 building is Charleston Standard #7: “Additions or exterior alterations to historic properties should be sympathetic to historic materials, features, and spatial relationships that characterize the property. The new work should be compatible with the historic materials, features, size, scale, proportion, and massing to protect the integrity of the property and its setting. To respect the authenticity of the historic structure and its context and setting, the new alterations or addition should be clearly discernable from the old. The differentiation may or may not be stylistic, and may be as subtle as a change in building footprint, material or other means.” • Staff support the Applicant’s attention to the existing historic walls to the rear and side of the Trolley Barn and their preservation and visibility within the interior of the proposed addition. At Preliminary Review, staff requires a detail showing how t his additional would be connected to the historic wall to make clear how the new addition is discernible from the historic structure. A more articulated joint or small hyphen would be required (akin to Carlo Scarpa’s work at Castelvecchio). • While the BAR Board and Staff are generally a reactive body that does not entertain, options, Staff have made an exception in this case due to the unique situation offered Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | March 11, 2026 Page 6 by the Applicant and potential impact on architectural dialogue within the City of Charleston. • On Sheet A320 the Applicant shows a Classical approach (Option 1) and a New Construction approach (Option 2). • Option 1 is meant to be didactic for the students (and public) as it would be built by the students enrolled in the American College of the Building Arts (ACBA) with the façade serving as a learning lab. Staff could support the Classical façade in this option because of its role as an active learning structure, not a static mimetic monument to classicism. To that end, staff would want to see the façade rebuilt over periods of time (to be determined in a later stage of the proposal) to emphasis that active role. Staff require restudy of the broken pediment clerestory window. It is understood that it is following the angle of the existing historic wall to the rear of the property, but it conflicts with the understanding of the use of Classical composition at the main façade of the addition. • Option 2 would provide a more standard approach to New Construction on the Peninsula with its use of brick, precast concrete lintel, and a large aluminum window system complementing the architectural character of the Trolley Barn and surrounding context. • In either Option, staff support the height, scale and mass as it is subordinate to the Trolley Barn. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR OPTION 1: 1. Restudy the broken pediment clerestory window to be truer to the classical language 2. Bring sample materials to Preliminary Review. 3. At Preliminary Review include a proposed process and timeline for student engagement in the building of the façade as well as the timeline for the potential rebuilding of the façade over time. 4. At Preliminary Review, submittal must include detail showing how the new additional will connect to the historic wall. 5. At Preliminary Review, physical materials required. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR OPTION 2: 1. Bring sample materials to Preliminary Review. 2. At Preliminary Review, submittal must include detail showing how the new additional will connect to the historic wall. 3. At Preliminary Review, physical materials required. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Deferral for restudy of one singular pathway option preferred by the Board with Board and Staff Comments and conditions BOARD COMMENTS: • The options aren’t really about an architectural style but more of how you are going to use this addition. To employ the trades of the ACBA and the students themselves in the construction of this addition makes a lot of sense. While this might be built and rebuilt over time, it’s a struggle to believe that is likely to happen because of the resources that go into doing that . If you were going to do that and if you were going to adopt the language of Option 1, some sort of separation between that façade and the Trolley Barn (as staff noted) is called for so that it stands on its own more clearly. • Having the classical façade turning the corner into a plain brick façade means that future versions of the Board might think you just ran out of money. If you are going to do Option 1, agree with staff comments. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | March 11, 2026 Page 7 • For Option 2, need to reconsider the massing because while there is an explanation of where that single sawtooth comes from with that angle being related to the angle of the historic remaining rear wall, it is simple not legible from Meeting Street. That single clerestory does not work proportionally or compositionally with either option. • There’s so much emphasis on that rear wall, why not allow it to be somehow visible rather than the addition in front masking it for both options. • We know this is being built as a veneer. This is not unlike 363 King Street, it’s not unlike the Bluestein building at King and Mary that the veneer is different than what is along the sides of it. What is unique here is that it is going to be quite literally a learning laboratory that just happens to be outside. • While a lot of our questions were about the pedagogy, what we really are looking at is the exterior and what fits here. As it relates to Option 1, you look at precedents the Greek Revival through E.B. White throughout the city it is deferential to the rest of the building. The reason to defer is to choose one. We are not prescriptive in terms of style. As it relates to the pedagogy, we should take a step back. • The deferral is important so the College can decide based on this discussion what way they want to go. • We also need to consider the paragraph from Charleston Standard #7. It is supposed to be complementary and it is so different. • But so is the modern addition to the old communications building on St. Philips Street. • Understanding the context of the ACBA, the palette that you are using is what should be highlighted in the structure. • In trying to understand Option 1, if this was a freestanding building understood in the round everything that is shown here could be supported but also trying to understand this in the context of a Category 1 building. Obviously the Trolley Barn is much larger in scale but it derives a lot of the reason it is a Category 1 building is because it has an honesty to the tectonic uses of the way the material was constructed and utilized in the structure. The brick y ou see on the outside is the load bearing brick . What brings the value to that structure is some of the character in which it’s used. In looking at a building next to it that utilizes beautiful forms and materials but in such a different way, would want to see it embody the best principles of classical architecture. But it’s not. It’s a façade. It’s a stage. Not having the rest of the side of the building being incorporated into the façade can cheapen some of the relationship that’s there. We have to take into account that this is sitting next to a Category 1 building. • There is a pattern of development in Charleston of ornamentation on the primary structure and simplification on the accessory structure. The utilitarian structures were toward the back, they were subordinate, they were reduced in their ornamentation. One of the things that we are doing here is that we are taking a simplified Category 1 structure and then adding an ornamented addition that calls a lot of attention to itself. • Need to consider the Board members that do not believe that constructing and reconstructing a façade on a veneer is all that good of an idea long term. • If you pick a different stylistic direction, you need to differentiate and you need to be very aware of what the BAR’s guidelines say as quoted in Staff comments. • It is important to understand that no one here is advocating against an architectural style. We don’t have stylistic agendas. For further Board Discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | March 11, 2026 Page 8 6. 245 Huger Street BAR2026-002448 | TMS #4590103048 | East Central | Council District 4 New Construction | Height Districts 4-12, 5 | Historic Corridor District Requesting Final Approval of a new hotel. Owner: 245 Huger Street LLC & TMGOC Applicant: Stephen Ramos (AIA) DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Final Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions and Final Review by Staff of Permit drawings. MADE BY: Trantham SECOND: Brown VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • The Applicant previously received Preliminary Approval by the Board on 12 November 2025. • At Preliminary Review, the Board and Staff asked the Applicant to study the following: – Bring physical samples of key materials to Final Review. – It might benefit the project to have hierarchy within the taller window systems. – At the ground level there was a change from arch to the flat top; the arches may be a better way to engage Huger Street. • In response to these comments, the submittal: – Revises the ballroom windows at the corner to have hierarchy in the mullion pattern. – Engages Huger Street with the introduction of awnings and additional entrances along the street. • Staff support these revisions based on previous comments. • Unrelated to previous Board/Staff discussion, the Applicant has made additional revisions: – A site wall was added to the SW corner of the site to enclose outdoor dining. – On level 8, the central 4 bays push out to facilitate interior circulation and to emphasize the building’s center. The opening sizes at level 8 were made slightly smaller. • Staff support these revisions as improvements to the overall project. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Any modifications to approved drawings required for code or fire department compliance, or contemplated during construction, must be approved by the BAR prior to undertaking the changes. Any modifications/substitutions to the materials or elements approved at the Final BAR Hearing must be specifically noted, reviewed and approved on the Mockup sample panel. 2. Deviations from previously approved submissions, if determined by the BAR Staff during or after completion of construction to be a downgrade of the quality of the project and inconsistent with previous approvals, are not approved, whether noted or not by S taff during our review of “For Permit” drawings. 3. All construction work is to consider adjacent or nearby structures and the protection and monitoring thereof. If any work involving significant vibration may be reasonably suspected to be a threat to historic or new adjacent or nearby structures, a program must be in place addressing how these structures are to be protected and monitored. A copy of this protection and monitoring plan is to be transmitted to Staff for review prior to work. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | March 11, 2026 Page 9 4. A separate signage package will need to be submitted for all words and graphics to be placed on the building, as these are not considered part of any approvals or motions for this Board discussion. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Final Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions with Final Review by Staff of For Permit Drawings For further Board Discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. 7. 560 King Street BAR2026-002438 | TMS #4600804052 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough Council District 4 | Not Rated | c. 2015 | Height Districts 4,8 | Old and Historic District Requesting Final Approval of exterior signage. Owner: Hosp. Chasc. King LLC Applicant: Insignia Rising DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Final Approval of the exterior signage with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions MADE BY: White SECOND: Trantham VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • The following Zoning Ordinance clauses and BAR policy statements are relevant to this application: o Art. 4, Part 3, Sec. 54-415(b. Façade Signs) ▪ Sign faces shall not occupy more than ten (10) percent per façade of the building. o BAR Signage Policy Statement (King Street) ▪ 1. Each sign shall be evaluated on a case -by-case basis. Generally, a façade sign shall be appropriately proportioned to the storefront, and its design shall be compatible with the architectural style of the façade. ▪ 3a. External or internal illumination generally will not be permitted. Exceptions may be made on a case-by-case basis. • On 11 February 2026, the previously proposed façade sign was denied due to its inappropriate height and scale relative to the visible building façade from King Street, as well as the lack of clarification regarding illumination. The Board did, however, express support for the overall design and typography. • The revised proposal reduces the overall scale of the sign and lowers its placement, with the bottom of the sign now located 35’ -6” above grade. The proposed scale and placement better relate to the building façade and to the pedestrian and vehicular experience along King Street. • The Applicant now proposes halo -lit channel letters with 3000K “warm white” LED modules at 94.1 lumens per module, addressing the Board’s prior concerns regarding illumination method and brightness. Staff find this level of illumination appropriate for identification/wayfinding purposes during nighttime hours. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | March 11, 2026 Page 10 STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. The Applicant shall request a final inspection during nighttime hours to allow Staff to verify the appropriateness of the sign’s illumination. 2. A separate sign permit must be obtained prior to installation. The sign specifications submitted with the permit application shall match those approved by the Board. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Final Approval of the exterior signage. For further Board Discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. 8. 274 Calhoun Street BAR2026-002387 | TMS #4601503002 | Medical Complex | Council District 6 Category 1 | c. 1802 | Height Districts 55/30S, 85/125 | Old and Historic District Requesting Final Approval for repairs and restoration of an existing fence. Owner: Medical University of South Carolina (MUSC) Applicant: Glenn Keyes Architect DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Final Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Condition with Final Review of Fencing Element samples and For Permit drawings by Staff. MADE BY: Brown SECOND: Sobchuk VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • This property is listed as a Category 1 in the 2025 Combined Architectural Inventory and therefore must go before the Board for review. • The gate and fencing are unique character -defining historic elements of the property and are cited by Jonathon Poston in his The Buildings of Charleston as "Victorian cast iron" which would make them easily over a hundred years old. The fencing is in very poor condition due to deferred maintenance and general neglect and it is noted that many elements in the fencing have been replaced with other materials, the most striking being wood and even PVC. • While the Applicant and Staff explored the use of possible substitute materials to replace large portions of the fencing per NPS Preservation Briefs 16 and 27, fortunately a source to provide duplicates of the badly deteriorated material in -kind for reconstruction has been located. • The Applicant desires to restore the gate and reconstruct fencing on either side of it. Due to the condition of the fencing Staff agree with this approach which preserves critical existing material where possible and provides for an in-kind reconstruction solution. STAFF CONDITIONS: Staff has no conditions STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Final Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Condition with Final Review of Fencing Element samples and For Permit drawings by Staff. For further Board Discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | March 11, 2026 Page 11 9. Update to the Architectural Inventory DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approval of use by the city of update to the Architectural Inventory MADE BY: Watkins SECOND: White VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 For further Board Discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel.

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.