RecordWell Data

_10212026-2281

Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Oct 21, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SOUTH CAROLINA PLANNING COMMISSION OCTOBER 21, 2026 MINUTES PowerPoint Presentation Present: Brett Bennett, Chair, Corey Barber, Daniela Harris, Pam Ireland, Gary Davis, Bill Smyth, Kevin Berry. Absent: Michelle Mansour, Grant Gilmore. Staff: Michele Reed, Brent Leary, Peter Stone, Kevin Mitchell, Janelle Mercer, Kate Miller, Lynnette Lynes Mr. Bennett called the meeting to order at 5:00 pm. 1. Approval of the Agenda Ms. Ireland moved for approval of the agenda. Mr. Smyth seconded the motion. All in favor. 2. Approval of Minutes Mr. Davis moved for approval of the minutes. Mr. Smyth seconded the motion. All in favor. 3. Planning Commission Recommendations Update Mr. Stone reviewed Town Council decision with the Commission. 4. General Correspondence 5. General Public Comment All correspondence was linked to the agenda. Mr. Jeff Irvine, 852 Detyens Rd, spoke regarding the Wakendaw sketch plan. He expressed concern with the loss of recreational green space and mature trees. He also expressed concern with drainage and the declining water levels of nearby lakes following the construction of Hamlet Square and its retention pond in the early 2000s, with some of the lakes completely drying up. He suggested that existing drainage issues should be resolved before approving further development that Planning Commission October 21, 2026 Page 2 of 15 could affect the entire watershed. He also spoke regarding the impact of having ten residential homes and that these additional homes will impact the schools and the neighborhood. He expressed concern about the increased traffic the proposed development would bring and the negative impact to bike and pedestrian safety. He suggested that this is not the development of ten homes or property rights, but what is right for the youth of the Town for generations to come. Ms. Margaret Mauldin, 721 Hawksbill, spoke regarding the Wakendaw sketch plan. She stated that a major benefit within the Town is that there are pedestrian friendly neighborhoods and the quality of life the traditional neighborhoods have. She suggested that the safety within the neighborhood would be impacted with the proposed development. She suggested that developing the homes in this location would impact the amount of green space available within the Town and reduce the amount of recreation space available for the neighborhood. She asked that the request is deferred to explore the traffic and area impacts. Ms. Bergans Connors, 717 Oak Marsh Drive , spoke regarding the Wakendaw sketch plan. She asked that the request be delayed to have a full understanding of the request and the impacts to the neighborhoods. She stated that the concerns recently discussed with the rezoning of properties should be taken into consideration for this proposal as well. She expressed concern with the neighborhood not having sidewalks and a full traffic study is needed for all the roadways in the neighborhood. She also expressed concern with stormwater and environmental impacts and that a thorough drainage assessment to evaluate downstream effects on existing homes. She also suggested that wetland, tree, and environmental reviews should be conducted. She stated that Trident Academy has property rights and financial considerations, but there should be responsible planning that considers the existing residents and the long -term impacts on the neighborhood. She asked that the project be delayed to complete an impact assessment. Ms. Shelby Swails, 1522 Candlewood Drive, spoke regarding the Wakendaw sketch plan and expressed concern with the increased development. She suggested that this proposal would reduce the number of fields available in the Town for additional sports. She suggested that there should be more concern with keeping the character of the community and neighborhoods. She suggested that the land should be used as an additional field for Lucy Beckham High School. She asked that the needs of the community should be considered when reviewing this request. Planning Commission October 21, 2026 Page 3 of 15 She suggested that the negative impact this would have on the youth sports should also be considered. She suggested that this is a crucial piece of property that should be preserved for the community and our children. Ms. Meredith Flandry, 837 Detyens, spoke regarding Wakendaw sketch plan and agreed with the previous comments. She expressed concern the request and asked that there should be a “pause” taken. She stated that the neighborhood has a single entrance from a busy Mathis Ferry Road. She suggested that this request would mean a loss of trees, loss of green space, loss of privacy, loss of property value, and the sudden departure from the historical use. She stated that the values of the Comprehensive Plan and the future land use recommendation should be considered. She suggested that the individual rights of the property owner should be balanced with the common good. She expressed concern with the recent construction of a new road within their development and the removal of significant trees for the new road without notification to the surrounding neighborhood. She suggested that there should be some time, transparency, and neighborly conduct for public discourse on the matter. Mr. Taylor Porter, 1579 Wakendaw, spoke regarding Wakendaw sketch plan and expressed concern with the proposed development and that this proposal would impact the surrounding neighborhoods in addition to Wakendaw . He suggested that more traffic calming such as stop signs and speed humps should be installed on Wakendaw Road. He agreed with the previous comments. Mr. Eric Lindsey, 1260 Chatfield, stated that Wakendaw Place neighborhood opposes the proposed development and suggested that there should be more time to review the proposal . He suggeste d that there is limited green space, and the request should be denied. Mr. Brett Thomas, 848 Detyens , expressed opposition to the request. He expressed concern with the development of the green space. He suggested that there is a responsibility to preserve the character of the neighborhood. He suggested that the trees should be preserved , and if removed, would be a permanent loss for the neighborhood . He also suggested that converting the historic green space for residential homes would be a detriment to the neighborhood and should be carefully reviewed to ensure no detrimental impacts. He suggested that a previous request to change the Future Land Use map of the Comprehensive Plan was denied and the recommended use has not changed. He Planning Commission October 21, 2026 Page 4 of 15 suggested that the field should be preserved for future youth sports. He asked that the request be deferred. Mr. Kevin Vincent, 829 Detyens, expressed disappointment in the lack of transparency for public notice of this request. He expressed concern about the existing flooding of the field and that this proposal would exacerbate the flooding in the area once developed. He expressed concern with the existing traffic and that the proposed development would cause additional traffic. He suggested that the field should be preserved for future youth sports. He suggested that this would negatively impact the value of the homes. Ms. Lauren Newman, Pres ident of Wakendaw Lakes Civic Association, spoke regarding the Wakendaw sketch plan. She stated that participation in the civic association is voluntary and the annual fees are used to maintain the beauty of the neighborhood and maintenance of the lakes . She expressed concern about whether the new homes would participate in the civic association. She expressed concern with drainage and that the new development would impact the stormwater system and lakes that the civic association is responsible for maintaining. She also expressed concern with Detyens and Pine Shadow roadways in need of repair and should be improved. She asked that the school work with the neighborhood association to come to an agreeable resolution for all parties. Mr. Joseph Tecklenburg, real estate agent for Trident Academy, spoke regarding the Wakendaw sketch plan. He suggested that the traffic impact of ten homes would be less than the traffic generated for soccer tournaments that are currently held on the field. He suggested that under the current zoning, 18 homes could be developed, but they are only asking to develop ten homes and suggested that this would generate less traffic than the soccer tournaments. He stated that the Town was approached about purchasing the property but declined the request. He suggested that this proposal strikes a balance between responsible development and Trident Academy property rights and should be approved. Ms. Cheryl Ross, 801 Detyens, spoke regarding the Wakendaw sketch plan and suggested that there is not a lot of traffic for the soccer games as there is a gate that is controlled to limit access. She stated that there has been a decrease in traffic throughout the neighborhood over the past few years. She stated that she is opposed to the development because of having only one entrance to the neighborhood and that this would increase traffic in the neighborhood. Planning Commission October 21, 2026 Page 5 of 15 Ms. Diane Tausig, Isle of Palms, and member of the Trident Academy Board, spoke regarding Wakendaw sketch plan. She stated that they made the decision to enroll their daughter at Trident Academy to help with her educational needs. She stated that Trident Academy serves a need within the Town and educating children that learn in a different manner. She suggested that to keep Trident Academy functioning and able to secure the school’s financial future and preserve the valuable education for this community, the development of this property is needed. She suggested that the question is not whether the community would prefer 6 ½ acres of open space or ten homes, but rather whether the community can accommodate responsible residential development while protecting an educational institution that has contributed so much to the Town. Mr. JC Taylor, Trident Academy Board Chair, stated that Trident Academy was invaluable in teaching his daughter that was diagnosed with dyslexia . He stated that Trident Academy provides a valuable need in teaching students with educational challenges. He stated that as part of their strategic planning, they researched the options available to remain fiscally responsible, maintain the mission of school, and provide the needed educational resources for future students. remain functioning. He stated that this is needed to help keep Trident Academy open and in Mount Pleasant. He suggested that this would provide the funding needed. Mr. Erik Kreutner, Assistant Head of Trident Academy, stated that their mission is to ensure long-term financial sustainability to provide learning opportunities and not recreational space for the neighborhood and community. He stated that their first responsibility is to the students and families and provide the necessary specialized education. He stated that the sale of the property and proposed development is a long-standing financial strategy and not an abandonment of their commitment to the community. He stated that this request is part of the responsible stewardship of the school to ensure they can serve students for generations. He stated that the school has allowed the property to benefit families and youth sport organizations, but this generosity should not be considered a permanent obligation. He suggested that the recreational needs of other organizations should not supersede the school’s responsibility to provide specialized education and fulfill the mission to their students and families. There being no further comments, Mr. Bennett closed public comment. Planning Commission October 21, 2026 Page 6 of 15 6. Business A. PUBLIC HEARING , R-30-26, Belle Hall PD, Planned Development , TMS No. 537-00-00-004, Request to allow additional permitted use of Commercial Recreation on La Mesa Road. Staff Report Ms. Miller reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Mr. Davis asked if Ms. Miller is a member of Town staff. Ms. Miller answered in the affirmative. Mr. Berry asked if a specific use is being considered. Ms. Miller answered that they are proposing a gym. There being no comments and no applicant, Mr. Bennett closed the public hearing. Mr. Bennett suggested that the request is consistent with the existing uses. Ms. Ireland moved for approval. Mr. Berry seconded the motion. All in favor. B. Vested Rights Extension, Extension Request, 0 Hale Road, TMS No. 560- 12-00-070, Request for second annual extension of Vested Rights as it pertains to Sketch Plan approval for subject property. Staff Report Mr. Stone reviewed the request with the Commission. Mr. Bennett stated that the requisite criteria, so there is no reason to deny the request. Ms. Ireland moved for approval. Mr. Smyth seconded the motion. All in favor. C. Sketch Plan , SP-13-26, Wakendaw Road, TMS No. 559 -00-00-533, Request to create 10 lots on 6.5 acres, zoned R-1, Residential District. Staff Report Mr. Berry recused himself due to a conflict of interest. Planning Commission October 21, 2026 Page 7 of 15 Mr. Mitchell reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Mr. Bennett asked if the overflow parking exists. Mr. Mitchell answered in the affirmative and stated that the developer has agreed to remove it so they are following the R-1 zoning requirements. Ms. Ireland asked if the parking ratio would be met with the removal of the overflow parking. Mr . Mitchell answered that the number of spaces were not counted, but the minimum parking requirements would have to be met . Ms. Ireland asked if the open space calculation includes the buffers and areas between the lots. Mr. Mitchell answered that the “green” area on the plan indicates the open space that was included in the calculation. He stated that the trail between two of the lots is part of and ingress/egress and not included in the open space calculation. Ms. Ireland suggested that the buffer should not be counted in the open space calculation. Mr. Barber asked if a different access was considered to avoid the removal of the tree in good condition tree and if a different configuration was considered. Mr. Mitchell answered that the configuration of the lot lends to having the access from the southern portion of the property. Mr. Barber asked if there is a roadway to the north of the school. Mr. Mitchell answered in the negative and stated that it is a parking lot drive aisle. Mr. Thomas Martin, Earthsource Engineering, and Mr. Hacker Burr, Head of Trident Academy, reviewed the request with the Commission. He stated that the proposed roadway location was determined as this is where they have right-of-way access to Wakendaw Road; they do not have access through the parking area to the north of the property. He stated that of the eleven trees proposed for removal, only one was considered in good condition, but is located where the right-of-way is proposed; therefore, it needs to be removed. Mr. Bennett asked about the parking lot and the constraints. Mr. Martin answered that Trident Academy leases the property from the owner which includes the property for the parking lot. Mr. Ireland asked the length of the roadway and if an easement has been considered to locate the roadway to the north of the school . Mr. Martin Planning Commission October 21, 2026 Page 8 of 15 answered that it is approximately 1100 feet. Ms. Ireland stated that the land development regulations limit the length of the roadway to 1,000 linear feet. Mr. Martin stated that there is a turnaround near the tree that connects to the parking lot. Mr . Mitchell concurred and stated that the turnaround breaks up the roadway, so the linear foot maximum is calculated from th e point of the turnaround. Ms. Ireland suggested that an LDR waiver would be needed to deviate from the maximum length allowed . Mr. Mitchell answered that this was a staff determination made because of having the turnaround. Ms. Ireland reiterated that an LDR waiver would be needed to deviate from the regulations. Mr . Mitchell stated that similar determinations have been made by staff in the past when there is a turnaround or break in the right-of-way. Mr. Barber asked if the turnaround is sufficient for emergency vehicles. Mr. Martin answered in the affirmative and stated that a gate would be installed as well to preserve the school security. Mr. Mitchell stated that this would be verified to ensure compliance. Mr. Hacker Bur r, Head of Trident Academy, stated that they have not approached the owner of the property regarding an easement, but there are also security concerns with public access to the school property. He stated that they have tried to be transparent with their plans and plans to maintain their financial responsibility. He stated that they have reached out to the neighborhood and have a meeting scheduled for early November to discuss this plan. He suggested that more services provided by Trident Academy are needed within the community, not less. Mr. Smyth asked if the applicant met with the neighborhood yesterday. Mr. Burr answered in the affirmative and stated that they have tried to contact the neighborhood previously on several occasions since late August . Mr. Smyth expressed concern that the residents of the neighborhood have indicated that they were not aware of the request until last Friday. Mr . Burr answered that he is not sure of the reason the residents were not aware of the request, but he can provide evidence that they have been trying to contact representatives of the neighborhood since late August. Ms. Ireland expressed concern that the owner of the Trident Academy property has not been previously contacted about having the access in a different location and asked if the access could be moved. Mr. Burr answered Planning Commission October 21, 2026 Page 9 of 15 that they have had discussions with the property owner about the request, but not about reconfiguring the roadway or if it could be located to the north of the school. Ms. Ireland suggested that moving the roadway to go around the tree in good condition shown within the proposed right -of-way should be considered with possibly acquiring additional property to do so. Mr. JC Taylor stated that since they do not own the school property, they did not consider moving the roadway on property they do not own. He stated that the proposed roadway configuration meets the Town standards and so a deviation of the proposed plan was not considered. Mr. Barber asked about the owner of the property and if there is an association with Trident Academy . Mr. Taylor answered that a benefactor purchased the property and leased it back to the school. Ms. Ireland clarified that the owner is a benefactor of the school and suggested that the property was purchased with the intent to allow the school to lease the property. Ms. Harris asked if a meeting with the neighborhood has been scheduled. Mr. Burr answered in the affirmative and stated that they have scheduled a meeting for early November to have constructive dialog with the neighborhood representatives. Mr. Taylor stated that he was included in the phone conversation yesterday regarding this project and several concerns of the neighborhood were expressed at that time including stormwater issues, participation of the new homeowners in the civic association, and traffic concerns. He stated that it was a positive conversation. Ms. Harris asked if there are any other issues that they intend to discuss. Mr. Taylor answered in the negative. Mr. Barber asked if other iterations have been considered. Mr. Taylor answered in the negative as this request seemed to be a reasonable one with little impact. Ms. Harris asked if the neighborhood concerns have been addressed. Mr. Taylor answered that the stormwater would be captured on site, which would be an improvement, and the ten homes would be less traffic than is currently seen with the school traffic and sport activities. He reiterated that they approached the Town to purchase the property so it could remain a sports field, but the Town did not entertain that offer. He stated that this development would allow the school property to be purchased by the school. Planning Commission October 21, 2026 Page 10 of 15 Ms. Harris asked if there would be any impacts to the existing ponds. Mr. Martin answered that most of the drainage would be handled on site and eventually drain out to I -526 with minimal stormwater handled through the existing ponds. He stated that the flow rates would be reduced. Ms. Ireland asked about the arborist report indicating that the trees in fair condition could be corrected with pruning and suggested that they should not be removed. Mr. Martin answered that they potentially could be preserved. Ms. Ireland suggested that the trees should be preserved if they can and asked if the roadway could be adjusted to avoid the trees. Mr. Martin answered that adjusting the roadway North closer to the school would impact a historic tree. Ms. Ireland suggested that some other options could be considered. Mr. Barber asked if the plan is to sell the land and then purchase the school, and if so, could this be done at the same time . Mr. Taylor answered that the goal is to sell this parcel and then use the proceeds to purchase the school property, but he was not sure if it could be done within the same transaction. He suggested that a conditional approval would provide more guidance that they could then reach out to the school property owner. Mr. Bennett asked if the overflow parking is needed to meet the required parking for the school. Mr. Burr answered that he was not sure, but there is room for additional parking if needed that could be configured so the parking requirements are met. Ms. Ireland asked if the overflow parking area is included in the current open space calculations. Mr. Martin answered in the negative, but once the parking was removed, it would be included as open space. Mr. Barber asked if the roadway could be configured so it is not abutting other residential property. Mr. Bur r noted that there is residential property abutting the north side as well , so he is not sure how the roadway could be configured so it is not abutting residential property. Mr. Davis read a portion of the Code of Ordinances §156.039(A) as follows: The purposes of the R -1, R-2, R-3, and R -4 Residential Districts are to provide for residential neighborhoods with small and medium lot sizes and to encourage the formation and Planning Commission October 21, 2026 Page 11 of 15 continuation of a stable, healthy residential environment. The regulations that apply within these districts are designed to: a) Discourage unwarranted and blighting encroachments by limiting commercial uses and prohibiting industrial uses; b) Disallow any other use that would subsequently interfere with the development or continuation of residential uses; and c) Discourage any use that would generate traffic on minor streets other than that required to serve residences on these streets. Mr. Davis stated that Wakendaw Road is a narrow street with no sidewalks. He suggested that based on the requirements outlined in the ordinance, the proposed request is not a feasible plan. Ms. Ireland read a portion of §155.054(A)(1) and (2) as follows: The desired outcome is to provide reasonable utilization of the property while achieving the intent and purpose of this Greenspace, Wetlands and Environmental Preservation and Protection Plan…that is conducted in a harmonious manner with the natural environment. Ms. Ireland suggested that while zoned R -1, there is an obligation to look for the intent and purpose of the land development regulations to make sure something is not being overdone, is reasonable, and not just maximizing the development capacity. She suggested that many of the trees listed in fair condition could be corrected and therefore should be preserved. She suggested that the roadway could be configured to avoid some of the trees as well even if it means losing some of the lots. She also suggested that the owner of the Trident Academy property should be included in the discussion and that other options should be presented. She suggested that a non -conforming parcel should not be created and if necessary, the required parking should be accommodated. She further suggested that the open space is not double the amount required as indicated by the applicant and the buffer should not be included in the open space calculation. She expressed concern with the length of the roadway and the turnaround and that the roadway should be more in keeping with the other roadways in the neighborhood to maintain the character. Mr. Barber suggested that there are options that could be considered. Planning Commission October 21, 2026 Page 12 of 15 Ms. Harris agreed and suggested that seeing the outcome with the neighborhood meeting could be beneficial. Mr. Smyth agreed. Mr. Davis suggested that based on the ordinance requirements, the current plan does not meet those requirements. Ms. Ireland that there is some traffic generated with the sport events that are held on the field should be considered as well; however, this is not the only issue of concern. Ms. Ireland moved for denial. Mr. Davis seconded the motion. All in favor with Mr. Berry abstaining. D. SKETCH PLAN, SP-14-26, 1520 Rifle Range Road, TMS No. 560-00-00-038, Request to create thirteen lots on 4.88 acres, zoned R -1, Residential District. This item was withdrawn by staff. E. Sketch Plan , SP-15-26, Spring Hope Drive , TMS No. 558-00-00-556, Request to create three lots on 1.44 acres. LDR Waiver also requested to subdivide from an access easement. Staff Report Ms. Mercer reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Ms. Ireland asked for clarification on the property line. Ms. Mercer showed the location of the easement. Mr. Mitchell clarified that recent changes to the LDRs would mean that the portion of the ingress/egress easement would be incorporated with the property that the easement serves; therefore, the property line would be shifted to the right. Mr. Berry asked if this would create a flag lot. Mr. Mitchell answered that it would have the configuration of a flag lot. Ms. Ireland stated that it makes sense to move the property line to the right, but it would still be a flag lot which is an issue. The Commission discussed the issue of having flag lots. Planning Commission October 21, 2026 Page 13 of 15 Mr. Davis asked what is being proposed , particularly showing the tree survey. Ms. Mercer showed the proposed sketch plan with the protected trees for the Commission. Mr. Davis McNair reviewed the request with the Commission. Mr. Barber asked if the roadway could be moved to the other side. Mr. McNair answered that this would mean the main structure would be located closer to the historic tree. He stated that there would be less impact to the historic tree with the configuration as proposed. Mr. Berry suggested that this is a sensitive plan with fewer lots than was previously proposed. Mr. Barber suggested that the roadway should be configured to accommodate all the lots. Ms. Ireland expressed concern with setting a precedent of allowing a flag lot. Mr. Berry moved for approval. Mr. Bennett seconded the motion. Motion passed on a 6 to 1 vote with Mr. Smyth, Mr. Bennett, Mr. Barber, Ms. Harris, Mr. Davis, and Mr. Berry in favor; Ms. Ireland opposed. 7. Discussion of Density in relation to Future Land Use Designations Ms. Reed reviewed the request with the Commission. Mr. Barber suggested that having a review of proposals when there is a discrepancy between the Future Land Use Map ( FLUM) and zoning could be beneficial. Ms. Ireland agreed that there should be a review and approval process when there is a discrepancy. She suggested that with the next update to the Comprehensive Plan, the properties should be rezoned to be consistent with the FLUM. Planning Commission October 21, 2026 Page 14 of 15 Mr. Bennett asked how many properties would be inconsistent with the FLUM. Ms. Reed answered that she is not sure. Mr. Bennett asked if properties recently annexed would have the discrepancy. Ms. Reed answered in the negative and stated that the discrepancies occur with properties that have had zoning for many years and with the updates to the Comp rehensive Plan, now do not match the FLUM. The Commission discussed having the review if there is a significant change to the property . The Commission discussed that looking at those discrepancies through the update of the Comprehensive Plan would be beneficial as well. The Commission agreed that a special exception should be required with specific parameters specified. Ms. Reed stated that staff would review this option to determine if it can legally be accomplished. 8. Discussion of Data Center Land Use and Zoning Ms. Reed reviewed this matter with the Commission. Ms. Ireland asked if the definition of an ancillary use couldbe better specified. Ms. Reed answered that this can be reviewed to ensure that clarification. Mr. Davis asked if the moratorium is for two years. Ms. Reed answered in the affirmative. Mr. Davis agreed that this is the time for this to be discussed and the appropriate parameters put in place. Ms. Ireland asked if the special exception could be configured specifically for the data center. Ms. Reed answered in the affirmative. Mr. Barber asked if the Town can impose water requirements or utility requirements within the special exception. Ms. Reed answered that this can be considered. Mr. Bennett suggested that noise pollution would be another important factor. Ms. Reed suggested that additional distance requirements could be considered. Planning Commission October 21, 2026 Page 15 of 15 Mr. Barber suggested that the loss of revenue should be another consideration because the data centers are not manned and independently run. Mr. Bennett suggested that the Town does not lend to having large data centers. The Commission agreed that a special exception should be considered with specific criteria outlined. There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 7:34 pm. Submitted by, L. Lynes PlanComsn10212026

Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.