RecordWell Data

_10122026-2269

Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Oct 12, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SOUTH CAROLINA HISTORIC DISTRICT PRESERVATION COMMISSION OCTOBER 12, 2026 MINUTES Staff Report Present: Meghan Gravitt, Chair, Krystine Edwards, Kenny Craft, Eugene Foxworth, Warren Player. Staff: Bryan Hankinson, Lynnette Lynes Ms. Gravitt called the meeting to order at 5:00 pm. A. Approval of Agenda Ms. Gravitt moved for approval of the agenda. Ms. Edwards seconded t he motion. All in favor. B. Approval of Minutes—September 14, 2026 Minutes Ms. Gravitt moved for approval of the minutes. Ms. Edwards seconded the motion. All in favor. C. General Public Comment D. Correspondence E. Consent Motions All correspondence received was linked to the agenda. There being no comments or consent motions, Ms. Gravitt continued with the agenda. F. Business 1. 303 Morrison St. , No Survey Card/Non -Historic – TMS 5320100046, Preliminary Review for the construction of a new addition to the primary structure. This item was withdrawn by the applicant. Historic District Preservation Commission October 12, 2026 Page 2 of 9 2. 2 Pierates Cruze , Survey Card 6061/Non-Historic – TMS 5320900007, Preliminary Review for maintenance on the primary structure, pool replacement, pool house, and hardscaping. Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Ms. Kim Floyd, and Mr. Bryan Plumley, owners, reviewed the request with the Commission and stated that they are available for questions. Mr. Will Smith, designer, asked for clarification about the porkchop eaves and suggested that this is a “poor man’s eave return”. Mr. John Durlack, 1 Pierates Cruze, stated that he resides next to the requested property. He expressed concern that the height, scale, and mass is too large and would be visible from Alhambra Hall and their property. He suggested that the addition would be intrusive, noisy, and af fect their use of their backyard. He suggested an engineer be consulted to ensure proper drainage of the property. There being no further comments, Ms. Gravitt closed public comment. Mr. Craft asked about the setback relief request. Mr. Smith answered that the pool is closer to the home. Mr. Hankinson clarified that a structure is considered attached if there is a connecting elevated walkway and therefore would have to meet the primary structure setbacks. Mr. Craft asked if the addition needed to be raised due to flood elevation. Mr. Smith answered in the affirmative. Mr. Craft asked the height of the roof. Mr. Smith answered that it is approximately ten feet. Mr. Plumley stated that the total square footage is approximately 400 square feet. Mr. Hankinson suggested that because it is considered a part of the primary structure the Commission could approv e encroachment into the primary structure setbacks. Mr. Smith stated that the accessory structure would be separated from the primary structure. Mr. Player suggested that this should be well shown on subsequent plans. Historic District Preservation Commission October 12, 2026 Page 3 of 9 Ms. Gravitt asked if the deck is included in the square footage for the porch. Mr. Smith answered that only the covered deck portion of the accessory structure is included in the porch percentage. Mr. Craft asked about the changes of the new pool from the existing pool. Mr. Plumley answered that the original plan was to keep the pool in the same location of the e xisting pool, but due to the new accessory setback requirements, they are asking for a variance to keep the pool in the same location. Mr. Hankinson stated that a setback variance would be needed from the Board of Zoning Appeals prior to receiving approval from this Commission. Mr. Smith stated that they are trying to be as environmentally sensitive to the site as possible. Mr. Foxworth asked if moving the pool to the other side of the lot was considered. Ms. Floyd answered that this was considered, but the neighboring property would be developed as well. Mr. Foxworth suggested that the bac of the structure would be prefer able to the pool. Mr. Foxworth suggested that it is too massive and should be scaled down. He suggested that it appears to be more of an ADU. Mr. Craft asked about the windows of the accessory structure and if they could be proportioned to be more in keeping with the main structure. He suggested that the dental details should be reviewed. Mr. Craft suggested that the back of the structure is bare and suggested that there should be more windows. Mr. Craft suggested that the partial gable and roofline should be restudied to help with the scale and mass. He suggested a hip roof would be more in keeping with the historic district. Mr. Smith thanked the Commission for their comments. Mr. Player suggested that the drainage should be maintained on the property, particularly around the pool area. He asked for details on the handrails. He suggested that the chart included in the plan should be reviewed to ensure the information is correct. He stated that fencing was not addressed Historic District Preservation Commission October 12, 2026 Page 4 of 9 and if being replaced, they should provide those details. He also suggested that material details for the deck should be included. Ms. Gravitt suggested that the architecture details should mimic the primary structure and be more cohesive. She suggested that the massing be reviewed, particularly the impact of the neighbors. Ms. Edwards agreed with Ms. Gravitt’s comments regarding cohesiveness. She suggested that the accessory structure should complement the primary structure and “make sense”. Mr. Craft suggested that the windows should be more proportionate. He suggested that the renderings should show better idea of massing. Ms. Gravitt suggested that an overlay showing the new pool compared to the existing pool should be included. 3. 328 Bennett St. , Survey Card 6157/Historic – TMS 5320100057, Preliminary Review for the demolition of a rear deck and the addition of enclosed heated space and a rear covered porch. Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Mr. Clay Tucker, architect, reviewed the request with the Commission. There being no comments, Ms. Gravitt moved to Commission questions. Mr. Craft asked that the massing be simplified. Ms. Gravitt asked about the porch calculations to ensure they are accurate. She stated that the porch should be 10%. Ms. Gravitt asked if the home is historic. Mr. Tucker answered that the rear sunroom is not historic. She stated that the additions should be subordinate to the main structure. Mr. Craft asked if any of the original windows are being relocated. Mr. Tucker answered that this could be considered. Historic District Preservation Commission October 12, 2026 Page 5 of 9 Mr. Foxworth asked the roof color. Mr. Tucker answered that it is a brown, bronze color. Mr. Foxworth asked if there are specific roof colors. Mr. Hankinson answered in the negative. Mr. Foxworth suggested that a more historic roof color should be considered. Mr. Craft suggested that the rear porch should have similar eave details and the window details clearer on the drawings. Ms. Gravitt asked if the brick material would change. Mr. Tucker answered in the negative. Mr. Player asked if the shutters would be operable. Mr. Tucker answered in the affirmative. Mr. Foxworth asked if any setback relief is being sought. Mr. Tucker answered in the negative. Mr. Craft suggested that it is a straightforward, simple design. 4. 211 Bennett St. , Survey Card 6141/Non-Historic – TMS 5320100260, Final Review for the installation of a driveway gate and new entrance hardscapes. Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Mr. Charles Quinn, architect, reviewed the request with the Commission. There being no comments, Ms. Gravitt closed public comment. Ms. Gravitt asked what other requests are being considered. Mr. Hankinson answered that more hardscape is being proposed due to moving the fence back as recommended by the Commission. Ms. Gravitt asked if a conditional approval can be given. Mr. Hankinson answered in the affirmative. Mr. Hankinson asked that the guidelines do not specify that the posts cannot exceed the 42 inch height. Historic District Preservation Commission October 12, 2026 Page 6 of 9 Mr. Player moved for approval. Mr. Foxworth seconded the motion. All in favor. 5. 420 Church St., Survey Card 4250/Non-Historic – TMS 5320100096, Final Review for alterations to a previously approved COA. Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Ms. Balzac, architect, reviewed the request with the Commission. There being no comments, Ms. Gravitt closed public comment. Mr. Craft expressed concern with the dentil molding and asked that details be provided. He suggested that there are existing casing details and suggested that the dentil molding might detract from the existing details. Mr. Craft asked if a full porch was previously proposed. Mr. Balzac answered in the affirmative, but it was too close to the road. Mr. Craft suggested that more details of the front porch and door should be provided. He suggested a simpler transom should be considered. Ms. Edwards agreed that the door should be simplified. Mr. Craft asked if the windows on the rear dormer are being proposed. Ms. Balzac answered in the affirmative to provide an egress. Mr. Craft suggested that the dent il mo lding should be resolved and the casings corrected. Mr. Craft asked if the front stoop needs railing. Ms. Balzac answered that she is unsure. Mr. Craft suggested that the overhang of the front door should be re-studied. Mr. Player asked the location of the fencing. Ms. Balzac showed the location of the fencing for the Commission. Mr. Player asked about the cupola. He suggested that the cupola is not consistent with the character of the historic district. Ms. Balzac asked about the pineapples. Ms. Balzac answered that this was a feature desired by the client. Historic District Preservation Commission October 12, 2026 Page 7 of 9 Ms. Edwards agreed that the pineapples on the fence was not appropriate. Ms. Gravitt suggested that more landscaping details should be provided. The Commission suggested that the amount of changes needed would be a significant amount of changes to warrant not having to wait the twelve months for resubmittal. Ms. Gravitt moved for denial. Mr. Player seconded the motion. All in favor. 6. 102 Pitt St. , Survey Card 5935/Historic – TMS 5320100090, Preliminary Review for the demolition and construction of new hardscapes, repainting of the primary structure, and rear infill of window. Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff comments with the Commission. Ms. Allison Dawson, architect, reviewed the request with the Commission. There being no comments, Ms. Gravitt closed public comments. Ms. Edwards asked if the rear was previously added. Ms. Dawson answered in the affirmative and stated that there is a clear delineation where the non-historic addition begins. Ms. Edwards asked if the window is historic. Ms. Dawson answered in the negative. Mr. Craft asked if there a way to keep the window for more natural light. Ms. Dawson answered that they prefer to fill in the window, but other options could be considered. Mr. Craft asked if the windows have bars. Ms. Dawson answered in the affirmative and stated that they are not metal bars, but metal and glass jalousie with wood mullion scrim on the outside. She stated that the metal bar note was a mistake. Mr. Craft asked if it is currently yellow brick. Ms. Dawson answered in the affirmative. Ms. Edwards asked about the doors. Ms. Dawson answered that they are not wanting to change the doors, but if necessary, they could be replaced in- kind. Ms. Edwards asked about the French doors on the side elevations. Ms. Dawson answered that there is a single door that then changes. She stated Historic District Preservation Commission October 12, 2026 Page 8 of 9 that there is a difference in the trusses and plinth showing where the addition starts. Mr. Craft asked about the proposed bricked in window. Ms. Dawson answered that it was done so that it shows that it was previously being there. Mr. Player asked about the front paving around the tree. Ms. Dawson answered that an arborist has reviewed the plan in relation to the tree. She stated that the proposed opening around the tree is larger than was existing. Mr. Player asked the color of the pavers. Ms. Dawson answered that the cut sheet for the pavers was included. Mr. Player asked what pattern would be used. Ms. Dawson answered that it would be a straight stack. Mr. Player asked about the ben ch around the tree and suggested that the drawing is a better rendition. Mr. Player stated that he likes the simplicity of the sign. Ms. Gravitt asked the materials for the sign. Ms. Dawson answered that this has been requested. She stated that the accent lighting is done by a local company. Mr. Foxworth asked if it is a muted metal for the lights. Ms. Dawson answered in the affirmative. Mr. Foxworth stated that he is comfortable with the window being filled in and likes that it will remain to show that it once existed. Mr. Hankinson asked for clarification from the Commission on whet her they are comfortable filling in the window. Ms. Dawson asked if final approval could be considered. Mr. Player suggested that the changes should be made for the Commission to review. Ms. Edwards suggested that the bench around the tree should be less modern. Mr. Player stated that he does not have a concern with filling in the window. Ms. Edwards agreed. Mr. Craft answered that he is not opposed to the window being filled in. Mr. Craft suggested that the renderings should be more accurate. Historic District Preservation Commission October 12, 2026 Page 9 of 9 Mr. Player asked if the tree coul d have irrigation. Ms. Dawson answered that this could be done. Ms. Gravitt suggested that more details on the materials for the sign and lighting should be provided. She stated that she is comfortable with filling in the window. G. Staff Approvals Mr. Hankinson reviewed staff approvals with the Commission as follows: 1. 416 Church St. , Survey Card 4250 /Non-Historic – TMS 5320100096, Approved for the construction of new roofing. 2. 303 Hibben St. , Survey Card 6230/Non-Historic – TMS 5320100100, Approved for the construction of new temporary fencing. 3. 310 Bennett St. , Survey Card 6155/Historic – TMS 5320100059, Approved for the construction of new roofing. 4. 9 William St. , Survey Card 6033/Non-Historic – TMS 5321300043, Approved for the construction of new fencing. H. Draft Review of Changes to Right-of-way Fencing Requirements Mr. Hankinson stated that he did not receive any draft changes from the Commission. Ms. Gravitt moved for deferral. Mr. Player seconded the motion. All in favor. I. Discussion of Items for Next Agenda There were no additional items for the next agenda. There being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 6:31 pm. Submitted by, L. Lynes HDPC10122026

Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.