RecordWell Data

BZA-SD Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Mar 4, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – SITE DESIGN PUBLIC COMMENT MARCH 4, 2026 A meeting of the B ZA-SD will be held on Wednesday, March 4, 2026 at 5:00 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting and also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bza-sd. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 1. 8 Poplar St. North Central | Council District 4 | TMS #463-12-01-003 | Zoned: DR-1F Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 1 grand tree. Owner: Nicholas Rembowski Applicant: April Magill, Root Down Designs, LLC No Comments Submitted 2. 2296 Clements Ferry Rd. Cainhoy | Council District 1 | TMS #267-00-00-130 | Zoned: LI Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 2 grand trees. Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 2 grand trees. Owner: Carpin Dennis Etal Applicant: Earthsource Engineering No Comments Submitted 3. Murraywood Rd Johns Island | Council District 3 | TMS #312-00-00-071, 657 & 330 | Zoned: DR-6/SR-1 Request variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 6 grand trees. Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 3 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec 54-330 to allow a reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 10 grand trees. Owner: Southeastern Recapitalization Group, LLC Applicant: Earthsource Engineering 10 Comments Submitted: • Will Inman, 1891 Brittlebush Lane, Johns Island, SC 29455 Submitted to Innovate Site on Feb. 27, 2026 2:32 PM The term “protected” for the grand oak trees which our island is known for is becoming more and more vague. We can’t allow this slippery slope to take away our island’s Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | March 4, 2026 Page 2 character. Building around these trees has always been the way we’ve coexisted with nature on the island, and size/scale of a development should not dictate whether or not our island looses its most precious aspect. Developers should be more considerate when trying to cram in Charleston’s growing population that doesn’t want to live in Nexton/Cane Bay for this very reason. • Shirley Stowe, 2910 Sweetleaf Lane, Johns Island, SC 29455 Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 2, 2026 3:45 PM I am opposed to the removal of all grand trees mentioned. I live on Sweetleaf and would be profoundly impacted by approval of this varience. • Peter Rubino, 3009 Tugalo St Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 3, 2026 12:45 AM The requested variance states the many of the trees are in poor health and need to be removed due to the layout of the development. In reviewing the submission, many of the trees to be removed and encroached are Grades A, B and C with a couple of D's. This does not sound like unhealthy trees and these should be saved by adjusting the layout to save and enhance the utilization of the existing trees. Just because previous developments in the overall Master Plan had many trees removed, it does not mean that we should allow the continuation of bad decisions impact this new are to be developed. Let's save the trees and figure out a way to adjust the layout so there is no impact. Past mistakes in allowing the removal of grand trees does not automatically mean that same mistake should be continued. Please do not approve these variance requests. • Leigh Dunlap, 113 Risewell Court, Johns Island, SC 29455 Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 3, 2026 8:13 AM As a Johns Island resident, I strongly oppose the removal of so many trees for these projects. It's ironic that one is called "Live Oaks Square" when it seeks to remove so many of them. These trees are part of the character of the Island and a reason people choose to live here. Projects need to design around them and incorporate them. Growth is understandable and necessary for a community, but not at the expense of destroying the very reason people want to live here. Turning Johns Island into one big condo complex with strip malls gives us nothing to enjoy while we're sitting in mind- numbingly awful traffic. • Jessica Snyder, 2860 Sweetleaf Ln Johns Islannd SC 29455 Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 3, 2026 9:17 AM Whitney Lakes Multi-Family (TMS #312-00-00-071, 657 & 330) To the Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design, I am writing to express my strong opposition to the request for variances and special exceptions regarding the Whitney Lakes Multi-Family project. The applicant is seeking to remove 9 grand trees and encroach upon the critical root zones of 10 others. Under South Carolina law and the City of Charleston Code, this application fails to meet the required "Unnecessary Hardship" criteria for the following reasons: 1. The Hardship is Self-Created (Not Extraordinary): Per Sec. 54-329, a variance requires "extraordinary and exceptional conditions." The existence of grand trees on a Lowcountry lot is not "exceptional"—it is a standard characteristic of our landscape. The only "hardship" here is the developer's desire to maximize density to 100 units. A self-created financial hardship is not a legal basis for a variance. 2. Failure to Explore Economically Reasonable Alternatives: The ordinance prohibits removal unless "no other reasonable design or Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | March 4, 2026 Page 3 economically reasonable alternative exists." The applicant has not demonstrated that a 90-unit or 85-unit plan—which would preserve these 19 impacted trees—is economically unfeasible. Preservation is possible; it simply requires a less aggressive site layout. 3. Detriment to Public Good and Drainage: Johns Island faces significant stormwater challenges. Removing 9 grand trees (which can each absorb hundreds of gallons of water daily) and reducing setbacks for 10 more will increase runoff and thermal heat in the Whitney Lakes area. This constitutes a "substantial detriment to the public good" and harms the "character of the district." 4. Special Exception Standards: Regarding the 3 grand trees under "Special Exception," we ask the Board to verify if these trees are truly in poor health via a certified arborist’s report. If they are healthy, they should be saved, as the "protection of specimen trees" does not outweigh the loss of healthy, established grand trees. We urge the Board to deny these requests and require the applicant to return with a site plan that respects the City’s tree canopy and the intent of Section 54-325. • Liz Munn, 3631 Morse Avenue, Johns Island SC 29455 Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 3, 2026 11:23 AM Removal of 6 grand trees, an exception for 3 grand trees and reduce the construction set back to protect 10 grand trees! This is outrageous and should not be permitted. Continued development of this area for single-family homes is expected. Slaughtering of every natural resource in the area is not. Developers and builders can and should investigate the ability to move trees, work around trees, and become more responsible. Do not ruin the beauty and reason why so many people want to move here. I respectfully request this tree removal be denied. These trees take 100 years to be replaced. A Tree fund a replanting or any other proposed effort is unacceptable. • Yvonne Riley, 1670 Pleasant Hill Dr Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 3, 2026 11:46 AM Enough trees has already been sacrificed on our island and more than enough multiFamily dwellings have been added! Stop. • Somer Gilbert, 2776 Calico Bass Ln Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 3, 2026 11:47 AM Please do not remove the grand trees from this area as they are very important to the surrounding ecosystem. We need them for flooding mitigation and the local wildlife. • Arabella Carrigan, 2728 Harmony Lake Drive Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 3, 2026 11:49 AM Charleston protects its historic downtown because we understand that preservation matters. Our grand oak trees deserve the same respect. Many of these live oaks have stood for centuries, longer than the buildings around them. They are living monuments to South Carolina’s history, witnesses to generations of change, hurricanes, and growth. Once they are cut down, they cannot be replaced in our lifetime. Planting a sapling does not replace a 200 year old canopy. If we truly value southern charm and historical integrity, we must protect the trees that define it. These oaks are not just beautiful backdrops for photographs. They are critical infrastructure. Their vast root systems stabilize soil and reduce erosion. Their canopies lower temperatures in a city that grows hotter every year. They absorb stormwater in a coastal community that faces flooding and stronger storms. Removing mature trees in the name of convenience or short term development is not progress. It is shortsighted policy that weakens our environmental resilience. Charleston’s identity is tied to the sweeping arches of live Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | March 4, 2026 Page 4 oaks draped in Spanish moss. Visitors travel here for that character and that sense of place. Our tree canopy is part of our tourism economy and part of what makes neighborhoods feel like home. Development and preservation can coexist, but only if preservation is treated as a priority and not an afterthought. Once these trees are gone, the character that draws people to Charleston disappears with them. If we have laws that protect historic buildings downtown, we must extend that same seriousness to historic trees. Grand oaks are older than most structures in this city. They are not landscaping. They are living history. Development should work around them, not erase them. These trees have survived centuries of storms and change. They anchor our communities and connect us to the past. Charleston can grow without losing its roots. Protecting our historic oaks is not anti growth. It is pro legacy. It is pro environment. It is pro Charleston. • Janet Boggs, 2958 Sweetleaf Lane Johns Island Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 3, 2026 11:59 AM Please deny the request to remove 19 grand oak trees. 4. Maybank Hwy. Johns Island | Council District 3 | TMS #313-00-00-584 & 585 | Zoned: PUD Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 1 grand tree. Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 15 protected trees. Owner: Crowne Partners, Inc. Applicant: SeamonWhiteside & Associates 7 Comments Submitted: • Shirley Stowe, 2910 Sweetleaf Lane, Johns Island, SC 29455 Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 2, 2026 3:47 PM I am opposed to the removal of the grand trees mentioned in this request. • Olivia Wanek, 3024 Reva Ridge Dr. Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 2, 2026 8:02 PM The removal of these trees for yet more apartments is abysmal. The overdevelopment of john’s island needs to stop and we should be focused on preserving such a beautiful island. Crowne can’t even fill the apartments they have there’s no reason they need to remove protected trees to build more. this about nothing more than simple greed. • Richard Jerue, 1935 Mitnick Lane, Johns Island, SC Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 3, 2026 10:38 AM I oppose the removal of the grand oak. This is supposed to be Live Oak Square. It would seem that the builder could come up with a design that would preserve the grand oak. If you look at the current Crowne apartment development thay have designed buildings that do preserve the grand trees. They should do this with their new project. Also, keeping as many of the protected trees as possible should be a BZA goal. • Liz Munn, 3631 Morse Avenue, Johns Island 29455 Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 3, 2026 11:27 AM Removal of 15 grand trees for an apartment complex should not be happening. An exception for one grand tree, which I assume is in a construction zone. That would total 16 grand trees removed for an apartment building. These trees are a resource for Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | March 4, 2026 Page 5 Johns Island. They protect us from environmental changes, flooding, and preserve our way of life. Many people move to our area for the natural beauty that is being proposed to be destroyed. To replace this natural resource would take over 100 years. Removing trees on the scale for construction projects is irresponsible. Grand trees can be moved, plans can be changed, and we can coexist. I strongly request this variance be denied, and these trees remain. • Yvonne Riley, 1670 Pleasant Hill Dr Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 3, 2026 11:48 AM Please don’t destroy it. Replacing these trees with something else is not the same. Grand trees take 100 years to mature. Do not do an irresponsible thing and remove these trees. Change your plans to coexist with these grand trees who have stood on this property for over 100 years. Trees assist with flooding issues. • Arabella Carrigan, 2728 Harmony Lake Drive Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 3, 2026 11:51 AM I am 16 years old. I grew up here in the heart of Johns Island. It breaks my heart to see the landscape being destroyed. Charleston protects its historic downtown because we understand that preservation matters. Our grand oak trees deserve the same respect. Many of these live oaks have stood for centuries, longer than the buildings around them. They are living monuments to South Carolina’s history, witnesses to generations of change, hurricanes, and growth. Once they are cut down, they cannot be replaced in our lifetime. Planting a sapling does not replace a 200 year old canopy. If we truly value southern charm and historical integrity, we must protect the trees that define it. These oaks are not just beautiful backdrops for photographs. They are critical infrastructure. Their vast root systems stabilize soil and reduce erosion. Their canopies lower temperatures in a city that grows hotter every year. They absorb stormwater in a coastal community that faces flooding and stronger storms. Removing mature trees in the name of convenience or short term development is not progress. It is shortsighted policy that weakens our environmental resilience. Charleston’s identity is tied to the sweeping arches of live oaks draped in Spanish moss. Visitors travel here for that character and that sense of place. Our tree canopy is part of our tourism economy and part of what makes neighborhoods feel like home. Development and preservation can coexist, but only if preservation is treated as a priority and not an afterthought. Once these trees are gone, the character that draws people to Charleston disappears with them. If we have laws that protect historic buildings downtown, we must extend that same seriousness to historic trees. Grand oaks are older than most structures in this city. They are not landscaping. They are living history. Development should work around them, not erase them. These trees have survived centuries of storms and change. They anchor our communities and connect us to the past. Charleston can grow without losing its roots. Protecting our historic oaks is not anti growth. It is pro legacy. It is pro environment. It is pro Charleston. • Janet Boggs, 2958 Sweetleaf Ln Johns Island Submitted to Innovate Site on Mar. 3, 2026 12:00 PM Please deny the request to remove 16 grand oak trees. Board of Zoning Appeals – Site Design Public Comment | March 4, 2026 Page 6 5. West Ashley Circle West Ashley | Council District 5 | TMS #301-00-00-819 | Zoned: PUD Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 5 grand trees. Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 5 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec 54-330 to allow a reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 3 grand trees. Owner: Bees Wedge, LLC Applicant: Kimley-Horn No Comments Submitted 6. Grand Oaks Blvd. West Ashley | Council District 10 | TMS #301-00-00-052 | Zoned: GB/LB Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 37 grand trees. Request a special exception from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 4 grand trees. Request a variance from Sec 54-327 to allow the removal of 22 protected trees. Request a variance from Sec 54-330 to allow a reduction in the impervious construction setback near the bases of 10 grand trees. Owner: Bees Resources Applicant: Thomas & Hutton DEFERRED No Comments Submitted

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.