_03042026-10729
City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Mar 4, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Charleston
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City of Charleston
Commission on History
March 4 , 202 6 , P age 1
City of Charleston
History Commission
March 4 , 2 0 2 6
A meeting of the History Commission was held this date beginning at 4 :0 0 p.m. at City Hall, 80
Broad Street.
Notice of this meeting was sent to all local news m e d ia .
Present: Harlan Greene, Chair, Elizabeth Chew, Peg Eastman, Wilmot Fraser (arrived at 4:03
p.m.) , Angela Mack, David McCormack, Ken Scarlett, and Dale Theiling.
L in k to m eetin g : h ttp s://w w w .yo u tu b e.co m /w atch ? v= 8X -iiH Jxf2s& t= 413s
A. Call to Order
Chair Greene called the meeting to order .
B. Minutes
1. January 7, 2026
On a motion of David McCormack, seconded by Elizabeth Chew, the Commission on History
voted unanimously to approve item B1.
C. Old Business
1. Moonshine Marker
On a motion of David McCormack, seconded by Peg Eastman, the Commission on History voted
unanimously to approve item C1 as shown below.
IN MEMORY OF MOONSHINE
POLICE HORSE, LOYAL PARTNER, FALLEN HERO
END OF WATCH: JANUARY 25, 1994
LAID TO REST HERE, MOONSHINE, OF THE CITY OF
CHARLESTON POLICE DEPARTMENT MOUNTED HORSE
PATROL UNIT, SERVED OUR COMMUNITY WITH HONOR,
LOYALTY, HEART, COURAGE, AND GRACE.
A STEADFAST COMPANION TO OFFICERS AND A BELOVED
PRESENCE ON OUR STREETS, MOONSHINE EXEMPLIFIED
City of Charleston
Commission on History
March 4 , 202 6 , P age 2
DEDICATION, STRENGTH, AND QUIET DIGNITY.
HIS IMPACT ON OUR COMMUNITY ENDURES.
MAY HIS MEMORY FOREVER BE A REMINDER OF THE TRUE
COST OF SERVICE.
SPONSORED BY THE CITY OF CHARLESTON POLICE
DEPARTMENT
Commissioner Fraser entered the Chamber at 4:03 p.m.
2. Protect and Respect the Bodies Under the YWCA (106 Coming Street) Update
Chair Greene gave an update on the 106 Coming Street project. He said he had presented the
Commission ’s resolution to City Council. At that meeting, he suggested that the Commission may
not have had to make a resolution if the City of Charleston had an archaeologist, but he said he
had made it clear that that was not in their resolution.
He said he had received an email from Anna-Catherine Alexander with the Preservation Society
giving an update on the project. He relayed that the State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO)
had made comments on Terracon Consultants, Inc. ’s updated program. These included questions
regarding funding if the project took decades to complete. They further said that the City of
Charleston had the power to rule on the issue, and that that should be a part of the plan. They
also said that it could not be accepted as a foregone conclusion that the graves would be moved
and that the building would be built. SHPO further said that while there was a Community
Engagement Council, they had not engaged with the descendant community.
D. Presentation: Pre-1734 Godfrey-Lining-Hill Family Cemetery at Magnolia Park (for
information only)
Ms. Donna Jacobs introduced the West Ashley Historians present at the meeting , including
Charlie Smith, Diane Hamilton, Ina Bootle, and Kenneth Marolda.
Mr. Charlie Smith gave a presentation regarding the Pre-1734 Godfrey-Lining-Hill Family
Cemetery at Magnolia Park . The full presentation can be viewed using the link above.
The cemetery was on public land and protected by a conservation easement now held by the
Lowcountry Land Trust. However, the cemetery was not named as a conservation value in that
easement because no one knew it was there at the time of writing. The West Ashley Historians
believed that a modification to the easement and a historic marker would provide the best long-
term protection for the cemetery.
Commissioner McCormack said that the presentation was probably the best-written and best-
researched presentation the Commission had received in a long time.
Further discussion was held regarding the cemetery.
Following discussion, Chair Greene thanked the West Ashley Historians.
E. Presentation: Reconstruction City Council Presented by Mike Lyons (for
information only)
City of Charleston
Commission on History
March 4 , 202 6 , P age 3
Mr. Mike Lyons gave a presentation on the Reconstruction-era Charleston City Council. The full
presentation can be viewed using the link above.
Mr. Lyons said he had been a Masters student at age 68 at the College of Charleston, and one
of the projects he had worked on for his thesis was the Reconstruction-era Black Republicans on
City Council. He thought it was a very interesting story, and he thought there could be a public
history project that could be placed at City Hall. He gave historical background on the City
government at that time.
Discussion was held amongst the Commission on Mr. Lyons ’ proposal.
Commissioner Eastman said that this was a chapter that was missing from City Hall.
Commissioner Fraser said he was impressed with the research and was in favor of what he was
doing. He thought it would be appropriate for the Commission to ask City Council to support the
project.
Chair Greene thanked Mr. Lyons for his presentation.
Commissioner Eastman said there were a lot of other things that happened in Council Chambers
not just during Reconstruction, and she felt such an exhibit should be all-inclusive, not limited to
a single period of time.
Further discussion was held.
Mr. Lyons said he would send the Commission a copy of his thesis.
Chair Greene thanked Mr. Lyons.
F. Miscellaneous Business
Commissioner Fraser said he had been talking to a number of people around the city to see
what people thought of the Robert E. Lee Memorial Highway monument being moved to Marion
Square, and he thought that in general, most people thought it was a bad idea. He felt that they
needed to remove it as soon as possible.
He said they also needed to clarify the position of the City regarding Marion Square.
Commissioner Fraser said that the City had previously stated that it did not own Marion Square ,
but Commissioner Fraser said that was a fiction . He said that the fact was the City did own it,
upkept it, that public funds kept it going, and that the City had a history of governing it through a
Special Commission since 1882.
He asked that the Commission place a draft resolution regarding this issue on the next agenda.
He said that the things placed in Marion Square needed to reflect the spirit of freedom.
Chair Greene said that the Assistant Clerk had distributed the current Memorandum of
Understanding between the City of Charleston and the Board of Field Officers of the Fourth
Brigade. There would be further discussion on the topic the following month.
Commissioner Theiling said the ownership of Marion Square is not a fiction ; it is owned by the
Board of Field Officers of the Fourth Brigade . He was the Chairman of that board. The
Memorandum of Understanding pertained to the public use of Marion Square. It did not talk
about the ownership or responsibilities of the City or the Board of Field Officers as far as what
was displayed on Marion Square. It had to do only with the public use, which had become very
complex in recent years.
He said that the sole purpose of the Board was to own Marion Square and to cooperate with the
City for its public use, which it had done since 1833. The Civil War had not disrupted that
agreement.
City of Charleston
Commission on History
March 4 , 202 6 , P age 4
He went on to say that the pre-war militia was a fact of life, but that they were now a
fraternal/social historic unit, and only two remained . He said there was nothing clandestine
about Marion Square and that the roadside marker was not there to “resurrect the Confederacy ”
as had been suggested by Commissioner Fraser at the previous meeting. The purpose of the
Board of Field Officers was to honor the military involvement of the State of South Carolina and
her people, particularly the City of Charleston. They were there to continue to represent the
military.
Commissioner Fraser said that it was the United States military.
Commissioner Theiling confirmed . He said that virtually all members of the Board are veterans
of the military .
Commissioner Fraser said that it was the United States military.
Commissioner Theiling confirmed and said that it was currently the 21 st Century.
Chair Greene asked for any further points of miscellaneous business.
No one asked to speak.
Chair Greene said they would proceed with Commissioner Fraser ’s proposal the following
meeting.
G. Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 5 :35 p .m .
Philip E . C la p p e r
Assistant Clerk of Council
Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.