RecordWell Data

BZA-Z Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Mar 3, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING PUBLIC COMMENT MARCH 3, 2026 A meeting of the Board of Zoning Appeals – Zoning (BZA-Z) will be held on Tuesday, March 3, 2026 at 5:15 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of the meeting and also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bza-z. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 975 & 989 Morrison Dr. East Central | Council District 4 | TMS# 459-01-01-083/001 | Zoned: UP Request variance from Sec. 54-299.25 to construct a multi-family development without an active use on the ground floor. Owner: Scott Fuller Applicant: Brad K Brown 135 Comments Submitted: • North Central Neighborhood Association Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Preservation Society of Charleston Submitted to Staff See attached letter. • Comments Submitted to Innovate Site 5 Comments in Support | 128 Comments in Opposition See attached comments. North Central Neighborhood Association March 2, 2026 Christina Walsh Agenda Technician City of Charleston, SC Subject: 975-989 Morrison Dr / BZA-Z March 3 / Agenda Item B-5. Request variance from Sec. 54-299.25 to construct a multi-family development without an active use on the ground floor NCNA Status: REQUEST DEFERRAL The North Central Neighborhood Association requests a deferral on this agenda item. The City of Charleston needs more time to study the long-term implications of its UP Zoning rules and FEMA Limit of Moderate Wave Action (LiMWA) areas, in which this property resides. The North Central Neighborhood Association supports clear and fair guidelines for developers that balance modern resiliency goals. We have serious concerns regarding the impact on neighborhood civic services (e.g., first responders) that such a large density building developed in a flood zone will have on the entirety of the Upper Peninsula. We strongly encourage the BZA-Z to defer this request for a variance to enable further study. Sincerely, Stephen Rosenberg President, North Central Neighborhood Association stephen@ncnachs.com Cc:// Robert Summerfield, Craig Bennett B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Comments Submitted to Innovate Site 5 in Support | 128 in Opposition 5 Comments Submitted in Support First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Pat DeMarco 1228 Winston - This would bring additional, sorely-needed housing to the peninsula. - Similar mid-rise developments already exist in the neighborhood. - This parcel, while near sensitive wetlands, has already been developed. The only concern would be tidal flooding, so the first floor may need to be solely for parking. Feb 27 2026 1:21AM Roman Rozek 46 Rivers Point Row, Charleston A huge problem in our community is affordable housing. Whether this project at this property will be some specific tier of affordable is irrelevant- the addition of suitable inventory to the market opens up competition and creates affordable units in the vicinity. Infill projects like this will help the people of our city. Feb 27 2026 8:52AM Justin Moffitt 5 Poplar St. I support the application. We need density in that area of the peninsula and the current building on that parcel is beyond ugly. Feb 27 2026 9:45AM Zac Viscidi 59 Cypress St Dense housing is needed, particularly in transport rich corridors like Morrison Drive. The concerns regarding potential flooding and the preservation of tidal creeks is important, and the city needs to require developers who are building on these critical lands to contribute to pools of money that mitigate potential flooding issues and help build infrastructure necessary to protect the greater community. Feb 28 2026 3:19PM Tyler Patterson 92 Nassau St Apt B, Charleston, SC I am writing in support of BZA agenda item B-5. As proposed, the project will address longstanding stormwater concerns through thoughtful site enhancements and modernized systems. These improvements are not only necessary but beneficial to the broader area. In addition, the project will play an important role in activating the North Morrison corridor by introducing vital aesthetic upgrades and pedestrian-oriented improvements that contribute to a safer, more attractive, and more functional streetscape. Mar 2 2026 10:10AM 128 Comments Submitted in Opposition First Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time Submitted Courtney Olson 1237 Gilmore Road Good afternoon Members of the Board, My name is Courtney Olson, and I serve as Executive Director of Friends of the Lowline. I am writing to respectfully oppose the requested variance for 989 Morrison Drive. Newmarket Creek is a regionally significant historic tidal creek on the east side of the Charleston peninsula. It is one of the last remaining intact tidal waterways in this area and plays a critical role in stormwater storage, tidal exchange, and long-term climate resilience. This creek system has already been severely impacted by decades of Feb 27 2026 3:04PM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 2 urbanization and marsh fill. What remains is environmentally and hydrologically valuable. Granting a variance under these circumstances would not meet the standard required by the Board. It would be of substantial detriment to the public good by increasing risk in a flood- prone area and further stressing a fragile tidal system that contributes to the peninsula’s resilience. Thank you for your time and service. Torrey Sanders 131 Spring Street Re: Opposition to Zoning Variance Request – 975 & 989 Morrison Drive The Coastal Conservation League submits this letter in opposition to the variance request before the BZA. We urge the BZA to deny the variance and, at minimum, defer action consistent with staff's own recommendation. The Variance Standard Is Not Met A variance requires a showing of extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the specific property. The applicant's own submission undermines this standard. They acknowledge that "several nearby properties (and across the peninsula) are now constrained by this same combination of UP zoning and LiMWA-based elevation requirements." A condition shared across multiple properties and an entire zoning district is not site-specific hardship. It is a systemic planning challenge that warrants a systemic planning response, not piecemeal variance relief. Approval Would Be Premature We understand that a design charrette is scheduled for March 16 that will address this property and other areas. Granting a variance before that process begins would be woefully premature and would prejudge outcomes that the community and planning staff have not yet had the opportunity to fully examine. The BZA should not foreclose options that the charrette is designed to explore. The Ecological Context Demands Caution This is an ecologically sensitive area. The tension between the Upper Peninsula zoning code's ground-floor activation requirements and FEMA and City floodplain regulations that prohibit such activation reflects a genuine and unresolved conflict, and should be addressed comprehensively, not resolved by variance on a single parcel. Further, the City has pursued NFWF funding for the Newmarket Creek Restoration Project. Approving this variance before understanding how development on and around this site interacts with that restoration potential would be irresponsible. The full ecological context of this site must be understood before any variance is granted. Conclusion For these reasons, the Coastal Conservation League respectfully urges the BZA to deny this variance request, or at a minimum defer action until after the March 16 charrette and any findings from the Newmarket Creek restoration planning process are available. Respectfully submitted, Torrey Sanders Conservation Programs Manager Mar 2 2026 11:39AM Anna- Catherine Alexander 147 King Street The Preservation Society of Charleston (PSC) is strongly opposed to item B.5 (975 & 989 Morrison Drive variance request). The request fails to meet the core criteria for granting a variance and, if approved, would undermine the character, safety, and long-term planning efforts for this area of the Upper Peninsula based on three primary rationales: - Ground floor activation is core to the City’s Mar 2 2026 11:36AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 3 purpose in establishing density incentives in the Upper Peninsula District - A variance contradicting FEMA policy could put Charleston at risk of losing disaster aid assistance - The variance request is inconsistent with current resilience planning efforts for Newmarket Creek The PSC will elaborate on these points in a formal letter of opposition submitted to the Board in advance of the meeting. Sarai Carter 4287 Spruill Ave As a member of the design team that completed the Charleston Comprehensive Integrated Water Plan, who studied in great detail the history and current conditions of development on the peninsula, I have to oppose this project. Newmarket Creek is one of the best opportunities the City has left to manage, restore, and benefit from hybrid green-grey infrastructure. The City invested one million dollars and my team of highly qualified engineers, architects, landscape architects, and public engagement professionals all gave two years of their lives to provide the best possible roadmap for resilience. Arguably the top recommendation was elevation-based zoning (keeping new developments out of the most low-lying areas and marsh edges), paired with proactive protection of the marsh. This proposed development is in direct opposition to the expert advice and resiliency strategy of the Charleston Water Plan. Of the 155 square miles of the city of Charleston, our team selected Newmarket Creek as a key site to demonstrate the principles of the Water Plan and the importance of nature based solutions for those areas most prone to flooding currently and most likely to experience increasing issues in the near future. Building anything on this site is pure folly. It is short sighted. It will have cascading negative impacts for the City, for the people of Charleston, and for the marsh that protects and provisions ecosystem services. I encourage everyone to review the Charleston Comprehensive Integrated Water Plan, with particular attention to the proposed planning concept for Newmarket Creek. The plan is publicly available as a GIS story map on the City’s website. Mar 2 2026 10:59AM Anna Brigid Creason 10 9th avenue Charleston, SC 29403 This building is horrendous and does not fit the Charleston landscape or architecture, not to mention the tidal land. Look at Meeting Street Lofts, they can’t rent out any of their leases because it’s constantly flooding. This is a lose lose for everyone. Not every inch of the peninsula needs to be high-income luxury apts. Feb 26 2026 2:50PM Laura Isenstein 4 Beaufain St. #206, Charleston SC 29401 Deny zoning variance request for 989 Morrison Drive. If approved, this variance would facilitate the construction of a 12-story apartment building on Newmarket Creek, one of the peninsula’s last intact tidal waterways that plays a key role in the peninsula’s resilience and stormwater management. This proposal exposes a serious planning contradiction: The site’s base zoning (Upper Peninsula District) requires an active ground floor use, while subsequently written FEMA regulations prohibit habitable ground floors in this high-risk flood area that can experience damaging coastal waves during a major storm. This variance does not support stormwater management the City of Charleston is working hard to address. Allowing development places future tenants at risk of flooding resulting in property loss and severe structural compromise Feb 26 2026 2:55PM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 4 of building integrity. This regulatory conflict necessitates a variance request to facilitate construction, underscoring that this is not an appropriate site for intense new development. Either the City and the Zoning Board are serious about stormwater management, flood reduction and providing safe affordable housing or they are still kowtowing to Developers who flash big bucks! Which is it? The Board’s decision on this item will speak volumes! Emily Pigott 21 Father Grants Court, Charleston, SC 29403 This request DOES NOT meet the criteria for granting a variance. "Variance Test: The Board of Zoning Appeals- Zoning is authorized to approve a variance from the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes the following findings: 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity; 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and 4. The authorization of the variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the variance." Responses to criteria: 1. Met; yes, there are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; Newmarket Creek is one of the peninsula’s last intact tidal waterways that plays a key role in the peninsula’s resilience and stormwater management 2. Unmet; these conditions DO generally apply to other property in the vicinity 3. Unmet; use of this property is NOT unreasonably restricted, as many other types of development could occur within the existing zoning, while still meeting the FEMA regulations. 4. Unmet; granting this variance would be a substantial detriment to the public good as Newmarket Creek is the peninsula's LAST intact tidal waterway. Damaging/altering this waterway would DECREASE resilience and CONTRADICT the City's stormwater management goals. Feb 26 2026 3:05PM Anne Liebergall 25 Legare Street, Charleston, SC 29401 Once again, it has become necessary to voice strong concerns for a proposed apartment building project in downtown Charleston - 989 Morrison Drive represents an ongoing assault to the architectural fabric of the peninsula. The scale of the project is grossly inconsistent with the heritage of Charleston that drives our local economy. There is also the VERY real concern that this structure would impact one of our last tidal waterways on the peninsula - critical in our resistance and stormwater management. Please vote with Charleston's delicate and vulnerable future in mind. As a downtown business owner and resident - we are trusting you to protect our future. Feb 26 2026 3:12PM Lynn Hanlin 67 Meeting Charleston, SC 29401 I feel a 12 story building at this location is wrong especially due to sunny day flooding. Intense building at this location will exasterbate flooding . Please vote no Feb 26 2026 3:15PM Caitlin Dirkes 1153 King Street I STRONGLY oppose the zoning variance request due to the height and most importantly the flood water risk of this site. This site should never be developed on as it is one of Feb 26 2026 4:45PM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 5 the peninsula's last intact tidal waterways that we need in this city to mitigate stromwater flooding. If this site were to be devolped, we would be doing IRREVERSIBLE damage to our city that is allready constantly trying to protect their residents during major storms. Jack Handegan 32 montagu Does not meet the necessary requirements to need a variance. Deny. Feb 26 2026 4:46PM Laighton Cain 1500 Mosstree Rd Unit B, 29405 This request contains concerning issues. This request does not meet the criteria for granting a variance. It would be of substantial detriment to the public, as this request compromises Newmarket Creek, a vital, natural asset to the peninsula’s resilience and stormwater management. In addition to this issue, the ground floor plans do not meet FEMA regulations, which prohibit habitable ground floors in this high-risk flood area that can experience damaging coastal waves during a major storm. Feb 26 2026 6:39PM Meghan Lee 512 Sarah Street Please do not allow this request to move forward. It does not meet the criteria for granting a variance; would be of substantial detriment to the public good; and would harm the character of the district. Not to mention, it’s the site of one of the peninsula’s last tidal creeks. Feb 26 2026 8:19PM Jan Roudebush 204, Fishburne St Charleston SC Does not fit the criteria. Does not fit the neighborhood. Harm or impedes the tidal creek. Feb 26 2026 10:35PM Anthony Petro 27 cypress Stop this nonsense over development. Why bend the rules to support over development. It will ruin that neighborhood. Feb 26 2026 10:40PM Ellen Harley 23 Wentworth St Charleston South Carolina 29401 this request does not meet the criteria for granting a variance on the grounds that it would be of substantial detriment to the public good and harm the character of the district. Feb 26 2026 10:44PM Sandy Sisson 3537 e. Higgins drive mount pleasant Opposed. Feb 27 2026 1:54PM Richard Hayes 8672 West Fairway Wood Drive, North Charleston SC 29420 This request does not meet the criteria for granting a variance on the grounds that it would be of substantial detriment to the public good and harm the character of the district. This proposal exposes a serious planning contradiction: The site’s base zoning (Upper Peninsula District) requires an active ground floor use, while subsequently written FEMA regulations prohibit habitable ground floors in this high-risk flood area that can experience damaging coastal waves during a major storm. This development would be on Newmarket Creek, one of the peninsula’s last intact tidal waterways that plays a key role in the peninsula’s resilience and stormwater management. This regulatory conflict necessitates a variance request to facilitate construction, underscoring that this is not an appropriate site for intense new development. Feb 27 2026 2:34PM Amy Luisi 2056 Saint James Dr Charleston SC 29412 If you destroy another tidal creek “Newmarket Creek” it will be the fault of the zoning board and flooding will be impacted a lot. Why do y'all always bow to these developers who are likely just real estate reits? Are there enough expensive housing already available? What Feb 27 2026 3:33PM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 6 happened to caring about the future of our community. And by the way it’s likely that there are graves on this parcel of land. Learn to show some respect to the earth. I miss the days when Charleston skyline showed only church steeples. What happened? Dr. Merrie Koester 11 Allgood Road, Charleston, SC 29407 This proposal is in direct violation of the SC Coastal Zone Management Act, established in 1972, which prohibits non- water dependent development of any kind in critical tideland, beach, or dune areas, as well as establishing construction setbacks. The proposed building would illegally impact a federally protected tidal wetland and introduce increased risk of flooding and pollution hazards, sacrificing invaluable health, safety and welfare ecosystem services being provided by Newmarket Creek. The proposed development flies in the face of recommendations clearly laid out in the Charleston Water Plan and threatens public health, safety, and welfare. Newmarket Creek is a key part of the proposed Just Ecological Corridor and emerging Lowcountry Lowline Project and includes some of the few remaining salt marshes on the peninsula. Respectfully submitted by Dr. Merrie Koester Feb 27 2026 3:40PM lin jay Commodore Rd. In a sea level city which constantly is struggling with stormwater drainage and sunny day flooding, it is imperative that we stop building on wetlands and creeks. I am adamantly opposed to a variance allowing for development at this site. It is clear that if we know living/active space is not recommended (actually regulated against on such a site), that the developers would be creating harm with the proposed building. Common sense should outweigh profits. Citizens expect/hope for their government to use best practices. Deny the variance. Feb 27 2026 8:34AM Nicholas Butler 6 Hampden Ct., Charleston, SC, 29403 I am strongly opposed to the proposed multi-family development at 975 and 989 Morrison Drive, and urge the board to deny the applicant's request for a zoning variance. The site in question is part of the natural floodplain of Newmarket Creek, an ancient waterway, and as such represents an important natural resource for stormwater resilience in the City of Charleston. The proposed development, if allowed to proceed, would constrict an already diminished outlet for stormwater and therefore increase the incidence of flooding in the surrounding neighborhood. Feb 27 2026 9:00AM Kelly Davoren 5 Gadsdenboro St, unit 510, Charleston The construction of a 12 story apartment building does not meet the criteria for a zoning variance because it would be a substantial detriment to the public good and harm the character of the district. Please stop this from happening. Feb 27 2026 9:59AM Andrew Zimmermann 838 Morrison Drive, Charleston 29403 Hello, I strongly oppose the project on 989 Morrison. The ground is a flood zone where the structure will always be threatened and the increase in residents of a 13 story building will overwhelm the transportation zones in the area. Feb 27 2026 10:10PM Kylie Tribble 5940 MARTIN STREET This request would be a substantial detriment to the public good & would harm the character of the district. This area is prone to extreme flooding and damaging coastal waves during extreme storms & is not an appropriate site for intense new development. Feb 27 2026 11:16AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 7 Hannah Jane Dantzscher 33 Poplar St Apt A Charleston 29403 Opposed to granting any variances to existing zoning, especially to development on the Marsh of an already flood prone area. The area should be developed in a manner that respects and mitigates the tidal patterns of new market creek as well as the scale and charm of surrounding area. No more giant eye sores on the skyline coming over the bridge. No more water displacement in flood prone areas and only mixed use development that contributes to the vibrancy of our community at an appropriate scale should be considered Feb 27 2026 11:48AM edwin harley 23 Wentworth St Charleston SC 29401 We oppose this project because The request does not pass the BZA variance test. There are not “extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property.” Many properties in the UP Zoning District are affected by the new line. (The map above visually depicts this.) These buildings are too big for the site and the surrounding context. A 12-story structure at this location exceeds what the area’s infrastructure, streetscape, and watershed systems can reasonably support. This project should be part of the City of Charleston’s broader effort to design context sensitive affordable housing. Charleston is developing new citywide standards for appropriately scaled mixed-income affordable housing—this project moves ahead outside of that coordinated framework. The focus in the headwaters of New Market Creek should be on citywide resilience and watershed planning, not large-scale construction projects. The city is investing heavily in resilience, drainage, and watershed planning in this area. Development in this area must align with, not work against, these ongoing efforts. LiMWA flood maps were updated after the Upper Peninsula zoning was created. Because the site is now within the LiMWA zone, it faces higher flood risk requirements. This introduces new challenges for UP mixed- use expectations—ground floor activation may no longer be feasible. These issues require more scrutiny by the City of Charleston and the public. Although perhaps not an issue for the BZA, it is important to note that this project does not align with the city’s broader resilience strategy and watershed planning work. Any development here must be evaluated in the context of current and future drainage, stormwater, and coastal resilience investments. Moving forward before the City of Charleston’s resilience and housing plans are fully incorporated risks long-term consequences for affordability, public safety, and flood management. This is the gateway to the headwaters of Newmarket Creek. The site sits at the entrance to an area where major flood mitigation, restoration, and stormwater improvements are underway. The city is actively planning tidal flood protection, stormwater relief, and marsh restoration for Newmarket Creek connected to other large- scale infrastructure projects, like the Lowcountry Lowline and potential Battery Extension improvements. The Morrison Drive project is not coordinated with the larger vision in purpose or design. Feb 28 2026 3:10PM Sarah Beardsley 12 Council Street, Charleston Please do not approve this variance. The height is far too great to be in keeping with the nature of the Peninsula and the floodwater protection will be further threaded by Feb 28 2026 4:22PM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 8 having this large project placed here with the proposed characteristics Mitzi Kendrick 165 Broad St Downtown does not have infrastructure for 12 story building. Fighting raising water and infrastrusture needs, while preserving history should be #1 priority. Feb 28 2026 5:13PM Sallie Springer 600 Quay Circle Unit 608 This request should be denied because of the risk of flooding in this low lying area. The parcel should not be developed. It is needed as part of the City's plan for tidal flood protection, stormwater improvements and the restoration of this portion of Newmarket Creek. Having lived in Charleston all of my life I am well informed on the flooding that occurs in this part of the city. Feb 28 2026 5:31PM Jane Beak 8082 Noble Oak Way, Charleston, SC 29412 It worries me deeply that after all the hard work done to protect this Morrison Dr. area that this petition to change is even being considered. We have enough flooding problems without this development being allow to circumvent protections for our peninsula. Please do not give a variance, please protect this area and please protect the citizens of Charleston. Thank you. Feb 28 2026 7:29PM Jeanie Knowlton 176 Dunnemann Ave. Charleston SC This request does not meet the criteria for granting a variance, as it would be of substantial detriment to the public good and harm the character of the district. Feb 28 2026 7:52AM John Roudebush 204 Fishburne st Charleston Do not approve this variance. It creates more chance of flooding & interruption of flood control. It undermine both the City of Charleston’s resilience work and the coordinated planning underway through Project 3500, which includes future affordable housing immediately adjacent to this site. Feb 28 2026 8:10PM Margaret Ling 4 Fields Pl. Charleston, sc 29403 I Oppose Irresponsible Development at 989 Morrison Dr. This area floods already and we as a city need to acknowledge that heavy development on salt marshes is what is drowning our city. Newmarket creek is also already incredibly polluted. We do not need more large buildings in that area. This zone lacks adequate parking and safe crossing. We do not need more people living here. Feb 28 2026 8:17AM Kenneth Hirsch 77 Bull Street, Charleston, SC 29401 The request does not pass the BZA variance test. As indicated on the map above, there are not “extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property.” Many properties in the UP Zoning District are impacted by the new line. These buildings are too big for the site and the surrounding context. A 12-story structure at this location exceeds what the area’s infrastructure, streetscape, and watershed systems can reasonably support. This project should be part of the City’s broader effort to design context-sensitive affordable housing. Charleston is developing new citywide standards for appropriately scaled mixed-income affordable housing—this project moves ahead outside that coordinated framework. The focus in the headwaters of New Market Creek should be on citywide resilience and watershed planning, not large-scale construction projects. The city is investing heavily in resilience, drainage, and watershed planning in this area. Development in this area must align with, not work against, these ongoing efforts. LiMWA flood maps were updated after the Upper Peninsula zoning was created. Because the site is now within the LiMWA zone, it faces higher flood risk requirements. Feb 28 2026 9:11PM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 9 This introduces new challenges for UP mixed-use expectations—ground floor activation may no longer be feasible. These issues require more scrutiny by the City and the public. Larry Musetti 98 Logan St Please do not approve. This is critical. It will be built on one of the last intact tidal waterways. The proposal requires active ground floor use that FEMA regulations prohibit. This violation necessitates a variance to aid construction. This site should not be allowed such over development that destroys our environment and wellbeing. Feb 28 2026 10:27AM June Green 1353 Wineberry Rd We oppose the Morrison Drive variance request because: The request does not pass the BZA variance test. There are not “extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property.” Many properties in the UP Zoning District are affected by the new line. (The map above visually depicts this.) These buildings are too big for the site and the surrounding context. A 12-story structure at this location exceeds what the area’s infrastructure, streetscape, and watershed systems can reasonably support. This project should be part of the City of Charleston’s broader effort to design context sensitive affordable housing. Charleston is developing new citywide standards for appropriately scaled mixed-income affordable housing—this project moves ahead outside of that coordinated framework. The focus in the headwaters of New Market Creek should be on citywide resilience and watershed planning, not large-scale construction projects. The city is investing heavily in resilience, drainage, and watershed planning in this area. Development in this area must align with, not work against, these ongoing efforts. LiMWA flood maps were updated after the Upper Peninsula zoning was created. Because the site is now within the LiMWA zone, it faces higher flood risk requirements. This introduces new challenges for UP mixed-use expectations—ground floor activation may no longer be feasible. These issues require more scrutiny by the City of Charleston and the public. Although perhaps not an issue for the BZA, it is important to note that this project does not align with the city’s broader resilience strategy and watershed planning work. Any development here must be evaluated in the context of current and future drainage, stormwater, and coastal resilience investments. Moving forward before the City of Charleston’s resilience and housing plans are fully incorporated risks long-term consequences for affordability, public safety, and flood management. This is the gateway to the headwaters of Newmarket Creek. The site sits at the entrance to an area where major flood mitigation, restoration, and stormwater improvements are underway. The city is actively planning tidal flood protection, stormwater relief, and marsh restoration for Newmarket Creek connected to other large- scale infrastructure projects, like the Lowcountry Lowline and potential Battery Extension improvements. The Morrison Drive project is not coordinated with the larger vision in purpose or design. Let’s prioritize Charleston’s resilience and watershed planning—not inappropriate, out of scale development. Feb 28 2026 10:55PM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 10 Ashley Smith 32 Pitt Street As a resident whose family has been in Charleston since 1780 and who has personally called this city home since 2018 I strongly oppose the Morrison Drive variance request because it does not meet the BZA’s standard for “extraordinary and exceptional conditions.” Many properties in the Upper Peninsula zoning district are affected by the same line change, so this is not a unique hardship. A 12-story structure at the gateway to the headwaters of New Market Creek is out of scale with the surrounding infrastructure, watershed systems, and the city’s ongoing flood resilience investments. If we do not monitor development closely, especially in critical areas like this, the Charleston we all know and love will be incrementally lost. This site deserves thoughtful, coordinated planning aligned with the City’s broader resilience and housing strategy, not a variance that risks long-term consequences for our community. Mar 1 2026 2:39PM Steve Sweney 1864 great hope drive mount pleasant We dont need buildings out of normal zoning. Mar 1 2026 4:51PM Jennifer Davis 5 Maiden Lane charleston SC 29401 Building in this flood plain on Morrison Drive is entirely contrary to all of the City's resilience planning. A twelve story building is out of scale with the surrounding buildings and the massive size building can't be supported by the area's infrastructure. It does not appear that this development meets the criteria for a variance. Why must we give in to developers when it is not in the best interest of the citizens of Charleston? Charleston must change direction and oppose large scale building projects to be built in flood plain. Thank you for your consideration. Mar 1 2026 5:25PM Donna Glazer 19 New Street I am against the Morrison Drive project Mar 1 2026 7:11PM Candace Martin 223 Nassau Street Charleston 29403 NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. Mar 1 2026 7:29AM Anonymous Anonymous Anonymous I'm totally against any new development especially ones that need variances or some special permission to build. We've had enough of these developers ruining our city Mar 1 2026 9:06PM Vickie Neighbour 40 Charlotte Street Environmental disaster. Mar 1 2026 9:20AM Tara Lowry 6 Bee St, Charleston, SC 29403 As a 25 year resident and property owner downtown, I stand with the Historic Charleston Foundation on this matter. Protecting our watershed and preserving our land and surrounding land from rising sea levels and climate change in the long run is more important than short term gains. Mar 1 2026 9:29PM Jan Roosenburg 117 Broad Street, Charleston, SC 29401 We do not need another 12 story building in Charleston and it is not wisdom to give a varisnce on the flood zone, our water problems will only be getting worse in years to come. Mar 1 2026 9:39AM David Quick 1502 Village Square, Mount Pleasant I oppose a zoning variance request for 989 Morrison Drive. If approved, the variance would facilitate the construction of a 12-story apartment building on Newmarket Creek, one of the peninsula’s last intact tidal waterways that plays a key role in the peninsula’s resilience and stormwater Mar 1 2026 11:13PM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 11 management. This proposal exposes a serious planning contradiction: The site’s base zoning (Upper Peninsula District) requires an active ground floor use, while subsequently written FEMA regulations prohibit habitable ground floors in this high-risk flood area that can experience damaging coastal waves during a major storm. This regulatory conflict necessitates a variance request to facilitate construction, underscoring that this is NOT an appropriate site for intense new development. This request does not meet the criteria for granting a variance on the grounds that it would be of substantial detriment to the public good and harm the character of the district. Meghan Edwards 71 Oyster Point Row Please do not allow this variance! This would be unsafe for the building inhabitants and the neighboring areas. This is a highly flooding area even after a short shower. Significant hydrological projects would be needed before such development would be prudent, and this should be part of the project before any variance is accepted. Mar 2 2026 8:13AM Janet Northen 310 Broad Street Please save Charleston and its precious waterways from greedy, unnecessary development. When is it enough? Mar 2 2026 8:21AM REBECCA ROUSE 935 Cottingham Drive PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE stop building more buildings. WE THE PEOPLE DO NOT WANT ANY MORE APARTMENT/CONDO STRUCTURES. Some people actually enjoy the natural landscape. I have lived here for 14 years and honestly the "developers" are so close to ruining the natural charm of Charleston, if they haven't already. Charleston WAS NOT built to sustain the high volume of traffic city developers keep pumping into this city. Not to mention - no new building are even CLOSE to replicating the old custom architecture this city is known for. ALSO do you want Charleston to just sink? NO MORE APARTMENTS Mar 2 2026 8:59AM Cara Levy 30 Rebellion Rd This area should not be built upon at all - ever. Please consider the importance of maintaining and protecting Charleston’s marshlands above new development. Mar 2 2026 9:19AM Jason Wilson 880 Dills Bluff Road I oppose the proposed development and change to zoning law for the 12 story building proposed at the Newmarket creek area Mar 2 2026 9:19AM Blake Suarez Gordon St This whole project would undermine city efforts and resilience projects if you waive the zoning requirement. Newmarket Creek is one of our last remaining tidal creeks on the peninsula and one of the key points defining the City of Charleston's Just Ecological Corridor, which was established last year in April. We need to be focusing our efforts on restoration, and flood mitigation rather than trying to build on this beautiful pocket of wetlands. We’re done with these out of town developers looking to fill their destructive quota. Mar 2 2026 9:20AM Jessica Murnane 19 Gordon Street Allowing this building to be built means this impact stormwater management and flood mitigation in a FEMA flood zone, which the City is investing and working on. It does not seem to align with helping the city that so desperately needs help right now in terms of flooding. Mar 2 2026 9:20AM Jill Ilagan 727 Corral Drive Please leave the creek and marsh intact. Flooding and overdevelopment are already a huge problem in the Lowcountry. We need our waterways and marshes to prevent flooding, to allow for storm water to drain properly and to restore our marshes. They are what makes Mar 2 2026 9:21AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 12 Charleston and the Lowcountry beautiful and unique. Destroying them decreases the cities value and natural beauty. Leave the marshes alone! Thomas Knaust 1446 N Sherwood drive I urge you to oppose this request, which does not meet the criteria for granting a variance and would result in harm to the public experience of the city, the character of the district, and the long-term resilience of Newmarket Creek. Newmarket is a part of the Just Ecological Corridor, and a critical part of Charleston’s stormwater management and flood resilience system via the upcoming “Newmarket Park”, as planned in the Lowline. The Upper Peninsula District zoning requires active ground-floor uses, these elements that make neighborhoods walkable, support local businesses, and create the daily activity that ties communities together. At the same time, FEMA flood regulations prohibit habitable ground floors in this high-risk coastal flood zone due to the potential for damaging wave action during major storms. In other words, the feature intended to create a vibrant urban streetscape cannot safely exist on this site. The need for a variance is not a minor technicality but an indication that it is a BAD IDEA to build something of this scale on this site, for environmental reasons, and for creating a city that we all like to walk around. Mar 2 2026 9:22AM Kristina Martin 45 Sycamore Ave I oppose the request to waive a key zoning requirement for a 12-story building on Newmarket Creek, at 989 Morrison Drive. This project does not meet the criteria for granting a variance and would result in harm to the character of the district and the long-term resilience of Newmarket Creek, including flood mitigation in a FEMA flood zone. Mar 2 2026 9:26AM Olivia Suarez Gordon St. I learned about this project the other night after hearing Brian Turner at the Preservation Society speak at an event hosted by the Charleston Climate Coalition and The Marsh Project. I strongly oppose this application. Why are we trying to facilitate the development of a 12-story apartment building on one of our peninsula’s last intact tidal creeks? Newmarket Creek is a natural resource we need to be celebrating, it is not an appropriate site for intense new development. It should never be a site for development. Mar 2 2026 9:27AM Marcus Sizemore 1121 Donahue Drive, Charleston SC 29407 This proposed development goes against everything that the City says they are doing by "restoring" Newmarket Creek. You can't have it both ways. Sunny day flooding is increasing every year. If the City approves this development, then what is the point of "Waterwise", the Dutch Dialogues or any of the other resiliency planning efforts that the City has put forward? Having stricter standards on properties that flood only works if you actually uphold them. There are numerous reasons not to build on top of tidal marsh but I don't think you understand any of them if you allow this development to move forward. Therefore, here are some reasons you should oppose this development: -Loss of critical habitat: Tidal marshes support nursery grounds for fish, shellfish, and migratory birds, reducing biodiversity when filled. -Decline in fisheries productivity: Many commercially and recreationally important species depend on marsh ecosystems at some life stage. -Irreversible ecosystem Mar 2 2026 9:27AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 13 damage: Marsh systems take decades to centuries to form and are extremely difficult to recreate successfully. - Natural flood protection: Marshes absorb storm surge and reduce wave energy, lowering flood risk to surrounding communities. -Increased flooding costs: Removing marsh storage capacity shifts flood risk onto homeowners, local governments (looking at your CITY of CHARLESTON), and insurers. -Sea level rise adaptation: Healthy marshes can migrate inland and keep pace with rising seas— development blocks this natural resilience. There is a beautiful example of a tidal marsh restoration project approximately 4,000 feet to the west of this project on the south side of Drum Island. That's what happens when you have good stewardship in place and follow through on actions that help (not harm) tidal marshes. If the SC Ports Authority can work to restore our marshes, then the City of Charleston can too. There's plenty of high ground elsewhere. Lisa Brueggemann 1590 John Fenwick Ln Dear Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals, I am writing to strongly oppose the requested waiver of a key zoning requirement for the proposed 12-story building on Newmarket Creek. Granting this waiver would undermine critical public investments and long-term planning efforts focused on marsh restoration, stormwater management, and flood mitigation in this FEMA-designated flood zone. The City has been actively working to strengthen coastal resilience, restore wetlands, and reduce flood risk for surrounding neighborhoods. Allowing this project to bypass established zoning safeguards directly contradicts those efforts. Zoning requirements in environmentally sensitive areas are not arbitrary. They exist to protect public safety, preserve natural flood buffers, support marsh restoration, and ensure that development does not increase downstream flooding or strain already vulnerable infrastructure. Weakening these standards sets a concerning precedent that could erode the integrity of future resilience planning. Newmarket Creek is a fragile and valuable ecological resource. Development decisions here must prioritize long-term environmental protection and climate resilience over short-term project expediency. A 12-story structure in a FEMA flood zone demands strict adherence to zoning and environmental safeguards — not exemptions from them. I respectfully urge the Board to deny this waiver request and uphold the zoning protections that safeguard our marshlands, infrastructure investments, and community safety. Thank you for your careful consideration. Sincerely, Lisa Brueggemann Mar 2 2026 9:28AM Emily Randisi 981 Ashley Avenue Charleston SC 29403 Dear Members of the Board of Zoning Appeals, I am writing to strongly oppose the variance request for 989 Morrison Drive. Granting this variance would allow a 12- story apartment building to circumvent a core zoning requirement in one of the most environmentally sensitive and flood-prone areas of our city. This is not a minor technical adjustment. It is a fundamental conflict between what the site can safely support and what the developer is proposing to build. Newmarket Creek is one of Charleston’s last intact tidal creeks and a critical component of the Just Ecological Corridor and the planned Newmarket Mar 2 2026 9:29AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 14 Park within the Lowline. The City is actively investing in marsh restoration, stormwater management, and flood mitigation in this FEMA-designated high-risk coastal flood zone. Approving a variance that enables intense development directly adjacent to this creek undermines those public investments and long-term resilience goals. The Upper Peninsula District zoning requires active ground- floor uses to promote walkability, neighborhood vitality, and economic activity. At the same time, FEMA regulations prohibit habitable ground floors on this site due to the risk of damaging wave action during major storms. This is not an arbitrary inconvenience—it is a clear indication that this site is incompatible with the scale and type of development proposed. If a project cannot meet zoning requirements without conflicting with federal flood safety regulations, that is evidence that the proposal is fundamentally inappropriate for the location. Granting this variance would set a troubling precedent, weakening zoning standards designed to protect public safety, environmental integrity, and the character of our neighborhoods. We should not sacrifice tidal marsh health, flood resilience, and thoughtful urban planning for a project that does not fit the site. I respectfully urge the Board to deny this variance request and uphold the standards that protect both our community and our natural systems. Schuyler Clogston 65 Cypress Street, Charleston SC 29403 This property is directly on one of the city's few remaining tidal creeks. The variance requested is due to the site not being compatible to the program or the scale. Activating the ground floor of buildings is required for the character of the neighborhood, creating an enjoyable and walkable urban sphere. This project would damage the creek, create a void in the urban fabric, and work against so many current efforts like the Lowline. I am adamantly opposed to this project at this scale in this location. Mar 2 2026 9:31AM Katherine Thomppson 131 Calyer Street, Brooklyn, NY 11222 We must stop this madness of building in fragile and yes, dangerous, FEMA flood zones. Build elsewhere. This wetland is intrinsic to nature-based resilient protections we need in the face of climate sea level rise and other weather events. Mar 2 2026 9:32AM Emily Storrow 40 Saint Margaret Street It's difficult to believe this is an actual proposal coming before the board, but here we are. When is enough enough? Newmarket Creek is one of the peninsula's last intact tidal waterways and plays a key role in the peninsula's resilience and stormwater management. Development here would undermine our stormwater management and flood mitigation in a FEMA flood zone that the city is actively investing in and working on. It's impossible to overstate just how inappropriate this site is for intense new development. Those of use who live on the peninsula have to contest with flooded and impassible roads—and the severe gridlock that ensues—with every major rain event (and even non-major events that correspond with high tide or a king tide). Please don't make the problem worse by green-lighting development where it has no business happening. This request does not meet the criteria for granting a variance. It would be of substantial detriment to the public good, while also harming the character of the district. I ask that you deny. Mar 2 2026 9:32AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 15 Sully SULLIVAN 1404 holt Street Myself and my family whole heartedly oppose this project. It should be obvious that building in the marsh is a terrible idea. Yet here we are, again. Protect our wetlands, focus on infrastructure, residents, and local work force before we put the needs of developers and outside investors before our own. Enough is enough. Let’s progress the city we have already and the people that live here already Charleston is full up. Focus on the low line focus on workforce housing. Focus on affordable housing focus on access to water not building in it. Thank you for your time and go back to Ohio. Mar 2 2026 9:34AM Allen Pendarvis 858 Rutledge Ave., Charleston SC As a Downtown resident, flooding and water mitigation is a constant concern. I am concerned and believe that granting this appeal will side-step rules designed to protect the peninsula from worsened flooding through over- development of historical creeks and waterways, worsening existing flooding issues. I stand opposed. Mar 2 2026 9:35AM Allessandra Stewart 624 Bootlegger Ln I absolutely oppose the request for a variance at this property. Flooding has become a huge problem on the peninsula in Charleston, and efforts to mitigate the flood risks downtown are constantly being undermined by developments downtown that are improperly built on marsh land. Enough is enough. Please do not approve a variance that is dangerous and also harmful to the general public in Charleston. Mar 2 2026 9:40AM suzanna hinkle 4971 n rhett ave, North charleston, sc This area of Charleston is at high risk for flooding. FEMA flood regulations prohibit habitable ground floors in this high-risk coastal flood zone due to the potential for damaging wave action during major storms. Not to mention, every time this area floods the foundation is at risk for developing a crack. Much like the Surfside highrise building in Miami, the building could collapse putting lives at risk. Here in Charleston, the Dockside condominiums in downtown by the aquarium have already been evaluated and deemed unsafe by engineers, no matter what public opinion is. We know the risks; now let's value people's lives and deny this exception for an un-occupied ground floor of an apartment building. Housing in Charleston is needed, but not like this. Mar 2 2026 9:43AM Henslee Elliott 336 Lantana Dr This development will directly interfere with the city’s plan for flood mitigation marsh restoration, and stormwater relief. As a lifelong Charlestonian is disheartening to see developments put before making our city, livable and resilient. We do not need more apartment complexes ! Mar 2 2026 9:45AM Laura Mooney 38 Ashley Ave Unit B, Charleston, SC 29401 As a homeowner in downtown Charleston, I am adamantly opposed to this project. Erecting a 12-story building on Newmarket Creek and in a FEMA flood zone would undermine the marsh restoration, stormwater management and flood mitigation efforts the City is actively investing in and working on. Projects like these are just adding to the already worsening flood conditions in the city. Not to mention degrading its natural beauty and native habitat. For the purposes of the BZA request, this project does not pass the variance test that states that there are “extraordinary and exceptional conditions" pertaining to the particular piece of property. Mar 2 2026 9:46AM Amanda Voges Charleston, SC I respectfully urge you not to waive the existing key zoning requirement for the proposed 12-story building along Newmarket Creek. The peninsula does not need another Mar 2 2026 9:47AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 16 apartment complex—especially in such a sensitive and vulnerable location. Approving this waiver would undermine ongoing efforts related to marsh restoration, stormwater management, and flood mitigation within a FEMA-designated flood zone—areas where the City is actively investing significant time and resources. Newmarket Creek is one of the last remaining relic tidal creeks on the peninsula, and it is already experiencing increased flooding due to surrounding development. Any future development in this area should prioritize resilient infrastructure modeled after the Dutch Dialogues approach, focusing on adaptive design, water management, and long-term public benefit. Decisions here should advance the public good, not intensify existing environmental and flooding challenges. Nicole Pierret 1615 Teal marsh rd We don’t want development! Let’s continue protecting the Marsh and its habitat! Mar 2 2026 9:53AM Hampton Williams 65 Cypress St. Charleston, SC 29403 I oppose this request, which does not meet the criteria for granting a variance and would result in harm to the public experience of the city, the character of the district, and the long-term resilience of Newmarket Creek. Mar 2 2026 9:57AM Melissa Funk 2039 Parkway Drive Save our wetlands. Water has memory and will always come back even if you build on top of it. We have seen this time and time again all over downtown. Save your money and time. Please build somewhere else. Mar 2 2026 9:58AM Lauren Mendenhall 5 Glengary Ct. Charleston SC 20405 We do NOT want the 12 story apartment building along Newmarket Creek approved. This would undermine marsh restoration, stormwater management and flood mitigation in a FEMA flood zone, which the City is actively investing and working on. We are strongly opposed to this. Mar 2 2026 10:01AM Zach Bechtel 624 Constant Drive, Charleston, SC 29412 This low lying marsh area needs to stay as storm water retention and utilized as such. Further development on this site will only exacerbate flood issues on surrounding properties and hurt the peninsula as a whole. Mar 2 2026 10:01AM John Maraia 140 Fairbanks Oak Alley #2A, Charleston, SC 29492 The development of a 12-story building on Newmarket Creek is counterproductive to the long-term sustainability of the Charleston peninsula as our city strives to overcome rising waters. This development would undermine marsh restoration, stormwater management and flood mitigation in a FEMA flood zone. It runs counter to the investments that the City Government has made to protect the people, homes and businesses of the city we love. Mar 2 2026 10:02AM Kristin Henry 1407 Downing Street, Charleston, SC 29407 Charleston marshland is a vital and cherished ecosystem that deserves to be protected. To risk this ecosystem for irresponsible development that Charleston does not need is reprehensible. I implore the city to do the right thing to protect charlestonians and the habitats we are responsible for protecting. Marsh land is vital to so much wildlife and also clean air and water systems that we all benefit from! Allowing this development would be an absolute crime. Mar 2 2026 10:03AM Charles Goldman 72 Alberta Ave, Charleston, 29403 This is flood area and bad for environment, Newmarket creek. It is a BAD IDEA to build something of this scale on this site, for environmental reasons, and for creating a city that we all like to walk around. Mar 2 2026 10:05AM Kendall Wase 303 Harbor Pointe Drive Apt. 2 Mt. Downtown Charleston especially, should not be focused on building anymore apartment buildings. Especially not on the marsh. I drive over the bridge multiple times a day and Mar 2 2026 10:06AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 17 Pleasant, SC 29464 have seen wildlife in the potentially affected areas, seen how the marsh floods terribly there, and from an aesthetic point, a new building to take away from the natural beauty (like pinnacle already did and is so distasteful) will only anger citizens, take away from tourist experience, and most importantly harm protected species and natural barriers. I’m a South Carolina native, Charleston law student, citizen, and advocate and cannot stand to see what is allowed to ruin this city. Gabby Ziegler 3414 Attley St As waters rise on Charleston’s streets with each afternoon thunderstorm in a growing frequency, putting residents, tourists, and historic buildings in peril, we have to consider what can be done to mitigate flood potential in Charleston. The proposed infrastructure on 989 Morrison Drive would harm our city’s ability to withstand and recover from flood events as well as destroy important habitat that is intrinsically tied to the character of the Lowcountry. This habitat and scenery is a large part of Charleston’s draw for the tourists we rely on to bring tax dollars to our city. I’ve lived here my entire life and the drive over the Ravenel has slowly become fragmented by large buildings eclipsing the historic skyline and marsh views that Charleston is known for. Another large residential building in this area will only harm residents further by increasing flooding, traffic, and destroying important habitat in one of the last remaining tidal creeks on the peninsula, Newmarket Creek. I strongly advise against this development in this area for its consequences will be irreversible in the history and future of our beloved city. Mar 2 2026 10:07AM Joel Caldwell 8 Magnolia Ave., Charleston, SC 29403 I am not opposed to more housing downtown, but I am opposed to building on wetlands. Newmarket Creek should be revitalized as part of the Lowline and the Just Ecological Corridor. It is also one of the last unfilled title waterways on the Charleston Peninsula. Do not allow a 12 story building here, please. Mar 2 2026 10:08AM Clare Parks 45 Sycamore Ave This development would undermine marsh restoration, stormwater management and flood mitigation in a FEMA flood zone, which the City is actively investing and working on. Mar 2 2026 10:11AM Nathaniel Hirschler 2608 Wye Ln 1) It does not pass the BZA variance test (there are no extraordinary conditions pertaining to this peice of property) 2) Newmarket Creek is a regionally significant historic tidal creek on the east side of the Charleston peninsula. It is one of the last remaining intact tidal waterways in this area and plays a critical role in stormwater storage, tidal exchange, and long-term climate resilience. This creek system has already been severely impacted by decades of urbanization and marsh fill. What remains is environmentally and hydrologically valuable. Mar 2 2026 10:19AM Diane Fletcher 51A Gadsden Charleston SC 29401 The Upper Peninsula District zoning requires active ground- floor uses, these elements that make neighborhoods walkable, support local businesses, and create the daily activity that ties communities together. At the same time, FEMA flood regulations prohibit habitable ground floors in this high-risk coastal flood zone due to the potential for damaging wave action during major storms. In other words, the feature intended to create a vibrant urban streetscape cannot safely exist on this site. The need for a Mar 2 2026 10:21AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 18 variance is not a minor technicality but an indication that it is a BAD IDEA to build something of this scale on this site, for environmental reasons, and for creating a city that we all like to walk around. Justina Ludwig 1100 Hampton Rivers Rd Charleston SC 29414 I urge the council to reconsider building a 12-story structure on this marshland. Preserving wetlands is crucial for protecting communities from flooding, supporting wildlife habitats, and maintaining natural ecosystems. I encourage exploring development alternatives that do not put these vital areas at risk Mar 2 2026 10:26AM Jan Schumann 21 Hester St, Charleston SC This structure will not meet requirements for the flood zone and city walk ability ordinances. They are mutually exclusive. It will also be a deterrent to the Just Ecological Corridor by impacting New Market Creek. While more housing is needed, this is not the place for it. Mar 2 2026 10:26AM Anna Rose Rossi 3406 Doctor Whaley Road I oppose this request, for environmental protection and public enjoyment reasons. Mar 2 2026 10:28AM libby zemke 123 Line st first of all, we have enough “multi family developments” - especially in this area of town - that still have plenty of unused occupancy. we don’t need another apartment building. second, this entire city and this area in particular has Serious unresolved flooding issues; filling in a marshland will only worsen this existing issue. just because you “can” do it doesn’t mean you should. this project is greedy and does not consider the community. Mar 2 2026 10:30AM Alexandria Jones 2919 Alabama Dr. North Charleston, SC 29405 Obviously locals are opposed to the continued developement on tidal creeks and surrounding areas! It’s already a flood zone… can we please show a shred of decency in development for the future of people, nature, and not be heralded as the greediest most careless group of humans in the southeast??! Vehemently opposed to this! Mar 2 2026 10:30AM Jake Griner 99 Westedge St I oppose the development adjacent to the historic newmarket creek. This tidal creek is ecologically important, and has suffered from decades of neglect. A large development on this site is almost certain to have a negative ecological impact. I will oppose any development here which does not have a significant, detailed plan to protect the tidal creek with endorsements from preservation groups. Mar 2 2026 10:34AM Shonda Stavig 1822 Austin Ave Charleston, SC Opposed to this project as it will significantly increase flooding to the area, as well as cause ecological damage to the biodiversity. Marshes are part of the charm and beauty of this city. Continuing to build for profit over these biodiverse areas disrupts the ecosystem from bottom to top. The peninsula - the land we live, work, and play on- cannot tolerate this kind of infrastructural development without repercussions to our daily lives. Mar 2 2026 10:36AM Sharleen Johnson 1181 Oakcrest Dr, Charleston, SC 29412 I oppose the Morrison Drive variance request because this site is located within the LiMWA flood zone (it falls within a critical FEMA-designated zone where 1.5-to-3-foot breaking waves are expected under certain conditions). The focus in this area, which is also the headwaters of Newmarket Creek, should be on citywide resilience and watershed planning, not large-scale construction projects. The city is investing heavily in resilience, drainage, and watershed planning in this area. Development in this area must align with, not work against, these ongoing efforts. Mar 2 2026 10:37AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 19 Emmy Welsh 767 Rutledge Ave The protection of marshland is critical for flood and climate resilience! Have we not learned over the course of Charleston’s history that instead of filling in these areas, we need to bolster and support them? While technology has advanced, the surge of development on the peninsula only increases the need to protect & continue marshland restoration as an aid for stormwater management & flood mitigation. The people and animals of the Lowcountry deserve better! Surely there is another, drier, location further inland for this development. Mar 2 2026 10:41AM Subhadra Glassman 2737 Garden Creek Road We need to protect the tidal creeks! These developers should not be allowed to destroy this important ecosystem, not just for the environment but for flood protection. Mar 2 2026 10:46AM Megan Hausamann 239 Buckhorn Drive Belvidere, NJ 07823 It does not pass the BZA variance. Newmarket Creek is a regionally significant historic tidal creek. It is one of the last remaining intact tidal waterways in this area and plays a critical role in stormwater storage, tidal exchange, and long-term climate resistance. This creek has already been severely impacted by decades of urbanization and marsh fill. What remains is environmentally and hydrologically valuable. Mar 2 2026 10:49AM Jennifer Mitchell 162 Broad Street, Charleston, SC 29401 I oppose the Morrison Drive Variance Request because: The request does not pass the BZA variance test. There are not “extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property.” Many properties in the UP Zoning District are affected by the new line. (The map above visually depicts this.) These buildings are too big for the site and the surrounding context. A 12-story structure at this location exceeds what the area’s infrastructure, streetscape, and watershed systems can reasonably support. This project should be part of the City of Charleston’s broader effort to design context sensitive affordable housing. Charleston is developing new citywide standards for appropriately scaled mixed-income affordable housing—this project moves ahead outside of that coordinated framework. The focus in the headwaters of New Market Creek should be on citywide resilience and watershed planning, not large-scale construction projects. The city is investing heavily in resilience, drainage, and watershed planning in this area. Development in this area must align with, not work against, these ongoing efforts. LiMWA flood maps were updated after the Upper Peninsula zoning was created. Because the site is now within the LiMWA zone, it faces higher flood risk requirements. This introduces new challenges for UP mixed-use expectations—ground floor activation may no longer be feasible. These issues require more scrutiny by the City of Charleston and the public. Although perhaps not an issue for the BZA, it is important to note that this project does not align with the city’s broader resilience strategy and watershed planning work. Any development here must be evaluated in the context of current and future drainage, stormwater, and coastal resilience investments. Moving forward before the City of Charleston’s resilience and housing plans are fully incorporated risks long-term consequences for affordability, public safety, and flood management. This is the gateway to the headwaters of Newmarket Creek. The site sits at the entrance to an area Mar 2 2026 10:54AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 20 where major flood mitigation, restoration, and stormwater improvements are underway. The city is actively planning tidal flood protection, stormwater relief, and marsh restoration for Newmarket Creek connected to other large- scale infrastructure projects, like the Lowcountry Lowline and potential Battery Extension improvements. The Morrison Drive project is not coordinated with the larger vision in purpose or design. Courtney Hutson 611 Ruby Drive Hi there! I am writing to strongly urge you, BZAZ, to oppose this permit to build upon this 12 acre site. The tidal salt marsh is VITAL to the community for many reasons, but today I am addressing its importance flood mitigation. Just one acre can hold 334,000 gallons of water. Not only does this com in handy during our hurricane storm events, but also during our more and more severe rainstorm events and peninsula flooding. PLEASE, do not fill in our natural sponge AND cover it with impermeable concrete. We do not want to look like Manhattan, which was once a flourishing tidal salt marsh as well. Please do not approve this short sighted project. Thank you for your time and consideration Mar 2 2026 10:55AM Eric Kencel 1822 Austin Avenue A high-rise development of this type would be the antithesis of what is needed for the city specifically in this area for long term sustainability and flood mitigation. The Charleston Water Plan specifically calls out the Newmarket Creek as a location better fit for a wetland stormwater park that would create walkable connections between communities, improve environmental quality, and reduce chronic flooding in the city's East side. A high-rise building would only exagerate flooding issues and contribute to a less welcoming and less sustainable city environment. Mar 2 2026 10:56AM Abbie Mobley 1736 Vassar Dr. Charleston SC 29407 This request does not satisfy the BZA variance criteria, as there are no extraordinary or exceptional conditions unique to this property, and it cannot meet UP mixed-use expectations for the ground floor due to the risk of extreme flooding. The proposed 12-story buildings are out of scale with the site and surrounding context and would exceed what the area’s infrastructure, streetscape, and watershed systems can reasonably support. Located at the gateway to the headwaters of Newmarket Creek, where the City is investing heavily in flood mitigation, stormwater management, and marsh restoration, the project is not aligned with ongoing resilience and watershed planning efforts, particularly given updated LiMWA flood maps and heightened flood risk requirements. Advancing this development risks long-term consequences for affordability, public safety, and effective flood management. Mar 2 2026 10:57AM Joy Smith 2804 Hartnett Blvd. Isle of Palms, SC 29451, Charleston Co. We are trying to preserve the last tidal creeks on the peninsula, Haymarket, Gadsden and Halsey Creeks. These three make up the composition of the proposed Just Ecological Corridor. I was under the impression that this was moving forward. How can a 12 story apartment building be considered on this site with its proximity to the creek. We have to respect the water here. We are destroying our wetlands and marshes and paving over what makes the low country so special. Federal law states that you cannot destroy wetlands and marshes. Builders get around this by remediating other wetlands in different locations. That can Mar 2 2026 11:02AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 21 only work for so long. How about protecting what is already in place? I would think that this large building or any building is not a good fit for this land. Local traffic is heavy now at the Ravenel and Morrison Dr. Move further up Morrison. How about land on the Naval Base. There should be plenty of space there. I also object that affordable housing will not be offered in this new build. Please do not approve this project. There are no positive outcomes here. The Just Ecological Corridor needs priority here. Let's lead the way with water sensitive development first! Philip Pittman 1882 Pierce Street, Charleston, SC 29492 I oppose this application due to insufficient environmental impact awareness and lack of public education. The impacts on the neighboring community are either poorly understood or inadequately conveyed, making this project appear to be a money grab with negative ecological effects. Mar 2 2026 11:02AM Grey Gowder 1629 Meeting Street Rd, STE A Charleston's history of filling and building upon our tidal creek basins has led to many of the resilience, environmental justice, and public health challenges our city faces today. The regulations for the Upper Peninsula Zoned District, FEMA Flood Zone regulations, and the site's hydrological realities paint a picture full of contradictions, most of which are at odds with the siting of this proposed structure in this specific location. There are appropriate locations for high-density, large footprint structures within the fabric of the Charleston peninsula, but this site is not one of them. This site is a low asphalt pad sitting atop part of the peninsula's largest tidal flood basin. It sits next to a culvert under Morrison Drive that acts as a chokepoint of that altered tidal system, restricting the flow in and out of the basin, which drains a vast area of the city around it. Building up that site and adding a hardened edge, as this applicant proposes, will redirect water from the surviving marsh into surrounding neighborhoods. This will hamper and greatly complicate the expensive and necessary hydrological resilience projects the City of Charleston is undertaking as part of its perimeter protection plan. The Carolina Ocean Alliance asks the members of the City of Charleston's Board of Zoning Appeals to recognize how the regulatory conflict underscores the inappropriateness of this site for high-intensity development, and deny the applicant's variance request. Mar 2 2026 11:06AM Olivia Greenslit 1427 Brockman Circle Charleston SC Allowing a 12-story apartment building along downtown's last tidal creek and in the Just Ecological Corridor AND in a high-risk coastal flood zone. Not only is this not safe for the building residents, but it will also degrade the surrounding ecosystem and area value to other Charleston residents and visitors. Downtown doesn't need another apartment complex in this area. Mar 2 2026 11:07AM Phillip Greenberg 5 King Street, Charleston, SC 29401 This project is totally wrong for this item because of flooding mitigation projects on the peninsula. Also the height(12 floors) and size of the project is too large for the lot. We support the HCF opposition to this project. Mar 2 2026 11:07AM Megan Pinckney 2254 Fiddler Creek Charleston, SC 29412 Building a twelve story structure on marshland isn’t only irresponsible, it will be costly to our government whenever the next hurricane blows through. Mar 2 2026 11:13AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 22 Max Kuller 2nd Bend Rd Harleyville SC 29448 This application deserves a firm denial on many levels. To start, the parcel quite simply does not meet the requirements for rezoning! There are no extraordinary or exceptional conditions that warrant consideration and the discussion should stop there! This project is detrimental to many stated long term goals of the city, particularly so in this case, as it sits in the newly declared FEMA flood zone. Allowing it to proceed would have serious adverse impacts on floodwater mitigation planning, storm water relief and marsh restoration that the city is actively investing in around the site. It would also adversely affect plans for badly needed affordable housing in the area. It is far too large of a building to be placed on this delicate land, it will alleviate none of the problems that Charleston needs to address, and will instead seriously add to the cities long term challenges if allowed. And with a ghost first floor to boot- just awful! PLEASE STRONGLY SAY NO! Mar 2 2026 11:16AM Carolina Arce 199 Shadowmoss Pkwy Not only would this be built on marsh land that’s already with water, but to destroy it and put a building in further damaging the natural habitat that aids in flooding in our city is a preposterous idea. Stop building on marshes that help the ecology of our city and keep safe the natural wildlife and resources provided to all. There are plenty of lots with empty buildings, deteriorating buildings, that can be purchased and repurposed instead of continuing to destroy our natural habitats. Protect! Mar 2 2026 11:18AM Charlene Boyd 184 East Bay Street I have been a tour guide for 12 years. I rarely get a new question from visitors, but about 2 weeks ago, I was asked one of my favorite questions so far, which has lingered in my subconscious ever since. I was asked, "What makes you proud of your city?" Charleston has been on the vanguard of how to build a resilient community that treasures and protects its past while innovating for the future. Our city's unique relationship with its history has given us the ability to see modern decisions in the broader context of time. Anything we do today will undoubtedly have consequences for the future. I have been proud of this city for how it has tackled new challenges and the conscious effort to ensure that today's decisions are being made for future generations, not for a quick buck today. Please reject this proposal. An exclusive apartment building with no public benefit will not make or break our future, but a weak commitment to flood mitigation will have ramifications that outlive us all. Mar 2 2026 11:24AM Stephanie Ferrigan 82 Broad Street Absolutely foolish to even be considering this proposed project. I strongly oppose. Enough with the destruction of marshland on our coast. Mar 2 2026 11:26AM Taylor Tillman 168 Riverland Drive 29412 I strongly oppose the requested zoning waiver for 989 Morrison Drive. This proposal seeks to override established zoning protections to allow a 12-story development on marshland connected to Newmarket Creek, within a FEMA flood zone. In a city already grappling with tidal flooding and investing public funds into marsh restoration and stormwater management, approving this exception would be irresponsible. Environmental safeguards are not obstacles to work around — they are protections for residents and taxpayers. Please reject this waiver and Mar 2 2026 11:28AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 23 uphold the standards designed to protect Charleston’s long-term resilience. Noah Rosenthal 67 America Street, Charleston, SC, 29403 I am speaking out against the proposed variance (Sec. 54- 299.25) to construct a multifamily development without an active use on the ground floor. This space is flood-prone, as evidenced by the flooding and effects of the nearby Newmarket Creek, which is one of the downtown peninsula’s last intact tidal creeks. Additionally, the area was designated in 2024 as a Limit of Moderate Wave Action (LiMWA) zone by FEMA. A key metric within LiMWA is the identification of areas where waves of up to three feet are expected under certain conditions. Similar to many areas of greater Charleston County, this area lacks the infrastructure and resilience necessary to support a 12- story building on a lot that currently holds an old boat propeller, a sizable puddle of water, and an industrial building. As a community, we must do better and work to responsibly develop and support growth that is rooted in resilience and environmental awareness. Mar 2 2026 11:28AM Ashley Sprouse West Ashley, SC As a City, we have got to start planning for our future and taking measures to make downtown more resilient as sea level rises. Do not build on our waterways. This is not a long-term housing solution and can only cause harm. Mar 2 2026 11:30AM Ashley Sprouse West Ashley, SC As a City, we have got to start planning for our future and taking measures to make downtown more resilient as sea level rises. Do not build on our waterways. This is not a long-term housing solution and can only cause harm. Mar 2 2026 11:30AM Adam Sutherland 4562 Mixson Ave, North Charleston, SC To whom it may concern, Please reject the pending application for a new 12-story building at 989 Morrison Drive. The zoning that is currently in place for this location is meant to protect the wetlands and wildlife that are essential to Charleston as a community. Approving this application would directly and detrimentally impact this rightfully protected space, while also continuing to contribute to the flooding issues that plague the entire peninsula. Thank you Mar 2 2026 11:32AM Cat Willett 53 Anson St Plainly: this is a bad idea. Take one look at this piece of land and it’s very apparent it would be unwise to build here. On the other hand, this is an area that could hugely benefit from investment in order to preserve it as a marshland, aiding with storm and floodwater management. I am opposed to any building structure here. Mar 2 2026 11:33AM Ansley Ramos 151 Coming Street This will undermine the marsh restoration, storm water management, and flood mitigation which the city is actively working on. Mar 2 2026 11:35AM Drew Geer 200 Grove Street This site has flooded for my entire 40+ years of living in Charleston, and the city is actively planning tidal flood protection, stormwater relief, and marsh restoration for Newmarket Creek connected to other large-scale infrastructure projects, like the Lowcountry Lowline and potential Battery Extension improvements. The Morrison Drive project is not coordinated with the larger vision in purpose or design. It is counter to it and is very short sighted. Mar 2 2026 11:36AM Polie Pavlova 197 Fox Squirrel Run, Summerville, SC I am a graduate student at the College of Charleston, and I voice my comment as an expert of environmental and social relations, as well as, a concerned citizen. This project seems highly negligent of ethical development on the Charleston Mar 2 2026 11:41AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 24 peninsula. Not only is it in a vulnerable flood area, but increasing impervious surface will also increase communities vulnerability to flooding and polluted run off. Newmarket creek is also one of the three remaining tidal creeks on the peninsula. This development will erase a historic site similar to previous in the past. The City of Charleston released a new plan called “living with water” and this proposed development does not align at all with the values and objectives of the “living with water” plan. Thus, this development will decrease green space for both animals and humans, increase vulnerability to flooding, increase traffic, and ultimately change the hydrodynamic feedbacks of Newmarket creek. I strongly oppose such unethical and profit-oriented development as this does not align with the City’s values nor its constituents. Blaike Marshall 809 Hitching Post Rd, Charleston, SC This grotesque proposal in the Newmarket Creek area is a testament to what is ruining the city of Charleston I was born and raised in. Waving a key zoning requirement meant to protect our city from what we just spent years and of multitudes of resources on the reconstruction of the Battery to combat—flooding. Marsh and wetlands are natural barriers and defenses against storm surges and the resulting deluge of flooding that already plagues us. And for what purpose? More short term rental properties built with roughshod unapproved materials and methods, only for the buck to be passed on down the line from private equity firm who overpromise and never deliver on fixing the mess their own greed created. If you care at all about this city and the communities within, you’ll be in opposition to this proposal and others just like it in the future. Mar 2 2026 11:42AM Tim McManus 816 east Ashley avenue, folly beach, sc 29439 I am writing to oppose the development at 975 And 989 Morrison Drive. New market creek holds significant environmental value to Charleston. While we may need development, it shouldn’t be at the expense of our waterways. Mar 2 2026 11:42AM Blaike Marshall 809 Hitching Post Rd, Charleston, SC This grotesque proposal in the Newmarket Creek area is a testament to what is ruining the city of Charleston I was born and raised in. Waving a key zoning requirement meant to protect our city from what we just spent years and of multitudes of resources on the reconstruction of the Battery to combat—flooding. Marsh and wetlands are natural barriers and defenses against storm surges and the resulting deluge of flooding that already plagues us. And for what purpose? More short term rental properties built with roughshod unapproved materials and methods, only for the buck to be passed on down the line from private equity firm who overpromise and never deliver on fixing the mess their own greed created. If you care at all about this city and the communities within, you’ll be in opposition to this proposal and others just like it in the future. Mar 2 2026 11:42AM A Foley 1025 Riverland Woods Pl, Charleston, SC 29412, USA In echoing the comments and concerns noted by the Historic Preservation Society and the Marsh Project, I am writing to oppose the construction of a 12-story structure at 989 Morrison. Charleston has been wisely working towards mitigating flood issues. This type of development is the equivalent of pouring water into a boat you're actively bailing out. Flood mitigation is a great use of tax-payer Mar 2 2026 11:43AM BZA-Z Public Comment B-5: 975 & 989 Morrison Drive Page 25 money. Don't waste it by approving construction that will exacerbate flooding. Rebekah Bradford 33 Charlotte Street (29403) I strongly urge you to reject this proposed project. To develop this area would undermine marsh restoration, stormwater management and flood mitigation in a FEMA flood zone, which the City is actively investing and working on. As a city under threat by hurricanes and rising sea levels, it is madness to continue to fill in our marsh areas that act as a buffer and shock absorber for storms. We have seen the consequences of that around MUSC after just a hard rain. Charleston is experiencing a building boom, but we have to be thoughtful about how we continue to develop on the Penisula, given our unique challenges. Allowing a 12-story building to be built here is counter to every effort the city continues to take to ensure Charleston thrives for decades to come. Thank you for your time. Mar 2 2026 11:49AM Maya Allen Black Mountain, NC I oppose the Morrison Drive project. Newmarket Creek is one of a few intact tidal creeks left on the peninsula and is precious. It is irresponsible and shortsighted to consider building at this scale upon a place that is and should be a wetland. There is not infrastructure to support it, and it would be a poor decision to invest in infrastructure only to enable unnecessary building on wetlands. I support denser housing and building homes, but not on wetlands. Mar 2 2026 11:55AM Liza Layfield 53 Church St This is a completely inappropriate request. In every way, this undermines the work the city is actively doing to mitigate flooding and protect waterways. If we have learned anything about the use of infill to support large scale construction, it is that it was and is a terrible idea. Let’s learn and grow from our mistakes and build any large scale development on solid, high ground. Mar 2 2026 11:56AM Rachel Wilson 2124 Fleet St, Baltimore MD The addition of any new building, let alone a 12-story building, at this site would tarnish the viewshed of the area and introduce new architectural elements that overwhelm the scale of the area. Work at this site would undermine efforts to preserve to the marshland and could cause untold damage to ecology of the marsh. As a former resident of the city and as an architectural historian, I oppose this project. Mar 2 2026 11:59AM Katie Koval Oak Point Road / 29412 Regulations should be honored. The city is filled with overdevelopment and encroachment on our water ways. This is one of the last tidal creeks in the area and essential for storm protection. Mar 2 2026 12:07PM CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 57 Ashe St. Cannonborough/Elliottborough | Council District 6 TMS# 460-00-01-100 | Zoned: DR-2F Request a variance from Sec. 54-301 to build a two-story rear porch addition with a 1’ rear setback (3’ required) and a 1’ east side setback (3’ required) and a variance to exceed maximum lot coverage (69% proposed, 57% existing, 50% allowed) to build a 2-story porch addition. Owner: Joette Westerburg & Jim Ruberg Applicant: Greg Demetri 2 Comments Submitted: • Robert Reifenberg, 59 Chapel Street, Charleston Submitted to Innovate Site on Feb. 25, 2026 9:09 PM I am co-owner, with my daughter, Jennifer, of 125 Line Street, the property that abuts the rear of 57 Ashe Street. I will address 57 Ashe Street's request for the rear set back variance. Previously, the Board denied the request for a set back exception insofar as it asked for a variance to go from the required 3' to 1' between the back property line and the proposed balcony. As I understand these revised plans for construction of a two story deck, the request has been revised from a 1' to 2' setback. This is of little consolation to my daughter and me. The thought of a hulking balcony overlooking her bedroom window, her parking area and anything and everything that happens on her property behind her building is chilling. The 125 Line Street property was purchased in 2023 based, in part, on existing setbacks and attendant expectations of privacy. As I look around the neighborhood, I have yet to find a single piazza that is built within 2' of a neighboring property line. Generally, there is a driveway of 8-10' that separates the upper piazza from the property line. Also, should we chose to build onto the rear of 125 Line, we could do so and be completely compliant with floor area ratios and other zoning requirements. (The parking area for 125 Line can currently accommodate 4 cars, and could be reduced to 2 so as to allow for an addition within permissible setback and floor area ratios and without need for zoning variance.) The viability of such a project would be significantly diminished if a two-story balcony were constructed allowing residents to look into the space. The proposed variance for 57 Ashe not only infringes on my daughter's privacy, but impairs her prospects to improve her own property. Moreover, as we read the revised petition for variance, we continue to see no basis in terms of hardship, etc. For these reasons, we object. • Jenny Reifenberg, 125 Line Street A Submitted to Innovate Site on Feb. 25, 2026 9:23 PM I own and reside at 125 Line Street, the property directly to the rear of 57 Ashe. I object to the petition for variance to allow construction of a two-story deck within 2' of my property line. My bedroom window is directly below that proposed construction. I could keep my shutters drawn at all times, but that seems an unreasonable accommodation to secure my own privacy. I bought the property based on existing setback requirements. If changed as requested in the petition, such will impair not only my use and enjoyment of my property but also the viability of expansion of my property within the current zoning requirements. CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS – ZONING 78 Cypress St. North Central | Council District 4 | TMS# 463-15-02-054 | Zoned: SR-1 Request a Special Exception under Sec. 54-110.f. to vertically extend a nonconforming east side setback to construct a second-story addition, and a variance from Sec. 54-301 to construct a 9’ tall fence (6’ allowed). Owner: Mcloughlin Living Trust Applicant: Sean McLoughlin 1 Comment Submitted: • Preservation Society of Charleston Submitted to Staff See attached letter. Position Statement Board of Zoning Appeals - Zoning March 3, 2026 78 Cypress St. Dear Board Members: The Preservation Society of Charleston (PSC) is opposed to this request. In considering the “reasonableness” of an extension under Sec. 54-110 (f), the Board must consider the “effects on properties in the vicinity,” and impacts on the “aesthetic character of the environs.” The proposed addition is out-of-scale with the streetscape and would result in an “unreasonable intensification” of the non-conforming use. We ask the Board to deny this request as proposed and encourage the applicant to consider a less intense addition with reduced impact on the historic form of the house and the character of the North Central neighborhood. The PSC seeks to be a resource for property owners and design/construction professionals seeking to make sensitive updates to historic properties, and our team welcomes the chance to discuss potential solutions with the applicant. Sincerely, Anna-Catherine Alexander Director of Advocacy Initiatives acalexander@preservationsociety.org

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.