RecordWell Data

_04062026-2162

Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Apr 6, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SC MOUNT PLEASANT TOWN COUNCIL Special Council Meeting Monday, April 6, 2026 12:30 p.m. Municipal Complex, Council Chambers 100 Ann Edwards Lane, Mount Pleasant, SC 29464 MI NUTES Cl ick here to listen to the recording 1. Call to Order Mayor Will Haynie called the Special Town Council Meeting to order on Monday, April 6, 2026 at 12:41 p.m. Council Members Brownstein, Whitaker, Hyatt, Chapman, Rambo, Tinkey, Crosby and Iacofano were all present. The Mayor noted that Council Members had been engaged in departmental budget reviews throughout the day in addition to the regular business items on the agenda. 2. Public Comments Mayor Haynie opened the floor for public comment, requesting that speakers provide their name and address and observe the two-and-a- half-minute time limit. Bob Adams stated that he had previously spoken in favor of the wetlands ordinance at the March 10 Town Council meeting. He returned to identify what he considered a drafting deficiency in the current language. He explained that the Supreme Court's decision in Sackett v. EPA limits the Clean Water Act to wetlands with a continuous surface connection to federally regulated water bodies, and that the proposed ordinance in Section 155.054(B)1 intends to cover areas not protected by that Act. However, he argued that the draft's references to "vernal pools and seasonal wet surface depressions" are limited to temporary bodies of water, leaving permanent wetlands unprotected and potentially subject to fill and development. He recommended amending Sections (B)1 and (B)3 to replace the existing phrases with broader language, such as "wetlands and other bodies of water fed by water sources not protected by the Clean Water Act" and "buffer to wetlands and other bodies of water defined in (B)1," respectively. Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 2 of 22 Lisa Schnipke expressed support for the ordinance, noting that wetland protections provide community resiliency. She emphasized that alterations to private property, including wetland fill or destruction, impact neighboring properties. She also asked that Town Council consider the potential for microplastics runoff from artificial turf at Gary Santos Park into nearby wetlands. Susie Carlson, attorney with the Southern Environmental Law Center and a Mount Pleasant resident, expressed support for the ordinance, citing increasing risks from sea level rise and flooding. She urged Council to keep the exceptions in the ordinance narrowly tailored, warning that broader exceptions — such as those covering home additions — could lead to cumulative and significant wetland loss over time and allow development regardless of project size or impact. Harriet Parker, Director of Development Stewardship at Charleston Waterkeeper, spoke in favor of Ordinance 26022. She described wetlands as critical infrastructure that filters pollution, stores floodwater, and provides habitat at no cost. She characterized the ordinance as a thoughtful, locally developed approach to protecting wetlands that lack state and federal protections and stated that Charleston Waterkeeper supports the ordinance as written. Michael Ramsey, a Charleston County resident, asked Council to consider carving out existing single-family lots and existing residential homes from the ordinance, while expressing understanding that the ordinance would make sense for new development and large developments. There being no additional speakers, Mayor Haynie closed public comment. 3. Final Reading: An Ordinance to amend Chapter 155, of the Mount Pleasant Code of Ordinances, specifically modifying Chapter 155.054, Greenspace Preservation and Protection Plan, and Environmental Guidelines for Land Development. This Ordinance establishes developmental standards for the environmental protection of isolated non-jurisdictional wetlands, Ord. No. 26022 (Item listed to allow for amendments. Final reading anticipated at April regular Town Council Meeting) Mayor Haynie clarified for the record that although the item was listed as a final reading, Council had agreed in advance to use this special meeting to consider and vote on amendments, with final reading Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 3 of 22 anticipated at the regular Town Council meeting the following Tuesday, April 14. Procedural Motion Legal Counsel David Pagliarini advised that the preferred procedural approach was to move for final approval, vote on any amendments, but withhold the final approval vote — leaving the item open for any additional amendments or discussion at the regular meeting. Council Member John Iacofano moved for final reading and for the item to be taken to the next council meeting, with the current meeting limited to discussion and possible action on amendments. The motion was seconded by Council Member Chapman. Mayor Haynie provided context for the ordinance, noting that it would add Section 155.055 to the existing Chapter 155 Land Development Regulations, which is part of the Greenspace Preservation and Protection Plan. He emphasized that the ordinance was not a new chapter but an amendment to and addition within an existing framework. The Mayor reflected on the more than one year of public process, citing coverage in the news media as early as March 31, 2025, and referencing the Town of Bluffton's loss of 500 acres of wetlands as a cautionary example. He stated that resiliency issues cannot wait, as lost wetlands cannot be recovered. He noted that the ordinance had been reviewed by the Flood Resilience Committee, the Planning Committee, the Police, Judicial and Legal Committee, the Planning Commission, and the Green Commission before arriving at Town Council. Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 4 of 22 Staff Presentation Kevin Mitchell presented an overview of the ordinance and its implementation tools. He noted that the ordinance applies to non- jurisdictional, isolated wetlands — those not covered under Army Corps of Engineers regulations — and that determinations of jurisdictional status would require a wetlands professional with a minimum of five years of field experience using the 1987 Army Corps Federal Manual and the appropriate regional data sheet. The ordinance would apply to all subdivisions and single-family activity. A buffer averaging 10 feet, Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 5 of 22 with a minimum of 5 feet and a maximum of 20 feet, would be required around isolated wetlands, with the Planning Commission having authority to increase the buffer width when deemed necessary for larger or more impactful developments. Regarding exemptions, Mr. Mitchell described the three-part criteria that would exempt a property from requiring a wetlands professional: (1) the owner submits an affidavit affirming no known knowledge of isolated wetlands or previous delineations on their property; (2) the town's GIS mapping tool shows no indication of suspected wetlands; and (3) the proposal does not increase density on the property. He noted this framework was modeled closely on Bluffton's ordinance. Environmental Manager Maeve Gimbert presented the GIS mapping tool used to identify potential isolated wetland areas. The tool layers three data sources: the National Wetland Inventory (US Fish and Wildlife, 2011), hydric soil data (USDA National Resources Conservation Service), and a sink/depression layer developed by the town's GIS team using 2025 topography data. Ms. Gimbert explained that hydric soil and depressional sinks represent two of the three primary wetland indicators under the Army Corps manual, with the third — hydrophilic vegetation — not yet available as a data layer. Stormwater ponds were removed from the tool to reduce confusion, as they are not classified as wetlands. The combined layer covers just under nine percent of the town. She noted that the tool is used as an internal staff tool to flag properties for closer review, not as a hard determination of wetland presence. Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 6 of 22 Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 7 of 22 Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 8 of 22 Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 9 of 22 Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 10 of 22 Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 11 of 22 Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 12 of 22 Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 13 of 22 Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 14 of 22 Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 15 of 22 Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 16 of 22 Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 17 of 22 Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 18 of 22 Several Council Members asked clarifying questions about the practical application of the tool. Mr. Mitchell confirmed that staff would exercise judgment — including field visits — before requiring a property owner to hire a wetlands professional, and that a blue dot on the map alone would not automatically trigger that requirement. He confirmed that interior renovations not involving land disturbance would not be subject to the ordinance. Council Member Brownstein asked about the cost of a wetland delineation, and Mr. Mitchell estimated a range of approximately $1,500 to $2,000 for an initial site visit and data collection. Mr. Mitchell also presented a slide clarifying the roles and responsibilities under the ordinance: the Planning Commission reviews and decides on subdivision requests and holds authority to increase buffer widths; property owners are responsible for disclosing historical knowledge, employing wetlands professionals (consistent with existing practices for stormwater and tree removal compliance), and ensuring long-term protection of isolated wetlands; and staff administers permits, uses the GIS tool, ensures design compliance, and investigates unpermitted impacts. Council Member Iacofano raised concerns about the visual complexity of the GIS map, particularly regarding random or isolated data points that may appear on residential properties, and expressed a preference for clearer, more black-and-white guidance for residents and staff. Ms. Gimbert clarified that data points appearing on roads or under structures are likely the result of the parent soil material or a closed topographic Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 19 of 22 contour and would be recognized as non-wetland data artifacts by trained staff. Amendment 1 — Strike Section D.2 Except for Critical Infrastructure and Emergency Activity Council Member Mike Tinkey introduced the first amendment, citing the importance of the town abiding by the same rules it imposes on residents. He proposed amending Section D.2, which provides an exception allowing the Director of Engineering and Development Services to authorize alterations serving an overriding public interest — including parks, recreation facilities, capital improvement projects, critical infrastructure, and emergency activities. His amendment would strike the broader language while retaining the provisions for critical infrastructure and emergency activity and would remove the single-director authority in favor of routing such requests through the normal Planning Commission review process. Council Member Brownstein asked what the normal process would be for a project that is no longer exempt. Mr. Mitchell explained that the Planning Commission reviews subdivision requests and could also review wetland impact applications from property owners or the town, similar to a model used by Bluffton. He indicated he had a draft slide outlining an alternate procedural pathway, which he briefly shared: applicants would submit a wetland impact application, which would go on public notice and be reviewed and decided upon by the Planning Commission. Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 20 of 22 Council Member Rambo expressed concern about vesting a significant amount of authority in an unelected body, particularly with respect to council-approved projects. He raised the scenario of a council-approved capital project being denied or substantially altered at the Planning Commission level, noting the potential for increased costs and outcomes contrary to Council's intent. Legal Counsel Pagliarini acknowledged that such a scenario could create a situation in which the town is defending or prosecuting something adverse to Council's wishes. Town Administrator Eric DeMoura confirmed that Gary Santos Park, currently under construction, would not be affected by the ordinance, and that most foreseeable future town projects involve roads, existing stormwater infrastructure, or already-built facilities that would be exempted or unaffected. The amendment was put to a roll call vote. Council Member Tinkey moved to amend the ordinance to strike Section D.2, retaining only the provisions for critical infrastructure and emergency activity, and removing the single-director authority in favor of the Planning Commission review process. Council Member Chapman seconded the motion. The motion carried 5–4, with Council Members Chapman, Crosby, Hyatt, Tinkey, and Mayor Haynie voting in favor, and Council Members Iacofano, Rambo, Whitaker, and Brownstein voting in opposition. Amendment 2 — Remove "Or Adjacent To" from Buffer Language Council Member Brownstein proposed removing the phrase "or adjacent to" from Section C.3.b., which prohibits the introduction of invasive species or non-native landscaping "within or adjacent to" the buffer or wetlands. He expressed concern that as written, the phrase could be interpreted as regulating landscaping anywhere on a property, since essentially all areas are "adjacent to" something. Mr. Mitchell confirmed that enforcement intent was not to be heavy-handed in this regard, but Council Member Brownstein suggested that removing the phrase would simplify and clarify the language. Council Member Hyatt noted the original purpose was to protect the wetland from nearby invasive plantings, such as kudzu, that could encroach into it. Council Member Brownstein moved to amend the buffer section of the ordinance to remove the phrase "or adjacent to" from Section C.3.b. Council Member Iacofano seconded the motion. The motion Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 21 of 22 carried 5–4 with Council Members Iacofano, Rambo, Brownstein, Chapman and Mayor Haynie voting in favor. Council Members Hyatt, Tinkey, Whitaker and Crosby voting in opposition. Amendment 3 — Exempt Existing Single-Family Homes (Not Adding Density) Council Member Brownstein moved to exempt existing single-family homes not adding density from the ordinance, expressing the view that the ordinance should first be implemented and tested on subdivisions and commercial projects before being extended to existing residential properties. He stated that homeowners with single-family residences do not have the same flexibility as developers to redesign or relocate improvements, and that lessons learned from initial implementation should inform any expansion of the ordinance's scope. Council Member Hyatt opposed the amendment, stating that the purpose of the ordinance is to protect wetlands regardless of where they are located, and that no exceptions should be made. Council Member Tinkey agreed, emphasizing that wetland loss is cumulative and that incremental losses — one at a time — add up to significant damage over time. Mayor Haynie stated that the vast majority of Mount Pleasant citizens are asking for more sensitivity about where and how development occurs, and that he would not support an amendment that allows existing single-family homeowners to damage wetlands affecting neighboring properties. Council Member Iacofano, who had seconded the motion for discussion purposes, ultimately voted against it, citing concern about the GIS map's blue dots appearing on properties that may not have obvious wetlands. Council Member Brownstein moved to amend the ordinance to exempt existing single-family homes not adding density from the ordinance's requirements. Council Member Iacofano seconded the motion for discussion purposes. The motion failed 2–7. Council Members Brownstein and Chapman voted in favor with Council Members Crosby, Hyatt, Iacofano, Rambo, Tinkey, Whitaker and Mayor Haynie voting in opposition. Amendment 4 — Update Language in Sections B(1) and B(3) to Reflect Clean Water Act Coverage Council Member Crosby moved to adopt the language amendments proposed by public commenter Bob Adams, updating Sections b(1) and b(3) to replace references to "vernal pools and seasonal wet surface Special Town Council Meeting April 6, 2026 Page 22 of 22 depressions" with broader language clarifying coverage of wetlands and water bodies not protected by the Clean Water Act. Legal Counsel Pagliarini confirmed that the language as proposed in Mr. Adams's correspondence was sufficient and that staff would redraft accordingly. Council Member Crosby moved to amend the ordinance to update Sections (B)1 and (B)3 to replace "vernal pools and seasonal wet surface depressions" with language encompassing wetlands and other bodies of water not protected by the Clean Water Act, consistent with the language proposed by public commenter Bob Adams. The motion was seconded by Council Member Hyatt. The motion carried unanimously. Additional Requests Council Member Rambo requested that Legal Counsel prepare, prior to the April 14 regular meeting, a legal brief addressing the enforceability of the ordinance, any potential legal vulnerabilities, and the legal implications of a council-approved project being subject to Planning Commission denial. Mayor Haynie confirmed that all amendments voted on during the special meeting would be incorporated into the version of the ordinance presented for final reading at the regular Town Council meeting on Tuesday, April 14, 2026. Legal Counsel clarified that the draft language would not be physically changed prior to that meeting, as the amendments would only be formally incorporated upon final vote. 4. Adjourn Mayor Haynie thanked Kevin Mitchell and staff, Brad Morrison, and Town Administrator Eric DeMoura for their extensive work on the ordinance. With no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 2:05 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Christine Barrett Clerk of Council April 6, 2026

Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.