RecordWell Data

BAR-S Meeting Results

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Feb 26, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL MEETING RESULTS FEBRUARY 26, 2026 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Lindsay Van Slambrook, Fillmore Wilson, William Bill Turner, Becky Fenno, Darryl Cobb STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: Frankie Pinto, Travis Galli A. Minutes 1. Review of Minutes from the February 12, 2026 Meeting DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approved with Van Slambrook edits MADE BY: Van Slambrook SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 B. Applications 1. 35 Nunan Street BAR2026-002373 | TMS# 460-07-04-171 | Westside | Council District 6 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1935 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting after-the-fact approval for demolition and approval for demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way. Owner: Legacy 28 Enterprises Inc. Applicant: Roy Reeves (Mike Loveday) Site visit on 02/26/2026 at 8:30 a.m. DECISION: DENIED MOTION: Denial of after the fact with Board conditions, and denial of proposed demolition MADE BY: Wilson SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Work with staff to submit appropriate drawings to accurately depict the original configuration of the structure to restore within 30 business days STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Historic context was not provided, staff felt was important to bring before the Board. Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 26, 2026 Page 2 2. Drawings of existing structure are incorrect: a. There should be 2 windows on existing front elevation b. Front door has side light and transom, similar to those that were on 63 Nunan c. Front porch metal railing is not shown d. Front porch column details and facia are not shown. e. Double hung window on east elevation should be centered between diamond windows 3. New built elevations shows rear stoop being enclosed as an addition. (comment struck at meeting, applicant not changing to new building) 4. Chimneys are not shown on new build drawings. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial of after the fact demolition and proposed demolition, applicant to submit revised plans to restore building to original configuration within 30 business days BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • Kevin Eberle, President Street, Hampton Park Terrace o Plans don’t show details o Concern inappropriate materials could be used • HCF o Insufficient submittal o Opposed to after the fact approval BOARD COMMENTS: • Applicant has stated he wants to return to original • 2 parts, after the fact and approval of additional demolition • Incorrect / inconsistencies in drawings 2. 4 South Battery Street BAR2026-002397 | TMS# 457-16-04-043 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Category 2 | c. 1895 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for restoration of parapet balustrade of architectural urethane. Owner: Stephen and Mary Hammond Applicant: e.e. fava architects Site visit on 2/26/2026 at 8:50 a.m. DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approval of duplicating balustrade with synthetic material with Board condition MADE BY: Wilson SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Mockup is not approved Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 26, 2026 Page 3 • Accurate drawings showing all of details of synthetic balustrade be submitted to staff for approval • Those drawings to duplicate the original historic balustrade STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Mockup provided per previous Board motion. 2. Per BAR Policy Statement Charleston Standards: a. The historic character of a property should be retained and preserved. The removal of distinctive materials or alteration of features, spaces, and spatial relationships that characterize a property may negatively impact the historic character and should be avoided. b. Charleston has a tradition of expert craftsmanship in even its simplest structures. Examples of craftsmanship such as distinctive materials, architectural features, finishes, and construction techniques should be protected. c. Additions or exterior alterations to historic properties should be sympathetic to historic materials, features, and spatial relationships that characterize the property. The new work should be compatible with the historic materials, features, size, scale, proportion, and massing to protect the integrity of the property and its setting. To respect the authenticity of the historic structure and its context and setting, the new alterations or addition should be clearly discernible from the old. The differentiation may or may not be stylistic, and may be as subtle as a change in building footprint, material, or other means. 3. Precedent case study: 29 Broad, Board reviewed and approved repairs to match existing in 2017 4. Precedent case study: 20 S Battery, Board gave conceptual approval a wood balustrade 4/28/2022. No permit was applied for. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial of material change BOARD QUESTIONS: • Can make a mold to match original balustrade. Mockup was made of stock product • Inconsistency between drawing and photograph. Believe it is better to have space between rail and roof • Top rail doesn’t align with top of pier PUBLIC COMMENT: • none BOARD COMMENTS: • Have allowed synthetic materials along Murray Blvd and S Battery • Have allows clad windows on some houses Murray Blvd • Objections to alternative materials due to visibility • Not that difficult to replace materials with original materials • Ideally balustrade should be wood • Significant for the public view, sympathetic to the material • Not in favor of the mockup, does not duplicate the original Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 26, 2026 Page 4 • Could support a synthetic balustrade that replicates the original, open to some alterations • Should match original as closely as can be determined by historic research • Could support approval of drawings or samples that show match • Understand the maintenance difficulties • If balustrade were existing now in wood, would feel differently 3. 122 Logan Street BAR2026-002398 | TMS# 457-08-02-085 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Category 3 | c. 1791 | Old & Historic District Requesting preliminary approval for proposed renovation and addition. Owner: 122 Logan Street, LLC Applicant: e.e. fava architects DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Preliminary approval with Board and staff conditions and final review by staff MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 Opposed: Wilson BOARD CONDITIONS: • See discussion STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Drawings call out “Per detail or architect approval equivalent system”. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. By final submittal a specific product must be called out and notes should indicate that any changes must be approved by staff. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Preliminary approval with Board and staff conditions and final review by staff of permit BOARD QUESTIONS: • Glass enclosure system PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Most of comments centered around rear addition and those have been addressed • Issue of preliminary submittal without dimensions • Staff to review size and scale as reviewing the final • Appreciate corner element retained • Concern about glass box, struggling with materials • No issue with height, scale, and mass Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 26, 2026 Page 5 4. 66 Cypress Street BAR2026-002384 | TMS# 463-12-01-073 | North Central | Council District 4 Category 4 (Group 1) | c. 1938 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting amendment to previous demolition approval. Owner: Mae Huber McAlary Applicant: Loyal Architects – Ross Ritchie Previous site visit on 8/28/2025 DECISION: DENIED MOTION: Denial of amendment to previous demolition approval MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Request asking for demolition portion of eave that Board required to be retained STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Requirement of previous Board motion BOARD QUESTIONS: • none PUBLIC COMMENT: • none BOARD COMMENTS: • Rake of the eave was what Board previously had issue with • Believe there is visibility from South Enston, don’t think would be seen from Peachtree • Have consistently required retention of eave • At minimum, eave return should be completely retained • Proposal preserves half of return • Dependent on visibility • Difficulty when can’t see what’s going back • Pretty consistent requirement of the Board to retain 5. 190 Line Street BAR2026-002374 | TMS# 460-07-04-141 | Westside | Council District 6 Not Surveyed | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for reconstruction of previous structure per Board motion. Owner: MFI Applicant: Trey Brown DECISION: DEFERRED MOTION: Deferral with staff conditions and Board discussion and for submission of more accurate and complete drawings Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 26, 2026 Page 6 MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • More accurate and complete drawings STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. Roof is rendered incorrectly, ridge should come to a point, not flat. 2. Fenestration on piazza should be restudied for placement. Without documentation of original placement, windows and doors should follow the typical rhythm seen in historic structures. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of reconstruction with Board and staff conditions and final review by staff of permit drawings BOARD QUESTIONS: • Front steps are drawn as open risers • One end of front picture window looks different than the other, CAD issue • Front window is off centered in wall • Foundation stucco finish • Piazza screen wall, broken pediment. Detailing off • Drawing error on ridge • Foundation doesn’t line up with piers • Lite pattern of windows PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Encouraged to see drawings o Would like to see rebuilt as was, keeping historic material o Missing details o Removal of chimney, would like to see retained BOARD COMMENTS: • Terrible drawings, so many mistakes o Roof is not flat o Not a historic window detail • Appreciate that structure is going back • Can’t approve these drawings o Roof incorrect o Drawings mislabeled o Window incorrect • Can approve reconstruction, not drawings Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 26, 2026 Page 7 6. 17 Pinckney Street BAR2026-002379 | TMS# 458-05-03-024 | Council District 8 Category 4 | c. 1870 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for exterior restoration, access deck, and shade structure. Owner: 14 Anson LLC Applicant: Dan Sweeney DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board conditions and preliminary / final review by staff of permit MADE BY: Fenno SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Shade canopy to be pulled in from east edge, 4-6” • Roof form be restudied with staff to reduce slope and be less heavy, more compatible with historic structure STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Previous demolitions approved 5/22/2025 and 1/8/2026 2. Proposed roof is below eave of historic house STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit BOARD QUESTIONS: • Will be hardscaping plans • Underpinning under ramp, haven’t detailed fully. Wood ramp, composite slats PUBLIC COMMENT: • none BOARD COMMENTS: • Everything going on with main structure is wonderful • Don’t have issue with ramp or anything going on at rear • Review of hardspace? By staff in permit • Concern about visibility of back, • Design is a little heavy • Roof form should be a little more compatible Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 26, 2026 Page 8 7. 105 King Street BAR2026-002371 | TMS# 457-12-04-055 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1945 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for second-story addition and fenestration changes. Owner: Harrison Malpass Applicant: Coastal Creek Design DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 Recuse: Wilson BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Submittal follows previous Board discussion / recommendation STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit BOARD QUESTIONS: • none PUBLIC COMMENT: • none BOARD COMMENTS: • Roofline is much better • This is a funky house 8. 32 Charlotte Street BAR2026-002380 | TMS# 459-13-01-100 | Garden District | Council District 4 Category 2 | c. 1820 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for rear addition. Owner: 32 Charlotte St, LLC Applicant: G.M. Wallace, Jr. Architect DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 2 Opposed: Wilson, Fenno BOARD CONDITIONS: • none Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 26, 2026 Page 9 STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Addition will be visible per staff site visit. 2. Windows have been returned to original configuration per previous Board motion. 3. Property is a category 2 in the architectural inventory so any alterations must be approved by the Board. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with Board comments with preliminary / final review by staff BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • none BOARD COMMENTS: • Previous comment were about how building touched or addressed historic structures, has addressed Board’s concerns • No previous request to respect corner at last meeting? • Reviewing plans was confusing. Existing plans are separated by elevations. Submittal requirements require existing, previous, and current to be adjacent • This is a lot of addition, very handsome single house • This request diminishes original, adds more complexity • Was previous motion addressed. Difficulty because current Board would not approve • Unfortunate architectural maneuver • A massing study wasn’t requested, only whether was visible • Category 2 building, our second highest rating, this is not a sensitive addition 9. 28 Montagu Street BAR2026-002382 | TMS# 457-03-02-048 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Category 3 | c. 1809 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for new two-story pool house. Owner: John and Marcie Crowe Applicant: Brian Crouch Architect DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board discussion and preliminary / final review by staff of permit MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • See discussion STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Proposal is subordinate and will be minimally visible from Montagu. 2. Proposed structure is differentiated from historic structure. Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 26, 2026 Page 10 STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit BOARD QUESTIONS: • none PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Easement holder, compliant with easement BOARD COMMENTS: • Fairly simple building, nice detailing • Historically accurate, rail should be below the parting bolt • Maybe some bracketing 10. 145 South Battery Street BAR2026-002395 | TMS# 457-11-01-019 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 1927 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for enclosed lift at rear. Owner: Jack Cleland Applicant: Sebastian von Marshall DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Proposed addition is an alteration to a previous addition, and will cause that addition to be visible from ROW. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit BOARD QUESTIONS: • Lift to the roof terrace, current access is through a window PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Makes sense. Simple, discrete Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 26, 2026 Page 11 11. 86 South Battery Street BAR2026-002375 | TMS# 457-11-02-035 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 1911 | Old & Historic District Requesting final approval for detail revisions to new construction plans for accessory building. Owner: Meredith and Sam Turner Applicant: Julia F. Martin Architects DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Final approval as submitted MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 2 Opposed: Wilson, Fenno BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Permit denied by staff 1/15/2026. The requested windows have vinyl components. Marvin Elevate windows are not comparable Marvin Ultimate due to material. 2. Staff cannot approve synthetic shutters. a. BAR Principle: The authenticity of Charleston should be supported by the use of materials that are authentic in their appearance and function. 3. Staff did not think the awnings appropriate due to visibility. BOARD QUESTIONS: • On east elevation, calls out awning, but not shown. Drawing issue PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Don’t have issue with proposed windows, setback from right of way • Allow composite siding and trim on new construction, don’t see issue with composite shutters • Understand reluctance on awnings, previously awning had gotten out of hand • High quality composite will last a long time. UV issues, expand / contract thermally • Policy has been that shutters have to be wood • Just outlined policy on windows, can’t go against • On new construction only issue with composite shutters is quality of shutter, many brand options • Structure is set so far back, not precedent setting • Visual difference from approved window Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 26, 2026 Page 12 12. 40 Broad Street BAR2026-002376 | TMS# 458-09-03-037 | French Quarter | Council District 8 Category 2 | c. 1891 | Old & Historic District Requesting final approval from new storefront awnings. Owner: Mike Shuler Applicant: Julia F. Martin Architects DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff conditions and preliminary / final review by staff MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Property is a category 2 in the architectural inventory so any alterations must be approved by the Board. 2. Per BAR signage policy, awning: Should fit over only the opening that it covers and not extend across the entire façade. 3. Proposed awning appear to be for sidewalk dining, which must be approved by zoning. Since the proposed is adjacent to a loading zone, the sidewalk must be at least 8’ wide with at least 5’ of unimpeded sidewalk. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. Must receive zoning approval for sidewalk dining prior to final approval STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with staff conditions and preliminary / final review by staff BOARD QUESTIONS: • none PUBLIC COMMENT: • none BOARD COMMENTS: • Think it’s appropriate Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 26, 2026 Page 13 13. 19 Ashley Avenue BAR2026-002381 | TMS# 457-07-04-042 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 1975 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for shutters and awning over front door. Owner: Ashley Severance Applicant: Scott Parker DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board conditions with preliminary / final review by staff MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Awning style should be like inspiration • Door head to be retained • Shutters on double windows to be bifold • Bottom panel of side lites to be solid STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Current door surround matches other side of duplex. 2. House is a mirror of other side of duplex, deviations from this symmetry alter the architectural integrity of the structure. 3. Proposed hood is not appropriate for the structure. 4. Drawings inconsistently show with belle curve roof, as seen in precedents. 5. BAR typically does not approve solid panel shutters above the first floor. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial as proposed BOARD QUESTIONS: • Drawings inconsistent, awning shown both with a curve and simple brace back • Difficulty in adding an awning without removing door surround PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Bad design without awning • Understand wanting to keep door surround • Don’t understand what design is supposed to be, shown differently • Think door surround should be retained, would be easy to work around • If neighbor needs awning, should match whatever is preferred • One of the Fitzsimmons townhouses (?) • Ok with panel shutters due to later date of building • Proposed side lites are different on either side Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 26, 2026 Page 14 14. 135 Ashley Avenue BAR2026-002388 | TMS# 457-03-01-011 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1900 | Old & Historic District Requesting appeal of after-the-fact staff denial for vinyl windows. Owner: Tanya Tinajero Applicant: Tanya Tinajero DECISION: DENIED MOTION: uphold staff denial MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. After the fact permit request denied by staff 12/23/25. Vinyl windows cannot be approved by staff. BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Very inexpensive windows. Unfortunate that this happened • Whatever goes back to replace should match previous windows • Lite pattern has been changed 15. 115 Smith Street BAR2026-002389 | TMS# 460-15-04-041 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 1968 | Old & Historic District Requesting final approval for Andersen Fibrex windows. Owner: Andrew Demos Applicant: Harborview Windows and Doors DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Overturn staff denial with Board conditions MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Lite cut matches 4/4 • Color be white Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 26, 2026 Page 15 STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Could not be approved by staff due to having vinyl components. 2. Staff cannot approve wholesale replacement of windows. 3. Existing windows appear to be wood, true divided light. 4. Proposed windows are a composite thermoplastic. 5. Staff is concerned about the quality of the product and its appropriateness for the Old and Historic district. 6. Unable to determine if the seams are visible, are the corners mitered, the appearance of the jam liner, ect. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial BOARD QUESTIONS: • Not a vinyl, fibrex • What’s the jamliner, fibrex • Insert, it’s screwed through the jam • Units 1, 2, 4, 6 PUBLIC COMMENT: • none BOARD COMMENTS: • Existing windows do need to be replaced • Since not all units are replacing, important to match lite pattern and color • Given age and simplicity of building, don’t have issue with non-wood window 16. Update to Architecture Inventory DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approval for review by City Council MADE BY: Van Slambrook SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval for review by City Council BOARD QUESTIONS: • none PUBLIC COMMENT: • none BOARD COMMENTS: • none

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.