RecordWell Data

BAR-S Public Comment

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Feb 26, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL PUBLIC COMMENT FEBRUARY 26, 2026 A meeting of the Board of Architectural Review – Small (BAR -S) will be held on Thursday, February 26, 2026 at 4:30 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street. The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hou rs in advance of the meeting. The comments will also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard. Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bar. Please check the website on the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items. For additional information, please contact: Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781 B. APPLICATIONS 1. 35 Nunan Street BAR2026-002373 | TMS# 460-07-04-171 | Westside | Council District 6 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1935 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting after-the-fact approval for demolition and approval for demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way. Owner: Legacy 28 Enterprises Inc. Applicant: Roy Reeves Site visit on 02/26/2026 at 8:30 a.m. 2 Comments Submitted: • Sarah Spangler, 395 Sumter Street Submitted to Innovate Site on Feb. 25, 2026 10:43 AM My name is Sarah Spangler, and I serve as President of the Westside Neighborhood Association. Regarding 35 Nunan, I was pleased to see that limited materials appear to have been removed at this time. To my untrained eye, and I will defer to the Board of Architectural Review, Historic Charleston, and the Preservation Society for formal determination, this home appears to be a Freedman’s cottage. There are only approximately 106 remaining above Septima P. Clark in what was historically a predominantly working class Black neighborhood, one of the first areas where Black families were able to own property and establish roots.Because of that context, preserving its scale and architectural integrity is especially important.It appears there may be plans to add a second story. If so, that would significantly alter the historic style of the home. The rendering does not clearly show this, but the architectural set references both A3 and A4 plans, which appear different. Clarification would be appreciated. My primary concern is whether the home will remain one story in keeping with its historic form. This would completely alter the public perception of the home. The diamond pane windows are exceptional and remain in good condition on at least one visible side (it appears that side will retain the diamond windows in the drawings). They are beautiful, character-defining features. Currently, one side of the home is boarded, and it is unclear whether those boards are covering additional diamond Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | February 26, 2026 Page 2 windows or if any were removed. If there are existing before photographs, that would be very helpful for clarity. Losing those windows would be a significant loss to the character of the home. I already did visit the site and take a series of photographs, which I have shared with the Preservation Society for additional review. I would love to know what was removed from the boarded right side of the house. I do want to say that I really appreciate the elements shown in the virtual rendering. Retaining the brick pillars and the styled railing looks thoughtful, and the white support columns are both beautiful, but still respectful of the historical structure. They are a bit more square than the currently existing round columns, and I am unclear if the round pillars are a historical architectural feature. The existing pillars also are perhaps salvagable as historic material, but I do not know if they are structurally damaged in some way. Please retain the historic character and scale of this property so that Westside remains consistent in its stylistic, historic, and classic architectural fabric. Thank you for your consideration. Please retain as much historic material and architectural features as possible. Respectfully, Sarah Spangler President Westside Neighborhood Association • Preservation Society of Charleston Submitted to Staff See attached statement. 2. 4 South Battery Street BAR2026-002397 | TMS# 457-16-04-043 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Category 2 | c. 1895 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for restoration of parapet balustrade of architectural urethane. Owner: Stephen and Mary Hammond Applicant: e.e. fava architects Site visit on 2/26/2026 at 8:50 a.m. No Comments Submitted 3. 122 Logan Street BAR2026-002398 | TMS# 457-08-02-085 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Category 3 | c. 1791 | Old & Historic District Requesting preliminary approval for proposed renovation and addition. Owner: 122 Logan Street, LLC Applicant: e.e. fava architects No Comments Submitted Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | February 26, 2026 Page 3 4. 66 Cypress Street BAR2026-002384 | TMS# 463-12-01-073 | North Central | Council District 4 Category 4 (Group 1) | c. 1938 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting amendment to previous demolition approval. Owner: Mae Huber McAlary Applicant: Loyal Architects – Ross Ritchie Previous site visit on 8/28/2025 12 Comments Submitted: • Zac Viscidi, 59 Cypress St Submitted to Innovate Site on Feb. 23, 2026 6:40 PM My wife and I are writing in support of our neighbors’ application to create a modest addition to their home. Please continue to allow sensible projects proceed in a timely manner. • Letters of Support Submitted to Staff See attached letters. • Resident, 56 Cypress St. • Rachel Coughlin, 58 Cypress St. • Brielle and Zac Viscidi, 59 Cypress St. • Resident, 64 Cypress St. • Resident, 68 Cypress St. • John and Markey Mossman, 59 Cypress St. • Christine Campbell and Eric Rehfield, 85 Cypress St. • Rivers and Sarah Evans, 29 Peachtree St. • Resident, 40 Peachtree St. • Christine and Nic Williams, 66 Maple St. • Denise Huber, 105 Magnolia Ave. 5. 190 Line Street BAR2026-002374 | TMS# 460-07-04-141 | Westside | Council District 6 Not Surveyed | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for reconstruction of previous structure per Board motion. Owner: MFI Applicant: Trey Brown 2 Comments Submitted: • Sarah Spangler, 395 Sumter Street Submitted to Innovate Site on Feb. 25, 2026 10:58 AM My name is Erin Spangler, and I serve as President of the Westside Neighborhood Association. I am writing regarding 109 Line Street in the Westside neighborhood. In consultation with the Preservation Society of Charleston, I respectfully request that key historic features of this structure be retained, including the historic chimney and the use of masonry brick or CMU for stair treatment on the stairs leading up to the door. This area floods significantly, and wood plank stairs are both inconsistent with our architecture and will struggle with the highly needed storm resilience of homes on this regularly flooded street. Preserving these elements is important to maintaining the architectural integrity and historic character of both the home and the surrounding Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | February 26, 2026 Page 4 community. Wooden stairs, while common in other contexts, tend to create a more coastal or “beach cottage” aesthetic that is not historically consistent with this particular structure (freedman's cottage) or neighborhood fabric. I concur with the Preservation Society that these architectural details should be clearly drawn and specified prior to authorization to ensure alignment with the home’s historic character. We greatly appreciate the Board’s ongoing efforts to protect Charleston’s architectural heritage, particularly in Westside, where several years of less-restricted development have resulted in structures that do not always reflect the neighborhood’s historic scale and style. It appears that this proposal is attempting to align with original photographs, which we support. If possible, I would also appreciate clarification regarding the side porch, boarded and covered in the photos, and any additional photos that show that detail, specifically the original door placement and porch configuration. Those elements help inform an accurate understanding of the home’s historic design. That design, however, does look consistent with our Freedman's cottage style homes on this street. Thank you for your continued stewardship of Charleston’s unique architectural legacy. Respectfully, Sarah Spangler President, Westside Neighborhood Association • Preservation Society of Charleston Submitted to Staff See attached statement. 6. 17 Pinckney Street BAR2026-002379 | TMS# 458-05-03-024 | Council District 8 Category 4 | c. 1870 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for exterior restoration, access deck, and shade structure. Owner: 14 Anson LLC Applicant: Dan Sweeney No Comments Submitted 7. 105 King Street BAR2026-002371 | TMS# 457-12-04-055 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1945 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for second-story addition and fenestration changes. Owner: Harrison Malpass Applicant: Coastal Creek Design No Comments Submitted Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | February 26, 2026 Page 5 8. 32 Charlotte Street BAR2026-002380 | TMS# 459-13-01-100 | Garden District | Council District 4 Category 2 | c. 1820 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for rear addition. Owner: 32 Charlotte St, LLC Applicant: G.M. Wallace, Jr. Architect 4 Comments Submitted: • Letters of Support Submitted to Staff See attached. • William Goodale • David Gross and Victoria Hanham • Arthur Hoey • Preservation Society of Charleston Submitted to Staff See attached statement. 9. 28 Montagu Street BAR2026-002382 | TMS# 457-03-02-048 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Category 3 | c. 1809 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for new two-story pool house. Owner: John and Marcie Crowe Applicant: Brian Crouch Architect No Comments Submitted 10. 145 South Battery Street BAR2026-002395 | TMS# 457-11-01-019 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 1927 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for enclosed lift at rear. Owner: Jack Cleland Applicant: Sebastian von Marshall 4 Comments Submitted: • Letters of Support Submitted to Staff See attached. • 146 S. Battery • 148 S. Battery • 149 S. Battery • 100 Murray Blvd. Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | February 26, 2026 Page 6 11. 86 South Battery Street BAR2026-002375 | TMS# 457-11-02-035 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 1911 | Old & Historic District Requesting final approval for detail revisions to new construction plans for accessory building. Owner: Meredith and Sam Turner Applicant: Julia F. Martin Architects No Comments Submitted 12. 40 Broad Street BAR2026-002376 | TMS# 458-09-03-037 | French Quarter | Council District 8 Category 2 | c. 1891 | Old & Historic District Requesting final approval from new storefront awnings. Owner: Mike Shuler Applicant: Julia F. Martin Architects No Comments Submitted 13. 19 Ashley Avenue BAR2026-002381 | TMS# 457-07-04-042 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 1975 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for shutters and awning over front door. Owner: Ashley Severance Applicant: Scott Parker No Comments Submitted 14. 135 Ashley Avenue BAR2026-002388 | TMS# 457-03-01-011 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1900 | Old & Historic District Requesting appeal of after-the-fact staff denial for vinyl windows. Owner: Tanya Tinajero Applicant: Tanya Tinajero 4 Comments Submitted: • Anthony Bartelme, 2 Halsey Street Submitted to Innovate Site on Feb. 19, 2026 8:14 AM Good morning, we live next to 135 Ashley Avenue on Halsey Street and support the B.A.R.'s staff denial of the owner's intention to replace existing wood frame windows with vinyl iterations. It's unfortunate that the owner began the project without seeking B.A.R. approval, however that corner property is a very visible one that sets the tone for the historic neighborhoods to the south. Its bones should be preserved according to the city's longstanding standards. Thank you for this opportunity to comment. • Donald Lesher, 133 Ashley Avenue Submitted to Innovate Site on Feb. 23, 2026 9:11 AM Several years ago I decided to address the windows in my 1910 house located on Ashley Ave that had either rotted, become racked or were out of square due to settlement of the house. One of my children occupied the house at the time while my permanent residence remained out of town. I contacted Muhler for consultation on the matter and the sales representative recommended vinyl window replacements as the cheapest and most effective solution. He added that I would need B.A.R. approval to Board of Architectural Review – Small Public Comment | February 26, 2026 Page 7 use vinyl replacements. Being an out-of-town owner similar to Dr. Montenegro and his wife Ms. Tinajero, I was not aware of this requirement. A team of three members of the B.A.R. came to the house to review my project and, as was expected by the Muhler rep, denied my application for vinyl windows and instead gave me a list of people who could repair or replace my windows with architecturally similar wooden windows. This was later accomplished when the house underwent an 8 month renovation prior to my wife and I becoming permanent residents in 2023. The vinyl windows would have cost me around $8000 for purchase and installation. The repair and replacement costs for architecturally similar wooden windows came to around $14,500. While I am giving Dr. Montenegro and his wife an understanding for not knowing about B.A.R. codes and requirements, I am opposed to allowing any exceptions to those codes and requirements. The requirements that are in place and enforced on permanent residents should be the same codes and requirements that are enforced for commercial rental property owners. It will be more expensive and perhaps there is an opportunity for Dr. Montenegro and his wife to recoup some of their loss from whoever sold and installed the windows and should have informed them of the need for B.A.R. approval. In summary, I support the B.A.R. denial for after-the fact denial for vinyl windows. We have a unique and beautiful city, and as a fairly new permanent resident, I fully support the efforts of the B.A.R. to maintain our beautiful surroundings and protect our architectural heritage. • Preservation Society of Charleston Submitted to Staff See attached statement. • Historic Charleston Foundation Submitted to Staff See attached statement. 15. 115 Smith Street BAR2026-002389 | TMS# 460-15-04-041 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 1968 | Old & Historic District Requesting final approval for Andersen Fibrex windows. Owner: Andrew Demos Applicant: Harborview Windows and Doors No Comments Submitted 16. Update to Architecture Inventory No Comments Submitted CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL 35 Nunan Street BAR2026-002373 | TMS# 460-07-04-171 | Westside | Council District 6 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1935 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting after-the-fact approval for demolition and approval for demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way. Owner: Legacy 28 Enterprises Inc. Applicant: Roy Reeves Site visit on 02/26/2026 at 8:30 a.m. Position Statement Board of Architectural Review – Small February 26, 2026 35 Nunan Street Dear Board Members, The Preservation Society of Charleston is opposed to this after-the-fact request for alterations to what appear to be historic, character-defining features. This submittal was difficult to understand as it did not provide adequate information or photographs showing the previously existing or current condition of the property. Clearer information regarding work undertaken without approval, and what is now being proposed is needed before this application can move forward. However, based on our staff’s observation, there appear to have been inappropriate, unapproved alterations to the windows, including the unique diamond shaped windows on the east elevation. We ask this applicant to return with a complete submittal that clearly outlines the nature of this after-the-fact request and for the Board to require that character-defining features be restored to their original configuration. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely, Flannery Antinoro Preservation Specialist CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL 66 Cypress Street BAR2026-002384 | TMS# 463-12-01-073 | North Central | Council District 4 Category 4 (Group 1) | c. 1938 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting amendment to previous demolition approval. Owner: Mae Huber McAlary Applicant: Loyal Architects – Ross Ritchie Previous site visit on 8/28/2025 p. Joe & Mae McAlary 66 Cypress St, Charleston, SC 29403 Monday, 6/2/2025 Dear Neighbors, We are respectfully requesting support from our neighbors regarding a home renovation project at our home located at 66 Cypress Street. We are seeking approval from the City of Charleston to expand our home in order to accommodate our growing family. We have lived in our home for over five years and have proudly called Charleston our home for over 13 years. Our family includes our 15-month-old daughter, and we are planning to have more children in the near future. As our family's needs grow, we hope to remain in the neighborhood we love by thoughtfully renovating our two-bedroom house to add additional bedrooms and living space. Our intention is to maintain the character of the neighborhood and ensure our home continues to be a positive part of our community. We are committed to completing the project with care and consideration for our neighbors and surroundings, and we want to give everyone the opportunity to share their thoughts. We are grateful for the support and encouragement, and we are gathering signed letters of support to submit as part of our application to the city, if you are in favor of our project and would like to show your support, please sign below. Thank you for being such wonderful neighbors and for your support as we take this next step for our family! Sincerely, Joe & Mae McAlary Neighbor Signature of Support Name: /JOco Ar'?'"0 Address: Signature: Date; _ Loyalarchitects i Letters of Support - 56 Cypress Street A.2 8.14.2025 SCALE: N/A The drawings and design are the pqopertv of Loyal Architects LLC and shall be used for the project for which they are prepared. All rights reserved. The reproduction or use of this drawing or the design here on without THE written consent OF THE ARCHITECT IS PROHIBITED. Joe & Mae McAlary 66 Cypress St, Charleston, SC 29403 Monday, 6/2/2025 Dear Neighbors, We are respectfully requesting support from our neighbors regarding a home renovation project at our home located at 66 Cypress Street. We are seeking approval from the City of Charleston to expand our home in order to accommodate our growing family. We have lived in our home for over five years and have proudly called Charleston our home forever 13 years. Ourfamily includes our 15-month-old daughter, and we are planning to have more children in the near future. As our family's needs grow, we hope to remain in the neighborhood we love by thoughtfully renovating our two-bedroom house to add additional bedrooms and living space. Our intention is to maintain the character of the neighborhood and ensure our home continues to be a positive part of our community. We are committed to completing the project with care and consideration for our neighbors and surroundings, and we want to give everyone the opportunity to share their thoughts. We are grateful for the support and encouragement, and we are gathering signed letters of support to submit as part of our application to the city. If you are in favor of our project andwould like to show your support, please sign below. ~ I"::™,? Sincerely, Joe & Mae McAlary , Neighbor Signature of Support Signature:. Date:_ Loyalarchitects ^ Letters of Support - 58 Cypress Street A.3 8.14.2025 SCALE: N/A The drawings and design are the property op Loyal Architects LLC and shall be used for the project for which they are prepared. All rights reserved. The reproduction or use of this drawing or the design here on without THE written consent OF THE ARCHITECT IS PROHIBITED. Joe & Mae McAlary 66 Cypress St, Charleston, SC 29403 Monday, 6/2/2025 Dear Neighbors, We are respectfully requesting support from our neighbors regarding a home renovation project at our home located at 66 Cypress Street. We are seeking approval from the City of Charleston to expand our home in order to accommodate our growing family. We have lived in our home for over five years and have proudly called Charleston our home for over 13 years. Our family includes our 15-month-old daughter, and we are planning to have more children in the near future. As our family's needs grow, we hope to remain in the neighborhood we love by thoughtfully renovating our two-bedroom house to add additional bedrooms and living space. Our intention is to maintain the character of the neighborhood and ensure our home continues to be a positive part of our community. We are committed to completing the project with care and consideration for our neighbors and surroundings, and we want to give everyone the opportunity to share their thoughts. We are grateful for the support and encouragement, and we are gathering signed letters of support to submit as part of our application to the city, if you are in favor of our project and would like to show your support, please sign below. Thank you for being such wonderful neighbors and for your support as we take this next step for our family! Sincerely, Joe & Mae McAlary | Neighbor Signature of Supportsignature of Support SName:_ Address; fieJk a^7ac VisntYli Signature: Date: 7/23/^^ Loyalarchitects Letters of Support - 59 Cypress Street A.7 8.14.2025 SCALE; N/A The drawings and design are the property op Loyal Architects LLC and shall be used for the project for which they are prepared. All rights reserved. The reproduction or use of this drawing or the design here on without THE written consent OF THE ARCHITECT IS PROHIBITED. 'M Joe & Mae McAlary 66 Cypress St, Charleston, SC 29403 Monday, 6/2/2025 Dear Neighbors, We are respectfully requesting support from our neighbors regarding a home renovation project at our home located at 66 Cypress Street. We are seeking approval from the City of Charleston to expand our home in order to accommodate our growing family. We have lived in our home for over five years and have proudly called Charleston our home for over 13 years. Our family includes our 15-month-old daughter, and we are planning to have more children in the near future. As our family's needs grow, we hope to remain in the neighborhood we love by thoughtfully renovating our two-bedroom house to add additional bedrooms and living space. Our intention is to maintain the character of the neighborhood and ensure our home continues to be a positive part of our community. We are committed to completing the project with care and consideration for our neighbors and surroundings, and we want to give everyone the opportunity to share their thoughts. We are grateful for the support and encouragement, and we are gathering signed letters of support to submit as part of our application to the city. If you are in favor of our project and would like to show your support, please sign below. Thank you for being such wonderful neighbors and for your support as we take this next step for our family! Sincerely, Joe & Mae McAlary " " Neighbor^ignature of Supporti Name: Address: Date: Loyalarchitects Letters of Support - 64 Cypress Street A.4 8.14.2025 SCALE; N/A The drawings and design are the property of Loyal Architects LLC and shall be used for the project for which they are prepared. All rights reserved. The reproduction or use of this drawing or the design here on without THE written consent OF THE ARCHITECT IS PROHIBITED. Joe & Mae McAlary 66 Cypress St, Charleston, SC 29403 Monday, 6/2/2025 Dear Neighbors, We are respectfully requesting support from our neighbors regarding a home renovation project at our home located at 66 Cypress Street. We are seeking approval from the City of Charleston to expand our home in order to accommodate our growing family. We have lived in our home for over five years and have proudly called Charleston our home for over 13 years. Our family includes our 15-month-old daughter, and we are planning to have more children in the near future. As our family's needs grow, we hope to remain in the neighborhood we love by thoughtfully renovating our two-bedroom house to add additional bedrooms and living space. Our intention is to maintain the character of the neighborhood and ensure our home continues to be a positive part of our community. We are comrnitted to completing the project with care and consideration for our neighbors and surroundings, and we want to give everyone the opportunity to share their thoughts. We are grateful for the support and encouragement, and we are gathering signed letters of support to submit as part of our application to the city. If you are in favor of our project and would like to show your support, please sign below. Thank you for being such wonderful neighbors and for your support as we take this next step for our family! Sincerely, Joe & Mae McAlary | - Neighbor Signature of Support Name: C. CAddress:. Signature: Date: ^ ^ ^ Loyalarchitects Letters of Support - 68 Cypress Street A.5 8.14.2025 SCALE; N/A The drawings and design ape the property of Loyal Architects LLC and shall be used for the project for which they are prepared. All rights reserved. The reproduction or use of this drawing or the design here on without THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE ARCHITECT IS PROHIBITED. Joe & Mae McAlary 66 Cypress St, Charteston. SC 29403 Monday, 6/2/2025 Dear Neighbors, We are respectfully requesting support from ourneighbors regarding a home r ^ project at our home located at 66 Cypress Street. We are seeking approval from t e y Charleston to expand our home In order to accommodate our growing family. We have lived in our home for over five years and have proudly called Charleston our home for over 13 years. Our family Includes our 15-month-old daughter, and we are planning to have more children in the near future. As our family's needs grow, we hope to remain In the neighborhood we love by thoughtfully renovating our two-bedroom house to add additional bedrooms and living space. Our intention is to maintain the character of the neighborhood and ensure our home continues to be a positive part of our community. We are committed to completing the project with care and consideration for our neighbors and surroundings, and we want to give everyone the opportunity to share their thoughts. We are grateful for the support and encouragement, and we are gathering signed letters of support to submit as part of our application to the city. If you are in favor of our project and would like to show your support, please sign below. Thank you tor being such wonderful neighbors and for your support as we take this next step for our family! Sincerely, Joe & Mae McAlary I Neighbor Signature of Support •-> a in m iKinJ We-jName:. Address: Signature: Date: ^ /lO'XS Loyalarchitects Letters of Support - 69 Cypress Street A.9 8.14.2025 SCALE: N/A The drawings and design are the property of Loyal Architects LLC and shall be used for the project for which they are prepared. All rights reserved. The reproduction or use of this drawing or the design here on without THE written consent OF THE ARCHITECT IS PROHIBITED. Joe & Mae McAlary 66 Cypress St. Charleslon, SO 29403 Monday, 6/2/2025 Dear Neighbors, We are respectfully requesting support from our neighbors regarding a home renovation project at our home located at 66 Cypress Street. We are seeking approval from the City o Charleston to expand our home in order to accommodate our growing family. We have lived in our home tor over five years and have proudly called Charleston our home for over 13 years. Our family includes our 15-month-old daughter, and we are planning to have more children in the near future. As our family's needs grow, we hope to remain in the neighborhood we love by thoughtfully renovating our two-bedroom house to add additional bedrooms and living space. Our intention is to maintain the character of the neighborhood and ensure our home continues to be a positive part of our community. We are committed to completing the project with care and consideration for our neighbors and surroundings, and we want to give everyone the opportunity to share their thoughts. We are grateful for the support and encouragement, and we are gathering signed letters of support to submit as part of our application to the city. If you are in favor of our project and would like to show your support, please sign below. Thank you for being such wonderful neighbors and tor your support as we take this next step for our family! Sincerely, Joe & f-lae McAlary f Neighbor Signature of Support Name: re of Support Address: Signature Loyalarchitects Letters of Support - 85 Cypress Street A.s 8.14.2025 SCALE: N/A The drawings and design are the property op Loyal Architects LLC and shall be used fob the project for which they are prepared. All rights reserved. The reproduction or use of this drawing or the design here on without THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE ARCHITECT IS PROHIBITED. Joo&MaeMcAtary 66 Cypress St, Charleston. SC 29403 Monday. 6/2/2025 Dear Neighbors. We are respectfully requesting support from our neighbors regarding a home renovation project at our home located at 66 Cypress Street. We are seeking approval from the City of Charleston to expand our home in order to accommodate our growing family. We have lived in our home for over five years and have proudly called Charleston our home for over 13 years. Our family Includes our 15-month-old daughter, and we are planning to have more children in the near future. As our family's needs grow, we hope to remain in the neighborhood we love by thoughtfully renovating our two-bedroom house to add additional bedrooms and living space. Our intention is to maintain the character of the neighborhood and ensure our home continues to be a positive part of our community. We are committed to completing the project with care and consideration for our neighbors and surroundings, and we want to give everyone the opportunity to share their thoughts. We are grateful for the support and encouragement, and we are gathering signed letters of support to submit as part of our application to the city, if you are in favor of our project and would like to show your support, ptease sign below. Thank you for being such wonderful neighbors and for your support as we take this next step for our family! Sincerely, Joe & Mae McAlary ~ " Neighbor Signature of Support Name; A Address; Signature; r'Tg- ; OS /ai /.X.OisDate; Loyalarchitects Letters of Support - 29 Peachtree Street A.n 8.14.2025 SCALE; N/A The drawings and design are the property of Loyal Architects LLC and shall be used for the project for which thev are prepared. All rights reseryed. The reproduction or use of this drawing or the design here on without THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE ARCHITECT IS PROHIBITED. Joe & Mae McAlary 66 Cypress St, Charleston, SC 29403 Monday, 6/2/2025 Dear Neighbors, We are respectfully requesting support from our neighbors regarding a home renovation project at our home located at 66 Cypress Street. We are seeking approval from the City of Charleston to expand our home in order to accommodate our growing family. We have lived in our home for over five years and have proudly called Charleston our home for over 13 years. Our family includes our 15-month-old daughter, and we are planning to have more children in the near future. As our family's needs grow, we hope to remain in the neighborhood we love by thoughtfully renovating our two-bedroom house to add additional bedrooms and living space. Our intention is to maintain the character of the neighborhood and ensure our home continues to be a positive part of our community. We are committed to completing the project with care and consideration for our neighbors and surroundings, and we want to give everyone the opportunity to share their thoughts. We are grateful for the support and encouragement, and we are gathering signed letters of support to submit as part of our application to the city. If you are in favor of our project and would like to show your support, please sign below. Thank you for being such wonderful neighbors and for your support as we take this next step for our family! Sincerely. Joe & Mae McAlati Neighbor Signature of Support Name; Address: ' ' ' 12.Signature; „ Loyalarchitects Letters of Support - 40 Peachtree Street A.i 8.14.2025 SCALE: N/A The drawings and design are the property of Loyal Architects LLC and shall be used for the project for which they are prepared. All rights reserved. The reproduction or use of this drawing or the design here on without THE written consent OF THE ARCHITECT IS PROHIBITED. Joe & Mae McAlary 66 Cypress St. Charteston. SC 29403 Monday, 6/2/2025 Dear Neighbors, We are respectfully requesting support from our neighbors regarding a home reno project at our home located at 66 Cypress Street. We are seeking approval from the C y Charleston to expand our home In order to accommodate our growing family. We have lived in our home for over five years and have proudly called Charleston our home tor over 13 years. Our family includes our 15-month-old daughter, and we are planning to have more children in the near future. As our family's needs grow, we hope to remain in the neighborhood we love by thoughtfully renovating our two-bedroom house to add additional bedrooms and living space. Our intention is to maintain the character of the neighborhood and ensure our home continues to be a positive part of our community. We are committed to completing the project with care and consideration for our neighbors and surroundings, and we want to give everyone the opportunity to share their thoughts. We are grateful for the support and encouragement, and we are gathering signed letters of support to submit as part of our application to the city, if you are in favor of our project and would like to show your support, please sign below. Thank you for being such wonderful neighbors and for your support as we take this next step for our family! Sincerely. Joe & Mae McAlary .. _ Neighbor Signature of Support Name: /\j | C VV « [ [ tV,]/0A C Address: Joh ^ ' Signature; ^ ^ Date: '7-j Z-t Loyalarchitects *«ww Letters of Support - 66 Maple Street A.io 8.14.2025 SCALE; N/A The drawings and design ace the pcooectv op Loyal Architects LLC and shall be used fob the project for which they are prepared. All rights reserved. The reproduction or use of this drawing or the design here on without THE written consent OF THE ARCHITECT IS PROHIBITED. Joe & Mae McAlary 66 Cypress St, Charleston. SC 29403 Monday, 6/2/2025 Dear Neighbors, We are respectfully requesting support from our neighbors regarding a home renovation project at our home located at 66 Cypress Street. We are seeking approval from the City of Charleston to expand our home in order to accommodate our growing family. We have lived in our home for over five years and have proudly called Charleston our home for over 13 years. Our family includes our 15-month-old daughter, and we are planning to have more children in the near future. As our family's needs grow, we hope to remain in the neighborhood we love by thoughtfully renovating our two-bedroom house to add additional bedrooms and living space. Our intention is to maintain the character of the neighborhood and ensure our home continues to be a positive part of our community. We are committed to completing the project with care and consideration for our neighbors and surroundings, and we want to give everyone the opportunity to share their thoughts. We are grateful for the support and encouragement, and we are gathering signed letters of support to submit as part of our application to the city. If you are in favor of our project and would like to show your support, please sign below. Thank you for being such wonderful neighbors and for your support as we take this next step for our family! Sincerely, Joe & Mae McAlary Neighbor Signature of Support Name: Address; 1^^ A/\ <71 giTlol 1 d 3 : J o^/2-5 Loyalarchitects Letters of Support - los Magnolia Avenue A.6 8.14.2025 SCALE: N/A The DRAWINGS and design are the propertvof Loyal Architects LLC and shall be used fop the project for which they are prepared. All rights reserved. The reproduction or use of this drawing or the design here on without THE written consent OF THE ARCHITECT IS PROHIBITED. CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL 190 Line Street BAR2026-002374 | TMS# 460-07-04-141 | Westside | Council District 6 Not Surveyed | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for reconstruction of previous structure per Board motion. Owner: MFI Applicant: Trey Brown Position Statement Board of Architectural Review – Small February 26, 2026 190 Line Street Dear Board Members, The Board’s November 2024 denial of after-the-fact demolition of 190 Line Street was conditioned with a requirement to rebuild the structure “exactly as it was, retaining original material.” This proposal requires continued study to ensure original details are faithfully replicated in compliance with this condition. The Preservation Society of Charleston asks the Board to defer this application based on the following areas that should be addressed prior to the next submittal. 1) This submittal has numerous drawing errors that need to be corrected and should include as-built drawings or plans that were referenced to inform the proposed reconstruction. 2) The previously existing historic chimney is missing from the drawings and must be reconstructed as part of this proposal. 3) The proposed front steps should be masonry to be consistent with the masonry foundation. The proposed wooden steps are inconsistent with the urban character of the neighborhood. 4) Lastly, we ask for clarification on whether any salvaged historic material is available for reuse as part of this reconstruction. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely, Flannery Antinoro Preservation Specialist CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL 32 Charlotte Street BAR2026-002380 | TMS# 459-13-01-100 | Garden District | Council District 4 Category 2 | c. 1820 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for rear addition. Owner: 32 Charlotte St, LLC Applicant: G.M. Wallace, Jr. Architect William Goodale 37 Chapel St Charleston, SC 29403 January 9th, 2026 Board of Architectural Review City of Charleston Department of Planning, Preservation & Sustainability Re: Approval and Support for Proposed Backyard Improvements at 32 Charlotte Street Dear Members of the Board of Architectural Review, I am the owner of 37 Chapel St which backs up to the property located at 32 Charlotte Street, Charleston, South Carolina. I am writing to formally express my approval and support for the proposed backyard plans submitted for this property. From what I have seen the proposed changes are designed to respect the historic character of the property and the surrounding neighborhood. I have no objections to the proposed changes and believe the improvements will enhance the property while preserving its architectural integrity. Please feel free to contact me using the below email if you require any additional information or clarification. Sincerely, William Goodale David Gross and Victoria Hanham 27 Charlotte Street Charleston, South Carolina 29403 January 10th, 2026 Board of Architectural Review City of Charleston Dear Members of the Board, Having reviewed the plans, we feel assured that the proposed work is thoughtfully designed and fully in keeping with the historic character of this wonderful house and the surrounding neighborhood. The plans appear sensitive to scale, materials, and architectural integrity, and we are confident that the project will be executed to a very high standard. Please do not hesitate to contact us should you have any questions or require any additional information. Yours sincerely, David Gross Victoria Hanham  GBC G G G  G GG   GBC 2 G G G GBC   C 3R  CS         Outlook Fwd: 32 Charlotte Street House Renovation and Garden Enhancement From Robin Gramling Date Thu 1/15/2026 12:32 PM To Kelly Ludwig; Skip Wallace; Ben Gramling glen; Martin Gramling; erika ---------- Forwarded message --------- From: Arthur Hoey Date: Thu, Jan 15, 2026 at 9:11 AM Subject: 32 Charlotte Street House Renovation and Garden Enhancement To: Robin Gramling, Ferrell, Kathleen Robin and Ben. Thanks for sharing plans for your house renovation. --------------------------------------------------- To: Members of the Charleston BAR Re: 32 Charlotte Street House Renovation and Garden Enhancement My wife, Kathleen Ferrell, and I live immediately west of the Gramlings at 36 Charlotte Street. We have reviewed their design for the minor house renovations and fully support their plans. We also support the associated hardscape related to the addition and the new hardscape planned for the rear yard and garden. The proposed changes will only further enhance the attractiveness of the property and neighborhood. Regards, Arthur Hoey -- Arthur HOEY January 8, 2026 Kemp and Daphne Lewis 29 Charlotte Street Charleston, SC 29403 We have lived at 29 Charlotte Street, across the street from the Gramlings, since 2020 when we purchased our home. We heartily endorse the proposed renovations at 32 Charlotte Street. The proposed changes are beautiful and harmonious with the existing buildings. They will be a wonderful addition to the home and to the neighborhood. We urge you to approve the proposed renovations to 32 Charlotte Street. Position Statement Board of Architectural Review – Small February 26, 2026 32 Charlotte Street Dear Board Members, The Preservation Society of Charleston appreciates the applicant reaching out to us and for taking our feedback into consideration. While the impact on the existing addition has been reduced , the proposed addition still diminishes the hyphen effect between the historic house and the dependency , especially on the west elevation. This Category 2 building has undergone numerous alterations over time, and the addition would further complicate already-complex massing and detract from the ability to read the evolution of the house, regardless of visibility. We encourage simplification of the proposed massing to preserve a legible hyphen, historic openings, and as much historic material as possible. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely, Flannery Antinoro Preservation Specialist CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL 145 South Battery Street BAR2026-002395 | TMS# 457-11-01-019 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 1927 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for enclosed lift at rear. Owner: Jack Cleland Applicant: Sebastian von Marshall Sebastian von Marschall Fwd: Sign in our yard about a BAR meeting Sun, Feb 22, 2026 at 8:16 PMJack Cleland To: Sebastian von Marschall And the response below just came in from Scott Hayes, across the street at 146 S Battery. ---------- Forwarded message --------- From: Scott Hayes Date: Sun, Feb 22, 2026 at 8:08 PM Subject: Re: Sign in our yard about a BAR meeting Thank you for letting us know Love the idea Scott D Hayes On Sat, Feb 21, 2026 at 1:22 PM Julia Buthman wrote: Thanks for the heads up! Sounds great! Julia & Ken On Feb 21, 2026, at 11:02 AM, Jack Cleland wrote: To our neighbor friends, we want to explain the sign in front of our house giving notice of a BAR-Small meeting to discuss a proposed “lift” at our house. We didn’t realize that this sign would appear so quickly, and we did not intend to surprise (or mystify) any of you with the sign. To summarize the background: 1. When we moved into our house in 2019, we noted that, from the roof over our kitchen, there’s a great view of the river, the Battery, etc. So, in 2020, we changed a bedroom window, thinking that we'd access the roof through that window. We also proposed to put a deck surface on that roof, which was approved, but we never followed through to convert the roof surface to a usable deck. 3. In the meantime, we realized (with COVID, my broken femur, life, guests, etc.): a. that access to the roof, through the interior bedroom window, was difficult and would be rarely used; and b. that a “lift” – basically a wheelchair lift that travels up one story – would allow access to the roof for folks of all abilities. 4. So, we’re now proposing to follow through with the idea of the (previously approved) deck. We also propose to install a lift to get from our backyard to the deck. More info on the lift itself is below. This lift will be enclosed in a wooden façade/structure that will try to make it blend seamlessly into the existing wall of the kitchen. The concept is to build a covering around the lift to “camouflage” it so that it looks like part of the existing kitchen. The combined lift/façade/deck concept is going to be presented at the BAR-Small meeting. If you have any concerns or questions about this concept, we’d like to try to respond to them. You can reach me or Mary. About the lift itself: We plan to install a RAM Flex Lift, which is shown in the picture below and is further explained at https://trustram.com/residential/residential-flex-li t/ . The proposed platform size is 36” (3 ft) x 54” (4.5 ft). The manufacturer advertises that the lift has an “All-Electric Drive System” which is “whisper-quiet”, has “no hydraulic fluid”, and thus has “no harsh smells”. <image.png> [Quoted text hidden] -- Jack Cleland Sebastian von Marschall Fwd: Sign in our yard about a BAR meeting Sun, Feb 22, 2026 at 7:33 PMJack Cleland To: Sebastian von Marschall This is from a neighbor across the street, in the duplex at 148 S Battery. ---------- Forwarded message --------- From: Sandy Christian Date: Sat, Feb 21, 2026 at 12:01 PM Subject: Re: Sign in our yard about a BAR meeting To: Jack Cleland Sounds awesome! Great idea Sandy Christian On Sat, Feb 21, 2026 at 11:02 AM Jack Cleland wrote: T o our neighbor friends, we want to explain the sign in front of our house giving notice of a BAR-Small meeting to discuss a proposed “lift” at our house. We didn’t realize that this sign would appear so quickly, and we did not intend to surprise (or mystify) any of you with the sign. To summarize the background: 1. When we moved into our house in 2019, we noted that, from the roof over our kitchen, there’s a great view of the river, the Battery, etc. So, in 2020, we changed a bedroom window, thinking that we'd access the roof through that window. We also proposed to put a deck surface on that roof, which was approved, but we never followed through to convert the roof surface to a usable deck. 3. In the meantime, we realized (with COVID, my broken femur, life, guests, etc.): a. that access to the roof, through the interior bedroom window, was difficult and would be rarely used; and b. that a “lift” – basically a wheelchair lift that travels up one story – would allow access to the roof for folks of all abilities. 4. So, we’re now proposing to follow through with the idea of the (previously approved) deck. We also propose to install a lift to get from our backyard to the deck. More info on the lift itself is below. This lift will be enclosed in a wooden façade/structure that will try to make it blend seamlessly into the existing wall of the kitchen. The concept is to build a covering around the lift to “camouflage” it so that it looks like part of the existing kitchen. The combined lift/façade/deck concept is going to be presented at the BAR-Small meeting. If you have any concerns or questions about this concept, we’d like to try to respond to them. You can reach me at or Mary. About the lift itself: We plan to install a RAM Flex Lift, which is shown in the picture below and is further explained at https://trustram.com/residential/residential-flex-lift/ . The proposed platform size is 36” (3 ft) x 54” (4.5 ft). The manufacturer advertises that the lift has an “All-Electric Drive System” which is “whisper-quiet”, has “no hydraulic fluid”, and thus has “no harsh smells”. -- Jack Cleland -- Jack Cleland Sebastian von Marschall Fwd: Sign in our yard about a BAR meeting Sun, Feb 22, 2026 at 7:32 PMJack Cleland To: Sebastian von Marschall This is from our neighbor to the west, at 149 S Battery. ---------- Forwarded message --------- From: Julia Buthman Date: Sat, Feb 21, 2026 at 1:22 PM Subject: Re: Sign in our yard about a BAR meeting To: Cleland Jack Thanks for the heads up! Sounds great! Julia & Ken [Quoted text hidden] -- Jack Cleland Sebastian von Marschall Fwd: Sign in our yard about a BAR meeting Sun, Feb 22, 2026 at 7:35 PMJack Cleland To: Sebastian von Marschall This is from a neighbor on Murray -- not directly behind us but next to a house directly behind us. ---------- Forwarded message --------- From: Constance Anastopoulo Date: Sat, Feb 21, 2026 at 11:06 AM Subject: Re: Sign in our yard about a BAR meeting To: Jack Cleland Jack & Mary, Sounds like a great idea for access. Thanks for the info, but it’s your house…proceed as you wish!😉 Constance Constance A. Anastopoulo [Quoted text hidden] -- Jack Cleland CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL 135 Ashley Avenue BAR2026-002388 | TMS# 457-03-01-011 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1900 | Old & Historic District Requesting appeal of after-the-fact staff denial for vinyl windows. Owner: Tanya Tinajero Applicant: Tanya Tinajero Position Statement Board of Architectural Review – Small February 26, 2026 135 Ashley Avenue Dear Board Members, The Preservation Society of Charleston is not supportive of this after-the-fact request. Per the Secretary of the Interior Standards, replacement should only be pursued for material that truly cannot be repaired, and vinyl is not an appropriate replacement material in the Old and Historic District. We ask that this application be denied and encourage the Board to require that any historic windows remaining on site be re-installed, and that any replacement windows be authentic, wood, true divided lites. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely, Flannery Antinoro Preservation Specialist Post Office Box 1120 ∙ Charleston, SC 29402 ∙ (843) 723-1623 ∙ Fax (843) 577-2067 ∙ www.historiccharleston.org To: Members of the Board of Architectural Review-Small From: Kate Dutilly, Preservation Planner Date: February 26, 2026 Re: 135 Ashley Avenue Historic Charleston Foundation has reviewed the appeal of the staff decision concerning the window replacement at 135 Ashley Avenue. Windows are a character-defining feature of historic structures and are integral to preserving their architectural character. Preservation best practices emphasize that original windows should be repaired whenever possible and, when replacement is necessary, replaced in kind to match the original material. Vinyl is not an appropriate replacement material for a historic property of this significance. Therefore, Historic Charleston Foundation respectfully requests that the staff decision be upheld.

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.