RecordWell Data

_03192026-2144

Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Mar 19, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TREE TASK FORCE Thursday, March 19, 2026 8:00 a.m. Municipal Complex, Committee Meeting Room 100 Ann Edwards Lane, Mount Pleasant, SC 29464 MINUTES Click here to listen to the recording. Discussion Topics 1. Call to order Chair McKee called the meeting to order at 8:00 a.m. Shanna Harris, David Quick, Michelle Mansour, George Grice and Deidre Kennedy were all present. Edward Oswald arrived at 8:02 a.m. (after vote on approval of agenda and minutes). 2. Approval of Agenda A motion was made to approve the agenda by Mr. Quick and seconded by Ms. Mansour. All present voted in favor. 3. Approval of minutes from February 19, 2026 meeting A motion was made by Mr. Quick to approve the minutes and seconded by Ms. Mansour. All present voted in favor. 4. Public Comment Mike Tinkey, Mount Pleasant Town Council Member, expressed excitement about the town having resources to develop a community forest master plan, a tree task force, ordinances, and other items to protect reserves and enhance future planning. Council Member Tinkey emphasized the importance of planning for the future and recommended putting some trees in the ground on a pilot basis to demonstrate the work being done and develop a management plan for planting. Council Member Tinkey specifically recommended looking at the goal of one thousand trees as a net one thousand, explaining that when considering trees going down in parks and other areas, the town starts with a significant net deficit. He stressed the importance of looking at net planting rather than gross numbers. He encouraged the development of a management plan that could determine planting strategies, whether for forestry, replenishing, harvesting for production, or conservation recreation purposes, which essentially describes urban forestry planning. Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 2 of 20 Council Member Tinkey urged the task force to develop a plan and budget during the current budget season, ensuring they have the resources to implement their goals. He recommended that the management plan take into account ecology, hydrology, biology, history, and culture when developing the planting program. He noted that any forestry person understands that urban forestry planning is a twenty to twenty-five year plan, with specific area plans using inventory data to determine where to plant. Council Member Tinkey suggested starting in areas with twenty-five percent coverage and recommended beginning with public works areas because they control maintenance and planting of trees. He emphasized focusing on areas the town can control rather than state-controlled areas, particularly where there are tree deficits or needs. He concluded by expressing excitement about the task force's work and encouraging them to look at budget requirements, necessary staffing, and short-term goals planning. No other members of the public came forward to speak. 5. Review of February 19 meeting discussion • Take Root program is strong but there is an opportunity for reimagining and expansion with partnerships • Review opportunity for a program that supports planting trees on private property • Coordination between Take Root and Tree Bank grant program • Canopy Restoration represents opportunity for planting in public spaces • Staffing- need tree coordinator- oversight of the canopy program • Updated Purpose: Livability (shade), flood mitigation, habitat, economics, quality of life (noise), trees are shared resource Recap from February Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 3 of 20 Mr. Bob O'Neill provided a recap of the major points from the February meeting, focusing on programmatic elements. He summarized that the Take Root program was strong but had opportunities for re-imagining and expansion through partnerships. The group had discussed reviewing opportunities for programs supporting tree planting on private property and coordinating Take Root and tree bank grant programs. Mr. O'Neill noted they had discussed canopy restoration and staffing needs, particularly the significant discussion about a tree coordinator position and how to handle the staffing function. He mentioned they had updated the purpose statement to include livability, flood mitigation, habitat, economics, quality of life, and trees as a shared resource. All members confirmed this was an accurate summary. Chair McKee provided context for where they were in the overall work plan. He explained that the group had established an objective to grow the urban forest and defined a purpose statement explaining why this was important to communicate to residents. They had reviewed programs and determined that while the existing programs were good, they were not at the volume needed to drive the objective they had set. To achieve this, they identified the need for a leader to push the effort forward, as current staffing treated tree programs as only part of their jobs rather than their primary focus. Chair McKee noted that today's conversation would focus on budget requirements and partnerships needed to move forward. He indicated Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 4 of 20 that Christiane Farrell had prepared materials to help understand current financial resources and future needs. Deidre Kennedy interjected that she thought they had been discussing more than just a coordinator position, suggesting they had talked about having a forestry department rather than just a coordinator. Christiane Farrell confirmed this was discussed in their previous meeting and would be covered more thoroughly in the budget discussion. Chair McKee acknowledged they had discussed creating a department with people focused on natural resources, though no final decisions were made. He noted concerns that pulling resources out of existing departments and creating a separate department could slow some processes, but emphasized they had not ruled out this option. He reminded the group that the community forest master plan had suggested creating such a department. 6. Work Plan TTF 2026 Work Plan Funding and Partnership Opportunities Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 5 of 20 Dr. Kendra Stewart introduced a slide showing potential components for the final report to town council. She explained that they wanted to start thinking about the end product early rather than waiting until the last minute to determine who would write the report and what it would contain. The proposed components included goals and purpose, current program assessment, recommendations, budget and staffing, education Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 6 of 20 outreach and partnerships, regulations and ordinance updates, and implementation timeline. The task force discussed the format of the final deliverable, agreeing it should include both a written report and a PowerPoint presentation that could be delivered to council. Mr. Quick suggested that multiple members could contribute rough drafts of different sections, which could then be merged together similar to their previous collaborative approach with spreadsheets. Ms. Kennedy volunteered to serve as the primary editor, noting she had access to an excellent assistant. Mr. Quick volunteered to be part of a drafting subcommittee. Chair McKee also agreed to participate in the drafting process. The group decided that everyone would contribute ideas based on the outlined framework, with different members focusing on areas they felt passionate about. They established a timeline where a draft would be completed by the April meeting, allowing for review and discussion at the May meeting, with final edits completed by June. The group agreed this approach would provide adequate time for review and refinement before presenting to council. a) Revenue Sources/Grants Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 7 of 20 Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 8 of 20 Ms. Farrell presented an overview of current funding sources for tree programs. She explained that tree mitigation funds largely support the tree bank and canopy programs, while the general fund supports public services activities. The town also uses hospitality and infrastructure funds for undergrounding projects and actively pursues grants when available. Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 9 of 20 The current fiscal year twenty-six budget allocates sixty thousand dollars annually for the tree bank grant and Take Root program, and one hundred thousand dollars for canopy restoration. Undergrounding receives one hundred thousand dollars per year. All unused funds carry over to subsequent years, which has occurred frequently with the undergrounding program while waiting for the Mathis Ferry project to begin. Public services landscaping and maintenance, funded through the general fund rather than tree mitigation money, handles roadways and facilities landscaping through contracted services. This represents a significant portion of tree-related spending but operates separately from the tree mitigation fund. b) Use of funds (planting with town funds) Ms. Farrell presented detailed spending information showing current program utilization. The Take Root program spends approximately five thousand dollars annually, averaging fourteen hundred tree giveaways per year at roughly five dollars per tree when purchased, with some trees provided free of charge. Canopy restoration spending increased significantly in the previous year to just under sixty thousand dollars. The tree grant program, which the group had previously agreed needed improvement, had no activity in calendar year twenty-five. The undergrounding program finally began moving forward with Mathis Ferry after holding funds for an extended period. Chair McKee noted the importance of tracking tree numbers alongside financial expenditures to understand the return on investment. He observed that in twenty twenty-five, they achieved fifty-three trees through the canopy restoration program plus additional trees through other projects, spending one hundred seventeen thousand dollars total. Adding Take Root giveaways, they estimated planting approximately six hundred trees per year currently, falling short of their one thousand tree net goal. Discussion arose about whether Take Root recipients were Mount Pleasant residents and whether trees were actually planted and survived. Mr. Quick questioned if there was a way to ensure only Mount Pleasant residents received trees, suggesting requiring address verification or providing different tree sizes based on residency. Chris Lubert explained the practical challenges of verification during busy distribution events. Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 10 of 20 The group acknowledged these were implementation details that could be addressed by a dedicated tree coordinator rather than requiring task force resolution. They agreed the Take Root program was a good brand that could be reinvigorated with proper leadership and attention. c) Pay versus Plant Ms. Farrell presented revenue information showing planning permit fees bringing in twenty-two thousand dollars, planning mitigation fees at thirty-eight thousand dollars, and significantly higher EDS collections due to different enforcement mechanisms and timing of collection. She displayed examples of recent development projects showing tree gains and losses, including developments like Miller Cadillac where the town actually gained trees through redevelopment. Ms. Farrell noted that as most land becomes developed and the town sees more redevelopment opportunities, there is potential for tree gains, particularly through commercial properties that must meet the one hundred sixty inches per acre requirement. The presentation included Patriots Point and other major developments that could significantly impact tree numbers, both positively and negatively. Chair McKee emphasized the importance of tracking these projects to demonstrate the town's proactive planning for tree loss and replacement. Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 11 of 20 Discussion focused on the current requirement for homeowners to plant two and a half inch caliper trees as mitigation. Chris Lubert explained the significant challenges in enforcement, noting that ninety-five percent of tree mitigation cases involve extensive back-and-forth communications and arguments. He described the difficulty homeowners face in sourcing appropriate trees, the cost burden, and the lack of desire for large canopy trees due to future maintenance concerns. Mr. Lubert suggested that dropping the required tree size might improve compliance, though this would affect mitigation fee calculations since fees are based on replacement tree costs. The group discussed various approaches to improving the mitigation process, including better education, simplified planting plans, and potential policy changes. Ms. Farrell stated an analysis showed seven hundred forty-two outstanding inches of required mitigation from existing structure permits, equating to approximately one hundred six thousand dollars in potential revenue. The group agreed to defer detailed discussion of enforcement improvements to future ordinance discussions while capturing the general challenges and potential solutions. d) Hardship situations Ms. Farrell briefly presented the concept of establishing a hardship program for mitigation requirements, noting they had encountered situations where the financial burden created genuine hardship for Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 12 of 20 property owners. The group agreed to include this topic in future ordinance discussions rather than addressing it in detail during the budget session. e) Tree grant program The tree grant program was noted as having no activity in the previous calendar year and was identified as needing significant improvement. The group had previously agreed this program required attention but did not delve into specifics during the budget discussion. f) Staffing and operational requirements (including staffing numbers and inventory of equipment) Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 13 of 20 Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 14 of 20 Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 15 of 20 Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 16 of 20 Ms. Farrell presented the Community Forest Master Plan's recommendation for ten staff positions with an estimated cost of seven hundred forty thousand dollars annually, which increased to nearly one million dollars when benefits were included. This did not include administrative staff, vehicles, or equipment costs, potentially bringing the total close to one million dollars annually. As an alternative, she presented a scaled-down option focusing on a single tree coordinator position. Based on current grade levels and benefits, a coordinator position would cost approximately sixty-five thousand dollars annually, plus potential vehicle costs around twenty thousand dollars, and an administrative support position at approximately forty thousand dollars, totaling around one hundred twenty-five thousand dollars annually. Ms. Farrell provided context about public services operations, noting they contract out major road and park maintenance while staff handle active facilities. Public services positions average six vacancies per year due to hiring and retention challenges, suggesting contractor pricing might be more realistic for cost projections. Equipment needs from the Community Forest Master Plan included both small and large equipment purchases plus safety equipment, though these costs did not include actual tree purchases or outreach budget requirements. Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 17 of 20 Cost per tree analysis showed significant variation depending on the approach. A contracted town project in twenty twenty-four averaged twelve hundred dollars per tree, with approximately half that cost attributed to watering and maintenance requirements. Wholesale tree prices averaged around two hundred dollars for 1.5 to 2 inch trees, while Take Root giveaways averaged five dollars each when purchased. The comprehensive budget analysis showed various scenarios ranging from no additional staff to full Community Forest Master Plan implementation. Current tree bank revenue of three hundred twenty- seven thousand dollars could support a coordinator position while leaving funds for expanded planting programs. Mr. O'Neill emphasized the need to determine both the ideal end state and a transition plan to reach that goal, noting that requesting two million dollars in the first year was unrealistic. He suggested developing a multi- year implementation timeline with specific budget requirements for each phase. Chair McKee shared his perspective from the subcommittee discussion, emphasizing that the leadership position was most critical. He argued they could fund a coordinator from existing revenue while expanding planting programs and pursuing lower average cost per tree through volunteer labor and community partnerships. He suggested focusing on funding one person whose dedicated job would be growing the urban forest, using existing budgeted but underutilized funds for expanded tree planting. The group discussion revealed general agreement with starting with a single coordinator position rather than immediately implementing the full Community Forest Master Plan staffing structure. Mr. Quick expressed support for this approach as more palatable to policymakers while maintaining the long-term vision for expansion. Members agreed this approach provided a foundation that could grow over time based on success and available funding. g) Nonprofit partnership consideration Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 18 of 20 Chair McKee discussed the potential need for public-private partnerships to achieve their tree planting goals, noting that other municipalities had successfully implemented similar programs. He referenced Charleston's tree program and Atlanta's fundraising events as examples of communities engaging private funding for public tree initiatives. Mr. Quick raised legal questions about whether the town could directly solicit private donations, noting the potential need for a separate 501(c)(3) organization. Dr. Stewart confirmed that Charleston had to establish a separate nonprofit to collect private donations, similar to arrangements for hurricane relief funds. The discussion included concerns about sustainability of nonprofit organizations, with Mr. Quick referencing the East Cooper Land Trust experience where the organization eventually was absorbed by Lowcountry Land Trust due to inability to function independently. Ms. Farrell confirmed that Mount Pleasant had initially provided seed funding for what became East Cooper Land Trust but discontinued support after several years. The group acknowledged that while Charleston's Parks Conservancy model showed success in maintaining public-private partnerships, the arrangement required ongoing city support and significant private fundraising. They agreed that rather than recommending creation of a specific nonprofit, they could suggest the need for public-private partnerships while leaving implementation details to be determined. Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 19 of 20 Chair McKee concluded that the recommendation should focus on funding a coordinator position from existing revenue while noting that achieving the full one thousand tree goal would require additional community partnership and funding sources. This approach would demonstrate commitment while providing flexibility for future expansion based on success and available resources. Mr. Quick questioned whether the undergrounding program should continue drawing one hundred thousand dollars annually from tree bank funds, suggesting this money could be better used for tree planting programs. He proposed shifting undergrounding funding to the franchise fees collected from Dominion Energy, which total approximately six million dollars annually. The discussion revealed that undergrounding projects require the town to match fifty percent of Dominion's costs, with the town's contribution historically coming from tree bank funds, infrastructure funds, and hospitality funds in roughly equal proportions. While this represented a policy decision for town council rather than the task force, several members supported the concept of preserving tree bank funds for tree planting rather than undergrounding infrastructure. Andy Weis from Public Services noted that tree bank funds could also be used for maintenance of existing canopy, which is equally important as expanding the canopy. He emphasized that maintaining tree health is crucial and represents a potential use for tree bank funding beyond just new plantings. Dr. Stewart suggested the group focus on identifying the total funding needed for tree programs rather than being overly prescriptive about funding sources, allowing council to determine the best approach to provide necessary resources. The task force reached consensus that they should recommend preserving and growing tree bank funds for tree-related purposes while suggesting that undergrounding funding could potentially come from alternative sources. This would support their primary recommendation of hiring a dedicated tree coordinator while maximizing funds available for tree planting and maintenance programs. Tree Task Force March 19, 2026 Page 20 of 20 7. Discuss next agenda (Ordinance) The group confirmed that the next meeting would focus on ordinance discussions, which was expected to be substantial and require significant time. They also confirmed the timeline for draft report preparation, with drafting committee members committed to producing initial content for review at the April meeting. 8. Adjourn There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 10:03 a.m. Respectfully submitted, Christine Barrett Clerk of Council March 19, 2026

Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.