RecordWell Data

_02192026-2125

Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Feb 19, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TREE TASK FORCE Thursday, February 19, 2026 8:00 a.m. Municipal Complex, Committee Meeting Room 100 Ann Edwards Lane, Mount Pleasant, SC 29464 MI NUTES Click here to listen to the recording. Discussion Topics 1. Ca ll to Order James McKee, Chair of the Tree Task Force, called the meeting to order at 8:00 AM on Thursday, February 19, 2026. Members Edward Oswald, Deidre Kennedy, Michelle Mansour, Shanna Harris and David Quick were all present. George Grice was absent. 2. Approval of Agenda Ms. Mansour moved to approve the agenda, seconded by Mr. Oswald. All present voted in favor. 3. Approval of Minutes from January 29, 2026 Meeting Ms. Mansour moved to approve the minutes, seconded by Ms. Harris. All present voted in favor. 4. Public Comment Chair McKee opened the floor for public comment, asking if there was anybody present who wished to speak. Lisa Schnipke thanked the task force members for volunteering their time and talent. She explained that in 2024 and 2025, she had attended many town meetings to advocate for the creation of a preservation and restoration tree task force, expressing gratitude to the town and Town Council for establishing it. Ms. Schnipke described how she had lived in the Belle Hall community for over 30 years. In 2024, their HOA partnered with residents to plant over 70 trees on HOA property, with residents planting and caring for these trees during their first year. She explained that they acquired these trees from an Arbor Day event sponsored by the Town of Mount Pleasant, where each resident could receive two native trees for free. Her neighborhood promoted this event and encouraged residents to reserve two trees - one to donate for HOA property and one for their Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 2 of 17 yards, resulting in probably restoring their canopy in Belle Hall by over 140 trees. Ms. Schnipke noted that their neighborhood was over 30 years old and had lost many Bradford pears over time, creating a significant amount of missing trees. She emphasized that the tree giveaway program was successful because of the town's ability to provide free trees, and she believed this program was funded through the tree bank program. She stressed that it was essential for this program to continue being fully funded to help residents and communities restore the canopy in privately owned spaces. Looking at the fiscal 2026 budget, Ms. Schnipke observed that excess funds appeared to be going towards power undergrounding, which she acknowledged was important but noted it was not creating an increase in tree canopy - only serving to preserve what already existed. She emphasized the need to plant trees now for the next 5, 10, and 200 years in the future, asking the task force to consider this in their recommendations to Town Council. Ms. Schnipke hoped the task force's goal would be to educate and engage citizens on the impact that trees they plant or remove in their yard also have on their neighbors. Chair McKee thanked Ms. Schnipke for her comments and, seeing no other public speakers, moved on to the next agenda item. 5. Review and discussion of updated Guide/Outline for development of Final Report Review of January 29 meeting discussion Chair McKee turned the discussion over to Dr. Kendra Stewart who noted that Mr. O’Neill could not be present as he was facilitating a council meeting in Georgia. Stewart apologized for Mr. O’Neill’s absence but expressed that the meeting would proceed well without him. Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 3 of 17 Dr. Stewart directed the group to review the report outline that had been discussed and edited at the previous meeting. She asked how everyone felt about the document and whether anything had been left off or needed to be added. Mr. Quick responded that he felt good about it. Dr. Stewart then presented the agreements from the previous meeting, including the target canopy goal of 40 percent, which would equal about 1,000 trees per year. The group had agreed to review progress every five years during comprehensive plan updates, with strategy to identify Updated Final Report Outline • Goal and purpose introduction. • Assessing the existing programs and activities: what is working- what is not. • Encouraging protection. • Planting. • Maintenance. • Regulation and enforcement. • Processes and procedures. • Staffing and Resources. • Education, outreach, and partnership. • Goal and purpose conclusion. Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 4 of 17 and plant in open spots that had been identified. She noted the Green Infrastructure Center technical assistance that had been awarded to the city for canopy analysis, referencing the McClellanville report as an example of what could be accomplished with those funds. Mr. Quick suggested adding beauty to the purpose section, which the group agreed upon without objection. Ms. Mansour brought up a point from the previous night's Planning Commission meeting, where someone had mentioned sound buffering as trees buffer sound from roads like Hungry Neck Boulevard. She noted that neighbors were opposed to certain HOA proposals because of the buffering aspect of trees and the natural habitat they provide for animals. Mr. Quick suggested ensuring that noise buffer was included under the livability aspect. Chair McKee asked whether beauty should be included as part of livability or as a separate item, and Mr. Quick indicated he was inclined to make it separate, noting that he marveled at live oaks and the wildlife in them daily. Chair McKee requested that the minutes acknowledge that staff had obtained the Green Infrastructure Center grant, calling it a major win that would help validate whether their goal of 1,000 trees per year or 20,000 total for their 20-year plan was achievable and reasonable. He explained that the Green Infrastructure Center had indicated the way to validate these numbers was to determine the plantable acres in the town. Chair McKee raised the topic of tree planting costs, noting they had different estimates ranging from $335 per tree from the Green Infrastructure Center (assuming volunteer participation) to $1,200 from town staff for contracted projects, and $825 from his neighborhood contractor for a six-foot tree. He suggested that a couple of task force members work with staff to arrive at a better cost estimate that everyone could agree upon, looking at process numbers and existing programs. Dr, Stewart agreed this would be helpful before the next meeting when budgets would be discussed. Mr. Quick thought it was a great idea but noted they would need to make assumptions about how trees would be planted and maintained, suggesting that bigger numbers sounded like private contractor costs for larger trees, while smaller trees had better survivability and lower maintenance costs. Chair McKee and Mr. Quick agreed to work with staff to develop cost estimates before the next meeting, with Christiane Farrell coordinating the meeting. Ms. Mansour added something about trees being a shared resource with the community, noting that many people view trees as individually Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 5 of 17 owned when they actually benefit everyone around, not just that specific lot. The group agreed to add this concept of trees as shared resources to the purpose section. 6. Work Plan TTF 2026 Work Plan Discussion and recommendations regarding Structure and Management of Tree Program Dr. Stewart confirmed that everyone was satisfied with the work plan and proceeded to discuss the structure and management of the tree program. She noted that the group had been sharing information and thinking about these issues, which would provide a head start on the day's discussion. 6a. Assess existing programs Christiane Farrell, Assistant Town Administrator, began the presentation by explaining she had flipped the order from the work plan, putting staff and leadership last to build up to staffing needs after discussing programs and decision-making processes. She noted much of the information had already been seen by the group and that their next meeting would focus on budget while the following one would cover ordinances. Ms. Farrell reviewed existing programs, noting the group was familiar with most of them due to their participation. Education and outreach programs included Take Root, invasive species partnerships with Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 6 of 17 Tallows and Bradford pears, and Arbor Day projects. Canopy restoration had grown significantly over the past year or two as an initiative many task force members had participated in. The public tree inventory was still ongoing with additional funding, expected to be completed within the next couple of months. Ms. Farrell noted it was extensive and provided a good foundation for identifying initial spots for planting. She mentioned that the tree bank grant program was underutilized, with staff believing improvements could be made. Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 7 of 17 Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 8 of 17 Ms. Farrell presented strategic plan initiatives that Planning Director Michele Reed had presented to Town Council, including furthering tree programs as a strategic plan initiative. This included continuing canopy restoration, building on Take Root and associated education, examining the tree grant program, and implementing task force recommendations. She showed numbers from the past few years demonstrating growth in outreach initiatives like Take Root and canopy restoration, while noting the tree grant program was lagging behind other initiatives. The data showed public projects being planted but did not illustrate mitigation numbers, which staff was working to develop. Ms. Farrell discussed Planning pop-ups as a different approach to reach people who might not come to town hall or community meetings. The Planning department would appear at various locations, with cooperation planned with HOAs. She noted this could fit into tree outreach efforts. Chair McKee highlighted information from Public Services Director Andy Weis's presentation about over 1,000 ponds, suggesting potential for planting cypress trees as part of stormwater management rather than just using ponds alone. He also noted the tree inventory had counted 20,000 trees so far, with numbers expected to increase upon completion. 6b. Processes Efficiency Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 9 of 17 Ms. Farrell outlined process and efficiency challenges that were non- ordinance related. Tracking permits and mitigation presented challenges, as did fee collection, particularly for the Planning department. The software program presented challenges primarily for Planning, though it worked well for EDS due to how they collected information associated with building permits. IT was working with Planning to add a different module to make information tracking and extraction easier. Managing complaints and public pressures consumed significant time, with complaints coming from both sides - those upset about mitigation requirements and process length, and those concerned when trees were removed. The process was very time-consuming with significant back- and-forth, often requiring multiple site visits for modifications and additional information. The expansion of tree protection zones had caused additional time to be spent on many projects. Tree processes were linked to other development processes, such as stormwater and Planning Commission approvals for subdivisions. Public projects presented challenges conducting surveys down to eight- inch trees, with the reality that when building roads or ball fields, trees could not be planted back in the middle of them, creating minimal opportunities for replanting. Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 10 of 17 Successful elements included the permit application fee and linking tree removal to building permits on the EDS side. Mr. Quick asked about the permit application fee structure, wondering if it was a flat fee or included earnest money that could be returned. Ms. Farrell confirmed it was a flat $50 fee for the Planning department. Chair McKee clarified there were two different approaches - residential non- construction paid $50 upfront, while residential construction and engineering projects collected higher fees and mitigation costs upfront, refunding money if trees were planted. Mr. Quick suggested the permit application fee might need examination, proposing a larger fee that could provide monetary incentive by allowing money back for tree planting or retaining funds for non-compliance. Ms. Reed explained the $50 fee was implemented with the new code to ensure serious applications, as previously people could submit applications without commitment, wasting staff time. She noted the challenge of balancing reasonable fees with preventing illegal tree removal due to unreasonable costs. 6c. Decision making (ordinance/ funding/ programs) Ms. Farrell outlined current decision-making structure, with Town Council responsible for policies and budgets, staff executing those policies including tree removal and enforcement, and program management involving three departments. Boards and commissions examined trees in various capacities, from tree removal to lot subdivision and commercial Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 11 of 17 building siting. Court involvement occurred after illegal activities, and Public Services handled maintenance and planting projects, often contracting out due to staff capacity limitations. 6d. Define management of planting program Ms. Farrell showed who currently managed different aspects of planting programs. Special programs were handled mainly by Planning and EDS with GREEN Commission involvement. Mitigation for residential and commercial projects involved the same two departments. CIP projects typically had project managers varying by department based on project type, while Public Services managed their planting program with a combination of in-house and contracted work. 6e. Staffing and leadership - current and future Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 12 of 17 Ms. Farrell reviewed current staffing, showing several arborists within the Planning department handling public projects, commercial projects, and single-family existing homes. An arborist sat on the Board of Zoning Appeals staff. Administrative staff did significant work tracking everything and collecting fees. Public Services had some in-house capacity and Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 13 of 17 some contracted work. Engineering side included building division and engineering division staff. She noted the extensive staffing involved, with much tied to other processes like NPDES, and business licenses required for tree companies. Many staff members touched tree processes, requiring significant time investment. Ms. Farrell concluded by identifying required versus desired functions. Tree ordinance requirements included permitting, mitigation, enforcement, and maintenance tied to ordinances. Program management was desired but not required, including programs like Take Root that had proven important and successful. She emphasized the need for awareness of how trees were intricately involved in other processes, noting that separating processes like NPDES site review for trees would not make sense as it would require two people on-site. Similarly, separating tree reviews from Planning Commission or DRB would be problematic as they examined many other site aspects. Budget considerations for next month would include staffing costs, and ordinance impacts would affect staffing needs for any modifications. Discussion of Programs and Structure Dr. Stewart suggested starting by discussing what processes and programs were working well, then addressing areas needing improvement. Chair McKee asked whether programs and processes should be discussed separately. He noted that ordinance requirements drove required staff and processes, which might be inefficient but were necessary, while programs were optional but focused on adding trees to achieve their 1,000 trees per year goal. Dr. Stewart agreed that focusing on programs first would be more straightforward before addressing more complex processes. Take Root Program Discussion Mr. Quick identified Take Root as obviously working well but noted concerning declining numbers from 1,563 trees in 2021 to 600 in the previous year. He expressed concern about the previous Arbor Day when they did not have trees and relied heavily on Duke Energy's program. Mr. Oswald asked why the numbers were trending down. Mr. Quick noted significant decline and mentioned that from volunteering Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 14 of 17 experience, they were not taking 1,000 trees home with leftover trees sometimes placed outside town hall with take-a-tree signs. Ms. Reed explained the cyclical nature of people's interest and various factors including giveaway location. She noted the Planning department ran the program with staff volunteering on weekends, and funding came from their budget plus donated trees from various groups. Different species, seasons, and locations were used without a set formula. Mr. Quick emphasized the dedication of staff showing up for long volunteer days, primarily consisting of staff members with some volunteers. Dr. Stewart noted the decline in interest was typical for programs after initial excitement but could be reactivated. Mr. Oswald suggested moving the program from staff who had other daily responsibilities to its own dedicated division. Mr. Quick warned about relying on volunteers, emphasizing the need for paid staff as foundation with volunteer support. Chair McKee referenced Charleston Trees group under Charleston Parks Conservancy, which had restarted their program three years ago with dedicated staff - someone whose job was tree giveaways for six months and park maintenance for six months, achieving 1,500 trees annually. The group discussed expanding Take Root, with Ms. Mansour suggesting taking it to HOAs and neighborhoods rather than just events. Ms. Reed mentioned goals of reaching out better to HOAs about grant programs allowing tree planting on HOA property. Chair McKee referenced Ms. Schnipke’s public comment about Belle Hall's approach, suggesting a neighborhood-level strategy where they would work with communities on organized planting rather than passive event attendance. He proposed going to neighborhoods with 100 trees asking where they would like them planted. Ms. Reed suggested doing this twice a year instead of events, meeting with community members in organized fashion. Chair McKee emphasized this would be more targeted and strategic, ensuring trees actually got planted in Mount Pleasant rather than being taken elsewhere. Mr. Quick saw value in both approaches - neighborhood outreach and maintaining public presence at events, suggesting events could have limited supply to create high demand. The discussion continued about incorporating tree giveaways into Planning pop-ups and farmer's market presence. Dr. Stewart raised Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 15 of 17 questions about the appropriate level of detail for council recommendations and whether expansion should come through additional staffing or community partnerships. Individual Tree Requests and Grant Program Mr. Oswald asked about individual requests for tree planting assistance. Ms. Farrell confirmed the town did not currently provide this service, with liability concerns noted. The group discussed the tree grant program's underutilization, with zero applications the previous year. Chair McKee explained his experience attempting to complete a grant application but stopping due to his HOA lacking a planting plan and internal support. He noted neighborhoods managing common areas typically did not have tree planting plans, focusing instead on shrubs and annuals. The discussion explored combining Take Root with the tree grant program to provide both trees and planting assistance, potentially including planning grants to help neighborhoods develop planting strategies. Canopy Restoration Program Chair McKee emphasized the canopy restoration program as working well, having planted 9 trees initially and 75 trees the second year. He suggested aggressively expanding this program using the tree inventory to identify specific locations and potential plantable areas from the Green Infrastructure Center grant. Mr. Quick noted the previous year was a pilot with limited suggestion periods, indicating potential for expansion with longer promotion periods and more active solicitation rather than waiting for public suggestions. Chair McKee suggested staff could proactively identify priority projects rather than only waiting for public suggestions, creating a prioritized project stack for multiple years. Dr. Stewart suggested establishing goals for each program to determine investment needs, questioning whether 84 trees was sufficient or if higher numbers were needed to reach the 1,000 tree annual goal. The group agreed that staff should determine capacity and how much planting would need to occur on private property versus public spaces. Staffing and Structure Discussion Chair McKee identified feedback from the group regarding fragmentation of skills and focus across departments, suggesting centralization with Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 16 of 17 dedicated leadership rather than staff doing trees in addition to other duties. Mr. Quick proposed an urban forestry division or department with dedicated arborists, public works staff specializing in trees, and a coordinator handling public relations and tree ordering. He noted that 15 staff members currently touched tree processes and suggested consolidating into a focused department that might also handle pollinator gardens. Dr. Stewart asked what problem the restructuring aimed to solve. The group identified coordination issues and staff being spread thin across multiple duties with each department handling different aspects without coordination. Brad Morrison, Engineering Development Services Director, acknowledged the larger concept of building more capacity but noted their current integrated regulatory processes worked well at the site level. He emphasized that separating tree processes from development approval would worsen communication. Mr. Morrison observed the group's passion for creation rather than just mitigation, suggesting programmatic approaches were the path to more trees. Farrell agreed with Mr. Morrison about site review integration, noting tree processes were completely combined with stormwater requirements. Separating site reviews would disrupt working processes and potentially increase bureaucracy. She suggested the need for someone overseeing and coordinating net gain and program enrichment while keeping functioning processes in place. Mr. Quick described situations where calling about tree removal resulted in being transferred between departments, indicating the need for a central point person. Morrison acknowledged information exchange problems but defended EDS processes as ordinance-compliant with certified arborists conducting reviews. Dr. Stewart clarified the issue was not staff performance but potentially ordinance-related, which would be addressed in future meetings. The discussion revealed that staff reviewed hundreds of plans with thousands of trees, making it difficult to recall specific cases. Ms. Reed explained ordinance requirements, noting that trees 16-24 inches were protected through mitigation requirements, while trees over 24 inches could not be removed unless dead or diseased. The ordinance determined what staff could approve or deny. Tree Task Force February 19, 2026 Page 17 of 17 Mr. Oswald emphasized focusing on the 40 percent canopy goal rather than getting into permitting details, noting limited new residential construction was not causing widespread tree loss. Chair McKee acknowledged being surprised by how much attention was given to tree protection in current processes but emphasized the need for dedicated leadership to focus on getting trees in the ground since everyone else was doing trees as part-time duties. The group consensus emerged around needing a point person whose full-time job would be trees, coordinating with existing staff and processes while leading tree programs and serving as the primary contact for tree-related questions. 7. Discuss next agenda (Funding and Partnership Opportunities) The group discussed the next meeting's agenda, which would focus on funding and partnership opportunities. Ms. Farrell noted the CFO would attend to help answer questions about costs and revenue sources. She mentioned examining staffing costs and exploring nonprofit partnerships, noting Town Administrator Eric DeMoura's experience with public-private partnerships. Ms. Mansour raised questions about County annexation and related tree coverage issues. Ms. Farrell indicated these process issues might be incorporated into the ordinance discussion rather than funding. Dr. Stewart confirmed the next meeting would focus on funding and partnerships, with remaining process issues addressed during the ordinance discussion. 8. Adjourn There being no further business, Chair McKee adjourned the meeting at 10:05 a.m. Respectfully submitted, Christine Barrett Clerk of Council February 19, 2026

Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.