RecordWell Data

BOA-25-04, 2870 Old Field Rd. - (City) Staff Report

City of Sumter · Sumter County · Other

Open the original document More from City of Sumter

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Sumter City-County Zoning Board of Appeals March 12, 2025 BOA-25-04, 2870 Old Field Rd. (City) The applicant (Cypress Winds, LLC) is requesting variances from the “Patio Home” minimum front and side exterior (corner lot) building setback requirements outlined in Article 3.d.5: (GR District) Development Standards; Article 3, Exhibit 3-3: Development Standards for Uses in the GR District; and Article 4.f.5: Side Yards of the City of Sumter Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance (the “Ordinance”) to facilitate the establishment of 21 new “Patio Home” lots with a front building setback of 25 ft. and side exterior (corner lot) setback of 12.5 ft. The Ordinance requires a 35 ft. front building setback and a 17.5 ft. side exterior (corner lot) building setback. The property is located at 2870 Old Field Rd., is zoned General Commercial (GC), and is represented by TMS# 187-00-02-018. 2 Sumter City-County Zoning Board of Appeals March 12, 2025 BOA-25-04, 2870 Old Field Rd. (City) I. THE REQUEST Applicant: Cypress Winds, LLC (Doc Dunlap) Status of the Applicant: Property Owner Request: The applicant is requesting variances from Patio Home minimum front and side exterior (corner lot) building setback requirements to facilitate the development of 21 new Patio Home lots. City Council Ward Ward 1 Location: 2870 Old Field Rd. Present Use/Zoning: Undeveloped / General Residential (GR) Tax Map Reference: 187-00-02-018 II. BACKGROUND The applicant is requesting variances from Patio Home” minimum front and side exterior (corner lot) setback requirements in order to develop Phase 2 of the Canopy of Oaks Subdivision. The Canopy of Oaks S ubdivision is located off Old Field Rd ., and Phase 2 consists of an extension of Canopy Dr. with 21 additional Patio Home” lots. The property is shown in red on the location map to the right. After approval to develop Phase 1 of the subdivision, the City of Sumter revised residential front setback requirements to a standard 35 ft. for most residential uses. Development in Phase 1 was allowed to proceed with a vested 25 ft. front setback requirement for new patio home units. The 3 remaining undeveloped area behind Phase 1 is not subject to the same vested rights protections and is required to comply with the current 35 ft. front setback requirements, and subsequently 17.5 ft. side exterior (corner lot) setback requirements. The applicant is requesting to develop under the same conditions as those vested under Phase 1. A timeline of events to date pertaining to the Canopy of Oaks Subdivision is provided below: • January 26, 2022 - Planning Commission approved a preliminary plat (Case# SD-21-04) for the development of a 65-unit subdivision consisting of townhome dwellings and single family attached dwellings on the front portion of the property only. Staff notes that initial plans received under the request included 98 townhome units on the entirety of the property, but revised plans for the front area only were submitted for approval during the review process to eliminate immediate fire access concerns. Figure 1: SD-21-04 Preliminary Plat Approved on January 26, 2022 4 • July 19, 2022 – City Council approved an amendment (Case# OA -22-08) to the City Zoning & Development Standards Ordinance, effectively establishing a standard 35 ft. front setback for most new residential development. • May 18, 2023 – A revision to the initial preliminary plat (Case# SD-21-04 Revision 1) was approved a t the staff level. This revision changed the housing type from townhome dwellings and s ingle family attached dwellings to patio home dwellings, a s ingle family detached product permitted on smaller lots with off -set side setback requirements. This change reduced the total number of lots and overall density of the project and reflects what is currently being built. It was determined that the initial setbacks vested under the initial approval were also vested for the approved change. Figure 2: SD-21-04 Revision1 Preliminary Plat Approved on May 18, 2023 5 • January 15, 2025 – The applicant submitted for preliminary plat approval for Phase 2 of the Canopy of Oaks Subdivision (Case# SD-21-04 Revision 2). The proposal includes 21 new patio home lots to the rear of the development previously approved. Under the plans submitted, the applicant is proposing a 25 ft. front setback in line with the previously approved lots. The applicant was informed during the technical review process that the 25 ft. vested front setback for the previous lots was not applicable to the new phase and that a 35 ft. front setback is required. Figure 3: SD-21-04 Revision 2 Proposed Plans If requested variances are approved, the proposed 21 new patio home lots would be subject to a 25 ft. front building setback. Additionally, Lot# 15, as shown on submitted plans , would be allowed a 12.5 ft. building setback on the exterior side section of the lot. 6 Figure 4: Scope of Variance Request The table below outlines exhibits attached to this staff report. Exhibit Reference Table Exhibit 1 Applicant Background/Justification & Setback Exhibit Exhibit 2 Lot Layout Plan for Canopy of Oaks Phase 2 7 Ordinance Requirements: Article 3, Exhibit 3-3 Article 4.f.5: Side Yards 4.f.5 Side Yards : Where a side yard abuts a street (i.e., corner lot), the minimum side yard requirement shall not be less than 50% required on the lot lying to the rear, when the rear lot faces a side street and no accessory building on said corner lot shall extend beyond the front yard line of the lot to the rear. If, however, the rear lot faces the opposite street, and in fact constitutes another corner lot, then the side yards setback for the district in which the lot is located shall prevail. Provision established herein may be excluded from a Planned Development (PD) which utilizes the Traditional Neighborhood Development (TND) design conventions. III. FOUR PART TEST In order to grant the requested variance, the request must meet all parts of a State-mandated four- part test. When reviewing a variance request, the Board may not grant a variance that would do the following • Allow the establishment of a use not otherwise permitted in a zoning district; • Extend physically a nonconforming use of land; • Change zoning district boundaries shown on the Sumter City- County Official Zoning Map. The fact a property may be utilized more profitably should a variance be granted shall not be considered grounds for approving a variance request. In granting a variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the Board may consider advisable to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. 8 Staff Review: 1) There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property. The property is a +/- 8-acre undeveloped section of the Canopy of Oaks Subdivision. Previous approvals for the front portion of the subdivision have vested rights protection for a 25 ft. front setback, as this was the standard in place at the time of initial approval. With a 25 ft. front setback requirement, the exterior side (corner lot) setback is 12.5 ft. The remaining undeveloped section of the property does not have the same vested rights protection and is subject to the more restrictive 35 ft. front setback requirement, and subsequently the more restrictive 17.5 side exterior setback. A linear stormwater pond intended to serve the larger Canopy of Oaks Subdivision has been completed on the west side of the property. T his somewhat limits the ability to modify lot sizes in order to place the applicant’s desired housing product. The applicant’s builder has stated that that same type of units constructed in Phase 1 cannot be done with an increased front setback requirement. Figure 5: Graphic Submitted By Applicant Showing 35 ft. vs. 25 ft. Front Setback 2) These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity. All property in the GR zoning district, not otherwise protected via non-conformity protections or vested rights protections, are subject to the newly adopted 35 ft. front setback requirement. 3) Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property. The application of the ordinance to the particular property would preclude the applicant from constructing the desired housing footprint on the proposed lots. However, it is noted an alternate footprint could be proposed or changes to the design of the development could be proposed to mitigate some of this issue. 9 4) The authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or to the public good, and the granting of the variance will not harm the character of the district. Approval of this variance will ultimately result in 21 new lots with development standards that will mirror those of the houses already complete in Phase 1. Thus, a continuation of the lot sizes and building footprints that have already been, or will soon be , completed. City Council elected to adopt more restrictive residential front setback requirements in 2022 to mitigate parking impacts that were primarily seen in new residential subdivisions with front setbacks of 25 ft. or less. Impacts include excess on-street parking of vehicles causing access challenges for larger emergency vehicles and the blocking of sidewalks by vehicles parked in designated off-street driveways due to insufficient space. These stated concerns would not be addressed if the variance is approved. While impacts to adjacent property would likely be minimal, there is the potential for impact to the overall public good that must be balanced against the desire for uniformity within the development. IV. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Staff recommends no additional conditions of approval if the Board makes the necessary findings to approve this request. V. DRAFT MOTIONS for BOA-25-04 A. I move the Zoning Board of Appeals approve BOA-25-04, subject to the findings of fact and conclusions developed by the BZA and so stated: B. I move the Zoning Board of Appeals deny BOA-25-04, subject to the following findings of fact and conclusions: C. I move the Zoning Board of Appeals enter an alternative motion for BOA-25-04. VI. BOARD OF APPEALS – March 12, 2025 Exhibit 1 160 Gills Creek Parkway - P.O. Box 50215 - Columbia, S.C. 29250 - (803)765-2463 21021 DESCRIPTION: C3A OF 17 PROJ. NO.SHEET SITE PLAN MICHAEL E. WEATHERLY, P.E. CONSULTING ENVIRONMENTAL & CIVIL ENGINEER SITE AND LANDSCAPE PLAN CANOPY OF OAKS SUBDIVISION - PHASE II SUMTER, SC SITE DEVELOPMENT TABLE: 1. OWNER & APPLICANT CYPRESS WINDS, LLC. MR. TYLER DUNLAP,OWNER 2990 BROAD STREET SUMTER, SC 29150 TEL: 1-803-469-9805 EMAIL: DOCDUNLAP@GMAIL.COM 2. ENGINEER CONTACT MIKE WEATHERLY, P.E. P.O. BOX 50215 COLUMBIA, SC 29150 TEL.: 803-765-2463 EMAIL: MEWPE1@AOL.COM 3. TAX MAP PARCELS 187-00-02-018 4. SITE ADDRESS 2870 OLD FIELD ROAD SUMTER COUNTY 5. ZONING: GRPROPOSED USE: SINGLE FAMILY /ZERO LOT LINE HOUSING 6. FEMA INFORMATION ZONE: X FIRM PANEL 45085C0283E / 0281E EFFECTIVE DATE 9-28-2018 7. SIZE OF PARCEL(S)8.0 ACRES 8. AREA OF OPEN AREA4.4 ACRES 9. AREA OF LOTS2.8 ACRES 10. AREA OF ROAD R/W0.8 ACRE 11. OPEN SPACE55% 12. SETBACKS REQ.FRONT - 25' SIDE - 0' & 8' SECONDARY SIDE - 12.5' REAR - 20' 13. LOT WIDTH TYP.>46' 14. PROPERTY IS SERVED BY CITY OF SUMTER WATER AND SEWER. Exhibit 2

Source: City of Sumter website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.