9-30-19 SPECIAL COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
Town of Pawleys Island · Georgetown County · meeting of Sep 30, 2019 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Pawleys Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES PAWLEYS ISLAND COUNCIL SPECIAL CALLED MEETING DATE/PLACE: September 30, 2019 Pawleys Island Chapel PRESENT: Mayor Jimmy Braswell, Ashley Carter, Guerry Green, Rocky Holliday & Sarah Zimmerman ABSENT: None THIS MEETING IS FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. NO ACTION WILL BE TAKEN BY COUNCIL Town Attorney, David DuRant stated that there is, under the state law, a provision for municipalities to determine how they elect their candidates and how they determine individuals pertaining to domicile, etc. On March 12, 2007 Pawleys Island passed an ordinance that approved the Georgetown County Election Commission the authority to accept candidate filings, fees, hearings of protest and to certify the results of the Town elections. There have been candidates that have filed and have been validated by the Georgetown County Election Commission. There have been no challenges to date regarding those candidates. There is a system that allows a challenge before an election and a short time after an election. Jimmy Braswell stated that after the public comment Attorney Bowers will make his presentation then Attorney Jenkinson regarding the legal qualification of candidacy. The candidates will not be called upon to speak about their candidacy. The attorneys will keep their presentations to 10 minutes. After both attorneys speak Mayor Braswell will open up questioning to each lawyer. Questions must be related to the subject matter and one question at a time. He asked the attorneys not to give their legal opinions as to residency or legal issues as it applies to the candidates. PUBLIC COMMENT Sumter Moore stated that he was in law enforcement for 26 years. If you want to change the law you need to do it in the proper way and to change any rule or regulation 1 month before the election is not the way to do it. Robert Moser stated that his question is about Pawleys Island tomorrow and not so much about Pawleys Island today. He feels the candidates have the best interest of Pawleys in mind but his concern is with the next election; will we have a developer from Columbia or from Myrtle Beach run for Mayor? Bebe Benton stated that to be in litigation is very costly and time consuming. What voters need to be considering when voting is, do these candidates live on Pawleys Island – is their domicile on Pawleys Island? To determine this, they must look at their intent and is Pawleys where they want to live all the time. You can also look at their auto registration, driver’s license, property tax exemption, tax return address, etc. and has their domicile address just changed because they want to vote in an election. John Benton stated that nothing will be done at this meeting and said that if there is a question it needs to be presented to the Election Commission. ______________________ Page 1 of 3 September 30, 2019
HEAR LEGAL PERSPECTIVE OF 2 INDEPENDENT COUNCILS PERTAINING TO WHAT CONSTITUTES ELIGIBILITY TO VOTE AND RUN FOR OFFICE WITHIN THE TOWN OF PAWLEYS ISLAND. A. Butch Bowers stated that he was asked to review the legal requirements to be eligible to vote and run for office. State law lists several things that you can consider. A person must be a resident of a particular jurisdiction in order to register to vote or run for office in that jurisdiction. A person’s residence is his domicile. The key question is what does domicile mean? A person can have only one domicile. You can own more than one property and even rent one but you can only claim one of those places as your domicile. From a case law, the single biggest issue to determine what one’s domicile is, is that persons intent. Does this person intend to return this property? A person can own and live in Columbia most of any given year and also have a home on the Pawleys Island and can still claim their Pawleys home as their domicile because they have an intent to return. This comes from a 1975-1976 Attorney General’s opinion and it comes from Supreme Court case from 1917. Anyone can challenge an election result and file a protest up to 48 hrs. after an election. Then a protest hearing is heard, from whoever is unhappy with the result, then they can go to the circuit court and file an appeal of that decision. Attorney Bowers represented Austin Beard in a recent case concerning his residency while serving on the Georgetown County Council. In that case Mr. Beard was living with his wife in Georgetown but he only owned land in his district, not a residence. There was no way to have an intent to return without having a house on the property so he couldn’t keep his position on council. Attorney Bowers also stated that renting a house you own for any amount of time does not prevent you from claiming that house as your domicile for voting purposes. That is a tax issue not a voting issue. B. Billy Jenkinson stated that the law states in order to be a qualified elector of a municipality you must be a resident as of the date of the election and if the candidate is not qualified then the election is void. The Election Commission determines this after an election. A person has only one domicile. There is no cookie cutter case pertaining to domicile as every candidate has a different set of facts and circumstances governed by law as to whether or not they are a resident. There was a case regarding an election for governor in 1974 with Charles (Pug) Ravenel running as the democratic nominee for this position. He lived in Charleston originally, went to a number of ivy league schools, was hired by Wall Street which one of the biggest investment firms in the country. He always stated that his intent was to go back to Charleston and did so in 1972 and then decided to run for governor in 1974. There is a 5-year residency requirement for governor. Mr. Ravenel’s last 3 years tax returns showed his address as New York so his intention to come back to SC did not hold up. The other things to look at when looking at residency issues is the tax returns, the real estate tax notices, where do they get their mail, what is on their driver’s license, what is on their checkbook and bank statements. Where are their boats and cars located? Where does their spouse live? Home is where a residence is located. Either we are a nation of laws or we are a nation of good buddies. When you go into the voting booth you must ask yourself should I follow the law or vote for a good buddy. ______________________ Page 2 of 3 September 30, 2019
Council had an opportunity to asked attorneys questions regarding domicile. Rocky Holliday asked Attorney Bowers to speak of his knowledge regarding the Ravenel case. Atty. Bowers stated that he believed the South Carolina 5-year constitutional requirement was the deciding factor of Mr. Ravenel’s domicile. No one disputed that Mr. Ravenel intended to come back to South Carolina but the sole issue of the 5-year residency period had not been done. This 5-year requirement is reserved for the Governorship only. Anyone running for any other lower level office does not need to meet the 5-year residency requirement. Guerry Green asked if you are qualified to vote are you qualified to run? Atty. Bowers answered yes. Mayor Braswell stated that in the Town’s Article of Incorporation it states that you must be a full time resident to be elected to office for the Town. Atty. Bowers stated that in his legal opinion, he felt that that would not be upheld in court because of the State rules and laws regarding domicile and regarding the determination of who is eligible to vote. You don’t have to live in a jurisdiction 365 days a year to be able to vote there. Atty. Jenkinson stated that what is in the statement of incorporation written by our founding fathers is something the court will respect. Sarah Zimmerman recited from various articles, “that a person’s fixed home is where there is an intention to return when he is absent. Further provides that a person changes his domicile for voting purposes if he has abandoned his prior home, has established a new home with the present intention to make that place his home and has no present intention to leave that place.” The Supreme Court stated, “the residence of a person is a mixed question of law and fact and that the intention of that person with regard to the matter is deemed a controlling element of the decision. Intent, as the Supreme Court has noted, is primarily an issue of fact.” Atty. Bowers stated that the most important part of what Sarah read is the word “Intent” which is the controlling element or the most important part of that decision but there are other factors to consider. Sarah asked, when you say return, does this not imply that you’d have to have been there in order to return. Atty. Bowers said yes but you don’t necessarily have to have that as your domicile first in order to return there. After many questions and discussion from the public, of what is considered a domicile, the meeting was adjourned.
_______________________________ ____________________ APPROVED DATE ___________________________________ ____________________ ATTEST DATE ______________________ Page 3 of 3 September 30, 2019
Source: Town of Pawleys Island website. First collected Nov 8, 2026.