_07142026-216
City of Gaffney · Cherokee County · meeting of Jul 14, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Gaffney
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Planning Commission Meeting
Minutes of July 14, 2026
City of Gaffney, SC – City Council Chambers
Planning Commission
An Agenda was posted and sent to the news media in accordance with the State FOI Act.
At about 5:30 pm, the meeting was called to order by Vice Chairwoman Nancy Davis.
Dale Guffey called the roll. Members Pattie McCraw, Nancy Davis, Donald Logan, and James Wilkins were
present. Chairwoman MaryPat Tyndall was absent. A quorum was established. Staff members present
were Alison Hall and Dale Guffey.
Item number three on the agenda was to consider the approval of minutes of the April 14, 2026, and
April 22, 2026, meetings. Donald Logan made a motion to accept the minutes. Pattie McCraw seconded
the motion. The motion was carried unanimously.
Item number four on the agenda was to hear a request from Limestone University to re-zone 1113
College Drive (Parcel 100-00-00-002.006), from College Education District (CE) to Multi-Family
Residential District (RM). John Wall was present to speak about this request and said this property was
also known as the Griffith Apartments and is a two-story brick structure on the corner of College Drive
and Hetty Hill. Rezoning this property from College Education District (CE) to Multi-Family Residential
District (RM) would put it on the tax books, and the City would start generating tax revenue from it. It is
for sale, but there is no contract on it as of now. A member of the Planning Commission asked if the city
would still get the revenue until it is sold. Ms. Hall said not until the deed transfers out of Limestone’s
name. A member of the Planning Commission asked if they rezone it, when that would happen. Mr. Wall
said when it’s sold. Ms. Hall said that’s more State regulated than anything in the ordinance, and as long
as it’s sold before December 31st, it would be tax revenue for next year, but if it’s after January 2nd they
would have to wait another year. Mr. Wall said he believed this was the last building they were going to
sell, and the rest would be sold as a whole with the campus. A member of the Planning Commission
asked how old the building was. The members discussed how long the building had been part of the
college, and there was concern about it being zoned separately due to the history. Ms. Hall said that it
was on its own parcel, so they would have to list that parcel as part of Limestone because it’s not part of
the parcel that Limestone is on. A member of the Planning Commission asked if it would change it being
in the Historic District. Ms. Guffey and Ms. Hall said that it would still be in the HPOD and that wouldn’t
change. There was a question about Multi-Family Residential being allowed in the HPOD, and Ms. Hall
said this parcel was already in this district. A member of the Planning Commission asked if there was any
impediment to it being a multi-family structure. Ms. Hall said it cannot be added onto or modified
substantially because the stand-alone parcel itself does not qualify for any more apartments because
you must have a one-acre lot, and for the duplexes there has to be 6,000 for the initial and 4,000 for
each additional unit. A member of the Planning Commission asked how much of the gravel parking lot
was going to go with this. Mr. Wall said all of it.
Item number five on the agenda was to conduct a public hearing on item number four. There were no
members of the public present to speak.
Item number six on the agenda was to consider the request on item number four. Donald Logan made a
motion to accept the request to rezone the parcel from CE to RM. Nancy Davis seconded the motion.
Donald Logan, Nancy Davis, and James Wilkins were in favor. Pattie McCraw was opposed. The motion
was carried.
Item number seven on the agenda was to hear a request submitted by the State of South Carolina Fiscal
Accountability Authority to annex 2 parcels (098-00-00-012.000 and 098-00-00-014.003), known as 120
Hampshire Dr., the Palmetto Patriots Home, with a Zoning District of General Commercial (GC). Ms. Hall
said this was in the works from 2019 when the Patriots Home was being built; the State wanted to annex
it into the City, but at that point there was paperwork that needed to be done which didn’t get
completed that time, but now it has been brought back up to complete the process of annexing. It’s tax-
exempt property; nobody gets tax dollars from it in the County or the City, so it’s a matter of finishing
the petition to annex it into the city. A member of the Planning Commission asked if there was a reason
they wanted it to be annexed into the City, but no reason was provided.
Item number eight on the agenda was to conduct a public hearing on item number seven. Mr. Craig
Sobol was present to speak at the public hearing. He said that Gaffney’s new budget did require
$1,000,000 from the reserve fund, and it also shows $3.3 million less revenue than they had in the
previous year. Currently, the property tax records show some discrepancies, and the County public
website records show no total assessed value since the County took it over in 2017. However, in 2023,
the County property tax paid was $77.751 from VSI of South Carolina; in 2024, $77,458; but in 2025, the
VSI only paid $43,500, so why was there a 34 percent drop in 2025, and will this reduce taxes for the
future? A comment was made that there wouldn’t be any property taxes because they are exempt. Ms.
Hall said yes, and all that is handled through the Cherokee County Auditor’s office. There was a question
of why they would not be paying it to the City if they were paying it to the County. Ms. Hall said if they
are paying it, the City would get a portion of it, but all of that is handled in Columbia. Mr. Sobol
questioned why the City would take on this property when there would be no revenue being brought
into the city, but expenses would be added by providing services. A member of the Planning Commission
asked who was currently handling providing services for this property. Mr. Sobol said he was concerned
about the City going further in debt. A member of the Planning Commission asked about the location of
the property. Ms. Hall explained the City property line and that it would extend out to include this
property, and the City Fire Department will respond either way.
Item number nine on the agenda was to consider the request of item number seven. The commission
discussed tabling the item until they could get some answers about why the fees were being paid, where
the money was going , and whether the city or the county would benefit more from this property. A
member of the Planning Commission asked why they would do this if they were not going to benefit
from it and said at least the county was getting some tax revenue. Ms. Hall said according to the tax
records, they were getting personal property tax, which was paid by any business. Mr. Sobol asked if
Gaffney would get the personal property tax. Ms. Hall said they would get a portion of it, so that would
be a gain. A member of the Planning Commission asked what the benefit would be to annex it and how
we have been taking care of it, and where the money was coming from. Ms. Hall said the Fire
Department has an agreement with Cherokee County. The commission discussed inspections for food
service, and it was stated that that was on a state level and those inspections were done by the
Department of Health and Human Services. Mr. Sobol asked why the state was pushing this annexation.
A member of the Planning Commission said that was the previous plan from 2019, but with no other
answers of why they wanted to annex this, they did not feel comfortable voting on it until that was
answered.
Patti McCraw made a motion to request to table the request to annex 120 Hampshire Drive, the
Palmetto Patriots Home, with a zoning district of General Commercial, until they get some answers to
their questions. The motion was seconded by James Wilkins. The motion was carried unanimously.
Item number ten on the agenda was to discuss an additional ordinance to allow an honorary street name
program. Ms. Hall said this would not be to change the street name and everyone's address, but to add
an honorary street name. She’s received two requests to do this and spoke with the City Public Works
Department, Barry Bundy and City Engineer Scott Keller, about what the costs would be for the signs,
which they think needs to be conveyed to the applicant versus the city paying for it. It would be about
$500.00 for the sign plus the mounting brackets that would have to go on the existing pole. Some
questions were: would they allow it on an SCDOT road, or would it need to be a city road; would they
have to have some significance to the city, would they have to have been born here; how long would the
application last, and how big of an area would they be allowed to do. Each sign would have that same
$500.00 cost. The commission members discussed the criteria that should be required to issue an
honorary street name and how to come up with it because if this is allowed, they would have a lot of
requests for this and a lot of people getting upset if they weren’t able to. Ms. Guffey said they had two
requests for renaming a street, and they had no current instructions on how to process them. Ms. Hall
said one of the requests was to rename W. Rutledge from the college area out, and there are 114 homes
that they would have to post and have them come in here and say the name of their road changed, so
unless they want 114 citizens in here and the 911 and post office ramifications of that, the honorary will
get you around that because it’s still going to be W. Rutledge but it’ll be “Honorary Alison Alley.” A
member of the Planning Commission asked if someone submits an application, would it come in front of
them to be voted on? Ms. Hall said they could decide if they wanted it to be considered on a staff level
or if they thought it should be voted on by PC. A member of the Planning Commission said they saw a
procedure where if a street had an honorary street name and the period was for two years, then at the
end of the two years they could reapply for it to continue to have that honorary name, but if there was a
wait list, then they would go to the end of the list for renewal. Ms. Guffey said that if someone pays a fee
of $1,000 with an application and the application does not get approved, then most of that money gets
returned to the applicant. There was concern about paying for the labor for the sign to be hung and
taken down, as well as the sign itself. Ms. Guffey said the commission could decide what the fee should
be to cover all the expenses. A member of the Planning Commission was concerned about there being
too many of these signs all over town. Ms. Hall suggested that they could set a limit on how many a
person could have at one time. A member of the Planning Commission was concerned about how a
scenario would be handled if an application was submitted to them and there was a dislike of the
person; would the voting be fair under those circumstances? There was a suggestion that they could
decide to let Council vote on it to avoid that. A member of the Planning Commission said they supported
the honorary signs if they were going to generate revenue but were concerned about who would keep
up with the times to take them down. The PC will consider criteria for an honorary street name program
at a future meeting.
Item number eleven on the agenda was the Zoning Administrator’s Report. Ms. Hall said in reference to
the North Gate Annexation that staff has a meeting the following day with a third-party attorney.
Northgate Development has given us a Statement of Intent, so we’re still hashing out how big the lots
would be, how many would be of this size, berms and buffers, vegetation on the berms and buffers,
amenities and where they would be, and the phasing schedule of what gets built when. They were
meeting to determine the legalities of it and what the next steps would be for Council to take for the
annexation. Then after they do the annexation, they could follow up with the details for the PDD so the
PDD has to come back in front of the Planning Commission. A member of the Planning Commission
asked about the rules for young children living in the community. Ms. Hall said they were looking at the
Housing for Older Persons Act to determine the requirements. Ms. Guffey said the minimum to be
considered a 55-and-over community required at least 80 percent of the houses to have at least one
resident over the age of 55. A member of the Planning Commission asked what the rules were about
children. Ms. Guffey said the HOPA was silent on that fact, but that doesn’t mean there can’t be rules on
it. Ms. Hall said they would need to determine how much of their rules needed to be written into the
PDD and how much they would need to enforce, and they can be different with different properties, but
they remain the same once they are set for a specific property. Ms. Guffey said in South Carolina, PDD’s
have to be mixed-use, which is why this PDD has a small commercial area. You can have a PDD that is an
older adult community, or one based more on a commercial part with some residential structures
sprinkled in. Hopefully they could be prepared at the next meeting to determine the requirements that
Ms. Hall previously mentioned and make a recommendation to Council. A member of the Planning
Commission asked how they would enforce the PDD if it was approved. Ms. Hall said all plans would
come through for approval by city staff.
A motion was made by Mr. Logan to adjourn, which was seconded by Mr. Wilkins. Being no further
business, Vice Chairwoman Nancy Davis adjourned the meeting at about 7:06 pm.
Respectfully submitted,
Rosina Parker
City Clerk
Approved at the August 11,2026, Planning
Commission Meeting.
Source: City of Gaffney website. First collected Nov 8, 2026.