City Council Meeting — Agenda Packet
City of Spartanburg · Spartanburg County · City Council · meeting of Dec 11, 2023 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Spartanburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
As required by the Americans with Disabilities Act, the City of Spartanburg will provide interpretive services for the City
Council Meetings. Requests must be made to the Communications & Marketing Office (596-2020) 24 hours in advance of the
meeting. This is a Public Meeting and notice of the meeting was posted with the Media 24 hours in advance according to the
Freedom of Information
CITY OF SPARTANBURG
SOUTH CAROLINA
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA
City Council Meeting
City Council Chambers
145 W. Broad Street
Monday, December 11, 2023
5:30 PM
I. Moment of Silence
II. Pledge of Allegiance
III. Approval of the Minutes of the November 27, 2023 Meeting
IV. Approval of the Agenda of the December 11, 2023 Meeting
V. Public Comment
**Citizen Appearance Forms are available at the door and should be submitted to the City Clerk prior to the start of the meeting.
VI. Proclamation Recognizing Cleveland Academy of Leadership
Presenter: Jerome Rice, Jr. Mayor
VII. Update on Use of American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Funding For Affordable
Housing Strategies
Presenter: Martin Livingston, Community Development Director
VIII. Resolutions
A. A Resolution to Authorize the City Manager to Enter Into an Employment
Contract for Municipal Judge
Presenter: Robert P. Coler, City Attorney
IX. Update on Morgan Square Project
Presenter: Chris Story, City Manager
X. Staff Updates
XI. City Council Updates
XII. Executive Session
A. An Executive Session to Discuss Proposed Contractual Arrangements
related to the potential lease of City Property Pursuant to Section 30-4-70
(a) (2) of the SC Code of Laws
Page 1 of 13
City Council Agenda Page 2
December 11, 2023
B. An Executive Session for the Routine Annual Review of the City Manager
and City Attorney pursuant to Section 30-4-70 (a)(1) of the South Carolina
Code of Laws
XIII. Adjournment.
City Code Sec. 2-57. Citizen Appearance. Any citizen of the City of Spartanburg may speak at a
regular meeting on any matter pertaining to City Services and operations germane to items within
the purview and authority of City Council, except personnel matters, by signing a Citizen’s
Appearance form prior to the meeting stating the subject and purpose for speaking. No item
considered by Council within the past twelve (12) months may be added as an agenda item other
than by decision of City Council. The forms may be obtained from the Clerk and maintained by the
same. Each person who gives notice may speak at the designated time and will be limited to a two
(2) minute presentation.
Page 2 of 13
City Council Meeting
City Council Chambers
145 W. Broad Street
Monday, November 27, 2023
5:30 p.m.
(These minutes to be approved at the December 11, 2023 Council Meeting)
City Council met this date with the following Councilmembers present: Mayor Jerome Rice, Jr, Mayor
Pro Tem Rob Rain, Councilmembers Erica Brown, Jamie Fulmer, Ruth Littlejohn, Meghan Smith and
Janie Salley. City Manager Chris Story, Deputy City Manager Mitch Kennedy, Assistant City
Manager Kevin Limehouse and City Attorney Robert P. Coler were in attendance. Notice of the
meeting was posted with the Media 24 hours in advance according to the Freedom of Information Act.
All City Council meetings are live streamed/recorded. To view the video for a complete transcript,
please visit https://www.cityofspartanburg.org/city-council
I. Moment of Silence – observed
II. Pledge of Allegiance - recited
III. Approval of the Minutes of the November 13, 2023 City Council Meeting –
Councilmember Fulmer made a motion to approve the minutes as received.
Councilmember Littlejohn seconded the motion, which carried unanimously 7 to 0.
IV. Approval of the Agenda for the November 27, 2023 City Council Meeting -
Councilmember Smith made a motion to approve the agenda as received.
Councilmember Brown seconded the motion, which carried unanimously 7 to 0.
V. Public Comment –
*Citizen Appearance forms are available at the door and should be submitted to the City Clerk
None
VI. Consent Agenda
A. An Ordinance Authorizing the Execution of a Development Agreement with
Palmetto Operating Company, LLC.
Presenter: Chris Story, City Manager
Councilmember Brown made a motion to approve the ordinance as presented.
Councilmember Fulmer seconded the motion, which carried unanimously 7 to 0.
B. An Ordinance Amending the Business License Ordinance of the City of
Spartanburg to Update the Class Schedule as Required by Act 176 of 2020.
Presenter: Robert P. Coler, City Attorney
Councilmember Brown made a motion to approve the ordinance as presented.
Councilmember Fulmer seconded the motion, which carried unanimously 7 to 0.
Page 3 of 13
VII. Resolution
A. Certifying a Building as An Abandoned Building Site Pursuant to the South
Carolina Abandoned Building Revitalization Act, Titel 12, Chapter 67, Section
12-67-100 et seq., of the South Carolina Code of Laws (1976), as amended,
regarding the property located at 641 East Main Street, Spartanburg, South
Carolina bearing Tax Map # 7-12-08-131.00
Presenter: Chris Story, City Manager
Councilmember Fulmer made a motion to approve the resolution as presented.
Councilmember Salley seconded the motion, which carried unanimously 7 to 0.
VIII. Approval of the 2024 City Council Meeting Calendar
Presenter: Christie Lindsey, City Clerk
Councilmember Fulmer made a motion to approve the 2024 City Council Meeting
Calendar. Mayor Pro Tem Rain seconded the motion, which carried unanimously 7 to 0.
IX. Staff Updates
X. City Council Updates- Each Councilmember gave updates on their activities since the
previous council meeting.
XI. Executive Session-
A. Pursuant to Section 30-4-70(a)(1) of the South Carolina Code of Laws Concerning
A Personnel Matter
Councilmember Fulmer made a motion to enter into Executive Sessions at 6:00 p.m.
Councilmember Smith seconded the motion, which carried unanimously 7 to 0.
XVI. Adjournment – Councilmember Smith made a motion to adjourn the meeting.
Councilmember Littlejohn seconded the motion, which carried unanimously 7 to 0. The
meeting adjourned at 6:25 p.m.
Christie B. Lindsey
Christie B. Lindsey, City Clerk
Page 4 of 13
REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION
TO: Chris Story, City Manager
FROM: Martin Livingston, Community Development Director
SUBJECT: Update On Use of American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Funding
For Affordable Housing Strategies
DATE: October 23, 2023
BACKGROUND:
The American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA), enacted in March 2021, provides State and Local Fiscal
Recovery Funds (SLFRF) to support a wide array of public health and economic challenges, including
affordable housing production and preservation. The SLFRF provides considerable flexibility and options
for states and localities to address the affordable housing crisis exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic.
It allows for direct investment in housing and the leveraging of additional resources through partnerships
and layered funding mechanisms. The City of Spartanburg received approximately $14 million in
American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funding. Below and attached describes strategies for deploying $2.5
million in funding for affordable housing.
Affordable Rental Strategy – $1,250,000
The City of Spartanburg will issue a Request for Proposals (RFP) to solicit development options for
affordable rental housing. Developers will have the option to propose developments on available city lots
and as well as privately owned properties. All funding sources available to the city will be used to assist
families at all income ranges. The city’s available allocation of HOME Partnership funds for rental and
homeless (HOME ARP funds) will be available to assist with developments that serve the homeless and
families below 60% of Area Median Income. The City’s ARPA funding will be used to assist rental
developments for families with incomes between 60% to 120% of Area median income. The city will
partner with a local Community Development Financial Institution – Community Works Carolina – our
current Spartanburg Housing Fund partner to deploy the funds and provide financial management. It is
the hope that developments can repay the ARPA funds to create a revolving pool of funds for long term
programs that generate affordable rental housing for the city. A maximum of $50,000 combined for all
sources will be allocated per unit with no more than $500,000 per development. This will allow at least
three developments in the city approximately 30 units or more as a goal for total developments. The
minimum affordability period will be 20 years per development. All properties will require inspections
periodically. The city’s investment will be secured by a mortgage for the affordability period.
Developments will be located in areas that are ARPA eligible areas and serve families that meet all funding
sources requirements. This will be the first round of offering for the ARPA rental development strategy.
Depending on the outcome, staff will issue another round of funding after July 1, 2024.
Page 5 of 13
Homeownership Strategy – $750,000
The city has a partnership with Community Works Carolina to manage its homeownership assistance
program. The program has assisted 10 families since 2017 with the purchase of their first homes. The city
has used Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funds for the program but will transition to using
HOME Partnership funds for any further assistance. The city has also assisted with homeownership efforts
working with several local and minority contractors to build affordable homeownership options on
scattered city-owned single-family lots. Both programs can be combined to assist families. The city still
has available single-family lots that can be used to develop homeownership options using the ARPA,
CDBG, and HOME Partnership funding. Staff is recommending issuing a Request for Proposals (RFP)
that would offer funding for donation of city owned lots, ARPA and city funding to assist in the
homeownership development efforts. Funding would be offered in the following homeownership Tiers:
Category Funding Activity
Tier I $10,000 Funding for closing cost assistance to families at or below 120% AMI.
Tier II $20,000 Developer funding for the development of homeownership lots between
60% to 120% AMI.
Tier III $30,000 Developer funding for the development of homeownership lots less than
80% AMI.
ARPA funds would be provided in the form of mortgages to the homebuyers amortized for 20 years and
repayable to create a revolving loan pool program. ARPA funds will serve families above 60% AMI.
HOME Partnership funds will be a deferred loan program amortized over 5 years and forgivable. Deferred
loan programs are converted to grants at the end of the term. HOME and CDBG Funds would serve
families below 80% AMI.
Owner-Occupied Repair Strategy – $500,000
Currently, the city has a U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Lead-Based Paint grant
program that serves families with children under six years old. There are more than 10 families that the
city could not serve with the program because there was no presence of Lead-based paint in the property.
Staff realizes that the repair needs of these families are important. The Lead-based Paint program at its
completion will have served over 30 families with children in the city. Also, the city has a partnership
with Christmas in Action to assist elderly families and individuals with critical housing repairs. These
programs are funded with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development – Community
Development Block Grant (CDBG) Funds. Approximately 10 families per year are served by Christmas
in Action. The city will issue a request for proposals for organizations that provide owner-occupied repairs
city-wide. ARPA funds will be provided to non-profit partner organizations that assist with elderly
homeowner’s repairs that have a need for owner-occupied repairs beyond critical repair and lead based
paint needs. The program would target elderly homeowners that have a need for repairs. The city would
offer funding to make repairs and a management fee to organizations assisting families. Funding would
be limited to homeowners at 100% AMI, elderly, and disabled. Any family with a home with a child under
six will be referred to the Lead Based Paint Program for assistance. This program will be a 5-year deferred
loan program to protect the city’s investment in the property. Deferred loan programs are converted to
grants at the end of the term.
Page 6 of 13
www.civitassc.com
1
To: Mitch Kennedy, Deputy City Manager
Martin Livingston, Community Development Director
City of Spartanburg, South Carolina
From: Karl Erich Chatham, Principal
Civitas LLC
600 Salty Alley
Mount Pleasant, SC 29464
Re: City of Spartanburg, South Carolina – Review of Eligible Uses of American Rescue Plan Act
Funding for Affordable Housing Programs
Background
The American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA), enacted in March 2021, provides State and Local Fiscal
Recovery Funds (SLFRF) to support a wide array of public health and economic challenges,
including affordable housing production and preservation. The SLFRF provide considerable
flexibility and options for states and localities to address the affordable housing crisis
exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic. It allows for direct investment in housing and the
leveraging of additional resources through partnerships and layered funding mechanisms. Below
please find a summary of eligible affordable housing programs as well as our recommendations
for how the City of Spartanburg might deploy the $2,500,0000 in ARPA funding that has been set-
aside for affordable housing programs.
Summary of ARPA Housing Program Options
Affordable Housing Development & Preservation: SLFRF can be used to finance the acquisition,
development, rehabilitation, and operations of affordable housing, both rental and
homeownership housing, as part of the response to the COVID-19 pandemic’s public health and
negative economic impacts (PH-NEI).
SLFRF can be utilized to finance the retrofitting and weatherization of properties to enhance
energy efficiency. This creates an opportunity to possibly leverage additional federal funding
sources like the Department of Energy's Weatherization Assistance Program, thereby increasing
the sustainability and cost-effectiveness of the housing units.
Page 7 of 13
www.civitassc.com
2
Predevelopment Activities: Funds can be used for predevelopment activities, including site work
and land acquisition, as part of affordable housing development or rehabilitation.
Adaptive Reuse: SLFRF enables the acquisition of properties such as market-rate rental units,
motels, or commercial properties, to be transformed into affordable housing units. This includes
both the conversion of these properties and the preservation of existing publicly supported
affordable housing.
Methods of Funding: Like the HOME Program, SLFRF may be used to fully or partially finance
long-term affordable housing loans with a minimum term of 20 years, provided the project has a
similar affordability period and other requirements are met. These funds can be layered with
other funding sources for new construction, substantial rehabilitation, and other housing-related
investments. This includes CDBG, HOME and LIHTC projects, as well as HUD’s Rental Assistance
Demonstration (RAD), Section 108 Loan Guarantee Program, HOME American Rescue Plan
(HOME-ARP), Project-Based Vouchers (PBVs), and others.
Documenting Eligibility for Housing Programs: Projects that meet certain requirements of
established federal housing programs, such as the Community Development Block Grant
Program (CDBG), HOME Investment Partnerships Program (HOME), and Low-Income Housing
Credit (LIHTC), are presumptively eligible for funding. For a project to qualify for presumptive
eligibility, it must adhere to four core program requirements:
1. Resident income restrictions (up to 120% AMI)
2. Affordability period and related covenant requirements for assisted units
3. Tenant protections
4. Housing quality standards
Recommendations for the City of Spartanburg
Given the nature of these funds being a one-time allocation, we strongly recommend utilizing
these funds in conjunction with other funding sources, including the city’s annual allocation of
HOME and CDBG funding as well as the HOME-ARP funding. To maximize the impact of these
funds, we recommend providing funds as repayable loans. Loans could be provided with a variety
financing options, including interest-free or below-market rate loans, deferred payment loans,
or loans with longer-term amortization. CDBG and HOME funds should then be focused to
provide forgivable funding for projects targeting lower-income households.
Page 8 of 13
www.civitassc.com
3
Below are our recommendations for deploying these funds in the two general categories
previously identified by the city.
Home Ownership Opportunities and Owner-Occupied Housing Rehab ($1,250,000):
1) If not already available, the city should establish an inventory of properties owned by the
city that might be suitable for housing development. Use CDBG funding to make site
improvements so lots are build-ready. Offer vacant lots to local non-profit development
organizations to build affordable home ownership housing. These organizations could
further utilize HOME and ARPA funds for low-cost construction financing to be repaid
upon the sale of the new home. The target population should be households between 60
and 80% AMI for lots improved with CDBG funds, or 80 to 120% AMI for all other sites.
2) Partnering with a local CDFI or community loan fund, provide home purchase assistance
in the form of second mortgages targeting households between 80 and 120% AMI. These
mortgages should be repayable, amortized for at least 20 years, with interest rates well
below market rate.
3) Focus CDBG funding for only emergency housing repairs for households at or below 60%
AMI. Utilize ARPA funds for minor housing repairs with a focus on only a specific set of
repair needs like roof replacement, plumbing repairs, and HVAC systems. Target ARPA
funds for households between 60 and 120% AMI. CDBG funds should continue to be
offered as simple grants while ARPA funds should be provided as repayable loans
amortized over 10 years with sliding scale interest rates based on household income.
Rental Housing Preservation & Development ($1,250,000):
1) Any city owned lots suitable for small multi-family developments should be made
available for local non-profit development organizations to build duplexes or other small
multi-unit developments. Again, CDBG funds can be used for site improvements then
HOME, HOME-ARP, and ARPA funds can be provided to subsidize the construction of
rental housing. Additional incentives could be offered for projects that commit to offering
affordable units for households below 50% AMI. Like the HOME program, funds should
be provided as mortgages amortized over 20 years, with below market rate interest rates,
and deed restrictions to enforce the affordability restrictions. Projects targeting
populations between 80 and 120% AMI should be required to repay the funding.
Page 9 of 13
www.civitassc.com
4
2) The city could issue an RFP for HOME and ARPA funding where eligible respondents would
include for-profit and non-profit affordable housing developers. Funds should be
provided for mixed income, multi-family developments where HOME funds are provided
to secure units targeting 50-80% AMI households and ARPA funds utilized to secure units
targeting 80-120% AMI households. HOME funds should be offered as deferred forgivable
loans and ARPA funds should be repayable. Like the recommendation above, funding will
be secured with second mortgage and deed restrictions.
3) ARPA funds could be paired with the very limited HOME-ARP funds to provide deep
subsidies for rental projects target households at or below 30% AMI as well as those
experiencing homelessness or at risk of becoming homeless. Like the two previous
recommendations, funding will be secured with second mortgages and deed restrictions.
We appreciate the opportunity to provide our thoughts and recommendations for the City of
Spartanburg. Should you have further questions or if you would like to discuss in more detail, we
are happy to be of further assistance.
Sincerely,
Karl Erich Chatham, Principal
Civitas, LLC
(843) 573-7825 office
(404) 408-1256 cell
erich.chatham@civitassc.com
www.civitassc.com
Page 10 of 13
INCOME LEVEL 1 Person 2 Persons 3 Persons 4 Persons 5 Persons 6 Persons 7 Persons 8 Persons
120% of AMI
NSP Program 66,450 75,950 85,450 94,900 102,500 110,100 117,700 125,300
100% of AMI
Median Income 55,375 63,250 71,188 79,063 85,438 91,750 98,063 104,375
80% of AMI
(Low Income) 44,300 50,600 56,950 63,250 68,350 73,400 78,450 83,500
60% of AMI 33,240 37,980 42,720 47,460 51,300 55,080 58,860 62,700
50% of AMI
(Very low Income) 27,700 31,650 35,600 39,550 42,750 45,900 49,050 52,250
30% of AMI 16,650 19,000 21,400 23,750 25,650 27,550 29,450 31,350
RENT LIMITS Efficiency 1 Bedroom 2 Bedrooms 3 Bedrooms 4 Bedrooms 5 Bedrooms 6 Bedrooms
HOME Rents
65% of AMI 880 944 1,136 1,303 1,434 1,563 1,693
Low HOME Rents
(5 or More HOME Units) 692 741 890 1,028 1,147 1,266 1,384
High HOME Rents 830 854 965 1,254 1,296 1,490 1,685
Market Rents 830 854 965 1,254 1,296 1,490 1,685
Effective: June 15, 2023
CDBG, HOME, and NSP Income Limits
City of Spartanburg, South Carolina
Based on U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) documentation
HOUSEHOLD SIZE
Information subject to change without notice. Please contact the City of Spartanburg Neighborhood Services Department at (864) 596-3560 regarding
updated income and rent limits.
Page 11 of 13
REQUEST FOR CITY COUNCIL ACTION
TO: Chris Story, City Manager
FROM: Robert Coler, City Attorney
SUBJECT: Contract for Municipal Court Judge
DATE: December 7, 2023
BACKGROUND:
City Council has completed its rigorous search for a new municipal court judge to replace Judge Erika
McJimpsey.
The attached resolution authorizes the City Manager to execute an employment contract with Attorney
Jacqueline Moss to become the new, permanent, full time municipal judge.
ACTION REQUESTED:
Approval for the City Manager to execute an employment agreement Attorney Jacqueline Moss to become
the permanent, full time municipal judge.
Page 12 of 13
RESOLUTION
TO AUTHORIZE THE CITY MANAGER TO ENTER INTO
AN EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT FOR MUNICIPAL JUDGE
WHEREAS, the Municipal Court for the City of Spartanburg was established by
Ordinance on December 15, 1980; and
WHEREAS, the Ordinance provided that the Court shall be presided over by one
or more full-time or part-time judges, at the discretion of Council; and
WHEREAS, City Council has reviewed and conducted interviews of qualified
applicants and desires to hire Jacqueline A. Moss as the Full Time Municipal Judge for
the City of Spartanburg ; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE MAYOR AND MEMBERS
OF COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SPARTANBURG, SOUTH CAROLINA, IN
COUNCIL ASSEMBLED:
Section 1. The City Manager is authorized to sign a two (2) year contract with
Jacqueline A. Moss, upon review by the City Attorney.
Section 2. The employment contract of the Municipal Judge will include terms
for the annual salary of the Municipal Judge as approved by City Council.
Section 4. This Resolution shall be become effective upon the date of enactment.
DONE AND RATIFIED this 11th day of December, 2023.
________________________________
MAYOR
ATTEST:
___________________________
CITY CLERK
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
CITY ATTORNEY
Page 13 of 13
Source: City of Spartanburg website. First collected Nov 8, 2026.