RecordWell Data

Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review — Agenda Packet

City of Spartanburg · Spartanburg County · Boards and Commissions · meeting of Oct 12, 2023 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Spartanburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

The City of Spartanburg Board of Architectural Design & Historic Review City of Spartanburg | Board of Architectural Design & Historic Review 1 AGENDA October 12, 2023, at 5:30 P.M. City Hall Council Chambers 145 W. Broad Street – Spartanburg, SC 29306 ( Please Note: Items as they appear on the Docket may or may not be considered in the order as they are presented. The Chairman will announce any changes after the roll call) I. Call To Order. II. Ro ll Call. III. F reedom of Information Act Compliance – Public notification of the City of Spartanburg’s Board of Architectural Design & Historic Review meeting has been published, posted and mailed in co mpliance with the Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the City of Spartanburg’s Zoning Ordinance. IV . Approval of Agenda. V. D isposition of Minutes from the September 14, 2023, Meeting. V I. Old Business: None. V II. New Business: 1. COA: 23-040-00061: Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 187 Carlisle Street (TMS: 7-12-14-286.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval of the construction of a single-family structure on a vacant lot. The property is l ocated in the R-8 SFD (General Residential – Single Family District). Owner: Thomas Wooten / A pplicant: Gabriel Weisser. 2. C OA: 23-040-00060: Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 544 S. Irwin Avenue (TMS: 7-16-02-237.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval to replace existing wood siding with Hardie board siding. The property is located in the R-8 SFD (General Residential – Single Family District). Owner/Applicant: Amy Wilhoit / Contractor: Freddie’s Painting. 3. C OA: 23-040-00062: Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 500 Pinckney Court (TMS: 7-16-02-072.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval of an addition to the rear of the existing structure. The property is located in the R-8 SFD (General Residential – Single Family District). Owner/Applicant: Henry Foster. V III. Update on Approved Certificate of Appropriateness for Minor Works since the September 14, 2023, Meeting. I X. Staff Updates. X. Ad journment. F or more information, please contact Martin L. Livingston, Jr., AICP, CPM, Community Development Director at (864) 580-5323 or by email at mlivingston@cityofspartanburg.org. Page 1 of 60 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2023-09-14 Page 1 of 5 Meeting Minutes of the Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review Tuesday, September 14th, 2023, at 5:30 PM City Hall Council Chambers The City of Spartanburg Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review (HARB ) met in City Hall Council Chambers on Tuesday, September 14th, 2023, at 5:30PM with the following members in attendance: Michael Pittillo, Bill Michels, Brandon Gaffney, Glory Boozer, Kenneth Brown and Sylvelie Franke. Representing for the Planning Department is, Martin Livingston, Community Director, Nan Zhou, Planner II, Tia Keitt, Planner II, and Oksana Holbrooks, Administrative Assistant. R oll Call: M r. Michels: Bill Michels Dr. Boozer: Glory Boozer. Mr. Pittillo: Michael Pittillo. Mr. Gaffney: Brandon Gaffney Mr. Brown: Kenneth Brown Ms. Franke: Sylvelie Franke Mr. Gaffney: Thank you all. As per Freedom of Information Act Compliance public notification of City of Spartanburg’s Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review meeting has been published, posted, and mailed in compliance with the Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance. A pproval of Agenda: A motion was made by Mr. Michels, seconded Dr. Boozer approve the agenda. The motion was approved with a vote of 6-0. M r. Gaffney: It’s been properly moved in second. All those in favor of accepting the agenda say aye. Attendees: Aye. Mr. Gaffney: Are there any nays? Ayes have it. Approval of Meeting Minutes from August 10th, 2023. A motion was made by Mr. Michels, seconded Mr. Brown approve the agenda. The motion was approved with a vote of 6-0. M r. Gaffney: Everyone had a chance to review the minutes . Mr. Michels: Bill Michels I make a motion to accept as presented. Mr. Brown: I’ll Second. Mr. Gaffney: It’s been properly moved in second. All those in favor accepting minutes from August 10 th, 2023 say aye. Attendees: Aye. Mr. Gaffney: Are there any nays? Ayes have it. O ld Business: N one. N ew Business: Page 2 of 60 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2023-09-14 Page 2 of 5 Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 575 Cecil Court (TMS: 7-16-02-269.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. Applicant is seeking approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness to install solar panels on the roof. The property is located in the R-8 SFD (General Residential– Single Family District). Owner: Terry Anderson / Applicant: William Clementi. Ms. Keitt: Good evening members of the HARB. Tia Keitt Planner with the City. I swear to tell the truth. Project Description and History The property owner, Mr. Terry Anderson, would like to install 10 solar panels on his roof. The contractor, 365Solar Energy, is proposing to connect five solar panels to the rear slope, and 5 solar panels to the front. The National Park Service’s website is clear on solar panels, https://www.nps.gov/orgs/1739/solar-p anels-on-historic-properties.htm, therefore, the contractor needs a decision from the historic review board regarding the placement of the five solar panels proposed for the front of the home. Drawings submitted by 365Solar Energy are included in the staff report, as well as pages from the Purchase & Installation Agreement. A nalysis Zoning Ordinance & Historic Design Manual Consistency The development request is subject to Section 510 of the City’s Zoning Ordinance, Historic Preservation. This section enables the Board to review applications involving historic structures and districts and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance. Section 510.4(c) Power and Duties of the Board Review application for and, where appropriate, issue Certificates of Appropriateness permitting the rehabilitation, alteration, reconstruction, or demolition of structures on or changes to Historic Sites. Findings 1. The character and appropriateness of the design – Each solar panel is about is 21.64sf [6.256’ x 3.45833’] and laid flat upon the roof. The solar panels are attached by a railing system. 2. The scale of the buildings – The scale of the building would not be impacted the installation of solar panels. The details state that the solar panels will not be higher than 6”. 3. The texture and materials- Solar Panels are a modern utility and contrasts materials typically associated with historic architecture. Installing solar panels requires several parts, including the rail system, mounting devices, and the 21.67 square foot panel, comprised of 66 solar cells, and weighs just under 50 lbs. 4. The relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate surroundings- There are a couple of homes in Hampton Heights that have solar panels that can be seen from the ground. 5. If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would be harmonious with the Historic District- NPS’ website states: an installation that negatively impacts the historic character of a property will not meet the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation. Page 3 of 60 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2023-09-14 Page 3 of 5 Applicant: William Clementi Consultant: Donnie Love, Preservation Architect Public Speakers: Rian Ivey, 608 Rountree Rd, Charlotte, NC 28217. Discussion: Historic District Guidelines don’t cover anything pertaining to solar panels. Possibly placing a battery and panels at the rear of property instead of front. With the demand for solar panels, we may need to revisit the guidelines in placement of solar panels at the rear. A motion was made by Mr. Michels, seconded Mr. Brown to deny the COA of solar panel placement of panels in front. However, if the applicant submits a redesign and placement of panels at the rear, than there will be no need to come before the HARB, but approval of Planning, with a vote of 6-0. Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – Applicant is seeking approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness to instal l a set of nine (9) roof mounted solar panels on the front roof. The property is located at 527 Beaumont Ave. in Beaumont Mill Village Historic District and is currently zoned as R -6, General Residential District (TMS # 7 -08-15-118.00). Landowner: Carrol and Virginia Painter; Agent/Contractor: Freedom Forever SC LLC/Brooke Bigham Ms. Zhou: Good evening board members. My name is Nan Zhou and I work with Planning Department. Project Description and History The project site is located on an approximately 6,861 square foot lot in the Beaumont Mill Village Historic District. The site is located on the east side of Beaumont Ave. The site currently contains one single-family home that was constructed in 1910. Thi s residential structure is a wood -framed bungalow with a brick foundation. The structure has an open porch in front of the house. This residential structure has a gable roof with comp shingle. The applicant is seeking approval from the Board of Architectural Design and Historical Review to install a set of nine (9) roof mounted solar panels on the front roof. The set of solar panels will take approximately 186.37 SF (14.88%) of the total roof area. The solar panels will be visible from Beaumont Ave Analysis Zoning Ordinance and Historic Design Manual Consistency The project site is located in the Beaumont Mill Village Historic District which has design guidelines for development. These guidelines are outlined in the Design Manual for the City of Spartanburg Historic Districts and Landmarks . The purpose of the Manual is to provide property owners guidance for the preservation and protection of historic and architecturally valuable districts and sites in the City. The project is also subject to Section 510 of the City’s Zoning Ordinance, Historic Preservation. This section allows the Board to review applications involving historic structures and districts and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance. Page 4 of 60 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2023-09-14 Page 4 of 5 The project site has a zoning designation of R-6, General Residential District, which allows for single family dwelling unit. Section 510.6 of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance list standards for reviewing Certificate of Appropriateness. Specifically, Section 510.6 (C)(2) states that in reviewing applications for new construction or alteration, the board shall consider the U.S. Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation and the five criteria listed in the findings. Findings Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C) 1. The character and appropriateness of the design – The proposed roof mounted solar panels will be placed on the front roof and do not interfere with any of the character defining features of the home. The proposed solar panels will maintain a low to median profile (3 inches minimum to 6 inches) ensures that they are appropriately designed so as to not seem out of character with the rest of the neighborhood. 2. The scale of the buildings – The scale of the bu ilding will remain the same. Adding roof mounted solar panels will not increase the scale of the primary structure. The proposed panels will maintain a low to medium profile (3 inches to 6 inches) and will not overwhelm the house or the site. 3. The texture and materials – The texture and materials of the solar panels will be solar glass (black) with anti -reflective surface treatment, and the frame of the panels is made of anodized aluminum (black). While the solar panels are clearly different from the asph alt shingles. the black color of the solar panels harmoniously will somewhat blend into the asphalt shingles. 4. The relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate surroundings – The proposed solar panels will not alter the pitch of the roof. However, properties to the left and right side of the project site do not currently have roof mounted solar panels on the front roof of the houses. Therefore, properties in the immediate surroundings do not share similar features of such elements . 5. If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would be harmonious with the Historic District – Despite the fact that currently in Beaumont Mill Village Historic District, there are no other houses having solar panels, adding solar panels will not drastically change the historic feature of the house and the historic neighborhood. Due to the low to medium profile of the solar panels, they would blend in with the District. Furthermore, as the photovoltaic industry continues to progress, it is likely that more homeowners will come to rely on solar panels in the near future. Applicant: Freedom Forever SC LLC/Brooke Bigham Consultant: Donnie Love, Preservation Architect Public Speakers: Virginia M Painter, 527 Beaumont Ave, Spartanburg, SC 29303. Justin Dabbs, 551 Fairview Ave, Spartanburg, SC 29303. Discussion: Page 5 of 60 HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2023-09-14 Page 5 of 5 Historic District Guidelines don’t cover anything pertaining to solar panels. Same as previous case solar should be placed at the rear of the property. A motion was made by Mr. Michels, seconded Dr. Boozer to deny the COA of solar panel placement of panels in front. However, if the applicant submits a redesign and placement of panels at the rear, then there will be no need to come before the HARB, but approval of Planning, with a vote of 6-0. Staff Updates: Continued Education Registration. Summons of two properties. The meeting was adjourned at 6:10 PM. ______________________________ Brandon Gaffney, Chairman Page 6 of 60 Planning Department PO Box 1749 • Spartanburg, SC 29304 • phone: (864) 596-2068 • email: planning@cityofspartanburg.org website: www.cityofspartanburg.org TO: The Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review RE: Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 187 Carlisle Street (TMS: 7 -12-14-286.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval of the construction of a single-family structure on a vacant lot. The property is located in the R-8 SFD (General Residential – Single Family District). Owner: Thomas Wooten / Applicant: Gabriel Weisser. Date: October 4, 2023 Project Description and History Before the HARB is an application for design approval and construction of a roughly 2000 sf home. Essentially a one and a half story home with an upstairs space of less than 550 sf, currently the home would potentially be three bathrooms & three bedrooms. Drawings, proposed materials and references to local house designs were submitted with the application and included with the staff report. Below is an image submitted by the builder. Page 7 of 60 Analysis Zoning Ordinance & Hampton Heights Historic Design Manual Consistency The development request is subject to Section 510 of the City’s Zoning Ordinance, Historic Preservation & the Design Manual for the City of Spartanburg Historic Districts & Landma rks, Section 6.0. Th ese sections enables the Board to review applications involving historic structures and districts and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance. Section 510.4(c) Power and Duties of the Board Review application for and, where appropriate, issue Certificates of Appropriateness permitting the rehabilitation, alteration, reconstruction, or demolition of structures on or changes to Historic Sites. Findings Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C) a. The character and appropriateness of the design – The proposed sketch is a nice historic house design with an inviting front porch . It’s different then neighboring properties where the home to the right has a porch with pickings and railings, and the home to the left does not have a front porch, but does have a side porch. The proposed design offers a different character than existing homes along Carlislie Street. b. The scale of the buildings – A one and a half story home to fill a vacant lot where Hydrick & Carlislie Streets intersect. The home that used to be there was a single story building with an enclose porch (image found in Vivian B. Fisher’s book) Neighboring properties are single story with low roof pitches with wide gables. As a two-story structure the pitch will be higher than adjoining properties and the scale will be impacted. c. The texture and materials – The builder plans to use materials to replicate historic homes: Harde Lap Siding, Painted wood True d Divided Lite Windows, Shutters, Asphalt shingle roof, Wood columns, trim and rafter tails. d. The relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate surroundings – The neighboring properties have a different pitch and the porch styles are in no way similar. Section 6.2.2 Directional Emphasis and 6.2.3 Shape states Guidelines for new construction within Hampton Heights Historic District. The front entrance of the new home is unique, and reminds you of bungalows from the low country area of South Carolina. e. If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would be harmonious with the Historic District – 313 Hydrick Street has a similar front porch style as proposed for 187Carlise St., yet the characteristics of the design stands out along Carlise St. It ’s definitely differs from the home that used to be at this location. Quick question, would the old design be approved today? Submitted by: Tia Keitt Tia Keitt, AICP /Planner II Staff Report includes: COA Major Works Application Permit # 23-0400061 Photos / Engineer Drawings / Solar Agreement Page 8 of 60 Page 9 of 60 Page 10 of 60 Page 11 of 60 Photo taken from page 61 of Hampton Heights of Spartanburg: It’s History, Houses, and People by Vivian B. Fisher. 2011 Page 12 of 60 Page 13 of 60 Page 14 of 60 Page 15 of 60 Page 16 of 60 Page 17 of 60 Page 18 of 60 Page 19 of 60 Page 20 of 60 Page 21 of 60 DONALD L. LOVE JR, ARCHITECT , AIA 608 Otis Boulevard, Spartanburg, SC · 864.415.0459 lovejrd@gmail.com October 1, 2023 Martin Livingston City of Spartanburg Neighborhood Services Director Re: 187 Carlisle Street Dear Martin, The purpose of this letter is to assist the Spartanburg Historic Architecture Review Board with a determination of appropriateness for the construction of a new residence at 187 Carlisle Street, in the Hampton Heights Historic District. Review of Guidelines for the Historic District forms the basis for my opinion. I have also reviewed the guidelines for new construction in Historic Districts from several other cities. The applicant has requested approval to construct a new residence on a vacant lot in the Historic District. Preliminary plans and elevations were provided. From my review of the preliminary plans and elevations, it appears the design meets the intent of the Guidelines in terms of building orientation and setbacks, directional emphasis, shape, massing, proportion, rhythm, and scale. The Guidelines state “new construction shall reference and not conflict with the predominant site and architectural elements of existing properties in the area of influence”. While new construction should be distinct, compatibility with the other buildings in the District is of a higher importance. My design review comments are as follows: • Final plans, elevations, and details must be provided for review. • The building appears to be sited properly with its orientation and setbacks compatible with the adjacent properties. • Although the proposed two-story house is between two single story houses, the massing appears to be compatible with other houses in the District. • More information is needed on the porch flooring. A wood porch floor is acceptable; however, the size and type of wood should be reviewed. It is unclear what is intended for the enclosure of the space under the porch. Continuing the concrete foundation would be appropriate. • The details for the rail at the rear entrance must be submitted. • A horizontal board with a drip edge should be added between the siding and the foundation . The lack of windows in the following spaces leaves large blank sections of wall on the exterior of the house which is not compatible with the other houses in the District. Early twentieth century houses generally had windows in every space . Adding windows to the following rooms would be appropriate: • Kitchen • Master bedroom • Master bath Based on my review of the documentation provided, the new construction will meet the Standards if the recommendations above are incorporated into the design, pending Board approval. Please let me know if you have any questions or require any additional information. Regards, Donald L. Love, Jr, Architect, AIA Historic Preservation Page 22 of 60 Planning Department PO Box 1749 • Spartanburg, SC 29304 • Phone: (864) 596-2068 • email: planning@cityofspartanburg.org website: www.cityofspartanburg.org TO: The Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review RE: Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – Applicant is seeking approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness to replace existing wood siding with Hardie board siding. The property is located at 544 S. Irwin Ave. in Hampton Heights Historic District and is currently zoned as the R-8/SFD (TMS# 7-16-02-237.00). Landowner/Applicant: Amy Wilhoit; Contractor: Freddie’s Painting. Date: October 5th, 2023 Project Description and History The project site is located on an approximately 10,934 square foot lot in the Hampton Heights Historic District. The site is located on the west side of South Irwin Avenue. The site currently contains one single-family home that was constructed in 19 26. This residential structure is a wood-framed bungalow with a brick foundation. The structure has an open porch on the right side of the house. This residential structure has a gable roof with comp shingle. The case came to Planning staff attention through code violation reported by two persons in the neighborhood about replacing the wood siding without a Certificate of Appropriateness and a building permit. A stop working order was issued by the Building Inspections Department. Staff went out and took some photos and discussed with the owner. Also, on the Certificate of Appropriateness application, the applicant wrote “the description of proposed work” as “some damaged wood siding needs replacing with new wood siding”. However, when Mr. Donnie Love, the City Historic Preservation Consultant, and City staff were on the site, we found out that the replacement of the damaged wood siding material is Hardie board instead of wood siding, not matching the “description of the proposed work”. The applicant is seeking approval from the Board of Architectural Design and Historical Review to replace damaged wood siding with Hardie board siding. Analysis Zoning Ordinance and Historic Design Manual Consistency The project site is located in the Hampton Heights District which has design guidelines for development. These guidelines are outlined in the Design Manual for the City of Spartanburg Historic Districts and Landmarks . The purpose of the Manual is to provide property owners guidance for the preservation and protection of historic and architecturally valuable districts and sites in the City. The project is also subject to Section 510 of the City’s Zoning Ordinance, Historic Preservation. This section allows the Board to review applications involving historic structures and districts and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance. The project site has a zoning designation of R-8/SFD, Single Family Zoning District, which allows for single family dwelling units. Section 510.6 of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance list standards for reviewing Certificate of Appropriateness. Specifically, Section 510.6 (C)(2) states that in reviewing applications for new construction or alteration, the board shall consider the U.S. Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation and the five criteria listed in the findings. Page 23 of 60 Page 2 of 17 Findings Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C) 1. The character and appropriateness of the design – The Hampton Heights Residential Rehabilitation Guidelines states “Retain original wood siding and repair rather than replace damaged material whenever possible. Whenever replacement is necessary, replace only deteriorated materials and match the original material in size, shape, texture, and material. Aluminum or vinyl siding is strongly discouraged. These materials are not successful in mimicking details of original wood siding (the most common material over which they are applied); subsequently, their use greatly compromises the historic integrity of buildings. Application often results in the loss or distortion of architectural details, and improper installation can result in damage of historic materials.” Also, The Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties with Guidelines for Preserving, Rehabilitation, Restoring & Reconstructing Historic Buildings states that “…identifying, retaining, and preserving wood features that are important in defining the overall historic character of the building (such as siding, brackets, window, and door surrounds. It is not recommended to remove or substantially change wood features which are important in defining the overall historic character of the building so that, as a result, the character is diminished. It is also not recommended to remov e a major portion of the historic wood from a façade instead of repairing or replacing only the deteriorated wood, then reconstructing the façade with new material to achieve a uniform or ‘improved’ appearance. When replacement is needed, the new work should match the old in material, design, scale, color and finish.” 2. The scale of the buildings – The scale of the building will remain the same. 3. The texture and materials – The texture and materials of the damaged siding replacement will be Hardie board. 4. The relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate surroundings – In the vicinity of the project site, staff notice houses having a combination of wood and vinyl sidings. 5. If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would be harmonious with the Historic District – Hampton Heights Residential Rehabilitation Guidelines states “ … in Hampton Heights, wood is the predominant exterior wall cladding material. The dominant exterior materials used in a neighborhood or historic district contribute to the visual relationships among buildings.” The original wood material should be retained and repaired rather than replaced with a new material. Therefore, the alteration would NOT be harmonious with the Historic District. Submitted by: Nan Zhou, AICP City Planner II City of Spartanburg Planning Department Page 24 of 60 Page 3 of 17 Attachments: Conditions of Approval Application Photos – Site Photos Specifications / Style of Proposed Windows Page 25 of 60 Page 4 of 17 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL FOR THE PROJECT ON PROPERTY AT: 544 S. Irwin Ave., Hampton Heights Historic District Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – Permission to replace damaged wood siding with Hardie board siding Zoning District: R-8/SFD; Landowner: Amy Wilhoit 1. If one or more of the following conditions is not met with respect to all its terms, then this approval may be revoked. 2. All plans for future construction which are not covered by this review shall be submitted to the City Planning Department for review and approval. 3. Major modifications to plans or exceptions to completion may be granted only by the City authority which approved the project. 4. This permit shall be exercised within six months of the date of final approval , or it shall become null and void. Extensions may be granted with permission of the Board. 5. A building permit shall be obtained from the Building Department prior to commencement of work. 6. The development of the site shall be in substantial accordance with the approved plans submitted and on file in the Spartanburg City Planning Department. Major modifications to plans or exceptions to completion may be granted only by the City authority which approved the project. Page 26 of 60 Page 5 of 17 SITE MAP – 544 S. Irwin Ave. Page 27 of 60 Page 6 of 17 ZONING MAP – 544 S. Irwin Ave. Page 28 of 60 Page 7 of 17 Photo – Front Page 29 of 60 Page 8 of 17 Photo – Left Side Page 30 of 60 Page 9 of 17 Photo – Right Side Page 31 of 60 Page 10 of 17 Photo – Property to the Right Page 32 of 60 Page 11 of 17 Photo – Properties to the Left Page 33 of 60 Page 12 of 17 Photo – Properties Directly Across from the Project Site Page 34 of 60 Page 13 of 17 Photo – Properties Directly Across from the Project Site Page 35 of 60 Page 14 of 17 Photo – Properties to the Left Side from the Project Site Page 36 of 60 Page 15 of 17 Photo - Properties to the Right Side from the Project Site Page 37 of 60 Page 16 of 17 Photo – Properties Across the Street from the Project Site Page 38 of 60 Page 17 of 17 Photo – Properties Across the Street from the Project Site Page 39 of 60 Page 40 of 60 Page 41 of 60 Page 42 of 60 DONALD L. LOVE JR, ARCHITECT , AIA 608 Otis Boulevard, Spartanburg, SC · 864.415.0459 lovejrd@gmail.com October 1, 2023 Martin Livingston City of Spartanburg Neighborhood Services Director Re: 544 South Irwin Avenue Dear Martin, The purpose of this letter is to assist the Spartanburg Historic Architecture Review Board with a request to install fiber cement siding at 544 South Irwin Avenue, in the Hampton Heights Historic District. Review of the Guidelines for the Historic District forms the basis for my opinion. I also reviewed Preservation Brief 8, Aluminum and Vinyl Siding on Historic Buildings : The Appropriateness of Substitute Materials for Resurfacing Historic Wood Frame Buildings and Preservation Brief 16 The Use of Substitute Materials on Historic Building Exteriors. The applicant has requested approval to remove selected areas of deteriorated wood siding on the front and sides of the house and replace it with fiber cement siding. On September 11, 2023, I visited the property with you, Ms. Nan Zhou, and Ms. Tia Keitt to observe the siding that had already been installed. The Guidelines for the Hampton Heights Historic District state that wood siding shall be retained whenever possible. When replacement is necessary the new material shall match the original in size, shape, texture, and material. The Guidelines also state that replacement with artificial material is strongly discouraged. The Secretary’s Standards for Rehabilitation state “deteriorated historic features shall be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement of a distinctive feature, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture, and other visual qualiti es and, where possible, material. Replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by documentary, physical, or pictorial evidence.” The original wood siding was determined to be rotten during the process of painting the house and was replaced with fiber cement siding prior to applying for the Certificate of Appropriateness. The new synthetic siding should be removed and be replaced with new wood siding to match the original per the Guidelines and the Standards. If new wood siding that is acceptable is not readily available, another potential solution is to remove wood siding from the rear of the house and use it to make the repairs to the front and the sides. Fiber cement siding can then be used to clad the rear. Please let me know if you have any questions or require any additional information. Regards, Donald L. Love, Jr, Architect, AIA Historic Preservation Page 43 of 60 Planning Department PO Box 1749 • Spartanburg, SC 29304 • phone: (864) 596-2068 • email: planning@cityofspartanburg.org website: www.cityofspartanburg.org TO: The Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review RE: Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 500 Pinckney Court (TMS: 7-16-02-072.00) in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District . The applicant is seeking approval of an addition to the rear of the existing structure. The property is located in the R -8 SFD (General Residential – Single Family District). Owner/Applicant: Henry Foster . Date: October Project Description and History Exactly one year ago, the applicant received a COA approval to finish construction of a 20’ x 20’ deck in the rear of his property. Over the past few months Mr. Foster began enclosing the deck and installing windows, ultimately creating a unpermitted conditioned space as an addition to the primary structure. The additional enclosure is built as a separate structure inches away from the home. A doorway from the back of the home leads to the new addition. Currently there is a STOP WORK ORDER in place by the Building Official. Mr. Foster was issued a Summons and appeare d in Court. A fine and a requi rement to submit a COA w as the outcome. Enclosed with the staff rep ort is the COA application and sketches submitted by Mr. Foster. Drawings from the original application are enclosed as a reference. The structure is currently unfinished. The Building Official has visited the property and has concerns about the existing structure. Planning Staff defers to the Building Official and Inspections Department to enforce Building Codes. Regarding the structure, Section 6.3.1 Additions to H istoric Buildings of the Hampton Heights Historic Guidelines is the focus of the Staff Report. Page 44 of 60 Analysis Zoning Ordinance & Historic Design Manual Consistency The development request is subject to Section 510 of the City’s Zoning Ordinance, Historic Preservation. This section enables the Board to review applications involving historic structures and districts and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance. Section 510.4(c) Power and Duties of the Board Review application for and, where appropriate, issue Certificates of Appropriateness permitting the rehabilitation, alteration, reconstruction, or demolition of structures on or changes to Historic Sites. Findings Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C) a. The character and appropriateness of the design – Final siding or details on how the home will be wrapped is yet to be determined. Currently the structure is a single room with three 36” x 62”: windows on each side. A sliding gl ass door faces the rear of the property with a view of the garage. A small deck is connected to the rear of the structure and wraps around the addition. b. The scale of the buildings – The front entrance to the home is not impacted by the addition. However, the side view of the home is visible from the sidewalk. The building’s foot print has been extended by 20 ft, plus the addition of a small deck that wraps around the building. c. The texture and materials – N/A All modern materials were used to build the addition. Final layer to be determined. The applicant plans to install solar panels on the addition. d. The relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate surroundings – The south side of the building can be seen from the sidewalk, but the front of the home is unchanged. The 400 sf addition has now extended the length of the home , wh ich is visible from the street. Homes that have more street frontage will have additional requirements, such as corner lots. e. If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would be harmonious with the Historic District – Page 45 of 60 The structure needs to come into compliance with the Building Codes. If the property owner installs a fence most of the addition would not be visible from the sidewalk. Right now as a new structure it is within the public’s view when walking down the street. If this was a corner lot the addition would have to meet design guidelines. At it’s current status the addition does not meet design guidelines. Submitted by: Tia Keitt Tia Keitt, AICP /Planner II Staff Report includes: COA Major Works Application Permit # 23-0400012 Photos / Sketches / Zoning Map Page 46 of 60 Page 47 of 60 Page 48 of 60 Page 49 of 60 Page 50 of 60 Page 51 of 60 Page 52 of 60 Page 53 of 60 Page 54 of 60 Page 55 of 60 Page 56 of 60 Page 57 of 60 Page 58 of 60 DONALD L. LOVE JR, ARCHITECT , AIA 608 Otis Boulevard, Spartanburg, SC · 864.415.0459 lovejrd@gmail.com October 1, 2023 Martin Livingston City of Spartanburg Neighborhood Services Director Re: 500 Pinckney Court Dear Martin, The purpose of this letter is to assist the Spartanburg Historic Architecture Review Board with a determination of appropriateness for the construction of a rear addition to the residence at 500 Pinckney Court, in the Hampton Heights Historic District. Review of the Guidelines for the Historic District forms the basis for my opinion. I have also reviewed the guidelines for additions to buildings in Historic Districts from several other cities. The applicant has requested approval to construct an addition to the rear of his residence in the Historic District. No information was provided for staff review prior to beginning construction. No certificate of appropriateness has been issued. On September 27, 2023, I visited the property with you and Ms. Tia Keitt to observe the addition. The work has been stopped by the Building Official due to the lack of a building permit. The basic form of the structure is partially enclosed and the windows have been installed. The new addition is to be connected to a prior addition, however that part of the work is incomplete. There is no exterior finish material or trim. A review of the Guidelines reveals the contradictions between the requirements and the actual construction. The Guidelines state, “additions must respect the character and integrity of original buildings and should incorporate design motifs that relate it to the historic building”. Two contradictions are immediately apparent. The eave of the new structure does not align with that of the original house as it is not as tall, and the windows are larger than the original with panes that are of the wrong proportion, and without divided lites. The windows should match those original to the house or be distinctly different. Close approximations meet neither the Guidelines nor the Standards. Compatibility with the original design is one of the most important items for consideration when building an addition to a historic house. Without it the addition does not meet the intent of Guidelines. My review of this addition concludes that it does not meet the Guidelines or the Standards and should not be approved. Please let me know if you have any questions or require any additional information. Regards, Donald L. Love, Jr, Architect, AIA Historic Preservation Page 59 of 60 STAFF APPROVED MINOR WORKS SINCE SEPTEMBER 14, 2023 MEETING  Approved  Date  Street Address  Approved Work  9/26/2023 521 Peronneau St Roof shingles replaced               Page 60 of 60

Source: City of Spartanburg website. First collected Nov 8, 2026.