Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review — Minutes
City of Spartanburg · Spartanburg County · Boards and Commissions · meeting of Oct 12, 2023 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Spartanburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2023-10-12 Page 1 of 7
Meeting Minutes of the Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review
Tuesday, October 12th, 2023, at 5:30 PM
City Hall Council Chambers
The City of Spartanburg Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review (HARB ) met in City
Hall Council Chambers on Tuesday, October 12th, 2023, at 5:30PM with the following members in
attendance: Bill Michels, Brandon Gaffney, Glory Boozer, Kenneth Brown, Mark Olencki, Tina
Wilson and Sylvelie Franke. Representing for the Planning Department is, Robert Cole, Attorney
for City of Spartanburg, Nan Zhou, Planner II, Tia Keitt, Planner II, and Oksana Holbrooks,
Administrative Assistant.
Roll Call:
Mr. Michels: Bill Michels
Dr. Boozer: Glory Boozer.
Ms. Wilson: Tina Wilson.
Mr. Gaffney: Brandon Gaffney
Mr. Brown: Kenneth Brown
Ms. Franke: Sylvelie Franke
Mr. Olencki: Mark Olencki
Mr. Gaffney: The Freedom of Information Act Compliance called for public notification to the City
of Spartanburg’s Board of Architectural Design and Historic Review meeting has been published,
posted, and mailed in compliance with the Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the
City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance.
Approval of Agenda:
A motion was made by Dr. Boozer, seconded Mr. Michels approve the agenda. The motion was
approved with a vote of 7-0.
Mr. Gaffney: It’s been properly moved in second. All those in favor of accepting the agenda say aye.
Attendees: Aye.
Mr. Gaffney: Are there any nays? Ayes have it.
Approval of Meeting Minutes from September 14
th, 2023.
A motion was made by Mr. Brown, seconded Dr. Boozer approve the agenda. The motion was
approved with a vote of 7-0.
Mr. Gaffney: Everyone had a chance to review the minutes .
Mr. Brown: I so move this is Ken.
Dr. Boozer: Second.
Mr. Gaffney: It’s been properly moved in second. All those in favor accepting minutes as presented
please say aye.
Attendees: Aye.
Mr. Gaffney: Are there any nays? Ayes have it.
Old Business: None.
HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2023-10-12 Page 2 of 7
New Business:
Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 187 Carlisle Street (TMS: 7-12-14-286.00) in
the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval of the
construction of a single-family structure on a vacant lot. The property is located in the R-8 SFD
(General Residential –Single Family District). Owner: Thomas Wooten / Applicant: Gabriel
Weisser.
Ms. Keitt: Good evening members of the HARB. Tia Keitt Planner with the City. I swear to tell the
truth.
Project Description and History
Before the HARB is an application for design approval and construction of a roughly 2000 sf home.
Essentially a one and a half story home with an upstairs space of less than 550 sf, currently the home
would potentially be three bathrooms & three bedrooms. Drawings, proposed materials and
references to local house designs were submitted with the application and included with the staff
report. Below is an image submitted by the builder.
Analysis
Zoning Ordinance & Hampton Heights Historic Design Manual Consistency
The development request is subject to Section 510 of the City’s Zoning Ordinance, Historic
Preservation& the Design Manual for the City of Spartanburg Historic Districts & Landmarks,
Section 6.0. These sections enables the Board to review applications involving historic structures and
districts and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance.
Section 510.4(c) Power and Duties of the Board Review application for and, where appropriate, issue
Certificates of Appropriateness permitting the rehabilitation, alteration, reconstruction, or demolition
of structures on or changes to Historic Sites.
Findings
Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C)
1. The character and appropriateness of the design –
The proposed sketch is a nice historic house design with an inviting front porch. It’s different
then neighboring properties where the home to the right has a porch with pickings and railings,
and the home to the left does not have a front porch, but does have a side porch. The proposed
design offers a different character than existing homes along Carlislie Street.
2. The scale of the buildings –
A one and a half story home to fill a vacant lot where Hydrick & Carlislie Streets intersect. The
home that used to be there was a single story building with an enclose porch (image found in
Vivian B. Fisher’s book) Neighboring properties are single story with low roof pitches with wide
gables. As a two-story structure the pitch will be higher than adjoining properties and the scale
will be impacted.
3. The texture and materials –
The builder plans to use materials to replicate historic homes: Harde Lap Siding, Painted wood
True d Divided Lite Windows, Shutters, Asphalt shingle roof, Wood columns, trim and rafter
tails.
4. The relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate
surroundings –
HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2023-10-12 Page 3 of 7
The neighboring properties have a different pitch and the porch styles are in no way similar.
Section 6.2.2 Directional Emphasis and 6.2.3 Shape states Guidelines for new construction
within Hampton Heights Historic District. The front entrance of the new home is unique, and
reminds you of bungalows from the low country area of South Carolina.
5. If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would
be harmonious with the Historic District –
313 Hydrick Street has a similar front porch style as proposed for 187Carlise St., yet the
characteristics of the design stands out along Carlise St. It’s definitely differs from the home that
used to be at this location. Quick question, would the old design be approved today?
Applicant:
Gabriel Weisser
Consultant:
Donnie Love, Preservation Architect
Public Speakers:
Gabriel Weisser, 3820 SC-414, Landrum, SC 29356.
Buddy Bush, Building Official for Building Department.
Discussion:
Historic District Guidelines don’t specify anything pertaining to new construction. Providing final set
of plans to Building Department for review, showing in detail how the proposed house will look like
in detail.
A motion was made by Mr. Brown, seconded Dr. Boozer to approve the COA with a condition
that revised drawings and modifications, be re-submitted to staff and Mr. Love, Mr. Michels
and another board member be present for review with a vote of 7-0.
Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – Applicant is seeking approval of a
Certificate of Appropriateness to replace existing wood siding with Hardie board siding. The
property is located at 544 S. Irwin Ave. in Hampton Heights Historic District and is currently
zoned as the R-8/SFD (TMS# 7-16-02-237.00). Landowner/Applicant: Amy Wilhoit;
Contractor: Freddie’s Painting.
Ms. Zhou: Good evening board members. My name is Nan Zhou and I work with Planning Department.
Project Description and History
The project site is located on an approximately 10,934 square foot lot in the Hampton Heights Historic
District. The site is located on the west side of South Irwin Avenue. The site currently contains one
single-family home that was constructed in 1926. This residential structure is a wood-framed bungalow
with a brick foundation. The structure has an open porch on the right side of the house. This residential
structure has a gable roof with comp shingle.
The case came to Planning staff attention through code violation reported by two persons in the
neighborhood about replacing the wood siding without a Certificate of Appropriateness and a building
permit. A stop working order was issued by the Building Inspections Department. Staff went out and took
some photos and discussed with the owner.
HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2023-10-12 Page 4 of 7
Also, on the Certificate of Appropriateness application, the applicant wrote “the description of proposed
work” as “some damaged wood siding needs replacing with new wood siding”. However, when Mr.
Donnie Love, the City Historic Preservation Consultant, and City staff were on the site, we found out that
the replacement of the damaged wood siding material is Hardie board instead of wood siding, not
matching the “description of the proposed work”. The applicant is seeking approval from the Board of
Architectural Design and Historical Review to replace damaged wood siding with Hardie board siding.
Analysis
Zoning Ordinance and Historic Design Manual Consistency
The project site is located in the Hampton Heights District which has design guidelines for
development. These guidelines are outlined in the Design Manual for the City of Spartanburg Historic
Districts and Landmarks. The purpose of the Manual is to provide property owners guidance for the
preservation and protection of historic and architecturally valuable districts and sites in the City. The
project is also subject to Section 510 of the City’s Zoning Ordinance, Historic Preservation. This
section allows the Board to review applications involving historic structures and districts and issue a
Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance.
The project site has a zoning designation of R-8/SFD, Single Family Zoning District, which allows
for single family dwelling units. Section 510.6 of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance list
standards for reviewing Certificate of Appropriateness. Specifically, Section 510.6 (C)(2) states that
in reviewing applications for new construction or alteration, the board shall consider the U.S.
Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation and the five criteria listed in the findings.
Findings
Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C)
Findings Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C)
1. The character and appropriateness of the design –
The Hampton Heights Residential Rehabilitation Guidelines states “Retain original wood siding
and repair rather than replace damaged material whenever possible. Whenever replacement is
necessary, replace only deteriorated materials and match the original material in size, shape,
texture, and material. Aluminum or vinyl siding is strongly discouraged. These materials are not
successful in mimicking details of original wood siding (the most common material over which
they are applied); subsequently, their use greatly compromises the historic integrity of
buildings. Application often results in the loss or distortion of architectural details, and
improper installation can result in damage of historic materials.”
Also, The Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties with
Guidelines for Preserving, Rehabilitation, Restoring & Reconstructing Historic Buildings states
that “…identifying,
retaining, and preserving wood features that are important in defining the overall historic
character of the building (such as siding, brackets, window, and door surrounds. It is not
recommended to remove or substantially change wood features which are important in defining
the overall historic character of the building so that, as a result, the character is diminished. It is
also not recommended to remove a major portion of the historic wood from a façade instead of
repairing or replacing only the deteriorated wood, then reconstructing the façade with new
material to achieve a uniform or ‘improved’ appearance. When replacement is needed, the new
work should match the old in material, design, scale, color and finish.”
2. The scale of the buildings –
The scale of the building will remain the same.
3. The texture and materials –
HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2023-10-12 Page 5 of 7
The texture and materials of the damaged siding replacement will be Hardie board.
4. The relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate
surroundings –
In the vicinity of the project site, staff notice houses having a combination of wood and vinyl sidings.
5. If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction would
be harmonious with the Historic District –
Hampton Heights Residential Rehabilitation Guidelines states “… in Hampton Heights, wood is the
predominant exterior wall cladding material. The dominant exterior materials used in a neighborhood
or historic district contribute to the visual relationships among buildings.” The original wood
material should be retained and repaired rather than replaced with a new material. Therefore, the
alteration would NOT be harmonious with the Historic District.
Applicant:
Amy Wilhoit
Consultant:
Donnie Love, Preservation Architect
Public Speakers:
Margaret Sullivan, 552 S. Irwin Ave, Spartanburg, SC 29306.
Ray Mayley, 498 S. Irwin Ave, Spartanburg, SC 29306.
Randy Cooksey, 539 S. Irwin Ave, Spartanburg, SC 29306.
Discussion:
The applicant has started worked work without obtaining proper permit. Once the permit was
submitted, incorrect description of work was provided on the application. Upon inspection of the
house, it was confirmed that indeed it was not in compliance. The breakdown of Hardie board
material and how it’s made does not meet the requirements of Historic District. It is not the
responsibility of Historic District and board members to address the financial cost of improvments of
each applicant, but follow the Historic guidelines. A new application should be re-submitted to the
correct work to be completed.
A motion was made by Mr. Michels, seconded Ms. Wilson to deny the request with a vote of 7-
0.
Certificate of Appropriateness for Major Works – 500 Pinckney Court (TMS: 7-16-02-072.00)
in the Hampton Heights Neighborhood Historic District. The applicant is seeking approval of
an addition to the rear of the existing structure. The property is located in the R-8 SFD
(General Residential – Single Family District). Owner/Applicant: Henry Foster.
Project Description and History Exactly one year ago, the applicant received a COA approval to
finish construction of a 20’ x 20’ deck in the rear of his property. Over the past few months Mr.
Foster began enclosing the deck and installing windows, ultimately creating a unpermitted
conditioned space as an addition to the primary structure. The additional enclosure is built
as a separate structure inches away from the home. A doorway from the back of the home leads to the
new addition. Currently there is a STOP WORK ORDER in place by the Building Official.
Mr. Foster was issued a Summons and appeared in Court. A fine and a requirement to submit a COA
was the outcome. Enclosed with the staff report is the COA application and sketches submitted by
HARB – Meeting Minutes – 2023-10-12 Page 6 of 7
Mr. Foster. Drawings from the original application are enclosed as a reference. The structure is
currently unfinished. The Building Official has visited the property and has concerns about the
existing structure. Planning Staff defers to the Building Official and Inspections Department to
enforce Building Codes. Regarding the structure, Section 6.3.1 Additions to Historic Buildings of
the Hampton Heights Historic Guidelines is the focus of the Staff Report.
Analysis
Zoning Ordinance & Historic Design Manual Consistency
The development request is subject to Section 510 of the City’s Zoning Ordinance, Historic
Preservation. This section enables the Board to review applications involving historic structures and
districts and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness subject to the Standards listed in the Ordinance.
Section 510.4(c) Power and Duties of the Board Review application for and, where appropriate, issue
Certificates of Appropriateness permitting the rehabilitation, alteration, reconstruction, or demolition
of structures on or changes to Historic Sites.
Findings
Certificate of Appropriateness, Section 510.6 (C)
1. The character and appropriateness
of the design –
Final siding or details on how the home will be wrapped is yet to be determined. Currently the
structure is a single room with three 36” x 62”: windows on each side. A sliding glass door
faces the rear of the property with a view of the garage. A small deck is connected to the rear of
the structure and wraps around the addition.
2.
The scale of the buildings –
The front entrance to the home is not impacted by the addition. However, the side view of the
home is visible from the sidewalk. The building’s foot print has been extended by 20 ft, plus the
addition of a small deck that wraps around the building.
3. The texture and materials –
N/A All modern materials were used to build the addition. Final layer to be determined. The
applicant plans to install solar panels on the addition.
4. The relationship of such elements to similar features of structures in the immediate
surroundings –
The south side of the building can be seen from the sidewalk, but the front of the home is
unchanged. The 400 sf addition has now extended the length of the home, which is visible from
the street. Homes that have more street frontage will have additional requirements, such as
corner lots.
5. If the property is in a Historic District, the extent to which the alteration or construction
would be harmonious with the Historic District –
The structure needs to come into compliance with the Building Codes. If the property owner
installs a fence most of the addition would not be visible from the sidewalk. Right now as a new
structure it is within the public’s view when walking down the street. If this was a corner lot the
addition would have to meet design guidelines. At it’s current status the addition does not meet
design guidelines.
Applicant:
Henry Foster.
Source: City of Spartanburg website. First collected Nov 8, 2026.