RecordWell Data

Board of Zoning and Appeals — Agenda Packet

City of Spartanburg · Spartanburg County · Boards and Commissions · meeting of Sep 12, 2023 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Spartanburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

The City of Spartanburg Board of Zoning Appeals City of Spartanburg | Board of Zoning Appeals 1 AGENDA September 12, 2023, at 5:15 P.M. City Hall Council Chambers 145 W. Broad Street – Spartanburg, SC 29306 (Please Note: Items as they appear on the Docket may or may not be considered in the order as they are presented. The Chairman will announce any changes after the roll call) I. C all To Order. II. Roll Call. III. Freedom Of Information Act Compliance – Public notification of Board of Zoning A ppeals meeting has been published, posted and mailed in compliance with the Freedom of Information Act and the Requirements of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance. IV. Approval of Agenda. V. Disposition of Meeting Minutes from the July 11, 2023, Meeting. VI. Old Business: None. VII. New Business: 1. AP P-23-020-0010: The City of Spartanburg’s Board of Zoning Appeals has received an appeal to t he Sign Ordinance size requirements for the Shine on Pine development located at 1425 Union S treet (TMS: 7-17-10-026.00); with a zoning designation of I-1 (Light Industrial District). Owner: GWH Carwash Landing Holdings, LLC / Applicant: SkyVision Signs / Agent: Cole Israel. 2. AP P-23-020-0011: The City of Spartanburg’s Board of Zoning Appeals has received an appeal to t he City suspending new antennas on the cell tower located at 138 S. Church Street (TMS: 7-12- 21-066.00); with a zoning designation of DT-5 (Downtown Urban District). Owner: Crown C astle USA, Inc / Applicant: Brittany Beam; Tower Engineering Professionals. VIII. Staff Announcements. IX. Adjournment. F or more information, please contact Martin L. Livingston, Jr., AICP, CPM, Community Development Director at (864) 58 0-5323 or by email at mlivingston@cityofspartanburg.org. Page 1 of 36 BZA - Meeting Minutes - 2023-06-13 Page 1 of 9 Meeting Minutes of the Board of Zoning Appeals Tuesday, July 11th , 2023, at 5:15 PM City Hall Council Chambers The Board of Zoning Appeals met in City Hall Council Chambers on Tuesday, June 13th, 2023, at 5:15PM with the following members in attendance: Brian Murdoch, McKay Moore, Brian Cohen, Darren Matz, Dominique Dawkins and Don Bramblett. Representing for the Planning Department is Martin Livingston, Community Director, Bob Coler, City Attorney, Nan Zhou, Planner I, Tia Keitt, Planner II, and Oksana Holbrooks, Administrative Assistant. Roll Call: Mr. Bramblett: Don Bramblett Ms. Moore: McKay Moore. Mr. Matz: Darren Matz. Mr. Murdoch: Brian Murdoch. Mr. Cohen: Brian Cohen. Ms. Dawkins: Dominique Dawkins Mr. Matz: Okay, thanks. Real quick we’ll read the Freedom of Information Act Compliance. Freedom of Information Act Compliance public notification Board of Zoning Appeals meeting has been published, posted, and mailed in compliance with the Freedom of Information Act and the requirements of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance. Approval of Agenda: A motion was made by Mr. Bramblett, seconded Ms. Moore to approve the agenda. The motion was approved with a vote of 6-0 Mr. Bramblett: I move to approve the agenda. Mr. Matz: Okay, second? Ms. Moore: Second Mr. Matz: All in favor of motion say aye? Attendees: Aye. Mr. Michels: All opposed? Nay. Okay. Mr. Michels: Okay disposition of minutes from June 13 th meeting minutes from the last meeting. Is there any comments that we need to add? Approval of Meeting Minutes from June 13th, 2023. A motion was made by Ms. Moore seconded Mr. Cohen to approve the meeting minutes. The motion was approved with a vote of 6-0 Ms. Moore: I move we approve with any submitted changes. Mr. Matz: Second. Mr. Cohen: Second Mr. Matz: All in favor? Attendees: Aye. Page 2 of 36 BZA - Meeting Minutes - 2023-06-13 Page 2 of 9 Mr. Matz: Aye’s have it. Old Business: VAR-23-00200005 The City of Spartanburg’s Board of Zoning Appeals has received a Variance request to the minimum lot size requirement for a development Caulder Avenue Duplexes located at Caulder Ave. (TMS # 7-16-08-078.00; 7-16-08-079.00; 7-16-08-080.00; 7-16-08-081.00; 7-16-08-082.00; 7-16-12-002.00; 7-16-12-003.00; 7-16-12-004.00; 7-16-12- 005.00; 7-16-12-006.00; 7-16-12-007.00); with a zoning designation of R-12 (General Residential District). Owner / Applicant: Spartanburg Housing / Agent: Paul Mills, Site Design Inc. Mr. Matz: Before we get started , can you please state you name and swear you in please? Ms. Zhou: Yes, good evening board members my name is Nan Zhou and I work with the Planning Department. I swear I’ll tell the truth. Project Description and History The project sites are approximately 150,218 square foot lots located in the R-12 (General Residential District) zone. The project site abuts Caulder Avenue to the southeast boundary. The project site is surrounded by R-12, General Residential District, across from Caulder Ave., R-6, General Residential District to the west side of the project site, and R-15, Single Family Residential District to the north side of the project side. The applicant/agent is proposing to build 24 affordable duplex housing units on the lots. However, due to the requirement of Group Housing Project Minimum Project Area – 4 Acres or more (R-12), the current lots’ total square footage is 3.95 Acre, and the owner does not own the adjacent surrounding lots. Therefore, a request of reducing the minimum project area down from 4 acres to 3.95 acres is needed in order for the applicant/agent to accomplish the affordable housing project. Analysis Zoning Ordinance Consistency The project site has a zone designation of R-12, General Residential District. Section 302.2 R-12 General Residential District Uses Permitted by Right of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance, R-12, General Residential District, does allow for two family and multi-family dwellings. However, given the available size of the land for the development of the proposed project, the applicant is seeking a minimum project size reduction variance for group housing projects. A Variance may be granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals to the minimum size standards required in the ordinance. Variances may only be granted in the instances listed in Section 603.4. Section 603.4 lists nine particular instances in which the Board may grant a Variance. Of these nine, two are applicable to this project; Section 603.4 (1): To permit any yard less than the requirements of this Ordinance. Section 603.4 (3): To permit the use of a lot or lots for a use otherwise prohibited solely because of the insufficient area or width of the lot or lots, but in no event shall the respective area and width of the lot or lots be less than eighty percent (80%) of the required area and width. The Board must utilize Section 603.3(A)(2) and determine if the proposal meets all the criterion for approval. To hear and decide appeals for Variance from the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the Ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. A Variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes and explains in writing the following findings: a. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; Page 3 of 36 BZA - Meeting Minutes - 2023-06-13 Page 3 of 9 b. These conditions do not generally apply to other properties in the vicinity; c. Because of these conditions, the application of the Ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and d. The authorization of a Variance will not be of substantial detriment to the adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the Variance. e. In granting a Variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the Board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. Findings 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property – Currently, the total combined square footage of the parcels is 3.95 acres which falls short of the required 4 acres for minimum group housing projects by 0.05 acres. The owner of these parcels does not own any of the adjacent surrounding lands, prohibiting them from recombining additional lands from the surroundings to make up the shortage of 0.05 acres. 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other properties in the vicinity – Properties located to the west side of the proposed project site are zoned R-6, General Residential District, and properties located to the northeast of the proposed project site are zoned for R-15, Single Family Residential District. If the proposed project parcels are zoned as R-6, General Residential District, then it would meet the minimum project areas required by the Zoning Ordinance. 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the Ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and – By granting the reduction of minimum project area for group housing projects, it will allow the landowner to accomplish building 24 affordable duplex housing units on these parcels. Otherwise, the proposed project cannot be developed with the desired number of affordable housing units. 4. The authorization of a Variance will not be of substantial detriment to the adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the Variance– No substantial detriment or harm will be caused to the general public good. The character of the district will not be harmed by the grating of the Variance since the neighborhood will still remain as residential uses. Furthermore, the total area of the proposed project area is 3.95 acres which is equal to 98.75% of the required area, 4 acres. 5. In granting a Variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the Board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare– In the event the Board finds that the Variance finding can be met and the project approved, conditions of approval are attached to this report. The Board may choose to approve or amend them based on the outcome of this proposal. Applicant: Zedekiah Heydenburg, Engineer of Site Design Joseph Jackson, Spartanburg Housing Development Director Page 4 of 36 BZA - Meeting Minutes - 2023-06-13 Page 4 of 9 Public Comments: Annie Kerns, 293 S Converse St, Spartanburg, SC 29306. Sonja Rice, 547 Caulder Ave, Spartanburg, SC 29306. Discussion: The need of the surrounding neighbors, the upkeep, the lighting and trash pickup, landscape and property value to the surrounding properties. If the project was to get denied the developer can rezone to a much more densely zoned requirement and have more buildings and be more populated. A motion was made by Mr. Bramblett, seconded Mr. Murdoch to approve with a vote of 4- 2. New Business: APP-23-020-0008: The City of Spartanburg’s Board of Zoning Appeals has received an appeal to the Bufferyard Requirements for the development of the Coke Facility Redevelopment Phase I located at 500 W. Main Street (TMS: 7-12-13-024.00); with a zoning designation of B-3 PDD (General Business – Planned Development District). Owner: Palmetto Operating Company, LLC / Applicant: Brett Baumgarten / Agent: Danny Balon; Seamon Whiteside Engineering Mr. Matz: Before we get started can you please state your name and relation to case please. Mr. Matz: You promiser to tell the truth? Ms. Keitt: Yes, Tia Keitt Planner with City of Spartanburg Planning Department. Project Description and History Palmetto Operating Company and Coastal Partners, LLC are working on the adaptive reuse site, 500 West Main St., formerly the Coca Cola Bottling Company, and transitioning the site into mixed-use commerical. The developers have hired Seamon Whiteside Engineering to conduct site analysis and to carry the project through rezoning, site plan review and now before the BZA to Appeal Zoning Ordinance Bufferyard requirements: §505.64 Landscaping Requirements for Buffers. Per the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance, the commerical redevelopment project is considered Medium Intensity Commerical. This use next to an existing single family district zoning requires the Bufferyard 4 landscaping between these two uses for the p rotection of residents from potential light and noise. See Table 505.1 entitled Buffered Yard Requirements (p. 169) of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance for the complete table The applicant is Appealing the required Bufferyard as outlined in Section 505 Tree Protection and Landscaping and have submitted the Zoning Appeals application through the Planning Department. Analysis Zoning Ordinance Consistency 505.64 Landscaping Requirements for Buffers A. Applicability. The purpose of a buffer is to protect existing low intensity land uses from being devalued or hurt caused by the effects of new higher intensity uses. The developer, owner or tenant of a new higher intensity use is required to install landscaped buffers adjacent to, but on their side Page 5 of 36 BZA - Meeting Minutes - 2023-06-13 Page 5 of 9 of, common property lines to protect existing lower-intensity uses. Buffers shall be required for all developed or redeveloped portions of a property based on the primary use of the property whether or not the primary use is located on a specific portion of the property. B. Bufferyard Requirements A proposed land use which is medium intensity commercial, high intensity commercial, light industrial or heavy industrial which abuts a single family residential use or multiple family residential use shall include a brick or stucco wall as part of the bufferyard. The wall, fence or berm illustrated in the bufferyard can be located on either side of the required bufferyard, but typically shall be located on the highest elevation within the bufferyard in order to maximize the screening function. The exact placement of required plants shall be the decision of the developer except that evergreen (or conifer) plant materials shall be planted in clusters rather than singly in order to maximize their chances of survival and that plants shall be sited utilizing existing and proposed topography to maximize the screening effect. 603.3 Appeals. The Landowner /Applicant is seeking an appeal to Section 505.64 Landscaping Requirements for Buffers. Such an appeal shall be submitted within thirty (30) days after a decision by a board. Such notice of an appeal shall be accompanied by a check in the amount of $50 payable to the City of Spartanburg to partially defray the cost of giving public notice of such hearing, none of which shall be refundable. The Planning Staff shall forthwith transmit to the Board all papers constituting the record upon which action appealed was taken from. An appeal stays all legal proceedings. The Board must utilize Section 603.3(A)(1) and determine if the proposed Appeal meets all the criterion for approval. The Board must hear and decide Appeals where it is alleged there is error in an order, requirement, decision, or determination made by an administrative official in the enforcement of the zoning ordinance; The Board may grant approval of the appeal in an individual case of unnecessary [site] hardship if the Board makes and explains in writing the following Findings: Findings a. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; The engineering firm (Seamon Whiteside) states that the existing building is located approx. 3 ft. from the adjoining property. At 20 ft. or less, Bufferyard 4 requires a Masonry Wall structure and 5 canopy trees. The engineer states that the slopes are steep (see application) and the required footing would put the wall over 9 ft high. Also, the constructability becomes a challenge, whereas installing a fence minimizess land disturbance. b. These conditions do not generally apply to other properties in the vicinity; Topography, new land use vs. historic buildings with current zoning codes are condtions that developers run into when redeveloping a site to be an adaptive reuse project. The Zoning Ordinance requires the developer to install a masonry wall anywhere within the buffer zone with a minimum height of 6 ft. Portions of the boundary consists of a steep slope and the engineers would prefer not to disturb the hill. The have proposed to install a 6 ft tall stockade fence. Page 6 of 36 BZA - Meeting Minutes - 2023-06-13 Page 6 of 9 c. Because of these conditions, the application of the Ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and Enforcing the Zoning Code would prohibit and unreasonably restrict the proposed commerical mixed use of the property. d. The authorization of a Variance will not be of substantial detriment to the adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the Variance. Approval of the Appeal would not be of substantial detriment to the adjacent properties. There is an existing 6’ fence with trees and bushes that serves as a natural barrier between properties along Washington St. There are portions of the property where residents can look directly onto the old Coca Cola site. Residents of Washington and Monk Streets are nestled between two major thoroughfares and replace the required masonry wall with a fence wil l not impact the character of, nor harm the residential district. e. In granting a Variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the Board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. Planning Staff have attached Conditions of Approval. Please note that the site plans and the building plans have been approved for this commerical redevelopment project. Condtions of Approval help to protect abutting properties residential properties in consideration of public health, safety and general welfare. At the July 11, 2022 meeting, the Board may grant approval of the Appeal and allow a 6 ft. fence replace the required 6’ masonry wall, approve the appeal with conditions that includes Staff comments and any additional conditions designated by the board, or deny the request. In the case of a denial, the applicant would be required to meet the landscaping and bufferyard requirements as it is written, or appeal the Board’s decision. If necessay, the Board can also table the matter for the next meeting and request additional information for review. In exercising its powers, the Board of Zoning Appeals may, in conformity with the provisions of Section 603, reverse or affirm, wholly or in part, or may modify the order, requirements, decision, or determination, and to that end, has all the powers of the officer from whom the appeal is taken and may direct the issuance of permit approval. The board, in the execution of the duties specified in this chapter, may subpoena witnesses and in case of contempt may certify this fact to the circuit court having jurisdiction. All final decisions and orders of the board must be in writing and be permanently filed in the office of the board as a public record. All findings of fact and conclusions of law must be separately stated in final decisions or orders of the board which must be delivered to parties of interest by certified mail. Applicant: Brett Baumgarten & Danny Balon, Seamon Whiteside Engineering. Public Comments: Chris Sawhill, 104 N Daniel Morgan Ave, Spartanburg, SC 29306. Pam Mitchell, 201 Briarwood Rd, Spartanburg, SC 29301. Dave Wenstrup, 505 W Main St, Spartanburg, SC 29302. Page 7 of 36 BZA - Meeting Minutes - 2023-06-13 Page 7 of 9 Discussion: The multi-use of the proposed project and the intention behind it. Confirmation location of the building, fence, landscaping, setbacks and buffer in between running along the property line. How does this project effect N. Highpoint Street and dates of the proposed project site. Does the building meet the code requirements and setbacks of the proposed site. A motion was made by Ms. Moore, seconded Mr. Dawkins to approve with a vote of 5-1. Ms. Moore: I move we approve the appeal to change the buffer yard extension. Ms. Dawkins: Second Mr. Matz: All in favor? Attendees: Aye Mr. Matz: All opposed? APP-23-00200009 The City of Spartanburg’s Board of Zoning Appeals has received an Appeal to the Parking Lot Landscaping Requirements for a commercial development located at 228 S. Pine St. and 453 E. Henry St. (TMS # 7-12-11- 284.00 & 7-12-11-284.02); with a zoning designation of B -3 (General Business District). Owner/Applicant: Newburg Investment / Agent Raj Patel. Ms. Zhou: My name is Nan Zhou and I’m here to present the last case request and it’s also an appeal for 228 S Pine St. Actually this request involves two pieces of property. Project Description and History The project sites are approximately 52,272 square foot (1.2 acre) commercial lots located at 228 S. Pine St. (TMS # 7-12-11- 284.00) and 453 E. Henry St. (TMS # 7 -12-11-284.02). The lots are currently zoned for B-3, General Business District. 228 S. Pine St. site contains one-story building that was a fast -food restaurant. 453 E. Henry St. currently is a bank contains one -story building with a drive through. The proposed redevelopment plan for the two lots will be a mixed -use development containing retail stores and restaurant with alcohol sales. The applicant is requesting an appeal to not installing tree islands which will take away one (1) parking space from the last row of the parking spaces (west side of the site). Based on the site plan, fifty-seven (57) parking spaces are provided for the site redevelopment based on the proposed use. Therefore, based on the current City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance Section 505 Tree Protection and Landscaping Requirements 505.62 Parking Lot Landscaping Requirements (B), One (1) Tree Island is required for the last row of the parking spaces (west side of the site). The requested appeal is to challenge the Parking Lot Landscaping requirements based on staff interpretation of tree islands needed to adhere to. The Landowner /Applicant is seeking an appeal to Parking Lot Landscaping Requirements, specifically to the one tree island installation needed for the last row of parking spaces (west side of the site) based on the number of parking spaces provided. The owner states that the current parking layout has taken advantage of sites’ horizontal limitation to provide the maximum number of parking spaces as required. Installing one (1) tree island per twelve (12) single row with each island having one (1) large canopy tree will reduce the number of parking spaces provided on the site as required and needed, which may bring concerns such as traffic flow, street access, and services needs of the potential tenants. Page 8 of 36 BZA - Meeting Minutes - 2023-06-13 Page 8 of 9 Such an appeal shall be submitted no later than ten (10) days after the start of construction or within thirty (30) days after a decision by a board, commission, or bureau, or a decision of the Zoning Administrator, whichever is lesser. Such notice of an appeal, special exception, or variance shall be accompanied by a check in the amount of $50 payable to the City of Spartanburg to partially defray the cost of giving public notice of such hearing, none of which shall be refundable. The officer from whom the appeal is taken shall forthwith transmit to the Board all papers constituting the record upon which action appealed was taken from. An appeal stays all legal proceedings in furtherance of the action appeal from, unless the officer from whom the appeal is taken certifies to the Board, after the notice of appeal shall have been filed with him, that by reason of facts stated in the certificate a stay would, in his opinion, cause imminent peril to life and property. In such case, proceedings shall not be stayed otherwise than by a restraining order which may be granted by this Board or by a court of record on application, on notice to the officer from whom the appeal is taken, and on due cause shown. To hear and decide appeals where it is alleged there is error in an order, requirement, decision, or determination made by an administrative official in the enforcement of the zoning ordinance. Analysis Zoning Ordinance Consistency The project site has a zoning designation of B-3 – General Business District. The zoning designation of the sites allows for mixed-use development such as a restaurant. The applicability of parking lot landscaping requirements shall apply to all surface parking lots containing more than four (4) parking spaces. In addition, these parking lot landscaping requirements shall apply to outdoor areas that store that have storage areas of 3,000 square foot or more. Also, the purpose of requiring parking lot landscaping is not only trying to beautify the parking lot, but also function to provide natural drainage and filter stormwater. The Board must utilize Section 603.3(A)(2) and determine if the proposal meets all the criterion for approval. To hear and decide Appeal from the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance when strict application of the provisions of the Ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. Am appeal may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the Board makes and explains in writing the following findings: a. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; b. These conditions do not generally apply to other properties in the vicinity; c. Because of these conditions, the application of the Ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and d. The authorization of a Variance will not be of substantial detriment to the adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the Variance. e. In granting a Variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the Board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. Findings 1. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property – Currently, the site is surrounded by three public roads, E. Henry St., S. Pine St., and Ribault St., street parking is not an ideal option for the site if the number of parking spaces cannot meet the requirements on site based on the current Zoning Ordinance. Installing one tree island in the last row of the parking spaces will reduce the number of parking spaces on the site as required. Page 9 of 36 BZA - Meeting Minutes - 2023-06-13 Page 9 of 9 2. These conditions do not generally apply to other properties in the vicinity – Property across from the E. Henry St., Sugar-n-Spice was a non-conforming development that was in the City since 1940s. YMCA (Young Mens Christian Association of Spartanburg) on the right side of the project site has tree islands on their parking lot. Properties across from S. Pine St. Ward Law Firm and Regions Bank all have tree islands on their front parking lots. 3. Because of these conditions, the application of the Ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and – There is no indication that a strict application of the ordinance would prevent the use of the property. The proposed use of the property is still permitted-by-right based on the current City Zoning Ordinance. The parking requirement can still be in compliance with the current zoning ordinance based on the square footage of the uses proposed by the owner. Furthermore, installing bike racks can reduce the parking by up to 20% if the required number of parking spaces cannot be met for the site development. Proposed Retail – around 9,225 SF Proposed Restaurant with 75 Seats – around 3,000 SF 4. The authorization of a Variance will not be of substantial detriment to the adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the Variance– Approval of the appeal would not be of substantial detriment to the adjacent properties and would not influence the property values, public health, safety, or general welfare of the public. However, by allowing the site to not install one tree island may pose challenges to other site’s development in terms of meeting the parking lot landscaping requirements due to concerns about reducing parking spaces required based on the proposed use can be accomplished by installing bike racks on the site, which would allow up to 20% parking reduction. 5. In granting a Variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the Board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare– At this time, staff doesn’t believe that any conditions could be applicable to this situation. Applicant: Newburg Investments, Raj Patel. Was not in attendance. Public Comments: No public comments. Discussion: Going over the landscaping and layout plan. The requirements and parking lot size for the multi- use. A motion was made by Mr. Murdoch, seconded Mr. Cohen the request for the appeal was denied to the parking lot landscape requirements with a vote of 6-0. The meeting was adjourned at 7:33 PM. ______________________________ Darren Matz , Chairman Page 10 of 36 Planning Department PO Box 1749 • Spartanburg, SC 29304 • phone: (864) 596-2068 • email: planning@cityofspartanburg.org website: www.cityofspartanburg.org To: The Board of Zoning Appeals RE: APP-23-020-0010: The City of Spartanburg’s Board of Zoning Appeals has received an appeal to the Sign Ordinance size requirements for the Shine on Pine development located at 1425 Union Street (TMS: 7-17-10- 026.00); with a zoning designation of I-1 (Light Industrial District). Owner: GWH Carwash Landing Holdings, LLC / Applicant: SkyVision Signs / Agent: Cole Israel Date: September 5, 2023 Project Description and History History of Site • January 24, 2022, Annexation & Zoning Approved by the City of Spartanburg City Council . Zoned I-1 Light Industrial • March – April. 2023 - Building Plans Review begins • April 2023 - BZA Variance Request - to permit the reduction of any required setback being in compliance with all applicable Building and Fire Codes and subject to review by the Building Official • September 2023 – BZA Appeal Application to permit additional square footage for signage. After developing this 2.64 acre site, the owner is before the Board of Zoning Appeals requesting an Appeal from the Sign Ordinance. The proposed signage exceeds the maximum allowable signage for this location. First, Per the Zoning Ordinance, because this site sits at an intersection with two front streets, each “wall” is allowed signage following the City’s Zoning Ordinance (§ 503.43b). Furthermore Section 503.43a states that Per the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance, despite having walls on two front streets, the busness cannot exceed the amount of signage calculated using Table C of the sign ordinance. Tabel C from the Sign Ordinance below: Page 11 of 36 Using the guidelines above, the Planning Department has determined the maximum allowable , combined square footage for this location is 250sf, because, as stated above, the size of such signs cannot exceed the amount of signage permitted is Table C. The sign permit application submitted includes around a total of 319.192 square feet of signage. The owner is appealing the Planning Department’s decision and asking for an additional ±69 square feet of signage. Please note that the Planning Department anticipates more signage as the business gets closer to its grand opening. While additional signage may not be requested, below is a note regarding smaller signs: Page 12 of 36 Analysis Zoning Ordinance Consistency 603.3 Appeals. The Landowner /Applicant is seeking an appeal to 503.4 Signs Permitted in Office, Institutional, Business, and Industrial Districts. An appeal stays all legal proceedings in furtherance of the action appeal from, unless the officer from whom the appeal is taken certifies to the Board, after the notice of appeal shall have been filed with him, that by reason of facts stated in the certificate a stay would, in his opinion, cause imminent peril to life and property. In such case, proceedings shall not be stayed otherwise than by a restraining order which may be granted by this Board or by a court of record on application, on notice to the officer from whom the appeal is taken, and on due cause shown. To hear and decide appeals where it is alleged there is error in an order, requirement, decision, or determination made by an administrative official in the enforcement of the zoning ordinance. The Board must utilize Section 603.3(A)(1) and determine if the proposed Appeal meets all the criterion for approval. The Board must hear and decide Appeals where it is alleged there is error in an order, requirement, decision, or determination made by an administrative official in the enforcement of the zoning ordinance; The Board may grant approval of the appeal in an individual case of unnecessary [site] hardship if the Board makes and explains in writing the following Findings: Findings a. There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of property; This is a large site, but staff does not believe there are extraordinary nor exceptional conditions pertaining to this particular piece of property. b. These conditions do not generally apply to other properties in the vicinity; The Zoning Ordinance tries to address properties of various conditions, including businesses that fronts two streets and exceed a 500 feet lot line. c. Because of these conditions, the application of the Ordinance to the particular piece of property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property; and There is no indication that a strict application of the ordinance would prevent the use of the property. All other commercial sign requests are limited to the maximum allowed total signage . Applying the ordinance would require the property owner to limit the maximum signage to the exterior of the building to 250 square feet. d. The authorization of a Variance will not be of substantial detriment to the adjacent property or to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the Variance. Staff does not anticipate any s ubstantial deteriment to the adjacent properties. The public good, and character of the light industrial / business corridor should not be harmed by granting the Variance / Appeal. e. In granting a Variance, the Board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location, character, or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the Board may consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to promote the public health, safety, or general welfare. Approval of the signage request would not influence the property values, public health, safety, or general welfare of the public. Should the Board approve the appeal, the Board may require a condition that limits the signage amount by a percentage of the maximum or a maximum number square feet of signage. The maximum that would be currently allowed 250 Square feet based on the zoning ordinance. Page 13 of 36 At the September 13 , 2023 meeting, the Board may grant approval of the A ppeal and allow the business to install 319.192 sf of signage, Approve the appeal with conditions that includes Staff comments and any additional conditions designated by the board, or deny the request. In the case of a denial, the applicant would be required to meet the signange requirements as it is written, or appeal the Board’s decision. If necessay, the Board can also table the matter for the next meeting and request additional information for review. In exercising its powers, the Board of Zoning Appeals may, in conformity with the provisions of Section 603, reverse or affirm, wholly or in part, or may modify the order, requirements, decision, or determination, and to that end, has all the powers of the officer from whom the appeal is taken and may direct the issuance of permit approval. The board, in the execution of the duties specified in this chapter, may subpoena witnesses and in case of contempt may certify this fact to the circuit court having jurisdiction. All final decisions and orders of the board must be in writing and be permanently filed in the office of the board as a public record. All findings of fact and conclusions of law must be separately stated in final decisions or orders of the board which must be delivered to parties of interest by certified mail. Submitted by: Tia Keitt Tia Keitt, AICP Planner II Attachments: Conditions of Approval Application and supplemental items Photos CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL FOR PROJECT ON PROPERTY AT: 1425 Union Street (TMS: 7-17-10-026.00) I-1 Light Industrial 1. If one or more of the following conditions is not met with respect to all its terms, then this approval may be revoked. 2. The use shall meet the standards and shall be developed within the limits established by Chapter 501.10 of the Spartanburg Municipal code as to the emission of noise, odor, smoke, dust, vibration, waste, fumes or any public nuisance arising or occurring incidental to its establishment or operation. 3. Submit an updated sign permit application with the approved square footage. The applicant shall be responsible for the completeness and accuracy of all forms and supporting material submitted in connection with any permit application. Any errors or discrepancies found therein may result in the revocation if any approval or permits issues in connection therewith. 4. The development of the site shall be in substantial accordance with the approved plans submitted and on file in the Spartanburg City Planning Department. All aspects of construction must be completed prior to use. Major modifications to plans or exceptions to completion may be granted only by the City authority which approved the project. 5. All required structures (including fences) and plant materials in the bufferyard shall be maintained in perpetuity by the developer and his successors, including the homeowners association or individual property owners if there is no homeowners association. Page 14 of 36 Signage Ordinance Follow Up – 503 Sign Regulations 503.4 Signs Permitted in Office, Institutional, Business, and Industrial Districts. A. Total Area of Business Signs Permitted for Each Establishment. Subject to other provisions of this section, the total area of all business signs for an individual office, business or industrial establishment shall not exceed the square footage shown below [Table C] for each linear foot of front building wall or front lot line, whichever is greater. On- site directional signs shall not be included in the computation of allowable square footage provided such sign bears no commercial message or logos, does not exceed two square feet in area and does not exceed two feet in height. Painted signs shall be included in the computation of allowable square footage listed in Table C [below]. Wall, monument, and pylon mounted signs may exceed the allotted square footage of the property by 15% provided halo-lit lettering is used. Signs for individual businesses in Zones GID, LOD, LC, B-1, D-T4, D-T5, D-T6, B- 3, B-4, I-1 and I-2 shall in no event exceed in the aggregate 200 square feet in area. However, where the lineal footage of a lot exceeds 500 lineal feet, the maximum square footage of signage may be increased to 250 square feet. (pg. 119) B. If any establishment has walls fronting on two or more streets, the sign area for each such street shall be computed separately. The square footage allowed for each street shall not be combined to come up with an aggregate square footage that could apply to any one street. The size of such signs cannot exceed the amount of signage permitted in Table C above. Page 15 of 36 Page 16 of 36 Page 17 of 36 Page 18 of 36 Page 19 of 36 Page 20 of 36 Page 21 of 36 Page 22 of 36 Page 23 of 36 Page 24 of 36 Page 25 of 36 Page 26 of 36 Page 27 of 36 Page 28 of 36 Page 29 of 36 Page 30 of 36 Page 31 of 36 1 Martin Livingston From: Pieper, Donovan <Donovan.Pieper@crowncastle.com> Sent: Thursday, August 31, 2023 10:58 AM To: Martin Livingston; bbeam@tepgroup.net Cc: Manyatis, Tim; Fontana, Briana; Oksana Holbrooks; Tia Keitt; Nan Zhou Subject: RE: BZA 142 S Church St - 807210 CAUTION: This message has originated from an External Source. Please use proper judgment and caution when opening  attachments, clicking links or responding to this email.    CAUTION: This email originated from outside your organization. Exercise caution when opening attachments or clicking  links, especially from unknown senders.  Martin,     First off, thank you and your staff for the help here in processing this request.  We have been notified that Dish Network  does not wish to proceed with the Zoning Appeal.  Please procee d with rescinding that request and let us know if  anything is needed on our end.       Thank you,     DONOVAN PIEPER  Service Delivery Supervisor  T: (205) 909-2039 | M: (205) 261-3323 | F: (724) 416-4045    CROWN CASTLE  CrownCastle.com     From: Martin Livingston <mlivingston@cityofspartanburg.org>   Sent: Wednesday, August 30, 2023 8:23 AM  To: Pieper, Donovan <Donovan.Pieper@crowncastle.com>; bbeam@tepgroup.net  Cc: Manyatis, Tim <Tim.Manyatis@crowncastle.com>; Fontana, Briana <Briana.Fontana@crowncastle.com>; Oksana  Holbrooks <oholbrooks@cityofspartanburg.org>; Tia Keitt <tkeitt@cityofspartanburg.org>; Nan Zhou  <nzhou@cityofspartanburg.org>  Subject: RE: BZA 142 S Church St  Importance: High        CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the  sender and know the content is safe.     Dear Applicant:     Please note that staff has received your application for the cell tower antenna to the City of Spartanburg’s  Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA). The meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, September 12, 2023, at 5:15 PM in the  City Council Chambers at 145 W. Broad Street. City staff will be required to provide the follow ing notifications  and postings regarding the meeting:  Page 32 of 36 2    1. City staff is required to send a notice to property owners within 400 feet of the subject parcel(s) to  make property owners aware of the request. Property owners immediately adjacent to the subject  property will receive a certified letter regarding the request.  2. City staff is required to post the property. A yard sign notifying the public of the request and meeting  regarding the subject property will appear on the property this week.  3. City staff is required to make the public aware of the request by posting the request in the newspaper  of general circulation. A legal ad will appear in the Spartanburg Herald Journal Newspaper regarding  the request on Monday, August 28, 2023.     Attached for your review is a copy of the notice that was sent to surrounding property owners for your  records. The property owner should receive a copy of the notice in the mail. If you have any questions, I can  be reached by email or the number provided below or at planning@cityofspartanburg.org. Than ks.     Martin L. Livingston, Jr., AICP, CPM  City of Spartanburg  PO Box 1749  Spartanburg, SC 29304  Phone: (864) 580-5323  www.cityofspartanburg.org     From: Oksana Holbrooks <oholbrooks@cityofspartanburg.org>   Sent: Wednesday, August 30, 2023 8:25 AM  To: Martin Livingston <mlivingston@cityofspartanburg.org>; Pieper, Donovan <Donovan.Pieper@crowncastle.com>;  bbeam@tepgroup.net  Cc: Manyatis, Tim <Tim.Manyatis@crowncastle.com>; Fontana, Briana <Briana.Fontana@crowncastle.com>  Subject: RE: BZA 142 S Church St     Good morning,      Thank you for your inquiry. I have cc the assigned Planner for an update. Please let me know if you have any further  questions     Oksana Holbrooks  Planning Department / City of Spartanburg  PO Box 1749, Spartanburg, SC 29304 / (864)580-5269  planning@cityofspartnaburg.org       From: Pieper, Donovan <Donovan.Pieper@crowncastle.com>   Sent: Tuesday, August 29, 2023 4:43 PM  To: Oksana Holbrooks <oholbrooks@cityofspartanburg.org>; bbeam@tepgroup.net  Cc: Manyatis, Tim <Tim.Manyatis@crowncastle.com>; Fontana, Briana <Briana.Fontana@crowncastle.com>  Subject: RE: BZA 142 S Church St     CAUTION: This message has originated from an External Source. Please use proper judgment and caution when opening  attachments, clicking links or responding to this email.     Page 33 of 36 3 CAUTION: This email originated from outside your organization. Exercise caution when opening attachments or clicking  links, especially from unknown senders.  Oksana,     I wanted to check in on next steps for this site that we sent in the attached zoning appeal form.   Is there anything  needed on our end or questions?  When are the expecte d timelines for next steps?     Thank you,     DONOVAN PIEPER  Service Delivery Supervisor  T: (205) 909-2039 | M: (205) 261-3323 | F: (724) 416-4045    CROWN CASTLE  CrownCastle.com     From: Oksana Holbrooks <oholbrooks@cityofspartanburg.org>   Sent: Wednesday, August 23, 2023 7:25 AM  To: Pieper, Donovan <Donovan.Pieper@crowncastle.com>; bbeam@tepgroup.net  Cc: Manyatis, Tim <Tim.Manyatis@crowncastle.com>  Subject: RE: BZA 142 S Church St        CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the  sender and know the content is safe.     Good morning,                  Thank you for your payment. This will be applied to the permit.     Oksana Holbrooks  Planning Department / City of Spartanburg  PO Box 1749, Spartanburg, SC 29304 / (864)580-5269  planning@cityofspartnaburg.org       From: Pieper, Donovan <Donovan.Pieper@crowncastle.com>   Sent: Tuesday, August 22, 2023 4:01 PM  To: Oksana Holbrooks <oholbrooks@cityofspartanburg.org>; bbeam@tepgroup.net  Cc: Manyatis, Tim <Tim.Manyatis@crowncastle.com>  Subject: RE: BZA 142 S Church St     CAUTION: This message has originated from an External Source. Please use proper judgment and caution when opening  attachments, clicking links or responding to this email.     CAUTION: This email originated from outside your organization. Exercise caution when opening attachments or clicking  links, especially from unknown senders.    You don't often get email from oholbrooks@cityofspartanburg.org. Learn why this is important    Page 34 of 36 4 This has been paid via the online system, see attached for reference.     Thank you,     DONOVAN PIEPER  Service Delivery Supervisor  T: (205) 909-2039 | M: (205) 261-3323 | F: (724) 416-4045    CROWN CASTLE  CrownCastle.com     From: Oksana Holbrooks <oholbrooks@cityofspartanburg.org>   Sent: Tuesday, August 22, 2023 2:11 PM  To: bbeam@tepgroup.net  Cc: Pieper, Donovan <donovan.pieper@crowncastle.com>  Subject: FW: BZA 142 S Church St        CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the  sender and know the content is safe.        From: Oksana Holbrooks   Sent: Tuesday, August 22, 2023 3:08 PM  To: bbeam@tepgroup.com  Cc: donovan.pieper@crowncastle.com  Subject: BZA 142 S Church St     Good afternoon,                   Your Board of Zoning Appeals Application has been logged into the system. The Planner will start  reviewing it shortly. If we have any questions, we will let you know.  At the meantime, if you wish to pay the Zoning Appeals Application Reviewing Fee in the amount of $150.00, you can  use the reference number 23‐00200011 to pay online.      https://ssl.sc.gov/checkout/CityOfSpartanburg/PlanningZoning.html         Thank you     Oksana Holbrooks  Planning Department / City of Spartanburg  PO Box 1749, Spartanburg, SC 29304 / (864)580-5269  planning@cityofspartnaburg.org       This email may contain confidential or privileged material. Use or disclosure of it by anyone other than the recipient is  unauthorized. If you are not an intended recipient, please delete this email.   This email may contain confidential or privileged material. Use or disclosure of it by anyone other than the recipient is  unauthori zed. If you are not an intended recipient, please delete this email.     You don't often get email from oholbrooks@cityofspartanburg.org. Learn why this is important    Page 35 of 36 5 This email may contain confidential or privileged material. Use or disclosure of it by anyone other than the recipient is  unauthorized. If you are not an intended recipient, please delete this email.   Page 36 of 36

Source: City of Spartanburg website. First collected Nov 8, 2026.