Planning Commission — Minutes
City of Spartanburg · Spartanburg County · Boards and Commissions · meeting of Aug 17, 2023 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Spartanburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Planning Commission - Meeting Minutes - 2023-08-17 Page 1 of 8
Planning Commission Meeting Minutes
August 17th, 2023 @ 5:30 PM
City Hall Council Chambers
Board Members Present: Dr. Phillip Stone, Reed Cunningham, Jemar Brown, Santiago Mariani
and Lekesa Whitner . City Staff Present: Martin Livingston, Community Development
Director, Nan Zhou, City Planner II; Tia Keitt, City Planner II , Oksana Holbrooks,
Administrative Assistant.
Rolls
Ms. Whitner: Lekesa Whitner, Commissioner.
Mr. Mariani: Santiago Mariani, Commissioner.
Mr. Cunningham: Creed Cunningham, Commissioner.
Dr. Stone: Phillip Stone, Commissioner.
Mr. Brown: Jemar Brown, Commissioner
Dr. Stone: Alright, I call the August 17
th, 2023, meeting of the City of Spartanburg of the Planning
Commission to order. My name is Phillip Stone I’m the Commission Chair I will be residing over
this hearings this evening. I will note for the record we have five members of the Commission
present, we have one absent and we have one vacancy, so we have quorum and are able to proceed
with the business before the body. Freedom of Information Act Compliance public notification of
this meeting has been published, posted, and mailed in accordance with the Freedom of Information
Act and the requirements of the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance.
Approval of meeting agenda
On a motion by Mr. Cunningham seconded by Ms. Whitner, the agenda for the meeting was
approved, by a vote of 5 to 0.
Mr. Cunningham: I move we accept the agenda.
Ms. Whitner: Second.
Dr. Stone: Moved by Mr. Cunningham, and seconded by Ms. Whitner to approve the agenda. All in
favor say aye.
Attendees: Aye.
Dr. Stone: Any opposed? The agenda is approved. The minutes of the July 20
th, 2023 meeting. Do I
hear a motion or any corrections or additions?
Approval of Meeting Minutes for July 20th , 2023
On a motion by Ms. Whitner seconded by Mr. Brown, the minutes of the meeting of July 20th,
2023, was approved by a vote of 5 to 0.
Mr. Cunningham: I make a motion that we accept the minutes of the July 20
th meeting.
Mr. Brown: Second
Dr. Phillip: Moved by Ms. Whitner seconded by Mr. Brown to approve the minutes. All in favor
say aye.
Attendees: Aye.
Dr. Phillip: Any opposed? Minutes are approved. Sign those in a bit.
Planning Commission - Meeting Minutes - 2023-08-17 Page 2 of 8
Old Business: None.
New Business:
The Planning Commission has received a rezoning request of a property located at 831 John B
White Sr. Blvd. (TMS: 6-21-11- 114.01) from the current zoning R -12, General Residentia l
District, to LOD, Limited Office District to accommodate the development of an office. Owner /
Applicant: Jaymar Group, LLC.
Dr. Stone: Ms. Zhou do you swear to tell the truth?
Ms. Zhou: Yes, I do.
Dr. Stone: Okay.
The project site is an approximately 31,623 square foot parcel located at 831 John B White Sr. Blvd.
The parcel borders John B White Sr. Blvd to the north and Wildwood Dr. to the west. The applicant
has requested approval of rezoning from a residential zoning designation of R-12, General Residential
District, to a commercial zoning designation of LOD, Limited Office District.
Across from the project site are Windsor House Assisted Living facility that currently has a zoning
designation of LOD, Limited Office District, and Hatcher Garden and Woodland Preserve that
currently has a zoning designation of GID, General Institutional District. Majority of properties to
the west and east side of the project site are zoned for LOD, Limited Office District. Properties to
the south are residentially zoned neighborhoods of R-12, General Residential District.
REQUIRED FINDINGS
Historically, the City of Spartanburg has required rezoning applications to meet certain criteria and
the Planning Commission must take the following findings of reasonable conformance in order to
recommend a selection or designation of zoning:
Staff offers the following analysis relating to each of these required findings:
ANALYSIS OF REQUIRED FINDINGS
The Zoning Ordinance enables Council to change the Zoning Ordinance or Map following public
notice and hearing. The Planning Commission reviews and recommends action on proposed zoning
changes at its regularly scheduled meetings. The following comments are based on established
criteria:
1. Consistency (or lack thereof) with the Comprehensive Plan – The 2004 Comprehensive Plan
Future Land Use Map has this portion of the John B White Sr. Blvd. corridor as a Limited Activity
Center. The 2004 Comprehensive Plan states that “This segment of the John B White Sr. Blvd.
(Central Section) contains less dense development and the dominant land use is low density
residential, though some offices, a school and several churches are also present. This area has
experienced a residential-to-office transition over the past several years. Most of the businesses
along this portion of the corridor are small office complexes. Traffic volume in this section of the
corridor is lower than in the eastern and western portions of the John B White Sr. Blvd.
Recommendations of this portion of the John B White Sr. Blvd are establishing this portion of the
corridor as a Limited Actiity Center. This continues the City’s successful practice of
accmmodating professional office and other low intensity commercial and civic uses, while
preserving the relatively non -congested character of the area and limiting impacts on nearby
Planning Commission - Meeting Minutes - 2023-08-17 Page 3 of 8
residential neighborhoods. On balance, allowing the remaining single family homes to become
other uses will produce a desirable outcome.” Thus, the proposed use for this parcel can be
intrepreted as consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and the Future Land Use Map with a LOD,
Limited Office District request.
The 2023 City of Spartanburg Final Draft Comprehensive Plan lists this portion of John B White
Sr. Blvd. as G-4 Corridor Infill Growth Sector. According to the draft document “These sectors
are areas that are generally loated along transportation corridors, conneting activity centers and
destinations in the City. These Sectors are mostly developed but still contain underutilized
parcels. Most are defined by a conventional, auto- oriented suburban pattern of primary
commercial development. Some of the larger, deeper parcels in this sector may allow for a change
in the pattern of development and the addition of mul ti-family and mixed -use buildings. New
development, redevelopment, or the reuse of existing alnd and buildings should be encouraged to
better meet the local goal of achieving more walkable and bikeable corridors and neighborhoods.
Some portions of these sectors should be rezoned to character-based districts.” Due to the nature
of the John B White Sr. Blvd. corridor, encouraging and supporting compact, mixed- use
development that responds to the wants and needs of residents, workers, students, and visitors are
recommended.
2. Compatibility with the present zoning and conforming uses of nearby property and with the
character of the neighborhood – The present characters of the adjacent surrounding properties
along John B White Sr. Blvd. are primarily office/less dense commercial uses that are zoned for
Limited Office District and institutional uses (Hatcher Garden) that is zoned for General
Institutional District. The proposed zoning designation of Limited Office District would be
consistent with other adjacent properties and uses to the north, west, and east side of the project
site along the main corridor of John B White. Sr. Blvd. The south side of the project site is
bordering R -12 residential neighborhoods. The proposed zoning request of Limited Office
District is not currently compatible with the residential uses to the back.
The zoning ordinance consideres LOD, Limited Office District as “….districts are established to
provide for office uses, including offices which have contact with the general public, but which
do not conduct sales of merchandise on the premises. It is intended that this district will develop
that will insure compatibility with residential districts.”
3. Suitability of the property affected by the amendment for uses permitted by the distr ict that
would be made applicable by the proposed amendment – If the proposed amendment of the
zoning classification from R-12, General Residential District, to LOD, Limited Office District is
granted, it will accommodate the proposed use of an office development. The proposed use may
not require a Site Plan review process if the business owner decides to remain the property as is
with some interior renovations. However, if the contract amount of the site and/or building
improvements filed with the Building Official for which a building permit is required exceeds
50% of the current market value based on the Spartanburg County Tax Accessor’s record, then
all portions of an existing property shall be retrofitted to meet the requirements of the Zoning
Ordinance. The site plan process allows City staff to provide feedback on the proposal site plan,
ensuring that all site requirements are met (setbacks, landscaping and buffering, parking, etc.)
4. Marketability of the property affected by the amendment for uses perm itted by the district
applicable to the property at the time of the proposed amendment – The marketability of the
property would likely increase with the proposed zoning change from residence to office
development. The proposed zoning change will allow for commercial uses, office,
institutional/public and quasi-public uses, and residential uses.
Planning Commission - Meeting Minutes - 2023-08-17 Page 4 of 8
However, with the change of use from R -12, General Residential District, to LOD, Limited
Office District, the off -street parking for the proposed use needs to be in compliance with the
City of Spartanburg Section 504 Off -Street Parking and Loading Requirement according
depending on the use.
5. Availability of sewer, water and storm water facilities generally suitable and adequate for the
proposed use – Both water and sanitary sewer services are available to this site. The site will be
reviewed by City staff during the Site Plan review process including, Planning, Building, Water,
Streets and Stormwater, for compliance with applicable regulations. The applicant is required to
submit an application for site plan review.
STAFF’S ANALYSIS & RECOMMENDATION
According to Section I Adoption and Interpretation of the City Of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance, §
105 Purpose, “The purpose of the zoning ordinance is to implement the land use element of the
comprehensive plan for those purposes set forth in S.C. Code § 6-29- 710.” This S.C. Code section
states that the “Zoning ordinance must be for the general purposes of guiding development in
accordance with existing and future needs and promoting the public health, safety, morals,
convenience, order, appearance, prosperity, and general welfare” of properties inside the City Limits.
One of the reasons for the Comprehensive Plan and City Zoning Ordinance is to have zoning
classifications that allow certain uses in conjunction with adjacent properties that may be considered
“less intense” uses. For this reason, the purpose is to protect the less intense uses from adverse
impacts on their property with regard, but not limited to, noise and/or light pollution, traffic
congestion, and any other adverse impact that a higher intense use could cause on a surrounding less
intense use.
Based on the above findings, staff recommends that should the Planning Commission approve this
request that the property be rezoned from R-12, General Residential District to LOD, Limited Office
District. The zoning designation would be conforming to the existing land use partterns and uses.
WRITTEN PUBLIC COMMENTS
Notices were sent to property owners within a 400 ft. radius of subject properties. A total of 40
Notices were sent to property owners of which 4 were mailed certified mail. A Planning Informational
meeting was held on Wednesday, August 9, 2023, at 5:30 PM at the City Council Chamber to discuss
the zoning designation request and to address any comments and concerns.
FUTURE PROCESS
Under State law, if the Planning Commission recommends approval of this application, staff will
schedule the matter for another public hearing and First Reading of Ordinance by City Council on
Monday, September 11, 2023. If the matter receives first reading approval, it will then go before the
City Council for a Second and Final Reading on Monday, September 25, 2023. The public hearings
will be publicly noticed.
If the Planning Commission recommends against the application, the negative recommendation will
be forwarded to the City Council. In this case, a public hearing before the City Council will be
conducted only if the applicant submits a written request within a two week period following the
Planning Commission’s action.
Planning Commission - Meeting Minutes - 2023-08-17 Page 5 of 8
On August 17th, 2023, the Planning Commission may act to support or oppose the application, with
or without changes to the proposal. The Commission could also continue the matter if additional
information, testimony or dialogue is deemed necessary.
Applicant:
Jaymar Group, LLC- Applicant not present.
Public Comments:
None.
Discussion:
The area transitioning to LOD is appropriate for the surrounding residents and use. Majority of the
houses are already equipped for the future business use.
A motion was made by Mr. Mariani , seconded Mr. Brown the request for rezoning for the
proposed project was approved to with a vote of 5-0.
The Planning Commission has received a request for rezoning of property located at 249 E.
Blackstock Road (TMS: 6-21-13-002.00) currently zoned LOD (Limited Office District) to be
assigned a new zoning designation of B-1 (Neighborhood Shopping District) to accommodate
the location of the Enterprise Rental A Car. Owner: Larry O. Harmon / Applicant:
Enterprise Rent A Car / Agent: Greyson Furnas; Colliers International.
Dr. Stone: Ms. Keitt, good evening. Do you swear to tell the truth?
Ms. Keitt: I do.
Dr. Stone: Thank you ma’am.
The owner of 249 E. Blackstock Road is requesting to rezone the parcel from LOD – Limited Office
District to B -1, Neighborhood Shopping District. Enterprise Rent -A-Car would like to relocate to
249 E. Blackstock Road from their current location, 238 E. Blackstock Rd. However, as an LOD
zone, auto rental is not a permitted use.
Per the City of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance, car rental businesses are premitted in B- 1 zoning
districts if : (1) no more than ten car can be parked on the property at one time; (2) no more than
five trucks can be parked on the property at one time. No truck shall have more than two axles nor
have a gross vehicle weight exceeding 32,000 lb.; (3) only trailers utilized for transporting a single
car can be located on the property. The B-3 (and higher) zoning districts allow for auto rentals when
the onsite inventory exceeds the limited requirements in B-1.
Planning Staff, hesitant to suggest a B -3 property to border the neighboring residential zoning
district, suggested the applicant apply for the B-1 zoning designation, followed by an application to
the Board of Zoning Appeals, where Enterprise Rent-A-Car could appeal the restrictions of the B-1
zoning to accommodate their inventory. Per Section 603.3, an Appeal may be granted when strict
application of the provisions of the ordinance would result in unnecessary hardship. Per Section
603.3A: A variance may be granted in an individual case of unnecessary hardship if the board makes
and explains in writing the following findings:
(a) There are extraordinary and exceptional conditions pertaining to the particular piece of
property;
(b) These conditions do not generally apply to other property in the vicinity;
Planning Commission - Meeting Minutes - 2023-08-17 Page 6 of 8
(c) Because of these conditions, the application of the ordinance to the particular piece of
property would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the utilization of the property;
and
(d) The authorization of a variance will not be of substantial detriment to adjacent property or
to the public good, and the character of the district will not be harmed by the granting of the
variance.
(e) In granting a variance, the board may attach to it such conditions regarding the location,
character or other features of the proposed building, structure, or use as the board may
consider advisable to protect established property values in the surrounding area or to
promote the public health, safety, or general welfare;
In order to keep the land use to a low-medium intensity, B-1 is the lowest use that can
accommodate the proposed business. Staff believes the Appeal process, though lenghty and time
consuming, can enable the proposed land use and offer some protection adjoining properties. The
B-1 zoning designation can create opportunities for neighborhood friendly businesses, whereas B-3
zoning would open this site to higher intensity uses that can become a nusiance to residential
communities. Moreover, the existing easement (enforced by Duke Power) drastically minimizes the
erection of structures, including buildings, fences and tree plantings. Given the size of the easement,
the site is strictly limited and forces the property owner / business to function at its current layout.
Map of easement provided at end of staff report. Below is a snippet of Section 301: District Use
Regulations showing permitted uses.
REQUIRED FINDINGS
605.3 Duties of City Planning Commission.
The jurisdiction, powers and duties of the City Planning Commission are enacted under the
Municipal Planning Enabling Legislation from S.C. Code Ann., Title 6, Chapter 29, §6-29- 310, et
seq. The City Planning Commission shall consider proposed amendments to [the City of Spartanburg
Zoning] Ordinance at its regularly scheduled meetings.
The City of Spartanburg requires Rezoning applications to meet criteria outlined in the Zoning
Ordinance and the Planning Commission must make the following findings of reasonable
conformance in order to recommend a change of zoning. Staff offers the following analysis relating
to each of these required findings:
ANALYSIS OF REQUIRED FINDINGS
The Zoning Ordinance enables Council to change the Zoning Ordinance or Map following public
notice and hearing. The Planning Commission reviews and recommends action on proposed zoning
changes at its regularly scheduled meetings. The following comments are based on established
criteria:
1. Consistency (or lack thereof) with the Comprehensive Plan –
The proposed land use is consistent with the comprehensive plan. Per the 2004 Comp Plan, this
particulary parcel can be considered either Core Activity or General Activity. B -2 is not a current
Zoning District in Spartanburg, but is recognized in the 2004 Comprehensive Plan. The Growth &
Conservation Map of the 2023 Comprehensive Plan designates this area as Corridoor Infill Growth.
Map provided at the end of the staff report.
2. Compatibility with the present zoning and conforming uses of nearby property and with the
character of the neighborhood –
Planning Commission - Meeting Minutes - 2023-08-17 Page 7 of 8
The site is situated between a B -1 and an LOD zoning district, so the requested B -1 Zoning would
be compatible with the present zoning districts of nearby properties. Across the street from the
property is an existing used car dealership, which indicates a car rental business is a conforming use
to nearby properties. Moreover, Enterprises’ current location (238 E. Blackstock) is less than half a
mile from the proposed location. East Blackstock Road is a busy commercial corridor so an auto
rental business fits into the character of East Blackstock Rd.
3. Suitability of the property affected by the amendment for uses permitted by the district that
would be made applicable by the proposed amendment--
238 E. Blackstock Rd. might be an ideal location for a car rental business. The rear portion of the
site can offer space for activities that need to take place, including parking additional cars, space to
clean vehicles and any other services necessary for a successful car rental business
4. Marketability of the property affected by the amendment for uses permitted by the district
applicable to the property at the time of the proposed amendment –
B-1 increases the options for land use, all of which includes LOD permitted uses. The marketability
of the property should not be impacted by the proposed rezoning of the site. The site is already
limited because of the Duke Power easement that covers about a third of the property, which would
impact the marketability more than the rezoning.
5. Availability of sewer, water and storm water facilities generally suitable and adequate for the
proposed use –
The property is in the cityand surrounded by city parcels. Sewer, water and storm water facilities are
available and suitable for the proposed development.
STAFF’S ANALYSIS & RECOMMENDATION
According to Section I Adoption and Interpretation of the City Of Spartanburg Zoning Ordinance,
§ 105 Purpose, “The purpose of the zoning ordinance is to implement the land use element of the
comprehensive plan for those purposes set forth in S.C. Code § 6-29-710.” This S.C. Code section
states that the “Zoning ordinance must be for the general purposes of guiding development in
accordance with existing and future needs and promoting the public health, safety, morals,
convenience, order, appearance, prospe rity, and general welfare” of properties inside the City
Limits.
One of the reasons for the Comprehensive Plan and City Zoning Ordinance is to have zoning
classifications that allow certain uses in conjunction with adjacent properties that may be considered
“less intense” uses . For this reason, the purpose is to protect the less intense uses from adverse
impacts on their property with regard, but not limited to, noise and/or light pollution, traffic
congestion, and any other adverse impact that a higher intense use could cause on a surrounding less
intense use.
Based on the above findings, staff recommends approval to rezone the parcels to B-1 Neighborhood
Shopping zoning district.
WRITTEN PUBLIC COMMENTS
30 Public Notices were sent to property owners within a 400 ft. radius of subject properties. A
Planning Informational meeting was held on August 9, 2023, at 5:30 PM at the City Council
Chamber to discuss the zoning designation request and to address any comments and concerns. A
representative from Breakthrough Church (235 E. Blackstock Rd.) attended the meeting and shared
Planning Commission - Meeting Minutes - 2023-08-17 Page 8 of 8
that members from the church park at the property in question. Apparently there is a driveable
pathway that allows the church to offer shuttle services to attendees who park on the lot in question
(249 E. Blackstock Rd.). The church is disappointed that they would lose access to the lot, and will
reach out to the owner. The church representative also shared that Enterprise will use their lot to
park cars when there is an overflow at the current location.
FUTURE PROCESS
Under State law, if the Planning Commission recommends approval of this application, staff will
s
chedule the matter for another public hearing and First Reading of Ordinance by City Council
on Monday, September 11, 2023. If the matter receives first reading approval, it will then go before
the City Council for a Second and Final Reading on Monday, September 25, 2023. The public
hearings will be publicly noticed.
I
n anticipation of the rezoning request being approved, the applicant could go before the BZA during
the October meeting. The Appeal application will have to be submitted to the Planning Department
by September 18
th to be on the agenda for the October 10th meeting. The next meeting will be
November 14th, where the application will have to be submitted by October 23rd.
If the Planning Commission recommends against the application, the negative recommendation will
be forwarded to the City Council. In this case, a public hearing before the City Council will be
conducted only if the applicant submits a written request within a two week period following the
Planning Commission’s action.
On August 17, 2023, the Planning Commission may act to support or oppose the application, with
or without changes to the proposal. The Commission could also continue the matter if additional
information, testimony or dialogue is deemed necessary.
Applicant:
Enterprise Rent A Car
Greyson Furnas; Colliers International, Agent.
Public Comments:
Andrew Metze, 8 Harrer Ct, Greer, SC 29651.
Bill McDaniel, 446 Oak Grove Rd, Spartanburg, SC 29301.
Discussion:
Moving the business and rezoning to B-1 to better utilize the use of open space, parking, better
ingress/egress for customers, and more updated facility. The proposed rezone is appropriate to
accommodate the business preferences without doing any harm to surrounding properties.
A motion was made by M s. Whitner, seconded Mr. Cunningham the request for rezoning for
the proposed project was approved to with a vote of 5-0.
The meeting was adjourned at 6:23 PM.
________________________________
Dr. Phillip Stone, II, Chairman
Source: City of Spartanburg website. First collected Nov 8, 2026.