Public-Safety-Committee-Agenda-Monday-March-162020
Anderson County · Anderson County · Agendas
Open the original document More from Anderson County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Public Safety Committee
Committee Members:
The Honorable Ray Graham, Chairman
The Honorable Craig Wooten
The Honorable Jimmy Davis
Monday, March 16, 2020 at 8:00 a.m.
Historic Courthouse-2nd Floor
Conference Room
1. Call to Order:
2. Invocation and Pledge of Allegiance:
3. Approval of Public Safety Minutes:
a . December 16, 2019
b. January 24, 2020
c . February 12, 2020
4. EMS rate increase:
5. Radio approval for West Pelzer:
6. Discussion concerning radios :
7. Citizen Comments:
8. Adjournment:
Tommy Dunn
Chairman. District 5
Craig Wooten
Counci l District 1
Brett Sanders Gracie Floyd
V. Chairman . District 4 Council District 2
Ray Graham
Council District 3
Jimmy Davis
Council District 6
Cindy Wilson
Counc il District 7
Lacey Croegaert
Clerk to Council
Honorable Ray Graham
Honorable Jimmy Davis
Mr. Steve Kelly
Mr. Mark Williamson
Mr. Mark Williamson
Rusty Burns I County Admi nistrat or
rburns&andersoncountysc.org
ANDERSON COUNTY
PO Box 8002, Anderson , South Caro lina 29622-8002 1 www.andersoncountysc.org
SOUTH CAROLINA
State of South Carolina
County of Anderson
ANDERSON COUNTY COUNCIL
PUBLIC SAFETY MEETING
DECEMBER 16, 2019
IN ATTENDANCE:
RAY GRAHAM, CHAIRMAN
TOMMY DUNN (sitting in for Craig Wooten)
JIMMY DAVIS
ALSO PRESENT:
RUSTY BURNS
LEON HARMON
LACEY CROEGAERT
Anderson County Council- Public Safety Committee Meeting- December 16, 2019
1 RAY GRAHAM: . .. meeting to order.
2 This is in reference to our Public Safety Committee
3 Meeting for Monday, December 16 , 2019 at 12 : 00 p.m.
4 At this time we'll call the meeting to order. I'm
5 going to ask Honorable Council Member Jimmy Davis if
6 he'll lead us in the invocation and pledge of
7 allegiance .
8 INVOCATION AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE BY JIMMY DAVIS
9 TOMMY DUNN: Mr . Chairman , if we
10 may , just for the record , Craig Wooten is out of town
11 and couldn't make it today. I ' ll be filling in for
12 him . Appreciate it .
13 RAY GRAHAM: Thank you , Chairman
14 Dunn.
15 At this time I ' m going to ask EMS Director Steve
16 Kelly if you ' ll step up to the mic . This meeting is
17 basically in reference to an appeal matter through
18 Medshore. Steve, if you don ' t mind , if you ' ll just
2
19 come up and just kind of brief council on where we are
20 and what you ' ve done as far as levying the fine. And
21 then I ' m going to , naturally, give them an opportunity
22 to speak, as well .
23 STEVE KELLY: (Inaudible)
24 RAY GRAHAM: Basically just where
25 we ' re at as far as today as far as what the fine is
26 and, you know, why was the fine put in place.
27 STEVE KELLY: Okay . The providers in
28 Anderson County , we have two different type contract s .
29 Medshore was put under what we refer to as a
30 performance base (inaudible) .
31 TOMMY DUNN : Hang on just a minute.
32 Can y ' all hear back there? You picking him up , Lacey?
33 Rusty, have him come over to this mic over here, see
34 if it ain ' t better than that one.
35 Thank you, Steve.
36 STEVE KELLY: Is t hat better?
37 Anderson County has two types of EMS contracts . The
38 one at Medshore , for the city, what we refer to as
39 Zone 9, is considered a performance - based contract
40 where they're not governed by a certain number of
41 trucks at any given time. They ' re more of a
42 performance base, which I believe the stipulations on
43 that contract was requirement to answer every 911 call
44 within that zone. Like I said, that was August of
45 2018 when it was signed . At the end of every month , I
46 get a report of the calls that Medshore did not
47 physically transport. I usually sit down with Josh
48 and review those calls.
49 This is not a hard numbers . I'm just using this
50 for an example. If there were twenty calls that I
Anderson Coun ty Coun cil- Public Safety Committe e Meeting - December 16, 20 19
1 had, I would print those calls out. May exclude some
2 of them because of errors straight off the bat.
3 Whatever I had left over I normally forwarded to Josh
4 Shore in a hard copy form. And then he got with
5 whoever at Medshore. I think normally it was Rob
3
6 pulled the computer data to further evaluate the calls
7 to see if they were truly missed or if there were any
8 more errors or just see what played into it. So for
9 most of the months that we reviewed those calls, we
10 brought the -- brought a findings back to Public
11 Safety Committee. We normally sat down with Medshore,
12 met, reviewed everything. And I guess at the end of
13 the day, most everyone that we reviewed, they just --
14 we evaluate it for changes that could be made and
15 attempted to make some changes to alleviate it from
16 happening in the future.
17 But since we're, I guess, a good ways into the
18 contract now, the last Public Safety meeting that was
19 had, we discussed levying fines for October. Back and
20 forth with Josh, talking with him, and I think we
21 ended up with four that we were going to fine with.
22 RAY GRAHAM: With these four, I
23 assume y'all have done went through the vent process
24 as far as ensuring that there was no viable reason on
25 why the four calls were missed?
26 STEVE KELLY: If you go by the
27 contract it says that any call that Medshore does not
28 transport in their ambulance is a fineable offense .
29 We were very lenient on the -- applying that. We
30 allowed exception if they responded to anything
31 whatsoever. If they responded to a supervisor;
32 anything that assisted whatsoever in the care of that
33 patient. So it's definitely not something we set out
34 just to hammer them with to make an example or
35 anything like that.
36 RAY GRAHAM: On the four calls that
37 was missed, before you levied the fine, did Mr. Shore
38 give you any information as far as what those four
39 calls were missed for and also I know in the past ---
40 STEVE KELLY: Every one of them ---
41 RAY GRAHAM: --- in my communication
42 with everybody in the loop on the emails, there's
43 normally some type of a plan put in place to basically
44 try to improve. And at the end of the day that's what
45 we try to do each month. Was there anything back on
46 these four calls in particular?
47 STEVE KELLY: Let's see, August,
48 September, October, Josh always responded back with a
49 brief paragraph of each call. And he did the same for
50 October. And then the four that we held accountable
4 Anderson County Council - Publi c Safety Committe e Meeting- December 16, 2019
1 on the fines, there were no resources responded
2 whatsoever and an ambulance had to respond from out of
3 the county or elsewhere in the county, into the city.
4 Not from a posting location or anything like that.
5 RAY GRAHAM: Thank you, sir.
6 Does any other council members have any questions
7 for Steve before . . . Thank you, Steve.
8 Greg, who is going to speak on y'all's behalf?
9 Are y'all going to do it jointly? By all means,
10 whoever you need just come on up and let's -- I mean
11 because I guess in a sense we're trying to be formal
12 here, but I mean we're all business partners and we're
13 just trying to figure out what ' s the best route to go.
14 GREG SHORE: Well, I appreciate the
15 committee listening to my appeal request. I know that
16 we met on October the 9th and I think Tommy chaired
17 that sub-committee meeting, and then we met again on
18 October the 17th with you, Ray, talking about the
19 issues.
20 Most of these issues that were discussed were
21 staffing issues that we presented to you that there is
22 a terrible shortage of paramedics and that we had
23 asked to possibly staff the units at a BLS level with
24 ALS QRVs to chase these units until we could help take
25 care of the alleviation of the shortage.
26 And we are seeing improvements on the shortage
27 because we've offered two raises. We gave a six
28 percent raise to our employees in September and we
29 just recently gave them another percentage. I don't
30 want to say the number because I'm not sure . Dick, do
31 you know the number of the current raise that they're
32 getting? Three percent? So a total of nine percent
33 since we first started talking about the paramedic
34 shortage.
35 My concern, and I guess I take it personally
36 because I ended up going to the hospital this weekend
37 over this issue and spent the night in the ER over my
38 blood pressure not being able to get under control.
39 Went through a CT scan, spinal tap and a couple of
40 other things because this really just bothers me. I
41 thought that we had an understanding that until we
42 could fi x the staffing issues and the dispatch issues
43 that we would review the calls that we missed, but
44 that we would wait and not fine us until we had all
45 this under control.
46 The six thousand dollar fine is a lot of money to
47 us, but what it's going to affect, when you look at
48 the calls that we run, we average an APC, an average
49 patient charge, of two hundred and fifty-five dollars
50 a call. If you take what we charge our customer and
Anderson County Council - Public Safety Committee Meeting - December 16, 2019
1 what our net result col l ection is, and we said that,
2 you know, two hundred and fifty-five dollars is what
3 we collect. Of a seven hundred dollar ambulance bill,
4 a lot of patients don't have insurance so we don't
5 collect anything. Some people have private insurance
6 and it pays a hundred percent. Medicaid pays a
7 fraction of our costs. But it's two hundred and
8 fifty-five dollars per call that we make revenue.
9 Plus the subsidy that the county gives us. But yet
5
10 the fine is fifteen hundred dollars, plus we lose the
11 two hundred and fifty-five dollars that we would have
12 got if we would have been able to make the call, which
13 we certainly want to do.
14 So when we look at the monetary costs of this,
15 it's quite expensive. But what concerns me is that
16 we're going to have to make adjustments to that. In
17 November we gave nine hours to promote public safety
18 in our community. Those hours will have to go away so
19 that we, you know, budget the money for the fines. We
20 also had nine special events in the month of November
21 that were donated to the community. We're going to
22 have to look at ways to get funding for those standbys
23 because this is not something that we budgeted.
24 I mean I started serving Anderson County in 1987
25 when we lost our rescue squad, and I've been covering
26 the county for thirty-two years. You know, if we
27 aren't following the contract then we should be
28 penalized, but there are stipulations that are kind
29 of, you know, beyond ou r control. And I really look
30 at Anderson County as a system. I have seven other
31 rescue squads that partner with us to serve the
32 community. And these four calls that we missed were
33 still answered. An ambulance arrived at the scene.
34 Last month we had a ninety-two percent compliance of
35 being at the scene of 911 calls. Ninety-two percent
36 with nine minutes and fifty-nine seconds response
37 time. Our employees are short, I think, right now
38 seventeen p ositions. So our other employees are back
39 filling these shifts. They're tired, they're worn
40 out, but they're still pe r forming at a high level. We
41 have over two hundred and fifty employees here in
42 Anderson that serve our community. We've j ust
43 provided a five dollar shift differential for the
44 weekends because the weekends was when we were having
45 trouble finding coverage and a lot of our employees
46 like to take their days off, their paid time off on
47 the weekends because that's what they do.
48 But in October we responded to two thousand five
49 hundred and thirty 911 calls. We transported fourteen
50 hundred and seventy-th r ee of them. In November our
Anderson County Council- Public Safety Committee Meeting- December 16, 2019
1 call volume was down considerably . We responded to
2 two thousand two hundred and thirty-four transport
3 requests and transported twelve hundred and eighty-
4 one. So we ' re seeing our call volume falling off ,
5 which has really kind of been a blessing because with
6 us being short it's helped us to , you know , capture
7 more calls .
8 But I just , you know , I just felt like -- I was
9 kind of blind-sided when I saw the fines because I
6
10 thought we had met and said , hey, we ' re working toward
11 those. We ' re going to meet regularly with Steve Kelly
12 to constantly monitor our progress. We donated an
13 ambulance to the career center over at District 2 , 3
14 and-- 3 , 4 and 5 for their EMT program because we ' re
15 working hard to make sure that we have more EMTs
16 certified and trained. We ' re working feverishly, but
17 yet we got hit with a fine. And we're going to pay
18 the fine if it ' s not-- if we can ' t appeal it. That ' s
19 part of doing business. But it ' s going to certainly
20 suffer with our non-profits that depend on us to
21 donate services to them.
22 And that ' s my biggest concern is we've got to
23 channel this money to a different path and that, I
24 think , is what upset me so bad that I ended up in the
25 ER Saturday morning at two a.m.
26 RAY GRAHAM: I'm going to hit on a
27 couple of things. As far as, you know , the good and
28 service that you, along with the other providers , has
29 provided Anderson County for years , I mean , there ' s no
30 question the value that that has brought . And there ' s
31 no question the service attitude that each and every
32 one of you has given this county . So that has
33 absolutely nothing to do with this here.
34 Along with a personal direction towards you or
35 your staff , you know , the entire provider , as far as
36 you guys , I mean that is -- in no part has anything to
37 do with this. We do still have some issues and I
38 think we have made a lot of great progress . I ' m with
39 you. We ' ve still got an issue on shortages . And I
40 see Chief Sutherland out there . I don ' t know if
41 there ' s any other providers from-- in the county, as
42 well, but I mean , you know, every one of those are
43 fighting the same battle . And at some point we've got
44 to figure out, you know, what are we going to do to
45 move forward? How are we going to ensure that our
46 county is served? I know one time , and I don ' t
47 remember the date, but you guys were out of town and I
48 know I spoke with Dick and Steve on the phone . It was
49 a Friday night because I was actually at my business,
50 and we had to an issue inside the city with coverage .
Anderson County Council- Public Safety Committee Meeting - December 16, 2019
1 And that was a major concern. And I'm not trying to
2 pull up different issues, but I mean I guess at the
3 end of the day, and by all means I want my fellow
4 council members to speak their mind, as well, but at
5 the end of the day what I want to see is every month
6 we move forward.
7 GREG SHORE: We've got a dozen ---
8 RAY GRAHAM: I think we continue
9 doing that.
10 GREG SHORE: We've got a dozen
11 paramedics across the country that work for Priority
12 that have agreed to come and help us cover shifts.
7
13 But the state has been slow to get them reciprocity so
14 that they can practice in our state. So that's been
15 an issue. But, you know, we're pulling every stop
16 that we can to take care of the staffing. And this is
17 not going to be fixed in a few months. It's going to
18 probably take a year or two before we see the
19 paramedics -- enough paramedics to meet the demand in
20 the upstate.
21 Greenville County, they had the same issue and
22 they were told that there was going to be a massive
23 walkout with their workforce and they quickly ponied
24 up enough money to avoid that. But that's what we're
25 having to do right now is throw money at it. And of
26 course, you know, that's a short band-aid to it, but
27 we've got a long term problem that we've got to fix.
28 And that's finding young people that are interested in
29 our profession. And we're working hard to mentor
30 these kids that are in high school, but it's just not
31 going to happen overnight. We're struggling and, you
32 know, I guess the fines are, you know, are necessary
33 probably from the standpoint, but it's going to cause
34 us to shift things that we do for our community and
35 the service we do to cover these fines. Because
36 they'll probably continue to happen.
37 We back up the rescue squads and I know they're
38 going to have to back us up. It's part of the system.
39 That's why we need to be shifting ambulances halfway
40 to different areas when we're level zero in Iva or
41 Belton or Pendleton or Anderson or whatever the case
42 may be. We need to make those shifts.
43 And I had hoped that that would work when we moved
44 our dispatch center out there. But what turned out to
45 be a different story or different pathway is that we
46 sent a dispatcher out there twenty-four/seven and
47 there was so much workload there that we had to send a
48 second dispatcher. And then after the second one got
49 there they said we're going to have to put a third
50 one. And corporate said, we can't send, you know,
Anderson County Council - Public Safety Committee Meeting - December 16, 2019
1 that many FTEs out there to handle what one person
2 should be able to handle. So it was integration with
3 our CAD system, so it meant that our dispatchers were
4 having to input all this information in there several
5 different ways and it just created an issue that we
6 had to pull our dispatchers back until we can get the
7 integration to the system because I believe that will
8 work. I think that our response times were better
8
9 when we were there. That's my gut feeling. I haven't
10 seen the actual numbers, but I was really pleased last
11 month when we weren't in dispatch we had a ninety-two
12 percent compliance in Anderson.
13 But my concern is that, you know, we'll have to
14 pay the fines, but it's going to divert money that we
15 were donating to these non-profits, and I'll tell you
16 who we provided service to this past month. We did a
17 public safety show and tell event with SK children at
18 Midway Elementary School; we partnered with the
19 Anderson Special Needs Disability Board for EMS
20 coverage for the Spooktacular 5-K run; we provided
21 service for the Veterans Day parade coverage; a
22 football game at old McCants stadium; the Gobbler 5-K
23 run at the Anderson Mall; and also in November we sent
24 nine hours of EMS coverage for Anderson County to
25 support community education and citizens' safety.
26 You know, those are things that we donate to the
27 community because we have the prosperity to do that.
28 But with the raises that we're having to give, the
29 overtime we're having to pay, the travel expense of
30 bringing paramedics from other states to come and help
31 us cover it is going to cost us more money.
32 And we did ask the Public Safety Committee to look
33 at letting us get an increase in our rates. That only
34 helps the private insurance. It's not going to help
35 Medicare, Medicaid and those that have no insurance.
36 But it will give us a small increase to help us absorb
37 these costs that we're doing on the increases.
38 RAY GRAHAM: As far as November,
39 Steve, have you looked at November's costs? Have
40 y'all already hashed out as far as what it's looking
41 like? Okay. So I mean I don't want to speculate on
42 where we're going to be at in November without you and
43 Josh have already actually communicated and walked
44 through that plan.
4 5 GREG SHORE: But I want to make it
46 clear because I see that the media is here. I just
47 want to make sure that they know that there has been
48 no patient that didn't receive an ambulance. These
49 four calls that we checked out -- and there were more.
50 There were about twenty, I think, total, but of those
9 Anderson County Council- Public Safety Committee Meeting- December 16, 2019
1 twenty there was a closer ambulance that was from
2 another provider that dispatch decided to send because
3 they were closer. And that ' s what we agreed , if we
4 have the closest ambulance, we want to send the
5 closest unit . We should never be squabbling or
6 fighting over that . That should be , let ' s think about
7 the patient first. There were a couple of calls where
8 our ambulances were in other districts answering calls
9 so we got exempt from those.
10 RAY GRAHAM: Right .
11 GREG SHORE : But , you know , we look
12 at them . We vet those things out. And if I feel like
13 that our system is not meeting the needs of the
14 county , then I ' m going to tell you, you know , we ' re
15 inadequate. But we ' re not . We're meeting the
16 standards .
17 You know, I had asked the council to recognize our
18 employees because they just got re-accredited about
19 three months ago . And that never happened . I mean
20 I ' m just taking it personal . I feel like that you ' re
21 just trying to kick us while we ' re down. And I mean
22 we ' re not down ; we ' re just struggling with personnel
23 -- certified personnel . I mean I could put non-
24 certifieds on the road, but that ' s not , you know, what
25 we need to be doing.
26 RAY GRAHAM: That ' s definitely not
27 the case. And I mean I guess in a sense
28 GREG SHORE: Well , I ' m glad to hear
29 that because I kind of felt that way.
30 RAY GRAHAM: Because when I first
31 got on council, each and every one of the people that
32 was involved in EMS realizes , we were at a point where
33 our system was failing. And we have reworked it . Are
34 we where we need to be? Absolutely not .
35 GREG SHORE : Going in the right
36 direction .
37 RAY GRAHAM: This here, this here ,
38 this process right here today , along with the steps
39 that each -- that your service , along with the other
40 providers, are continuing to provide our county on a
41 daily basis and continue to improve and continue
42 putting their brains together and their ideas on how
43 can we make it better , the entire system, is what is
44 continuing moving this program forward . We ' re still
45 not where we need to be and we realize that . But I
46 mean we're not failing because we realize we need to
47 continue moving forward .
48 GREG SHORE: Well, I ' ve been serving
49 the county since 1976 and I ' ve been your 911 provider
50 for thirty-two years. And I ' m the junior provider .
Anderson County Council- Public Safety Committee Meeting- December 16, 2019
1 All the other rescue squads have been here since the
2 sixties. And they started out with volunteers. And
3 of course volunteerism got tough there twenty years
4 ago and council realized it and started subsidizing
10
5 the providers so that they could put paid staff on it.
6 So we have improved. And there's a lot more
7 improvement. But I just feel like that we need a
8 little bit more time before we start getting penalized
9 financially for these missed calls.
10 RAY GRAHAM: So what -- and
11 naturally this is not my call. This will definitely
12 be council's. But what do you recommend? As far as
13 on this fine today, naturally we're going to have to
14 go into Executive Session and speak with our concerns
15 on this. But what do you recommend? I mean where do
16 you see the benefit as far as moving forward? Because
17 at the end of the day I'm comfortable in saying our
18 Director Steve, who I've got a hundred percent faith
19 in, ---
20 GREG SHORE: I do, too.
21 RAY GRAHAM: --- along with our
22 Public Safety Committee, our direction is to move the
23 county forward whether we're dealing with law
24 enforcement or in this case dealing with EMS, the
25 Public Safety's direction is to move it forward. It's
26 not to levy a fine on anyone. In fact, my question
27 is, what are we going to do with the fine money? It
28 needs to be some good brought out of that money if we
29 do initiate the fine.
30 GREG SHORE: Well, I hope you give
31 it to non-profits because we're going to have to start
32 charging them for services and maybe they can pay us
33 for that.
34 RAY GRAHAM: But what do you
35 recommend that we're going to move forward, or what
36 can you tell me we're going to move forward if we did
37 not do the fine?
38 GREG SHORE: Our recommendation is
39 just like we talked about at our sub-committee
40 meetings, that we continue to meet with you and
41 continue to monitor the progress that we're having
42 with the shortage, with response times, and we're
43 meeting with Steve, I think, is it every two weeks?
44 Meeting with Steve every two weeks so that we can
45 review these before the end of the month because there
46 are, like I say, two thousand calls to go through; not
47 all of -- the majority of them meet the criteria of
48 the response time. What we're looking at is the ones
49 that fall out of that and the ones that we just
50 weren't available because we were on other calls.
11 Anderson County Council- Public Safety Committee Meeting- December 16, 2019
1 But I think we need to continue to monitor this
2 and report back to the council on our progress. Are
3 we making headway or are we taking steps back? That's
4 what we talked about in October when we met two times,
5 and that's what surprised me with the fine. I thought
6 we were going to continue to meet and continue to
7 monitor it and see, you know, what direction we're
8 heading in.
9 I think we're heading in a positive direction.
10 But . ..
11 JIMMY DAVIS: Mr. Shore.
12 GREG SHORE: Yes.
13 JIMMY DAVIS: Medshore agreed to the
14 fifteen hundred dollars in the contract; correct, per
15 call?
16 GREG SHORE: Yes, sir.
17 JIMMY DAVIS: At what point did you
18 think that that fifteen hundred dollar fine per missed
19 call once all the calls have been qualified, at what
20 point did you think that the county would levy that
21 fine against Medshore?
22 GREG SHORE: If someone did not
23 receive an ambulance.
24 JIMMY DAVIS: I'm talking about when
25 -- you keep saying that you thought the understanding
26 was that we would give you time to get appropriate
27 personnel numbers or whatever. But I mean at some
28 point in time we had to have some type of time frame
29 in our mind of when that levy would start taking
30 place. That's my question.
31 GREG SHORE: I'm really thinking
32 that it's going to take us six months to twelve months
33 to get our staffing stabilized from the shortage of
34 paramedics. And that's looking at what's currently in
35 paramedic class. We're sponsoring several paramedics
36 with Tri-County Tech's program they just started up.
37 And the Upstate EMS Council. We have three programs
38 in the upstate or in our catchment area, and that's
39 Greenville Tech, Upstate EMS Council, and Tri-County
40 Tech. I serve on the Upstate EMS Council board. Josh
41 serves on the Tri-County Tech board. So we're
42 monitoring those programs so that we know, you know,
43 how many paramedics they're going to be able to
44 produce. But you have other agencies that are vying
45 for these paramedics. So it really comes down to
46 who's going to pay the most or, you know, it's almost
47 like a bidding war now that we've got ourselves into.
48 But you know, it's going to take a while for this to
49 stabilize. And then
50 RAY GRAHAM: Go ahead, Mr. Whipple.
12 Anderson County Council -Public Safety Committee Meeting - December I 6, 20 I 9
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
DICK WHIPPLE: If I could just add
briefly about that ---
RAY GRAHAM: If you could, introduce
yourself. I'm not sure if the other council members
are ---
DICK WHIPPLE: That's fine. I'm Dick
Whipple. I'm the Vice President of Operations and
Special Projects for Priority Ambulance. But if I may
add a little bit to that question.
One of the provisions in the contract was to
transition the county here to the National Academy
standards of EMD. And as we've had a recent meeting
and continuous meetings about this, the current system
introduces a lot of inefficiencies in the system in
the way that calls are processed. It's not a judgment
of the people. It's a judgment of the process that
happens where ninety percent, basically, of our calls
are considered priority one or life threatening. And
that's unlike any system in the country.
And with the National Standard EMD process, if we
were to transition into that, we could introduce a lot
more efficiency in matching the right resources with
the right calls, with the right response time.
We can also look at other alternative resources to
stir patients to, as opposed to burdening the
emergency departments or burdening the EMS systems on
calls that typically neither one of us are going to be
paid or are going to be very low pay calls. And it's
not about the money, but it's about helping the people
get to the right resource timely and more efficiently.
So right now there's a lot of system-introducing
efficiencies that also burden all the providers, but
burden certainly where we do the majority of the
calls. Where we have extra staff, we have to staff to
overcome those inefficiencies that area introduced in
this system. And so that's where part of this
struggle comes to.
Our capture rate is around anywhere between fifty
eight and about seventy percent it looks like. And
most system are somewhere in the mid-seventies even to
the mid-eighty percent on capture rate. So you can
see there's a lot of calls that we're going on that
we're not even transporting patients on that frankly
didn't need an ambulance to start with. And so to
your point about when we would start doing that, I
think when we have an entire system, and looking at
this from a system's perspective, that where the EMD's
in place, you know, where people have the opportunity
to have the staffing. I think from my perspective
that would be where you're going to have a more
Anderson County Council- Public Safety Committee Meeting- December 16, 2019
1 manageable system and more appropriately be able to
2 respond to those. Hopefully that makes some sense.
3 JIMMY DAVIS: Thank you.
4 RAY GRAHAM: You guys got any other
5 questions?
6 TOMMY DUNN: I've got a few things.
7 Greg, I appreciate what you've done for Anderson
8 County. I consider you a friend. I also want to say
9 Medshore Ambulance Service has done great for the
10 community of Anderson County. Business is business,
11 and that's what brought us here today. We've got to
12 find out -- fix this. Fines is nothing. Fines ain't
13 going to bring somebody back that died of a heart
13
14 attach on the side of the road because the ambulance
15 didn't get there on time. That's what we want to make
16 sure. This ain't about -- we've got a bad
17 misunderstanding if we're thinking Belton should be
18 covering the city of Anderson because they shouldn't
19 be. They're there to back up, but it should be no
20 somebody having to come from Belton to answer a call
21 in the city of Anderson. We've got a problem when
22 that happens.
23 The other thing, the meeting me and you said, your
24 son, Lieutenant Baker, Steve Kelly, I thought we had
25 an understanding, too. I thought we had an
26 understanding we was talking about the dispatch --
27 y'all having a dispatch-- central dispatch. We
28 talked about and went over it. When I left the room,
29 I said y'all get the nuts and bolts worked out and
30 let's have these meetings and get something worked up.
31 The next thing I know I'm getting an email saying
32 y'all are pulling out of dispatch-- of central
33 dispatch. And that's fine. That wasn't my
34 understanding either. I thought we was going to get
35 something worked out on that. So that's a two-way
36 street of sort of getting blind-sided.
37 Lieutenant Baker, I'd like to ask you to step up
38 to the mic and ask you a little bit. We're getting
39 all this about our dispatch and about what -- where
40 we're at and where we need to get. Because I don't
41 think I understand exactly what the gentleman, Mr.
42 Whipple, was talking about before about having a
43 system we can prioritize a little bit better maybe
44 than what we're doing.
45 DAVID BAKER: Yes, sir.
46 TOMMY DUNN: I don't think if a call
47 comes in and there ain't much -- now I don't mean to
48 make light of nothing and Mr. Kelly, you let me know
49 -- on these four calls we're talking about, we ain't
50 talking about somebody getting a stumped toe or run
Anderson County Council - Public Safety Committee Meeting -December 16, 2019
1 ove r a finger. These we r e pretty major instances,
2 f r om my understanding; I know one of them was.
3 DAVID BAKER: When I (inaudible) . I
4 can't tell you exactly right now what ---
5 TOMMY DUNN: Come up t o the mic a
6 little bit. Lieutenant, if you'll go ahead-- how is
7 the prioritize and how is that coming in working on
8 that if you'd like to speak to that since you got
9 brought up in this.
14
10 DAVID BAKER: That's okay. I'm going
11 to br i ng up a couple of conversations and I'll let
12 Steve kind of discuss about how the -- what makes it a
13 priority and what does not.
14 To make a long story short, we did have a meeting
15 which I was called to. It was an EMS based meeting
16 and some subject matter came up with dispatch where
17 the EMD portion of how dispatch determines what's
18 priority, what's not, and that kind of thing. I don't
19 know how old that system is. My understanding is many
2 0 a year ago the folks sat down and decided this was the
21 direction we needed to go. Times have changed and it
22 certainly needs to be updated. We had discussion
2 3 about potentially updating that, which we had recent
2 4 discussion again just the other day with Mr. Whipple
25 and Josh Shore from Medshore over at the office to
26 discuss some other things.
2 7 One of the things that kind of falls back to us is
28 we're getting ready to transition to a new large
29 software package at dispatch. I know that Medshore
30 had offered their EMD to us potentially. That comes
31 with a cost. Not necessary a cost from us to Medshore
32 but a certification process with forty people or sixty
33 something people at forty hours for certification. I
34 did the math the other day; just for certification was
35 somewhere around thirty to forty thousand dollars in
36 salaries for forty hours for employees. That does
37 comes at a pretty great cost to us.
38 One of the other costs would be to update our
39 existing card system. And that might be a band - aid
40 fi x , but it's certainly at least something we need to
41 look at. And I think that number was thrown out
42 somewhere around twenty thousand. When I say a band-
43 aid fix, it takes care of today the prioritization
44 into the EMD which would be similar to what Medshore's
45 system is with their process. Again, that's twenty
46 thousand dollars we've got to find in the budget
47 somewhere to do.
48 And then what we then need is for the EMS and
49 probably getting together with all the EMS chiefs to
50 determine what should change within our current card
15 Anderson County Council- Public Safety Commillee Meeting - December 16, 2019
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
system. Yes, sir.
TOMMY DUNN: And I don't want to
speak -- we've got six other council members.
DAVID BAKER: Sure.
TOMMY DUNN: If this was best, we
don't want to throw good money after bad.
DAVID BAKER: Right.
TOMMY DUNN: But if twenty thousand
dollars will make the system work better for the
people of Anderson County, I think we could find it.
DAVID BAKER: Yes, sir.
TOMMY DUNN: But we want to make
sure. Y'all need to look at some another. Y'all are
the professionals. Y'all need to look at this . I'm
just throwing out in the future, you know. Y'all need
to get together and come up with a plan.
DAVID BAKER: Yes, sir.
TOMMY DUNN: I told y'all that day,
in how it's going to work and then give us a dollar
figure. And if it ain't going to be no better, we
don't need to do it.
DAVID BAKER: Correct.
RAY GRAHAM: We did have a meeting
this past week concerning that. And just to clarify,
it's not what's best for Medshore or what's best for
Belton or for Iva, it truly-- we're looking at the
two options -- Becky, the Director of dispatch, you
know, everybody was in that meeting, along with David,
as well, and we did discuss the different options.
And we are kind of -- we've got some items for people
to go out and check on and basically bring a report
back to determine what is best for the county.
You know, honestly I think if we get this
implemented, regardless which way we go, either update
what we've got or go with the other system, I think a
lot of these problems that we're having not only with
Priority and Medshore but with the other providers, as
well, a lot of these problems that we're having with
the missed calls-- and what it is, it's taxing the
system on a call that probably could be a non
emergent, and it's really nothing more than a stumped
toe, but yet we're having to send a medic and EMT to
that call. So we are looking at those options on
that.
DAVID BAKER: To give you an idea,
there are some questions that are asked in those EMD
cards as they're going through. One of the questions
might be, are you having any trouble breathing? And
obviously that triggers or changes the priority to a
higher priority. So if you had a situation to where,
16
Anderson County Council- Public Safety Committee Meeting- December 16, 2019
1 you know, it's not a-- I guess everybody could define
2 traumatic event differently, but an event where the
3 priority should be higher or not, that card makes that
4 decision based on just breathing, asking that
5 question, you know, with trouble breathing.
6 So those are some things that, you know, whether
7 we stay with our existing system, the EMSs, along with
8 their group and the various chiefs will have to get
9 together to make a determination should that change
10 and if so how should it change? What should that
11 question be? And then we would invest our twenty-plus
12 thousand, you know, in changing the card system to
13 update what we currently have and are using.
14 Our other option, as mentioned, would be to go in
15 with the EMD system that Medshore is currently using
16 and then we have to look at potential funding for
17 training and certifications and that kind of thing.
18 I'm going to turn it over to Steve to answer
19 unless y'all have got another question specifically
20 about dispatch. We did get together with them the
21 other day about some concerns and I think we all came
22 to the agreement that things are good. We do have
23 still a pod area over there that could accommodate up
24 to four if that decision is ever made for them to
25 return. So that's there.
26 And I agree with Greg, I think we all agree that
27 when they were in-house it was a lot more efficient, a
28 lot quicker. I can't speak for his manpower issue,
29 but I can certainly see and could tell a difference.
3 0 TOMMY DUNN: Thank you.
31 DAVID BAKER: Yes , sir.
32 STEVE KELLY: The dispatch software
33 we keep talking about, just so we're all on the same
34 page, there's two major types. We currently use what
35 is called APCO. We swapped to it county-wide eight,
36 nine years ago. It was seen at that time as a more
37 cost-effective alternative. So they swapped to it.
38 The Priority dispatch that Medshore is currently
39 using, it is the gold standard in the dispatch
40 community. It is the best that's out there, but it is
41 also very expensive on the initial purchase and the
42 continuing costs as far as training and stuff like
43 that.
44 So the APCO is the deck of cards we have now .
45 That's what we have to work with. We're not going to
46 be able to change it in the foreseeable future.
47 That's what we had when this contract was signed.
48 That's what we've had for seven, eight years. As
49 David did say, we've got a data download that we're
50 wanting to try to get pushed through in the next
17
Anderson County Council - Public Safety Committee Meeting- December 16, 2019
1 couple of weeks, but honestly that's two, three months
2 before that can even be pushed out and them having
3 live on 911.
4 TOMMY DUNN: Let me just also,
5 you're monthly reviewing all EMS providers; right? I
6 mean this ain't picking on Priority One?
7 STEVE KELLY: The only one that gets
8 this is Medshore, and that's because of what we deemed
9 is that performance-based contract.
10 TOMMY DUNN: I mean, you're
11 constantly monitoring the others though and making
12 sure
13 STEVE KELLY: For everything that
14 they have that they're supposed to be monitored for,
15 such as time compliance and stuff of that nature, yes.
16 RAY GRAHAM: Yes, Greg, go ahead.
17 GREG SHORE: (Inaudible) We picked
18 the performance-based side because we peak out at like
19 nineteen ambulances with our call volume. But when
20 you do the static deployment and we-- let's say we do
21 six or seven ambulances and they're just dedicated to
22 911 calls, that costs us about thirty thousand dollars
23 a month subsidy. And when you look at the subsidy
24 that you pay for us, it's a lot less because we
25 decided to do it that model to save money and keep the
26 taxpayers' costs down. So I just wanted to let you
27 know why we went that way. And I think Dick has a
28 comment, too, that he wants to make.
29 RAY GRAHAM: And right now you're
30 still comfortable with that type of contract?
31 GREG SHORE: Well, I think it's the
32 most cost-effective contract that we could do. If you
33 said, hey, we would rather have your ambulances
34 dedicated to nothing but 911 calls; transports will be
35 handled by another group of vehicles, we could do
36 that, but the cost would be higher because you see
37 that forty percent of the calls we go on doesn't
38 generate a transport. And when we do transport a
39 patient, we make two hundred and fifty-five dollars a
40 call. So you can do the math and figure out the labor
41 and the costs . But yeah, we could do that other path.
42 It's just-- you know, it's got a different model of
43 subsidy based with it.
4 4 RAY GRAHAM: Okay. Dick, I'm going
45 to give you one other opportunity and then we're going
46 to probably go into Executive Session. But go right
47 ahead, please.
48 DICK WHIPPLE: Sorry.
49 RAY GRAHAM: No, that's fine.
50 DICK WHIPPLE: I wanted to tag on to
18 Anderson County Council- Public Safety Committee Meeting- December 16, 2019
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
what David had mentioned . So we did have the meeting
and I thought it was quite productive . And again ,
those type of meetings , I think , a re really important
t o the progress , both from a provider perspective , but
also from the county.
And we ' ve committed as Priority Ambulance to help
fund the initial training, substantially fund it , and
also make available some of the software that we have
by extending the licensure to make that happen if the
transition to the EMD were to take place through the
National Academy .
You know , the stopgap -- what I would call a
stopgap measure , what they're taking about updating
their system to make that more where the priorities
are more stratosphied (verbatim) will definitely help .
But , you know , from our position we still think that
the National Academy standard is the way to go to gain
the most efficiency .
RAY GRAHAM: Thank you.
Do I have a motion to go into Executive Session?
TOMMY DUNN : Motion to go into
Executive Session for contractual matters.
JIMMY DAVIS: I second .
RAY GRAHAM: All in favor? At this
time we're going to go into Executive Session in the
conference room.
EXECUTIVE SESSION
RAY GRAHAM: We ' ll call the Public
Safety meeting back in session . Do I have a motion?
TOMMY DUNN : I make the motion we
come out of Executive Session
JIMMY DAVIS: Second .
TOMMY DUNN: --- with no action .
RAY GRAHAM: Have a motion by
Councilman Dunn ; second by Councilman Davis . All in
favor . In favor a hundred percent .
JIMMY DAVIS: Mr . Chair?
RAY GRAHAM: Go ahead , sir .
JIMMY DAVIS: I would like to make a
motion that we stick to the levying of a fine, but we
reduce that fine from a total of six thousand dollars
to two thousand dollars, which would be five hundred
dollars per occurrence on four occurrences.
RAY GRAHAM: Do I have a second on
that?
TOMMY DUNN: Second.
RAY GRAHAM: All in favor. Stand
approved a hundred percent.
I think -- personally I think where we need to go
from here is again at the end of the day we need to
19 Anderson County Council- County Council Meeting - September 18, 2018
1 figure out what we're going to do to move forward in a
2 positive direction. I think - - I know with the
3 holidays and everything next week, it ' ll probably be
4 the first of the year . But probably the first week in
5 January , we need to schedule a meeting and kind of
6 look and make sure -- I know we had a lot of stuff on
7 the table as far as this past week with dispatch, EMD,
8 AFCO program. We need to look at those opportunities
9 and just look at all the opportunities that's
10 available to move the whole progr am forward. And this
11 is not only for you guys, it ' s also for the other
12 providers .
13 I assure you , this fine is not about the money;
14 it ' s not about a personal issue by no means , but we ' ve
15 got to continue moving for ward . And I think we have .
16 I think we ' ve carne a long ways. I think we ' ve still
17 got a ways to go, though .
18 So with that being said, please reach out to me
19 and let's get a date set up for the first week in
20 January and let ' s go ahead and start trying to get --
21 working on some of these opportunities for
22 improvement . I ' d love to talk more about getting you
23 guys as far as dispatch , as far a s the EMD system , and
24 truly try to put s ome of these issues to bed as far a s
25 that ' s ca u sing u s problems .
26 I know the manpower is a major issue , I know along
27 with the other providers , they ' re having the same
28 problems. So by all means when we have this in
29 January , you know , it's not a closed meeting to
30 Priority , it ' s a meeting for EMS . I mean , we
31 definitely want to get all the players involved and
32 see what can we do. Because at the end of the day you
33 kind of rely on each other as resources . And you
34 know , that ' s what ' s made our system work so great for
35 so many years . We just need to con t inue moving
36 forward .
37 At this time , Leon , have we got any citizens
38 comments?
39 LEON HARMON: There are no citizens
40 signed up .
41 RAY GRAHAM: At this time , council
42 members , anything else?
43 TOMMY DUNN : Good . Appreciate it .
4 4 RAY GRAHAM: Meeting adjourned.
45
46 (MEETING ADJOURNED AT 12:46 P.M.)
Minutes
Public Safety Committee Meeting
Friday, Janu
ary 24, 2020
The Public Safety Committee Meeting of Friday , January 24, 2020 was called to order at 12:00 pm by
Chairman Ray Graham . Mr. Craig Wooten and Mr. Jimmy Davis were in attendance for the Public Safety
Committee meeting. The Invocation and Pledge of Allegiance was provided by Mr. Jimmy Davis.
The following items were considered by the committee:
3. Animal Control Ordinance Revision, Lieutenant David Baker
This is a recommended amendment for Section 42-116 of the Animal Control Ordinance . The current
County ordinance mimics the state law requiring charges to go to the higher court . The County needs an
ordinance to utilize for a lesser offense that can provide an educational opportunity . The larger serious
offenses such as willful or malicious killing , abuse, maiming, beating, disfiguring, administrating of any
poison or exposure of poisonous substance to any animal or pet would still go to State level to the higher
court. Amending the ordinance will allow us to handle maltreatment cases that are not geared toward
physical abuse such as confining any animal or pet without sufficient food and water, adequate shelter
and sanitary conditions . Amending this ordinance will allow us to educate the public and be able to give
an officer the discretion. The staff recommendation is to amend the ordinance to remove and exclude
some of the verbiage that automatically requires it to be sent to higher court.
Mr. Craig W oaten made the motion to move this ordinance revision to full council and a second from Mr.
Jimmy Davis, the committee voted unanimously to recommend to Full Council.
4. Body Camera Update, Captain Ross Brown, and Lieutenant Mike Beninger
After December 3, 2019 the fmancing and grant funding was obtained to purchase the cameras . The body
cameras arrived at the beginning of January 2020. A train the trainer class is scheduled for Monday ,
January 27, 2020 with training provided by Adam Westmore land
and Mike Beninger. The trainers will
train their own shifts on how to use and implement the cameras. On January 29, 2020 the Solicitors
Office and Public Defenders will attend a training
class and set up accounts for access. The information
will be sent out as a linlc After the training is complete the body cameras units will be issued . The units
have sku numbers that will be put into the supply system to be tracked . There are 126 units that will be
used by the specialized enforcement units , street narcotics road patrol and animal control.
5. Dispatch Update, Mr. Steve Kelly
Ms. Becky Carter , E-911 Director and staff are in the process of revising and updating the Dispatch
APCO cards that are used to determine what type of emergency is occurring when a 911 call is received.
This process cannot be completed while on duty requiring staff to work on their days off to complete .
Once the update process is complete the cards will need to be reviewed by Becky Carter , Steve Kelly and
Dr. King before implementing . Steve Kelly will bring back pricing for Priority Dispatch including
the
training and overtime to the Public Safety Committee .
7. December Compliance, Mr. Steve Kelly
No discussion on this item at this time
Minutes
Public Safety Committee Meeting
Friday, January 24, 2020
8. EMS PLAN 2020, Mr. Steve Kelly
In Anderson County during the night time 16 ambulances run and during the day time it fluctuates
between 20-24 ambulances with 2 QRV 's. We currently send the closest ambulances.
Dr. Brett Stoll stepped down and Dr. Michelle King from Anderson ER took over as the Primary Medical
Control Physician . There are a new set of protocols that will be sent out by March .
Over the last 18 months the 911 compliance times have been tracked with data indicating possible
recommended changes such as current placement of ambulances, and some areas with no coverage. If call
volume and growth continue in the Powdersville area there may be a need to implement a 12hour
ambulance in the Powdersville area. Pelzer currently runs 4 ambulances that travel on a continuous basis
to the Powdersville Area .
6. EMS Fee Schedule Discussion, Mr. Steve Kelly
The Fee schedule shows what the County allows the providers to charge private insurance . The fee
schedule was increased in July 2018 . Steve Kelly will collect additional data and bring back to the Public
Safety Committee.
9. EMD GRANT, Lieutenant David Baker
For the Financial year 2018-2019 Anderson County was awarded the Hazard Mitigation Grant from the
South Carolina Emergency Management Division in the amount of $38,778 . This grant funding was used
to conduct a commodity closed study by a hired contractor who came to monitor the roadways and
determine what chemicals and in what quantities they are traveling through Anderson County . The
purpose of this study was to put together a comprehensive plan that includes what type of training is
needed and what type of equipment is needed to combat and handle any potential incident with this type
of hazard . There was left over funding from the supplemental grant that could be used for Hazmat training
.The total amount of funding is $25,370 . Anderson County will receive $13,000 for training that is
specific to combatting a chlorine based chemical. The training will be conducted and hosted by Anderson
County. The remainder of funding in the amount of$12 ,370 will go directly to the Fire Academy to be
used for additional risk based , air monitoring and hazmat technician training. It is a 20% match fund grant
and the salary for James McAdams can be utilized as the individual who will be responsible for reporting .
Mr. Jimmy Davis made the motion to accept this grant and a second from Craig Wooten , the committee
voted unanimously to recommend to Full Council.
10. Annual Report 2019, Lieutenant David Baker
Lieutenant David Baker gave a brief summary of the 2019 Annual Report which included data from
Dispatch , Animal Control , and the Sheriffs Office .
There being no further business , the Public Safety Committee meeting was adjourned at
1:09pm.
-------------- -------- --, Chair
D ate ------ ------ -------- ----
Minutes
Public Safety Committee Meeting
Wednesday, February 12, 2020
The Public Safety Committee Meeting of Wednesday , February 12, 2020 was called to order at 8:02am
by Chairman Ray Graham. Mr. Craig W oaten and Mr. Jimmy Davis were in attendance for the Public
Safety Committee meeting. The Invocation and Pledge of Allegiance was provided by Mr. Craig Wooten .
3. Executive Session:
a. Discussion concerning Ems Contracts
Mr. Craig Wooten made the motion to go into Executive Session to discuss EMS contracts and a second
from Mr. Jimmy Davis, the committee voted unanimously to go into Executive Session.
Mr. Craig Wooten made the motion to come out of Executive Session and a second from Mr. Jimmy
Davis, the committee voted unanimously to come out of Executive Session with no decisions made or
votes taken.
There being no further business , the Public Safety Committee meeting was adjourned at
9:30am .
-------- ---- ------ ------ , Chair
Date ---------------------- --
Source: Anderson County website. First collected Nov 8, 2026.