RecordWell Data

Special Called County Council Meeting — Agenda Packet

Beaufort County · Beaufort County · County Council Meeting · meeting of May 19, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Beaufort County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Special Called County Council Meeting Beaufort County, SC 2nd Floor Ceremonial Courtroom, Beaufort County Courthouse, 102 Ribaut Road, Beaufort, SC 29902 Monday, May 19, 2025 5:00 PM AGENDA COUNCIL MEMBERS: ALICE HOWARD, CHAIR ANNA MARIA TABERNIK, VICE CHAIR DAVID P. BARTHOLOMEW PAULA BROWN LOGAN CUNNINGHAM GERALD DAWSON YORK GLOVER MARK LAWSON LAWRENCE MCELYNN JOSEPH PASSIMENT THOMAS REITZ 1. CALL TO ORDER 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3. STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE WITH FOIA 4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA 5. CITIZEN COMMENTS PERIOD – 30 MINUTES TOTAL 6. DISCUSSION RELATED TO THE INTERGOVERNMENTAL AGREEMENT BETWEEN BEAUFORT COUNTY A ND THE SOUTH CAROLINA TRANSPORTATION INFRASTRUCTURE BANK (SIB) CONCERNING IMPROVEMENTS OF HIGHWAY US 278 FROM MOSS CREEK DRIVE TO SPANISH WELLS ROAD AND THE ACTION TAKEN BY THE SIB AT THEIR MEETING ON MAY 12, 2025- Mike Moore, County Administrator & Jared Fralix, Assistant County Administrator, Infrastructure 7. ADJOURNMENT TO WATCH COMMITTEE OR COUNTY COUNCIL MEETINGS OR FOR A COMPLETE LIST OF AGENDAS AND BACKUP PACKAGES, PLEASE VISIT: https://beaufortcountysc.gov/council/council-committee-meetings/index.html 1 2 #3 REQUEST FOR PUBLIC COMMENTS Beaufort County, SC Council Date: Ji/ / f / CX-) � I Na me: Print: ---=-'==-=a----=--rn_��==+----¥�=-r:,;___----�---- Signature: ---------+-------------f-----­ Home Address: ---------1C'""7""-------------- Email Address: ;y;, j'Y\.OL '-1'.ll � e (,-lt �h, �J'Is ( Ci. rd S:C. qav' Phone Number: ------,.-------- District: ____ _ _ Topic: _ ___,:);.:c...=_1-L-- i v.-, ________________ _ #4 REQUEST FOR PUBLIC COMMENTS Beaufort County, SC Council Date: .5 11 'f /�o�"'r•7 Name: Print: lwr '1 Jn / vh uL I Signature: lk:l-A =:i:/1 ,14�_o,.a'-t .. - Home Address: / 9 f/:vdv 1.iP � f ,.,,� d td Email Address: /i.,, r., r e,.n,w ,Mc; - c:, ,( vA / 1 'f (J''''J ✓- (.Av/ Phone Number: £91fJ'- )__f 4. -- 7 EtJ.J District: _____ _ '')7.L9 Topic: _ __:_�...!..,__-=v _________________ _ 3 #5 REQUEST FOR PUBLIC COMMENTS Beaufort County, SC Council Date: -------- Name: Print: ---------------------- Signature: _____________________ _ Home Address: --------------------- Email Address: --------------------- Phone Number: District: ----------- -------- Topic: _______________________ _ #6 REQUEST FOR PUBLIC COMMENTS Beaufort County, SC Council Date: I 1 1-f --,..----t-----==-----..------ Home Address: --------------------- Email Address: --------------------- Phone Number: District: ----------- -------- Topic:� 4 BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY ITEM TITLE: DISCUSSION RELATED TO THE INTERGOVERNMENTAL AGREEMENT BETWEEN BEAUFORT COUNTY AND THE SOUTH CAROLINA TRANSPORTATION INFRASTRUCTURE BANK (SIB) CONCERNING IMPROVEMENTS OF HIGHWAY US 278 FROM MOSS CREEK DRIVE TO SPANISH WELLS ROAD AND THE ACTION TAKEN BY THE SIB AT THEIR MEETING ON MAY 12, 2025 MEETING NAME AND DATE: SPECIAL CALLED MEETING OF COUNTY COUNCIL – May 19, 2025 PRESENTER INFORMATION: Mike Moore, County Administrator and Jared Fralix, Assistant County Administrator ITEM BACKGROUND: In November 2021 Beaufort County entered into an Intergovernmental Agreement (IGA) with the with the South Carolina Transportation Infrastructure Bank (SIB) to finance improvements along the US 278 corridor from Moss Creek Drive to Spanish Wells Road. The project aimed to replace the eastbound Karl Bower Bridge over Mackey Creek, increase capacity, reduce congestion, potentially improve the three other bridge structures, and make multimodal transportation improvements to the corridor. The original funding plan included:  SIB Contribution: Up to $120 million  Beaufort County: $80 million from the 2018 1% Sales Tax Referendum, $12.3 million from Road Impact Fees, and $7 million from General Obligation Bonds  Town of Hilton Head Island: $3.35 million in the form of right-of-way dedication  Federal Guideshare Funds: $4.2 million  SCDOT Bridge Replacement Funds: $65.5 million This brought the total project funding to $292.35 million. The county and SCDOT committed to expending all financial contributions for the project before SIB would be obligated to pay or reimburse any eligible costs on the project and to provide additional funding to complete the project in the event of cost overruns. The preferred alternative called for a six-lane bridge and six-lane road improvements. However, due to significant inflation from 2021 to 2024, the projected cost rose to $490 million, prompting the County to seek additional funding. A proposed penny sales tax referendum to allocate an additional $90 million to the project was placed on the November 2024 ballot but did not pass. Following the referendum’s failure, Beaufort County developed a revised, lower-cost plan—championed by Senator Tom Davis—that included replacing only a portion of the bridge infrastructure. This plan was approved by a joint resolution and submitted to the SIB for consideration. 5 On March 28, 2025, the County Administrator submitted a formal update to the SIB outlining the revised scope. The proposal included a three-lane eastbound bridge, diverging from the original six-lane plan. On April 14, 2025, the SIB Chairman responded with a series of questions, to which the County Administrator replied on April 30, 2025. The SIB Board met on May 12, 2025, and voted to reject the County’s revised proposal. In a follow-up conference call on May 15, County representatives, including the Chairman of County Council, the County Administrator, and legislative delegates (Senator Davis, Representatives Newton and Herbkersman), met with SIB Chairman John White. The following concerns were cited as reasons for rejection: 1. The revised funding sequence conflicted with the IGA, which specified that SIB funds were to be used first, not last. 2. The Town of Hilton Head Island’s contribution was land (right-of-way), not cash. 3. The scaled-back bridge plan reduced the number of lanes from what was originally agreed upon and did not believe the SIB should still contribute the full $120,000,000. 4. The County had not clearly outlined a strategy for covering cost overruns; the SIB suggested County bonding capacity (up to $87 million) be pledged. (Staff does not recommend this) 5. A detailed project timeline for construction and completion was not provided. 6. The SIB expected increased financial commitment from both SCDOT and the County to reduce reliance on SIB funding. 7. The IGA had been violated since construction did not commence in 2024. Following this discussion, the County Administrator, County Attorney and ACA Jared Fralix consulted with SCDOT Secretary Justin Powell. SCDOT expressed a readiness to proceed with replacing the two-lane Mackay Creek Bridge using $90 million in already committed funds. SCDOT indicated a preference to construct a three-lane bridge, contingent upon Beaufort County contributing the additional funds needed for the third lane. PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE: Staff has identified two viable paths forward: Option 1: Terminate the IGA with the SIB and collaborate with SCDOT to proceed with replacing the existing Mackay Creek Bridge. Staff and SCDOT prefer to construct a three-lane bridge to anticipate future corridor needs. Beaufort County would need to fund the incremental cost of the third lane. Option 2: Continue negotiating an amended IGA with the SIB. This would include restructuring the funding sequence to prioritize County funds, then SCDOT funds, and finally any remaining SIB contribution. Beaufort County would assume responsibility for any cost overruns. The SIB’s full $120M commitment to the project is critical. If the SIB is unwilling to maintain the IGA commitment, then the project may no longer be viable without an identified additional funding source. FISCAL IMPACT: TBD depending upon what amounts the SIB agrees to contribute and actual costs of the project. STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL: 6 Staff recommends Option 1: Terminate the IGA with the SIB and proceed in partnership with SCDOT to construct a replacement bridge over Mackay Creek. Staff further recommends coordinating with SCDOT to construct a three-lane bridge to ensure capacity for future needs. OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION: Motion to approve/deny option 1 or 2 for replacement of the bridges to Hilton Head Island and the 278 corridor. Next Steps: County Council Meeting – May 27 2025 7 Nov. 30 8 9 10 Nov. 30 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 2024 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 SIGNATURE PAGE FOR BEAUFORT COUNTY IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Beaufo1t County has caused this Agreement to be executed on its behalf and its seal to be affixed hereto. Attest: By: ----=--e �--=--1_J Cl)v¼)-=---· _ Printed Name: C � i, f � j Y 4 rv,'..s Ti tie: Y'f � � t iwJ: +0 f l-0 UJW\��d� (SEAL) 24 Note: This Agreement was approved by the Beaufort County Council on December 1 3, 2021 by adoption of Resolution 2021/36. 31 32 33 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Date: July 24, 2019 34 1 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION This page is intentionally left blank. 35 1 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The US 278 Corridor Improvement project is in Beaufort County, SC and includes the consideration of improvements for the US 278 Corridor from Moss Creek Drive to Spanish Wells Road. The project corridor is a SC Department of Transportation (SCDOT) owned and maintained facility and is a part of the National Highway System (NHS). In addition, US 278, including the entire project limits, is within the Strategic Statewide Freight Roadway Network in the SCDOT South Carolina Statewide Freight Plan. US 278 is the only access onto and off Hilton Head Island, and improvements to this corridor provide a public benefit to the residents, employees, and the large amount of tourism that not only benefits the region, but the en tire state. The estimated cost for this project is $246 million, with an additional $26.4 million in project risk, resulting in the need for a total of $272.4 million. South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) budgeted $43.5 million to replace th e eastbound span of the Karl Bowers Bridge. In addition, Beaufort County voters have implemented a 1 cent transportation sales tax to raise $80 million for this project and additional local matches (described further in the Financial Plan) have provided an additional $12.35 million to ensure that this project does not simply address a structural issue but truly solves a long -term capacity concern for the corridor. Beaufort County is respectfully requesting that the State Infrastructure Bank (SIB) provide th e remaining funds for this project in the amount of $120 million, less than 50% of the total cost, bringing the full funding allocations of this project , including assessment of project risk, to $272.4 million. The purpose of this project is to address structural deficiencies at the existing eastbound Karl Bowers Bridge over MacKay Creek, to increase capacity, and reduce congestion along US 278 from Moss Creek Drive to Spanish Wells Road. US 278 is part of the National Highway System (NHS). Public Benefit The US 278 Corridor Improvement Project is a project of statewide significance. The implementation of this project will: • Increase mobility of people and goods. • Increase reliability and capacity of the transportation network by decreasing congestion and d elay. • Improve or replace the deteriorating conditions of existing bridges. • Improve public safety and improve hurricane evacuation routes. • Improve the quality of life for the region’s population and visiting guests. • Support local, regional, and statewide economies The improvements proposed along this section of the US 278 corridor will address the bottleneck caused by the reduced 2-lane roadway (per direction) where it is joined by 3-lane improvements at both ends of this project. This bottleneck has caused crippling traffic congestion which has impacted local economies, increased crash rates, and impaired hurricane evacuation efforts that have plagued this stretch of roadway for decades. This project supports all the goals and objectives list ed in the South Carolina Department of Transportation, South Carolina Multimodal Transportation Plan (MTP). This project is consistent with all local land use plans and will include the required transportation network enhancements to keep pace with the growth this area is experiencing and will continue to see. The County, MPO, and Town of Hilton Head Island have all passed resolutions supporting this important project in the regional infrastruct ure. The SIB Criteria states that “the ranking and scoring is done as part of the program categories Long Range Plan.” This project has met the criteria and is listed in the priority list by SCDOT as well as being the number one priority in the LATS MPO. Th rough the LATS MPO criterion scoring of projects, this project, identified a s the number one priority, has a score of 74. Based on the provided criteria for Public Benefit, as well as identifying that these improvements are part of both the National Highway System and the State Freight Network , the resulting score is a 74/100 whic h equals 37 points x 1.1=40.7. As the maximum number of points within the Public Benefit section is capped at 50, this project scores 40.7 points for the Public Benefit criteria. Financial Plan This project is in excess of $50 million and will follow the guidelines as described in the SIB criteria requiring a local contribution of at least 25% of the total project costs with additional credit provided for the grant application for each additional 5% of l ocal contribution and non-Bank funding. The $246 million project, including project risk, is broken down as follows: 36 2 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Based on the points calculation within Section 5.2.a, the following points are allocated for this project: For a project over $50 million, the amount of local contribution must be at least 25%. With a $246 million project, 25% of th e total cost is $61.5 million. The Beaufort County one-cent tax provides $80 million specific to this project, thereby meeting the 25% local fund commitment, and exceeding the match with an additional $18.5 million. This equates to 15.04 points. The Beaufort County Road Impact Fees provide an additional $12.3 million equating to an additional 10 points. Per Section 5.24, the additional elements as noted in Table 8 provide an additional local match / non-Bank funded amount of $60.1 million. This equates to 24.42 points. The committed funds in both local match as well as non -Bank funds resu lt in a total score of 49.46 points of the available 50 points. Point of Contact: Robert McFee, PE, Director Engineering & Infrastructure Beaufort County Engineering Division Mailing Address: P.O. Box 1228 Beaufort, SC 29901-1228 Street Address: 104 Industrial Village Road Beaufort, SC 29906 Telephone: 843-255-2730 Facsimile Number: 843-255-9420 E-Mail Address: RMcFee@bcgov.net Relationship to Applicant: Beaufort County on behalf of the South Carolina Department of Transportation Application Prepared by: JMT Jennifer J. Ray, AICP Address: 952 Houston Northcutt Boulevard Suite 100 Mt. Pleasant, SC 29464 Telephone: 410-316-2231 E-Mail Address: JRay@JMT.com Total Cost to Prepare: $125,000 AMOUNT OF LOCAL CONTRIBUTIONS FUNDING SOURCE AMOUNT Beaufort County one-cent tax referendum, as approved by the voters on November 6, 2018 $80,000,000 Beaufort County Road Impact Fees $12,300,000 Per Section 5.25 Federal Guideshare / Local money for the Environmental Assessment/Preliminary Engineering $4,200,000 SCDOT Bridge Replacement Funds $43,521.112 Beaufort County Funds for Jenkins Island Work $9,000,000 Town of Hilton Head Island Right-of-Way Dedication $3,350,000 Total Local / Non-Bank Funded Match including Project Risk (see Table 8) $152,370,112 SCIB Grant Request $120,000,000 Total Project Risk $272,370,112 37 3 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION TABLE OF CONTENTS (Section Numbering corresponds to the Application Criteria) EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .................................................................................................................................................................. 1 III. DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT ..................................................................................................................................................... 5 PROJECT SCOPE ........................................................................................................................................................................ 5 PROJECT INTENT ....................................................................................................................................................................... 7 IV. PUBLIC BENEFIT ..................................................................................................................................................................... 11 4.1 TRAFFIC STUDIES & SUPPORTING DATA ....................................................................................................................... 12 4.2 URGENCY OF PROJECT .................................................................................................................................................... 18 4.3 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT RESOLUTION ...................................................................................................................... 19 4.4 CERTIFICATE FROM THE ADVISORY COORDINATING COUNCIL FOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT OF THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE ............................................................................................................................................... 19 4.5 CURRENT AND FIVE-YEAR HISTORY OF UNEMPLOYMENT DATA ............................................................................... 20 4.6 LOCAL SUPPORT FROM RESIDENTS THROUGH PETITIONS OR COMMENTS AT PUBLIC HEARINGS .................... 21 4.7 LOCAL RESOLUTIONS ....................................................................................................................................................... 26 4.8 REGIONAL AND STATEWIDE SIGNIFICANCE .................................................................................................................. 29 4.9 PROS AND CONS OF ALL ALTERNATIVE TRANSPORTATION PLANS TO THE PROJECT .......................................... 41 4.10 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS OF PROJECT .................................................................................................................... 42 4.11 EVENTS/MILESTONES TO IMPLEMENT PHASES OF PROJECT .................................................................................. 44 4.12 CURRENT STATUS OF THE PROJECT ........................................................................................................................... 44 4.13 ENTITY STATEMENT AGREEING TO RESPONSIBILITIES ............................................................................................ 45 4.14 PROJECT SCORE ............................................................................................................................................................. 45 4.15 CONSULTATION WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE ....................................................................................... 45 V. FINANCIAL PLAN ..................................................................................................................................................................... 46 5.1 TOTAL PROJECT COST ...................................................................................................................................................... 46 5.2 PROJECT WITH TOTAL COST: IN EXCESS OF $50 MILLION .......................................................................................... 46 5.3 SOURCE OF LOCAL CONTRIBUTION ............................................................................................................................... 47 5.4 AMOUNT OF ASSISTANCE REQUESTED FROM BANK ................................................................................................... 47 5.5 FORM OF ASSISTANCE REQUESTED .............................................................................................................................. 47 5.6 OTHER PROPOSED SOURCES OF FUNDS ...................................................................................................................... 47 5.7 ANTICIPATED SCHEDULE OF FUNDS DISBURSEMENT ................................................................................................. 47 5.8 SCHEDULE OF PROJECT RECEIPT FOR LOCAL CONTRIBUTIONS .............................................................................. 48 5.9 COMMITMENT TO FUTURE MAINTENANCE .................................................................................................................... 48 5.10 CONTINGENCY PLANS SHOULD THE BOARD APPROVE LESS THAN THE REQUESTED FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE OR ACTUAL PROJECT COSTS EXCEED ESTIMATED PROJECT COSTS ............................................................................ 48 5.11 IMPACT FEES .................................................................................................................................................................... 48 5.12 HOSPITALITY TAX ............................................................................................................................................................. 49 38 4 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 5.13 LOCAL SALES TAX ............................................................................................................................................................ 49 5.14 USER FEE .......................................................................................................................................................................... 49 5.15 TAX INCREMENT FINANCING DISTRICTS ...................................................................................................................... 49 5.16 ASSESSMENT PROGRAM ................................................................................................................................................ 49 5.17 DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT PROGRAM ..................................................................................................................... 49 5.18 ZONING & LAND USE CONTROLS TO FOSTER USE OF EXISTING ROADS TO CONNECT DEVELOPMENTS ........ 49 5.19 CASH FLOW ANALYSIS .................................................................................................................................................... 49 5.20 INFLATION RATE ............................................................................................................................................................... 50 5.21 CONDEMNATION PROCEEDINGS ................................................................................................................................... 50 5.22 OTHER FUNDING SOURCES SOUGHT ........................................................................................................................... 50 5.23 POTENTIAL OBSTACLES ................................................................................................................................................. 50 5.24 LOCAL MATCH OR CONTRIBUTION ................................................................................................................................ 50 39 5 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION III. DESCRIPTION OF PROJECT The US 278 Corridor Improvement project is in Beaufort County, SC and includes the consideration of improvements for the US 278 Corridor from Moss Creek Drive to Spanish Wells Road. The project corridor is a SC Department of Transportation (SCDOT) owned and maintained facility and is a part of the National Highway System (NHS). In addition, US 278, including the entire project limits, is within the Strategic Statewide Freight Roadway Network in the SCDOT South Carolina Statewide Freight Plan. US 278 is the only access onto and off Hilton Head Island, and improvements to this corridor prov ide a public benefit to the residents, employees, and the large amount of tourism that not only benefits the region, but the entire state. PROJECT SCOPE The purpose of this project is to address structural deficiencies at the existing eastbound Karl Bowers Bridge over MacKay Creek, to increase capacity, and reduce congestion along US 278 from Moss Creek Drive to Spanish Wells Road. US 278 is part of the National Highway System (NHS). The eastbound Karl Bowers Bridge will be replaced; it was originally buil t in 1956 and is scheduled for replacement. Additional potential improvements include: • Modifications to the remaining three bridge structures; • Improved access to Pinckney Island National Wildlife Refuge; and • Improved access to the C.C. Haigh, Jr. boat ramp. Considerations for multimodal transportation improvements for this corridor will also be included. Prior to the western limit at Moss Creek Drive, this project will tie into the Bluffton Parkway flyover ramps that were constructed in 2015. At the eastern limit, the project will tie into the Cross-Island Parkway, which begins just east of the intersection with Spanish Wells Road and Wild Horse Road on Hilton Head Island. The Karl Bowers Bridge and the J. Wilton Graves Bridge each contain two separate structures for the eastbound and westbound travel lanes, adding up to four structures in total that will be modified for improvement or replacement . Multimodal transportation imp rovements will be considered to provide better connectivity between existing networks and facilities. The at-grade intersections at Pinckney Wildlife Refuge, Hog Island, Jenkins Island , Squire Pope Road, and Spanish Wells Road will be evaluated for necessa ry intersection safety improvements. Any needed upgrades will be included in this project. The estimated cost for this project is $246 million, with an additional $26.4 million in project risk, resulting in the need for a total of $272.4 million. South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) budgeted $43.5 million to replace the eastbound span of the Karl Bowers Bridge. In addition, Beaufort County voters have implemented a 1 cent transportation sales tax to raise $80 million for this project and additional local matches (described further in the Financial Plan) have provided an additional $12.35 millio n to ensure that this project does not simply address a structural issue but truly solves a long -term capacity concern for the corridor. Beaufort County is respectfully requesting that the State Infrastructure Bank (SIB) provide the remaining funds for thi s project in the amount of $120 million, less than 50% of the total cost, bringing the full funding allocations of this project , including assessment of project risk, to $272.4 million. IMAGE 1: US 278 BRIDGES TO HILTON HEAD ISLAND 40 6 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION MAP 1: PROJECT CORRIDOR MAP 41 7 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION PROJECT INTENT The US 278 Corridor Improvement Project is a project of statewide significance. The implementation of this project will: • Increase mobility of people and goods. • Increase reliability and capacity of the transportation network by decreasing congestion and delay. • Improve or replace the deteriorating conditions of existing bridges. • Improve public safety and improve hurricane evacuation routes. • Improve the quality of life for the region’s population and visiting guests. • Support local, regional, and statewide economies The improvements proposed along this section of the US 278 corridor will address the bottleneck caused by the reduced 2-lane roadway (per direction) where it is joined by 3-lane improvements at both ends of this project. This bottleneck has caused crippling traffic congestion which has impacted lo cal economies, increased crash rates, and impaired hurricane evacuation efforts that have plagued this stretch of roadway for decades. The US 278 bottleneck has not only become a transportation challenge for residents and visitors in the immediate project vicinity, but it has also hampered the movement of people and goods impacting both local and regional economies . A large portion of Beaufort County’s labor force must face long delays every day on their commute to and from work across these bridges. Eliminating this bottleneck will promote employment in the area by improving mobility and decreasing congestion. This project builds upon work that has been in motion for years and is the inevitable next step and missing link to complete both the US 278 Corridor Improvements as well as the Bluffton Parkway Project, providing an improved connection from Hilton Head Island to the mainland. (Refer to Map 2) This project has been listed in master plans by the State, County, MPO, and Local Governments. US 278 CORRIDOR IMPROVEMENTS The transportation network in Beaufort County has been undergoing significant improvements to accommodate the growing population (16.3% increase from 2010 to 2018)1, a booming tourism industry and supporting economies, such as recreation, dining, and hospitality. To keep pace with transportation demand, US 278 has undergone a variety of improvement s including widening of US 278 from four lanes to six lanes (from Okatie Highway SC 170 to the eastern approach to the US 278 bridges to Hilton Head Island and from Squire Pope Road to Wilborn Road). US 278 Phase 1 (Funded by Beaufort County and SCDOT) – Construction completed 2008 - 2013, the mainland portions of US 278 were widened from four to six lanes from SC 170 to the approaches to the Atlant ic Intracoastal Waterway. This section of roadway was widened to increase safety and capacity resulting from t he increasing residential and retail growth of the area and tourism on Hilton Head Island. US 278 Phase 2 – Anticipated Construction 2019, includes improvement or replacement of US 278 on Jenkins Island. This roadway project will widen US 278 from four lanes to six lanes. It will include a multiuse path and will follow a super street design to eliminate left turns and allow only right in and right out entry. BLUFFTON PARKWAY PROJECT EXPANSION - The Bluffton Parkway Project was an effort led by Beaufort County to address the traffic and safety issues along the congested US 278 corridor leading onto Hilton Head Island by creating the Bluffton Parkway as an alternative route to US 278 to alleviate delays and congestion and serve as a hurricane evacuation route. The 12-mile parkway was completed in 2015 and connects to US 278 at the western side of the Karl Bowers Bridge and includes two 12 ft. travel lanes in each direction, a 24 ft. landscaped median, and eight ft. multiuse pathways paralleling both sides of the roadway. 1 U.S. Census Bureau, Population Estimates, Percent Change – April 1.2010 to July 1, 2018 42 8 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Bluffton Parkway, Phase 1 Bluffton Parkway, Phase 2 Bluffton Parkway, Phase 3 Bluffton Parkway, Phase 4 Bluffton Parkway, Phase 5 US 278, Phase 2 US 278, Phase 1 US 278 - Phase 1 Completed in 2008 and 2013 US 278 - Phase 2 Anticipated Construction 2019 Bluffton Parkway - Phase 4 General Obligation Bonds Bluffton Parkway - Phase 3 General Obligation Bonds Bluffton Parkway - Phase 2 General Obligation Bonds Bluffton Parkway - Phase 1 By Development Agreement Bluffton Parkway - Phase 5 Completed in 2012 - 2015 1 cent Sales Tax / FHWA Grant MAP 2: US 278 CORRIDOR IMPROVEMENTS & BLUFFTON PARKWAY PROJECTS MAP 43 9 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION SUPPORTS SCDOT’S MULTIMODAL TRANSPORTATION PLAN (MTP) GOALS This project supports all the goals and objectives listed in the South Carolina Department of Transportation, South Carolina Multimodal Transportation Plan (MTP). (See Table 1) TABLE 1: SCDOT MULTIMODAL TRANSPORTATION PLAN GOALS & OBJECTIVES (EXCERPT) OBJECTIVES: ACHIEVED BY THIS PROJECT GOAL: MOBILITY AND SYSTEM RELIABILITY Reduce the number of system miles at unacceptable congestion levels. ✔ Utilize the existing transportation system to facilitate enhanced modal options for a growing and diverse population and economy. ✔ Improve travel time reliability (on priority corridors or congested corridors). ✔ Reduce the time it takes to clear incident traffic. ✔ Utilize the existing transportation system to facilitate enhanced modal options for a growing and diverse population and economy. ✔ GOAL: SAFETY AND SECURITY Reduce highway fatalities and serious injuries. ✔ Reduce bicycle and pedestr ian and other vulnerable roadway users’ fatalities and serious injuries. ✔ Reduce roadway departure related fatality and serious injury crashes. ✔ Reduce fatal and serious injury crashes within work zones. ✔ Reduce highway - rail grade crossing crashes involving fatality or serious injury. N/A Reduce fatal and serious injury crashes at intersections. ✔ Reduce fatal and serious injury crashes involving commercial motor vehicle. ✔ GOAL: INFRASTRUCTURE CONDITION Maintain or improve the current state of good repair for the NHS. ✔ Reduce the percentage of remaining state highway miles (non -interstate/strategic corridors) moving from a “fair” to a “very poor” rating while maintaining or increasing the % of miles rated as “good”. ✔ Improve the condition of the state highway system bridges. ✔ Improve the state transit infrastructure in a state of good repair. ✔ GOAL: ECONOMIC AND COMMUNITY VITALITY Utilize the existing transportation system to facilitate enhanced freight movement to support a growing economy. ✔ GOAL: ENVIRONMENT The SCDOT’s Multimodal Transportation Plan (MTP) does not include objectives under this goal but does include guiding principles to implement this goal. This project will implement these guiding principles as appropriate throughout the lifecycle of this project. ✔ GOAL: EQUITY The SCDOT’s Multimodal Transportation Plan (MTP) does not include objectives under this goal but does include guiding principles to implement this goal. This project will implement these guiding principles as appropriate throughout the lifecycle of this project. ✔ Source: South Carolina Department of Transportation, South Carolina Multimodal Transportation Plan (MTP) (2014) 44 10 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION CONSISTENCY WITH LOCAL LAND USE PLANS Consistent with local land use plans, this project represents tangible progress towards achieving goals and objectives set by the state and municipalities across the region. The project is located within a rural / undeveloped land use area providing the transportation linkage between regional commercial land along the US 278 corridor in Bluffton and a mix o f lands use types on Hilton Head Island including park, non -residential, and residential land. Maps 3 – 6, extracted from the 2010 Beaufort County Comprehensive Plan , depict that this project is consistent with both the existing and future land use plans for the area. This project will include the required transportation network enhancements to keep pace with the growth this area is experiencing and will continue to see. MAP 4: EXISTING LAND USE / HILTON HEAD ISLAND BEAUFORT COUNTY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN (2010) Project Area Project Area MAP 6: FUTURE LAND USE / HILTON HEAD ISLAND BEAUFORT COUNTY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN (2010) Project Area Project Area MAP 3: EXISTING LAND USE / BLUFFTON AREA BEAUFORT COUNTY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN (2010) MAP 5: FUTURE LAND USE / BLUFFTON AREA BEAUFORT COUNTY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN (2010) 45 11 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION IV. PUBLIC BENEFIT ENHANCEMENT OF MOBILITY AND SAFETY US 278 is an essential urban principal arterial and the only connection between Hilton Head Island and the mainland, carrying 56,300 vehicles per day 2, making it one of the most congested roadways in South Carolina. There is more traffic on this section of US 278 than nearby Interstate 95 as it crosses into Georgia, which carries an average of only 55,300 vehicles daily.3 The bottleneck on US 278 created by the narrow bridges is quite significant, making traveling US 278 to and from Hilton Head Island no leisurely task. On a busy summer weekend, it can take hours to get on and off the island. Each day, residents, tourists, retirees, hospitality workers, and beachgoers all face the congested roadway and the bottleneck that oc curs on both ends of the project. This bottleneck leads to heightened occurrences of traffic incidents and higher crash rates. This corridor experiences an elevated number of rear -end type crashes, which are typical in bottleneck areas. Decreasing congestion will allow travelers to get to their destinations in a more efficient manner and increase the safe passage of people and goods to and from Hilton Head Island. This is imperative, especially for the work force that travels every day from Jasper, Hampto n, and Allendale Counties. Every delay impacts their livelihood as well as their ability to support their own local economies, which then ripples into regi onal and state impacts. The supporting evidence that substantiates this project provides the public b enefit of enhancing mobility and safety is included throughout Sections 4.1 – 4.15 of IV. Public Benefit. INCREASE IN THE QUALITY OF LIFE AND GENERAL WELFARE OF THE PUBLIC. The regional population of the Hilton Head Island -Bluffton-Beaufort MSA and Beaufo rt County is projected to continue to see growth rates higher than the overall growth rate of the state. Beaufort County is the 7th fastest gro wing county in South Carolina. This population growth has added and will continue to add increased pressure to t he transportation system leading to more congestion, delay, and safety issues unless the transportation network is enhanced to accommodate the increased mobility needs of the growing population. This project provides an opportunity to improve the quality of life for employees, residents, and visitors of Beaufort County, providing the opportunity for enhanced recreation, improved public health, an d air quality. The supporting evidence that substantiates this project provides the public benefit of increasing the quality of life and general welfare of the public is included throughout Sections 4.1 – 4.15 of IV. Public Benefit PROMOTION OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT Hilton Head Island is a vacation destination for tourists from across the state and around the country. According to a 2017 study, over 3,020,000 tourists visit Beaufort County each year. In 2016, tourism in Beaufort County was estimated to contr ibute an economic impact (output) of approximately $1.53 billion within the County; and approximately 7% of the statewide tourism industry in South Carolina. Not only is Hilton Head Island rated as the #1 Best Island in the Continental U.S., according to Travel and Leisure’s World’s Best Award, the area is also known for a variety of world -class golf courses, scenic natural features, historic architecture, plantation homes, historic forts, fine seafood, famed landmarks, recreational amenities, and a temper ate climate. Beaufort County contains one of only three National Historic Landmark Districts in South Carolina. B ecause this area’s tourism generates a substantial amount of revenue for South Carolina, improving the efficiency of the region’s transportation network should be a high priority for additional state investment. 2 SCDOT, Average Annual Daily Traffic Sheets, Beaufort County (2018) 3 SCDOT, Average Annual Daily Traffic Sheets, Jasper County (2017) IMAGE 2: US 278 APPROACHING BRIDGES 46 12 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 4.1 TRAFFIC STUDIES & SUPPORTING DATA TRAFFIC VOLUMES US 278 is an essential urban principal arterial on the National Highway System (NHS) and the only connection between Hilton Head Island and the mainland . SCDOT estimated Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT) for the project area of US 278, roug hly between S-242 (FORDING ISLAND RD EXT) to S-79 (SPANISH WELLS RD) is 56,300 AADT, based on 2018 data2 and the estimated truck traffic accounts for 8% of the total traffic based on SCDOT 2017 truck traffic data. This high percentage of freight traffic comes as no surp rise being that US 278 is part of the State’s Strategic Freight Network and the only land route for freight traveling to and from Hilton Head Island. SCDOT estimates that by 2040 this section of roadway will have an AADT of over 65,600 vehicles, increasing the urgency of improving the capacity of the corridor. With an average of 56,300 vehicles per day, this is one of the most traveled corridors in South Carolina. The traffic volumes on US 278 often exceed those of I-95 and are routinely above 60,000 vehicles per day. IMAGE 3: US 278 BRIDGES TO HILTON HEAD ISLAND TRAFFIC JAM Source: The Island Packet 47 13 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION PAVEMENT QUALITY SCDOT’s Pavement Management Department collects pavement condition data and calculates a Pavement Quality Index (PQI) to communicate the pavement’s condition rating. A surface’s PQI is given a range between the 0 - 5, higher PQI’s equate to better pavement quality while a low PQI indicates poorer pavement quality. As shown in Chart 1; the average PQI for this section of US 278 is 3.06, with some fluctuation througho ut the “fair” range. As determined by SCDOT, “fair” is a general term used to describe the condition of the pavement that has a Remaining Service Life (RSL) of five to nine years.4 Chart 1 shows a noticeable decrease in pavement quality in the approximate area that corresponds with the structurally deficient eastbound span of the Karl Bowers Bridge. More information on structural conditions of the bridges is in Section 4.2. 4 SCDOT, The State of the Pavement Report, (2014) CHART 1: US 278 PAVEMENT QUALITY INDEX Source: South Carolina Department of Transportation (2017) Great Poor 48 14 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION SOUTH CAROLINA CRASH STATISTICS South Carolina has one of the highest rates of traffic fatalities per 100 million vehicle miles traveled in the country5 • One person is killed every 8.9 hours on South Carolina roadways. 6 • One person is injured every 8.7 minutes.6 • One traffic collision occurs every 3.7 minutes.6 Collisions, resulting injuries, and fatalities are on the rise in South Carolina (Charts 2 & 3), these trends are far exceeding the national average (See Chart 4). 5 Insurance Institute for Highway Safety Highway Loss Data Institute, General Statistics Based on 2016 US DO T FARS Data (2017) https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/state-by-state 6 South Carolina Department of Public Safety, South Carolina Traffic Collision Fact Book (2017) IMAGE 4: TRAFFIC CRASH Data Source: South Carolina Traffic Collision Fact Book 2017 Data Source: South Carolina Traffic Collision Fact Book 2017 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 CHART 3: SOUTH CAROLINA 10 YEAR TRAFFIC FATALITIES (NUMBER OF FATALITIES) 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 CHART 2: SOUTH CAROLINA 10 YEAR MOTOR VEHICLE COLLISIONS (THOUSANDS OF COLLISIONS) 49 15 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION CHART 4: MILEAGE DEATH RATE (FATALITIES PER 100 MILLION VEHICLE MILES TRAVELED) SOUTH CAROLINA vs. NATIONAL AVERAGE 25 YEAR TREND 1993 - 2017 50 16 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION PROJECT AREA CRASH DATA SUMMARY South Carolina led the country in most traffic fatalities per 100 million vehicle miles traveled in 2017.5 The state’s roadway network continues to be one of the deadliest in the United States . This section of roadway is one of the heaviest traveled corridors in the st ate often experiencing congestion, delay, and increased amounts of traffic related crash incidents. At the project limits, travelers are wedged from six lanes into four lanes. This bottleneck leads to increased congestion and results in heightened numbers of crashes, especially rear-end crashes caused by the abru pt accelerating and decelerating of vehicles traveling through the congested area. As illustrated in Chart 5, this section of US 278 experienced 6 48 total crashes over just a five-year period (2014-2018).7 According to the SCDOT, the statewide average for rear-end type crashes is approximately 35%. This section of roadway experienced a five -year average rear-end crash rate of 6 3%, demonstrating that this section is well above the statewide average for similar roadways. The US 278 Bridges as they currently exist present a hazardous gateway into a well-visited tourist attraction and massive economic contributor to the entire state. Regarding Urban Principal Arterials , one way that SCDOT mitigates for rear-end crashes in bottleneck area s is by implementing roadway widening and additional lanes to increase capacity and decrease congestion. Expanding this section of US 278 to 6-lanes would likely reduce the total number o f crashes along US 278 and increase the safety of the traveling public. 7 SCDOT, Five-Year Crash Summary – Beaufort County US 278 (FORDING ISLAND RD) to (SQUIRE POPE RD), (2018) CRASH SUMMARY US 278 Project Area (From Fording Island Rd. Intersection to Squire Pope Rd. Intersection) 01/01/2014 – 12/31/2018 Approximately 3.7 miles Fatality Crashes 5 Injury Crashes 149 PDO Crashes 494 2014-2018 Total Crashes 648 Rear End 412 Angle 93 Sideswipe 59 Head On 4 Run Off Road 60 Animal 1 Bicycle 0 Pedestrian 2 Other 17 Total Crashes 648 CHART 5 – FIVE-YEAR CRASHES WITHIN PROJECT LIMITS (2014 – 2018) Source: South Carolina Department of Transportation 51 17 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Not only did this portion of US 278 have elevated numbers of crashes, but these crashes resulted in heightened reports of fatalities and injuries. As depicted in Chart 6, in five-years’ time there were 5 fatalities within the project limits and 149 crashes that resulted in injuries. This dangerous roadway is causing injury for residents, commuters, and tourists. On top of these life- threatening accidents, 494 crashes that resulted in personal damage only (PDO) were also recorded. According to the SCDOT, this portion of roadway has a significantly higher amount of crashes than other 4-mile stretches of similar roadways. As illustrated in Chart 6, the spikes in crashes over the past five years are mostly occurring near the western ends of this project’s limits, which corresponds to the beginning points of the bottleneck at the western end of the approach to the US 278 bridges. Segment 11.15 – 11.25 is located near the intersection of US 278 and Moss Creek Drive. Segment 11.35-11.45 is located near the intersection of US 278 and Salt Marsh Drive. Four out of five fatalities in the project limits took place near the bottleneck at the west end of the bridge. This narrowing roadway is causing a bottleneck in traffic and is fueling the elevated numbers of injuries and fatalities along this section of US 278. The traffic bottlenecks are creating a hazardous section along one of the most well-traveled corridors in South Carolina, a state that already yields one of the highest numbers of traffi c fatalities per 100 million vehicle miles traveled in the country. CHART 6: FIVE-YEAR CRASHES WITHIN PROJECT LIMITS (2013 – 2017) BY SEGMENT 52 18 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 4.2 URGENCY OF PROJECT The current state of the US 278 bridges to Hilton Head Island is producing severe congestion, promoting unsafe travel, limiting mobility for freight and goods, and ultimately hindering the economic stability of the region. All four of the US 278 bridge structures are listed as functionally obsolete. The eastbound structure of the Karl Bowers Bridge is also rated as structurally deficient, with a Sufficiency Rating of only 53.7. As a structurally deficient bridg e, the eastbound bridge over Mackay Creek requires repairs or replacement to avoid future weight restrictions for this important freight corridor. US 278 has been listed as a system upgrade project in the 2018 SCDOT Statewide Transportation Improvement Pro gram (2017-2022) to improve the US 278 corridor 8 and is ranked as the #1 priority project in the Lowcountry Area Transportation Study (LATS) 2015-2019 Transportation Improvement Program (TIP)9 SCDOT has allocated $43.5 million to be used to remediate the structural deficiencies of the eastbound structure of the Karl Bowers Bridge. Improving only the structural deficiencies of the eastbound stru cture of the Karl Bowers Bridge will resolve the existing structural issues through rehabilitation or reconstructio n, but it will not address the pressing capacity and congestion issues stemming from all four of the 2 -lane bridges. If the structural deficiencies of the eastbound structure of the Karl Bowers Bridge are not repaired or improved, weight and use restrictio ns will need to be added to the bridges . Weight and use restrictions on the bridge will result in impaired movement of suppl ies and goods that fuel the thriving tourism -based economy on Hilton Head Island. With the tourism industry in the Hilton Head Islan d-Bluffton-Beaufort MSA contributing such a significant amount to South Carolina’s total revenue, these weights and use restrictions would lead to notable statewide impacts. It is crucial that this project be approved now for the full funding amount so that the $92.35 million in local funds and the $43.5 million from the SCDOT can be used concurrently with the SIB grant funds to appropriately develop a scope for the project improving all four bridge spans and addressing both the structural deficiencies of the Karl Bowers Bridge as well as the capacity issues caused by all four of the narrow bridge spans and associated roadways. This will enhance the flow of commuters, tourists, labor force workers, and freight across the region. DETERIORATING CONDITIONS OF EXISTING BRIDGES According to the American Road and Transportation Builders Association 2018 Deficient Bridges Report, the US 278 eastbound lane of the Karl Bowers Bridge over Mackay Creek is ranked #15 on the topmost traveled structurally deficient bridges in South Carolina ; ranked #1 on this list for the Lowcountry region.10 During an inspection of the bridges over eight and a half years ago, Collins Engineers, Inc. found corrosion of the steel girders, cracks in the concrete girders and footings, loss o f protective coating in the superstructure, exposure of the footings, undermining at the channel piers and more. 11 Repairs have included routing cracks and filling them with flexible mastic sealant, cleaning corrosion off steel girders and spraying with a protective coating, repairing the spall at the bottom of some pile caps, and many more. 8 South Carolina Department of Transportation, Statewide Transportation Improvement Program (2017-2022) 9 Lowcountry Area Transportation Study (LATS) Metropolitan Planning Organization, 2015-2019 Transportation Improvement Program (2016) 10 American Road and Transportation Builders Association, 2018 Deficient Bridge Report (2018) 11 Collins Engineer Inc., Cursory Above Water and Underwater Investigation of US 278 East and West Bound Over Mackay Creek and Skull Creek (2010) IMAGE 5: CRACKS AND RUST STAINS ON A PILE UNDER US 278 WBL OF KARL BOWERS BRIDGE OVER MACKAY CREEK Source: Collins Engineer Inc. 2010 53 19 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Bridge inspections performed in 2018 found that the superstructure and substructure of the eastbound bridge over Mackay Creek are in poor condition.12 The bridges are facing structural challenges as well as roadway congestion and mobility challenges. Therefore, the replacement of these bridges is a priority for the region. In addition, while the bridges are being replaced due to the structural condition, consideration for the alleviation of congestion with the new structures would ensure strategic use of funds. More information regarding the urgency of this project is in Section 4.8 - REGIONAL AND STATEWIDE SIGNIFICANCE. 4.3 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT RESOLUTION Not applicable. The South Carolina Transportation Infrastructure Bank (the Bank) criteria states: “If applicable, a resolution from the local governing body or bodies which make a finding, with supporting information, that the project is essential to the ec onomic development in the area or state and consistent with applicable local land use plans. Must be submitted if applicable as an Economic Development project.” This project is not an Economic Development project. 4.4 CERTIFICATE FROM THE ADVISORY COORDINATING COUNCIL FOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT OF THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE Not applicable. The South Carolina Transportation Infrastructure Bank (the Bank) criteria states:” If applicable, a certificate that the project is essential to the economic development in the state from the Advisory Coordinating Council for Economic Development of the Department of Commerce. Must be submitted if applicable as an Economic Development P roject.” This project is not an Economic Development project. 12 SCDOT: The Office of Bridge Maintenance, National Bridge Inventory Structure Inventory and Appraisal Report (2018) IMAGE 6: CRACKS ON SUPPORTING CONCRETE BENEATH BRIDGE. Source: Collins Engineer Inc. 2010 54 20 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 4.5 CURRENT AND FIVE-YEAR HISTORY OF UNEMPLOYMENT DATA According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, SC Dept of Employment & Workforce , Beaufort County and the Hilton Head Island- Bluffton-Beaufort Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA) are both tied for having the 10th Best Unemployment Rate (3.2%) compared to all South Carolina Counties.13 The unemployment rate has been steadily declining for each jurisdiction, as shown in Chart 7. The civilian labor force and overall employment has been on the rise in the Hilton Head Island -Bluffton-Beaufort M SA, while unemployment is on the decline, as shown in Table 2. Beaufort County has seen a steady increase in the number of jobs that are provided through the tourism industry, up 300 jobs between 2015 and 2016.14 Tourism and the military installations are the driving force behind the low unemployment rates of the County and the MSA. As employment rises in the region, the mobility and efficient flow of goods and people become heightened priorities for the economic preservation of the area. The effectiveness of the roadway network must be constantly evaluated and improved upon to ensure the economic viability of the region remains intact. 13 Bureau of Labor Statistics, SC Dept of Employment & Workforce Data (2018) 14 Regional Transactions Concepts, LLC, Estimate Total Impact of Tourism in Beaufort County, SC, 2016 (2017) TABLE 2: CURRENT & FIVE-YEAR EMPLOYMENT DATA HILTON HEAD ISLAND-BLUFFTON-BEAUFORT MSA YEAR CIVILIAN LABOR FORCE EMPLOYMENT UNEMPLOYMENT UNEMPLOYMENT RATE 2018 87,731 84,927 2,804 3.2% 2017 86,333 82,896 3,437 4.0% 2016 84,375 80,834 3,841 4.5% 2015 83,519 78,979 4,540 5.4% 2014 80,930 76,345 4,585 5.7% Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, S.C. Dept of Employment & Workforce 3.2% 4.0% 4.5% 5.4% 5.7% 3.2% 4.0% 4.6% 5.5%5.7% 0% 2% 4% 6% 20182017201620152014 CHART 7: FIVE YEAR UNEMPLOYMENT RATE Hilton Head Island-Bluffton-Beaufort MSA Beaufort County 55 21 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 4.6 LOCAL SUPPORT FROM RESIDENTS THROUGH PETITIONS OR COMMENTS AT PUBLIC HEARINGS Local support for the project is reflected in the passage of the 1 cent tax referendum by the citizens in November 2018 that is providing $80 million dollars for the US 278 project. In addition, there have been multiple public information meetings held to inform the public about this project. The Town of Hilton Head Island sponsored the first two public meetings with support from the Town of Bluffton and Beaufort County. The first public meeting was on July 18, 2018 from 6 pm – 8 pm at the Hilton Head High School; 70 Wilborn Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC 2992.The second was held on August 15, 2018 from 6 pm – 8 pm at the Bluffton Branch County Library; 120 Palmetto Way , Bluffton, SC 29910. At these meetings a ttendees participated in visioning sessions to discu ss the transportation needs of the U.S. 278 corridor to Hilton Head Island. Public attendees generally supported the US 278 Corridor Improvement Project and demonstrated a desire for increased multi-modal facilities along US 278, highly supporting pursuing ways to decrease congestion along the US 278 corridor and across the region. They also demonstrated support for more alternative routes to US 278 to improve regional mobility. SCDOT held the NEPA Scoping Public Meeting on Thursday, September 27, 2018, between 6:00 pm and 8:00 pm at the Hilton Head High School; 70 Wilborn Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC 29926. The purpose of the meeting was to officially introduce the project to the community, gather initial comments from the public, identify the needs for the project, and help identify concerns people may have about the improvements or the project's impact to the natural and human environments. The formal public comment period for the meeting was open from September 27 through October 12, 2018; including an online comment forum. SCDOT has left the online comment forum available on the project website and it will remain open throughout the project development process. There is a second public information meeting planned for September 19 , 2019 to present the range of alternatives as well as the reasonable alternatives. The following lists the 102 comments received as a result of the September 27, 2018 public meeting to date: TABLE 3: COMMENTS FROM SEPTEMBER 27, 2018 PUBLIC MEETING NO. GENERAL COMMENT 1 In favor of project, sales tax; wants replacement of all 4 bridges, or at least replacement of oldest one and widening of others 2 Concerned about bridge architecture 3 Traffic lights are a main source of the congestion; only look to widening to 3 lanes; 4 Would like a segregated bike/ped facility 5 Questions regarding the boundaries of the project (where will the highway come in and question about turning right from the service station) 6 Wants to end the toll on the cross Island parkway 7 Would like to widen to 3 lanes and limit growth 8 Wants to route the highway away from the native islander property; wants cross island rout expanded; wants to exempt Gullah natives from the toll 9 Add an underpass to connect the boat ramp side to the refuge side, close the median and restrict traffic movement on existing curb to right in/right out 10 Lives in Windmill Harbor; concerned about entry/exit design; likes the east bound acceleration lane length and width; should keep a consistent 45mp speed throughout 11 Should have a pull-off lane for accidents; 2 access points to the island; need a safer way for residents at Mariners Cover/Windmill Harbor to enter 278 12 Interested in road/bridge re- alignment at start of the bridge (assume Bluffton side); continue lanes all the way to Cross Island 13 Need safer exit/access at Windmill Harbor; remove left turn access at several intersections; separate bike path the entire corridor 14 Night work wanted; build one bridge at the time; residents need viable lanes for use on the bridge during high tourist season 56 22 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 15 Thanks for meeting; handouts and displays amazing 16 Thanks; wider shoulders, 3 lanes for traffic each way, aesthetically impressive architecture, hidden power lines, bike lanes 17 Funding; create programs to reduce commute traffic like rideshare, working with major employers 18 Wants it to stay true to native islanders; native islander sign should be larger; crosswalk over head to the Stoney community; flyover at Windmill Harbor; not a fan of this meeting format 19 More meetings wanted for the Islanders, ways to get off the island, drainage, more sewer in native community, limb up trees 20 Concerned if we widen bridges and not all the roads there is no point; would like another bridge from the south end to Daufuskie Island and then there to Bluffton 21 Was hoping to see how it would be done. 22 open up toll road; be considerate of Gullah community 23 Important to include bike/ped trail 24 include bike lanes on new bridge 25 New bridge separate from existing one; 3 lanes each way 26 Safety concerns regarding signage at the exit for the Cross Island Roadway 27 Disappointed in lack of presentation; would like a presentation for a group of churches 28 wide safe lanes for cycling including access to/from bridge 29 Reverse lanes during specific hours/seasons; work with employers to impleme nt a 15 min clock for employees 30 Reverse lanes during specific hours/seasons; work with employers to implement a 15 min clock for employees 31 Questions about impacts to native islanders; wants consideration of a toll; look at advanced construction techniques 32 Continue on the Bluffton parkway exit lane as free flow instead of merge ; night work during tourist season 33 More lanes & wider bridges needed; reverse a lane 34 Need another bridge 35 need 3 lanes in both directions; environmental impact should be a minimum 36 Concerns about traffic at intersection of 278 and Squire Pope Road 37 Wants improvements 38 Build suspension bridge from new flyover 39 New bridge 40 Noise wall wanted 41 maintenance in Bluffton on 278 medians is poor 42 Continue flyover express to the HHI bridge; include landscaped safe haven medians includin g the native island community; make the total island pedestrian friendly, improve intersection at Squire Pope Road 43 Wanted to know where the plan was 44 Concerns about Gullah people; does not want to widen but instead reduced speeds 45 Preferred a presentation 46 Preferred a presentation 47 Concerned about timing of project and ability to enter into her family property off of 278 across from the Crazy Crab 48 New bridge to the cross island; suggested a parallel road along 278 over hog island and tha t others at the Town of HHI had already designed a plan for this 49 Concerned about access to 278 from property along 278 across from Crazy Crab. Suggests additional traffic light between the bridge & Squire Pope Road; extend the bridge from Bluffton park way to the Cross Island; tunnel; concerned because they've lost land previously to widenings and are fac ed with this again. 50 Comments regarding the Jenkins Island project 57 23 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 51 Lives in Windmill Harbor; concerned about noise; would like softer pavement ma terials and a wall 52 Wants to know if citizens really have input on the project and worries about the inconvenience to the native islanders with the widening of the road 53 wants additional bridge; widening to 3 lanes 54 Wants to widen throughout project area because of congestion 55 Would like to see Gatherings neighborhood protected from traffic noise. Upset that the wall built around the community was shortened and so several homes are exposed 56 Would like bike and ped pathways 57 Thinks it should be 4 lanes both ways; would like to know costs of 4 lanes both ways 58 Wants bike lane; seams in bridge joint should be better maintained in the future 59 Bluffton to blue heron tying into south side of 278 east of existing abutment. A better solution during engineering phase would be to create a ramp exit for blue heron right at attachment to 278 even if using part of shoulder as deceleration lane with shoulder ends sign, allowing existing deceleration lane acquired for three lane expansion. Also extend blue heron east acceleration lane as allowed. Bridge will level on pickney like existing and curve between existing road and power line approximately 114 feet of room. Park area will be closed during construction and boat ramp should have to be relocated. During construction and fill of pickney for new three lanes a pass through pre -cast cement tunnel should be installed with a temporary end wall and as other lanes are closed it can be e xtended for a way to get to the national refuge and return to Bluffton. Tunnel may need a pump 60 Concerned about widening because of its impact to her property. It is difficult to exit her property now. Would like to have a way to slow traffic - whether through speed limit or traffic light. Wants a meeting with Stoney Com munity. 61 Opposes RVs having to do U Turns to get to the Hilton Head Harbor RV Resort 62 It is imperative that bicycle and pedestrian accommodations be made for the entire Moss Creek to Squire Pope Rd stretch. This connectivity should stretch all the way to the existing pathways on the island, on the Bluffton Parkway and to Moss Creek. 63 I am in favor of replacing the bridge for safety but am opposed to native islanders' land being assumed for this project. I am opposed to widening the road to include more lanes. The project should not displace any residents of any historical properties. 64 Please include a bicycle lane on the bridge. 65 I do not want any new bridges to have more than the present two lanes onto the Island. We do not have enough room on the Island for any more visitors--we are like a balloon, and it will pop. I also agree with the Coastal Conservation League's position: a new bridge that avoids impacts to the multi- generational Gullah community in the Stoney neighborhood, accommodates future transit, provides a safe way onto the island for bike and pedestrian traffic and integrates into the existing neighborhoods on both sides of the river. 66 Please make sure that we include bicycle and pedestrian lanes on the new bridges. It is absol utely imperative that this is included. our bridge improvements. Currently HHI is a "gold medal bicycle community" but there is no way a sane person would consider riding through the area being discussed for improvement. Thank you. 67 Windmill Harbour is a well-established residential community and must continue to have safe and practical ingress and egress. Please add me to any email group that deals with this topic. 68 I hope we can move forward in renovating these aging (but critically important) bridg es. After many years of service in this harsh marine environment, where any metal corrosion (such as at bridge expansion joints, arch and deck support points, etc.) will be accelerated, SCDOT is correct in bringing this issue up now and pushing it to successful completion. 69 Any new bridge should avoid negative impact to the multi- generational Gullah community in the Stoney neighborhood, accommodates future transit, provides a safe way onto the island for bike and pedestrian traffic and integrates into t he existing neighborhoods on both sides of the river. 70 Lane access to the Island is totally inadequate and traffic is insane in the morning going to the Island and in the evening coming off the island. Medical appointments in am to doctors or the hospital causes us to leave several hours early to get there on time. It’s a bottleneck and it gets worse when come in on Friday and Sat for check in. 71 Email Included 8 pages of further description from previous comment 58 24 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 72 CCL: Summary of letter includes: (1) increased roadway safety for vehicles, bicycles and pedestrians; (3) (2) anticipation and accommodation of future state and local investments in mass transit; (4) avoidance of adverse impacts to the existing native islander community in the Stoney neighborhood; (5) protection of important environmental resources, including Pinckney Island Wildlife Refuge. 73 Concerned about the oil and pollution that go into the waterway from 278, especially into Jarvis Creek if there are additional lanes. Would like to limit expansion to the current lanes already there. 74 The road should be redirected because of the direct impact on the Gullah family properties: redirect the highway to follow the existing power lines or to go over the marsh behind the Crazy Crab and ti e back into the cross island parkway. 75 Does not want to widen the road because of all the traffic and it would take away from the yards and make it more dangerous for pedestrians. 76 Asked questions - if SCDOT study was incorporating improvements from Beaufort County on Jenkins Island and if there was enough land to have 3 lanes in both directions underneath the Bluffton Parkway flyover 77 Disagrees with widening from 4-6 lanes because of the impact to the Stoney community and also that it will change the character of the island. 78 would like an alternate route along the marsh side that would take west bound traffic from Squire Pope Rd off Island to a 3 lane bridge and another one that would take the eastbound traffic from Spanish Wells from 3 lane br idge; No 3 lanes in Gullah Community; encourages mass transit 79 Concerned about safety of community at large and thinks the speed limit is too high, taking of land from native islanders; would like a 2nd bridge for the islanders 80 Would like to see the culvert reopened connecting the tidal creek around Hog Island because its currently causing a loss of shrimp/oyster beds; wants sidewalks/bike paths on HHI to connect to the bridge 81 Thinks the traffic problem is only during peak hours during peak season; does not want any additional tourists; options should not adversely impact native islanders or the environment; should consider only 1 reversable late, not 2 82 Does not think the road needs to be widened, the speed limit needs to be reduced. Concerned about Stoney community. 83 Would like to see a bridge come onto the island but would like to come up with a plan to come around the Stoney area. Would like to look at Spanish Well Road or S. Pope Road to have a new road leaving the island. They (Stoney Community) would like to meet with the head of the SCDOT. 84 Does not want intrusion into his family land (108 William Hilton Parkway) 85 Concerned specifically about 2 Gullah families specifically in that area. Instead proposes to use the powerline corridor behind Stoney starting at Windmill Harbor and over to the Cross Island or use the Jarvis Creek Waterway by bridging from Windmill Harbor to the Cross Island parkway. 86 Provided information on a new 200- unit housing development near Spanish Wells & Jonesville Road. Thinks the traffic study needed for the development is done by SCDOT and has questions about that. 87 endorse and encourage the inclusion of a new safe bicycle pathway system stretching from Squire Pope over the bridges onto the Mainland 88 would like to see a bicycle pathway that would allow bicycle traffic to travel safely across the bridge 89 Represents the Native Island community and would like to see if he would host a Q&A in the community 90 I am writing to express my desire for safe, separated, bike/ped facilities across the bridge to connect Bluffton and HHI’s bike/ped network 91 very supportive of project. Would like bike lanes 92 Both on road bicycle lanes and off-road multi-user side paths are appropriate and warranted 93 I would urge you to include bike and pedestrian pathways from Squire Pope Road to Moss Creek 59 25 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 94 When the SC 802 bridge connecting Lady's Island and Beaufort was built, a fairly narrow ped facility was included. I have been over the bridge literally dozens of time. I have yet to see the ped facility empty. Also mostly African Americans exercising walking over the bridge and back. When SCDOT designs a single-track bike/ped facility, please provide a parking area on each side of the bridge, the mainland and especially on HHI side. Not much, enough for perhaps 20 cars. Ditto a small lot on Pinckney Island. 95 Same email as sent to the project email. Email Included 8 pages of further description from previous comment 96 I would strongly encourage you to incorporate into this project special bike/walking lanes. Currently the bridge is shared by cars, bikers and even pedestrians and it would be beneficial to have better separation and protection. 97 Against having an expressway through their residential, native community. Sites the difficulty getting out of her driveway and suggests lower speed limits, traffic lights and more circles like the southern end of the island. If there is a need to have a high-speed way, I would suggest that a high speed thoroughfare be connected to the bridge or the Bluffton Parkway, travel over the waterway and connect to the Cross Island Expressway. This can be at a cost to the travelers. Does not want increased lanes to manage traffic. 98 it is imperative to include bike lanes 99 In support of bike lanes; points to NWP that runs out of parking spaces during peak season but could accommodate more bikes if there were a safe way to get there. 100 Has concerns about environmental impact of water pipes underneath current 278 struc ture 101 Note on behalf of the Fish & Wildlife Service in response to LOI 102 Comments on behalf of Savannah Riverkeeper about the NWR, Stoney Community, & Boat Ramp 60 26 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 4.7 LOCAL RESOLUTIONS The resolutions listed below convey support for this project and corroborate that the current bridges along US 278 connecting to Hilton Head Island are an impediment to citizens and visitors, a safety hazard (particularly during emergency evacuations) and hinder economic activity and future development of the area. A full-size copy of each resolution is provided in Appendix A. Beaufort County Council Resolution 61 27 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Lowcountry Area Transportation Study Policy Committee Resolution 62 28 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Resolution In addition, support for this project has been received by Henry McMaster, Governor of South Carolina, The City of Beaufort, and the Town of Bluffton, as well as listed and prioritized in many long range and strategic plans. Appendix B contains the signed letters of support received for the project to date. Appendix C contains a listing of existing plans where this project is prioritized or referenced. 63 29 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 4.8 REGIONAL AND STATEWIDE SIGNIFICANCE ENHANCEMENT OF MOBILITY AND SAFETY Congestion Reduction Studies have shown that congestion on urban road networks cost the nation billions per year in longer and less reliable journey times, reduced mobility, increased vehicle operating costs, and environmental degradation.15 Congestion results when traffic demand approac hes or exceeds the available capacity of the roadway system. Bottlenecks, signal timing, and traffic incidents all contribute to congestion. Traffic congestion varies daily along the US 278 bridges to Hilton Head Island due to increased travel during peak hours of morning and evening commute periods and local school traffic. The summertime also sees increased traffic congestion due to the large number of tourists that visit the island each year. The stretch of US 278 from Fording Island Road to Spanish Wel ls Road (roughly covering the project area) has seen a steadily increasing annual average daily traffic count over the last ten years (an 18.5% increase from 2008 – 2018). This section of the roadway has not been upgraded or improved to account for this ad ded traffic flow, while both adjoining ends of US 278 have been widened or additional routes have been provided . The impact of this is illustrated in Figure 1 . This bridge replacement and congestion relief project will address the present traffic issues as well as allow for continued growth and economic development for the region while also addressing structural concerns. US 278 has been widened to six lanes, except the portion from Moss Creek Drive to Squire Pope Road, which remains a four-lane section. This has created a bottleneck on both ends of the project area. Bottlenecks on the roadway account for 40% of all traffic congestion with the next leading contributor, traffic incidents, at 25%. 16 Many of the traffic incidents that occur along this section of US 278 are due to the bottleneck and congestion. This bottlenecking of the roadway presents a challenge for maintaining flow rates along the corridor. Vehicles are forced to travel at lower speeds and either merge or allow others to merge into t he two available lanes. The narrowing of the roadway chokes the traffic flow and limits the overall capacity of the highway. The widening of these bridges into Hilton Head Island will allow all previous widened sections along US 278 and all added routes, like Blu ffton Parkway, to operate in a complete, more efficient system. With the bridges being only two lanes in each direction, any traffic incident can delay traffic and cause congestion long after the roadways have been cleared. As compared to other arterial r outes with alternative routes, this section of US 278 does not have any alternative routes, meaning that any traffic incident or congestion occurring along the bridge is much more significant compared to other arterials that have alternative routes. This widening project would provide the expanded capacity needed to reduce this congested section of roadway and deliver a more efficient east-west corridor for the region. 15 Office of Economic and Strategic Analysis, U.S. Department of Transporta tion, Assessing the Full Costs of Congestion on Surface Transportation Systems and Reducing Them through Pricing, (2009) 16 SCDOT, South Carolina Strategic Corridors Plan, (2014) FIGURE 1: The capacity at the bottleneck will dictate the capacity of the roadway. Traffic cannot travel faster than the speed through the bottleneck. IMAGE 7: CONGESTION LEADING UP TO US 278 BRIDGES TO HILTON HEAD ISLAND Capacity = 6 Vehicles Capacity = 4 Vehicles Capacity = 6 Vehicles Throughput = 4 Vehicles 64 30 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Strategic Freight Network US 278 is listed as part of the Strategic Statewide Freight Roadway Network in the SCDOT South Carolina Statewide Freight Plan (See Map 7). The Statewide Freight Roadway Network identifies roadway networks that provide through state and cross ‐regional movement as well as connections to the nodes of the network that include ports, airports and inland freight facilities. These networks have been identified as important to the flow of goods. Preserving the Statewide Freight Network assets is key to the success of the state’s economy as these routes sustain the reliability and efficiency of the goods movement network in South Carolina. The deteriorating bridge conditions, traffic congestion, and bottlenecks that occur on US 278 impact the reliabili ty and resilie ncy of this system,17 increasing costs to freight carriers and consumers. Improving the US 278 bridges as listed in this application represents tangible progress towards 10 of the 11 state freight objectives listed in the SCDOT 2018 State Freight Plan17 (Table 4. The state’s goals align with the National Freight Goals required in Fixing America's Surface Transportation Act (FAST Act). TABLE 4: SCDOT GOALS & OBJECTIVES (EXCERPT FROM 2018 STATE FREIGHT PLAN17) OBJECTIVES: ACHIEVED BY THIS PROJECT STATE GOAL: MOBILITY AND SYSTEM RELIABILITY | NATIONAL GOAL: ECONOMIC COMPETITIVENESS Reduce the number of system miles at unacceptable congestion levels. ✔ Improve travel time reliability (on priority corridors or congested corridors). ✔ Reduce congestion on the freight transportation system. ✔ Improve the year‐round reliability of freight transportation on the interstate system. ✔ STATE GOAL: SAFETY | NATIONAL GOAL: SAFETY, SECURITY, RESILIENCY / ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY Improve the safety, security, and resilience of the freight transportation system. ✔ Improve substandard roadways. ✔ Enhance truck parking availability and information management on SC interstates/South Carolina Freight Network. - STATE GOAL: INFRASTRUCTURE CONDITION | NATIONAL GOAL: STATE OF GOOD REPAIR Maintain or improve the current state of good repair for the National Highway Service (NHS). ✔ Reduce the percentage of remaining state highway miles (non-interstate/strategic corridors) moving from a “fair” to a “very poor” rating while maintaining or increasing the % of miles rates as “good”. ✔ Improve the condition of the state highway system bridges. ✔ STATE GOAL: ECONOMIC AND COMMUNITY VITALITY NATIONAL GOAL: ECONOMIC COMPETITIVENESS / ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY Utilize the existing transportation system to facilitate enhanced freight movement to support a growing economy. ✔ 17 SCDOT, South Carolina Statewide Freight Plan, (2018) MAP 7: ROADWAY FREIGHT NETWORK 65 31 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION REGIONAL ECONOMY IMPACTS Access between Hilton Head Island and the mainland is critical to economic vitality and sustaining local, regional, and statewide economies. The congestion and delay produced by this stretch of US 278 is a crucial interruption in a transportation network that Beaufort County and the region rely on for the movement of goods and people. Improving the bridges to alleviate congestion will provide a mechanism for long term economic competitiveness by: • Improving long term transportation efficiency and reliability for the movement of people and goods • Improving access between employment centers, job opportunities, and workforces • Increasing the economic productivity of labor (the fewer hours employees spend commuting will result in higher productivity at their jobs) • Supporting long term job creation Tourism is a critical source of revenue and employment for South Carolina as it generates $21.2 billion annually and supports one in every ten jobs in the state. 18 Tourists contribute to sales, profits, jobs, tax revenues, and personal income. According to a 2017 study, over 3,020,000 tourists visit Beaufort County each year. In 2016, tourism in Beaufort County was estimated to contribute an economic impact (output) of approximately $1.53 billion within the County. This is approximately 7% of all of the to urism industry in South Carolina.14 Having a robust and efficient transportation system is a cornerstone to at tracting and sustaining tourism and the economic impacts that it brings. Tourism related revenues can provide alternative sources of revenues for local governments to support visitors and the local population. This revenue can also be used as a tool to off set increasing local taxes or placing the burden on residents. Improving the US 278 corridor to Hilton Head Island is crucial to maintaining the tourism industry flourishing in Beaufort County, particularly on Hilton Head Island. As areas in Beaufort Cou nty, such as Hilton Head Island and Bluffton, continue to experience population growth and increasing visitors, the local governments will depend on tourism as an economic driver. As popularity and travel grow, the efficiency o f the highways and roadways become even more essential to the economic preservation of the area. The mobility of the region allows for the proper flow of tourists, goods, and the necessary transportation system for the labor force. US 278 must be improved to provide Beaufort County with an efficient transportation system to support its booming tourism industry. Economic Impact of Tourism Hilton Head Island is home to over 24 public and private championship golf courses, 12 miles of pristine beaches, 250 restaurants, and hundreds of oth er amenities that make the island one of the most visited places in South Carolina. 19 Tourism continues to grow in Beaufort County, bringing positive economic impacts, but also putting increased pressure on the transportation networ k. The US 278 bridges to Hilton Head Island are part of the critical transportation network necessary to support a bustling to urism economy. Investing in and improving these bridges will increase the efficiency of the transportation network and increase the mobility of people, goo ds, and services necessary to preserve the flourishing tourism industry and associated economic impac ts felt across the region. Tourism is a major economic engine that not only fuels Beaufort County, but also provides positive economic impacts for the region and the state. Tourism is a $21.2 billion industry in South Carolina and supports one in every 10 jobs in the state. In 2015, the U.S. Travel Association estimated that spending on travel or on behalf of tourism in South Carolina totaled $21.2 billion in 2016. This represents a 4.7% increase from 2015.20 According to a 2017 study, over 3,020,000 tourists visit Beaufort County each year. In 2016, tourism in Beaufort County was estimated to contribute an economic impact (output) of approximately $1.53 billion within the County . Tourist spending generated a positive impact on net revenues to local governments in Beaufort County of approximately $15 million; this does not include revenues generated by state and local accommodations tax and local hospitality taxes. The estimates output multiplier for total tourist spending for Beaufort County was 1.40, meaning that every dollar spent by tourists in Beaufort County increases output in the County’s economy by a total of $1.40. 14 This impact is important for local governmen ts to help lessen the tax burden on residents by providing a supplement (or alternative) revenue stream. 18 South Carolina Department of Parks, Recreation, and Tourism, Fiscal Year 2017-18 Accountability Report, (2018) 19 Hilton Head Island Visitor and Convention Bureau, Explore Hilton Head Island, SC. https://www.explorehiltonhead.com/, accessed on August 8, 2018 66 32 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Not only are tourists arriving to and traveling around Hilton Head Island by personal vehicle, but bicycle tourism also accounts for a noteworthy po rtion of the economic impacts of tourism. Regional Transactions Concepts, LLC estimated that bicycle tourism contributed approximately $12 million in 2017 to the total tourist expennditures on Hilton Head Island.14 This number accounts only for biking related expeditures and does not include other associated bicycle tourism impacts on service industries such as dining and lodging. Workforce Deficit In 2016, Beaufort County supplied over 13,800 direct tourism j obs (increased by 300 jobs since 2015). Beaufo rt County supplies the 3rd highest number of tourism jobs in the state. In 2016 it was estimated that there were 17,208 jobs that comprise the estimated total employment impact generated by tourists in Beaufort County, meaning tourism jobs accounted for 16 .5% of all jobs in Beaufort County in 2016.20 Even though the tourism industry is booming across Beaufort County and Hilton Head Island some business owners in the resort and hospitality industries are struggling to find workers to fill open positions. A newspaper article from May 24, 2017 by the Island Packet21 documented that job fairs hosted by the South Carolina Restaurant and Lodging Association on Hilton Head Island attracted dozens of employers, but few job seekers. According to the article, some of the workforce deficit can be attributed to new E-Verify requirements for legal workers, but business owners also cited the traffic delays and difficulties traveling to and fr om the Island using the US 278 bridges as a cause for workers not being able to access jobs on the Island. Most of the resort and hospitality workers do not live on Hilton Head Island. The lack of affordable housing on the Island me ans that many workers must commute from other areas to reach their places of employment on the Island. Acc ording to the U.S. Census Bureau, Center for Economic Studies it is estimated that in 2015 there were a total of 20,636 people employed on Hilto n Head Island. Of the total number of people employed on the islan d, 12,693 people (61.5%) commuted to the Hilton Head Island daily from other areas. An estimated 5,398 people live on Hilton Head Island but commute off the island daily for their jobs. Additionally, it is estimated that there were 7,943 people that both lived and worked on Hilton Head Island.22 Palmetto Breeze offers public transportation service from inland areas to Hilton Head Island. Many Island employees use this public transit service riding from Allendale, Colleton, Hampton and Jasper Counties, and elsewhere in Beaufort County to Hilton Head Island. Allendale riders, as an example, face a 1.5-hour commute (approximately 76 miles) to travel between their homes in Allendale, SC to commute to their jobs on Hilton Head Island. The delays along the commute are often attributed to congestion caused by the bottlenecks of the US 278 bridges. Improving the bridges to alleviate congestion would increase traffic flow making 20 U.S. Travel Association, The Economic Impact of Travel on South Carolina Counties 2016 (2017). 21 The Island Packet, Workforce Crisis: At Hilton Head Job Fair, Employers Far Outnumber Job Seekers, Article by Teresa Moss, https://islandpacket.com/news/business/article152191112.html, accessed on August 8, 2018 22 U.S. Census Bureau, Center for Economic Studies, Inflow/Outflow Analysis (2015) IMAGE 8: PALMETTO BREEZE PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION SERVICE 67 33 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION it easier and faster to commute on and off the Island. Making access to the Island easier will encourage more workers to apply for jobs on the Island, eliminating some workforce deficit. INCREASE IN THE QUALITY OF LIFE AND GENERAL WELFARE OF THE PUBLIC Population Growth The region has developed significantly with new residents moving in regul arly, making Beaufort County the 7th fast est growing county in South Carolina. Both the Hilton Head Island-Bluffton-Beaufort MSA and Beaufort County’s growth rates are projected to be higher than the overall growth rate of the state. According to population projections by the South Carolina Revenue and Fiscal Affairs Office and as illustrated in Chart 9: Population Growth Rate, by 2030 the population of Beaufort County is anticipated to grow by approximately 33%, Hilton Head Island -Bluffton-Beaufort MSA will grow by approximately 21%, and the sta te of South Carolina will grow by about 19%. The transportation system needs to support the increasing residential population, additionally it must account for the daily influx of commuters and visitors. According to the Beaufort County Comprehensive P lan, tourists, visitors, seasonal residents, and daily commuters increase the County’s population by an additional 34% on an average day. 23 23 Beaufort County, Beaufort County Comprehensive Plan, (2010) 0 50,000 100,000 150,000 200,000 250,000 300,000 2000 2010 2018 2020 (Projected) 2025 (Projected) 2030 (Projected) CHART 8: PROJECT POPULATION GROWTH Beaufort County Hilton Head Island-Bluffton-Beaufort MSA *Information based on population projections provided by the South Carolina Revenue and Fiscal Affairs Office and S.C. Department of Employment and Workforce Community Profile 4.5% 18.5% 8.1% 32.9% 8.3% 20.6% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% Growth Rate 2010 -2018 Projected Growth Rate 2018 -2030 CHART 9: POPULATION GROWTH RATE South Carolina Beaufort County Hilton Head Island-Bluffton-Beaufort MSA 68 34 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Air and Environmental Effects Traffic congestion contributes to a reduc tion in local and regional air quality. When vehicles travel at the posted speed limits they function more efficiently. When vehicles travel through cong ested corridors there is an increased amount of stop -and-go actions, which can decrease fuel efficiency and increase air pollution produced by vehicles. Improving congestion along this corridor could lead to improved air quality for the region and increased quality of life for residents and visitors. Enhanced Bicycle and Pedestrian Networks Improving the multimodal connections along the US 278 bridges to Hilton Head Island would mean improved safety for pedestrians and bicyclists traveling through the corridor. This project will evaluate all options to improve the multimodal connections throughout the corridor. Beaufort County and Hilton Head Island provide an extensive bicycle and pedestrian transportation and recreation network. Bicycling and walking are not only modes of transportation , but they can be forms of recreation and improve an individual’s ove rall health and well -being. A study from the American Journal of Public Health found that when an environment is more walkable and bikeable, the obesity rates are lower, and a larger perc entage of adults achieve the recommended level of physical activity.24 With such a large percentage of Hilton Head Island’s workforce commuting into the island from over the bridge, a non -motorized transportation alternative could improve the health of the region as well as reduce congestion on the roadway. As the US 278 Corridor Improvement Project aims to decrease traffic congestion, multi-modal transportation options will also be considered to remove some of the congestion by replacing vehicle trips with bicycle or pedestrian trips. Improving connectivity over the bridge could create a potential for new bicycle shops , hotels, and restaurants in the region. This could have a beneficial impact on the mainland’s economic development and physical health of the population. Hilton Head Island is recognized as a Gold Level B icycle Friendly Community by the American League of Bicyclists, giving the designation as one of the top bicycle-friendly communities in the United States.25 Hilton Head Island is one of only three Gold Level Communities in the Southeast and only one of four on the East Coast to receive this designation. The Gold Level distinction recognizes the Town's commitment to improving conditions for bicycling through its investment in bicycling promotion, education programs, infrastructure and pro-bicycling policies. 24 The U.S. Department of Transportation – Safer People, Safer Streets: Pedestrian and Bicycle Safety Initiative 25 The League of American Bicyclists, Bicycle Friendly State ranking, and summary list of Bi cycle Friendly Communities, Businesses, and Universities within the state. https://bikeleague.org/bfa/awards#community, accessed on June 13, 2019 HILTON HEAD ISLAND BICYCLE FACTS: The island is only 12 miles long and five miles wide but there are: ▪ 1 mile of bike lanes ▪ 120 miles of shared-use paths • 64 miles paved public paths ▪ 8 miles of planned pathways ▪ 2 miles of single track ▪ 24% of arterial streets have bikes lanes or paved shoulders IMAGE 9: TOURIST BIKE RENTAL COMPANIES Source: Explore Hilton Head Island 69 35 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION The Island provides a bicycle network of over 108 miles of multiuse paths for people to enjoy by bicycle or on foot 26 (see MAP 8: PUBLIC PATHWAYS MAP TOWN OF HILTON HEAD (2015). Hilton Head Island supports a bicycle culture that can be felt across the community and numerous bicycle shops and hotels across the Island. The 35 bicycle shops and hotels provide a combined 25,000 bicycles that may be rented any day of the week. Hilton Head Island provides 30 Pathway Kiosks featuring maps, biking brochures, and biking do’s and don’ts videos for out of town guests and visitors. Hilton Head Island has even developed its own bicycling app, Island Compass, which includes information for biking around the Island. As shown in MAP 8: PUBLIC PATHWAYS MAP TOWN OF HILT ON HEAD (2015), there are no bicycle lanes or pathways along US 278 to connect Hilton Head Island to the mainland. A pathway across Jenkins Island will be considered to tie into the US 278 bridges. This potential future connection across Jenkins Island and the bridges could provide bicycle access from Hilton Head Island to the mainland as well as the 7.7-mile Pinckney Island Ride Trail on the Pinckney Island National Wildlife Refuge. 26 Hilton Head Island-Bluffton Chamber of Commerce & Visitor and Convention Bureau, Biking on Hilton Head Island, Explore Hilton Head Island, SC. https://www.hiltonheadisland.org/see-do/biking/biking-hilton-head-island, accessed on October 24, 2018. MAP 8: PUBLIC PATHWAYS MAP TOWN OF HILTON HEAD (2015) 70 36 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Bluffton Parkway is paralleled by a shared use path which currently stretches between Buckwalter Parkway and Buckingham Plantation Road, ending approximately 1,500 feet before the Bluffton Parkway flyover ramps connecting to the US 278 bridges to Hilton Head Island. There is also a shared use path along US 278 on Hilton Head Island, beginning at the intersection of US 278 and Gumtree Rd and continuing east along US 278 connecting into Hilton Head Island’s extensive pathway network. As shown in Map 9: Existing Bicycle Network, the missing link in the bicycle network is from the end of the Bluffton Parkway shared use path at Buckingham Plantation Road across the US 278 bridges to the intersection of US 278 and Gumtree Rd on Hilton Head Island. Creatin g a bicycle connection across this portion of US 278 could provide the missing link in the network and offer an alternative mode of transportation between Hilton Head Island and the mainland. A bicycle connection along the US 278 bridges is supported in multiple area planning documents. The Town of HHI Comprehensive Plan (2017) Goal 6.3-D is “To have a pathway network that provides for recreational opportunities as well as an alternative means of transportation to and on the Island.” On page 88 of the pla n, Implementation Strategy 6.3-D is to “Coordinate with SCDOT and Beaufort County to provide a pathway link to the mainland.” The 2010 Beaufort County Comprehensive Plan contains a map from the Trails and Blueways Master Plan, which recommends adding a tra il along the US 278 bridges. 27 The 2040 Lowcountry Area Transportation Study (LA TS) Long Range Transportation Plan recommends a future roadway improvement over the bridges to include 10’ outside paved shoulders as shown in Figure 2.28 Wide shoulders are usef ul not only for bicycle access but also for emergency vehicle access and improved evacuation capacity. Multimodal transportation improvements will be considered in the US 278 Bridges to Hilton Heads Island Project. Regardless of the type of bicycle and pedestrian accommodations, any improvements to the non-motorized connections across the US 278 bridges will: • Enhance non-motorized transportation alternatives • Improve the appeal of the Island to visitors • Improve bicycle, pedestrian and driver safety 27 Beaufort County, Beaufort County Comprehensive Plan – Appendix 10 A - Trails and Blueways Master Plan, (2010) 28 Lowcountry Council of Governments, The 2040 Lowcountry Area Transportation Study (LATS) Long Range Transportation Plan, (2015) FIGURE 2: US 278 Bridge Widening - Recommended Future Roadway Cross-Section32 Source: 2040 Lowcountry Area Transportation Study (LATS) Long Range Transportation Plan MAP 9: EXISTING BICYCLE NETWORK 71 37 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project HURRICANE EVACUATION In the event of a mandatory evacuation of an area, congest ion and delays are expected and unavoidable on the roadways. With each evacuation event, Beaufort County analyzes the efficiency of their roadway network and works to identify regions or areas where congestion and delays are at unacceptable levels. These evaluations are based on actual evacuations. Improvements to Beaufort County’s evacuation system over the past few years include the Bluffton Parkway project and the widening of Okatie Highway (SC 170). The remaining piece to this upgrade of the evacuation network is the widening of the US 278 bridges to Hilton Head Island, an area at higher risk of evacuation events. There are 32 American Red Cross shelter locations within the 46 counties in South Carolina where hurricane evacuees can seek safety. While temporary shelters are available during smaller scale storms, Beaufort County has no shelters for its residents for any Category 1 or greater hurricanes. In the event of an evacuation, the near est location would be the sole shelter in Jasper County.29 Due to the low elevations of the Lowcountry , the coastal barrier islands of Jasper, Beaufort, Colleton, and Charleston Counties are typically the first to require evacuation. When Hurricane Irma hit South Carolina in 2017, these islands had to be vacated, affecting 44,457 residents. Of this number, 42,000 evacuees were from Hilton Head Island.30 Several other threatening hurricanes have hit South Carolina in the past years, including Hurricane Joaquin in 2015 which caused intense flooding and Hurricane Matthew in 2016 that brought immense economic impacts throughout the South. 29 The American Red Cross, Red Cross Supporting Evacuation Shelters in South Carolina, (2016) 30 The Post and Courier – 44,457 South Carolina Residents Impacted by Evacuations in Response Hurricane Irma, (2017) IMAGE 10: TRAFFIC INTENSIFIES DURING THE MANDATORY EVACUATION DUE TO IMPENDING HURRICANE. Source: https://www.longroom.com 72 38 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Evacuation Zones South Carolina’s 2018 Critical Need Transportation Operations Plan evaluated the state’s elevations and assigned evacuation zones based on the projected surges that woul d affect the areas. Evacuation Zone A represents the most vulnerable locations of each county. Beaufort County is the only county in the state that is entirely comprised of Zone A (as shown in Image 11).31 With this susceptibility, the county’s hurricane evacuation routes must be as efficient and functional as possible. This 2018 Operations Plan found that the time it takes to execute an evacuation is based on multiple variables which include the coasta l county at risk, the category of storm, time of year, and time of day that the evacuation commences.29 The state is divided into four conglomerates: northern, western, central, and southern. In the event of an evacuation , the southern conglomerate , which includes Beaufort, Jasper, Colleton, and Hampton County could take up to 24 hours to fully vacate.29 While the completion of the Bluffton Parkway provided an alternative evacuation route from east to west and the widening of US 170 and parts of US 278 decreased delays in the Bluffton and Beaufort area, it did not solve the problem entirely. The US 278 bridges that all Hilton Head Islands’ residents, employees, and tourists must cross to leave the island are only 4 lanes total, creating massive delays as the road bottlenecks . This stretch of US 278 from Moss Cre ek Drive to Squire Pope Road is the only remaining 4-lane portion of the roadway. In an emergency event, Hilton Head Island residents face extreme traffic conditions before they can reach the widened portion of US 278 or Bluffton Parkway. With the population steadily growing on the island and storm frequency and severity increasing, the issue worsens each year. 31 South Carolina Emergency Management Division, State of South Carolina Critical Transportation Need Evacuation Operations Plan, (2018) IMAGE 11: ALL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY IS CLASSIFIED AS EVACUATION ZONE A, MAKING ALL RESIDENTS IN BEAUFORT COUNTY VULNERABLE TO A HURRICANE REGARDLESS OF THE MAGNITUDE.29 73 39 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Evacuation Routes The need to improve evacuation routes and decrease evacuation times is critically important to the areas that are experiencing growth and are subject to constant storm threats. After Hurricane Matthew made landfall in 2016, South Carolina reevaluated their evacuation plans and incorporated several new operational methods including the use of school buses as the primary mean for Critical Transportation Needs (CTN) evacuees.29 While South Carolina is using their lessons learned to improve the evacuation process, the changes that are in discussion and implementation will likely not significantly change the evacuation times from Hilton Head Island due to the bottleneck at the bridges. This narrowing of US 278 will continuously present serious delays unless the roadway is widened. Increasing the capacity of the road, such as widening the bridges will allow for continuous, constant flow of traffic off the island and eradicate the largest cause of evacuation delay in the area. To keep up with the island’s growing population, the worsening structural state of the bridge and the intensifying threat of hurricanes, the bridges into Hilton Head Island must be improved and the capacity increased. The goals of this project will complete the transformation of the county’s roadway network into an efficient and appropriate evacuation route. IMAGE 12: HURRICANE IRMA APPROACHES FLORIDA AND SOUTH CAROLINA IN 2017 WITH MAXIMUM SUSTAINED WINDS AT 155 MPH. Source: NASA Hurricanes – Geo-color Image of Hurricane Irma 2017 MAP 10: HURRICANE EVACUATION ROUTES IN BEAUFORT COUNTY 74 40 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Storm Surges Recent studies have found that the climate change is producing more destructive and powerful hurricanes. As sea levels rise globally, storm surge levels will likely increase in magnitude and frequency . The rainfall rates produ ced by a hurricane will increase by 10 -15% and t he intensities of these storms will heighten by 1 -10% in the Atlantic Basin.32 The rise in storm surge level is particularly alarming for Beaufort County due to the low elevation. A category 3 storm currently produces a storm surge of 9 -12 feet in southeast South Carolina,32 which would flood almost all of Hilton Head Island and much of the mainland of Beaufort County (See MAP 11). Beaufort County cannot afford having a poorly functioning evacuation route with i ts extreme vulnerability to storm surge levels. Because this study also found that there will be more frequent occurrences of intense storms, there will also be more strain on the already structurally deficient bridge as evacuations become more frequent . This intensification of the regio n’s hurricanes will cause further destruction and need for evacuation in the future. South Carolina Emergency Management Division (SCEMD) has estimated the Hurricane Evacuation Clearance Times for 2018 as illustrated in Table 5. The 2018 clearance times were estimated using the increase in population ( 15% increase, as estimated by ESRI Business ) in the evacuation zones of Beaufort County from 2010 to 2018. The population increase was then applied to the clearance times that were developed for the 2013 Hurricane Evacuation Study (HES). 32 NOAA, Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory: Global Warming and Hurricanes, https://www.gfdl.noaa.gov/global-warming-and-hurricanes/, accessed on June 17,2019 Hurricane Category & Evacuation Response Southern Normal Lane Use Occupancy Low High CATEGORY 1 – 2 Rapid 8 (9) 13 (15) Medium 11 (13) 15 (17) Slow 13 (15) 18 (21) CATEGORY 3 - 5 Rapid 14 (16) 19 (22) Medium 17 (20) 22 (25) Slow 19 (22) 24 (28) (#) factors in the population increase between 2010 and 2018 MAP 11: HURRICANE STORM SURGE AREAS TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND TABLE 5: BEAUFORT COUNTY INTERIM HURRICANE EVACUATION TIMES (HOURS) 75 41 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 4.9 PROS AND CONS OF ALL ALTERNATIVE TRANSPORTATION PLANS TO THE PROJECT SCDOT evaluated a range of alternative transportation plans for this project corridor, seven are currently being carried forward as reasonable alternatives . The se remaining seven alternat ives will be further reviewed and refined, with a proposed preferred alternative to be determined after a Public Hearing. Chart 10 illustrates the range of alternatives that have been considered and the remaining process that will determine the final proposed preferred alternative. SCDOT used the following evaluation criteria to evaluate the pros and cons o f each of the original alternatives, this led to the identification of the remaining seven alternatives: • Structural Deficiencies: This criterion evaluat es whether the alternative address es the structural deficiencies along eastbound US 278 (bridge over Mackay Creek) • Wetlands: Freshwater and critical area wetlands, as defined through GIS mapping, were identified based on the total area of potential impact by the alternatives • Right-of-Way: A review of the total acreage of right -of-way impacted as well as the number of individual tracts was evaluated per alternative. • Neighborhoods: The total number of neighborhoods anticipated to be impacted was evaluated for each alternative • Protected Lands: Each alternative was evaluated to determine if protected lands were i mpacted as well as the total acreage and number of individual tracts. • Pickney National Wildlife Refuge Compatibility: Each alternative was evaluated to determine if it was compatible with the Pickney National Wildlife Refuge. CHART10: ALTERNATIVES DEVELOPMENT FLOWCHART 76 42 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 4.10 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS OF PROJECT Lying along the Intracoastal Waterway, Hilton Head Island encompasses 42 square miles of semi -tropical geography. The geography surrounding the project area includes barrier islands with constantly changing ecosystems, wetlands, salt marshe s, tidal creeks, forestland, brushland, freshwater ponds, and uncultivated fields. The area is home to a variety of wildlife inc luding deer, alligators, loggerhead sea turtles, manatees, dolphins, and hundreds of species of birds. Currently this project is 40% through the Environmental Assessment (EA) process for this project and will have preliminary alternatives developed by Fall 2019 The entrance to Pinckney Island National Wildlife Refuge (NWR) is located between the Karl Bowers Bridge and the J. Wilto n Graves Bridge. The 4,053-acre refuge was established in December 4, 1975. The island was once part of a plantation owned by Major General Charles Cotesworth Pinckney; a prominent lawyer active in South Carolina politics from 1801 to 1815. Few traces of the island's plantation exist today, as most of the Island has been returned to its natural form. 33 The environmental features are part of the attraction for tourists visiting Hilton Head Island. This project aims to improve access to Pinckney Island and m inimize environmental impacts from roadway improvements. Map 1 2 illustrates some of the known environmental features located within the project area. As shown in the map, the project is located wit hin the vicinity of wetlands, refuge areas, and threatened and endangered species (including plants and animals). The map also shows the NEPA Study Area, during NEPA investigations more detailed environmental impacts and mitigation opportunities will be de termined. EXPECTED LEVEL OF NECESSARY ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENT The expected level of Environmental Document is a Finding of No Significant Impact (FONSI), which is anticipated to be approved by early 2021. It is anticipated that a US Army Corps permit will be required. In addition, it is anticipated that the following permits will also be required: • US Army Corps of Engineers • US Coast Guard • South Carolina Department of Health and Environmental Control (DHEC) 33 U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, Pinckney Island – About the Refuge. Department of the Interior, Jan. 6, 2015. https://www.fws.gov/refuge/Pinckney_Island/about.html, Accessed: August 14, 2018 IMAGE 13: PINCKNEY ISLAND NATIONAL WILDLIFE REFUGE ENTRANCE 77 43 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION MAP 12: ENVIRONMENTAL FEATURES & NEPA STUDY AREA 78 44 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 4.11 EVENTS/MILESTONES TO IMPLEMENT PHASES OF PROJECT This application is being submitted upon the passing of the Beaufort County Special Transportation Sales and Use Tax. The project is currently going through the Environmental Documentation and NEPA Compliance process which will conclude in 2020. The FONSI will be approved by FWHA in early 2021. The US Army Corps of Engineers permit approval and the US Coast Guard permit approval are both anticipated by 2022.The Preliminary Design and Concept Studies is currently underway and will conclude in 2020. Right-of-Way Acquisition is anticipated to begin in 2021 and be completed in 2023. The construction bid date is in 2023 with a 4-year construction duration beginning in 2023 and concluding in 2027, with the pro ject opening to the public in 2027. 4.12 CURRENT STATUS OF THE PROJECT SCDOT is moving the project through the planning phase with an environmental assessment (EA). The goal is acquiring right-of- way and building the selected preferred alt ernative. In association with FHWA and Beaufort C ounty, SCDOT will develop the EA, a process that will include reviewing alternatives and comparing the beneficial and negative impacts on the natural and human environments. Efforts will be focused on community involvement and communication to ensure the successful development of the environmental process. During the Alternative Development Process a range of alternatives will be considered and evaluated, including the no-build option, mass transit, high-occupancy vehicle lanes, and ridesharing. The alternatives analysis will explain how alternatives were evaluated and why each alternative was eliminated from consideration. The range of alternatives, reasonable alternatives, and results of the analysis will be presented and available for comment in the fall of 2019. 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 Environmental Documentation and NEPA Compliance FONSI Approval US Army Corps of Engineers Permit Approval US Coast Guard Permit Approval Preliminary Design and Concept Studies Right-of-Way Acquisition Construction Project Open to the Public CHART 11 : MAJOR PROJECT EVENTS AND MILESTONES 79 45 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 4.13 ENTITY STATEMENT AGREEING TO RESPONSIBILITIES 4.14 PROJECT SCORE The SIB Criteria states that “the ranking and scoring is done as part of the program categories Long Range Plan.” In addition, SC Code Section 57-1-370(B)(8) states that the project shall be “taking into consideration at least the following criteria: a. financial viability including a life cycle analysis of e stimated maintenance and repair costs over the expected life of the project; b. public safety; c. potential for economic development; d. traffic volume and congestion; e. truck traffic; f. the pavement quality index; g. environmental impact; h. alternative transportation solutions; and i. consistency with local land use plans.” This project has met each of these criteria and is listed in the priority list by SCDOT as well as being the number one priority in the LATS MPO. Through the LATS MPO criterion scoring of projects, this pr oject, identified as the number one priority, has a score of 74. An explanation of the LATS MPO scoring is in Appendix D. Based on the provided criteria for Public Benefit, as well as identifying that these improvements are part of both the National Highway System and the State Freight Network , the resulting score is a 74/100 which equals 37 points x 1.1=40.7. As the maximum number of points within the Public Benefit section is capped at 50, this project scores 40.7 points for the Public Benefit criteria. 4.15 CONSULTATION WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE Not applicable. The South Carolina Transportation Infrastructure Bank (the Bank) criteria states: “Consultation with the Department of Commerce is recommended for guidance in scoring when submitting a projec t that supports Economic Development for the State. The prioritization scoring scale for a project with this purpose would use a 0 -100% scoring scale based on the Department of Commerce scoring criteria.” This project is not an Economic Development project. TABLE 6: ACTIVITIES & RESPONSIBLE ENTITIES ACTIVITIES & RESPONSIBLE ENTITIES ACTIVITY RESPONSIBLE ENTITY CONTACT NAME ADDRESS PHONE Environmental Studies SCDOT Craig Winn 955 Park Street, Room 401 Columbia, SC 29202-0191 (803) 737-6376 Design of Project SCDOT Craig Winn 955 Park Street, Room 401 Columbia, SC 29202-0191 (803) 737-6376 Rights of Way Acquisition SCDOT Mark Westbury PO BOX 308, 858 Highway 15 North, St. George, SC 29477 (843) 636-9681 Construction SCDOT Toby Wickenhoefer 6355 Fain Boulevard, North Charleston, SC 29406 (843) 746-6734 Construction Management SCDOT Toby Wickenhoefer 6355 Fain Boulevard, North Charleston, SC 29406 (843) 746-6734 Operation SCDOT Josh Johnson 6355 Fain Boulevard, North Charleston, SC 29406 (803) 602-4415 Maintenance SCDOT Michael Black 6355 Fain Boulevard, North Charleston, SC 29406 (843) 746-6715 Contract documents will be available upon request once finalized and signed. 80 46 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION V. FINANCIAL PLAN 5.1 TOTAL PROJECT COST The total cost of the US 278 Corridor Improvement Project is $246 million. This cost estimate was provided by SCDOT Project Manager Craig Winn on October 12, 2018 as part of the US 278 Corridor Improvements project (www.scdot278corridor.com). Expense Categories Estimated Amount Preliminary Engineering through Construction Plans (10% of Construction Costs) $18,200,000 Environmental Permitting and Mitigation $10,000,000 Right-of-Way (to be obtained) $2,000,000 Utility Relocations $10,000,000 Total Construction Cost* $205,800,000 Total Project Cost $246,000,000 Local Obligations Contingency** $26,370,112** Total Project Risk $272,370,112 * Total Construction Cost includes General Mitigation, 15% Inflation Cost, 13% CEI and Contingency. SCDOT contributions are limited and 66.7% of the work will be funded by Beaufort County, with all associated risks of project delivery. **The local obligations contingency is not included within the total project cost at this time, however, elements such as Bridge Foundation Contingency, Portland Cement Index (FHWA Technical Advisory T 5080.3), Steel, and additional right -of-way are all included within the total project risk. 5.2 PROJECT WITH TOTAL COST: IN EXCESS OF $50 MILLION This project is in excess of $50 million and will follow the guidelines as described in Section 5.2.a . requiring a local contribution of at least 25% of the total project co sts with additional credit provided for the grant application for each additional 5% of local contribution and non-Bank funding. The $246 million project, including project risk, is broken down as follows: Based on the points calculation within Section 5.2.a, the following points are allocated for this project: For a project over $50 million, the amount of local contribution must be at least 25%. With a $246 million project, 25% of the total cost is $61.5 million. The Beaufort County one-cent tax provides $80 million specific to this project, thereby meeting the 25% local fund commitment, and exceeding the match with an additional $18.5 million. Th is equates to 15.04 points. The Beaufort County Road Impact Fees provide an additional $12.3 million equating to an additional 10 points. Per Section 5.24, the additional elements as noted in Table 8 provide an additional local match / non-Bank funded amount of $60.1 million. This equates to 24.42 points. The committed funds in both local match as well as non -Bank funds result in a total score of 49.46 points of the available 50 points. TABLE 8: AMOUNT OF LOCAL CONTRIBUTIONS FUNDING SOURCE AMOUNT Beaufort County one-cent tax referendum, as approved by the voters on November 6, 2018 $80,000,000 Beaufort County Road Impact Fees $12,300,000 Per Section 5.25 Federal Guideshare / Local money for the Environmental Assessment/Preliminary Engineering $4,200,000 SCDOT Bridge Replacement Funds $43,521,112 Beaufort County Funds for Jenkins Island Work $9,000,000 Town of Hilton Head Island Right-of-Way Dedication $3,350,000 Total Local / Non-Bank Funded Match including Project Risk (see Table 7) $152,370,112 SCIB Grant Request $120,000,000 Total Project Risk $272,370,112 TABLE 7: TOTAL PROJECT COST EXPENSE CATEGORIES 81 47 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 5.3 SOURCE OF LOCAL CONTRIBUTION Beaufort County voters have passed a 1 % local sales tax that will generate $80 million for the US 278 Bridge Corridor Improvement project to Hilton Head Island as part of this project. This tax was passed under the South Carolina Code of Laws Title 4 – Counties, Chapter 37 Optional Methods for Financing Transportation Facilities §4-37-30. The tax will generate a total of $120 million which will be used on transportation projects across Beaufort County. The additional funds generated from this t ax will include $10 million for sidewalk and pathway improvements, $30 million for traffic improvements on US 21 across Lady's Island, and $80 million committed to the US 278 Bridge Improvement project. The key attributes of the transportation sales tax cite that the funds are to be used for a clearly delineated list of projects, the tax is for a fixed period, and the tax is for a fixed dollar amount of revenue to be generated. The sales tax approved by the voters of Beaufort County explicitly stated that the se funds would be used for the project noted abov e, with $80 million for the US 278 bridge improvements, and would automatically sunset after 4 years or as soon as $120 million is generated. The sales tax cannot be put into effect again without voter approval. Additional local matches and non-Bank funding is discussed in Section 5.2 5.4 AMOUNT OF ASSISTANCE REQUESTED FROM BANK Beaufort County formally requests $120,000,000 from the South Carolina State Transportation Infrastructure Bank Board to assist in the completion of the US 278 Corridor Improvement Project. This grant would represent 44.1% of the overall project cost. 5.5 FORM OF ASSISTANCE REQUESTED Beaufort County requests that the funding from the SIB be in the form of a $120,000,000 grant. The money generated from the local match and the non-Bank funded sources previously described will provide the remaining 55.9% of the program’s costs. 5.6 OTHER PROPOSED SOURCES OF FUNDS As listed above, Beaufort County has passed a local sales tax that will generate $80 million for traffic improvements on Hilton Head Island as part of this project. The sales tax language, as approved, specifies the use of the funds and states: “I approve a special transportation sales and use tax in the amount of one percent to be imposed in Beaufort County for no mo re than 4 years, or until a total of $120 million dollars in resulting revenue has been collected, whichever comes first.” These improvements are specific to traffic improvements on Hilton Head Island, traffic improvements on Lady’s Island, and sidewalk & pathway improvements in Beaufort County. As documented in the Capital Program, SCDOT is committed to funding $43.5 million to be used for replacing the eastbound span of the Karl Bowers Bridge using bridge replacement funds. SCDOT’s statement regarding the commitment of these funds, as well as the County’s letter requesting this statement, is in Appendix E. 5.7 ANTICIPATED SCHEDULE OF FUNDS DISBURSEMENT The following represents the anticipated schedule of funds disbursement for the project to move forward. While the construction is not anticipated for several years, the urgency of the grant application is to ensure that the project can continue to move forward with necessary key next steps including completion of environmental review and documentation, design and construction. CHART 12: ESTIMATED CASH FLOW DIAGRAM 82 48 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 5.8 SCHEDULE OF PROJECT RECEIPT FOR LOCAL CONTRIBUTIONS It is anticipated that the Beaufort County 1% local sales tax will generate approximately $2.5 million per month, $30 million per year, for the life of the tax referendum (four years or until the total amount is $120 million; whichever comes first). This is the total tax referendum amount , of which $80 million is committed to this project. The projection of receipt of local contributions is as follows: 5.9 COMMITMENT TO FUTURE MAINTENANCE US 278 is within the state owned and maintained network and, after improvements are completed, will remain within the state owned and maintained highway network. Therefore, the future maintenance and responsibility of this roadway will be with SCDOT and included within their annual maintenance and operational programming. 5.10 CONTINGENCY PLANS SHOULD THE BOARD APPROVE LESS THAN THE REQUESTED FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE OR ACTUAL PROJECT COSTS EXCEED ESTIMATED PROJECT COSTS The $246 million estimate that is currently being used was developed by SCDOT as an estimate of what a project of this size could potentially cost based upon major structures cost and contingency. Should the Board fail to approve the amount requested and/or the project costs exceed the current estimate, Beaufort County would consider another referendum in 2020 for the project. In addition, we would work with SCDOT in order to identify other s tate or federal grant programs such as BUILD Grants in order to fund this vital piece of infrastr ucture. Phasing of the project would be difficult given the topography and that the primary nature of the improvements are bridges which are the only surface transportation link to the ma inland. However, preliminary reviews suggest it could be accomplished by constructing the western -most MacKay bridges first or focusing on only the east bound segment of the corridor. The current SCDOT estimate for this project includes a minimal contingency value, however, should actual costs exceed the estimated costs, shortfalls may be addressed using County Road Impact Fees, County TAG fees, CTC funding, or other locally appropriated funds. 5.11 IMPACT FEES Beaufort County has implemented traffic impact fees dedicated to the preliminary planning and engineering of this project to assist in its financing. $0 $20,000,000 $40,000,000 $60,000,000 $80,000,000 $100,000,000 $120,000,000 $140,000,000 May-19 July-19 September-19 November-19 January-20 March-20 May-20 July-20 September-20 November-20 January-21 March-21 May-21 July-21 September-21 November-21 January-22 March-22 May-22 July-22 September-22 November-22 January-23 March-23 May-23 CHART 13: SCHEDULE OF PROJECTED REVENUES FOR LOCAL CONTRIBUTIONS 83 49 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 5.12 HOSPITALITY TAX Beaufort County has not implemented a hospitality tax dedicated to this project to assist in its financing. This tax may be allocated for this project by County Council action. Currently traffic impact fees have already been allocated for project funding. 5.13 LOCAL SALES TAX Beaufort County voters passed a 1% local sales tax that will generate $80 million for traffic improvement s on Hilton Head Island as part of this project. More information regarding the sales tax is in Section 5.3 SOURCE OF LOCAL CONTRIBUTION. 5.14 USER FEE Beaufort County has not implemented user fees dedicated to this project to assist in its financing. User fees are not appropriate to use along this corridor, as user fees (tolls) are typically used where motorists have an option to pay a toll or use another road. US 278 is the only route for motorists to access Hilton Head Island. 5.15 TAX INCREMENT FINANCING DISTRICTS Beaufort County has not implemented a Tax Increment Fina ncing Districts (TIF) dedicated to this project to assist in its financing. TIFs are typically used in areas that redevelopment of blighted properties or public property development is ta rgeted or desired. This is not the case for areas in and around Hilton Head Island and Beaufort County that would be impacted by the US 278 Bridges. The development goals for the area align with preservation of the corridor and accommodating the existing a nd projected traffic needs than redevelopment or additional development making a TIF an inappropriate funding source for this project. 5.16 ASSESSMENT PROGRAM Beaufort County has not implemented an assessment program dedicated to this project to assist i n its financing. An assessment program is not appropriate for this project as the impact of improving the US 278 bridges to Hilton Head Island reaches far beyond just the property owners within the area. The impact of these bridges is felt across the regio n and the state in terms of the large amount of tourism occurring in Hilton Head Island and resulting economic impacts and revenues. 5.17 DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT PROGRAM Beaufort County has not implemented a development agreement program dedicated to this p roject to assist in its financing. A development agreement program is not appropriate for this project as the improving the US 278 bridges to Hilton Head Island is not to service any specific development. These bridges are part of the critical transportati on system serving both the region and state interests. 5.18 ZONING & LAND USE CONTROLS TO FOSTER USE OF EXISTING ROADS TO CONNECT DEVELOPMENTS This section is not applicable to the US 278 bridges to Hilton Head Island, as this project is the only connection of ground -based transportation connection between Hilton Head Isla nd and the mainland of South Carolina. This project reaches well beyond the purpose of connecting developments. These bridges are part of the critical transportation system serving both the region and state interests. 5.19 CASH FLOW ANALYSIS The major determination for this project currently is to make the most effective and efficient use of funds for the region. With the status of the Karl Bowers Bridge, SCDOT must invest funds to replace the structure. While the remaining three bridges were constructed between 1982-1983 and are not in need of immediate replacement due to structural deficiencies, they do suffer from deferred maintenance and will require improvements for congestion relief, and eventually, will require replacement for capacity improvements as the region continues to grow. Based on this, the estimated system preservation costs versus the current project cost, illustrate the current investment is a better use of funds economically, as well as for the public benefit obtained. 84 50 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Potential system preservation costs for these types of structures, using present day value and assuming a 70 -year lifespan for these structures (replacement in 2053), is shown below: TABLE 9: ESTIMATED MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR COSTS OF PROJECT OVER EXPECTED USEFUL LIFE TIME FRAME MAINTENANCE ACTIVITY ESTIMATED COST 2020 – 2025: Miscellaneous Steel Repairs / Painting $10M - $15M 2030 – 2035: Miscellaneous Steel Repairs $1.0M - $2.0M Major Systems Preservation Investment $85M - $95M 2035 – 2040: Miscellaneous Crack Repair / Crevice Corrosion $10M - $15M 2040 – 2045: Miscellaneous Steel Repairs $1.0M - $2.0M 2050 – 2055: New Structures to be Built / Existing Structures demolished $190M - $200M Karl Bowers Bridge Structure to be modified $20M - $25M TOTAL $317M - $329M 5.20 INFLATION RATE The South Carolina Department of Transportation used an inflation factor of 15% in the proposed cost estimate. This inflation factor only covers the 36-month design development period. 5.21 CONDEMNATION PROCEEDINGS The South Carolin a Department of Transportation is willing to serve as the named party in any condemnation proceedings i f condemnation is needed to complete this project, as this is a SCDOT project improving SCDOT infrastructure. 5.22 OTHER FUNDING SOURCES SOUGHT Other funding, besides those already listed hereinabove, have not been utilized or sought for this project at t his time. The South Carolina gas tax increase is not able to be used for this project as most of that funding is going to address deteriorating infrastructure that has already been prioritized by the state. These bridges were not part of that list as three of the four bridge spans of US 278 to Hilton Head Island were built in the 1980’s and are not in need of repair due to deteriorating infrastructure but instead need expansion to address the lack of capacity. 5.23 POTENTIAL OBSTACLES Currently Beaufort County has no legal issues related to this project. There are no pending lawsuits against the County associated with this project at this time. An Environme ntal Assessment (EA) is currently underway on the project. SCDOT anticipates an approved FONSI by 2021 and US Army Corps of Engineers and US Coast Guard permits by 2022 Right-of-way costs have not yet been calculated. Managing Obstacles Beaufort County and SCDOT have a long and successful history of collaboration on major highway projects and are both committed to ensuring the success of this project. Beaufort County has been proactively engaging and coordinating with the public, stakeholders, and partners including: • South Carolina Department of Transportation • Town of Hilton Head • Town of Bluffton • USACOE • SCDHEC • Coastal Conservation League • Native Island Community 5.24 LOCAL MATCH OR CONTRIBUTION Per the evaluation criteria, this information is listed within Section 5.2 PROJECT WITH TOTAL COST: IN EXCESS OF $50 MILLION. The Financial Plan scope for this application is 49.46 points out of a maximum score of 50 points 85 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project APPENDIX A LOCAL RESOLUTIONS 86 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Beaufort County Council Resolution 87 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 88 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Lowcountry Area Transportation Study Policy Committee Resolution 89 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 90 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council Resolution 91 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 92 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 93 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 94 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 95 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION APPENDIX B LETTERS OF SUPPORT 96 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Henry McMaster, Governor of South Carolina – Letter of Support 97 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION The City of Beaufort – Letter of Support 98 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION The Town of Bluffton – Letter of Support 99 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Southern Carolina Regional Development Alliance – Letter of Support 100 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION APPENDIX C EXISTING PLANS WHERE THIS PROJECT IS PRIORITIZED OR REFERENCED 101 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION This project has unanimous support from all local governing bodies and jurisdictional entities and has been listed and prioritized in many long range and strategic plans. This roadway project has been listed as a priority project in the following documents: SOUTH CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION: • SCDOT Statewide Transportation Improvement Program (STIP) (2017 -2022) The US 278 Corridor Improvements / US 278 Corridor Improvements from Buckingham Plantation Dr to Squire Pope Road, including replacement of eastbound Mackay Creek Bridge, intersection improvements on Pinckney Island and improvements to Jenkins Island is listed in the SCDOT STIP • SCDOT Lowcountry Project/Ten Year Plan (2018) o The 2018 SCDOT Ten -Year Plan for the Lowcountry region lists the US 278 eastbound bridge over Mackay Creek replacement as a priority project.34 o Listed under Lowcountry Projects: “Route: Fording Island Rd (US 278 EB) County: Beaufort Project Name: US 278 EBL over Mackay Creek Construction Year: 2023 Category: Eliminate Interstate/NHS Structurally Deficient Bridges” • 2016 SCDOT Interstate/NHS Bridge Replacement Priority List o The US 278 eastbound lane of the Karl Bowers Bridge over Mackay Creek is #2 ranked structurally deficient bridge in South Carolina. • South Carolina 2040 Statewide Multimodal Transportation Plan (2014) o “US 278 has been identified for priority improvements to pre serve and improve freight movements by truck within South Carolina.”35 LOWCOUNTRY AREA TRANSPORTATION STUDY (LATS) METROPOLITAN PLANNING ORGANIZATION: • Lowcountry LATS Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) (2019) o “US 278 Corridor Improvements from Buckingham Plantation Dr to Squire Pope Rd, including replacement of the EB Mackay Creek Bridge, intersection improvements on Pinkney Island and improvements to Jenkins Island.”36 34 South Carolina Department of Transportation, Lowcountry Project/Ten Year Plan, (2018) 35 South Carolina Department of Transportation, South Carolina 2040 Statewide Multimodal Transportation Plan, (2014) 36 Lowcountry Area Transportation Study (LATS) Metropolitan Planning Organization, Lowcountry LATS Transportation Improvement Program, (2019) 102 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION BEAUFORT COUNTY: • Beaufort County Strategic Plan (2018) o “U.S. Highway 278 Expansion/Improvements is listed as a top priority under the Policy Agenda for the Beaufort County Strategic Plan.”37 o “U.S. Highway 278 Corridor (Gateway): Environmental Assessment for Bridge is listed as a t op priority under the Management Agenda for the Beaufort County Strategic Plan.”37 • Beaufort County Comprehensive Plan (2010) o “Additional Planned Transportation Improvements to Address 2025 Needs: US 278 Bridge Widening from to Hilton Head Island to 6 lanes divided. Estimated cost = $155 Million”38 • Southern Beaufort County Regional Plan (2006) o “The most visible consequence of southern Beaufort County’s fast rate of growth is the demand it places on the region’s roads. The rapid rate of growth has already caused portions of U.S. 278, the region’s primary east- west arterial, to fail with traffic volumes far exceeding capacity between S.C. 46 and the bridges to Hilton Head Island.”39 TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND: • Town Council 2018 Key Priorities Dashboard (2018) o “The Hilton Head Town Council authorized funding in the amount of $45,882 to assist Beaufort County with the engineering services required to prepare this application to the State Infrastructure Bank (SIB). An intergovernmental agreement has been executed as a result. “ 40 • Town of Hilton Head Island Comprehensive Plan (2017) o Goal 6.3-D is “To have a pathway network that provides for recreational opportunities as well as an alternative means of transportation to and on the Island” … Implementation Strategy 6.3-D is to “Coordinate with SCDOT and Beaufort County to provide a pathway link to the mainland.” o “The bridges onto the Island are critical public facilities that provide the only vehicular access for residents and visitors to the Island, as well as the only ground transportation link for emergency evacuations. Protection of these critical facilities should be a priority.”41 • Mayor's Task Force for the Island's Future - Vision for 2025 (2010) o “THREATS - Third Priority Tier: - Limited capacity of bridge to mainland; … It is the intent of the Town Council of Hilton Head Island to revitalize the Island’s buildings and infrastructure by: Improving access to the Island (local, county, state, and federal) as well as internal connectivity and circulation.”42 37 Beaufort County, Beaufort County Strategic Plan, (2018) 38 Beaufort County, Beaufort County Comprehensive Plan, (2010) 39 Beaufort County, Southern Beaufort County Regional Plan, (2006) 40 Town of Hilton Head Island, Town Council 2018 Key Priorities Dashboard, (2018) 41 Town of Hilton Head Island, Town of Hilton Head Island Comprehensive Plan, (2017) 42 Town of Hilton Head Island, Mayor's Task Force for the Island's Future - Vision for 2025, (2010) 103 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION Improving the US 278 bridges to reduce congestion between Moss Creek Drive and Squire Pope Road and replacing the structurally deficient eastbound span on the Karl Bowers Bridge corresponds with priorities, goals, and objectives listed in all local and regional planning documents and has unanimous support from all entities with jurisdictional influence in the area. The project is also listed in the following additional local land use plans and related documents: Beaufort County: • Beaufort County Strategic Plan (2018) • Jenkins Island Access Management System - Preliminary Project Planning Environmental Screening Report (2015) • Beaufort County Comprehensive Plan (2010) • Cursory Above Water & Underwater Investigation of US 278 Eastbound & W estbound Over MacKay Creek and Skull Creek (2010) South Carolina Department of Transportation: • South Carolina Statewide Transportation Improvement Program (2017 -2022) • South Carolina Strategic Corridors Plan (2014) • South Carolina 2040 Statewide Multimodal Transportation Plan (2014) Lowcountry Area Transportation Study (LATS) Metropolitan Planning Organization: • 2040 Lowcountry Area Transportation Study (LATS) Metropolitan Planning Organization's Long-Range Transportation Plan (2015) Town of Bluffton • Town of Bluffton Comprehensive Plan (2014) Town of Hilton Head Island: • Town of Hilton Head Island Comprehensive Plan (2017) Lowcountry Area Transportation Study (LATS) Metropolitan Planning Organization: • 2040 Lowcountry Regional Transit and Coordination Plan (2014) Jasper County, South Carolina • Jasper County Comprehensive Plan (2014) 104 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION APPENDIX D LATS MPO Scoring Criteria 105 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 106 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION APPENDIX E SCDOT Commitment of Funds 107 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 108 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 109 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 110 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 111 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 112 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 113 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 114 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 115 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 116 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 117 Beaufort County - US 278 Corridor Improvement Project STATE INFRASTRUCTURE BANK APPLICATION 118 COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY OFFICE OF THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR ADMINISTRATION BUILDING BEAUFORT COUNTY GOVERNMENT ROBERT SMALLS COMPLEX 100 RIBAUT ROAD POST OFFICE DRAWER 1228 BEAUFORT, SOUTH CAROLINA 29901-1228 TELEPHONE: (843) 255-2023 FAX: (843) 255-9403 www.beaufortcountysc.gov CHERYL H. HARRIS EXECUTIVE ASSISTANT MIKE MOORE COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR March 28, 2025 S outh Carolina Transportation Infrastructure Bank Chairman John White 955 Park Street, Room 120 B Columbia, SC 29201 R E: US 278 Corridor Project – Project Update and Request Following Sales Tax Referendum D ear Chairman White, This letter is in response to your correspondence dated November 7, 2024, requesting an update on Beaufort County’s plans for the US 278 Corridor Project following the failed transportation sales tax referendum last November. We sincerely appreciate the SC TIB Board’s willingness to extend the response deadline to March 31, 2025, allowing time for the County, the Town of Hilton Head Island, and other project stakeholders to formulate a revised and realistic path forward. Since the SCTIB meeting on November 20, 2024, we have worked diligently toward that goal. With the option of a transportation sales tax no longer available to close the project’s funding gap, our initial efforts focused on identifying other potential local funding sources. Unfortunately, the scale of the shortfall far exceeded the County’s ability to bridge the gap using alternative funding. As a result, the conversation shifted from how to fully fund the original project scope to what could be accomplished within the existing $300 million in committed funding. At the recommendation of our legislative delegation, the County, the Town and SCDOT explored a phased approach that would address the most critical needs —specifically, the aging eastbound bridge spans. SCDOT developed six alternative concepts with varying cost estimates. Of these, only one alternative fit within the available fu nding. This alternative includes the construction of a new three-lane eastbound bridge, along with minimal roadwork to tie into the existing roadway network. Due to funding constraints, the bridge would be initially striped for two lanes, with the third lane to be opened in a future phase when additional funding is available. The westbound lanes and bridge structures would remain in use for the time being. Access to Pinckney Island would be maintained via the existing spans across Skull Creek. Although this redefined scope is more limited than originally envisioned, it addresses the most immediate safety concerns while laying the groundwork for future corridor improvements. With 119 strong coordination between Beaufort County and the Town of Hilton Head Island, both jurisdictions have reached consensus on this refined project plan. To formalize this support, the County and Town jointly adopted Resolution 2025/15, which outlines the key components of the revised project. A copy of the resolution is included with this letter for your reference. Rather than requesting additional funds from SCTIB to close the $190 million funding gap, Beaufort County respectfully requests that SCTIB maintain its current $120 million funding commitment to support this revised project scope. We believe this remains a meaningful and impactful infrastructure improvement that will deliver long -term regional and statewide benefits. With broad stakeholder alignment, we are prepared to advance the project immediately upon receiving SCTIB’s confirmation of continued support. With funding in place, the County and SCDOT are ready to finalize the NEPA process, complete engineering and permitting, and move the project to construction bidding by the end of 2027. In addition to maintaining the current SCTIB funding commitment, the County requests SCTIB’s approval of the proposed expenditure order of funds. The total revised project cost is estimated at $272.7 million. With $298.53 million currently available—including SCTIB’s $120 million—this leaves approximately $25.83 million beyond the base project cost. As the project owner, Beaufort County bears responsibility for any project cost overruns. The County proposes to allocate the remaining $25.83 million as follows: • Funding a required water main relocation for the local public service district; • Delivering a small safety improvement project in the Stoney Community, consistent with the original corridor vision; • Establishing a contingency reserve of approximately $15 million to cover unforeseen expenses. Should these contingency funds remain unspent at project completion, they will be directed toward additional road improvements within the US 278 corridor. This approach offers both fiscal responsibility and flexibility to address project-related priorities while managing taxpayer dollars prudently. The SCTIB funds would remain dedicated to construction activities, as originally pledged. The proposed order of expenditure is: County and SCDOT funds would cover engineering, right -of- way acquisition, and utility coordination. The construction costs would be paid in the following order—SCDOT funds, SCTIB funds, then County funds. If construction costs exceed projections, the County’s reserved contingency would be used to cover the overages. If not, the reserves would support enhancements within the corridor. As you can see, significant time and effort have gone into developing this revised plan to responsibly advance this critical infrastructure project. We are grateful for SCTIB’s continued investment and partnership and respectfully request favorable consideration of our two requests: 120 1. Retain SCTIB’s $120 million project commitment; 2. Approve the proposed order of expenditure as outlined above. Thank you for your continued support of Beaufort County and the US 278 Corridor Project. We look forward to working together to deliver meaningful improvements for the region and the State of South Carolina. Kindest regards, Mike Moore County Administrator CC: Charles Cannon – SCTIB Executive Director Justin Powell – SCDOT Secretary of Transportation Marc Orlando – HHI Town Manager Beaufort County Delegation County Council Attachments: 1. County and Town Joint Resolution 2025/15 2. State Delegation Support Letter 3. Rep. Mace Support Letter 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 133 134 135 136 US 278 Corridor Project Update May 19, 2025 137 2 Option 1 Option 6 Plans from SCDOT at 2/12/25 Joint Council Meeting 138 2 Option 1 Plan presented 2/12/25 139 2 Option 1Option 6 Option 6 Plan presented 2/12/25 140 Available Funding County (Sales Tax & Impact Fees) $101.00M SCDOT $ 90.60M HHI (R/W Dedication) $ 3.35M State Infrastructure Bank $120.00M Total = $314.95M Available Cash for Remaining Project = $298.53M (Less $13.07M already expended and $3.35M HHI R/W donations) 4 Presented by SCDOT at 2/12/25 Joint Council Meeting 141 Where Are We Now? 7 142 May 12, 2025 Rejection of County’s Revised Proposal The SIB Board voted to reject the County’ s revised proposal based on the following concerns: • Funding Sequence Conflict: The revised funding plan contradicted the Intergovernmental Agreement (IGA), which required SIB funds to be used last, not first. • Town Contribution Misalignment:Hilton Head Island’s contribution was in the form of land (right-of- way), not cash • Reduced Bridge Scope: The scaled-back design reduced the number of lanes from the original agreement. The SIB did not believe it should still contribute the full $120 million. • Unclear Cost Overrun Strategy: The County did not provide a clear plan to cover potential cost overruns. The SIB suggested pledging County bonding capacity (up to $87 million)—not recommended by staff. • Missing Timeline: A detailed construction and completion schedule was not included. • Expected Local Commitment: The SIB expected increased financial participation from both SCDOT and the County to lessen reliance on SIB funds. • IGA Violation:The agreement was violated as construction did not commence in 2024. 8 SIB Board Decision 143 May 15, 2025: County representatives held a conference call with members of the legislative delegation and the Chair of the State Infrastructure Bank (SIB) to discuss the proposal's rejection and potential next steps. May 15, 2025: County representatives held a conference call with SCDOT Secretary of Transportation to discuss the possible alternatives in response to the SIB discussion. May 19, 2025 A special called meeting of County Council was convened to evaluate and consider possible options for moving forward. 9 Post Rejection Follow-up Actions 144 Staff Identified Options 10 145 Staff Identified Options 11 Option #1 – 5/19/25 Terminate the Intergovernmental Agreement (IGA) with the State Infrastructure Bank (SIB) Collaborate with SCDOT to proceed with the replacement of the Mackay Creek Bridge Construct a 3-lane bridge, as recommended by SCDOT and staff, to accommodate future corridor capacity needs Fund the third lane’s incremental cost using a portion of the $80M from the 2018 Sales Tax Referendum Utilize remaining sales tax funds and consider utilizing $21M in impact fees for additional improvements along the US 278 Corridor, from Moss Creek Rd to Squire Pope Rd. 146 Option 1 – Available Funding County (Sales Tax & Impact Fees) $101.00M SCDOT $ 90.60M HHI (R/W Dedication) $ 3.35M State Infrastructure Bank $120.00M Total = $191.60M Total Project Cost = $101,670,000M ($13,070,000M already expended) 6 147 Staff identified Options 12 Option #2 – 5/19/25 Pursue an amended Intergovernmental Agreement (IGA) with the State Infrastructure Bank (SIB), restructuring the funding sequence to prioritize: 1. County funds 2. SCDOT contributions 3. Remaining SIB funding Beaufort County would assume responsibility for any project cost overruns under the amended agreement. The SIB’s full $120M commitment to the project is critical Maintaining the SIB’s full $120 million commitment is essential to the project’s viability. Without the SIB’s full support, the project cannot proceed unless an alternative, clearly identified funding source is secured. 148

Source: Beaufort County website. First collected Nov 8, 2026.