Natural Resources Committee — Agenda Packet
Beaufort County · Beaufort County · Natural Resources Committee · meeting of Apr 7, 2025 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Beaufort County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Natural Resources Committee
Beaufort County, SC
Council Chambers, Administration Building Beaufort County Government Robert Smalls
Complex 100 Ribaut Road, Beaufort
Monday, April 07, 2025
4:00 PM
AGENDA
COMMITTEE MEMBERS:
YORK GLOVER, CHAIRMAN PAULA BROWN VICE-CHAIR
GERALD DAWSON LAWRENCE MCELYNN
ANNA MARIA TABERNIK ALICE HOWARD, EX OFFICIO
1. CALL TO ORDER: York Glover, Committee Chair
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE: York Glover, Committee Chair
3. STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE WITH FOIA: York Glover, Committee Chair
4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES - March 3, 2025
6. PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD – 15 MINUTES TOTAL
7. ASSISTANT COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR REPORT - Rob Merchant, Planning and Zoning Director
8. PLASTICS ORDINANCE UPDATE - Juliana Smith, Environmental Long Range Planner
9. A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE THE DOCUMENTS NECESSARY
AND TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO CONTRIBUTE TO THE PROCUREMENT BY THE OPEN LAND TRUST FOR A
CONSERVATION EASEMENT ON PROPERTY LOCATED IN UNINCORPORATED BEAUFORT COUNTY KNOWN
AS TROTTER’S LOOP - PIN# R200 004 000 0285 0000, R200 004 000 059A 0000, R200 004 000 065B 0000,
R200 004 000 065A 0000, R200 004 000 065C 0000, R200 004 000 065D 0000, R200 004 000 0065 0000,
R200 004 000 066A 0000, R200 004 000 0066 0000, R200 004 000 0067 0000, R200 004 000 0057 0000,
R200 004 000 057C 0000, R200 004 000 057D 0000, R200 004 000 073A 0000, R200 004 000 073C 0000,
R200 004 000 071A 0000, R200 004 000 0058 0000, R200 003 000 0016 0000 (FISCAL IMPACT: ($310,000
from the Green Space Program Fund Account #4706-10-0000-54400 Land Acquisition) - Mike McShane,
Green Space Committee Chair
10. A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE THE DOCUMENTS NECESSARY
AND TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO CONTRIBUTE TO THE PROCUREMENT BY BEAUFORT COUNTY FOR FEE SIMPLE
REAL PROPERTY LOCATED IN UNINCORPORATED BEAUFORT COUNTY KNOWN AS THE NORTH WIDGEON
TRACTS (PIN# R600 007 000 001A 0000, R600 007 000 0011 0000, R600 007 000 0010 0000, R600 007 000
0009 0000, R600 007 000 0008 0000, R600 007 000 0007 0000, R600 007 000 0006 0000, R600 007 000
1
County Council Agenda – Beaufort County, SC
0005 0000) ( FISCAL IMPACT: $250,000 from the Green Space Program Fund Account #4706 -10-0000-
54400 - Land Acquisition) - Mike McShane, Green Space Committee Chair
11. AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE THE NECESSARY DOCUMENTS
AND PROVIDE FUNDING FOR THE PURCHASE OF TAX MAP SERIAL NUMBERS TMS R600 007 000 001A
0000, R600 007 000 0005 0000, R600 007 000 0006 0000, R600 007 000 0007 0000, R600 007 000 0008
0000, R600 007 000 0009 0000, R600 007 000 0010 0000, AND R600 007 000 0011 0000, ALSO KNOWN
AS NORTH WIDGEON FEE (Fiscal Impact: $2,200,000 plus closing costs from Beaufort County Rural and
Critical Land Preservation Program Bond Referendum Account # 4500-80-0000-54400) - Amanda Flake,
Natural Resources Planner
12. ADJOURNMENT
TO WATCH COMMITTEE OR COUNTY COUNCIL MEETINGS OR FOR A COMPLETE LIST OF AGENDAS AND
BACKUP PACKAGES, PLEASE VISIT:
https://beaufortcountysc.gov/council/council-committee-meetings/index.html
2
Natural Resources Committee
Beaufort County, SC
Council Chambers, Administration Building Beaufort County Government Robert Smalls
Complex 100 Ribaut Road, Beaufort
Monday, March 03, 2025
4:00 PM
MINUTES
COMMITTEE MEMBERS:
YORK GLOVER, CHAIRMAN PAULA BROWN VICE-CHAIR
GERALD DAWSON LAWRENCE MCELYNN
ANNA MARIA TABERNIK ALICE HOWARD, EX OFFICIO
TO WATCH COMMITTEE OR COUNTY COUNCIL MEETINGS OR FOR A COMPLETE LIST OF AGENDAS AND
BACKUP PACKAGES, PLEASE VISIT:
https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/336326
1. CALL TO ORDER
Committee Chairman Glover called the meeting to order at 4:00 pm.
PRESENT
Committee Chair York Glover
Committee Vice-Chair Paula Brown
Council Member Lawrence McElynn
Council Vice-Chair Anna Maria Tabernik
Council Chair Alice Howard
Council Member Joseph Passiment
Council Member Thomas Reitz
Council Member Gerald Dawson
ABSENT
Council Member David Bartholomew
Council Member Mark Lawson
Council Member Logan Cunningham
2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Committee Chairman Glover led the Pledge of Allegiance.
3. STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE WITH FOIA
3
Item 5.
Natural Resources Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
4. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Dawson, Seconded by Council Vice-Chair Tabernik to approve
the agenda.
The Vote: The motion was approved without objection.
5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES - February 3, 2025
Motion: It was moved by Council Vice-Chair Tabernik, Seconded by Committee Vice-Chair Brown, to
Approve the Minutes from February 3, 2025.
The Vote: The motion was approved without objection.
6. PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD
1) Derick Setter
2) Felice Lamarca
3) Scott Daniel
4) Grant McClure
5) Dennis Ross
6) Debra Smith
7) Robert Oetting
8) Reynold Stuart
To view public comment: https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/336326?ts=97
AGENDA ITEMS
7. AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZONING MAP FOR 49.16 ACRES (R600 029 000 0005 0000, R600 029
000 0143 0000, R600 029 000 1194 0000, R600 029 000 0002 0000, R600 029 000 008A 0000, R600 029
000 008C 0000, R600 029 000 0006 0000, R600 029 000 0026 0000) LOCATED O N OKATIE HIGHWAY
FROM T2 RURAL (T2R) TO NEIGHBORHOOD MIXED USE (C3) - Rob Merchant, AICP, Director, Beaufort
County Planning and Zoning
February 3, 2025, Natural Resources Committee Meeting: Motion to postpone to March 3, 2025, without
objection.
This rezoning application went before the Beaufort County Planning Commission at their December 2,
2024, meeting. At that time, the Commission unanimously recommended denying the proposed
amendment to the County Council.
The applicant is seeking to amend the zoning of 49.16 acres. The parcels are currently zoned T2 Rural and
the applicant requests a zoning amendment to (C3) Neighborhood Mixed -Use. The applicant is working
with the Lowcountry Veterans Housing Foundation nonprofit to provide 24 affordable units for Disabled
American War Veterans and First Responders. The applicant intends to enter a Development Agreement
to provide assurances.
Staff recommends denial. While the Comprehensive Plan calls for the development of this area, how it is
being proposed is not compatible with the existing surrounding land and would adversely impact the
properties surrounding these parcels that are not participating in this application as they are to remain
zoned T2 Rural; thus this rezoning would not result in logical and orderly development patterns. If the
County wishes to move forward with the rezoning, staff recommends implementing an area-wide plan
with Bluffton and the school district. However, it is important to note that the applicant proposes
providing 24 units addressing much-needed affordable housing for the community.
4
Item 5.
Natural Resources Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
Motion: It was moved by Committee Vice-Chair Brown, Seconded by Council Chair Howard, to open the
floor for discussion.
Motion: It was moved by Council Vice-Chair Tabernik, Seconded by Council Chair Howard, to Deny the
Request for an Ordinance to Amend the Zoning Map for 49.16 Acres R600 029 000 0005 0000, R600 029
000 0143 0000, R600 029 000 1194 0000, R600 029 000 0002 0000, R600 029 000 008A 0000, R600 029
000 008C 0000, R600 029 000 0006 0000, R600 029 000 0026 0000) Located on Okatie Highway from T2
Rural (T2R) to Neighborhood Mixed Use (C3)
1) Is not consistent with the goals and policies of the comprehensive code and the purposes of the
development code.
2) Is in conflict with provisions of the development code and or our code of ordinances.
3) Does not address a demonstrated community need.
4) Is not required by changed condition.
5) Is not compatible with existing and proposed use of land surrounding this land.
6) Would adversely affect nearby land.
7) Would not result in logical and orderly development patterns.
8) Would result in adverse impact on the natural environment (water, air, noise, stormwater
management, wildlife, vegetation, wetlands, and the natural functioning of the environment).
9) Would not result in development that is adequately served by Public Facilities (streets, potable water,
sewer, stormwater management, solid waste collection and disposal, schools, parks, police, fire,
emergency medical facilities)
The Vote: The motion was approved without objection.
To view the discussion: https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/336326
8. AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZONING MAP FOR 121.43 ACRES (R600 013 000 0008 0000, R600 013
000 0050 0000, R600 013 000 0105 0000, R600 013 000 010 4 0000) LOCATED ON OKATIE HIGHWAY
FROM T2 RURAL (T2R) TO T4 NEIGHBORHOOD CENTER (T4NC) AND T3 NEIGHBORHOOD - OPEN (T3N-
O) USING A VILLAGE PLACE TYPE OVERLAY (PTO) - Rob Merchant, AICP, Director, Beaufort County
Planning and Zoning
February 3, 2025, Natural Resources Committee Meeting: Motion to postpone to March 3, 2025, without
objection.
This rezoning application was before the Beaufort County Planning Commission's January 6, 2025,
meeting. At that time, the Commission unanimously recommended denying the proposed amendment to
the County Council.
The applicant is seeking to amend the zoning of 121.43. The parcels are currently zoned T2 Rural, and the
applicant is requesting a zoning amendment to T4 Neighborhood Center and T3 Neighborhood -Open
using a Village Place Type Overlay. This application contains a land transfer that would provide a 30-acre
tract for a much-needed future public school site. It would also yield 258 maximum residential units and
350,000 sqft of commercial space; however, th is would be decided through a Development Agreement
Process.
The staff does not support this rezoning request. Although the 2040 Comprehensive Plan designates this
area as a Village Place Type and staff has determined that the applicant is willing to provide enhancements
5
Item 5.
Natural Resources Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
and expansions of SC 170, the level of service for the affected intersection and roads will not be up to par
with the County's preferred standards. If the rezoning is to be granted, staff recommends that a
Development Agreement be entered to ensure that correct mitigation measures, density, and service
levels are memorialized.
Public Comment: Kathleen Keating
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Passiment, Seconded by Council Member Dawson to open the
item for discussion.
Motion: It was moved by Council Chair Howard, Seconded by Council Vice -Chair Tabernik, to deny the
Ordinance Amending the Zoning Map for 121.43 Acres (R600 013 000 0008 0000, R600 013 000 0050
0000, R600 013 000 0105 0000, R600 013 000 0104 0000) Located on Okatie Highway from T2 Rural (T2R)
to T4 Neighborhood Center (T4nc) and T3 Neighborhood Open (T3N-O) Using a Village Place Type Overlay
(PTO).
1) Is consistent with the goals and policies of the comprehensive code and the purposes of the
development code.
2) Is in conflict with provisions of the development code and or our code of ordinances.
3) Does address a demonstrated community need.
4) Is not required by changed conditions.
5) Is compatible with existing and proposed use of land surrounding this land
6) Would not adversely affect nearby land.
7) Would result in logical and orderly development patterns.
8) Would not result in adverse impact on the natural environment (water, air, noise, stormwater
management, wildlife, vegetation, wetlands, and the natural functioning of the environment).
9) Would not result in development that is adequately served by public facilities (streets, potable water,
sewer, stormwater management, solid waste collection and disposal, schools, parks, police, fire
emergency medical facilities).
The Vote: The motion was approved 6:1:1 abstain
Yea: Committee Chairman Glover, Council Member Dawson, Council Member McElynn, Council Vice-Chair
Tabernik, Council Chair Howard, Council Member Reitz
Nay: Council Member Passiment
Abstain: Committee Vice-Chair Brown
To view the discussion: https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/336326?ts=4342
9. AN ORDINANCE FOR A TEXT AMENDMENT TO THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CODE (CDC): APPENDIX
B (DAUFUSKIE ISLAND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CODE) DIVISION 3 (PERMITTED USES) TO PERMIT
THE USE OF ANIMAL SERVICES: CLINIC/HOSPITAL IN D2 RURAL (D2R). (FISCAL IMPACT: None.) -Rob
Merchant, AICP, Director, Beaufort County Planning and Zoning
This text amendment application was presented to the Beaufort County Planning Commission at its
February 3, 2025, meeting. The Commission voted 7 -0 to recommend approval of the proposed
amendment to the County Council.
6
Item 5.
Natural Resources Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
The proposed amendment permits Anima l Services: Clinic/Hospital within Daufuskie Island's D2 Rural
zoning district. The current standards do not allow this use; however, more intense uses, such as Animal
Services Kennel, are allowed in the district. Therefore, it is consistent with the purpose of D2R.
Motion: It was moved by Council Member McElynn, Seconded by Council Member Reitz to open the item
up for discussion.
Motion: It was moved by Committee Vice-Chair Brown, Seconded by Council Member McElynn to approve
an Ordinance for a Text Amendment to the Community Development Code (CDC): Appendix B (Daufuskie
Island Community Development Code) Division 3 (Permitted Uses) to Permit the Use of Animal Services:
Clinic/Hospital in D2 Rural (D2R).
1) Is consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies of the comprehensive plan.
2) Is not in conflict with any provision of this development code or the code of ordinances.
3) Is required by changed conditions.
4) Does address a demonstrated community need.
5) Is consistent with the purpose and i ntent of the zones in the development code, or would improve
compatibility among uses and ensure efficient development within the county.
6) Would result in a logical and orderly development pattern.
7) Would not result in adverse impacts on the natural environment including but not limited to water, air,
noise, stormwater management, wildlife, vegetation, wetlands, and the natural functioning of the
environment.
The Vote: The motion was approved without objection.
To view the discussion: https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/336326?ts=7093
10. A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO ACCEPT A NATIONAL COASTAL
RESILIENCE FUND GRANT AWARD FROM THE NATIONAL FIS H AND WILDLIFE FOUNDATION . (FISCAL
IMPACT: Receipt of $169,667.50 to be applied to the Beaufort County Planning & Zoning Department
Grants Revenue Fund. Fiscal Impact: In-kind match (in lieu of County funds) in the amount of $153,054
will be provided by Be aufort County and its partners through services provided. In kind match is
comprised of $120,000 worth in high -resolution aerial imagery and LIDAR from the GIS Department,
$6,890 worth in services rendered compiling GIS data layers and identifying data gap s from the GIS
Department, $7,800 worth in services to continue GIS data layer compilation and gap filling from the
GIS Department, $2,400 worth in services arranging public engagement sessions, including providing a
venue, from the Port Royal Sound Founda tion, and $15,964 worth in services in graphic design from
staff at the SC Sea Grant Consortium).
The National Fish and Wildlife Foundation's National Coastal Resilience Fund (NCRF) Gran Program
supports nature-based solutions that protect coastal communities and enhance fish and wildlife habitat.
The NCRF invests in many project types, including projects that shore up natural infrastructure to mitigate
the impacts of storms and coastal hazards on our communities. Grants are awarded to non -profit 501(c)
organizations, state, territorial, local, and municipal governments, Tribal governments and organizations,
educational institutions, or commercial (for-profit) organizations.
This grant supports a recommendation of the Long -Term Resilience Strategy (adopted May 2024) to
bolster coastal resilience for our community by "identify(ing) and map(ping) where living shorelines can
be effectively used, including recommendations about which types of living shorelines to use in different
environmental conditions" within Beaufort County. In partnership with the SC Sea Grant Consortium,
7
Item 5.
Natural Resources Minutes – Beaufort County, SC
College of Charleston, Port Royal Sound Foundation, and several Beaufort County Departments, the
Planning and Zoning Department applied for and is being awarded grant funding to conduct map ping to
incentivize and develop living shorelines to improve salt marsh habitat conditions and community
resilience.
Motion: It was moved by Council Chair Howard, Seconded by Council Member Dawson, to Approve a
Resolution Authorizing the County Administrator to Accept a National Coastal Resilience Fund Grant
Award from the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation.
The Vote: The motion was approved without objection.
To view the discussion: https://beaufortcountysc.new.swagit.com/videos/336326?ts=7334
11. THE REAPPOINTMENTS OF EUGENE MEYERS, CECILY MCMILLAN, AND ED PAPPAS TO THE PLANNING
COMMISSION FOR A THREE-YEAR TERM WITH THE EXPIRATION DATE OF FEBRUARY 2028
Motion: It was moved by Council Vice-Chair Tabernik, Seconded by Council Chair Howard, to Approve
the Reappointments of Eugene Meyers, Cecily McMillian, and Ed Pappas to the Planning Commission for
a Three-Year Term with the Expiration Date of February 2028.
The Vote: The motion was approved without objection.
12. THE REAPPOINTMENTS OF NATALIE HARVEY AND KATRINA EPPS TO THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION
REVIEW BOARD FOR A FOUR-YEAR TERM WITH THE EXPIRATION DATE OF FEBRUARY 2029
Motion: It was moved by Council Member Brown, Seconded by Council Member Howard, to approve the
Reappointments of Natalie Harvey and Katrina Epps to the Historic Preservation Review Board for a Four-
Year Term with the Expiration Date of February 2029.
The Vote: The motion was approved without objection.
13. Adjournment 6:06 pm
Ratified:
8
Item 5.
CITIZEN COMMENTS
Natural Resources
April 7, 2025
FULL NAME (print only) Agenda Topic
Page 1 of 3
9
Item 6.
Status Update
10
Item 8.
Beaufort County Staff from:
Representatives from:
Keep Beaufort County Beautiful Board
Port Royal Sound Foundation
Coastal Conservation League
Planning & Zoning Solid Waste & Recycling
Communications & Accountability
Stormwater
11
Item 8.
Business Survey Consumer Survey
• Determine what types of waste products are of concern to
our community members
• Assess what types/levels of regulation work for our
community and businesses
12
Item 8.
• Released on Connect Beaufort County and County Social Media
Pages
• Press Release Published and picked up by Media Outlets
• Pushed by Port Royal Sound Foundation on Social Media
• Talks and Communications by Coastal Conservation League
• Outside Foundation shared surveys
• Business Organizations shared with their networks including:
• Flyers posted at all County Libraries
• Postcard Blitz to Businesses
⚬ Beaufort Chamber of Commerce
⚬ HHI - Bluffton Chamber of Commerce
⚬ Beaufort Area Hospitality Asst
⚬ Main Street Beaufort
13
Item 8.
138 Business responses
6,062 Consumer Responses
Regulatory Preferences
January 13 - April 3
14
Item 8.
Finish Analysis
Bring back results
Develop recommendations
15
Item 8.
16
Item 8.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
RECOMMEND COUNCIL APPROVE A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE COUNTY
ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE THE DOCUMENTS NECESSARY AND TO PROVIDE
FUNDS TO CONTRIBUTE TO THE PROCUREMENT BY THE OPEN LAND TRUST FOR A
CONSERVATION EASEMENT ON PROPERTY LOCATED IN UNINCORPORATED
BEAUFORT COUNTY KNOWN AS TROTTER’S LOOP (PIN# R200 004 000 0285 0000, R200
004 000 059A 0000, R200 004 000 065B 0000, R200 004 000 065A 0000, R200 004 000 065C 0000,
R200 004 000 065D 0000, R200 004 000 0065 0000, R200 004 000 066A 0000, R200 004 000 0066
0000, R200 004 000 0067 0000, R200 004 000 0057 0000, R200 004 000 057C 0000, R200 004 000
057D 0000, R200 004 000 073A 0000, R200 004 000 073C 0000, R200 004 000 071A 0000, R200 004
000 0058 0000, R200 003 000 0016 0000), NOT TO EXCEED THE REQUESTED AMOUNT
($310,000)
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
Natural Resources Committee, Monday, April 7, 2025
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
Mike McShane, Chairman of the Green Space Advisory Committee (15 minutes)
ITEM BACKGROUND:
The Open Land Trust submitted a Green Space Program Conservation Easement application on behalf of the
landowners for consideration. On June 10, 2024, the Community Services and Land Use Committee approved
due diligence and negotiations of the application. On March 7, 2025, the Green Space Advisory Committee
(GSAC) met, reviewed existing due diligence provided by the applicant, and voted to recommend approval for
the contribution of funds not to exceed the requested amount of $310,000. The (GSAC) vote was unanimous.
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
Trotter’s Loop is a privately owned 55 +/- acre property located in Unincorporated Beaufort County on Pleasant
Point Drive and Trotters Loop. The Open Land Trust (Applicant) is working with the property owners to place a
conservation easement over the entire property, which is currently comprised of eighteen (18) individual parcels
that would be consolidated into three (3) parcels. The conservation easement would allow for a maximum of five
(5) total parcels. The appraised value for the conservation easement is approximately $775,000. The application
requests 40% funding ($310,000) from the Green Space Program and the landowner is donating 60% of the
easement value ($465,000). The conservation easement will be held and managed by the Open Land Trust and
will protect this property in perpetuity. A preservation outcome for this property would achieve several goals of
the Green Space Program, including: preservation of intact natural habitats for plants and animals; protection of
water quality; and preservation of scenic corridors along rural county and state roadways.
FISCAL IMPACT:
($310,000) from the Green Space Program Fund Account #4706-10-0000-54400 (Land Acquisition)
RECOMMENDATION TO COUNCIL:
Green Space Advisory Committee (GSAC) recommends approval to fund the application, not to exceed the
requested amount of ($310,000)
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
Motion to approve, modify, or deny a Resolution to expend funds in the amount of ($310,000) from the Green
Space Program Fund to contribute to the procurement of a conservation easement for Trotter’s Loop located in
Unincorporated Beaufort County.
17
Item 9.
RESOLUTION 2025/_____
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE
THE DOCUMENTS NECESSARY AND TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO CONTRIBUTE TO
THE PROCUREMENT BY THE OPEN LAND TRUST FOR A CONSERVATION
EASEMENT ON PROPERTY LOCATED IN UNINCORPORATED BEAUFORT
COUNTY KNOWN AS TROTTER’S LOOP (PIN# R200 004 000 0285 0000, R200 004 000
059A 0000, R200 004 000 065B 0000, R200 004 000 065A 0000, R200 004 000 065C 0000,
R200 004 000 065D 0000, R200 004 000 0065 0000, R200 004 000 066A 0000, R200 004 000
0066 0000, R200 004 000 0067 0000, R200 004 000 0057 0000, R200 004 000 057C 0000,
R200 004 000 057D 0000, R200 004 000 073A 0000, R200 004 000 073C 0000, R200 004 000
071A 0000, R200 004 000 0058 0000, R200 003 000 0016 0000), NOT TO EXCEED THE
REQUESTED AMOUNT ($310,000)
WHEREAS, the Trotter’s Loop Tracts (the “Property”) consisting of 55 +/- acres is
located in Unincorporated Beaufort County on Lady’s Island near Broomfield Creek, and exists in
a relatively natural condition; and
WHEREAS, the Property possesses freshwater wetlands, intact tree canopy, and fields,
providing considerable naturally occurring water quality and other ecosystem services associated
with these habitats; and
WHEREAS, the Property remains in a relatively rural condition and preserves scenic
corridors along rural county and state roadways; and
WHEREAS, the Property is located in the vicinity of the Marine Corps Air Sation (MCAS)
Beaufort, and incompatible development would produce undesirable impacts to the mission of the
installation; and
WHEREAS, the Beaufort County Council recognizes the need to preserve land that
provides scenic, natural, environmental, recreational, rural, and open space character which is
deemed essential to the County’s economic viability, environmental resilience, and overall quality
of life; and
WHEREAS, the Beaufort County staff received a Conservation Easement Application
from the Open Land Trust requesting 40% of the appraised conservation easement value in
funding from the Green Space Program to partially fund a conservation easement which was
presented to the Green Space Advisory Committee at their June 3, 2024 meeting, where the
Green Space Advisory Committee voted unanimously to recommend due diligence and
negotiations to the Community Services and Land Use Committee; and
WHEREAS, the Beaufort County Community Services and Land Use Committee
authorized staff to engage in due diligence and negotiations during their June 10, 2024 meeting;
and
18
Item 9.
WHEREAS, the Beaufort County staff began conducting due diligence and negotiations
to further evaluate the property and application against the Beaufort County Green Space
Program Criteria to calculate the procurement benefits and overall value; and
WHEREAS, the Beaufort County staff presented the existing due diligence documents
provided by the applicant and the staff project evaluation and recommendation to the Green
Space Advisory Committee during their March 7, 2025 meeting; and
WHEREAS, the Green Space Advisory Committee (GSAC) met, reviewed the staff
evaluation and existing due diligence, and voted unanimously to recommend approval for the
contribution of funds not to exceed the requested amount $310,000; and
WHEREAS, the Beaufort County Council finds that it is in the best interest of the citizens
and residents of Beaufort County for the County Administrator to execute the documents necessary
to contribute to funding for a conservation easement for the purposes of purchasing development
rights and providing public benefits through preserved open spaces and natural habitats,
maintained ecosystem services, and preserves scenic corridors along rural roadways in perpetuity.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that Beaufort County Council, duly assembled, does
hereby authorize a Resolution authorizing the County Administrator to execute the documents
necessary and to provide funds from the Green Space Program Fund to contribute to the
procurement by the applicant, the Open Land Trust, for a conservation easement on a property
located in Unincorporated Beaufort County known as the Trotter’s Loop Tracts (PIN#S R200 004
000 0285 0000, R200 004 000 059A 0000, R200 004 000 065B 0000, R200 004 000 065A 0000,
R200 004 000 065C 0000, R200 004 000 065D 0000, R200 004 000 0065 0000, R200 004 000
066A 0000, R200 004 000 0066 0000, R200 004 000 0067 0000, R200 004 000 0057 0000, R200
004 000 057C 0000, R200 004 000 057D 0000, R200 004 000 073A 0000, R200 004 000 073C
0000, R200 004 000 071A 0000, R200 004 000 0058 0000, R200 003 000 0016 0000), not to
exceed the requested amount ($310,000).
Adopted this ____ day of ____________, 2025.
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
BY:
Alice Howard, Chairman
ATTEST:
Sarah W. Brock, Clerk to Council
19
Item 9.
TroTTer’s Loop TracTs – conservaTion easemenT
appLicanT – open Land TrusT
55 +/- Acres
20
Item 9.
TroTTer’s Loop TracTs – conservaTion easemenT
MAP KEY
OLT Conservation Easement
RCL Conservation Easement
Preserved Lands non RCL
County Passive Parks
Trotter’s Loop Tracts
21
Item 9.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
RECOMMEND COUNCIL APPROVE A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE COUNTY
ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE THE DOCUMENTS NECESSARY AND TO PROVIDE
FUNDS TO CONTRIBUTE TO THE PROCUREMENT BY BEAUFORT COUNTY FOR FEE
SIMPLE REAL PROPERTY LOCATED IN UNINCORPORATED BEAUFORT COUNTY
KNOWN AS THE NORTH WIDGEON TRACTS (PIN# R600 007 000 001A 0000, R600 007 000
0011 0000, R600 007 000 0010 0000, R600 007 000 0009 0000, R600 007 000 0008 0000, R600 007
000 0007 0000, R600 007 000 0006 0000, R600 007 000 0005 0000), NOT TO EXCEED THE
REQUESTED AMOUNT ($250,000)
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
Natural Resources Committee, Monday, April 7, 2025
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
Mike McShane, Chairman of the Green Space Advisory Committee (10 minutes)
ITEM BACKGROUND:
This is a Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Program project which was also submitted to the
Green Space Program to support their work and purchase of the properties. See Rural and Critical
Lands Preservation Program AIS for project background.
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
The North Widgeon Tracts comprise of several parcels totaling 9.55 +/- acres located in
Unincorporated Beaufort County along Highway 170, the Broad River, and are adjacent to a Beaufort
County owned and operated passive park, Widgeon Point. The Open Land Trust (Applicant) applied
to the Green Space Program to partner with the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Program’s final
project (see project narrative for Rural and Critical Lands AIS). A preservation outcome for this
property would achieve many goals of the Green Space Program, including: preservation of an intact
natural habitat for plants and animals; protection of water quality; preservation of an established
maritime forest; improved environmental resilience; protection of viewsheds along Highway 170, the
Port Royal Sound, the Broad River, Wigeon Point; and expansion of an abutting Beaufort County
owned and operated passive park, offering public access.
FISCAL IMPACT:
($250,000) from the Green Space Program Fund Account #4706-10-0000-54400 (Land Acquisition)
RECOMMENDATION TO COUNCIL:
Green Space Advisory Committee (GSAC) recommends approval to fund the application, not to
exceed the requested amount ($250,000).
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
Motion to approve, modify, or deny a Resolution to expend funds in the amount of ($250,000) from
the Green Space Program Fund to contribute to the procurement of a fee simple acquisition for the
North Widgeon Tracts located in Unincorporated Beaufort County.
22
Item 10.
RESOLUTION 2025/_____
A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE
THE DOCUMENTS NECESSARY AND TO PROVIDE FUNDS TO CONTRIBUTE TO
THE PROCUREMENT BY BEAUFORT COUNTY FOR FEE SIMPLE REAL
PROPERTY LOCATED IN UNINCORPORATED BEAUFORT COUNTY KNOWN AS
THE NORTH WIDGEON TRACTS (PIN# R600 007 000 001A 0000, R600 007 000 0011
0000, R600 007 000 0010 0000, R600 007 000 0009 0000, R600 007 000 0008 0000, R600 007
000 0007 0000, R600 007 000 0006 0000, R600 007 000 0005 0000), NOT TO EXCEED THE
REQUESTED AMOUNT ($250,000)
WHEREAS, the North Widgeon Tracts (the “Property”) consisting of 9.55 +/- acres is
located in Unincorporated Beaufort County along Highway 170, the banks of the Port Royal Sound
and Broad River, and are undeveloped in nature; and
WHEREAS, the Property is surrounded by saltwater wetlands, and possesses an intact
maritime forest comprised of live oaks, loblolly pines, and palmettos, providing considerable
naturally occurring water quality and other ecosystem services associated with these habitats; and
WHEREAS, the waterfront edges of the Property supports improved resilience of the
immediate area by providing space for marsh migration and capacity to absorb sea level rise; and
WHEREAS, the Property is part of the viewshed from Highway 170, the Port Royal
Sound, the Broad River, and Wigeon Point Passive Park, preserving the scenic corridor; and
WHEREAS, the Property abuts an existing Beaufort County owned and operated Passive
Park, Widgeon Point, providing opportunity to expand an existing park for public access; and
WHEREAS, the Beaufort County Council recognizes the need to preserve land that
provides scenic, natural, environmental, recreational, rural, and open space character which is
deemed essential to the County’s economic viability, environmental resilience, and overall quality
of life; and
WHEREAS, prior to an application being submitted to the Green Space Program, the
Property was reviewed by the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Review Board where the
Board recommended approval for due diligence; and
WHEREAS, following the recommendation from the Rural and Critical Lands
Preservation Review Board, the Community Services and Land Use Committee recommended
approval of due diligence at their October 14, 2024 meeting; and
WHEREAS, the Green Space Program staff received a Fee Simple Application from the
Open Land Trust to assist the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Program fee simple
procurement of the Property which was presented to the Green Space Advisory Committee
23
Item 10.
(GSAC) at their December 6, 2024 meeting, where the GSAC voted to recommend due diligence
and negotiations to the Natural Resources Committee; and
WHEREAS, the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Review Board reviewed their due
diligence and voted to recommend approval for the expenditure of Rural and Critical Lands
Preservation Program funds during their January 13, 2025 meeting; and
WHEREAS, the Beaufort County Natural Resources Committee authorized Green Space
Program staff to engage in due diligence and negotiations during their January 13, 2025 meeting;
and
WHEREAS, the Green Space Advisory Committee met, discussed the property and was
presented with the Rural and Critical Lands Preservation Program’s interest and partnerships for
acquiring the Property, along with pertinent timelines moving forward during their March 7,
2025 meeting, where the (GSAC) unanimously voted to recommend approval for the expenditure
of Green Space Program funds to contribute to the fee simple procurement of the Property, not to
exceed the requested amount ($250,000); and
WHEREAS, Beaufort County Council finds that it is in the best interest of the citizens and
residents of Beaufort County for the County Administrator to execute the necessary documents to
contribute to funding for the procurement of a government owned fee simple acquisition of real
property for the purposes of purchasing development rights and providing public benefits through
preserved open spaces and natural habitats that offer public access, maintained ecosystem services,
improved resilience, and preservation of scenic corridors in perpetuity.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that Beaufort County Council, duly assembled, does
hereby authorize a Resolution authorizing the County Administrator to execute the documents
necessary and to provide funds from the Green Space Program Fund to contribute to the
procurement by Beaufort County for fee simple real property located in Unincorporated Beaufort
County known as the North Widgeon Tracts (PIN# R600 007 000 001A 0000, R600 007 000 0011
0000, R600 007 000 0010 0000, R600 007 000 0009 0000, R600 007 000 0008 0000, R600 007
000 0007 0000, R600 007 000 0006 0000, R600 007 000 0005 0000), not to exceed the requested
amount ($250,000).
Adopted this ____ day of ____________, 2025.
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
BY:
Alice Howard, Chairman
ATTEST:
Sarah W. Brock, Clerk to Council
24
Item 10.
North WidgeoN tracts – Fee simple
applicaNt – opeN laNd trust
9.55 +/- Acres
MAP KEY
North W idgeon Tracts
25
Item 10.
No rth Wi dgeo N t racts – F ee simple
MAP KEY
North Widgeon Tracts
26
Item 10.
BEAUFORT COUNTY COUNCIL
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ITEM TITLE:
ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE THE NECESSARY DOCUMENTS AND
PROVIDE FUNDING FOR THE PURCHASEOF TAX MAP SERIAL NUMBERS TMS R600 007 000 001A 0000, R600
007 000 0005 0000, R600 007 000 0006 0000, R600 007 000 0007 0000, R600 007 000 0008 0000, R600 007
000 0009 0000, R600 007 000 0010 0000, AND R600 007 000 0011 0000, ALSO KNOWN AS NORTH WIDGEON
FEE
MEETING NAME AND DATE:
Natural Resources Committee; April 7, 2025
PRESENTER INFORMATION:
Amanda Flake, Natural Resources Planner
ITEM BACKGROUND:
Rural and Critical Land Preservation Board recommended to pursue due diligence on 10/7/24 and Community
Service and Land Use Committee voted to approve due diligence on 10/14/24. Partner funds were applied for
and sought from the Greenspace Program and SC Conservation Bank. With staff recommendation, RCLP
Board recommended to purchase, utilizing $2,200,000 of RCLP Bond funds, on January 13, 2025.
PROJECT / ITEM NARRATIVE:
North Widgeon Fee is the highest priority of the County Land Preservation Department due to its physical and
visual proximity to Widgeon Point Preserve. The property consists of +/- 9.55 high acres along the banks of
the Broad River and has access from Highway 170 at the base of the Broad River bridge. The landowners
applied to the Rural and Critical Lands Program in September 2024 and the RCLP Board unanimously
supported the project: the total purchase price of $2,700,000 represents a bargain sale by the landowners -
$2,200,000 is recommended from the RCLP Bond funds (Fund 4500), $250,000 was sought and recommended
by the Greenspace Advisory Board (a concurrent resolution references these funds) and $250,000 was
applied for and approved by the SC Conservation Bank on March 19, 2025 (email approval included). This
funding partnership mirrors that required to acquire Widgeon Point Preserve nearby and will utilize the
majority of the remaining funds from the Rural and Critical Lands Program to expand this important public
access. Staff enthusiastically supports this recommendation.
FISCAL IMPACT:
$2,200,000 plus closing costs from Beaufort County Rural and Critical Land Preservation Program Bond
Referendum (Account # 4500-80-0000-54400)
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS TO COUNCIL:
Staff recommends approval
OPTIONS FOR COUNCIL MOTION:
Motion to approve, modify or reject purchase of North Widgeon Fee
If approved, move to 1st reading at County Council on April 28, 2025.
27
Item 11.
1
ORDINANCE 2025/_____
ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO EXECUTE THE
NECESSARY DOCUMENTS AND PROVIDE FUNDING FOR THE PURCHASE OF TAX MAP
SERIAL NUMBERS TMS R600 007 000 001A 0000, R600 007 000 0005 0000, R600 007 000 0006
0000, R600 007 000 0007 0000, R600 007 000 0008 0000, R600 007 000 0009 0000, R600 007 000
0010 0000, AND R600 007 000 0011 0000, ALSO KNOWN AS NORTH WIDGEON FEE
WHEREAS, Seller wishes to sell and Purchaser wishes to purchase the fee simple interest on
property currently identified as R600 007 000 001A 0000, R600 007 000 0005 0000, R600 007 000 0006
0000, R600 007 000 0007 0000, R600 007 000 0008 0000, R600 007 000 0009 0000, R600 007 000 0010
0000, and R600 007 000 0011 0000 of +/- 9.55 acres, also known as North Widgeon Fee, collectively
hereinafter “North Widgeon Fee”; and
WHEREAS, the purchase of fee simple interest of North Widgeon Fee has been demonstrated to
meet the Critical Lands Criteria of the Rural and Critical Lands Program (“RCLP”); and
WHEREAS, the Property is within the unincorporated Beaufort County and is located between
Widgeon Point Preserve and the banks of the Broad River; and
WHEREAS, the proposal to purchase North Widgeon Fee is for a fee simple acquisition with a
bargain sale purchase price of $2,700,000.00, plus closing costs; and
WHEREAS, the proposed purchase of North Widgeon Fee was presented to the Rural and Critical
Land Preservation Board (RCL PB) at the January 13, 2025 meeting and the RCL PB unanimously
recommended approval of the purchase and authorized $2,200,000 toward the purchase price; and
WHEREAS, The Beaufort County Greenspace Advisory board recommended $250,000 toward
the purchase price at the March 7, 2025 meeting; and
WHEREAS, the South Carolina Conservation Bank approved $250,000 toward the purchase price
at their March 19, 2025 meeting; and
WHEREAS, the proposed purchase of North Widgeon Fee was presented to the Natural Resources
Committee on April 7, 2025 meeting at which time it was referred to County Council; and
WHEREAS, County Council finds that it is in the best interest of the citizens and residents of
Beaufort County for the County Administrator to execute the necessary doc uments for the fee simple
acquisition and purchase of North Widgeon Fee.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that Beaufort County Council, duly assembled, does
hereby authorize the County Administrator to execute the necessary documents and provide funding of
$2,200,000, plus closing costs, from the Rural and Critical Land Preservation Program for the purchase of
real properties identified as TMS R600 007 000 001A 0000, R600 007 000 0005 0000, R600 007 000 0006
0000, R600 007 000 0007 0000, R600 007 000 0008 0000, R600 007 000 0009 0000, R600 007 000 0010
0000, and R600 007 000 0011 0000, also known as North Widgeon Fee.
Adopted this ____ day of ______________, 2025.
28
Item 11.
2
COUNTY COUNCIL OF BEAUFORT COUNTY
BY:
Alice Howard, Chairwoman
ATTEST:
Sarah W. Brock, Clerk to Council
29
Item 11.
30
Item 11.
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) AGREEMENT TO SELL AND
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT ) PURCHASE REAL PROPERTY
THIS AGREEMENT TO SELL AND PURCHASE REAL PROPERTY (“Agreement”) is made and entered
into this ________ day of ____________, 2025, by and between Parker Family LP, a South Carolina
limited partnership; Daniel E. Henderson as Trustee of the Daniel E. Henderson Revocable Trust U/A/D
November 6, 2012; Susan P . Henderson as Trustee of the Susan P . Henderson Revocable Trust U/A/D
_________; Kathleen Elizabeth Sweeny, individually; John R. Peters, III, Trustee of the John R. Peters, III
share of Trust B under the Revocable Trust Agreement of Ellen B. Peters dated July 11, 2011, as amended
and restated on December 27, 2012; Kathleen E. Sweeny, Trustee of the Kathleen E. Sweeny share of
Trust B under the Revocable Trust Agreement of Ellen B. Peters dated July 11, 2011, as amended and
restated on December 27, 2012; and John R. Peters, III, individually ("Seller") and BEAUFORT COUNTY, a
political subdivision of the State of South Carolina ("Purchaser"); hereinafter collectively referred to as
the “Parties”.
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, the Parties hereto had preliminary discussions with regards to the sale and purchase
of certain real property located near Beaufort in Beaufort County, South Carolina, and it is their desire to
document their understandings with respect to said sale and purchase.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the premises and of the mutual promises and covenants
herein contained the Parties agree as follows:
1. Real Property. The Seller agrees to sell and the Purchaser agrees to purchase certain real
property containing approximately nine and thirty-three hundredths (9.33) acres with TMS# R600 007
000 001A 0000, R600 007 000 0011 0000, R600 007 000 0010 0000, R600 007 000 0009 0000, R600 007
000 0008 0000, R600 007 000 0007 0000, R600 007 000 0006 0000, R600 007 000 0005 0000 commonly
known as “North Widgeon Fee” and as further described in Exhibit A attached hereto and incorporated
herein by reference; hereinafter collectively referred to as the “Property".
2. Purchase Price. The purchase price of the Property shall be TWO MILLION SEVEN HUNDRED
THOUSAND ($2,700,000.00) Dollars (“Purchase Price”).
3. Conveyance of Title. The Seller shall convey fee simple title of the Property to the County.
Seller agrees to convey the Property by marketable title, free and clear of all liens and encumbrances
whatsoever and those agreed upon to be assumed by Purchaser (the “Permitted Exceptions”).
Purchaser shall have the responsibility to examine the title to the Property. Purchaser shall notify Seller
in writing of any title defects during the Inspection Period. Seller shall have twenty (20) days from the
date of such notification in which to cure such defects at its own expense or to decline to cure such
defects noted by Purchaser . Seller shall notify Purchaser in writing of Seller’s election to cure or decline
to cure such defects noted by Purchaser within ten (10) days of receipt of Purchaser’s notice. Purchaser
shall then have five (5) days from the date of Seller’s notice within which to notify Seller of Purchaser’s
termination of this Agreement for lack of sufficient cure to such defects. Absent Seller’s receipt of notice
from Purchaser within said five (5) day period, all of Purchaser’s outstanding defects shall be deemed
31
Item 11.
Permitted Exceptions, and the Closing shall be held on or before the date provided for Closing in this
Agreement.
4. Survey. Purchaser engaged Gasque Inc land surveyors, licensed in South Carolina, to prepare an
update to boundary survey of the Property (the "Survey"), which shall be certified to Seller, Purchaser,
and the title insurers.
5. Inspection. Purchaser hereby acknowledges and agrees that Purchaser has or will thoroughly
inspect and examine the Property prior to closing. Purchaser is responsible for obtaining inspection
reports from qualified professionals to assess the Property.
a) Inspection Period. Purchaser may cancel this Agreement at any time prior to April 28
2025 (the “Inspection Period”). Purchaser shall notify Seller in writing of its desire to cancel this
Agreement. This Agreement shall be cancelled immediately upon Seller’s receipt of written
cancellation notice, and neither party shall have any further obligations hereunder .
b) Right of Access for Inspection. Purchaser and/or its agents shall have the privilege of
going upon the Property at any time during the existence of this Agreement to inspect, examine,
survey and to make test borings, soil boring tests and any other tests which the Purchaser may
deem necessary, at Purchaser’s expense. Purchaser assumes all responsibility for the acts of
itself, its agents or representatives in exercising its rights under Agreement.
6. Closing. The Closing occurs when Purchaser transfers the Purchase Price to Seller and Seller
conveys title of the Property to Purchaser.
a) Closing. The Closing shall occur on or before May 31, 2025 (“Closing Date”) at the office
of Purchaser’s attorney, or on such other date, place and/or time as the Parties may mutually
agree.
b) Closing Costs and Prorations. All current real estate taxes, assessments, dues and other
proratable items, if any, shall be apportioned pro rata on a per diem basis as of the Closing Date.
All taxes for any years prior to 2025 shall be the responsibility of the Seller. Seller shall be
responsible for paying the South Carolina recording fee (formerly referred to as documentary
stamps), transfer tax to be affixed to the deed and related transfer documents, if any such fee or
tax be applicable to this transaction. Purchaser shall be responsible for any other fees for
recording the deed and for any of its financing costs. Each party shall be responsible for its own
legal fees.
7. Brokerage Fees. Seller represents that the Property is not subject to a listing contract with any
real estate broker. The Parties agree to hold each other harmless from any claim of commission by
others arising by, through or on account of the acts of the Parties.
8. Seller's Delivery of Documentation. Seller shall deliver to Purchaser at or before the Closing
Date (at such times as Purchaser may reasonably request) a Limited Warranty Deed, the delivery and
accuracy of which shall be a condition to Purchaser's obligation to consummate the purchase and sale
herein contemplated.
32
Item 11.
9. Conditions Precedent. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary stated herein, the obligations
of Purchaser to purchase the property are expressly made subject to the Seller’s representation that as
of the Closing Date the warranties and representations of Seller shall be true and correct. The foregoing
conditions are for the sole benefit of and may be waived by Purchaser by written notice to Seller.
10. Default. If Purchaser or Seller fails to perform any provision of this Agreement, the other party
may elect to seek any remedy provided in equity (but not at law for money damages) as a result of such
failure to perform, including an action for specific performance of Seller’s obligations under this
Agreement, or terminate this Agreement with a written notice. If terminated, both Parties agree to
cooperatively pursue their obligations set forth herein in good faith.
11. Notices. Any notice, communication, request, approval or consent which may be given or is
required to be given under the terms of this Agreement shall be in writing and shall be transmitted (1)
via mail, hand delivery or express overnight delivery service to the Seller or the Purchaser, (2) via
facsimile with the original to follow via hand delivery or overnight delivery service, or (3) via e-mail,
provided that the sending party can show proof of delivery, as the case may be, at the
addresses/numbers set forth below:
TO PURCHASER: Beaufort County
Attn: Amanda Flake
Post Office Drawer 1228
Beaufort, SC 29901-1228
E-mail: aflake@bcgov.net
(843) 255-2140
Copy to: Beaufort County
Post Office Box 1228
Beaufort, SC 29901
Attn: Dylan Kidd, Deputy County Attorney
Email:dkidd@bcgov.net
(843) 255-2025
Thomas A. Bendle, Jr.
Howell, Gibson and Hughes PA
Post Office Box 40
Beaufort, SC 29901
(843) 522-2400
Email: tbendle@hghpa.com
TO SELLER: Parker Family, LP
Attn: John E. Parker, Esquire
101 Mulberry Street East
Hampton SC 29924
Daniel E. Henderson, Esquire
Susan P . Henderson
33
Item 11.
690 N. Green Street
Ridgeland SC 29936
John R. Peters, III
103 Edisto Drive
Hampton, SC 29924
Kathleen Elizabeth Sweeny
414 West Park Avenue
Long Beach, NY 11561
12. Assignment by Purchaser. Purchaser shall have the right to assign this Agreement to a related
entity by giving Seller notice of such assignment (which shall include the name and address of the
Assignee) together with an executed counterpart of the assignment wherein such Assignee assumes the
performance of all of the terms and conditions of this Agreement on the part of the Purchaser to be
performed.
13. Condemnation. In the event that at the time of Closing all or any part of the Property is
acquired, or is about to be acquired, by authority of any governmental agency in the exercise of its
power of eminent domain or by private purchase in lieu thereof (or in the event that at such time there
is any threat or imminence of any such acquisition by any such governmental agency), Purchaser shall
have the right, at its option, to terminate this Agreement, or to purchase only so much of the Property
not condemned or under threat of condemnation, in which event the purchase price and terms shall be
adjusted accordingly.
14. No Joint Venture. It is understood and agreed between the Parties hereto that this is an
agreement for the sale of real estate and is in no way to be considered a joint venture between the
Parties. It is further understood and agreed that Purchaser is assuming no liabilities, whether fixed or
contingent, of Seller, and that this is a purchase of real estate assets.
15. Entire Agreement. This Agreement incorporates any and all prior agreements, covenants, and
understandings between the Parties hereto concerning the subject matter hereof, and all such
covenants, agreements and understandings have been merged into this agreement. No prior agreement
or understandings, verbal or otherwise, of the Parties or their agent shall be valid or enforceable unless
embodied in this Agreement.
16. Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in counterparts. Each of the counterparts shall
be deemed an original instrument, but all of the counterparts shall constitute one and the same
instrument.
17. Severability. If any portion of this Agreement shall be held to be invalid or unenforceable for any
reason, the remaining provisions shall continue to be valid and enforceable. If a court finds that any
provision of this Agreement is invalid or unenforceable, then such provision shall be deemed to be
written, construed, and enforced as so limited.
18. Amendment. This Agreement cannot be amended orally or by a single party. No amendment or
change to this Agreement shall be valid unless in writing and signed by both Parties to this Agreement.
34
Item 11.
19. Authority. Each individual and entity executing this Agreement hereby represents and warrants
that he, she or its has the capacity set forth on the signature pages hereof with full power and authority
to bind the party on whose behalf he, she or it is executing this Agreement to terms hereof.
20. Governing Law. The laws of the State of South Carolina shall govern the interpretation, validity,
performance and enforcement of this Agreement, and, of any personal guarantees given in connection
with this Agreement.
21. Time is of the Essence. The time and dates specified in this Agreement shall be enforced;
however, the time and dates may be modified for reasonable cause when both Parties agree in writing to
a reasonable extension.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF , and in acknowledgement that the Parties hereto have read and understood each
and every provision hereof, the Parties have caused this Agreement to be executed on the date first
written above.
WITNESSES: PURCHASER:
_________________________ ____________________________________
Michael Moore
_________________________ Beaufort County Administrator
WITNESSES: SELLER:
Parker Family, LP
By: Parker Family GP , LLC
Its: General Partner
_________________________ ________________________________
By: John E. Parker
Its: Manager
_________________________ ________________________________
Daniel E. Henderson as Trustee of
the Daniel E. Henderson Revocable
Trust U/A/D November 6, 2012
_________________________ ________________________________
Susan P . Henderson as Trustee of
the Susan P . Henderson Revocable
Trust U/A/D ____________________
__________________________ ________________________________
Kathleen Elizabeth Sweeny, individually
35
Item 11.
__________________________ ________________________________
Kathleen E. Sweeny, Trustee of the
Kathleen E. Sweeny share of Trust B
under the Revocable Trust Agreement
of Ellen B. Peters dated July 11, 2011,
as amended and restated on
December 27, 2012
__________________________ ________________________________
John Robert Peters, III, individually
__________________________ ________________________________
John R. Peters, III, Trustee of the
John R. Peters, III share of Trust B
under the Revocable Trust Agreement
of Ellen B. Peters dated July 11, 2011,
as amended and restated on
December 27, 2012
36
Item 11.
Exhibit A
PROPERTY DESCRIPTION
All those certain pieces, parcels or lots of land shown and depicted as lots 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 ,7 and Existing
Access Easement, containing 9.51 acres in the aggregate, as shown and delineated on that certain plat
prepared by David E. Gasque RLS dated December 21, 1998, revised February 1, 2002, and recorded in
the office of the Register of Deeds for Beaufort County in Plat Book 94 at page 174. This plat is
incorporated into and made a part of this description by reference. For further description as to courses,
distances, metes and bounds, reference is made to the plat.
Together, by quit-claim and without warranty, all right title and interest, if any, in and to the following
described property:
ALL that certain piece, parcel or tract of land shown as a portion of a twenty-two (22) acre lake, highland
and marsh, commencing at the Southwestern tip of the above-described the (10) acres; thence running
South-Southwesterly a distance of200' feet along the right-of-way of South Carolina Highway 170; thence
running through the 22 acre lake for an approximate distance of 1,600' feet in an East-Southeasterly
direction; thence turning to an Easterly direction for an approximate distance of 500' feet to the waters
of the Broad River; thence running along the said waters of the Broad River for approximately 1,800'
feet; thence turning in a North- Northwesterly direction for approximately 400' feet again to the right-of-
way of South Carolina Highway 170; thence running in a South-Southwesterly direction for an
approximate distance of 1,100' feet to where the same reaches the Northwestern tip of the above-
described 10 acres. This description is meant to represent a 200' foot strip of the 22 acre lake, and all
highland and marsh within the described boundaries on the Northeast and South of the above described
10 acres which are being conveyed to the fullest extent of ownership.
AND
All their right, title and interest, if any to any highland and marshland between the northern boundary
of the above property and Broad River; this specifically includes approximately 0.8 acres of highland
along the northern boundary which is outside the critical line.
Beaufort County Tax Map:
R600 007 000 001A 0000
R600 007 000 0011 0000
R600 007 000 0010 0000
R600 007 000 0009 0000
R600 007 000 0008 0000
R600 007 000 0007 0000
R600 007 000 0006 0000
R600 007 000 0005 0000
37
Item 11.
From: Kate Schaefer
To: Nagid, Stefanie; Davis, Mark; Smith, Juliana; Flake, Amanda
Subject: Fwd: North Widgeon - Approval Notice
Date: Friday, March 21, 2025 6:49:02 AM
[EXTERNAL EMAIL] Please report any suspicious attachments, links, or requests for
sensitive information to the Beaufort County IT Division at helpdesk@bcgov.net or to
843-255-7000.
FYI and for our files.
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: <msp@portal.sc.gov
>
Date: Thu, Mar 20, 2025 at 3:17 PM
Subject: North Widgeon - Approval Notice
To: <kate@openlandtrust.org
>, <dhenderson@parkerlawgroupsc.com>,
<sam.rivera@tylertech.com>, <amber.larck@sccbank.sc.gov>,
<margaret.pennebaker@sccbank.sc.gov>, <info@sccbank.sc.gov>,
<adair.roark@sccbank.sc.gov>
Dear Kate Schaefer:
I am pleased to inform you that the South Carolina Conservation Bank Board reviewed and
approved the above-mentioned project in the amount of $250,000.00. Before the Bank can
disburse funding, you must satisfy the terms and conditions of the Grant Agreement, which is
accessible within the Online Application Portal. Please note that this approval is contingent on
a final closing being scheduled within the Grant Period and any other conditions listed in
Section VI of the Grant Agreement.
We appreciate your interest and hard work in improving the quality of life in South Carolina
and are pleased that the Conservation Bank could play a role in accomplishing this project.
Congratulations on your successful request and I look forward to working with you in the
future.
If you have any questions, do not hesitate to contact this office.
J. Raleigh West III
Executive Director
803-734-0360
38
Item 11.
39
Item 11.
40
Item 11.
NORTH WIDGEON
41
Item 11.
South Carolina - Charleston, Greenwood, Greenville, Moncks Corner & Walterboro
Georgia – Blackshear, Soperton & Statesboro
Office (843) 538-6814 ∙ Fax (843) 538-6112 ∙ Website www.compasssouthappraisals.com
Appraisal Report
7 Okatie Highway
Okatie, SC 29909
Beaufort County
Report Date: November 21, 2024
Client:
Open Land Trust
Attn: Kate Schaefer
Beaufort County Rural & Critical Land Preservation Program
kate@openlandtrust.org
Compass South File Number: 2024-1376
42
Item 11.
P.O. Box 1766 ∙ Walterboro, South Carolina 29488
Office (843) 538-6814 ∙ Fax (843) 538-6112 ∙ Website www.compasssouthappraisals.com
November 21, 2024
Open Land Trust
Attn: Kate Schaefer
Beaufort County Rural & Critical Lands Program
kate@openlandtrust.org
Re: 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie SC 29909 in Beaufort County
Dear Ms. Schaefer:
In fulfillment of the agreement outlined in our engagement letter dated October 23,
2024, we are pleased to present the attached revised appraisal report for the above
referenced property as of Monday, November 11, 2024. The report, which is qualified
by the definitions, limitations and certifications set forth therein, sets forth our opinion
of the subject property's market value in the amount of $2,700,000, together with the
data and reasoning which formed the basis of that opinion.
This report is specifically prepared for Beaufort County Rural & Critical Land
Preservation Program, Beaufort County Greenspace Program and the SC Conservation
Bank and is intended for use only by these entities, their associates, professional
advisers, and appropriate regulatory authorities, if applicable. It may not be distributed
to or relied upon by any other persons or entities without our prior written permission.
If you have any questions concerning this report, please contact the undersigned.
Jennifer G. Dean, CG5598 Travis Lee Avant, ASA, ARM-RP,
Certified General Real Estate Appraiser R/W-AC
Certified General Real Estate Appraiser
CG4749
43
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Table of Contents
Table of Contents
Table of Contents ......................................................................................................................... 1
Summary Information ................................................................................................................. 1
Identity of Client ...................................................................................................................... 1
Effective Date of the Appraisal .............................................................................................. 1
Summary Description of the Subject Property .................................................................... 1
Appraised Value ...................................................................................................................... 1
Type of Report .......................................................................................................................... 1
Date of the Report .................................................................................................................... 1
Real Property Interest Appraised .......................................................................................... 1
Intended Use of the Appraisal ............................................................................................... 2
Intended User(s) ....................................................................................................................... 2
Type and Definition of Value ................................................................................................. 2
Property Specific Information .................................................................................................... 4
The Subject Real Estate ............................................................................................................ 4
The Owner(s) of Record(s) and Tax Map Parcel(s) ............................................................. 5
Sales History ............................................................................................................................. 5
South Carolina Property Taxes .............................................................................................. 6
Site Characteristics ................................................................................................................... 7
Existing Use of the Property ................................................................................................. 10
Title Description ..................................................................................................................... 10
Aerial(s) ................................................................................................................................... 10
Photographs of the Subject Property .................................................................................. 11
Work Performed ......................................................................................................................... 14
United States Economy ......................................................................................................... 14
Regional Economy ................................................................................................................. 15
The State Market and Economy – South Carolina ............................................................ 18
Local Market Conditions ...................................................................................................... 24
Highest and Best Use ............................................................................................................. 28
As Vacant Land .................................................................................................................. 28
The Scope of Work ................................................................................................................. 29
Sales Approach ........................................................................................................................... 31
The Value of the Vacant Subject Land ................................................................................ 31
44
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Table of Contents
Reconciliation ............................................................................................................................. 47
Assumptions and Limiting Conditions .................................................................................. 48
Extraordinary Assumptions and Hypothetical Conditions ............................................ 51
Certification and Qualifications of the Appraiser ................................................................. 52
Certification and Qualifications of the Appraiser ................................................................. 57
Addenda ...................................................................................................................................... 61
45
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Summary Information
1
Summary Information
Identity of Client
This appraisal is prepared for and on behalf of Beaufort County Rural & Critical Land
Preservation Program.
Effective Date of the Appraisal
Monday, November 11, 2024
Summary Description of the Subject Property
The property is a 9.511 +/- acre tract comprised of seven lots and one access easement
with a total of eight tax map parcels and has a physical address of 7 Okatie Highway,
Okatie, SC 29909. Indications from the surrounding market area show that when
properties are purchased, end users often only consider the portions of the property
which may be usable. This is typically the high ground. While it may not always hold
true, it is representative of the typical actions of an investor/developer. Therefore, the
subject and comparables have been adjusted to reflect only their acreages of usable
uplands.
Appraised Value
Based on the scope of work, methodologies and analysis performed, and set forth
herein, the value of the subject property, as of the effective date of the appraisal, is
$2,700,000.
Type of Report
This appraisal is prepared as an 'Appraisal Report', as defined by the Uniform
Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP). Accordingly, this report
summarizes our analysis and the rationale for our conclusion(s).
Date of the Report
November 21, 2024
Real Property Interest Appraised
The property is appraised on the understanding that the owner's interest is 'fee simple',
which is 'an absolute ownership unencumbered by any other interest or estate, subject
only to the limitations imposed by the governmental powers of taxation, eminent
46
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Summary Information
2
domain, police power, and escheat'. [Source: Appraisal Institute, The Dictionary of Real
Estate Appraisal, 7th ed. (Chicago: Appraisal Institute, 2022).]
Intended Use of the Appraisal
The intended user(s) are to employ the information contained in this appraisal report
for the purpose of establishing a valuation for sale.
Intended User(s)
On the basis of instructions received at the time of the assignment, Beaufort County
Rural & Critical Land Preservation Program, Beaufort County Greenspace Program and
the SC Conservation Bank are recognized as the intended user(s) of this appraisal report
and it is intended for use only by these entities, their associates, professional advisers
and appropriate regulatory authorities, if applicable. It may not be distributed to or
relied upon by any other persons or entities without Compass South Appraisals prior
written permission.
Type and Definition of Value
The subject property is appraised at 'market value', which is defined as 'the most
probable price which a property should bring in a competitive and open market under
all condition’s requisite to a fair sale, the buyer and seller each acting prudently and
knowledgeably, and assuming the price is not affected by undue stimulus. Implicit in
this definition is the consummation of a sale as of a specified date and the passing of
title from seller to buyer under conditions whereby:
o Buyer and seller are typically motivated.
o Both parties are well informed or well advised and acting in what they consider
their own best interests.
o A reasonable time is allowed for exposure in the open market.
o Payment is made in terms of cash in U.S. dollars or in terms of financial
arrangements comparable thereto; and
o The price represents the normal consideration for the property sold unaffected
by special or creative financing or sales concessions granted by anyone
associated with the sale.'
This definition is from regulations published by federal regulatory agencies pursuant to
Tile XI of the Financial Institution Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act (FIRREA) of
1989, between July 5, 1990, and August 24, 1990, by the Federal Reserve System (FRS),
National Credit Union Administration, (NCUA), Federal Deposit Insurance
47
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Summary Information
3
Corporation (FDIC) and the Office of Comptroller of Currency (OCC). The definition is
also referenced in regulations jointly published by OCC, FRS, and FDICI in June 1994,
and the Interagency Appraisal and Evaluations Guideline, as revised and updated
December 2010 (Interagency Appraisal and Evaluation Guidelines, 75 F.R. 77450, 77453
& 77472 (Dec. 10, 2010)).
48
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Property Specific Information
4
Property Specific Information
The Subject Real Estate
The property is a 9.511 +/- acre tract comprised of seven lots and one access easement
with a total of eight tax map parcels and has a physical address of 7 Okatie Highway,
Okatie, SC 29909. It has a peninsula shape with marsh frontage along its north, east and
south sides. The southern boundary is the saltwater pond between the subject tract and
Widgeon Point Preserve on its southwestern side owned by Beaufort County Open
Land Trust. The site is undeveloped with gentle rolling topography and covered in a
plethora of old oak trees and other indigenous coastal plants and trees. Access is
gained via a cattle gate from Highway 170 (Okatie Highway). The interior road is an
earth-covered drive that provides access to each lot.
After submission of the original report dated November 18, 2024, we were informed of
the following information. First, the property is improved with a water hydrant along
with having septic permits for each of the lots dated February 7, 2003. We have
subsequently made an assumption that these permits would be renewed and each of
the sites could be improved with individual septic systems. Second, the owner
provided an email correspondence of an offer made on the property from Bill
Anderson, broker with ERA Evergreen Real Estate. The offer is for $2,800,000 and a
information related to the email is discussed later in this report. The date of the offer is
unknown.
The tract has been on the open market for several years with an original price of
$5,000,000. The most recent price change was $3,500,000 on December 5, 2023 (mls#
183103). Said listing states the tract contains 21.98 acres. Public records indicate the
following: 5.6+/- acres is a portion of the pond and 6.7 +/- acres is marsh. The survey
recorded in plat book 68 at page 73 indicates there are 9.511 acres of uplands. We are
appraising the property as a total tract and not as individual lots. This report is based
upon the assumption that the upland acreages used in this report are correct and if
found to be incorrect the results of this report could change.
49
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Property Specific Information
5
The Owner(s) of Record(s) and Tax Map Parcel(s)
Sales History
Research of the applicable public records, private data services and an interview of the
current owner, revealed that the subject is currently listed for sale, though not under
contract; however, we were informed the client od this report is interested in a possible
purchase of the tract. Additionally, according to these sources, the subject has not
transferred during the past three years.
The subject is listed for sale at $3,500,000 and was listed for over 300 days with an initial
asking price of $5,000,000. Based on a comparison with other current listings, the subject
appears to be overpriced. Below is a summary of the sales history.
The owner provided an email correspondence of an offer made on the property through
Bill Anderson, broker with ERA Evergreen Real Estate. A copy of the email is shown
below. The date of the offer is unknown.
Location Parcel
Upland - Total
Acreage Owner Sale Price
Access Easement R600-007-000-001A-0000 1.671 Daniel E. Henderson, Trust of Rev. Trust $10
Lot 1 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0005-0000 1.260 Parker Family, LP $5
Lot 2 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0006-0000 0.930 Susan P. Henderson Rev. Trust $5
Lot 3 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0007-0000 0.880 Daniel E. Henderson, Trust of Rev. Trust $10
Lot 4 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0008-0000 0.910 John R. Peters, III, etal. $5
Lot 5 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0009-0000 0.930 Judith Peters and John Robert Peters, III $10
Lot 6 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0010-0000 1.160 Parker Family, LP $5
Lot 7 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0011-0000 1.770 Judith Peters and John Robert Peters, III $10
9.511
Location Parcel Sale Date Deed/Page Owner Sale Price
Access Easement R600-007-000-001A-0000 8/13/19 3786/771 Daniel E. Henderson, Trust of Rev. Trust $10
Lot 1 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0005-0000 12/21/09 2918/1284 Parker Family, LP $5
Lot 2 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0006-0000 8/25/20 3902/693 Susan P. Henderson Rev. Trust $5
Lot 3 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0007-0000 8/13/19 3786/771 Daniel E. Henderson, Trust of Rev. Trust $10
Lot 4 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0008-0000 12/31/12 3203/2045 John R. Peters, III, etal. $5
Lot 5 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0009-0000 7/30/21 4044/3047 Judith Peters and John Robert Peters, III $10
Lot 6 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0010-0000 12/21/09 2918/1278 Parker Family, LP $5
Lot 7 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0011-0000 7/30/21 4044/3047 Judith Peters and John Robert Peters, III $10
50
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Property Specific Information
6
South Carolina Property Taxes
Properties in South Carolina are exposed to the “ATI Law”, which means the fair
market value of a parcel of real property and any improvements thereon as determined
by appraisal at the time the parcel last underwent an assessable transfer of interest. In
this law, “fair market value" means the fair market value of a parcel of real property
and any improvements thereon as determined by the property tax assessor by an initial
appraisal, by an appraisal at the time the parcel undergoes an assessable transfer of
interest, and as periodically reappraised pursuant to Section 12-43-217.
When real estate is subject to the six percent assessment ratio provided pursuant to
Section 12-43-220(e) and is currently subject to property tax undergoes an assessable
transfer of interest after 2010, there is allowed an exemption from property tax in an
amount equal to 25% of ATI fair market value of the parcel. If the ATI fair market value
of the parcel is less than the current fair market value, the exemption otherwise allowed
pursuant to this section does not apply. The exemption allowed does not apply unless
the owner of the property, or the owner's agent, notifies the county assessor that the
property will be subject to the six percent assessment ratio before January 31st for the
tax year for which the owner first claims eligibility for the exemption.
South Carolina law also limits the increase in the taxable value of real property
attributable to the countywide reassessments to fifteen percent. Market value may
51
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Property Specific Information
7
increase more than 15%, but if it does, the taxable value is limited or capped. The 15%
reassessment cap is not a cap on taxes. The “15% Cap” reduces the value on which some
properties are taxed creating a taxable value.
More information can be found here:
https://www.scstatehouse.gov/code/t12c037.php
The most recent taxes on the subject total $10,804.94 and are reported as unpaid but not
delinquent as of the effective date of this appraisal. Under the state’s law governing
assessable transfers of interest, when real property is sold the sales price becomes the
assessed value for property tax purposes. The property presently has an assessed value
of $858,700; accordingly, should the property transfer for our estimated market value,
the property taxes could increase.
Site Characteristics
Location
The subject is located at 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 and is a peninsula that is
surrounded on three sides by water. It is located on Lemon Island facing the Broad
River.
Shape and Topography
It has a peninsula shape with marsh frontage along its north, east and south sides. The
southern boundary is the saltwater pond between the subject tract and Widgeon Point
Preserve on its southwestern side owned by Beaufort County Open Land Trust. The
site is undeveloped with gentle rolling topography and covered in a plethora of old oak
trees and other indigenous coastal plants and trees. A survey is recorded in plat book
94 at page 174, a copy of which are in the Addenda.
Location Parcel
Upland - Total
Acreage
Assessed
Value Taxes Status
Access Easement R600-007-000-001A-0000 1.671 $6,900 $117.04 Not Yet Due
Lot 1 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0005-0000 1.260 $146,600 $1,963.18 Not Yet Due
Lot 2 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0006-0000 0.930 $90,800 $1,225.06 Not Yet Due
Lot 3 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0007-0000 0.880 $89,800 $1,212.90 Not Yet Due
Lot 4 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0008-0000 0.910 $95,900 $1,293.30 Not Yet Due
Lot 5 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0009-0000 0.930 $92,800 $1,251.88 Not Yet Due
Lot 6 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0010-0000 1.160 $126,800 $1,700.10 Not Yet Due
Lot 7 Lemon Island R600-007-000-0011-0000 1.770 $209,100 $2,041.48 Not Yet Due
9.511 $858,700 $10,804.94
52
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Property Specific Information
8
Zoning
The property is zoned Natural Preserve (T1NP) by Beaufort County. The Natural
Preserve (T1) Zone is intended to preserve areas that contain sensitive habitats, open
space, and limited agricultural uses. The Zone typically does not contain building;
however, single-family dwellings, small civic buildings or interpretive centers may be
located within this zone. A copy of zoning regulations is in the Addenda.
Restrictions, Covenants and Access
A permanent non-exclusive right of ingress, egress and for installation of underground
utility installation and maintenance over, across, under and through that certain
“Existing Access Easement” as shown and depicted on that certain plat recorded in the
office of the register of Deeds for Beaufort County in Plat Book 68 at Page 39.
Utilities
After submission of the original report dated November 18, 2024, we were informed of
the following information. First, the property is improved with a water hydrant along
with having septic permits for each of the lots dated February 7, 2003. We have
subsequently made an assumption that these permits would be renewed and each of
the sites could be improved with individual septic systems.
Flood Zone
The subject property appears to lie in the 100-year flood plain, which is an area
adjoining a river, stream, or watercourse covered by water in the event of a 100-year
flood. The flood having a one percent chance of being equaled or exceeded in
magnitude in any given year. Factors which may be affected by properties located in
53
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Property Specific Information
9
such a flood plain include building permits, environmental regulations, and flood
insurance. A flood plain map for the area is found in an Addendum to this report.
Environmental Issues
We are qualified to detect the existence of hazardous materials but have no knowledge
of the existence of such material on or in the property. This appraisal is predicated on
the assumption that there are no such materials on or in the property that could create a
loss in value.
Earthquake Hazard Zone
According to the US Geological Survey’s seismic hazard map, there is only one area in
the southeastern United States in which earthquake peak ground acceleration (PGA)
has a 2% chance of being exceeded in 50 years at a value of over 80%g, and that is in the
Lowcountry of South Carolina. Talwani and Schaeffer from the University of South
Carolina used evidence from previous earthquakes to determine how often earthquakes
like the 1886 earthquake have occurred in the Charleston/Coastal area. They
determined that earthquakes in the Charleston area appear to occur about every 400-500
years and the possibility that large earthquakes may occur in Georgetown and Bluffton
on average 2,000-year cycles. Unfortunately, their data set is limited to only the last
6,000 years because of changes in groundwater levels, which affect the formation of
earthquake features. Therefore, it seems unlikely that a large earthquake will occur
anytime soon in the Lowcountry. Statistically, there is a 1/400 chance that a large
earthquake will occur each year in this area, and a significantly smaller chance in other
areas across the southeast. Further information can be found
here: https://www.usgs.gov/
Strengths and Weaknesses
The tract has water and marsh frontage along the Broad River with views toward
Beaufort along with the coastal aesthetics of live oaks and other indigenous plants.
There are no notable weaknesses.
Conclusion about the Site
Based on the foregoing analysis and the site inspection, in our opinion, the subject
property is located on a site that is comparable to that of other residential tracts in the
immediate area. Additionally, there is no apparent disadvantage(s) to the site from the
perspective of marketability.
54
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Property Specific Information
10
Existing Use of the Property
The subject property is an undeveloped tract of land along the marshes and waterways
of the Broad River.
Title Description
A copy of the primary page of the current, recorded title description can be found in the
Addenda to this report.
Aerial(s)
55
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Property Specific Information
11
Photographs of the Subject Property
Entrance to tract
Interior access easement road
56
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Property Specific Information
12
Tract interior
View of saltwater pond on northwest side of property
57
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Property Specific Information
13
Tract interior
Street scene
Note: Additional photographs are in an Addendum to this report.
58
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
14
Work Performed
United States Economy
According to a CoStar report, ‘The U.S. economy reaccelerated in the year's second
quarter after a marked slowdown at the beginning of the year. Real economic growth
measured 3.0% in the second quarter (on a seasonally adjusted annualized basis), more
than twice the 1.4% growth rate in the first quarter. The boost was mainly driven by
resilient household spending growth and solid business investment. However,
expectations are for growth to slow in the second half of the year as job growth slows
and the full impact of the Federal Reserve's tightening program flows through the
economy.
Consumer spending, the primary driver of economic growth, has been strong as
households spend excess savings accumulated during the pandemic, and the labor
market has continued adding jobs. According to the latest data, inflation-adjusted
spending rose 5.3% over the prior year in July, the fifth consecutive month of growth of
over 5%. However, spending growth has exceeded income growth in all but two
months of the past three years, leaving consumers more reliant on borrowing, the cost
of which has been rising as interest costs have surged. Delinquency rates of credit card
balances and personal loans have been increasing. Still, household balance sheets are
solid, with asset and home price gains adding to household wealth and allowing
consumers to continue to spend.
The labor market, strong in the first quarter due to a resurgence in economic activity in
late 2023, has slowed meaningfully. Monthly job gains numbered 142,000 in August,
below expectations, and gains in the prior two months were revised lower by 86,000
positions. The three-month average of job growth has been on a broad decline since
mid-2021. Meanwhile, initial and continuing claims for unemployment benefits are
drifting higher, and job openings have fallen below their pre-pandemic trend.
The Federal Reserve's monetary tightening program has been successful at lowering
inflation. The personal consumption expenditures (PCE) price index, the Federal
Reserve's preferred measure of inflation, eased from 7.1% in June 2022 to 2.5% in July
2024, continuing its slow descent. Core PCE, which excludes food and energy prices,
has also turned softer and sits at 2.6%. Stickier price gains in core services, excluding
housing services, keep the Federal Reserve watchful for an acceleration of inflation.
59
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
15
However, the recent weakness in the labor market has prompted the Fed to suggest it
will pivot its policy and begin lowering rates at its next meeting.
The outlook is for economic activity and job growth to continue to slow through 2024 as
the full impact of higher interest rates flows through the economy. Factory activity has
contracted for 21 of the last 22 months as investment and production cooled due to
higher financing costs. Meanwhile, the services side of the economy has held up
somewhat better but has skirted with contraction twice this year. The housing market,
one of the most interest-rate-sensitive sectors of the economy, has stagnated as higher
mortgage rates and still-elevated prices erode affordability and impact demand. At the
same time, inventories of homes for sale remain lean.’
Regional Economy
The Beige Book is a Federal Reserve System publication about current economic
conditions across the 12 Federal Reserve Districts. It characterizes regional economic
conditions and prospects based on a variety of mostly qualitative information, gathered
directly from each District’s sources. Reports are published eight times per year. It
Federal Reserve System publication about current economic conditions across the 12
Federal Reserve Districts. It characterizes regional economic conditions and prospects
based on a variety of mostly qualitative information, gathered directly from each
District’s sources. Reports are published eight times per year.
Economic activity grew slightly in three Districts, while the number of Districts that
reported flat or declining activity rose from five in the prior period to nine in the
60
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
16
current period. Employment levels were steady overall, though there were isolated
reports that firms filled only necessary positions, reduced hours and shifts, or lowered
overall employment levels through attrition. Still, reports of layoffs remained rare. On
balance, wage growth was modest, while increases in nonlabor input costs and selling
prices ranged from slight to moderate. Consumer spending ticked down in most
Districts, having generally held steady during the prior reporting period. Auto sales
continued to vary by District, with some noting increases in sales and others reporting
slowing sales because of elevated interest rates and high vehicle prices. Manufacturing
activity declined in most Districts, and two Districts noted that these declines were part
of ongoing contractions in the sector. Residential construction and real estate activity
were mixed, though most Districts’ reports indicated softer home sales. Likewise,
reports on commercial construction and real estate activity were mixed. District contacts
generally expected economic activity to remain stable or to improve somewhat in the
coming months, though contacts in three Districts anticipated slight declines.
Employment levels were generally flat to up slightly in recent weeks. Five Districts saw
slight or modest increases in overall headcounts, but a few Districts reported that firms
reduced shifts and hours, left advertised positions unfilled, or reduced headcounts
through attrition—though accounts of layoffs remained rare. Employers were more
selective with their hires and less likely to expand their workforces, citing concerns
about demand and an uncertain economic outlook. Accordingly, candidates faced
increasing difficulties and longer times to secure a job. As competition for workers has
eased and staff turnover has fallen, firms felt less pressure to increase wages and
salaries. On balance, wages rose at a modest pace, in line with the slowing trend
described in recent reports. Skilled tradespeople and other workers with specialized
skills remained in short supply and continued to see stronger wage increases, as did
those in unions.
1
On balance, prices increased modestly in the most recent reporting period. However,
three Districts reported only slight increases in selling prices. Nonlabor input cost
increases were largely described as modest to moderate and as generally easing, though
one District described input cost increases as ticking up. A number of Districts observed
that both freight and insurance costs continued to increase. By contrast, some Districts
noted that cost pressures moderated for food, lumber, and concrete. Looking ahead,
contacts generally expected price and cost pressures to stabilize or ease further in the
coming months.
61
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
17
Economic activity in the Fifth District (Richmond) slowed mildly this cycle, reversing
from a slight increase reported last period. Consumer spending on retail goods,
vehicles, and tourism declined in recent weeks. Manufacturing activity contracted
slightly, as well. Residential real estate activity softened alongside mortgage loan
demand; however, banks noted an increase in demand for home equity lines of credit.
Commercial real estate activity picked up slightly amid an increase in demand for retail
leasing and continued strength in industrial construction. Port activity picked up
moderately while trucking demand remained flat. Employment increased slightly in
recent weeks and several contacts said that they were not looking to make changes to
headcounts at this time. Price growth slowed slightly but remained elevated on a year-
over-year basis.
Commercial real estate activity continued to increase slightly in recent weeks. Retail
leasing picked up, but sales remained flat. New construction continued for pad sites,
such as gas stations and fast food, and for repurposing of vacant retail buildings. Office
space continued to see rightsizing with more investments going towards luxurious
aesthetics to create a “country club feel,” as one Virginia agent noted. Industrial
remained strong with some projects being limited by power and site availability.
Commercial investors were increasingly struggling with loans maturing and were
declining replacement rates and potential new buyers were sitting on the sidelines.
Financial institutions reported a softening of loan demand primarily in the commercial
real estate and business loan portfolios. However, lenders continued to see modest
increases in the demand for home equity lines of credit. Some lenders started to report a
slight increase in mortgage loan refinancing activity brought on by the downward
movement in rates. Institutions were seeing a stabilization in deposit levels, but
competition remained strong in the marketplace for new balances. Some lenders noted
that they have started to see a decline in the credit quality of borrowers, but
delinquencies remained stable.
Economic activity in the Sixth District (Atlanta) declined slightly since the previous
report. Labor markets and wages grew modestly. Prices grew modestly, and firms’
pricing power diminished. Low- to moderate-income consumers and small businesses
remained financially challenged. Consumer spending weakened amid growing price
sensitivity. Leisure travel continued to slow while business travel improved; spending
at hotel properties declined. Demand for housing fell amid a persistent lack of
affordability, and housing starts contracted. Commercial real estate activity was mixed.
62
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
18
Activity in the transportation sector weakened. Manufacturing activity declined. Loan
volumes grew slowly. Energy activity increased.
Commercial real estate (CRE) activity remained mixed. Vacancy rates rose in the office,
industrial, and multifamily sectors. While reporting modestly declining multifamily
and industrial starts, CRE contacts noted an increase in “clicks-to-bricks” investment,
where online sales are supplemented with a brick-and-mortar presence, driving more
sales both in-person and online. Firms reported a slight uptick in property sales
transaction volumes, especially for smaller office properties. Increasing CRE loan
maturities continued to create challenges for lenders. Underwriting standards remained
tight, making access to loans challenging.
Loan volumes at Sixth District financial institutions grew modestly. Asset quality
remained stable, though segments of their portfolios, such as commercial real estate,
commercial and industrial, and consumer lending, continued to soften. However, many
institutions remained selective in their credit risk appetite. Earnings showed
improvement driven by new loan volume and higher asset yields as compared to
funding costs. Borrowing declined modestly as banks reduced reliance on more
expensive liquidity sources. Cash balances increased moderately due to balance sheet
repositioning.
The State Market and Economy – South Carolina
The subject property is in the county (or counties) of Beaufort, South Carolina. The
state, which is roughly triangular and spread over 32,020 square miles, is bordered by
North Carolina to the north, the Atlantic Ocean to the east, and Georgia to the west and
south. South Carolina has 5.1 million people, 46 counties, and 187 miles of coastline.
63
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
19
According to the State of South Carolina Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (Fiscal Year
ended June 30, 2023), South Carolina extends from the Atlantic Ocean westward to the
Blue Ridge Mountains, containing over 30,000 square miles. Fortieth in geographic area
among the fifty states, South Carolina ranks twenty-third in population with
approximately 5.2 million citizens. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, the State’s rate
of population growth is presently the eighteenth fastest in the nation.
South Carolina has a diversified economic base including manufacturing, trade,
healthcare, services, and leisure/hospitality. Businesses have relocated here from all
over the world taking advantage of the State’s skilled labor force, competitive wages,
moderately priced land, excellent port facilities and accessibility to markets, and, in
recent years, substantial tax and other economic incentives.
During the year ended June 30, 2023, total non-farm employment in the State increased
by 89,800 (or 4.1%) to 2,304,100. Industry sector gains during that period were as
follows: Education and Health Services (25,100); Professional and Business Services
(15,100); Leisure and Hospitality (14,300); Construction (8,800); Financial Activities
(7,300); Mining, Logging, Information, and Other Services (6,100); Trade,
Transportation, and Utilities (5,600); Government (4,600); and Manufacturing (2,900).
64
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
20
South Carolina’s unemployment rate was 3.1% in June 2023, which decreased from the
June 2022 rate of 3.2%. The State’s unemployment rate was 2.9% in October 2023, the
most recent month available. In comparison, the U.S. unemployment rate was 3.6% in
June 2023 and 3.9% in October 2023.
The South Carolina Leading Index (SCLI) decreased by 0.62 points from June 2022 to
June 2023 to 102.37. Above the 100 marks, the SCLI forecasts generally improving
economic conditions for South Carolina over the upcoming three to six months. The
SCLI closed the month of July 2023 at 102.01, the most recent month available.
The number of real estate closings decreased by 13.0% between June 2022 and June 2023
due in large part to rising mortgage rates and rapidly increasing inflation. However, the
supply of available homes on the market in South Carolina remains low. As inventory
tightens, real estate selling prices in South Carolina have increased, with the median
price of homes sold increasing 2.6% between June 2022 and June 2023. In addition, the
number of residential building permits decreased by 9.4% compared to a year ago and
the dollar amount of those permits decreased by 6.7% between June 2022 and June 2023
The following graph compares South Carolina, the southeastern United States, and the
entire United States in per capita personal income growth over the last five years.
https://cg.sc.gov/financial-reports/annual-comprehensive-financial-reports-acfrs
65
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
21
The State continues to fund programs related to job creation. In calendar year 2022, the
State committed $19.192 million to the South Carolina Coordinating Council on
Economic Development’s Set-Aside Fund, which is dedicated to improving the
economic well-being of the State by providing funds to local governments to develop
the infrastructure necessary for new and expanding business. Programs like this helped
to recently attract Scout Motors Inc. to Richland County, Envision AESC to Florence
County, Redwood Materials to Berkeley County, and Tin Thanh Group Americas to
Allendale County. Scout Motors Inc. is expected to create 4,000 jobs, Envision AESC is
expected to create over 1,100 jobs, Redwood Materials is expected to create 1,500 jobs,
and Tin Thanh Group Americas is expected to create 1,031 jobs in the coming years.
South Carolina’s job creation and capital investment from manufacturers have
experienced steady growth since the end of the 2007 - 2009 recession. In 2022 alone, the
State attracted more than $10.27 billion in new capital investment from manufacturing
companies, which resulted in the creation of more than 14,083 jobs.
Over the last several years, South Carolina has continued to demonstrate its ability to
attract expanded economic opportunities for citizens. Manufacturing has grown
substantially. Even in the midst of challenging national economic conditions, the State’s
business-friendly climate and committed workforce continue to attract investment that
creates well-paying jobs.
In 2012, the State established an Aerospace Task Force to prepare the State for future
growth. The task force is focused on developing the aerospace supply chain for
companies like Boeing, Lockheed Martin, and GE Turbine and supporting initiatives to
assure that South Carolina has a workforce ready for the aerospace industry.
South Carolina’s exports were $31.5 billion in 2022, which is an increase of over 6.0%
from 2021. In 2022, South Carolina ranked 19th in the United States in exports. These
export figures were bolstered by the fact that the State is the nation’s top exporter of
completed passenger vehicles and tires. The State also recently established a
Transportation, Distribution and Logistics (TDL) Council that includes strong private
sector participation. Part of the mission of this council is to prepare South Carolina for
the Panama Canal expansion, providing South Carolina with a world-class port that
will have the capacity to support the expected increase in merchant shipping. The Port
of Charleston is deepening its shipping channel from forty-five to fifty-two feet. The
66
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
22
project was fully completed in December 2022, making Charleston the deepest port on
the east coast.
Due in part to the State’s economic outreach initiatives, South Carolina’s total economic
output or gross domestic product (GDP) was $295.880 billion in 2022. Between 2021 and
2022, real GDP grew 2.4%, compared to the southeast states’ average growth of 2.6%
during that period.
With the cost of living 6.3% below the national average, South Carolina offers
exceptionally productive employees at one of the lowest labor costs in the nation. South
Carolina is a right-to-work state and in 2022 had the lowest unionization rate in the
nation, at 1.7% of the workforce. As a result of this and other factors, Area Development
Magazine ranked South Carolina second in its Top States for Doing Business 2023
survey. In this 2023 survey, South Carolina ranked first in the nation in the available
real estate, site readiness programs, and speed of project permitting categories.
The Beige Book is a Federal Reserve System publication about current economic
conditions across the 12 Federal Reserve Districts. It characterizes regional economic
conditions and prospects based on a variety of mostly qualitative information, gathered
directly from each District’s sources. Reports are published eight times per year. It
Federal Reserve System publication about current economic conditions across the 12
Federal Reserve Districts. It characterizes regional economic conditions and prospects
based on a variety of mostly qualitative information, gathered directly from each
District’s sources. Reports are published eight times per year.
The Fifth District (Richmond) economy grew slightly. On balance, consumer spending
was flat to up slightly this period. Reports from retailers were mixed as some shops and
restaurants reported declines while others, namely furniture and hardware stores,
reported increased sales. Spending on travel, on the other hand, picked up as hotel
occupancy increased and future bookings were strong. Port activity declined slightly,
and the collapse of the Francis Scott Key Bridge led to the shutting down of traffic
coming in and out of the Baltimore harbor and main port terminal and the diversion of
shipments to other East Coast ports.
In residential real estate, respondents noted that so far it hasn’t been a robust spring
market; however, there remained pent up demand in the housing sector. Total closed
sales dropped month-over-month. Days on market increased slightly but was still
67
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
23
below the historic average; housing inventory remained tight. Listing prices were flat,
but many homes were still selling above asking price. Single family homes for first time
home buyers remained in short supply. Construction cost increases continued to
moderate in the Fifth District. Demand for home improvement projects declined
considerably from this time last year.
In the Fifth District, overall market activity in commercial real estate improved slightly
this period. Retail and industrial/flex space leasing remained robust with higher rental
rates and low vacancy rates. In the office sector, there was greater leasing activity
related to firms looking for more efficient space and moving to suburban locations.
However, an increasing number of commercial office buildings were unable to qualify
for refinancing this period. Commercial real estate sales slowed, and capital markets
activity was negligeable, which resulted in declining commercial real estate values.
Commercial contractors cited a lack of qualified candidates to fill positions as well as
rising material and labor costs.
Most financial institutions reported that they are observing a slight increase in loan
demand within their business and commercial real estate loan portfolios. One banker
noted that this slight increase was due to “pent up” demand and businesses were only
borrowing for immediate business needs. Deposit levels continued to decline modestly
with competition high for any available deposits in the marketplace. Institutions that
were once reluctant to have deposit specials began offering these promotions to
maintain their balances. Loan delinquency rates remained stable from the last report
with no changes noted in customer credit quality.
Economic activity in the Sixth District (Atlanta) grew modestly. Labor markets eased
further, and wage pressures moderated. Many nonlabor cost increases stabilized, while
the cost of others, like food and insurance, continued to rise. Consumer spending was
steady, but sales of discretionary items slowed. Leisure and business travel remained
healthy. District housing inventories grew, and affordability improved somewhat.
Commercial real estate activity slowed. Transportation demand remained mixed.
Manufacturing grew at a modest pace. Lending was flat on balance. Activity in the
energy sector increased somewhat.
Though home ownership affordability improved amid lower mortgage rates, home
price appreciation increased or stabilized in most markets, consistent with national
trends. Rising insurance premiums and HOA fees in coastal markets remained a
68
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
24
challenge for homeowners on fixed incomes. While still below historic norms, rising
existing home inventory, new subdivision developments, and an increase in spec-home
availability in the new home market led to higher inventory levels. Housing inventories
in southwest Florida increased at a sharper rate than the rest of the district due to
weaker demand and the lingering effects of Hurricane Ian.
Commercial real estate (CRE) conditions were mixed. Office and multifamily sectors
cooled as occupancies declined. Oversupply in the multifamily and industrial sectors
weighed on market conditions, as sizable amounts of new construction were delivered.
Firms reported that imprecise CRE appraisals were leading to valuation accuracy
challenges. Like the rest of the nation, Sixth District markets will contend with rising
CRE loan maturities in 2024.
Lending at District financial institutions remained relatively flat amid continued
contraction in most consumer loan segments. One notable exception was home equity
lines of credit, which have steadily increased in originations and utilization.
Commercial real estate loan originations, including multifamily, experienced minor
upticks since the previous report. The allowance for loan and lease losses continued its
slow but steady increase as economic uncertainty drove banks to adjust reserves. Cash
balances at financial institutions also increased slightly, consistent with broader
industry trends. Large time deposits experienced continued growth but may be
showing early signs of flattening as institutions start to lock-in anticipated interest rate
cuts by the Federal Reserve. Borrowings declined over the period as banks paid down
this more expensive source of funding.
Local Market Conditions
County Description
According to the county’s Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (Fiscal Year Ended June
30, 2023), Beaufort County is located in the southeastern corner of the State of South
Carolina, known as the “Lowcountry.” With a total area of approximately 923 square
miles, of which approximately 576 square miles or 62% is land and approximately 347
square miles or 38% is water, it is bordered to the south and east by the Atlantic Ocean,
to the west by Jasper County, and to the north by Hampton and Colleton Counties.
Beaufort County stretches nearly 30 miles along the Atlantic Ocean and includes 64
major islands and hundreds of small islands.
69
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
25
The County is one of the fastest growing areas in South Carolina, with an estimated
population of 194,614 in 2022, up from 167,423 in 2012. The County is a center for
tourism, retirement and the associated services, and the military in South Carolina. The
County has a balanced and very stable economy, created by a diversity of public and
private employers, with the unemployment rate well below the statewide average and
that of the neighboring counties. The local tax base has grown an average of
approximately 2% per year over the last five years (discounting the reassessment years).
In addition to the established resort community of Hilton Head Island, there are several
major developments established in southern Beaufort County. These developments
include Sun City Hilton Head, Spring Island, Callawassie Island, Colleton River
Plantation, Belfair, Berkeley Hall, Palmetto Bluff and Westbury Park. As expected, these
developments have sparked an increase in commercial construction along the Highway
278 corridor, including a Home Depot, a Lowe’s, an expanded Factory Outlet Mall, a
Dick’s Sporting Goods store, a Target department store, Sam’s Club Wholesale store,
Wal-mart and several major supermarkets. Likewise, in northern Beaufort County,
communities continue to develop at Dataw Island, Lady’s Island, Cat Island, Brays
Island, and Habersham and throughout the City of Beaufort, as well as the Town of Port
Royal.
Beaufort County is also the location for three major military installations, the U.S.
Marine Corps Recruit Depot located at Parris Island, the Marine Corps Air Station-
Beaufort, and the Beaufort Naval Hospital. These locations have benefited by the
Department of Defense closing certain other military bases in the nation.
The City of Beaufort is the county seat of Beaufort County and was founded in 1711.
The downtown area borders the Beaufort River, with the Henry C. Chambers
Waterfront Park as its central feature. The city has one of the nation’s largest National
Historic Landmark Districts. The prominent role of the city and the surrounding sea
islands led to the establishment of the federal Reconstruction Era National Monument
in 2017. There are several military bases in the area, including the Marine Corps Air
Station-Beaufort within the city limits as well as the nearby Parris Island Marine Corps
Recruit Depot and the US Naval Hospital; both in nearby Port Royal. The City’s
population was 13,607 according to the 2020 US Census.
70
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
26
The Local Market & Economy
The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), a part of the U.S. Census Bureau, collects and
reports data on per capita and median household income using a five-year average,
with unemployment and population data also being available from the BLS. Using the
most recent data available, the average, per capita income, median household income as
well as unemployment for the applicable areas for this report were as follows:
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Sales Approach - Median HH Income & Population for Comparables
Okatie Okatie 37,661 United States 308,745,538 311,556,874 313,830,990 315,993,715 318,301,008 320,635,163 322,941,311 324,985,539 326,687,501 328,239,523 331,449,281 332,031,554 333,287,557 334,914,895 USA $64,994 $35,384 Area Jan-19 Feb-19 Mar-19 Apr-19 May-19 Jun-19 Jul-19 Aug-19 Sep-19 Oct-19 Nov-19 Dec-19 Jan-20 Feb-20 Mar-20 Apr-20 May-20 Jun-20 Jul-20 Aug-20 Sep-20 Oct-20 Nov-20 Dec-20 Jan-21 Feb-21 Mar-21 Apr-21 May-21 Jun-21 Jul-21 Aug-21 Sep-21 Oct-21 Nov-21 Dec-21 Jan-22 Feb-22 Mar-22 Apr-22 May-22 Jun-22 Jul-22 Aug-22 Sep-22 Oct-22 Nov-22 Dec-22 Jan-23 Feb-23 Mar-23 Apr-23 May-23 Jun-23 Jul-23 Aug-23 Sep-23 Oct-23 Nov-23 Dec-23 Jan-24 Feb-24 Mar-24 Apr-24 May-24 Jun-24 Jul-24 Aug-24 Sep-24 Oct-24 Nov-24 Dec-24 Industrial 4 2012 2012.4 1.65%
187,117 Beaufort County, South Carolina South Carolina 4,635,649 4,671,994 4,717,354 4,764,080 4,823,617 4,891,938 4,957,968 5,021,268 5,084,156 5,148,714 5,131,848 5,193,266 5,282,634 5,373,555 SC 1 $57,216 $30,727 SC 4.1 3.8 3.8 3.4 3.8 4.2 3.8 3.5 2.2 2.5 2.5 2.8 3.5 3.6 3.6 11.8 11.8 9.3 9.5 7.2 5.4 4.5 4.6 6.7 6.1 5.9 5.5 5.1 4.2 5.2 5.0 4.9 3.9 3.7 3.8 4.0 4.5 4.8 3.9 3.1 3.6 4.0 3.9 3.9 3.6 4.2 3.3 3.6 4.2 4.3 4.0 2.9 3.3 4.1 4.2 2.9 3.0 3.5 3.4 3.6 3.9 4.2 3.9 3.4 4.2 5.3 5.7 6.2 #DIV/0! Lodging 5 2013 2013.1 1.98%
Georgia 9,711,881 9,802,431 9,901,430 9,972,479 10,067,278 10,178,447 10,301,890 10,410,330 10,511,131 10,617,423 10,729,828 10,788,029 10,912,876 11,029,227 GA 2 $62,800 $32,427 GA 5.1 4.4 4.1 3.5 3.9 4.4 4.4 4.2 3.5 3.5 3.2 3.5 4.0 4.0 4.9 10.4 7.5 6.7 7.0 5.3 5.5 4.1 5.0 5.6 5.0 4.4 4.1 3.8 4.0 4.6 3.3 3.3 2.6 2.6 3.1 3.1 3.6 3.5 3.6 2.6 3.0 3.6 3.3 3.5 2.9 3.4 3.1 3.0 3.8 3.6 3.7 3.0 3.7 3.8 3.6 4.2 3.6 3.7 3.2 3.1 3.4 3.3 3.5 3.1 3.7 4.4 4.3 4.5 #DIV/0! RV/Camp Mfg. Hsg. & MH Park 6 2013 2013.2 1.93%
Limits (Largest City/Town in County) North Carolina 9,574,323 9,657,592 9,749,476 9,843,336 9,932,887 10,031,646 10,154,788 10,268,233 10,381,615 10,488,084 10,449,445 10,565,885 10,698,973 10,835,491 NC 3 County Population $60,516 $34,209 County Per Capita NC 5.8 5.4 5.1 4.4 4.4 4.0 3.5 4.2 4.1 4.0 3.8 4.0 4.4 4.0 4.2 3.6 4.3 4.1 3.6 4.1 4.0 3.8 3.4 3.7 3.8 3.8 3.8 3.4 3.6 3.6 3.4 3.9 4.0 3.9 3.5 3.7 4.3 4.5 4.5 #DIV/0! Office 7 2013 2013.3 2.74%
4.4%
6.2%
5.2%
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Mar-24 Apr-24 May-24 Jun-24 Jul-24 Aug-24
Percentage of Population Unemployed
Month-Year
Unemployment Rate - Not Seasonally Adjusted
USA
SC
Beaufort
Source: www.bls.gov
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
SC SC SC SC SC
497 497 497 497 497
Beaufort Beaufort Beaufort Beaufort Beaufort
7 7 7 7 7
$72,661 $72,661 $72,661 $72,661 $72,661
187,117 187,117 187,117 187,117 187,117
Hilton Head IslandOkatie OkatieSt. Helena IslandSt. Helena Island
Cost Approach - Median HH Income & Population for Comparables
$64,994
$35,384
$57,216
$30,727
$72,661 $72,142
$0
$10,000
$20,000
$30,000
$40,000
$50,000
$60,000
$70,000
$80,000
Median Household Per Capita
Income
Type of Income
Comparative Income Chart
USA
SC
Beaufort
Sources: bls.gov & stlouisfed.org
71
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
27
This data indicates that the area in which the subject property is located was in a
comparatively better position, economically, than the state. Apart from this statistical
data, we also specifically addressed the market for the subject property. Based on
discussion with local market participants familiar with the area, the market for
properties such as the subject was found to be noticeably improved on the prior year.
That same source observed that the market for such properties is likely to improve over
the coming year.
Conclusion on the Market for the Subject Property
Based on the foregoing, in our opinion, the market for the subject property is relatively
strong and likely to remain so for the foreseeable future - and our report on market
value reflected that conclusion.
Most Probable Buyer
Based on the type of property and current market conditions, in our opinion, the most
probable buyer of the subject property would be an owner occupier or developer.
Foreclosure Activity
Based on a review of the general market area of the subject property, as well as
discussions with a local lender, foreclosure activity in the area is at normal levels.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Income Approach - Median HH Income & Population for Comparables
37,661 United States 308,745,538 311,556,874 313,830,990 315,993,715 318,301,008 320,635,163 322,941,311 324,985,539 326,687,501 328,239,523 331,449,281 332,031,554 333,287,557 334,914,895 USA $64,994 $35,384 Area Jan-19 Feb-19 Mar-19 Apr-19 May-19 Jun-19 Jul-19 Aug-19 Sep-19 Oct-19 Nov-19 Dec-19 Jan-20 Feb-20 Mar-20 Apr-20 May-20 Jun-20 Jul-20 Aug-20 Sep-20 Oct-20 Nov-20 Dec-20 Jan-21 Feb-21 Mar-21 Apr-21 May-21 Jun-21 Jul-21 Aug-21 Sep-21 Oct-21 Nov-21 Dec-21 Jan-22 Feb-22 Mar-22 Apr-22 May-22 Jun-22 Jul-22 Aug-22 Sep-22 Oct-22 Nov-22 Dec-22 Jan-23 Feb-23 Mar-23 Apr-23 May-23 Jun-23 Jul-23 Aug-23 Sep-23 Oct-23 Nov-23 Dec-23 Jan-24 Feb-24 Mar-24 Apr-24 May-24 Jun-24 Jul-24 Aug-24 Sep-24 Oct-24 Nov-24 Dec-24 Industrial 4 2012 2012.4 1.65%
187,117 Beaufort County, South Carolina South Carolina 4,635,649 4,671,994 4,717,354 4,764,080 4,823,617 4,891,938 4,957,968 5,021,268 5,084,156 5,148,714 5,131,848 5,193,266 5,282,634 5,373,555 SC 1 $57,216 $30,727 SC 4.1 3.8 3.8 3.4 3.8 4.2 3.8 3.5 2.2 2.5 2.5 2.8 3.5 3.6 3.6 11.8 11.8 9.3 9.5 7.2 5.4 4.5 4.6 6.7 6.1 5.9 5.5 5.1 4.2 5.2 5.0 4.9 3.9 3.7 3.8 4.0 4.5 4.8 3.9 3.1 3.6 4.0 3.9 3.9 3.6 4.2 3.3 3.6 4.2 4.3 4.0 2.9 3.3 4.1 4.2 2.9 3.0 3.5 3.4 3.6 3.9 4.2 3.9 3.4 4.2 5.3 5.7 6.2 #DIV/0! Lodging 5 2013 2013.1 1.98%
Georgia 9,711,881 9,802,431 9,901,430 9,972,479 10,067,278 10,178,447 10,301,890 10,410,330 10,511,131 10,617,423 10,729,828 10,788,029 10,912,876 11,029,227 GA 2 $62,800 $32,427 GA 5.1 4.4 4.1 3.5 3.9 4.4 4.4 4.2 3.5 3.5 3.2 3.5 4.0 4.0 4.9 10.4 7.5 6.7 7.0 5.3 5.5 4.1 5.0 5.6 5.0 4.4 4.1 3.8 4.0 4.6 3.3 3.3 2.6 2.6 3.1 3.1 3.6 3.5 3.6 2.6 3.0 3.6 3.3 3.5 2.9 3.4 3.1 3.0 3.8 3.6 3.7 3.0 3.7 3.8 3.6 4.2 3.6 3.7 3.2 3.1 3.4 3.3 3.5 3.1 3.7 4.4 4.3 4.5 #DIV/0! RV/Camp Mfg. Hsg. & MH Park 6 2013 2013.2 1.93%
Limits (Largest City/Town in County) North Carolina 9,574,323 9,657,592 9,749,476 9,843,336 9,932,887 10,031,646 10,154,788 10,268,233 10,381,615 10,488,084 10,449,445 10,565,885 10,698,973 10,835,491 NC 3 County Population $60,516 $34,209 County Per Capita NC 5.8 5.4 5.1 4.4 4.4 4.0 3.5 4.2 4.1 4.0 3.8 4.0 4.4 4.0 4.2 3.6 4.3 4.1 3.6 4.1 4.0 3.8 3.4 3.7 3.8 3.8 3.8 3.4 3.6 3.6 3.4 3.9 4.0 3.9 3.5 3.7 4.3 4.5 4.5 #DIV/0! Office 7 2013 2013.3 2.74%
170,000
175,000
180,000
185,000
190,000
195,000
200,000
205,000
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024
Population
Year
County Population
Beaufort
Source: www.bls.gov
72
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
28
Exposure & Reasonable Marketing Times
In determining whether or not there is a market for the property, we considered two
periods of time – one prior to the appraisal date and the other following that date. The
first, known as 'the exposure time', is the estimated length of time the property would
have been offered on the market prior to a hypothetical sale at market value on the date
of the appraisal. The second, known as 'the reasonable marketing time', is an estimate
of the amount of time it might take to sell the property at the estimated market value
during the period immediately after the date of an appraisal. In the instant case, we
determined, based on a study and review of market conditions, particularly those
demonstrated by these comparable sales, that the 'exposure time' needed to
consummate a sale prior to the appraisal would have been approximately 12-18 months.
Using a similar approach, we then determined the 'reasonable marketing time' to be
approximately 12-18 months.
Highest and Best Use
This appraisal is prepared under the assumption that the property's value should reflect
its 'highest and best use'. This term means ‘the reasonably probable use of property that
results in the highest value. The four criteria that the highest and best use must meet are
legal permissibility, physical possibility, financial feasibility, and maximum
productivity. [Source: Appraisal Institute, The Dictionary of Real Estate Appraisal, 7th ed.
(Chicago: Appraisal Institute, 2022).]
The subject property must meet four 'highest and best use' criteria, it must be:
Physically Adaptable; Legally Permissible; Financially Feasible; and Maximally
Productive.
As Vacant Land
Physically Adaptable
Size, shape, area, and terrain affect the use to which land may be developed. The
subject property's underlying land is sufficiently regular in shape to allow for many
forms of utilization. Surface water runoff is adequate and, based on our site
inspection, the soil or sub-soil has no apparent irregularities that would restrict the
property from being used in any reasonable manner.
Legally Permissible
The property is zoned Natural Preserve (T1NP) by Beaufort County. The Natural
Preserve (T1) Zone is intended to preserve areas that contain sensitive habitats, open
73
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
29
space, and limited agricultural uses. The Zone typically does not contain building;
however, single-family dwellings, small civic buildings or interpretive centers may be
located within this zone. A copy of zoning regulations is in the Addenda. A permanent
non-exclusive right of ingress, egress and for installation of underground utility
installation and maintenance over, across, under and through that certain “Existing
Access Easement” as shown and depicted on that certain plat recorded in the office of
the register of Deeds for Beaufort County in Plat Book 68 at Page 39.
Financially Feasible
The financial feasibility of a property is best determined by comparing its market
value with its acquisition and improvement costs, if any. In the case of the subject’s
vacant land, such feasibility is not an issue until such time as consideration is given
to developing the property.
Maximally Productive
The maximally productive use of the subject must be considered in the light of how it
is used, who uses it and the time or period of its use. In this case, the subject property,
as vacant land, is best suited for residential use.
Conclusion as to Highest and Best Use
Based on the preceding discussion, and particularly our determination of its maximally
productive use, in our opinion, the highest and best use of the subject property, as
vacant land, is residential use.
The Scope of Work
There are three main approaches to appraisal valuation: sales, cost and income. In
order to properly perform the necessary work, the appraiser must first determine which
approaches are applicable. Having made that determination, the appraiser will then
undertake appropriate research of both the subject property and its market area. The
research performed may include reviews of publicly available data, such as
governmental tax and property records; review of proprietary records, such as Multiple
Listing and other subscription services; inspection of proprietary data maintained by
the appraiser; consideration and inspection of comparable properties, whether sold or
listed for sale; and interviews with participants in the appropriate marketplace, such as
owners, brokers and other appraisers.
74
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Work Performed
30
As noted above, the first step in this process is the determination of which approach to
valuation is appropriate in the circumstances. This is addressed below for each of the
three main approaches.
Sales Approach
In the case of residential properties, such as the subject property, the sales approach is a
commonly used and accepted method. This is because there is usually a reasonable
availability of comparable sales data and because many residential properties are priced
and sold based on such data. In the case of the subject property, reasonable data is
available, which we identified and analyzed. The detail of those comparables, and an
analysis of how their adjusted values led us to a determined value for the subject, is
found further on in this report.
Cost Approach
This approach is frequently used for buildings and other improvements, particularly in
the case of newer properties. In the case of the subject property, there are no
improvements that contribute any significant value to the property. Therefore, we
determined that the use of this approach for the subject property would not be
appropriate.
Income Approach
This approach is generally reserved for appraising income productive properties and is
based on the Principal of Anticipation, which reasons that there is value in the
expectation of benefits (income) to be received in the future, and that this value may be
defined as the present value of all rights to such future benefits. We typically utilize a
process commonly referred to as direct capitalization, which is a method used to
convert an estimate of a single year's income expectancy into an indication of value in
one direct step. This is typically achieved by dividing the net income estimate by an
appropriate capitalization rate, which is determined either by a band-of-investments,
journals or market extraction.
The subject is not an income productive property. Therefore, we determined that this
approach was not applicable.
75
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
31
Sales Approach
As noted above, a primary method of determining the market value of a property is
through the identification and analysis of comparable sales, and if appropriate, listings
and contracts, of property within reasonable proximity and with reasonable
comparability to the subject property. This approach, sometimes called the 'market
data' approach is based under a tripartite assumption that: (a) there is a market for a
particular property; (b) that both buyers and sellers are fully informed as to the market
and state of the market for that type of property; and (c) that the property will be
exposed in the open market for a reasonable period.
The Value of the Vacant Subject Land
On the following pages are the properties that we identified as suitable comparables for
the purpose of establishing market value for the subject property. This data was then
analyzed, summarized, and adjusted to reflect the variations within those properties
that would tend to affect such value.
76
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
32
ID 16245 Tax ID R510 007 000 0082 0000; R510 007 000 1161 0000; 1162,
1163
Transaction Type Closed Sale Grantor Old House Creek Development, LLC
Property Rights Fee Simple Grantee Bailey Point Investment, LLC
Address 55 Jonesville Road Price $6,700,000
City Hilton Head Island Current Use Vacant
County Beaufort Book/Page 4099/3174
State SC Verification Public Records, CoStar
Zip 29926 Distance 11.74
Date 12/22/2021
Usable Acres 26.15 Land SF 1,290,116.52
Price Per Usable Acre $256,244 Price Per Land SF $5.19
Timber Value per Acre Improvements Value
Controlled Waterflow
Marshland Tidal Acres
Marshland Tidal Value
This is the sale of four tracts that have frontage on Jonesville Road and Spanish Wells Road near the north end of Hilton Head Island, SC.
Portions of the property front on the headwaters of the tidal creek known as Old House Creek as well as on the marshes of Jarvis Creek.
There is no apparent deep water frontage. A plat of the property (PB152/96) indicates there is a total of 29.617 acres, of which 3.407 acres
are tidal wetlands. We have excluded this acreage, and used a total of 26.147 acres. The property is mostly zoned RM4, which for a parcel
of this size, can be developed at 8 units per acre. A small portion, south of Spanish Wells Road, is zoned RM-8. After this sale, the property
was subdivided into individual lots and were sold off.
Values
General Information
Comments
Land Comparable 1
77
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
33
ID 16330 Tax ID R600 023 000 0021 0000
Transaction Type Closed Sale Grantor Kovalcik Family Trust
Property Rights Fee Simple Grantee John Thomas Lopat
Address 78 Harrison Island Road Price $765,000
City Okatie Current Use Land
County Beaufort Book/Page 4139/0815
State SC Verification Public records, MLS, local agent
Zip 29909 Distance 7.01
Date 4/4/2022
Usable Acres 5.00 Land SF 217,756.44
Price Per Usable Acre $153,031 Price Per Land SF $3.51
Timber Value per Acre Improvements Value
Controlled Waterflow
Marshland Tidal Acres
Marshland Tidal Value
This is a sale of a 5.02-acre lot at 78 Harrison Island Road, in the Pinckney Island community in greater Bluffton, SC. The property is
generally trapezoidal in shape and fronts on the marshes of the Colleton River. There is no deep water accessibility. The property was
listed on MLS in late February of 2022 for $855,000 and sold on April 5, 2022 for $765,000 after being on the market for 21 days. This
property is accessed via a dirt road. The property is zoned Rural T2R by Beaufort County that allows for 1.2 dwelling units per acre.
General Information
Land Comparable 2
Comments
Values
78
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
34
ID 30600 Tax ID R600-008-000-008B-0000
Transaction Type Closed Sale Grantor Thomas A. Gardner and Nanci A. Dumsha-Gardner
Property Rights Fee Simple Grantee Kenneth D. Harbour and Paige C. Harbour
Address 39 Okatie Bluff Rd. Price $2,125,000
City Okatie Current Use Deepwater Land
County Beaufort Book/Page 4250/3277
State SC Verification Public Record, Third Party Sources
Zip 29909 Distance 6.92
Date 6/12/2023
Usable Acres 13.07 Land SF 569,503.44
Price Per Usable Acre $162,536 Price Per Land SF $3.73
Timber Value per Acre Improvements Value $50,000
Controlled Waterflow
Marshland Tidal Acres
Marshland Tidal Value
General Information
Land Comparable 3
This is the sale of a tract of land comprised of 13.074 acres located at 39 Okatie Bluff Road on the marshes and deep water of Okatie River in
Okatie, SC. The property has a mobile home that contributed no value to the transfer. There was an older dock on the Okatie River built in
1981 that contributed approximately $50,000 to the sale. The property is zoned Rural T2R by Beaufort County that allows for 1.2 dwelling
units per acre.
Values
Comments
79
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
35
ID 27485 Tax ID R300-010-000-0040-0000
Transaction Type Closed Sale Grantor Carolina Child Care Properties, LLC
Property Rights Fee Simple Grantee Craig Kingery and Gerri Denise Kingery
Address 40 Stedy Git N It Lane Price $1,400,000
City St. Helena Island Current Use Land - Deep Water
County Beaufort Book/Page 4275/1754
State SC Verification Public Records, Secondary Sources
Zip 29920 Distance 13.32
Date 9/14/2023
Usable Acres 5.43 Land SF 456,073.20
Price Per Usable Acre $257,827 Price Per Land SF $3.07
Timber Value per Acre Improvements Value $180,000
Controlled Waterflow
Marshland Tidal Acres
Marshland Tidal Value
Values
Comments
This is the sale of a 10.47-acre parcel of land located at 40 Stedy Git N It Lane on St. Helena Island, SC. The land is an island that is
accessible through a private gate over a bridge (supports 24,000 lbs. per axle group) that crosses the marsh. The site is improved with a
deep water covered dock, boat lift, floating dock, well (pump house with reverse osmosis system, power and septic tank system. It has 360
marsh views and sits along Doe Point Creek with easy boating access to Port Royal Sound. The site improvements (including bridge, dock,
etc.) contributed approximately $180,000 to the value. The property sold for $1,400,000 on September 14, 2023 after being on the market for
199 days. A survey is recorded in plat book 87 at page 14.
All of the 10.47 acres uplands. Of the total acreage 5.01 acres are protected in a conservation easement (CE) with the National Wild Turkey
Federation, Inc. (recorded bk 1914 at pg. 1055). The easement areas are located within the 50' setback around the perimeter of the land and
on the corner tips. The remaining 5.43 acres have no restrictions and are buildable - this area is in the center of the site and thus, the CE had
no adverse effect on the marketability of the sale. The property is zoned Rural T2R by Beaufort County that allows for 1.2 dwelling units per
acre.
General Information
Land Comparable 4
80
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
36
ID 27896 Tax ID R300-022-000-044C-0000
Transaction Type Closed Sale Grantor Robert Faucette
Property Rights Fee Simple Grantee Kathryn Mariani Altemus
Address 31 Luna Drive Price $775,000
City St. Helena Island Current Use Land - Deep Water
County Beaufort Book/Page 4152/3109
State SC Verification Public Records, Secondary Sources
Zip 29920 Distance 10.44
Date 6/3/2022
Usable Acres 3.25 Land SF 141,570.00
Price Per Usable Acre $238,462 Price Per Land SF $5.47
Timber Value per Acre Improvements Value $80,000
Controlled Waterflow
Marshland Tidal Acres
Marshland Tidal Value
This is the sale of 3.25 acre site that is located along the deep water of Wallace Creek on St. Helena Island, SC. The site has easy access to
the ICW by boat. The property has power and a well in place along with a dock, covered pier head and floater. The is an old septic tank on
the property but the condition is unknown. The well and dock improvements contributed an estimated $80,000 to the sale. It sold on June
3, 2022 for $775,000 and later transferred non-arm's length on December 14, 2023. A survey is recorded in plat book 34 at 17. The property
is zoned Rural T2R by Beaufort County that allows for 1.2 dwelling units per acre.
General Information
Land Comparable 5
Comments
Values
81
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
37
Location Map
The following map shows the relative position of these comparables to the subject
property (subject is the yellow pin). It should be noted that some of the location pins
may be overlapping due to their proximity to one another and/or the subject.
82
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
38
Adjustments & Summary
The following table identifies each of these comparables, by number, in summary form
designed to show the value of each. That value is then been adjusted up or down, in
percentage terms, for a variety of factors intended to improve the comparability of that
property with the subject property, as discussed below.
Comparable 1 2 3 4 5
ID 16245 16330 30600 27485 27896
Date 12/22/2021 4/4/2022 6/12/2023 9/14/2023 6/3/2022
Price $6,700,000 $765,000 $2,125,000 $1,400,000 $775,000
Usable Acres 26.147 4.999 13.074 5.430 3.250
Improvements $0 $0 $50,000 $180,000 $80,000
1 2 3 4 5
Value per Usable Acre $256,244 $153,031 $158,712 $224,678 $213,846
Transaction adjustments
Property rights
As adjusted $256,244 $153,031 $158,712 $224,678 $213,846
Finance or Concessions 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
As adjusted $256,244 $153,031 $158,712 $224,678 $213,846
Conditions of sale 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
As adjusted $256,244 $153,031 $158,712 $224,678 $213,846
Post Acqn. Costs 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
As adjusted $256,244 $153,031 $158,712 $224,678 $213,846
Market Timing 14% 13% 7% 6% 12%
As adjusted $292,118 $172,925 $169,822 $238,158 $239,508
Property adjustments
Location (17%) 25% 11% 25% 25%
Site 0% 24% 24% 11% 11%
Adjustments (17%) 49% 35% 36% 36%
As adjusted value $242,458 $257,658 $229,259 $323,895 $325,730
Relative size 25% (10%) 10% (10%) (10%)
Total net adjustments 8% 39% 45% 26% 26%
As adjusted price $303,072 $231,892 $252,185 $291,506 $293,157
Adjustment Grid
83
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
39
The tables above depict the mean, median, range and standard deviation for the
comparables before and after all adjustments were applied. The mean and median are
both measures of central tendency. A mean is the sum of values for a variable in a
sample or population divided by the number of items in the sample or population
(otherwise known as the average). A median is identified as the middle value in an
ordered array of numerical values. If the ordered array contains an even number of
values, then the median is the mean of the two values on either side of the middle. The
range, however, is simply the difference between the highest and lowest values.
Finally, the standard deviation is a measure of the amount of dispersion of a set of
values. A low standard deviation indicates that the values tend to be close to the mean
of the set, while a high standard deviation indicates that the values are spread out over
a wider range.
Ideally, the range and standard deviation for the comparables will both be as close to
zero as possible. In the tables above, if the range and standard deviation have
decreased from before and after the adjustments were applied, this would indicate that,
as a whole, the adjustments were warranted (the last table shows the percentage that
these numbers changed). The only reason these numbers would remain the same is if
no adjustments were needed in the given set of comparables. Finally, if the range and
standard deviation increased, this would indicate that, as a whole, the adjustments
actually made the sales less comparable to the subject and the analysis is flawed.
Transactional Adjustments
The preceding summary addresses a series of factors affecting property value. Price
adjustments including potential property rights, financing, sales conditions,
expenditures, and market conditions can impact the per unit value of the property. As a
result, we examined all comparable sales for any potential price adjustments. Based on
Before Adjustments After Adjustments
Mean $201,301.99 Mean $274,362.51
Median $213,846.15 Median $291,505.86
Range $103,212.94 Range $71,180.19
Standard Dev. $39,664.58 Standard Dev. $27,448.00
Percentage that Range & Standard Dev. Tightened
Range
Standard Dev. (30.80%)
(31.04%)
Data on Comparability
84
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
40
the analysis of the comparable sales, we determined that one transactional adjustment is
warranted.
Time Adjustment
According to The Appraisal of Real Estate, 15th Edition, real estate markets are dynamic,
and appraisers describe this quality as a market’s life cycle. The complementary land
uses that make up neighborhoods and the homogeneous land uses within districts
typically evolve through four stages:
1. Growth—a period during which the market area gains public favor and acceptance
2. Stability—a period of equilibrium without marked gains or losses
3. Decline—a period of diminishing demand
4. Revitalization—a period of renewal, redevelopment, modernization, and increasing
demand
Transition often occurs in the revitalization stage when a land use that is no longer
financially feasible is discontinued in favor of a more productive use. Although these
stages can describe the life cycle of market areas in a general way, they should not be
used as specific guides to market trends. No set number of years may be assigned to
any stage in the cycle. Many real estate markets remain stable for a long time, and
decline is not necessarily imminent in all older areas. Unless decline is caused by a
specific external influence—e.g., natural disaster, major economic event—it may
proceed at an imperceptible rate and can be interrupted by a change in use or a revival
of demand. A market has no set life expectancy, and the life cycle is not an inevitable
progression. At any point in the cycle, a major change can interrupt the order of the
stages. For example, a strong negative influence such as a major employer suddenly
pulling out of a community or the closing of a military base can cause a real estate
market that is growing to decline rather than stabilize.
After a period of decline, a real estate market may undergo a transition to other land
uses, or its life cycle may begin again due to revitalization. Revitalization often results
from organized rebuilding or restoration undertaken to preserve the architecture of
significant structures. It may also be caused by a natural resurgence of demand. The
rebirth of an older, inner-city neighborhood, for example, may simply be due to
changing preferences and lifestyles.
85
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
41
It is also worth noting that the cost to borrow money has risen substantially since 2022,
with the prime rate being the simplest to track. The prime rate is the interest rate that
commercial banks charge their most creditworthy customers. The Federal Reserve sets
the federal funds overnight rate which serves as the basis for the prime rate (generally
300 basis points above the federal funds rate) which is the starting point for other
interest rates. The prime rate, which is sometimes simply referred to as prime, is the
most commonly used benchmark used by lenders when setting their interest rates for
various products.
Below is a graph of US inflation, prime and the 10-year US treasury rate since 2000
(percentages were the rate at the end of each period), demonstrating the changes over
this period:
86
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
42
According to information gathered from local brokers and online research of multiple
listing services, we determined an increase of 5% per annum to be appropriate for
market timing for this property type.
Location Adjustments
Adjustments are usually made to the comparable sales for location differences such as
access, traffic flows, highway influence, location of the county seat and other populated
towns, distance from applicable market areas, etc. To establish relative values for
these factors, we assigned each of the properties, for each factor, a value on a scale
from 1 to 5, with 5 being the highest.
Surroundings
Comparable 1 is located on Hilton Head Island and was ranked as good for this factor.
Sales 4 and 5 are on St. Helena Island that is some distance from shopping,
employment, etc. These two comparables were rated as below average. Sales 2 and 3
are similar in overall surroundings to that of the subject.
Proximity to major nodes
The subject property is just off Okatie Highway and was rated as above average for
proximity to major nodes. Sale 1 is in close distance to Highway 278, the major road
system on Hilton Head Island and was ranked as above average. The other sales are all
ranked as average for this characteristic.
Accessibility
Sale 2 is directly accessed via a dirt road and was rated as below average for
accessibility.
Summary
The following table brings these elements together and establishes what, in our opinion,
is a reasonably objective determination of the relative differences in value attributable
Poor 1
Below average 2
Average 3
Above average 4
Good 5
87
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
43
to each comparable by virtue of its locational difference from the subject property:
Site Adjustments
The physical attributes of a property can impact their perceived and actual value. In
considering the subject property and the comparables, we looked at physical factors
that, in our opinion, influence and affect value. To establish relative values for these
factors, we have assigned for each of the properties, for each factor, a value on a scale
from 1 to 5, with 5 being the highest. These ratings were not intended to imply that a
particular factor is considered poor or underperforming but is intended to illustrate that
a particular factor is inferior or superior in comparison to the subject.
Easements
Sale 4 has a total upland acreage of 10.47 acres. Of the total acreage, 5.01 acres are
protected by a conservation easement. The easement areas are located within the 50’
setback around the perimeter of the land and on the corner tips. The remaining 5.43
acres have no restrictions and are buildable – this area is in the center of the site and
thus, the CE had no adverse effect on the marketability of the property. The subject and
all the sales were ranked as average.
View
The subject property along with sales 1, 4 and 5 have good views and were rated as
good for this characteristic. Sales 2 and 3 were given a rating of above average.
Water/Marsh Frontage
The physical characteristics of a parcel of land that an appraiser must consider include’
the type of frontage. In the immediate case, the subject, and sales 1, 4 and 5 were
ranked as good for this factor. Sales 2 and 3 are above average.
Subject 1 2 3 4 5
Surroundings 3.0 5.0 3.0 3.0 2.0 2.0
Proximity to major nodes 4.0 4.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0
Accessibility 3.0 3.0 2.0 3.0 3.0 3.0
10.0 12.0 8.0 9.0 8.0 8.0
Location adjustment (17%) 25% 11% 25% 25%
Location Adjustment
88
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
44
Zoning
The subject property is zoned Natural Preserve (T1NP) by Beaufort County. This
zoning allows for 0.1 dwelling units per acre; however, the subject property has already
been subdivided into seven lots along with an access easement. Sales 2, 3, 4 and 5 are
zoned T2R by Beaufort County which allows for 1.2 dwelling units per acre. The
subject and these four comparables were rated as average for zoning. Sale 1 is zoned
RM-8 by the Town of Hilton Head Island that allows for 8 dwelling units per acre and
thus, it was ranked as good.
Utilities
After submission of the original report dated November 18, 2024, we were informed of
the following information. First, the property is improved with a water hydrant along
with having septic permits for each of the lots dated February 7, 2003. We have
subsequently made an assumption that these permits would be renewed and each of
the sites could be improved with individual septic systems. The subject was rated as
good for this factor. The sales were rated as average.
Summary
The following table identifies the elements for the subject property and the comparables
and establishes what, in our opinion, is a reasonably objective determination of the
relative differences in value attributable to each comparable by virtue of its differences
from the subject property. Please note that for each of these ratings, which were to
some extent subjective, we have allowed for marginal attributions by assigning less
than whole numbers to a category where we deemed appropriate:
Relative Size
In general, it is an established probability that the larger a property, the lower its per
unit value. For that reason, it is important that small properties not be relied upon to
value large properties. In this selected group of comparables, we have attempted to
Subject 1 2 3 4 5
Easements 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0
View 5.0 5.0 4.0 4.0 5.0 5.0
Water/Marsh Frontage 5.0 5.0 4.0 4.0 5.0 5.0
Zoning 3.0 5.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0
Utilties 5.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0
21.0 21.0 17.0 17.0 19.0 19.0
Site adjustment 0% 24% 24% 11% 11%
Site Adjustment
89
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
45
address this issue by selecting only those sales that were reasonably comparable, among
other things, by reference to their relative size. However, as these comparables do vary
in size, we did perform a test, using simple linear regression analysis, to determine
whether or not they exhibited any reasonable level of correlation between their size and
their as-adjusted values.
The size adjustment represents the final factor that could, possibly, affect value. For
such an adjustment to be made, it is necessary to first determine that there is, indeed,
some reasonable correlation between values and size. In our opinion, to make that
determination properly, only the as-adjusted values should be considered. To do
otherwise would make any such determination of correlation invalid because factors
outside of size would not have been adjusted for and could, accordingly, corrupt the
correlation. Thus, in our analysis, we have first adjusted for all other factors. Then,
using the as-adjusted values, we determined, using regression analysis, whether there
was reasonable evidence of a correlation between size and value. In the case of the
subject property, we concluded that such a correlation did exist. Accordingly, we have
adjusted to properly align their as-adjusted values with their related size.
90
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals The Sales Approach
46
Determination
Most weight was placed on Sale 3 due to timing and its similarity in acreage size.
Secondary weight was given to Sale 1 due to the least degree of net adjustments and on
Sale 4 due to it being the most recent sale. Equal but less weight was placed on the
remaining sales.
Total size 9.511
Value/unit $280,000
Total Value $2,663,080
Rounded $2,700,000
Value Indication - Land
91
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Reconciliation
47
Reconciliation
In determining the final opinion of value, we reviewed all the analyses and previous
work performed; the data, logic and techniques were checked and verified. The data
was carefully considered and reviewed to ensure the quantity, quality, and authenticity.
Second, we applied logic and judgment through the reconciliation process to arrive at
the final estimate of value, which was our perception of the most likely, most probable
price available in an arm’s length transaction of the subject property.
Sales Approach
The sales approach reflects the value of the property from the perspective of an
informed buyer. This approach is usually the most insightful valuation method when
numerous timely sales of similar properties are available for analysis. In the subject
property case, several such sales were available. Therefore, in our opinion, the result
from this approach is a good indication of market value for the subject property.
Determination
After considering the results shown in the sales approach, in our opinion the value of
the subject is $2,700,000 as of Monday, November 11, 2024.
92
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Assumptions and Limiting Conditions
48
Assumptions and Limiting Conditions
General Assumptions
This appraisal report is based on the following assumptions:
That title to the property is good and marketable unless otherwise stated.
The property is under responsible ownership and management.
The property is free of all liens and encumbrances, including material easements and
rights of way, unless otherwise stated.
That the facts, estimates and opinions furnished to us by others were given in good faith
and were honestly expressed.
Any data or information provided by the owners, or their agents are substantially correct.
There are no hidden or other unapparent conditions in or on the property that would
change the appraised value.
That structural and mechanical conditions which visually appear to be sufficient for their
intended purpose are indeed so.
That the owner has maintained the property in compliance with all applicable federal,
state and local regulations and laws, including the payment of any related taxes, unless
otherwise stated.
That all applicable zoning, use regulations and restrictions have been complied with.
That all required licenses, certificates, legislated or administrative consents from any local,
state or national governmental or private entity or organization have been or can be
obtained or renewed for any use on which the value estimated in this report is based.
That the utilization of the land and any improvements is within the boundaries or
property lines of the property, unless noted within the report.
93
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Assumptions and Limiting Conditions
49
That revenue stamps placed on deeds, used to indicate comparable sales, were in the
correct amount to reflect the true and actual money consideration involved; and that the
information secured from brokers or interested parties to verify the transactions, is in
conformity with the facts.
Limiting Conditions
This report is made expressly subject to the following stipulations and conditions:
No responsibility is assumed for any legal descriptions or for any matter requiring legal
competence.
Any sketches, plans or drawings are provided only to assist the reader in visualizing the
property.
We specifically accept no responsibility for damage from termites, woodborers or any
other wood-infesting insects.
No responsibility is assumed for any adverse condition that would only be discoverable
by an inspection performed by a qualified engineer or similar specialist.
We are not qualified to detect the existence of hazardous material but have no knowledge
of the existence of such materials on or in the property. This appraisal is predicated on the
assumption that there are no such materials on or in the property that could cause a loss in
value, unless so noted.
No responsibility is assumed by us for matters that are legal in nature, or for auditing or
engineering opinions, nor is any opinion of the title rendered herewith.
Possession of this report or any copy does not carry with it the right of publication, nor
may the report, or any portion thereof, be used for any purpose by any but the Client
without the previous written consent of the appraiser.
This property has not been surveyed to establish the facts of legal description and
dimensions; these are presumed to be substantially as stated in information provided to
us.
94
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Assumptions and Limiting Conditions
50
The provision of this report does not obligate us to voluntarily give sworn testimony with
reference to the property evaluated. If given, such testimony would be contingent upon
both appropriate compensation and the opportunity to review the appraisal report in light
of market change.
This report is an opinion of value and does not constitute any form of guarantee of that
value.
To the best of our knowledge, the presence of Radon has not been detected on this
property or, if detected, has been determined that the level is considered safe according to
the standards established by the Environmental Protection Agency. We do not, however,
make any guarantees or warranties that the property has been tested for the presence of
Radon, or, if tested, that the tests were conducted pursuant to EPA approved procedures.
The property was not reviewed to determine whether or not it is in conformity with the
various requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, as amended. It is
possible that a compliance survey could determine that the subject property does not
conform to one or more of the requirements of the ADA. If so, this fact could have a
negative effect on the market value of the subject property.
The names and qualifications of the appraiser or appraisers who materially assisted in
the preparation of this report are found below. For the sake of simplicity and
consistency, the use of the terms 'we' or 'us', rather than the first person singular, has
been used throughout this report to reflect the possibility that more than one appraiser
participated in the work performed for this report.
95
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Assumptions and Limiting Conditions
51
Extraordinary Assumptions and Hypothetical Conditions
An extraordinary assumption is 'an assumption, directly related to a specific
assignment as of the effective date regarding uncertain information used in an analysis
which, if found to be false, could alter the appraiser’s opinions or conclusions.’ (USPAP
2024-2025)
A hypothetical condition is 'a condition, directly related to a specific assignment, which
is contrary to what is known by the appraiser to exist on the effective date of the
assignment results but is used for the purpose of analysis.' (USPAP 2024-2025)
There are extraordinary assumption(s) but no hypothetical conditions in this report.
The survey recorded in plat book 68 at page 73 indicates there are 9.511 acres of
uplands. We are appraising the property as a total tract and not as individual lots. This
report is based upon the assumption that the upland acreages used in this report are
correct.
We have assumed that the septic permits would be renewed and each of the sites could
be improved with individual septic systems. Additionally, we have assumed that the
property is improved with a water hydrant.
It is assumed that the information provided to us about the offer made on the property
is correct and current.
If any of the above assumptions were found to be untrue, the results of this report could
change.
96
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Certification(s) and Qualification(s)
52
Certification and Qualifications of the Appraiser
Certification Statement
I certify to the best of my knowledge and belief:
The statements of facts contained in this report are true and correct to the best of my
knowledge.
The reported analyses, opinions, and conclusions are limited only by the reported
assumptions and limiting conditions and is my personal, impartial, and unbiased
professional analyses, opinions, and conclusions.
I have no present or prospective interest in or bias with respect to the property that
is the subject of this report and have no personal interest in or bias with respect to
the parties involved.
I have not previously appraised, and I have not provided any service in any other
capacity, regarding the real property which is the subject of this appraisal within the
three-year period immediately preceding acceptance of this assignment.
I have no bias with respect to the property that is the subject of this report or to the
parties involved in the assignment.
My engagement in this assignment was not contingent upon developing or
reporting predetermined results.
My compensation for completing this assignment is not contingent upon the
development of reporting of a predetermined value or direction in value that favors
the cause of the client, the amount of the value opinion, the attainment of a
stipulated result, or the occurrence of a subsequent event directly related to the
intended use of this appraisal.
My analysis, opinions, and conclusions were developed, and the report was prepared
in conformity with the Uniform Standards of Processional Appraisal Practices.
97
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Certification(s) and Qualification(s)
53
I have not made an inspection of the subject property.
No one provided professional real estate appraisal assistance to the person(s)
signing this report.
Although several market participants may be contacted as a part of my routine
market research investigation, absolute client confidentiality and privacy are
maintained at all times with regard to this assignment without conflict of interest.
Professional Associations
I hereby certify that, to the best of my knowledge and belief, the statements of fact
contained in this report are true and correct, and this report has been prepared in
conformity with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice of The
Appraisal Foundation.
The report analysis, opinions, and conclusions were developed, and this report has
been prepared in conformity with the Principles of Appraisal Practice and Code of
Ethics of the American Society of Appraisers.
As of this date of this report, I am in good standing, completed the continuing
educational requirements and in compliance with programs of the Accredited Senior
Appraiser (ASA) and Appraisal Review Management (ARM) of the American
Society of Appraisers.
__________________________________________
Travis Lee Avant, ASA, ARM-RP, R/W-AC
SC Certified General Real Estate Appraiser CG 4749
98
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Certification(s) and Qualification(s)
54
Statement of Qualifications of the Appraiser
Travis Lee Avant
ASA -Accredited Senior Appraiser Designation and Appraisal Review RP Designation
Employment History
1983 to 1986 United States Army
1986 to 2000 Law Enforcement, Colleton Co. SC, including six years as elected Sheriff
2000 to 2003 Criminal Investigator, SC Law Enforcement Division -SLED
2003 to 2007 General Appraiser, Hartnett & Co, Charleston, SC
2007 to 2009 Summary Court Magistrate in Colleton County
2011 to 2013 Colleton County Election Commission Board Director
2007 Current- Present founder and co-owner of CSI and principal and team lead appraiser of
Compass South Appraisals
Education
1987 Graduate of Trident Tech College, AS Public Service
1994 Graduate, the F.B.I. National Academy, Quantico, VA
1996 National Sheriff’s Institute Administrators Academy, Colorado
2000 Graduate, The University of South Carolina, AS and Bachelor of Science
Current Business and Professional Affiliations
ASA - Designated Accredited Senior Appraisers and Appraisal Review
ASA - Representative of the Ethics Committee
Board President, Palmetto Rural Telecommunication
Board Director, South Carolina Broad Band Association
Board Director, Executive Committee, SC Palmetto Agribusiness Council
Board Director with a local community bank
Current State Certified General Real Estate Appraiser License
Active: Alabama, Georgia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee and Virginia – temporary licenses
in past – Texas, Arkansas, Mississippi and Florida.
Brokers Real Estate License
Accredited Buyers Representation - ABR® designee of NAR. Real Estate organization that encourages the
highest standard of ethical business practices.
Appraisal Experience
I have twenty-one years as an appraiser with extensive experience appraising various types of rural and
commercial and residential properties. To include commercial, industrial, office and retail uses, c -stores
hotels, residential subdivision and a variety of special purposes type properties. Experience includes
timberland, recreational property, historical plantations, venues, and agricultural products, such as
99
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Certification(s) and Qualification(s)
55
poultry, and orchards. I have completed over one hundred appraisal assignments involving conservation
and preservation easements.
I have completed over hundreds of eminent domain assignments with litigation experience. Eminent
Domain clients include condemnor and condemnee for property owners, several counties and municipal
governments, utility companies and law firms across South Carolina. I have experience in appraisal
review; completed over 100 hours of training with emphasis on appraisal review training and have
experience providing technical, UASFLA and USPAP compliance appraisal reviews. I have testified as a
witness in Federal, State, Family, Master of Equity, Common/Civil and Criminal Court.
Articles and Presentations
Contributor for the TAQEEM appraisal review manual was recently published by the American Society
of Appraisers. I’ve served a few times as a guest instructor for ASA regarding Appraisal Review course
training and on Eminent Domain topics at the annual ASAIC as well as providing instructions to a few
organizations on the appraisal process.
Appraisal Education
Uniform Standards, USPAP, 2024-2025
Eminent Domain, SCDOT, 2024
SC Land Use, Seminar Group, 2024
Conservation Easements: Legal, Appraisal, Accounting, and Ethical Issues, Appraisal institute 2023
Business Practice and Ethics, Appraisal institute, 2023
Appraising Environmentally Contaminated Properties, 2023
Conservation Transactions: Legal and Appraisal Matters, SCCB 2022
Comprehensive Appraisal Overview, Appraisal Institute, 2022
Appraisal Review Theory, Appraisal Institute, 2021
Easement Valuation, IRWA, 2021
Supervisory - Trainee Course, 2021
Code of Ethics, IRWA, 2021
Eminent Domain, IRWA, 2020
Comprehensive Appraisal Overview, Appraisal Institute, 2020
Appraisal Review Theory, Appraisal Institute, 2019
Realtors ® Appraisal Code of Ethics, 2018
Cost Approach Certificate, Core Logic, 2018
The Law and Litigation with Eminent Domain, SC Bar, 2018
Eminent Domain and Condemnation, Appraisal Institute, 2018
Expert Witness / Scope of Work / Going Concern, Appraisal Society Appraisers 2017
Forest Valuation II, Appraisal Institute, 2017
Principals of Real Estate Appraisals, IRWA 2017
Uniform Appraisal Standards for Federal Land Acquisitions, 2016, 2017
Ethics and the Right of Way Profession, IRWA, 2016
Appraisal Review Management, Appraisal Society Appraisers, 2015, 2016
Accredited Buyers Representation - ABR® designee, NAR, 2015
Standards of Practice for the Right of Way Professional, IRWA 2015
The Valuation of Partial Acquisitions, IRWA 2015
100
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Certification(s) and Qualification(s)
56
Real Estate Finance, Statistics Valuation Modeling, Appraisal Institute, 2013
General Appraisal Report Writing and Case Studies, Appraisal Institute, 2013
Hypothetical and Extraordinary Conditions, Appraisal Institute, 2012
Conservation Easements, 2006, 2012, 2013, 2015
Business Practice & Ethics, Appraisal Institute, 2012
Fundamentals of Separating Real Property, 2012
Appraising the Appraiser, Appraisal Institute, 2012
Applied Forest Finance, FORISK, 2010
Advanced Sales and Cost Approach, Appraisal Institute, 2009
Advanced Income Capitalization, Appraisal Institute, 2009
Commercial Real Estate Analysis, CCIM, 2006
The Professional Guide to URAR- Secondary Mortgages, 2005
Appraisal Principles, Appraisal Institute, 2005
Discounted Cash Flow, 2004
Applied Income Property Valuation, 2003
Advanced Income Capitalization Procedures, 2003
Introduction to Income Property Appraisal, 2003
Financial Cash Flow, 2003, 2013
Appraising Single family Residences, 2003
Applied Property Valuation Case study 2003
Principals of Real Estate Appraisals, 2003
South Carolina Department of Labor, Licensing and Regulation
Real Estate Appraisers Board
CERTIFIES THAT:
TRAVIS LEE AVANT
IS AUTHORIZED TO PRACTICE
Certified General Appraiser
LICENSE NO.
AB .4749 CG
EXPIRATION DATE: 06/30/2026
To ve rify current license status, go to http://ve rify.llronline.com/LicLookup/LookupMain.aspx
101
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Certification(s) and Qualification(s)
57
Certification and Qualifications of the Appraiser
Certification Statement
I certify to the best of my knowledge and belief:
The statements of facts contained in this report are true and correct to the best of my
knowledge.
The reported analyses, opinions, and conclusions are limited only by the reported
assumptions and limiting conditions and is my personal, impartial and unbiased
professional analyses, opinions, and conclusions.
I have no present or prospective interest in or bias with respect to the property that
is the subject of this report and have no personal interest in or bias with respect to
the parties involved.
I have not previously appraised and I have not provided any service in any other
capacity, regarding the real property which is the subject of this appraisal within the
three-year period immediately preceding acceptance of this assignment.
I have no bias with respect to the property that is the subject of this report or to the
parties involved in the assignment.
My engagement in this assignment was not contingent upon developing or
reporting predetermined results.
My compensation for completing this assignment is not contingent upon the
development of reporting of a predetermined value or direction in value that favors
the cause of the client, the amount of the value opinion, the attainment of a
stipulated result, or the occurrence of a subsequent event directly related to the
intended use of this appraisal.
My analysis, opinions and conclusions were developed, and the report was prepared
in conformity with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practices.
I made an inspection of the subject property.
102
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Certification(s) and Qualification(s)
58
No one provided professional real estate appraisal assistance to the person(s)
signing this report.
Although several market participants may be contacted as a part of my routine
market research investigation, absolute client confidentiality and privacy are
maintained at all times with regard to this assignment without conflict of interest.
Professional Associations
I hereby certify that, to the best of my knowledge and belief, the statements of fact
contained in this report are true and correct, and this report has been prepared in
conformity with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice of The
Appraisal Foundation.
The report analysis, opinions, and conclusions were developed, and this report has
been prepared in conformity with the Code of Professional Ethics and Standards of
Professional Practices of the Appraisal Institute.
The use of the report is subject to the requirements of the Appraisal Institute relating
to review by its duly authorized representatives.
As of this date of this report, I have completed that Standards and Ethics Education
Requirements.
As of this date of this report, I am in good standing and a Practicing Affiliate of the
Appraisal Institute.
________________________________________
Jennifer G. Dean
SC Certified General Real Estate Appraiser CG 5598
103
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Certification(s) and Qualification(s)
59
Statement of Qualifications of the Appraiser
Jennifer G. Dean, CG 5598
Employment History
1991 to 2005 Rhodes Oil Company, Inc., Walterboro, SC
2006 to 2007 General Appraiser, Hartnett & Co, Charleston, SC
2007 to date General Appraiser of Compass South, Inc.
Education
1989 Graduate of the University of South Carolina, Associates Degree
1991 Graduate of the University of South Carolina, Bachelor of Arts Degree
Business and Professional Affiliations
Practicing Affiliate of the Appraisal Institute
General Accredited Appraiser / National Association of Realtors / Appraisal Section
SC Real Estate License
National, State and Local Realtors Association
South Carolina Professional Appraisers Coalition
Appraisal Experience
Over eighteen years as an appraiser with extensive experience appraising various types of
commercial properties. To include commercial, industrial, office and retail uses, c-stores and a
variety of special purposes type properties.
Appraisal Real Estate Education
Uniform Standards, USPAP, 2024-2025
Integrated Approaches to Value, ASFMRA, 2023
Comprehensive Appraisal Overview, Appraisal Institute, 2022
Appraisal of Fast-Food Facilities, 2022
Appraisal of Industrial and Flex Buildings, 2022
Ethics is a Code, 2021
Contract or Effective Rent: Finding the Real Rent, Appraisal Institute, 2021
State of SC Economic Summit, Appraisal Institute, Part 2, 2021
Appraising Convenience Stores, Appraisal Institute, 2020
SCPAC Annual Conference 2020
State of SC Economic Summit, Appraisal Institute, 2020
American Society of Appraisers, Appraisal Review Management 201, 2018
Supervisor-Trainee Course for South Carolina 2016
General Appraiser Report Writing and Case Studies 2016
The Lender Client and the Appraiser 2015
Professional Expectations and Obligations 2015
104
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Certification(s) and Qualification(s)
60
Title Insurance for Real Estate Professionals 2015
Uniform Standards, USPAP, 2005, 2006, 2008, 2010, 2012, 2014, 2016, 2017, 2020, 2021
Liability Issues for Appraisers Performing Litigation 2014
Marketability Studies: Six-Step Process & Basic Applications 2014
Advanced Education Diagnostic Test 2013
Fundamentals of Separating Real Property, 2013
Personal Property and Intangible Business Assets 2012
Square Footage and Other Essential Topics, 2012
Developing, Understanding and Defending Adjustments, 2012
Business Practices and Ethics, AI, 2009, 2011, 2013, 2014, 2020
Advanced Excel, Appraisal Institute, 2011
Residential Design: The Makings of a Good House, AI, 2010
Commercial Appraisal Engagement and Review, 2010
Appraisal Challenges: Declining Markets & Sales Concessions, 2008
Valuation of Conservation Easements, AI, 2008
Eminent Domain, 2006
Applied Income Property Valuation, 2005
Advanced Income Capitalization Procedures, 2005
Introduction to Income Property Appraisal, 2005
Discounted Cash Flow Analysis, 2005
HP-12C Financial Cash Flow, 2004
Applied Residential Property Valuation, 2004
Appraising the Single-Family Residence, 2004
Principles of Real Estate Appraisal, 2004
105
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Addenda
61
Addenda
Addendum A Engagement Letter
Addendum B County Data
Addendum C Listing Report
Addendum D Photographs
Addendum E Flood Map
Addendum F Zoning
Addendum G Septic Tank Permits
106
Item 11.
SC offices in Charleston, Greenville, Greenwood,
Moncks Corner and Walterboro
GA offices in Blackshear, Soperton, and Statesboro
(843) 538-6814 (Main Office)
www.CompassSouthAppraisals.com
October 24, 2024
Open Land Trust
Ms. Kate Schaefer
kate@openlandtrust.org
843-521-2175
Subject property: Widgeon Point; located in Beaufort Co, SC.
R600 007 000 0011 0000 R600 007 000 0008 0000
R600 007 000 001A 0000 R600 007 000 0007 0000
R600 007 000 0010 0000 R600 007 000 0006 0000
R600 007 000 0009 0000 R600 007 000 0005 0000
Dear Ms. Schaefer:
In accordance with your request, we are pleased to submit this proposal for an appraisal
report on the subject property identified above. The proposed report will be prepared and
submitted in accordance with your instructions, subject to the following terms and conditions.
Purpose of the Report
The purpose of this Summary Appraisal Report is to estimate the market value of the fee
simple interest in the subject property in 'as is condition' as of the date of inspection - TBD.
The report is to be used for Market Value.
Fees
Our estimated fee for performing all services necessary to complete this assignment will be
$1,575. Fee is due and payable upon submission of our report. The fee is considered earned
upon receipt of payment(s). This fee does not include additional services beyond the delivery
of the final report.
Due Date
Subject to unforeseen and unavoidable circumstances, our report will be completed and
submitted to you no later than twenty business days following our receipt of your signed
acknowledgement and acceptance of the terms of the terms of this proposal; as well as
107
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Contract for Services
2
additional documents, to include, but not limited to, contracts for sale, options to purchase,
listing reports, maps, aerials, property details, leases, expense reports, rent rolls, and the alike.
Expiration of Agreement
This Agreement is valid only if signed by both Appraiser and Client within three days of the
Date of Agreement specified.
Appraisal Standards and Confidentiality
This report will be prepared and presented in accordance with the requirements of the
Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP), as adopted by the Appraisal
Standards Board of the Appraisal Institute, American Appraisal Society and the rules and
regulations of the state. Appraiser shall not provide a copy of the written Appraisal Report to,
or disclose the results of the appraisal prepared in accordance with this Agreement with, any
party other than Client, unless Client authorizes, except as stipulated in the Confidentiality
Section of the ETHICS RULE of the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice
(USPAP).
Market Value
The subject property will be appraised at 'market value', which is defined as 'the most
probable price which a property should bring in a competitive and open market under all
conditions requisite to a fair sale, the buyer and seller each acting prudently and
knowledgeably, and assuming the price is not affected by undue stimulus. Implicit in this
definition is the consummation of a sale as of a specified date and the passing of title from
seller to buyer under conditions whereby: Buyer and seller are typically motivated; Both
parties are well informed or well advised and acting in what they consider their own best
interests; A reasonable time is allowed for exposure in the open market; Payment is made in
terms of cash in U.S. dollars or in terms of financial arrangements comparable thereto; and The
price represents the normal consideration for the property sold unaffected by special or
creative financing or sales concessions granted by anyone associated with the sale.'
Conditions of Limitation
The report will be made subject to certain general assumptions and limiting conditions that
will be identified in the appraisal report.
In the event our appraisal work reveals the need for an extraordinary assumption or
hypothetical condition it will be identified in the appraisal report.
108
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Contract for Services
3
Extraordinary Assumption and Hypothetical Conditions
An extraordinary assumption is 'an assumption, directly related to a specific an assignment-
specific assumption as of the effective date regarding uncertain information used in an
analysis which, if found to be false, could alter the appraiser’s opinions or conclusions.’
(USPAP 2024-2025) A hypothetical condition is 'a condition, directly related to a specific
assignment, which is contrary to what is known by the appraiser to exist on the effective date
of the assignment results but is used for the purpose of analysis.' (USPAP 2024-2025) There
may be extraordinary assumptions or hypothetical conditions in this report.
Changes to Agreement
Any changes to the assignment as outlined in this Agreement shall necessitate a new
Agreement. The identity of the client, intended users, or intended use; the date of value; type
of value; or property appraised cannot be changed without a new Agreement.
Cancellation
Client may cancel this Agreement at any time prior to the Appraiser’s delivery of the
Appraisal Report upon written notification to the Appraiser. Client shall pay Appraiser for
work completed on assignment prior to Appraiser’s receipt of written cancellation notice,
unless otherwise agreed upon by Appraiser and Client in writing.
No Third-Party Beneficiaries
Nothing in this Agreement shall create a contractual relationship between the Appraiser or the
Client and any third party, or any cause of action in favor of any third party. This Agreement
shall not be construed to render any person or entity a third-party beneficiary of this
Agreement, including, but not limited to, any third parties identified herein.
Limitation of Liability
Customer understands and agrees that if Compass South Appraisals, it’s agents or employees
are found liable for any loss or damage resulting from a failure to perform any of the
obligations under this agreement including, but not limited to negligence, breach of contract,
or otherwise, then the liability of Compass South Appraisals, it’s agents or employees shall be
limited to the amount of the fee paid by Customer.
Arbitration
Resolution of disputes by arbitration – If after the proper notice by Customer, Compass South
Appraisals has re-inspected, evaluated, and addressed any alleged deficiencies in the
performance of the inspection or preparation of the Report; and if the parties cannot reach an
amicable resolution to same, then both parties agree that the subject matter of the dispute shall
be submitted to binding arbitration subject to the rules of American Arbitration Association.
The venue for any dispute resolution shall be in Colleton County, South Carolina. The term
109
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Contract for Services
4
“dispute” includes any dispute as to the deficiency of the inspection, report, or any other duty
of either party arising under this agreement.
Furthermore, the parties agree that should a dispute arise as to any matter herein, the
prevailing party shall be entitled to an award to include all costs associated with the defense of
the case, plus interest and attorney’s fees.
Use of Employees or Independent Contractors
Appraiser may use employees or independent contractors at Appraiser’s discretion to
complete the assignment, unless otherwise agreed by the parties. Notwithstanding, Appraiser
shall sign the written Appraisal Report and take full responsibility for the services provided as
a result of this Agreement.
Testimony at Court of Other Proceedings
Unless otherwise stated in this Agreement, Client agrees that Appraiser’s assignment pursuant
to this Agreement shall not include the Appraiser’s participation in or preparation for,
whether voluntarily or pursuant to subpoena, any oral or written discovery, sworn testimony
in a judicial, arbitration or administrative proceeding, or attendance at any judicial, arbitration,
or administrative proceeding relating to this assignment. Should our participation be involved,
the hourly rate would be $300.00.
Appraisers Independence
Appraiser cannot agree to provide a value opinion that is contingent on a predetermined
amount. Appraiser cannot guarantee the outcome of the assignment in advance. Appraisers
cannot ensure that the opinion of value developed as a result of this Assignment will serve to
facilitate any specific objective by Client or others or advance any particular cause. Appraiser’s
opinion of value will be developed competently and with independence, impartiality and
objectivity.
Governing Law & Jurisdiction
The interpretation and enforcement of this Agreement shall be governed by the laws of the
state in which the Appraiser's principal place of business is located, exclusive of any choice of
law rules.
110
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Contract for Services
5
Thank-you for the opportunity to assist with your real estate appraisal needs. If the preceding
terms and conditions are acceptable, please sign the acknowledgement, below, and return a
signed copy to us.
Yours sincerely,
Travis Lee Avant, ASA, ARM-RP, R/W-AC
SC Certified General Real Estate Appraiser
Brittany Avant McCants, MAI
SC Certified General Appraiser, 7122
Acknowledgement
I have read the terms and conditions of this contract proposal, as set forth above, and both
understand and agree to such terms and conditions.
______________________ ______________________
Signature Date
______________________
Printed Name
111
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Contract for Services
6
Statement of Qualifications of the Appraiser
Travis Lee Avant
ASA -Accredited Senior Appraiser Designation and Appraisal Review RP Designation
Employment History
1983 to 1986 United States Army
1986 to 2000 Law Enforcement, Colleton Co. SC , including six years as elected Sheriff
2000 to 2003 Criminal Investigator, SC Law Enforcement Division -SLED
2003 to 2007 General Appraiser, Hartnett & Co, Charleston, SC
2007 to 2009 Summary Court Magistrate in Colleton County
2011 to 2013 Colleton County Election Commission Board Director
2007 Current- Present founder and co-owner of CSI and principal and team lead appraiser of
Compass South Appraisals
Education
1987 Graduate of Trident Tech College, AS Public Service
1994 Graduate, the F.B.I. National Academy, Quantico, VA
1996 National Sheriff’s Institute Administrators Academy, Colorado
2000 Graduate, The University of South Carolina, AS and Bachelor of Science
Current Business and Professional Affiliations
ASA - Designated Accredited Senior Appraisers and Appraisal Review & Management
ASA - Representative of the Ethics Committee
Board President, Palmetto Rural Telecommunication
Board Director, South Carolina Broad Band Association
Board Director, Executive Committee, SC Palmetto Agribusiness Council
Board Director with a Community Bank
Current State Certified General Real Estate Appraiser License
Active: Alabama, Georgia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee and Virginia – temporary licenses in past – Texas,
Arkansas, Mississippi and Florida.
Brokers Real Estate License
Accredited Buyers Representation - ABR® designee of NAR. Real Estate organization that encourages the highest standard
of ethical business practices.
Appraisal Experience
Twenty years as an appraiser with extensive experience appraising various types of rural and commercial and residential
properties. To include commercial, industrial, office and retail uses, c-stores hotels, residential subdivision and a variety of
special purposes type properties. Experience includes timberland, recreational property, historical plantations, venues, and
agricultural products, such as poultry, and orchards. I have completed over one hundred appraisal assignments involving
conservation and preservation easements.
112
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Contract for Services
7
I have completed over hundreds of eminent domain assignments with litigation experience. Eminent Domain clients include
condemnor and condemnee for property owners, several counties and municipal governments, utility companies and law
firms across South Carolina. I have experience in appraisal review; completed over 100 hours of training with emphasis on
appraisal review training and have experience providing technical, UASFLA and USPAP compliance appraisal reviews. I
have testified as a witness in Federal, State, Family, Master of Equity, Common/Civil and Criminal Court.
Articles and Presentations
Contributor for the TAQEEM appraisal review manual was recently published by the American Society of Appraisers.
TAQEEM is a Saudi Authority for Accredited Valuations for the government of a Middle Eastern country. I have served a
few times as a guest instructor for ASA regarding Appraisal Review courses as well as providing instructions to a few
organizations on the appraisal process.
Appraisal Education
SC Land Use, Seminar Group, 2024
Conservation Easements: Legal, Appraisal, Accounting, and Ethical Issues, Appraisal institute 2023
Business Practice and Ethics, Appraisal institute, 2023
Appraising Environmentally Contaminated Properties, 2023
Conservation Transactions: Legal and Appraisal Matters, SCCB 2022
Comprehensive Appraisal Overview, Appraisal Institute, 2022
Appraisal Review Theory, Appraisal Institute, 2021
Easement Valuation, IRWA, 2021
Supervisory - Trainee Course, 2021
Code of Ethics, IRWA, 2021
Eminent Domain, IRWA, 2020
Comprehensive Appraisal Overview, Appraisal Institute, 2020
Appraisal Review Theory, Appraisal Institute, 2019
Realtors ® Appraisal Code of Ethics, 2018
Cost Approach Certificate, Core Logic, 2018
The Law and Litigation with Eminent Domain, SC Bar, 2018
Uniform Standards, USPAP, every year and current
Eminent Domain and Condemnation, Appraisal Institute, 2018
Expert Witness / Scope of Work / Going Concern, Appraisal Society Appraisers 2017
Forest Valuation II, Appraisal Institute, 2017
Principals of Real Estate Appraisals, IRWA 2017
Uniform Appraisal Standards for Federal Land Acquisitions, 2016, 2017
Ethics and the Right of Way Profession, IRWA, 2016
Appraisal Review Management, Appraisal Society Appraisers, 2015, 2016
Accredited Buyers Representation - ABR® designee, NAR, 2015
Standards of Practice for the Right of Way Professional, IRWA 2015
The Valuation of Partial Acquisitions, IRWA 2015
Real Estate Finance, Statistics Valuation Modeling, Appraisal Institute, 2013
General Appraisal Report Writing and Case Studies, Appraisal Institute, 2013
Hypothetical and Extraordinary Conditions, Appraisal Institute, 2012
Conservation Easements, 2006, 2012, 2013, 2015
Business Practice & Ethics, Appraisal Institute, 2012
Fundamentals of Separating Real Property, 2012
Appraising the Appraiser, Appraisal Institute, 2012
Applied Forest Finance, FORISK, 2010
Advanced Sales and Cost Approach, Appraisal Institute, 2009
113
Item 11.
Compass South Appraisals Contract for Services
8
Advanced Income Capitalization, Appraisal Institute, 2009
Commercial Real Estate Analysis, CCIM, 2006
The Professional Guide to URAR- Secondary Mortgages, 2005
Appraisal Principles, Appraisal Institute, 2005
Discounted Cash Flow, 2004
Applied Income Property Valuation, 2003
Advanced Income Capitalization Procedures, 2003
Introduction to Income Property Appraisal, 2003
Financial Cash Flow, 2003, 2013
Appraising Single family Residences, 2003
Applied Property Valuation Case study 2003
Principals of Real Estate Appraisals, 2003
114
Item 11.
115
Item 11.
Beaufort County, South Carolina generated on 10/28/2024 11:25:18 AM EDT
Property ID (PIN) Alternate ID (AIN) Parcel Address Data refreshed as of Assess Year Pay Year
R600 007 000 001A 0000 00073707 , 10/25/2024 2024 2024
Current Parcel Information
Owner PARKER FAMILY LP
Owner Address PO BOX 457
HAMPTON SC 29924
Property Class Code ResVac Highway & Street ROW
Acreage 13.8600
Legal Description ESMT/POND/MARSH LEMON ISLPB32 P245 PB68 P39 PB68 P73PB94 P174*1.56 ESMT 5.60 AC POND 6.70 AC MARSH SPLIT 8/99 7.95 AC 7/5-11
Historic Information
Tax Year Land Building Market Taxes Payment
2024 $6,900 $6,900 $117.04 $0.00
2023 $6,900 $6,900 $46.06 $46.06
2022 $6,900 $6,900 $44.24 $44.24
2021 $6,900 $6,900 $43.91 $43.91
2020 $6,900 $6,900 $43.42 $43.42
2019 $6,900 $6,900 $43.21 $43.21
2018 $6,900 $6,900 $35.48 $35.48
2017 $6,900 $6,900 $33.73 $33.73
2016 $6,900 $6,900 $33.52 $33.52
2015 $6,900 $6,900 $32.99 $32.99
2014 $6,900 $6,900 $10.81 $10.81
Sales Disclosure
Grantor Book & Page Date Deed Vacant Sale Price
PARKER FAMILY LP 3786 771 8/13/2019 co $10
PARKER FAMILY LP 3192 3221 11/14/2012 De $5
PETERS J ROBERT JR PARKER JOHN E HENDERSON DANIEL E 2918 1299 12/21/2009 Fu $5
PETERS J ROBERT SR 453 1836 6/1/1986 Fu $0
THOMPSON ROBERT THOMAS JR 453 1825 6/1/1986 Fu $157,000
THOMPSON ROBERT THOMAS JR 1985 95 10/1/1985 Ex $0
116
Item 11.
12/31/1776 Or $0
Improvements
Building Type Use Code Description Constructed Year Stories Rooms Square Footage Improvement Size
117
Item 11.
Beaufort County, South Carolina generated on 10/28/2024 11:56:00 AM EDT
Property ID (PIN) Alternate ID (AIN) Parcel Address Data refreshed as of Assess Year Pay Year
R600 007 000 0005 0000 08620049 , 10/25/2024 2024 2024
Current Parcel Information
Owner PARKER FAMILY LP
Owner Address PO BOX 457
HAMPTON SC 29924
Property Class Code ResVac Platted&Unplatted
Acreage 1.2600
Legal Description LOT 1 LEMON ISLAND S/D PB68 P73 LOT LINE REVISED BY PB94 P174
Historic Information
Tax Year Land Building Market Taxes Payment
2024 $146,600 $146,600 $1,963.18 $0.00
2023 $146,600 $146,600 $1,963.20 $1,963.20
2022 $115,000 $115,000 $1,780.22 $1,780.22
2021 $115,000 $115,000 $1,742.96 $1,742.96
2020 $115,000 $115,000 $1,686.38 $1,686.38
2019 $115,000 $115,000 $1,662.23 $1,662.23
2018 $115,000 $115,000 $1,572.02 $1,572.02
2017 $288,700 $288,700 $3,230.12 $3,230.12
2016 $288,700 $288,700 $3,173.71 $3,173.71
2015 $288,700 $288,700 $3,028.32 $3,028.32
2014 $288,700 $288,700 $2,985.27 $2,985.27
Sales Disclosure
Grantor Book & Page Date Deed Vacant Sale Price
Multiple Owners 2918 1284 12/21/2009 Ge $5
PETERS J ROBERT SR PARKER JOHN E HENDERSON DANIEL E 1122 1686 12/31/1998 Fu $59,366
12/31/1776 Or $0
Improvements
Building Type Use Code Description Constructed Year Stories Rooms Square Footage Improvement Size
118
Item 11.
119
Item 11.
Beaufort County, South Carolina generated on 10/28/2024 11:51:10 AM EDT
Property ID (PIN) Alternate ID (AIN) Parcel Address Data refreshed as of Assess Year Pay Year
R600 007 000 0006 0000 08620058 , 10/25/2024 2024 2024
Current Parcel Information
Owner SUSAN P HENDERSON REV TRUST
Owner Address PO BOX 2500
RIDGELAND SC 29936
Property Class Code ResVac Platted&Unplatted
Acreage .9300
Legal Description LOT 2 LEMON ISLAND S/D PB68 P73 LOT LINE REVISED BY PB94 P174
Historic Information
Tax Year Land Building Market Taxes Payment
2024 $90,800 $90,800 $1,225.06 $0.00
2023 $90,800 $90,800 $1,225.05 $1,225.05
2022 $71,200 $71,200 $1,112.72 $1,112.72
2021 $71,200 $71,200 $1,089.66 $1,089.66
2020 $71,200 $71,200 $1,054.66 $1,054.66
2019 $71,200 $71,200 $1,039.72 $1,039.72
2018 $71,200 $71,200 $981.22 $981.22
2017 $301,400 $301,400 $2,503.66 $2,503.66
2016 $301,400 $301,400 $2,460.04 $2,460.04
2015 $301,400 $301,400 $2,347.56 $2,347.56
2014 $301,400 $301,400 $2,307.88 $2,307.88
Sales Disclosure
Grantor Book & Page Date Deed Vacant Sale Price
SUSAN HENDERSON REVOC TRUST 3902 693 8/25/2020 co $5
HENDERSON SUSAN P 3195 199 11/14/2012 De $5
PETERS J ROBERT SR PARKER JOHN E HENDERSON DANIEL E 1122 1691 12/31/1998 Fu $59,366
HENDERSON DANIEL E 1122 1706 12/31/1998 Fu $5
12/31/1776 Or $0
120
Item 11.
Improvements
Building Type Use Code Description Constructed Year Stories Rooms Square Footage Improvement Size
121
Item 11.
Beaufort County, South Carolina generated on 10/28/2024 11:37:28 AM EDT
Property ID (PIN) Alternate ID (AIN) Parcel Address Data refreshed as of Assess Year Pay Year
R600 007 000 0007 0000 08620067 , 10/25/2024 2024 2024
Current Parcel Information
Owner DANIEL E HENDERSON REV TRUST
Owner Address PO BOX 2500
RIDGELAND SC 29936
Property Class Code ResVac Platted&Unplatted
Acreage .8800
Legal Description LOT 3 LEMON ISLAND S/D PB68 P73 LOT LINE REVISED BY PB94 P174
Historic Information
Tax Year Land Building Market Taxes Payment
2024 $89,800 $89,800 $1,212.90 $0.00
2023 $89,800 $89,800 $1,212.88 $1,212.88
2022 $70,400 $70,400 $1,100.04 $1,100.04
2021 $70,400 $70,400 $1,077.25 $1,077.25
2020 $70,400 $70,400 $1,042.65 $1,042.65
2019 $70,400 $70,400 $1,027.87 $1,027.87
2018 $70,400 $70,400 $969.99 $969.99
2017 $301,900 $301,900 $2,475.54 $2,475.54
2016 $301,900 $301,900 $2,432.41 $2,432.41
2015 $301,900 $301,900 $2,321.21 $2,321.21
2014 $301,900 $301,900 $2,280.96 $2,280.96
Sales Disclosure
Grantor Book & Page Date Deed Vacant Sale Price
DANIEL E HENDERSON REVOC TRUST 3786 771 8/13/2019 co $10
HENDERSON DANIEL E 3192 3221 11/14/2012 De $5
PETERS J ROBERT SR PARKER JOHN E HENDERSON DANIEL E 1122 1691 12/31/1998 Fu $5
12/31/1776 Or $0
Improvements
122
Item 11.
Building Type Use Code Description Constructed Year Stories Rooms Square Footage Improvement Size
123
Item 11.
Beaufort County, South Carolina generated on 10/28/2024 11:35:24 AM EDT
Property ID (PIN) Alternate ID (AIN) Parcel Address Data refreshed as of Assess Year Pay Year
R600 007 000 0008 0000 08620076 7 OKATIE HWY , 10/25/2024 2024 2024
Current Parcel Information
Owner ELLEN B PETERS IRREVOC TRUST AGRMT
Owner Address 212 HARRIET ST
HAMPTON SC 29924
Property Class Code ResVac Platted&Unplatted
Acreage .9100
Legal Description LOT 4 LEMON ISLAND S/D PB68 P73 LOT LINE REVISED BY PB94 P174
Historic Information
Tax Year Land Building Market Taxes Payment
2024 $95,900 $95,900 $1,293.30 $0.00
2023 $95,900 $95,900 $1,293.31 $1,293.31
2022 $75,200 $75,200 $1,173.65 $1,173.65
2021 $75,200 $75,200 $1,149.29 $1,149.29
2020 $75,200 $75,200 $1,112.31 $1,112.31
2019 $75,200 $75,200 $1,096.53 $1,096.53
2018 $75,200 $75,200 $1,035.13 $1,035.13
2017 $298,900 $298,900 $2,644.26 $2,644.26
2016 $298,900 $298,900 $2,598.16 $2,598.16
2015 $298,900 $298,900 $2,479.32 $2,479.32
2014 $298,900 $298,900 $2,437.53 $2,437.53
Sales Disclosure
Grantor Book & Page Date Deed Vacant Sale Price
PETERS ELLEN B 3203 2045 12/31/2012 De $5
PETERS J ROBERT SR PARKER JOHN E HENDERSON DANIEL E 1122 1681 12/31/1998 Fu $59,366
PETERS J ROBERT JR 1122 1696 12/31/1998 Fu $5
12/31/1776 Or $0
Improvements
124
Item 11.
Building Type Use Code Description Constructed Year Stories Rooms Square Footage Improvement Size
125
Item 11.
Beaufort County, South Carolina generated on 10/28/2024 11:32:57 AM EDT
Property ID (PIN) Alternate ID (AIN) Parcel Address Data refreshed as of Assess Year Pay Year
R600 007 000 0009 0000 08620085 , 10/25/2024 2024 2024
Current Parcel Information
Owner PETERS JOHN ROBERT III SWEENY KATHLEEN ELIZABETH
Owner Address 103 EDISTO DR
HAMPTON SC 29924
Property Class Code ResVac Platted&Unplatted
Acreage .9300
Legal Description LOT 5 LEMON ISLAND S/D PB68 P73 LOT LINE REVISED BY PB94 P174
Historic Information
Tax Year Land Building Market Taxes Payment
2024 $92,800 $92,800 $1,251.88 $0.00
2023 $92,800 $92,800 $1,251.89 $1,251.89
2022 $72,800 $72,800 $1,138.10 $1,138.10
2021 $72,800 $72,800 $1,114.50 $1,114.50
2020 $72,800 $72,800 $1,078.68 $1,078.68
2019 $72,800 $72,800 $1,063.39 $1,063.39
2018 $72,800 $72,800 $1,003.68 $1,003.68
2017 $300,400 $300,400 $2,559.90 $2,559.90
2016 $300,400 $300,400 $2,515.29 $2,515.29
2015 $300,400 $300,400 $2,400.28 $2,400.28
2014 $300,400 $300,400 $2,359.76 $2,359.76
Sales Disclosure
Grantor Book & Page Date Deed Vacant Sale Price
PETERS JUDITH 4044 3047 7/30/2021 co $0
PETERS J ROBERT JR %ELLEN B PETERS 2793 2353 12/17/2008 Ex $0
PETERS J ROBERT SR PARKER JOHN E HENDERSON DANIEL E 1122 1681 12/31/1998 Fu $5
12/31/1776 Or $0
Improvements
126
Item 11.
Building Type Use Code Description Constructed Year Stories Rooms Square Footage Improvement Size
127
Item 11.
Beaufort County, South Carolina generated on 10/28/2024 11:27:10 AM EDT
Property ID (PIN) Alternate ID (AIN) Parcel Address Data refreshed as of Assess Year Pay Year
R600 007 000 0010 0000 08620094 , 10/25/2024 2024 2024
Current Parcel Information
Owner PARKER FAMILY LP
Owner Address PO BOX 457
HAMPTON SC 29924
Property Class Code ResVac Platted&Unplatted
Acreage 1.1600
Legal Description LOT 6 LEMON ISLAND S/D PB68 P73 LOT LINE REVISED BY PB94 P174
Historic Information
Tax Year Land Building Market Taxes Payment
2024 $126,800 $126,800 $1,700.10 $0.00
2023 $126,800 $126,800 $1,700.08 $1,700.08
2022 $99,400 $99,400 $1,541.66 $1,541.66
2021 $99,400 $99,400 $1,509.47 $1,509.47
2020 $99,400 $99,400 $1,460.60 $1,460.60
2019 $99,400 $99,400 $1,439.74 $1,439.74
2018 $99,400 $99,400 $1,360.86 $1,360.86
2017 $289,600 $289,600 $3,173.88 $3,173.88
2016 $289,600 $289,600 $3,118.48 $3,118.48
2015 $289,600 $289,600 $2,975.64 $2,975.64
2014 $289,600 $289,600 $2,930.93 $2,930.93
Sales Disclosure
Grantor Book & Page Date Deed Vacant Sale Price
PARKER MARGARET S 2918 1278 12/21/2009 Ge $5
PARKER JOHN E 1122 1701 12/31/1998 Ge $5
PETERS J ROBERT SR PARKER JOHN E HENDERSON DANIEL E 1122 1686 12/31/1998 Fu $5
12/31/1776 Or $0
Improvements
128
Item 11.
Building Type Use Code Description Constructed Year Stories Rooms Square Footage Improvement Size
129
Item 11.
Beaufort County, South Carolina generated on 10/28/2024 11:23:28 AM EDT
Property ID (PIN) Alternate ID (AIN) Parcel Address Data refreshed as of Assess Year Pay Year
R600 007 000 0011 0000 08620101 , 10/25/2024 2024 2024
Current Parcel Information
Owner PARKER FAMILY LP
Owner Address PO BOX 457
HAMPTON SC 29924
Property Class Code ResVac Platted&Unplatted
Acreage 2.0500
Legal Description LOT 7 LEMON ISLAND S/D PB68 P73 LOT LINE REVISED BY PB94 P174
Historic Information
Tax Year Land Building Market Taxes Payment
2024 $209,100 $209,100 $2,041.48 $0.00
2023 $209,100 $209,100 $1,975.50 $1,975.50
2022 $164,000 $164,000 $1,792.85 $1,792.85
2021 $164,000 $164,000 $1,755.43 $1,755.43
2020 $164,000 $164,000 $1,698.59 $1,698.59
2019 $164,000 $164,000 $1,674.34 $1,674.34
2018 $164,000 $164,000 $1,583.75 $1,583.75
2017 $100,500 $100,500 $1,440.07 $1,440.07
2016 $100,500 $100,500 $1,415.23 $1,415.23
2015 $100,500 $100,500 $1,351.19 $1,351.19
2014 $100,500 $100,500 $1,347.01 $1,347.01
Sales Disclosure
Grantor Book & Page Date Deed Vacant Sale Price
PARKER FAMILY LP 3786 771 8/13/2019 co $10
Multiple Owners 3192 3221 11/14/2012 De $5
PETERS JUDITH 2918 1299 12/21/2009 Fu $5
PETERS J ROBERT JR PARKER JOHN E HENDERSON DANIEL E 2793 2353 12/17/2008 Ex $0
12/31/1776 Or $0
UNKNOWN OWNER 08620101 12/31/1776 Or $0
130
Item 11.
Improvements
Building Type Use Code Description Constructed Year Stories Rooms Square Footage Improvement Size
131
Item 11.
132
Item 11.
133
Item 11.
134
Item 11.
135
Item 11.
136
Item 11.
137
Item 11.
138
Item 11.
139
Item 11.
140
Item 11.
141
Item 11.
142
Item 11.
143
Item 11.
144
Item 11.
145
Item 11.
146
Item 11.
147
Item 11.
148
Item 11.
149
Item 11.
150
Item 11.
151
Item 11.
152
Item 11.
153
Item 11.
154
Item 11.
155
Item 11.
156
Item 11.
157
Item 11.
158
Item 11.
159
Item 11.
160
Item 11.
161
Item 11.
162
Item 11.
163
Item 11.
164
Item 11.
165
Item 11.
166
Item 11.
Land - Active Private Report 7 Okatie Highway , Okatie, SC 29909 MLS #: 183103 LP: $3,500,000
Sub-Type: Resident S/D Lot
Major Area: Okatie
Minor Area: Lemon Island
Unit/Apt/Bldg #:
County: Beaufort
Apx. Acres: 21.98
Sale/Rent: For Sale
Community:
Waterfront: Deep Water/Limited
Access
Dock: Not Applicable
Boat Slip:
Lot Dim: 21.98
Zoning: Residential
Directions: From Beaufort take Hwy 170 over Broad River Bridge. Property at first gate on left after crossing bridge.
Remarks: Beautiful One of a KIND peninsula that is surrounded on all sides by water. Located on Lemon Island facing the Broad River Bridge with
approximately 10 acre saltwater pond on backside of property. Subdivided into 7 lots. Half of property on Broad River.
Private Remarks: Buyer to verify acreage. EMD to be held by closing attroney. Listed Lots: R600-007-000-0006, 0007, 0009, 0010, 0011, 001A, 0005.
Shared Interest Y/N: No
Lot SqFt: 957,449
List Price Sqft:
List Price/Acre: $159,235.67
Dock Permits in Hand:
Covenant: No
Rental Duration: None
Aicuz: No
Olrea/B: No
Bank Owned: No
Foreclosure: No
Short Sale: No
Sign: Yes
View Desc.:
Property
Taxes:
Tax Database
ID:
R600-007-000-0008-0000
Legal Desc: LOT 4 LEMON ISLAND S/D PB68 P73 LOT LINE REVISED
BY PB94 P174
Key Code #: 08620076
D-M-P-R:
Acre Range: 10 - 50
Documents on File: Legal Description; Survey
Flood Insurance: Status Unknown
Imp/W/House/MH: No
Lot Location: Deep Water; Marsh/Water; Pond/Lake; Tidal/Creek
Possession: At Closing
Road Frontage: Highway
Road Service: Asphalt
Showing Inst.: Appt Only
Surface Water: Pond(s)
Topography: Partially Wooded
Utilities Available: Electricity Available; Public Water; Septic
Vacancy: Vacant
Will Sell: Cash; Conventional
HOA/POA Fee: No
HOA Fee:
HOA Fee Contact Info:
Regime Fee: No
Regime Fee Amount:
Regime Fee Contact Info:
Transfer Fee: No
Transfer Fee Amount:
Transfer Fee Contact:
Name Office Primary Office E-mail
Listing Member: William Charles Anderson ERA Evergreen Real Estate Co 843-379-2411 843-379-2411 beaufortlistings@gmail.com
Original List Price: $5,000,000
Current Price: $3,500,000
Sold Price/Acre:
List Date: 12/05/2023 ADOM/CDOM: 347/347
Paid Cl:
Paid Poi:
Information is deemed to be reliable, but is not guaranteed. © 2024 MLS and FBS. Prepared by Aubrey Hill on Friday, November 15, 2024 12:38 PM. The information on this
sheet has been made available by the MLS and may not be the listing of the provider.
flexmls Web https://bmls.flexmls.com/cgi-bin/mainmenu.cgi
1 of 2 11/15/2024, 12:38 PM
167
Item 11.
History for MLS # 183103 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 $3,500,000
+ MLS # Status Price
%
Change Date DOM CDOM Address Begin Date
Original List
Price
+ 183103 Active $3,500,000 12/06/2023 347 347 7 Okatie Highway 12/05/2023 $5,000,000
flexmls Web https://bmls.flexmls.com/cgi-bin/mainmenu.cgi
2 of 2 11/15/2024, 12:38 PM
168
Item 11.
169
Item 11.
170
Item 11.
Division 3.2: Transect Zones
T1 Natural Preserve
3-16 Beaufort County Community Development Code
3.2.30 T1 Natural Preserve (T1) Standards
General note: the illustrations above are intended to provide a brief overview of the transect zone and are descriptive in nature.
A. Purpose
The Natural Preserve (T1) Zone is intended to preserve
areas that contain sensitive habitats, open space, and limited
agricultural uses. This Zone typically does not contain
buildings; however, single-family dwellings, small civic
buildings or interpretive centers may be located within this
zone.
171
Item 11.
Division 3.2: Transect Zones
T1 Natural Preserve
Beaufort County Community Development Code 3-17
B
B. Building Placement C. Building Form
Setback (Distance from ROW/Property Line) Building Height
Front 50’ min. Main Building 35 feet / 2
stories max. Side Street 50’ min.
Side: Ancillary Building 35 feet / 2
stories max.
Side, Main Building 50’ min.
Side, Ancillary Building 20’ min. Ground Floor Finish Level1 No minimum
Rear 100’ min. Footprint
Lot Size (One Acre Minimum) Maximum Lot Coverage n/a
Width n/a Lot coverage is the portion of a lot that is covered by
Depth n/a any and all buildings including accessory buildings.
Miscellaneous Notes
Where existing adjacent buildings are in front of the 1Buildings located in a flood hazard zone will be required
regulated BTL or front setback, the building may be set to to be built above base flood elevation in
align with the façade of the front-most immediately accordance with Beaufort County Building Codes
adjacent property. D. Gross Density2
Gross Density 0.1 d.u./acre
2Gross Density is the total number of dwelling units
on a site divided by the Base Site Area (Division 6.1.40.F)
172
Item 11.
Division 3.2: Transect Zones
T1 Natural Preserve
3-18 Beaufort County Community Development Code
E. T1 Allowed Uses
Land Use Type1 Specific Use
Regulations T1
Agricultural
Agriculture & Crop Harvesting P
Forestry P
Residential
Dwelling: Single Family Detached
Unit
P
Dwelling: Group Home P
Home Office 4.2.90 C
Recreation, Education, Safety , Public
Assembly
Park, Playground, Outdoor
Recreation Areas
2.8 P
Recreation Facility: Campground 4.1.190 S
Ecotourism 4.1.330 S
Key
P Permitted Use
C Conditional Use
S Special Use Permit Required
--- Use Not Allowed
End Notes
1 A definition of each listed use type is in Table 3.1.70 Land
Use Definitions.
173
Item 11.
174
Item 11.
175
Item 11.
176
Item 11.
177
Item 11.
178
Item 11.
179
Item 11.
180
Item 11.
181
Item 11.
182
Item 11.
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment
North Widgeon
7 Okatie Highway
Okatie, SC 29909
Beaufort County TMS # GIS Acres Owner
R600 007 000 0005 0000 1.26 Parker Family LP
R600 007 000 0006 0000 0.93 Susan P Henderson Rev Trust
R600 007 000 0007 0000 0.88 Daniel E Henderson Rev Trust
R600 007 000 0008 0000 0.91 Peter & Sweeny
R600 007 000 0009 0000 0.93 Peter & Sweeny
R600 007 000 0010 0000 1.16 Parker Family LP
R600 007 000 0011 0000 2.05 Parker Family LP
R600 007 000 001A 0000 1.43 Parker Family LP
Total GIS Acres 9.55
Submitted to and for the Use of:
Open Land Trust
PO Box 75
Beaufort, SC 29901
Submitted by:
SRC Environmental
108 Charping Lane
Anderson, SC 29621
Submittal Date: March 5, 2025
183
Item 11.
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
March 5, 2025
Open Land Trust
Attn: Ms. Kate Schaefer
448 W. Cheves Street
Beaufort, SC 29901
Re: North Widgeon
7 Okatie Highway
Okatie, SC 29909
Ms. Schaefer:
Thank you for the opportunity to provide environmental services for you. It is our commitment to
provide our clients with the most efficient, timely, and cost -effective approach to environmental
issues.
As requested, SRC, Inc. has completed a current Phase I Environmental Site Assessment for the
subject property that consists of 8 contiguous parcels totaling 9.55 GIS acres, and is located at 7
Okatie Highway in Okatie, SC. The current Phase I was designed to meet the standards and
guidelines of the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM E1527 -21), including All
Appropriate Inquiry (AAI) while providing an environmental site assessment of the project site.
The enclosed Phase I ESA was prepared for the exclusive use of the Open Land Trust, and/or
their Assigns, for use in the assessment and evaluation of the environmental condition of the
subject property at the time the report was completed based on reasonably ascertainable
information, and within the scope and limitations of the ASTM E1527-21 guidelines.
The current Phase I ESA, in conformance with the scope and limitations of ASTM
guidelines, has revealed no evidence of existing or historical recognized environmental
conditions (RECs) associated with the site, or adjacent sites. No further investigation is
recommended.
SRC welcomes the opportunity to serve you. If you have any questions, or require any additional
information, please feel free to contact me at 864-376-2864.
Sincerely,
Michael Whaley
President
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
Enclosures
184
Item 11.
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Section Subject Page
1.0 Executive Summary 1
2.0 Introduction 2
2.1 Purpose 2
2.2 Detailed Scope-of-Services 2
2.3 Significant Assumptions 3
2.4 Limitations and Expectations 3
2.5 Special Terms and Conditions 4
2.6 User Reliance 4
3.0 Subject Property Description 5
3.1 Location and Legal Description 5
3.2 Subject property and Vicinity General Characteristics 5
3.3 Current Use of Property 6
3.4 Description of Structures, Roads, Other Improvements 6
3.5 Current Uses of the Adjoining Properties 6
4.0 User Provided Description 7
4.1 Title Records 7
4.2 Environmental Liens or Activity and Use Limitations 8
4.3 Specialized Knowledge 8
4.4 Commonly Known or Reasonably Ascertainable Information 8
4.5 Valuation Reduction for Environmental Issues 8
4.6 Owner, Property Manager, and Occupant Information 8
4.7 Reason for Performing Phase I 9
4.8 Other 9
5.0 Records Review 10
5.1 Standard Environmental Record Sources 10
5.2 Additional Environmental Record Sources 10
5.3 Physical Setting Sources 10
5.4 Historical Use Information on the Property 10
5.5 Historical Use Information on Surrounding Properties 10
6.0 Subject Property Reconnaissance 11
6.1 Methodology and Limiting Conditions 11
6.2 General Site Setting 11
6.3 Exterior Observations 12
6.4 Interior Observations 13
185
Item 11.
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
Section Subject Page
7.0 Interviews 14
7.1 Interview with Owner 14
7.2 Interview with Site Manager 14
7.3 Interviews with Occupants 14
7.4 Interviews with Local Government Officials 14
7.5 Interviews with Others 14
8.0 Additional Services/Non-Scope Considerations 15
9.0 Findings 16
9.1 Federal RCRA Generators List 17
9.2 Toxic Release Inventory (TRI) List 18
9.3 Leaking Underground Storage Tank (LUST) 19
9.4 Underground Storage Tank (UST) 20
9.5 SC Drycleaners List 21
9.6 Historical Cleaners 22
10.0 Opinion 24
11.0 Data Gaps 24
12.0 Conclusions 24
13.0 Deviations 24
14.0 References 25
15.0 Signature of Environmental Professional 25
16.0 Qualifications of Environmental Professional 26
Appendix A: Figure 1: Location Map
Appendix B: Figure 2: Topographical Maps
Appendix C: Figures 3A, 3B & 3C: Historical Aerials
Appendix D: Figure 4: Wetlands Map
Appendix E: Figure 5: Soils Map
Appendix F: Site Photographs
Appendix G: NETR Background Database Report
Appendix H: Deed Information and Title Insurance (if available)
Appendix I: Property Documents
Appendix J: Questionnaire
186
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 1
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This Phase I Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) by Southeastern Regulatory
Compliance, Inc. (SRC) is designed to identify existing historical, visual, or physical
evidence of recognized environmental conditions ( RECs), historical recognized
environmental conditions (H RECs), controlled recognized environmental conditions
(CRECs), or potential risks at the North Widgeon site located at 7 Okatie Highway in
Okatie, SC. The subject property consists of 8 contiguous parcels totaling 9.55 GIS acres.
The subject property is an island with vegetation consisting of live oaks, palmettos, and
loblolly pines that are representative of a maritime forest. Observed wildlife included a
bald eagle, an eastern diamondback rattlesnake, raccoons, and white-tailed deer. Aerial
photography dating back to 195 1 and topographic maps back to 19 20 sourced from
www.historicaerials.com were reviewed and did not in dicate any signs of habitation,
agriculture, or logging operations. However, bricks an d mortar were observed on the
southeastern side of the island during the on-site inspection. Some debris that was likely
deposited by high tides was also observed.
Mr. Michael Whaley , Environmental Professional (EP) of SRC , conducted the on -site
inspection on February 28, 2025 . The inspection of the subject property and directly
adjacent sites did not visually or physically identify sources of improper use, treatment,
storage, generation, or disposal of hazardous substances that resulted in environmental
contamination of the subject property . No sources of surface contamination were
physically observed. There were no leaking drums or containers visually or physically
observed which might contain hazardous substances. There were no strong or pungent
odors associated with the subject property that would indicate the presence of additional
hazardous substances.
Current and past use of the subject property did not indicate sources of environmental
contamination that have had an adverse environmental impact on the subject property.
No current or past uses of directly adjacent properties appear to have involved the use,
treatment, storage, or disposal of hazardous materials that resulted in environmental
contamination of the subject property. There were no limitations or significant data gaps
encountered during this investigation that are considered to have hindered SRC’s ability
to evaluate or identify recognized environmental conditions associated with the subject
property.
In the ESA, review s of pertinent Federal and State records regarding the potential
environmental concerns include but are not limited to: NPL Listings, RCRA CORRACTS
and RCRA Permitted TSD Facility Listings, CERCLIS/NFRAP Listings, ERNS Listings,
State Equivalent SPL Listin gs, Registered UST and LUST Facilities, State Waste
Landfills, Incinerators, or Transfer Stations Listings, and RCRA Generators Listings. The
Federal and State environmental databases did not indicate the presence of current
facilities or sites located within a 1-mile radius of the subject property.
187
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 2
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
2.0 INTRODUCTION
2.1 Purpose
Ms. Kate Schaefer, of the Open Land Trust, requested that SRC conduct this ESA for the
subject property. This ESA was conducted to determine the potential for environmental
impact to the subject property and is intended to fulfill the due diligence clause of the
“innocent landowner defense” and “bona fide prospective buyer” clause of the
Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA).
2.2 Detailed Scope-of-Services
This ESA was conducted in general accordance with the guidelines set forth in the
American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) Standard E 1527-21, “Standard
Practice for Environmental Site Assessments: Phase I Environmental Site Assessment
Process,” and consisted of the tasks listed below.
• Inspections of the subject property and surrounding properties
• Examination of historical documents
• Interviews with individuals and public officials familiar with the site’s history
• Examination of State and Federal regulatory agency records
The purpose of the assessment was to identify Recognized Environmental Conditions
(RECs) connected to the subject property.
• A REC is defined as the presence of hazardous substances or petroleum
products in, on or at the subject property due to a release to the environment; (2)
the likely presence of hazardous substances or petroleum products in, on or at the
subject property due to a release or li kely release to the environment; or (3) the
presence of hazardous substances or petroleum products in, on or at the subject
property under conditions that pose a material threat of a future release to the
environment.
• An Historical REC (HREC) is defined as a previous release of hazardous
substances or petroleum products affecting the subject property that has been
addressed to the satisfaction of the applicable regulatory authority or authorities
and meeting unrestricted use criteria established by the applicable regulatory
authority or authorities, without subjecting the property to any controls (for example
activity and use limitations, or other property use limitations).
• A controlled REC (CREC) is a REC affecting the subject property that has been
addressed to the satisfaction of the applicable regulatory authority or authorities
with hazardous substances or petroleum products allowed to remain in place
subject to implementation of required controls (for example, activity and use
limitations or other property use limitations).
• De minimis conditions are conditions a condition related to a release that
generally does not present a threat to human health or the environment and that
generally would not be the subject of an enforcement action if brought to the
attention of appropriate governmental agencies.
188
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 3
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
• A business environmental risk (BER) is the presence of a condition which can
have a material environmental impact that is not the result of those environmental
issues required to be investigated in ASTM E1527-21 practice. BERs often involve
non-scope considerations such as: asbestos, lead paint, lead in drinking water,
radon, wetlands, ecological resources, endangered species, cultural and historic
resources, regulatory compliance, industrial hygiene, health and safety, indoor air
quality, biological agents, and mold.
• De minimis conditions and BERs are not considered RECs and were not
addressed during this ESA and were beyond the defined scope of work.
ASTM standards attempt to facilitate high quality, standardized environmental site
assessments; ensure that the standard of appropriate inquiry is practical and reasonable;
and clarify industry standards for appropriate inquiry. The ESA should provide: a Federal
and State regulatory records review which may help to identify recognized environmental
conditions; a site background description, which includes a history of previous uses of the
property and adjoining properties which describes recognized environ mental conditions;
an on-site inspection which evaluates the environmental setting and existence of potential
hazardous substances, petroleum products, storage tanks, PCBs, waste disposal;
interviews; and findings and conclusions. In addition, SRC provides non-scope services
including wetland review, lead-based paints, asbestos, and other contamination sources
and conditions of concern in connection with the property only upon request.
2.3 Significant Assumptions
Conclusions regarding the potential environmental impact of nearby, off -site facilities on
the subject property are based on readily available information from the environmental
databases and geologic and hydrogeologic conditions reported for the subject property
vicinity. As a basis for the conclusions regarding adjacent and nearby contaminated
properties, we have assumed the surface -water flow and groundwater flow directions to
be generally in the down -gradient direction of the surface topography, which was
determined from our field observations, review of available topographic maps, and use of
NETR. In respect to the migration of vapors resulting from volatile organic compounds
released to the environment, we have assumed that vapor may migrate in any vertical or
horizontal direction depending on geological and hydrogeological as well as man -made
conditions in the area of the subject property. There were no significant data gaps that
interfered with the Environmental Professional’s ability to properly perform the site
assessment.
2.4 Limitations and Exceptions
The application of the ASTM guidelines is limited to certain environmental conditions that
may exist on the property and are practically reviewable. This approach is site-specific
in that it relates to the assessment of recognized environmental conditions on a specific
parcel of commercial real estate. As such, this practice does not specifically address
additional issues in the transaction such as business entities or as sets that may involve
environmental liabilities. No ESA can wholly eliminate uncertainty regarding the potential
for recognized environmental conditions in connection with a parcel. However, proper
application is intended to reduce this uncertainty. Appropriate inquiry does not imply
189
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 4
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
exhaustive assessment of clean property as there is a point at which the cost of information
obtained, or the time required to gather it outweighs the usefulness of the information.
Finally, the ESA is limited by the extent of physical obstructions including existing structures,
ecological barriers, buildings, asphalt, and other paved sites, as well as availability of
appropriate land use records. As such, there may be certain environmental conditions that
could not be identified within the general scope of the Phase I Environmental Site
Assessment. The current ESA should be considered comprehensive and reliable in its scope
within the limitations described above and is valid for a p eriod of 180 days from the date of
the report, or a 1 -year time period if five specific components (interviews, searches for
recorded environmental cleanup liens, review of government records, site reconnaissance of
the subject property, and the Environmental Professional (EP) Declaration) are updated. The
180 day or 1-year time period begins with the date upon which the first of these components
was completed.
2.5 Special Terms and Conditions
The specific terms and conditions referenced in this report are consistent with the general
reference, use and definitions provided in the ASTM E1527-21 Standard Practice.
2.6 User Reliance
Based on the ASTM guidelines, an environmental professional is not required to verify
independently the information provided but may rely on information provided unless he or she
has actual knowledge that certain information is incorrect, or unless it is obvious that certain
information is incorrect based on other information obtained in the Phase I Environmental
Site Assessment, or actually known to the environmental professional.
The current Phase I Environmental Site Assessment was prepared under the guidelines
provided by ASTM. The results of the records review, on -site inspection, and interviews are
considered to be reliable within the general limitations described by ASTM guidelines. The
records review, on-site inspection, and interviews were conducted in concert with each other
and support the findings and conclusions. Since there is no knowledge or reason to believe
that any of the information is incorrect, SRC has concluded that the current ESA is reliable
within the general limitations described in ASTM guidelines and is valid for a period of 180
days from the date of the report.
This report entitled “Phase I Environmental Site Assessment,” has been prepared at the
request of Ms. Kate Schaefer and for the exclusive use of:
Open Land Trust
448 W. Cheves Street
Beaufort, SC 29901
- and/or their assigns -
Reliance cannot be transferred without the permission of the above, and only if the other party
agrees to the same limitations.
190
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 5
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
3.0 TRACT DESCRIPTION
3.1 Location and Legal Description
The subject property consists of 8 contiguous parcels totaling 9.55 GIS acres.
Beaufort County TMS # GIS Acres Owner
R600 007 000 0005 0000 1.26 Parker Family LP
R600 007 000 0006 0000 0.93 Susan P Henderson Rev Trust
R600 007 000 0007 0000 0.88 Daniel E Henderson Rev Trust
R600 007 000 0008 0000 0.91 Peter & Sweeny
R600 007 000 0009 0000 0.93 Peter & Sweeny
R600 007 000 0010 0000 1.16 Parker Family LP
R600 007 000 0011 0000 2.05 Parker Family LP
R600 007 000 001A 0000 1.43 Parker Family LP
Total GIS Acres 9.55
The location of this subject property is shown in Figure 1, which contains screenshots
from LandID. Figure 2 contains excerpts from the 1958, and 2020 United States Geologic
Survey (USGS) 7.5 -minute quadrangle map s (Spring Island & Laurel B ay, SC
quadrangles) in Beaufort County, South Carolina.
3.2 Subject Property and Vicinity General Characteristics
The subject property and vicinity are those of maritime forest along the South Carolina
coast.
191
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 6
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
3.3 Current Use of the Subject Property
The subject property is used for recreational purposes that include hunting activities.
3.4 Descriptions of Structures, Roads, Other Improvements on the Subject
Property
The only improvements include a grass surfaced track that allows entrance to the subject
property.
3.5 Current Uses of the Adjoining Properties
The island is surrounded in all directions by wetlands.
There are no recognized environmental conditions (RECs) associated with the adjacent
sites.
192
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 7
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
4.0 USER PROVIDED INFORMATION
4.1 Title Records
Title information was collected from the Beaufort County Assessor’s Office. The current
owners are listed as:
Beaufort County TMS #
GIS
Acres Owner Address City State Zip Code
R600 007 000 0005 0000 1.26 Parker Family LP PO Box 457 Hampton SC 29924
R600 007 000 0006 0000 0.93
Susan P
Henderson Rev
Trust PO Box 2500 Ridgeland SC 29936
R600 007 000 0007 0000 0.88
Daniel E
Henderson Rev
Trust PO Box 2500 Ridgeland SC 29936
R600 007 000 0008 0000 0.91 Peter & Sweeny 103 Edisto Drive Hampton SC 29924
R600 007 000 0009 0000 0.93 Peter & Sweeny 103 Edisto Drive Hampton SC 29924
R600 007 000 0010 0000 1.16 Parker Family LP PO Box 457 Hampton SC 29924
R600 007 000 0011 0000 2.05 Parker Family LP PO Box 457 Hampton SC 29924
R600 007 000 001A 0000 1.43 Parker Family LP PO Box 457 Hampton SC 29924
Total GIS Acres 9.55
193
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 8
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
4.2 Environmental Liens or Activity and Use Limitations
Legal or physical restrictions are often in place on contaminated properties. These
restrictions, which may include institutional and/or engineering controls, are intended to
prevent adverse impacts to individuals or populations that may be exposed to hazardous
substances and petroleum products in the soil, soil vapor, groundwater, and/or surface
water on an environmentally impacted property.
There were no legal or physical restrictions or limitations on the use of, or access to, the
subject property identified during this ESA. Available county electronic and hardcopy real
property files were searched for land use restrictions, environmental liens, or similar
documents concerning the subject property. No such documents were identified during
this assessment. The Superfund Lien database was searched during this assessment,
and the subject property was not listed.
4.3 Specialized Knowledge
No known specialized knowledge has been transferred to the environmental professional.
The purchase price being paid for this property reasonably reflects the fair market value.
4.4 Commonly Known or Reasonably Ascertainable Information
The user provided commonly known or reasonable ascertainable information that would
assist SRC with identifying conditions indicative of RECs in connection with the property.
4.5 Valuation Reduction for Environmental Issues
No known valuation reduction has been transferred to the environmental professional due
to historic environmental issues that may have been in place prior to the findings of this
report.
4.6 Owner, Property Manager, and Occupant Information
The current owner and property manager is Mr. Danny Henderson . There are no
occupants.
194
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 9
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
4.7 Reason for Performing Phase I
The environmental professional performed the ESA on the subject property due to a
commercial real estate transaction.
This ESA was conducted to make “all appropriate inquiry into the previous ownership and
uses of the property consistent with good commercial or customary practice” as defined
by CERCLA §101(35), 42 U.S.C. §9601(35), for the bona fide prospective purchaser
exception or the innocent landowner defense to CERCLA liability.
4.8 Other
No other information is applicable to this subject property or the environmental conditions
therein.
195
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 10
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
5.0 RECORDS REVIEW
5.1 Standard Environmental Record Sources
Available Federal and State record sources of environmental concern on or near the subject
property were reviewed to determine if there was evidence of recognized environmental
conditions or risks that may have an adverse environmental impact on the subject property.
The records reviewed included the files of the Groundwater, Wastewater, and Solid &
Hazardous Waste Management offices of the South Carolina Department of Environmental
Services (DES). In addition to site-specific files, the following DES documents, which are
updated regularly and accessed by a subcontracted information service, National
Environmental Title Research, LLC. (NETR), were reviewed for reference to the subject
property and surrounding properties. Any site identified on the NETR list was cross -
referenced with any available DES file. A copy of the radius search conducted by NETR is
attached.
5.2 Additional Environmental Record Sources
No other environmental record sources were available at the time of this review.
5.3 Physical Setting Source(s)
A 7.5-minute USGS topographic map (Spring Island & Laurel B ay, SC quadrangle) was
referenced for the physical setting of the subject property in relation to its surroundings
(Appendix A).
5.4 Historical Use Information on the Property
Historical use of the property, where available, was determined through review of USGS 7.5
Minute topographic maps, aerial photography, GIS Mapping websites, USDA Field Office,
and Google Earth Pro . Z oning, land use records, deeds, surveys, and tax maps were
resourced via the Beaufort County Government website.
Aerial photography dating back to 1951 and topographic maps back to 1920 sourced from
www.historicaerials.com were reviewed and did not in dicate any signs of habitation,
agriculture, or logging operations. However, bricks an d mortar were observed on the
southeastern side of the island during the on-site inspection. Some debris that was likely
deposited by high tides was also observed.
5.5 Historical Use Information on Adjoining Properties
Historical use of the adjacent properties, where available, was determined through review of
USGS 7.5 Minute topographic maps, aerial photography, GIS Mapping websites, USDA Field
Office, and Google Earth Pro. Zoning, land use records, deeds, surveys, and tax maps were
resourced via the Hampton County and Jasper County Government websites.
According to readily available information the adjoining properties have always been
wetlands. The EP does not consider this to represent a REC.
196
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 11
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
6.0 TRACT RECONNAISSANCE
6.1 Methodology and Limiting Conditions
The subject property and surrounding properties, shown in Appendix A, were inspected
by the EP for evidence of potential sources of environmental impact to the groundwater
and soil of the subject property by using a grid pattern and walking several transects to
ensure complete coverage of the subject property. Drone reconnaissance was also used.
There were no physical obs tructions. There were no other limiting conditions such as
weather.
6.2 General Subject Property Setting
The subject property is an island with vegetation consisting of live oaks, palmettos, and
loblolly pines that are representative of a maritime forest. The general vicinity is similar
in all respects.
197
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 12
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
6.3 Exterior Observations
Exterior observations of the subject property and adjacent sites by the Environmental
Professional (EP) did not visually or physically observe, or identify from the interviews or
records review, any of the following:
• Pits, Ponds, or Lagoons on the property used in connection with waste disposal
or waste treatment
• Wastewater
• Stained Soil or Pavement (other than de minimis)
• Stressed Vegetation
• Wells (groundwater monitoring wells)
• Septic Systems
• Solid Waste (including trash, demolition debris or construction debris)
There was a limited amount of trash observed around the per imeter of th e subj ect
property that was likely d eposited by storms , or high tides. None of it consi sted of
petroleum products, or hazardous materials.
The EP does not consider this to represent a REC.
198
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 13
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
6.4 Interior Observations
NA
199
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 14
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
7.0 INTERVIEWS
7.1 Interview with Owner
Attempts to contact Mr. Danny Henderson were unsuccessful. This report will be revised
if any information is provided.
7.2 Interview with Subject Property Manager
See 7.1.
7.3 Interviews with Occupants
NA
7.4 Interviews with Local Government Officials
The Beaufort office of the SCDES Bureau of Coastal Management was contacted. There
was no specific knowledge pertaining to recognized environmental conditions associated
with the subject property, or the adjoining properties. The EP does not consider this to
represent a REC.
The Beaufort County Assessor’s Office headed by Ms. Ebony Sanders was contacted.
Guidance was provided on researching the property’s value. There was no specific
knowledge pertaining to recognized environmental conditions at the subject property.
The EP does not consider this to represent a REC.
The Beaufort County Register of Deeds office was contacted. Aid was given in
downloading available deeds. There was no specific knowledge pertaining to recognized
environmental conditions at the subject property. The EP does not consider this to
represent a REC.
7.5 Interviews with Others
No other interviews were conducted.
200
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 15
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
8.0 ADDITIONAL SERVICES/NON-SCOPE CONSIDERATIONS
No additional services, or non -scope considerations were provided. These include :
asbestos, lead paint, lead in drinking water, radon, wetlands, ecological resources,
endangered species, cultural and historic resources, regulatory compliance, industrial
hygiene, health and safety, indoor air quality, biological agents, and mold.
201
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 16
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
9.0 FINDINGS
The subject property was not listed in any of the searched regulatory databases.
The EP does not consider this to represent a REC.
Note: all database searches were less than four months old according to information
provided by NETR (see attached).
202
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 17
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
9.1 Federal RCRA Generators List
RCRA-SQG: RCRAInfo is EPA’s comprehensive information system, providing access to
data supporting the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) of 1976 and the
Hazardous and Solid Waste Amendments (HSWA) of 1984. The database includes
selective information on sites which generate, transport, store, treat and/or dispose of
hazardous waste as defined by the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA).
Small quantity generators (SQGs) generate between 100 kg and 1,000 kg of hazardous
waste per month.
There were no RCRA Generators within the search radius.
The EP does not consider this to represent a REC.
203
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 18
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
9.2 US Toxic Release Inventory
The Toxics Release Inventory (TRI) is a publicly available EPA database that contains
information on toxic chemical releases and other waste management activities reported
annually by certain covered industry groups as well as federal facilities. TRI reporters for
all reporting years are provided in the file.
There were no TRI sites listed within the search radius.
The EP does not consider this to represent a REC.
204
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 19
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
9.3 Leaking Underground Storage Tanks (LUST)
The Leaking Underground Storage Tank Incident Reports contain an inventory of
reported leaking underground storage tank incidents. The data come from the SC
Department of Environmental Services (SCDES) Leaking UST list.
There were no LUST sites within the search radius.
The EP does not consider this to represent a REC.
205
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 20
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
9.4 Underground Storage Tank (UST)
The Underground Storage Tank database contains registered USTs. USTs are regulated
under Subtitle I of the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). The data come
from the SC Department of Environmental Services (SCDES) list: Comprehensive
Underground Storage Tanks (UST).
There were no UST sites listed within the search radius.
The EP does not consider this to represent a REC.
206
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 21
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
9.5 SC Drycleaner Facilities
Environmental contamination at a dry cleaner site can occur from spills and leaks of
solvent. Drycleaners that are operating and have registered with the South Carolina
Department of Revenue (SCDOR) are subject to inspection by the South Carolina
Department of Environmental Services (SCDES). However, not all Drycleaners in
operation have registered with the SCDOR, therefore this coverage is not a complete
representation of the state's drycleaners..
There were no dry cleaner sites within the search radius.
The EP does not consider this to represent a REC.
207
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 22
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
10.0 OPINION
I offer the following opinion as to whether the all appropriate inquiry conducted in
accordance with 40 CFR Part 312 and/or 33 CFR 137 has identified conditions indicative
of releases or threatened releases of hazardous substances, pollutants, contaminants,
petroleum and petroleum products, and controlled substances on, at, in, or to the subject
property.
SRC has performed a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment in conformance with the
scope and limitations of ASTM Practice E1527-21 of the subject property located at 7
Okatie Highway in Okatie, SC . There are no historical or current recognized
environmental conditions associated with the subject property, or adjacent properties. It
is the opinion of the EP that no further investigation is necessary.
11.0 DATA GAPS
I am identifying the following data gaps (as defined in 40 CFR Part 312.10) in the
information developed as part of the all appropriate inquiry that affects my ability as an
environmental professional to identify conditions indicative of releases or threatened
releases of hazardous substances, pollut ants, contaminants, petroleum and petroleum
products, and controlled substances on, at, in, or to the subject property. I am also
including comments regarding the significance of said data gaps on my ability as an
environmental professional to provide an opinion as to whether the all appropriate inquiry
has identified conditions indicative of releases and threatened releases.
A significant data gap is defined by E1527–21 as a data gap that affects the ability of the
environmental professional to identify a REC. There were no limitations or significant
data gaps encountered during this investigation that are considered to have hindered the
EP’s ability to evaluate or identify recognized environmental conditions associated with
the subject property.
12.0 CONCLUSIONS
Generally, a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment considers visual, physical, and
historical evidence of environmental contamination on and adjacent to a subject property.
There are no indications of current or historical recognized environmental conditions on
the subject property or adjacent sites. The EP does not consider this to represent a REC
and does not recommend further investigation.
13.0 DEVIATIONS
No deviations were performed from the ASTM Designation E1527–21 “Standard Practice
for Environmental Site Assessments: Phase I Environmental Assessment Process”. All
available sources were referenced to obtain the necessary information outlined in ASTM
E1527-21 to perform a qualified environmental opinion and conclusion.
208
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 23
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
14.0 REFERENCES
ASTM Designation E1527 -21 “Standard Practice for Environmental Site Assessments:
Phase I Environmental Assessment Process”
15.0 SIGNATURE OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROFESSIONAL
This report, entitled “Phase I Environmental Site Assessment,” has been prepared in
accordance with guidelines set forth in the American Society for Testing and Materials
(ASTM) Standard E 1527-21, “Standard Practice for Environmental Site Assessments:
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment Process”.
I declare that, to the best of my professional knowledge and belief, I meet the definition
of Environmental Professional as defined in §312.10 of 40 CFR 312” and 12.13.2.
I have the specific qualifications based on education, training, and experience to assess
a property of the nature, history, and setting of the subject property . I have developed
and performed the all appropriate inquiries in conformance with the standards and
practices set forth in 40 CFR Part 312.
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
Michael W. Whaley, M.S.
March 5, 2025
Date
209
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 24
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
16.0 Qualifications (Resume) of Environmental Professional
MICHAEL WAYNE WHALEY, B.Sc., M.Sc.
108 Charping Lane (864) 376-2864
Anderson, SC 29621 mikew@srcenvironmental.com
PROFILE
• Eighteen years progressively responsible experience in Environmental, Health and Safety program
management with medium to large-scale organizations.
• Thorough knowledge of current environmental and safety legislation at the state and federal level,
including RCRA, Title V Permitting, and the Clean Water Act.
• Proficient in assessing needs, managing multiple projects, and meeting deadlines.
• Proven successful in forming and leading effective safety teams to reduce accidents and injuries.
• Skilled instructor and facilitator; outstanding oral and written communication skills .
• Experienced in consulting and manufacturing settings (i.e., vinyl production and printing, metals
fabrication, and a Tier 1 supplier to the automotive industry).
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Program Management
• Composed and implemented Spill Prevention Control and Countermeasures Plan (SPCC), Stormwater
Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP), OSHA Emergency Response Plan, and RCRA Contingency Plan.
• Developed and utilized monitoring plans to meet all requirements of Title V Air Permit, and National
Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Permit.
• Conducted regular self-audits and managed insurance-based on-site audits to maintain compliance.
• Formed and led effective safety teams that reduced overall injuries by 20% and reduced recordable
injury rates well below industry average.
• Managed Worker’s Compensation claims for staff of 200 and reduced claims by 25% annually.
• Emergency Preparedness and Right to Know Coordinator for facilities with 200 -735 full -time
employees.
Research, Analysis and Evaluation
• Managed and conducted industrial hygiene and/or environmental testing and developed and
implemented options for compliance.
• Modeled wastewater discharges into riverine systems to determine toxicity requirements and mixing
zone size.
• Conducted Phase I Environmental Site Assessments for industrial and commercial clients.
• Performed Job Hazard Analyses and Hazard Assessments, articulating complex issues and formulating
strategies for change.
• Managed all records associated with health and safety issues including OSHA 200, Worker’s
Compensation, and Accident/Near-miss tracking; analyzed and evaluated emerging trends.
• Analyzed water usage trends and reduced purchased water usage and wastewater generation by
over 25%.
210
Item 11.
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment March 5, 2025
North Widgeon, 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909 Page 25
Commercial Real Estate Services
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Inc.
www.srcenvironmental.com
864-376-2864
Written and Verbal Communication
• Provided expert advice and consultation to senior management and industry associates on a wide
range of environmental, safety and compliance issues.
• Generated and submitted monthly, quarterly, and annual reports for air quality, wastewater, hazardous
waste, infectious waste, Form R, Tier II, and stormwater according to local, state, and federal
regulations for a Large Quantity Hazardous Waste Generator with RCRA Part B Permit.
• Trained employees in all areas of safety and environmental regulations with consistently positive
feedback.
• Developed and presented information to Key Operating Indicator (KOI) Team about EHS issues relating
to productivity and profit.
• Produced written compliance procedures and trained plant personnel according to OSHA Safety
Programs, and US DOT, US EPA, and SC DES regulations.
• Published author.
EMPLOYMENT HISTORY
Owner 2002 - Current
Southeastern Regulatory Compliance, Anderson, SC
Science Department Adjunct Professor 2015 - Current
Tri-County Technical College, Pendleton, SC
Science Department Educator 2017 - Current
Anderson School District 4
Science Department Educator 2015 - 2017
Anderson School District 1
Science Department Educator 2006 - 2015
Anderson School District V
EHS/Facilities & Security Supervisor 2005 - 2006
AFCO, Anderson, SC
Environmental Specialist 2003 - 2005
Michelin N.A., Anderson, SC
Safety and Environmental Manager 2001 - 2003
AVX Corporation, Myrtle Beach, SC
Safety and Environmental Coordinator 1998 - 2001
VyTech Industries, Inc., Anderson, SC
Safety and Environmental Engineer 1994 - 1998
The Torrington Co., Union, SC
Project Scientist 1992 - 1994
RMT, Inc., Greenville, SC
Research Specialist 1991 - 1992
The Institute for Wildlife and Environmental Toxicology, Pendleton, SC
EDUCATION AND PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
M.Sc., Biological Sciences 2014
Clemson University, Clemson, SC
M.Sc., Aquatic Toxicology (Fisheries and Wildlife) 1991
Clemson University, Clemson, SC
B.Sc., Biology 1987
The Citadel, Charleston, SC
• 24-hour OSHA 1910.120 Hazardous Waste Operators Health and Safety Emergency Response
Training
• OSHA Programs Training including, but not limited to Ergonomics, Bloodborne Pathogens, CPR and
First Responder, Lockout/Tagout, Emergency Response, and Fire Prevention and Control
• RCRA Hazardous Waste Management Training
211
Item 11.
APPENDIX A
212
Item 11.
Southeastern Regulatory
Compliance, Inc.
mikew@srcenvironmental.com
www.srcenvironmental.com
864.376.2864
FIGURE 1
Location Map
North Widgeon
7 Okatie Highway
Okatie, SC 29909
213
Item 11.
APPENDIX B
214
Item 11.
Southeastern Regulatory
Compliance, Inc.
mikew@srcenvironmental.com
www.srcenvironmental.com
864.376.2864
FIGURE 2
Topographical Map 1:24,000 Scale
Spring Island & Laurel Bay, SC Quads – ‘58 & ‘24
North Widgeon
7 Okatie Highway
Okatie, SC 29909
215
Item 11.
APPENDIX C
216
Item 11.
1951 (NETR Historical Aerials)
1955 (NETR Historical Aerials)
Southeastern Regulatory
Compliance, Inc.
mikew@srcenvironmental.com
www.srcenvironmental.com
864.376.2864
FIGURE 3A
1951 & 1955 Aerials
North Widgeon
7 Okatie Highway
Okatie, SC 29909
217
Item 11.
1983 (NETR Historical Aerials)
1994 (Google Earth Pro)
Southeastern Regulatory
Compliance, Inc.
mikew@srcenvironmental.com
www.srcenvironmental.com
864.376.2864
FIGURE 3B
1983 & 1994 Aerials
North Widgeon
7 Okatie Highway
Okatie, SC 29909
218
Item 11.
2015 (Google Earth Pro)
2021 (Google Earth Pro)
Southeastern Regulatory
Compliance, Inc.
mikew@srcenvironmental.com
www.srcenvironmental.com
864.376.2864
FIGURE 3C
2015 & 2021 Aerials
North Widgeon
7 Okatie Highway
Okatie, SC 29909
219
Item 11.
APPENDIX D
220
Item 11.
Southeastern Regulatory
Compliance, Inc.
mikew@srcenvironmental.com
www.srcenvironmental.com
864.376.2864
FIGURE 4
Wetlands Map
North Widgeon
7 Okatie Highway
Okatie, SC 29909
221
Item 11.
APPENDIX E
222
Item 11.
Southeastern Regulatory
Compliance, Inc.
mikew@srcenvironmental.com
www.srcenvironmental.com
864.376.2864
FIGURE 5
Soils Map
North Widgeon
7 Okatie Highway
Okatie, SC 29909
223
Item 11.
APPENDIX F
224
Item 11.
Figure 1: Okatie Highway – Northeast View
Figure 2: Entrance to Subject Property
225
Item 11.
Figure 3: Interior View of Palmettos, Live Oaks, and Loblolly Pines
Figure 4: Southeast View towards Tidal Flat at High Tide
226
Item 11.
Figure 5: Ponded Water – Center of Property
Figure 6: North View toward Property Boundary
227
Item 11.
Figure 7: Interior View of Live Oaks and Palmettos
Figure 8: East View towards Broad River
228
Item 11.
Figure 9: Bricks and Mortar from Possible Old Home Site
Figure 10: Fallen Hunting Stand
229
Item 11.
Figure 11: North View of Island Boundary and Okatie Highway Bridge
Figure 12: West View towards Okatie Highway
230
Item 11.
Figure 13: Aerial View of Forest Canopy
Figure 14: Aerial View towards Southern Boundary of the Property
231
Item 11.
APPENDIX G
232
Item 11.
Site Name: North Widgeon
Location: 7 Okatie Highway, Okatie, SC 29909
Prepared for: SRC, Inc.
Ref: Kate - Open Land Trust
Center Coordinates: 32.374328,-80.793725
Prepared Date: Tue Mar 04 2025 11:03:59 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
ENVIRONMENTAL
RADIUS REPORT
ASTM E1527-21
233
Item 11.
2055 E. Rio Salado Pkwy, Tempe, AZ 85381 | 480-967-6752
234
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Summary
Federal < 1/4 1/4 - 1/2 1/2 - 1
Lists of Federal NPL (Superfund) sites 0 0 0
Lists of Federal Delisted NPL sites 0 0 0
Lists of Federal sites subject to CERCLA removals and CERCLA orders 0 0 0
Lists of Federal CERCLA sites with NFRAP 0 0 0
Lists of Federal RCRA TSD facilities 0 0 0
Lists of Federal RCRA facilities undergoing Corrective Action 0 0 0
Lists of Federal RCRA generators 0 0 0
Federal institutional control/engineering control registries 0 0 0
Federal ERNS list 0 0 0
State < 1/4 1/4 - 1/2 1/2 - 1
Lists of state and tribal Superfund equivalent sites 0 0 0
Lists of state and tribal hazardous waste facilities 0 0 0
Lists of state and tribal landfills and solid waste disposal facilities0 0 0
Lists of state and tribal leaking storage tanks 0 0 0
Lists of state and tribal registered storage tanks 0 0 0
State and tribal institutional control/engineering control registries0 0 0
Lists of state and tribal brownfields sites 0 0 0
Lists of state and tribal voluntary cleanup sites 0 0 0
235
Item 11.
Other < 1/4 1/4 - 1/2 1/2 - 1
State and/or tribal lists of sites requiring further investigation / remediation0 0 0
State list of Significant Environmental Hazards (SEH) 0 0 0
Lists of state and tribal mine sites requiring further investigation and/orremediation 0 0 0
State and/or tribal lists of spills and spill responses 0 0 0
State and/or tribal lists of emergency responses 0 0 0
State and/or tribal lists of dry cleaners 0 0 0
State and/or tribal lists of clandestine laboratory cleanups 0 0 0
State and/or tribal lists of scrap/used tire processing facilities 0 0 0
State and/or tribal lists of underground injection control sites 0 0 0
State and/or tribal listings of permitted drywells 0 0 0
Automobile salvage yards 0 0 0
Livestock Waste Control sites 0 0 0
Controlled Animal Feeding Operations (CAFOs) 0 0 0
State and/or tribal lists of registered aboveground storage tanks (ASTs) 0 0 0
C.A.A. Permitted Facilities 0 0 0
NPDES Permitted Facilities 0 0 0
Onsite Wastewater Treatment sites 0 0 0
State and/or tribal lists of permitted facilities 0 0 0
U.S. EPA Enforcement, Compliance History Online (ECHO) 0 0 0
Resource Conservation and Recovery Act Information (RCRAInfo) 0 0 0
U.S. EPA Underground Storage Tanks (UST) 0 0 0
U.S. EPA Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) database 0 0 0
U.S. EPA Toxic Release Inventory System (TRIS) 0 0 0
236
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of Federal NPL (Superfund) sites
The National Priorities List (NPL) is the list of sites of national priority among the known
releases or threatened releases of hazardous substances, pollutants, or contaminants
throughout the United States and its territories. The NPL is intended primarily to guide the
EPA in determining which sites warrant further investigation. The NPL is updated periodically,
as mandated by CERCLA.
There were no Federal NPL sites found within a one-mile radius of the target property.
237
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of Federal Delisted NPL sites
The EPA may delete a final NPL site if it determines that no further response is required to
protect human health or the environment. Under Section 300.425(e) of the NCP (55 FR 8845,
March 8, 1990), a site may be deleted when no further response is appropriate if EPA
determines that one of the following criteria has been met: 1) EPA, in conjunction with the
state, has determined that responsible parties have implemented all appropriate response
action required, 2) EPA, in consultation with the state, has determined that all appropriate
Superfund-financed responses under CERCLA have been implemented and that no further
response by responsible parties is appropriate, 3) A remedial investigation/feasibility study
(RI/FS) has shown that the release poses no significant threat to public health or the
environment and, therefore, remedial measures are not appropriate.
There were no Federal Delisted NPL sites found within a half-mile radius of the target
property.
238
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of Federal sites subject to CERCLA removalsand CERCLA orders
CERCLA identifies the classes of parties liable under CERCLA for the cost of responding to
releases of hazardous substances. In addition, CERCLA contains provisions specifying when
Federal installations must report releases of hazardous substances and the cleanup
procedures they must follow. Executive Order No. 12580, Superfund Implementation,
delegates response authorities to EPA and the Coast Guard. Generally, the head of the
Federal agency has the delegated authority to address releases at the Federal facilities in its
jurisdiction.
There were no Federal sites subject to CERCLA removals and/or orders found within a
half-mile radius of the target property.
239
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of Federal CERCLA sites with NFRAP
No Further Remedial Action Planned (NFRAP) is a decision made as part of the Superfund
remedial site evaluation process to denote that further remedial assessment activities are not
required and that the facility/site does not pose a threat to public health or the environment
sufficient to qualify for placement on the National Priorities List (NPL) based on currently
available information. These facilities/sites may be re-evaluated if EPA receives new
information or learns that site conditions have changed. A NFRAP decision does not mean the
facility/site is free of contamination and does not preclude the facility/site from being
addressed under another federal, state or tribal cleanup program.
There were no Federal CERCLA sites with No Further Remedial Action Planned
(NFRAP) decisions found within a half-mile radius of the target property.
240
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of Federal RCRA TSD facilities
The final link in RCRA's cradle-to-grave concept is the treatment, storage, and disposal facility
(TSDF) that follows the generator and transporter in the chain of waste management
activities. The regulations pertaining to TSDFs are more stringent than those that apply to
generators or transporters. They include general facility standards as well as unit-specific
design and operating criteria.
There were no Federal RCRA treatment, storage and disposal facilities (TSDFs) found
within a half-mile radius of target property.
241
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of Federal RCRA facilities undergoing CorrectiveAction
Corrective action is a requirement under the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act
(RCRA) that facilities that treat, store or dispose of hazardous wastes investigate and cleanup
hazardous releases into soil, ground water, surface water and air. Corrective action is
principally implemented through RCRA permits and orders. RCRA permits issued to TSDFs
must include provisions for corrective action as well as financial assurance to cover the costs
of implementing those cleanup measures. In addition to the EPA, 44 states and territories are
authorized to run the Corrective Action program.
There were no Federal RCRA facilities undergoing corrective action(s) found within a
one-mile radius of the target property.
242
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of Federal RCRA generators
A generator is any person who produces a hazardous waste as listed or characterized in part
261 of title 40 of the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR). Recognizing that generators also
produce waste in different quantities, EPA established three categories of generators in the
regulations: very small quantity generators, small quantity generators, and large quantity
generators. EPA regulates hazardous waste under the Resource Conservation and Recovery
Act (RCRA) to ensure that these wastes are managed in ways that protet human health and
the environment. Generators of hazardous waste are regulated based on the amount of
hazardous waste they generate in a calendar month, not the size of their business or facility.
There were no Federal RCRA generators found at the target property and/or adjoining
properties.
243
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Federal institutional control/engineering controlregistries
Institutional Controls (IC) are defined as non-engineered and/or legal controls that minimize
the potential human exposure to contamination by limiting land or resource use. Whereas,
Engineering Controls (EC) consist of engineering measures (e.g, caps, treatment systems,
etc.) designed to minimize the potential for human exposure to contamination by either
limiting direct contact with contaminated areas or controlling migration of contaminants
through environmental media.
There were no Federal institutional or engineering controls found at the target
property.
244
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Federal ERNS list
The Emergency Response Notification System (ERNS) is a database used to store
information on notification of oil discharges and hazardous substances releases. The ERNS
program is a cooperative data sharing effort encompassing the National Response Center
(NRC), operated by the US Coast Guard, EPA HQ and EPA regional offices. ERNS data is
used to analyze release notifications, track EPA responses and compliance to environmental
laws, support emergency planning efforts, and assist decision-makers in developing spill
prevention programs.
There were no Federally recorded releases of oil and/or hazardous substances at the
target property.
245
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of state and tribal Superfund equivalent sites
In order to maintain close coordination with the states and tribes in the NPL listing decision
process, the EPA's policy is to determine the position of states and tribes on sites that EPA is
considering for listing. Consistent with this policy, since 1996, it has been the EPA's general
practice to seek the state or tribe's position on sites under consideration for NPL listing by
submitting a written requiest to the governor/state environmental agency or tribe. Various
states may have their own program for identifying, investigating and cleaning up sites where
consequential amounts of hazardous waste may have been disposed that work in conjunction
with the EPA's Superfund remedial program.
There were no State and/or tribal Superfund equivalent sites found within a one-mile
radius of target property.
246
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of state and tribal hazardous waste facilities
EPA established basic hazardous waste management standards for businesses who produce
hazardous waste and categorized three businesses based on the volume of hazardous waste
produced in a calendar month. On the federal level, there are three generator categories:
large quantity generator, small quantity generator, and conditionally exempt small quantity
generator. Some states are authorized to establish generator categories that are different
from those that federal EPA set up. State regulatory requirements for generators of hazardous
waste may be more stringent than the federal program.
There were no State and/or tribal hazardous waste facilities found within a half-mile
radius of the target property.
247
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of state and tribal landfills and solid wastedisposal facilities
Title 40 of the CFR parts 239 through 259 contain the regulations for non-hazardous solid
waste programs set up by the states. EPA has requirements for state solid waste permit
programs, guidelines for the processing of solid waste, guidelines for storage and collection of
commercial, residential and institutional solid waste, and the criteria for municipal solid waste
landfills. State solid waste programs may be more stringent than the federal code requires.
There were no State and/or tribal landfills or solid waste disposal facilities found within
a half-mile radius of the target property.
248
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of state and tribal leaking storage tanks
A typical leaking underground storage tank (LUST) scenario involves the release of a fuel
product from an underground storage tank (UST) that can contaminate surrounding soil,
groundwater, or surface waters, or affect indoor air spaces. Once a leak is confirmed,
immediate response actions must be taken to minimize or eliminate the source of the release
and to reduce potential harm to human health, safety, and the environment. Each state has
unique requirements for initiating responses to a release, and it is up to the UST owner or
operator to conduct actions in compliance with his/her local rules.
There were no State and/or tribal leaking storage tanks found within a half-mile radius
of the target property.
249
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of state and tribal registered storage tanks
EPA initially issued UST regulations in 1988. In 2015, EPA modified the UST regulation, which
was effective October 13, 2015 in Indian Country and states without State Program Approval.
EPA recognizes that, because of the size and diversity of the regulated community, state and
local governments are in the best position to oversee USTs: 1) State and local authorities are
closer to the situation in their domain and are in the best position to set priorities, 2) Subtitle I
of the Solid Waste Disposal Act allows state UST programs approved by EPA to operate in
lieu of the federal program, 3) the state program approval (SPA) regulations set criteria for
states to obtain the authority to operate in lieu of the federal program. State programs must
be at least as stringent as EPA's. A complete version of the law that governs USTs can be
found in U.S. Code, Title 42, Chapter 82, Subchapter IX.
There were no State and/or tribal registered storage tanks found at subject and
adjoining properties.
250
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
State and tribal institutional control/engineeringcontrol registries
Institutional controls are non-engineered instruments such as administrative and legal
controls that help minimize the potential for human exposure to contamination and/or protect
the integrity of the remedy. Engineering controls consist of engineering measures (e.g, caps,
treatment systems, etc.) designed to minimize the potential for human exposure to
contamination by either limiting direct contact with contaminated areas or controlling migration
of contaminants through environmental media. It is EPA's expectation that treatment or
engineering controls will be used to address principal threat wastes and that groundwater will
be returned to its beneficial use whenever practicable.
There were no State and/or tribal institutional and/or engineering controls found filed
against the target property.
251
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of state and tribal brownfields sites
Since its inception in 1995, EPA's Brownfields and Land Revitalization Program has grown
into a proven, results-oriented program that has changed the way communities address and
manage contaminated property. The program is designed to empower states, tribes,
communities, and other stakeholders to work together to prevent, assess, safely clean up,
and sustainably reuse brownfields. Beginning in the mid-1990s, EPA provided small amounts
of seed money to local governments that launched hundreds of two-year Brownfields pilot
projects and developed guidance and tools to help states, communities and other
stakeholders in the cleanup and redevelopment of brownfields sites.
There were no State and/or tribal brownfields sites found within a half-mile radius of
the target property.
252
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of state and tribal voluntary cleanup sites
State cleanup programs play a significant role in assessing and cleaning up contaminated
sites. State cleanup programs typically are programs authorized by state statutes to address
brownfields and other lower-risk sites that are not of federal interest. The EPA has historically
supported the use of state cleanup programs and continues to provide grant funding to
establish and enhance the programs. This approach was codified in 2002 as Section 182 of
the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA).
There were no State and/or tribal voluntary cleanup sites found within a half-mile
radius of the target property.
253
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
State and/or tribal lists of sites requiring furtherinvestigation / remediation
No records found
254
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
State list of Significant Environmental Hazards (SEH)
No records found
255
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Lists of state and tribal mine sites requiring furtherinvestigation and/or remediation
No records found
256
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
State and/or tribal lists of spills and spill responses
No records found
257
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
State and/or tribal lists of emergency responses
No records found
258
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
State and/or tribal lists of dry cleaners
No records found
259
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
State and/or tribal lists of clandestine laboratorycleanups
No records found
260
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
State and/or tribal lists of scrap/used tire processingfacilities
No records found
261
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
State and/or tribal lists of underground injectioncontrol sites
No records found
262
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
State and/or tribal listings of permitted drywells
No state and/or tribal permitted drywells were found within a half-mile radius of the target
property.
263
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Automobile salvage yards
No records found
264
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Livestock Waste Control sites
No records found
265
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Controlled Animal Feeding Operations (CAFOs)
No records found
266
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
State and/or tribal lists of registered abovegroundstorage tanks (ASTs)
No records found
267
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
C.A.A. Permitted Facilities
No records found
268
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
NPDES Permitted Facilities
No records found
269
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Onsite Wastewater Treatment sites
No records found
270
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
State and/or tribal lists of permitted facilities
No State and/or tribal permitted facilities found within a half-mile of the target property.
271
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
U.S. EPA Enforcement, Compliance History Online(ECHO)
No records found
272
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Resource Conservation and Recovery Act Information(RCRAInfo)
No records found
273
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
U.S. EPA Underground Storage Tanks (UST)
No records found
274
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
U.S. EPA Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA)database
No records found
275
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
U.S. EPA Toxic Release Inventory System (TRIS)
No records found
276
Item 11.
environmental.netronline.com
Disclaimer - Copyright and Trademark Notice
This report contains certain information obtained from a variety of public and other sources reasonably available to
Nationwide Environmental Title Research, LLC (NETR). It cannot be concluded from this Report that coverage information for
the target and surrounding properties does not exist from other sources. NO WARRANTY EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, IS
MADE WHATSOEVER IN CONNECTION WITH THIS REPORT. NATIONWIDE ENVIRONMENTAL TITLE RESEARCH,
LLC SPECIFICALLY DISCLAIMS THE MAKING OF ANY SUCH WARRANTIES, INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION,
MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR USE OR PURPOSE. ALL RISK IS ASSUMED BY THE USER. IN
NO EVENT SHALL NATIONWIDE ENVIRONMENTAL TITLE RESEARCH, LLC, BE LIABLE TO ANYONE, WHETHER
ARISING OUT OF ERRORS OR OMISSIONS, NEGLIGENCE, ACCIDENT OR ANY OTHER CAUSE, FOR ANY LOSS OF
DAMAGE, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, SPECIAL, INCIDENTAL, CONSEQUENTIAL, OR EXEMPLARY
DAMAGES. ANY LIABILITY ON THE PART OF NATIONWIDE ENVIRONMENTAL TITLE RESEARCH, LLC, IS STRICTLY
LIMITED TO A REFUND OF THE AMOUNT PAID FOR THIS REPORT. Purchaser accepts this report "AS-IS". Any analyses,
estimates, ratings, environmental risk levels or risk codes provided in this report are provided for illustrative purposes only,
and are not intended to provide, nor should they be interpreted as providing any facts regarding, or prediction or forecast of,
any environmental risk for any property. Only a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment performed by an environmental
professional can provide information regarding the environmental risk for any property. Additionally, the information provided
in this Report is not to be construed as legal advice.
Copyright 2025 by Nationwide Environmental Title Research, LLC (NETR). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any media or
format, in whole or in part, of any report or map of Nationwide Environmental Title Research, LLC, or its affiliates, is
prohibited without prior written permission.
Nationwide Environmental Title Research, LLC (NETR) and its logos are trademarks of Nationwide Environmental Title
Research, LLC or its affiliates. All other trademarks used herein are the property of their respective owners.
277
Item 11.
APPENDIX H
278
Item 11.
279
Item 11.
280
Item 11.
281
Item 11.
282
Item 11.
283
Item 11.
284
Item 11.
285
Item 11.
286
Item 11.
287
Item 11.
288
Item 11.
289
Item 11.
290
Item 11.
291
Item 11.
292
Item 11.
293
Item 11.
294
Item 11.
295
Item 11.
296
Item 11.
297
Item 11.
298
Item 11.
299
Item 11.
300
Item 11.
301
Item 11.
302
Item 11.
303
Item 11.
304
Item 11.
305
Item 11.
306
Item 11.
307
Item 11.
308
Item 11.
309
Item 11.
310
Item 11.
311
Item 11.
312
Item 11.
APPENDIX I
313
Item 11.
314
Item 11.
315
Item 11.
316
Item 11.
317
Item 11.
318
Item 11.
319
Item 11.
320
Item 11.
321
Item 11.
322
Item 11.
323
Item 11.
324
Item 11.
325
Item 11.
326
Item 11.
327
Item 11.
328
Item 11.
329
Item 11.
APPENDIX A
330
Item 11.
APPENDIX B
331
Item 11.
APPENDIX C
332
Item 11.
APPENDIX D
333
Item 11.
APPENDIX E
334
Item 11.
APPENDIX F
335
Item 11.
APPENDIX G
336
Item 11.
APPENDIX H
337
Item 11.
APPENDIX I
338
Item 11.
APPENDIX J
339
Item 11.
Project Name
Beach City Road Fee
Davis Road Fee
North Widgeon Fee
Due Diligence Fees
Closing Fees
TOTAL COSTS
Remaining Available
FY24 Acquisitions
Cherry Hill Oak Fee
location
HHI
Bluffton
Okatie
Total Cost
$1,557,570.00
Cotton Hall Fee $4,464,807.63
Barrell Landing Orr Fee $438,416.40
Toto/ $6,460,794.03
FY25 Acquisitions
Boundary St - Logan
Graves Settlement Refund
Rawstrom Road Fee
Seaside Rd PDR
Davis Road Fee
Total Cost
$339,451.33
$25,000.00
$1,876,409.21
$377,645.40
pending
North Widgeon Fee pending
Total $2,618,505.94
FY2S RCLP Bond Funding Spending Summary
Amount
$0
$858,000
$2,200,000
$10,000
$10,000
$3,078,000
$172,826
Status
4/7/25: Seller sold to another party, project is inactive
3/10/25 approved by CC; closing in April 2025
4/7/25: requesting NRC to recommend purchase approval; see notes below
for legal/title work remaining on pending projects
~55K/active project (2 pending projects)
North Widgeon Fee Notes:
S2.2M from RCLP, $250K from Green Space, $250K from SC Conservation Bank
3 readings at County Council in April/May 2025 in order to close in June 2025
FY24 CLOSE OUT:
FY24 SOY
Interest
Prof Svc
Acquisitions
Transfer Out
$14,401,612.51
$191,871.00
Revenues $14,593,483.51
$194,711.09 OLT and DD
$6,460,794.03 see FY24 Closed
S2,000,000.00 Camp St Mary
Expanses $8,655,505.12
FY25 ACTUAL: 4/7/2025
FY25 SOY $5,942,892.98
Interest
Prof Svc
Acquisitions
$74,824.00
Revenues $6,017,716.98
$148,385.32 OL T and DD
$2,618,505.94 see FY25 list
Expenses $2,766,891.26
Balance $3,250,825.72
340
Item 11.
Source: Beaufort County website. First collected Nov 8, 2026.