County Council Regular Meeting — Minutes
Georgetown County · Georgetown County · County Council · meeting of Sep 19, 2017 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Georgetown County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Georgetown County Council
Meeting Minutes
September 19, 2017
1
Georgetown County Council held a Regular Council Session on Tuesday, September 19, 2017,
at 5:30 PM in County Council Chambers located in the old Georgetown County Courthouse, 129
Screven Street, Georgetown, South Carolina.
Present: Austin Beard Lillie Jean Johnson
Everett Carolina Johnny Morant
Ron L. Charlton John Thomas
Steve Goggans
Staff: Sel Hemingway Wesley P. Bryant
Theresa E. Floyd Jackie Broach
Other staff members, members of the public, and representatives of the media were also
present. In accordance with the Freedom of Information Act, a copy of the agenda was sent to
newspapers, television, and radio stations, citizens of the County, Department Heads, and
posted on the bulletin board located in the lobby of the historic Courthouse.
Chairman Johnny Morant called the meeting to order. An invocation was given by
Councilmember Ron Charlton, and all joined in the pledge of allegiance.
APPROVAL OF AGENDA:
A recommendation was made to move a report recognizing winners of a recent Pileau/Ice
Cream Charity Cook-off, and presentation of checks to the charities forward on the meeting
agenda to follow ‘public comments’.
Councilmember Ron Charlton moved for approval of the meeting agenda, as amended.
Councilmember Lillie Jean Johnson seconded the motion. No discussion followed the motion.
In favor: Austin Beard Lillie Jean Johnson
Everett Carolina Johnny Morant
Ron L. Charlton John Thomas
Steve Goggans
PUBLIC COMMENTS:
Rev. Sandra Ladson
Rev. Ladson, speaking in opposition of Ordinance No. 2017-19 to rezone 948 acres on Penny
Royal Road, said she was one of twenty-eight property owners in the surrounding area notified
by letter regarding the proposed rezoning from Farm/Agriculture and Conservation Preservation
to Heavy Industrial. Perhaps this met the County’s notification requirements, but is this due
diligence on behalf of the County when every property owner along Penny Royal Road will be
affected? Is the County acting without fully investigating conflicting information and questions
that have remained unanswered? Enough questions have been asked that the Planning
Commission, a body appointed by County Council to advise them, voted unanimously to deny
moving forward. She urged County Council to demand answers to these and other questions
prior to moving forward.
Emerson Gower
Mr. Gower, Chairman of the Georgetown County Economic Development Alliance, said that he
moved for Georgetown County seven years ago and began looking for a place to volunteer. The
Economic Development Alliance focuses on creating jobs, and bringing new quality jobs to the
area in order to support a diversified tax base necessary for positive economic development. In
Georgetown County Council
Meeting Minutes
September 19, 2017
2
his travels, he observed the states that have successful strong economic development
programs have the highest quality of living; it gives a community the opportunity to control its
future, and prevents its youth from having to leave the area. The site being considered tonight is
located in an industrial corridor, and considered to be the best industrial development location in
Georgetown County. Successful economic growth is preceded by a competitive program. You
cannot wait until the last minute to put your package together, or you will be written off. He
urged County Council to support the rezoning (represented by Ordinance No. 2017-19).
Tiffany Jaspers
Ms. Jaspers, SC Department of Employment & Workforce, said manufacturing jobs have a
competitive salary range; nationwide manufacturing jobs have the highest median salary of any
industry. Georgetown County’s weekly wages for industrial jobs are the third highest in the
State, and the turnover rate in this area is 4% lower than average. Additionally manufacturing
jobs typically offer good benefits such as health insurance and 401K plans.
Amelia Thompson
Ms. Thompson, a staff attorney with the SC Environmental Law Project, spoke in opposition of
Ordinance No. 2017-19 stating this site is special and unique from an environmental standpoint;
it encompasses nearly 1,000 acres, full of wetlands and diverse habitats that perform an
important function for the Sampit River that is already polluted from industrial discharges. The
addition of other heavy industry and discharge sources into the river will be detrimental to it, and
the health of the people that live here in Georgetown County. Ms. Thompson reminded County
Council of words spoken during the invocation regarding being good stewards, which includes
protecting our environment.
Rob Ardis
Mr. Ardis, President/CEO Santee Electric Cooperative, stated that he was raised in Georgetown
County, graduated from the local school district, married here, and his children were born here.
He has a full appreciation of the local natural beauty and would not support anything that could
potentially hurt the quality of life in this area. He said residents should not allow fear from what
was done in the past and should trust the permitting processes are put in place to protect us.
This property is located in a corridor with two mills and a generating plant. Large power
customers take a great deal of the burden of fixed utility costs. Residential rates would be much
higher in this area if not for the large power customers, such as 3V Inc. and American Gypsum.
This is Georgetown County’s best chance to boost our prosperity and we owe it to our citizens.
For this reason he, and Santee Electric, support the Penny Royal development project.
Angelyn Smith
Ms. Smith is a Project Manager for the SC Power Team, which is “the economic development
arm” of all 20 electric cooperatives in the State. She said industrial prospects seek out available
sites, and that economic development is not going to happen without site ready property. There
have been many economic development successes around the State and the goal is to bring
the same success to Georgetown County. The SC Power Team supports the rezoning of Penny
Royal Property (Ordinance No. 2017-19).
Jeff McKay
Mr. McKay, representing the North Eastern Strategic Alliance (NESA), a regional economic
development organization of which Georgetown County is a member. He said the clients NESA
works with invest millions into communities and provide hundreds of jobs. These clients are
looking to minimize their risks and rarely look at communities that do not have ready sites
available. He said eight of the nine counties NESA is involved with have active industrial site
Georgetown County Council
Meeting Minutes
September 19, 2017
3
programs that support economic development. South Carolina is going through a period of
unprecedented growth right now, and without good available locations we will “lose the war”,
and will not land these opportunities.
Eileen Johnson
Ms. Johnson voiced opposition to Ordinance No. 2017-19 stating that the previous speakers
had eloquently voiced what they want, however they had different visions for Georgetown
County. She asked Council members if they had all of the information they need to make a
decision that will change the fate of Georgetown County’s citizens and waterways. Council
members are elected to preserve and protect the people they represent and that should be
utmost on their mind. The County already has an industrial site that is almost empty. Area
residents have not seen the documents between Red Mountain and Georgetown County that
indicate what the relationship is, or whether there are any contingencies on the property
purchase. She pointed out other questions that have gone unanswered and noted that she has
submitted a Freedom of Information request to the County. This rezoning is devaluing the
property of residents in the area and the stigma is hanging over their heads.
Bill Kinsey
Mr. Kinsey voiced opposition to Ordinance No. 2017-19. He said he hoped that County Council
would not factor in too much of the information provided tonight by those on the “corporate
payroll”. The heavy industry that depends on rivers is the biggest detriment to those rivers. He
stated that the Boeing Company said the reason they chose Charleston was due to the beauty
of the surrounding area. Georgetown County should focus its investments on improving area
roads and other improvements that will attract industry leaving landowners to promote their own
property.
Alex Michau
Mr. Michau said he was previously employed by Georgetown County for 25 years. He stated
that the retiree health insurance provided by the County is good. Mr. Michau said the County’s
ditches need to be maintained, and mosquito control is needed. He said overall the County has
been good to him.
Michelle Sinkler
Ms. Sinkler, SC Coastal Conservation League, spoke in opposition of Ordinance No. 2017-19
rezoning 948 acres on Penny Royal Road. She said the community clearly does not support
this project as the Chamber is full. The Planning Commission listened to the concerns of the
community and voted to reject it. When people continue to work toward an original goal without
pausing to listen to questions, reevaluate or shift course it is called “dysfunctional momentum”.
A recent example of an entity refusing to listen to cues is the Santee Cooper debacle. County
Council cannot be captured by tunnel vision. She asked that County Council pause, take time to
reflect, ask questions, and come back with a more transparent plan that restores the confidence
of stakeholders.
Walter Bratcher
Mr. Bratcher spoke in opposition of Ordinance No. 2017-19 stating that he is a resident of the
area and lives across the creek from the property in question. Mr. Bratcher displayed a large
aerial map of the property and made observations that he said would not be obvious to County
Council on the tour that was brief and did not encompass the entire tract of property. The tract
is bordered on the left by powerlines, which would prohibit construction. There is a huge marsh
bordering the right side of the property, and end of the property is an island at high tide that is
not accessible. Additionally there is a cemetery and burial site on the property. Mr. Bratcher
Georgetown County Council
Meeting Minutes
September 19, 2017
4
indicated that the property appears useless for development, yet Red Mountain Timber has
other tracts available that would not impact homeowners in the vicinity, and he questioned why
those tracts are not being considered.
Tim Tilley
Mr. Tilley stated that he is the President/Owner of Envirosept, Vice Chair of the HGTC
Foundation, former Chairman of the Economic Development Alliance, former Chair of the Port
Task Force, and member of the Grand Strand Economic Outlook Board. He provided statistics
and data supporting that the economic stimulus of manufacturing on the economy and
employment. He said that industrial development is crucial for economic growth and needed for
any area to be successful. Employment statics reveal that jobs in neighboring counties have
grown while employment in Georgetown County has decreased. He asked that County Council
consider these facts in the decision before them as Georgetown County needs manufacturing
growth to make our County successful.
Brian Tucker
Mr. Tucker, Georgetown County Economic Development Director, stated that he was excited
about this opportunity. He said the Penny Royal and its unique combination of characteristics
could not be found anywhere else in this County, and rarely found available anywhere else in
the State. The property gives Georgetown County a competitive advantage it does not have
otherwise. Georgetown County does not have interstate access. Of the 28 new project
announcements South Carolina has made this year, with the exception of one, all are located in
counties with direct access to interstates. The Penny Royal site is consistent with the future
Land Use Plan, and the industrial site in Andrews that is set up to accommodate smaller
manufacturing facilities. The site has several industrial neighbors, and is surrounded by
wetlands which will provide significant buffers both to residents and Penny Royal Road. There
is no plan to develop all 948 acres. He said Georgetown County is at a crossroads and we
need to be bold with strategic leadership and vision. This is a win-win situation to bring good
paying jobs, with quality companies that respect our residents, communities, and natural
resources.
Ron Church
Mr. Church, President of Harmony Home Owners Association, said that prior to this they were
optimistic they would see new development, and that decision is on County Council’s shoulders.
Many years ago a “clean, conscious, industrial neighbor” proposed locating in Georgetown
County. Today that industry has left an ugly mark on a beautiful city. It is a good case study on
what can happen despite DHEC, EPA and other agencies responsible for industrial oversite.
Companies looking to move here will not promote their selves negatively. Once they move here
we cannot dictate what they do. Large private or publicly traded companies are not concerned
with property values. No one in the ‘Save the Sampit’ group is opposed to economic
development. They are simply opposed to developing this (Penny Royal) site. The boundary of
this property is 65% Sampit River and/or Turkey Creek. The County is blessed to be
surrounded by five rivers that empty into a magnificent bay. Why risk our most valuable asset?
Mr. Church read the County’s mission statement, and said this project is in direct violation of two
of the three points. Forty years from now we don’t want this to be an example of good
intentions gone wrong.
Georgetown County Council
Meeting Minutes
September 19, 2017
5
MINUTES:
Regular Council Session – August 22, 2017
Councilmember Ron Charlton moved for approval of the August 22, 2017 meeting minutes.
Councilmember John Thomas seconded the motion. Chairman Johnny Morant called for
discussion on the motion, and there was no discussion.
In favor: Austin Beard Lillie Jean Johnson
Everett Carolina Johnny Morant
Ron L. Charlton John Thomas
Steve Goggans
Special Council Session – August 22, 2017
Councilmember Ron Charlton moved for approval of the August 22, 2017 special meeting
minutes. Councilmember John Thomas seconded the motion. Chairman Johnny Morant called
for discussion on the motion, and there was no discussion.
In favor: Austin Beard Lillie Jean Johnson
Everett Carolina Johnny Morant
Ron L. Charlton John Thomas
Steve Goggans
CONSENT AGENDA:
The following reports were included on the Consent Agenda, and therefore approved previously
during the meeting:
Acceptance of FAA AIP17 Grant Offer – County Council approved a recommendation to accept
a FAA AIP-19 grant award (#3-45-0025-019-2017) in the amount of $191,192 and authorize
$10,622 of County funds for the project (to be appropriated from fund balance of the General
Fund at a later date).
Contract #15-073, Airport Engineering & Planning Services: (3) Task Orders for Approval –
County Council approved Contract 15-073, Task Orders #05, #06, and #07 with Talbert and
Bright Inc. for a total of $210,436.00 contingent upon the concurrent approval of AIP Grant 3-45-
0025-019-2017.
Procurement #17-097, CERP Replacement for (2) Ford F250 Pick-Ups for Public Works –
County Council approved two purchase orders to Vic Bailey Ford of Spartanburg, SC, at
$30,734.00 each, to total $61,468.00 for the Capital Equipment Replacement Plan vehicles as
previously scheduled for Public Works.
Bid #16-077, East Bay Tennis Courts Renovation Project – County Council awarded a contract
to Green Wave Contracting of Georgetown, SC for a total bid amount of $453,355.00 which
includes the base bid proposal of $450,855.00, Add/Alternate #1 for QuickStart striping at
$1,000.00 and Add/Alternate #2 for Pickleball striping at $1,500.00.
Bid #17-063, Fontaine Magnitude 55H-FLD Flat Level Deck Lowbed “Brand Name or Equal”
Hydraulic Lowboy Gooseneck Trailer – County Council awarded a contract to Southeast Trailer
Mart, Inc. of Simpsonville, SC for a total of $73,405.69 inclusive of taxes and delivery.
Procurement #17-082, Roll-Off Truck with Cable Hoist – County Council approved a purchase
from Triple T Truck Centers of Wilmington, NC as the delivering dealer for a Freightliner 114SD
Roll-Off Truck with Cable Hoist in the amount of $151,110.10 inclusive of sales tax and delivery.
Georgetown County Council
Meeting Minutes
September 19, 2017
6
Employee Policy – Recommendation for approval of proposed amendments to the policy
pertaining to time off awards for employees who come in to work during disasters or other
events when the County has closed operations.
RESOLUTIONS / PROCLAMATIONS:
Resolution No. 2017-14–To Adopt a Strategic Business Plan for the Georgetown County Airport
Councilmember Austin Beard moved for the adoption of Resolution No 2017-14 accepting the
Strategic Business Plan for the Georgetown County Airport dated July 2017, as presented to
County Council by the Airport Strategic Planning Committee in a work session on August 22,
2017. Councilmember Steve Goggans seconded the motion. Upon a call for discussion from
Chairman Johnny Morant, there was no discussion on the motion.
In favor: Austin Beard Lillie Jean Johnson
Everett Carolina Johnny Morant
Ron L. Charlton John Thomas
Steve Goggans
ORDINANCES-Third Reading
Ordinance No. 2017-18
Councilmember Austin Beard moved for third reading approval of Ordinance No. 2017-18 to
amend the Turkey Creek Planned Development (PD) to allow for 174 townhome units, 180 "in
common" single family units and 179 "fee simple" parcels. Councilmember John Thomas
offered a second. Chairman Morant called for discussion on the motion.
Councilmember Austin Beard moved to amend Ordinance No. 2017-18 to include additional
wording to pertaining to short term camper rental sites, and stipulations regarding approval of a
revised traffic study. Councilmember John Thomas seconded the amended motion. No
discussion occurred on the amended motion.
In favor: Austin Beard Lillie Jean Johnson
Everett Carolina Johnny Morant
Ron L. Charlton John Thomas
Steve Goggans
The vote on the main motion was as follows:
In favor: Austin Beard Lillie Jean Johnson
Everett Carolina Johnny Morant
Ron L. Charlton John Thomas
Steve Goggans
ORDINANCES-Second Reading:
Ordinance No. 2017-19
Councilmember Steve Goggans moved for second reading approval of Ordinance No. 2017-19,
an amendment to the Georgetown County Zoning map to rezone approximately 948 acres
located along Pennyroyal Road and the Sampit River, further identified as TMS#01-0437-002-
00-00, from Forest and Agriculture (FA) and Conservation Preservation (CP) to Heavy Industrial
(HI) with the following contingencies: (1) referral of the matter to Council’s Land Use Committee
(at the pleasure of Chairman Morant) to prepare a set of reasonable deed covenants/restrictions
and design guidelines that will guide future industrial development on the site with consideration
Georgetown County Council
Meeting Minutes
September 19, 2017
7
given to the surrounding community; (2) more of the county’s due diligence to be completed
ahead prior to 3rd reading to understand exactly where wetlands are, as well as other
environmental considerations. Councilmember John Thomas seconded the motion. Chairman
Morant called for discussion on the motion.
Councilmember Everett Carolina said this is a time of tough choices and critical decisions. The
Heavy Industrial classification allows for industries with heavy impacts on our environment, and
infrastructure along with employment and has to be decided with forethought. Constituents have
voiced environmental concerns, residential property value concerns and a number of other
issues. He said the County must do the maximum due diligence before a final decision is made
and supported referring this to the Land Use Committee with consideration given to create a
committee that represents the interests of the people in the immediate Penny Royal area.
Councilmember Ron Charlton asked for clarification on the motion and whether a citizen group
representing residents of the Penny Royal would work with the Land Use Committee to discuss
their issues and concerns. Chairman Johnny Morant concurred. He stated that the motion is to
move forward with second reading of Ordinance No. 2017-19 with the intention is to refer this
matter to Council’s Land Use Committee to meet with representatives from the community to
address the issues expressed here tonight.
Councilmember Steve Goggans moved to amend Ordinance No. 2017-19, to incorporate
proposed text as the ordinance was introduced at first reading by title only. Councilmember
John Thomas seconded the motion. There was no discussion on the amended motion.
In favor: Austin Beard Lillie Jean Johnson
Everett Carolina Johnny Morant
Ron L. Charlton John Thomas
Steve Goggans
The vote on the main motion was as follows:
In favor: Austin Beard Lillie Jean Johnson
Everett Carolina Johnny Morant
Ron L. Charlton John Thomas
Steve Goggans
Ordinance No. 2017-20
A motion was made by Councilmembers Steve Goggans, and seconded by Councilmember
John Thomas, for second reading approval of Ordinance No. 2017-20, an amendment to the
Pavilion Square Flexible Design District (FDD), including TMS# 04-0161-015-04-00, and TMS#
04-0161-016-00-00, to allow for a grocery store to be located on the west side of Highway 17
just south of Petigru Drive in Pawleys Island. Upon a call for discussion the motion, none
occurred.
In favor: Austin Beard Lillie Jean Johnson
Everett Carolina Johnny Morant
Ron L. Charlton John Thomas
Steve Goggans
Georgetown County Council
Meeting Minutes
September 19, 2017
8
Ordinance No. 2017-21
Councilmember Steve Goggans moved for second reading approval of Ordinance No. 2017-21
to rezone approximately one acre of property located at Beaumont Drive, a portion of TMS# 04-
0164-004-01-00, from the True Blue Planned Development (PD) to Forest Agriculture (FA).
Councilmember John Thomas seconded the motion. Chairman Morant called for discussion,
and there was none.
In favor: Austin Beard Lillie Jean Johnson
Everett Carolina Johnny Morant
Ron L. Charlton John Thomas
Steve Goggans
Ordinance No. 2017-22
Councilmember Austin Beard moved for second reading approval of Ordinance No. 2017-22, an
Ordinance to declare as surplus a portion of a tract, identified as TMS #02-1010-005-00-00, and
to authorize the County Administrator to sell the property in the manner as prescribed within
Ordinance No. 2008-09, “Georgetown County Purchasing Ordinance, as amended”.
Councilmember Lillie Jean Johnson seconded the motion. Chairman Morant called for
discussion.
Councilmember Austin Beard moved to amend Ordinance No. 2017-22, to incorporate proposed
text as the ordinance was introduced at first reading by title only. Councilmember Lillie Jean
Johnson seconded the motion. There was no further discussion.
In favor: Austin Beard Lillie Jean Johnson
Everett Carolina Johnny Morant
Ron L. Charlton John Thomas
Steve Goggans
The vote on the main motion was as follows:
In favor: Austin Beard Lillie Jean Johnson
Everett Carolina Johnny Morant
Ron L. Charlton John Thomas
Steve Goggans
ORDINANCES- First Reading:
No reports.
BIDS:
No reports.
REPORTS TO COUNCIL:
Recognition – Georgetown County Morale Committee Cook-off Winners
This report was presented earlier during the meeting.
Georgetown County recently hosted a Georgetown County employees donated their time and
culinary skills to raise money for charity at the First Annual Georgetown County Employee
Morale Committee Charity Pileau and Ice Cream Cook-off. Six employees volunteered their time
to make pileau and four churned homemade ice cream for the event. More than 100 County
employees purchased ticket to sample each entry and vote for their favorite. The event raised a
Georgetown County Council
Meeting Minutes
September 19, 2017
9
total of $520 to go to the winner’s choice of charities; in addition the winner received a traveling
trophy to display for the upcoming year in their department. The winner of the pileau contest
was Doug Johnson from Park Maintenance who chose the proceeds, while Debbie Newton
using a family recipe for vanilla ice cream with an Ivey twist won the ice cream contest. Debbie’s
share of the proceeds will go to the Family Justice Center.
EXECUTIVE SESSION:
A motion was made by Councilmember Ron Charlton, and seconded by Councilmember Austin
Beard, to move into Executive Session to discuss a legal matter. There was no discussion
following the motion.
In favor: Austin Beard Lillie Jean Johnson
Everett Carolina Johnny Morant
Ron L. Charlton John Thomas
Steve Goggans
County Council moved into Executive Session at 7:18 PM.
OPEN SESSION:
As Open Session resumed at 7:58 PM, Chairman Johnny Morant noted that during Executive
Session a legal issue as previously disclosed. During Executive Session, no decisions were
made by County Council, nor were any votes taken.
Chairman Morant moved to appoint Councilmembers Everett Carolina to serve with the Land
Use Committee in discussing the matter concerning the Penny Royal rezoning, stating that the
Committee Chairman, Austin Beard had concurred. For this purpose the Land Use Committee
will consist of Chairman Austin Beard, Councilmember Steve Goggans, Councilmember John
Thomas, and Councilmember Everett Carolina.
Being no further business, Chairman Morant adjourned the meeting at 8:00 PM.
________________________________
Date
__________________________________
Clerk to Council
Source: Georgetown County website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.