RecordWell Data

Planning Commission Meeting — Minutes

Lancaster County · Lancaster County · Planning Commission · meeting of Nov 18, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Lancaster County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

MEMBERS OF LANCASTER COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION JASON CAVALIER , DISTRICT 1 T. YOKIMA CURETON , DISTRICT 2 LYNETTE HINSON , DISTRICT 3 JUDIANNA TINKLENBERG , DISTRICT 4 CHAIR : MICHELLE RICHARDS , DISTRICT 5 SHEILA HINSON , DISTRICT 6 FRANCES LIU, DISTRICT 7 SECRETARY : MARA MATA MINUTES Lancaster County Planning Commission November 18, 2025, 6:00 p.m. Chairman Richards called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m. 1. Roll Call: Quorum is present (7 Commissioners) Commissioners Present: Jason Cavalier, Dist. 1 Michelle Richards, Dist. 5 T. Yokima Cureton, District 2 Sheila Hinson, Dist. 6 Lynette Hinson, District 3 Frances Liu, Dist. 7 Judianna Tinklenberg, Dist. 4 Staff Present: Ginny Merck-Dupont; County Attorney Jennifer Bryan, Planning Technician Allison Hardin, Development Services Dir. Corey Barnes, Planner April Williams, Planning Director Kirsten Willis, Planner Matthew Blaszyk, Planner Mara Mata, Administrative Assistant The following press were notified of the meeting by email in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act: The Lancaster News, Kershaw News Era, The Rock Hill Herald, The Fort Mill Times, Cable News 2, Channel 9, and the local Government Channel. The agenda was also posted in the lobby of the County Administration Building for the required length of time and was published on the County website. 2. Prayer and Pledge of Allegiance……………………………Jason Cavalier THE FOLLOWING IS A SUMMARY OF PROCEEDINGS. IT IS NOT A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT. 3. APPROVE AGENDA Chairman Richards called for a motion to approve the Agenda. Motion to Approve by J. Cavalier; 2 nd by Y. Cureton. Called vote: 7:0. Motion approved unanimously. 2 4. APPROVE MINUTES a. September 16, 2025 Regular Minutes Chairman Richards called for a motion to approve amended minutes September 16, 2025, Regular Minutes as written. Motion to Approve amended minutes by J. Tinklenberg; 2 nd by J. Cavalier. Called vote: 7:0. Motion approved unanimously. b. October 21, 2025, Regular Minutes Chairman Richards called for a motion to approve October 21, 2025, Regular Minutes as written. Motion to Approve by J. Cavalier; 2nd by L. Hinson. Called vote: 7:0. Motion approved unanimously. c. November 6, 2025, Workshop Minutes Chairman Richards called for a motion to approve November 6, 2025, Workshop Minutes as written. Motion to Approve by J. Cavalier; 2nd by Y. Cureton. Called vote: 7:0. Motion approved unanimously. Chairman Richards and Commissioner Hinson discussed the recent amended Planning Commission’s rules and procedures stating a commissioner could vote or abstain on a meeting’s minutes if not present at that meeting. Chairman Richards opened the floor to comments from the public. 5. CITIZEN’S COMMENTS [see Sign-In sheet attached] 1. Dana Nickerson (Email) Chairman Richards summarized, please see attachments for full comment. 2. Desiree Accetturo (Email) Chairman Richards summarized, please see attachments for full comment. 3. Jeanine Clifton (Indian Land) shared her frustrations with the continued development of Barberville development and pleads for help from the Planning Commission. 3 4. Geoff Larson (Indian Land) shared his concerns over the Barberville Rd/Fort Mill highway project and its advertised business and current zoning, as well as a plan that was released that had his backyard as the property’s daycare playground. Chairman Richards and April Williams discussed presenting DA-2024-1663 and RZ- 2024-1663 together and holding separate public hearings for the items. RZ-2025-1292 MPV Activity Road will be presented separately. 6. PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS FOR RECOMMENDATION TO COUNCIL a. DA-2024-1663 Meritage Homes Application by Tim Sheehy for Meritage Homes of the Carolinas for a Development Agreement for 355 acres located between Charlotte Highway and Activity Drive (p/o TM# 0044-00-0006.00) to allow development of single-family residential development. Staff Presentation: April Williams presented the application consistent with the staff report. Staff Recommendations: Approval, with all concerns and comments being forwarded to the ad hoc committee for this project. Questions to staff: Commissioner Cureton and April Williams discussed how the development agreement for DA-2024-2259 compares to DA-2024-1663. Commissioner Cureton stated she felt there was not enough discussion on this DA to have a vote. April Williams explained that this DA is not asking for cluster zoning, has a clause about being subject to future impact fees by the county, and a few minor changes regarding deadlines. Comment from applicant(s): Sarah Shirley (Fort Mill) spoke on behalf of Kimley-Horn. She introduced John Lintner and Tim Sheehy, both with Meritage Homes, Bailey Patrick and Mike Bilodeau with MPV Properties, and Dan Ballou, the attorney who helped draft up the development agreement, which was voluntary. She presented for the Meritage Homes portion. She explained that changes were made after hearing conversations with the public and Planning Commission. She stated they had changed the cluster zoning, added verbiage regarding future impact fees, the land donation for the proposed school, and the community not being age restricted. The traffic impact analysis is also being looked at. She discussed a letter sent to the school district pledging the acreage. She discussed the site plan and proposed residential homes. 4 John Lintner (Charlotte) spoke on behalf of Meritage Homes. He introduced Meritage as a company and stated that they primarily serve young buyers, and plan with community in mind. Questions from Commissioners: Commissioner Cavalier and Sarah Shirley discussed how contingent this DA is on the DA-2024-2259 being approved. Should that development not move forward, this group is willing to donate the 25 acres needed for the school. Commissioner Cureton and John Lintner discussed the price point of these homes with the current average income in Lancaster. The homes will be between 1,500 and 3,500 square ft with sales prices being in the 300,000s. Commissioner Tinklenberg and Sarah Shirley discussed the school district’s response to Kimley-Horn reaching out regarding the land donation for the proposed school site, and that specifics about the grading of land would be worked out with them. Commissioner Liu and April Williams discussed the difference between Rural Neighborhood, Medium Density Residential, and Low Density Residential. Commissioner Liu and Sarah Shirley discussed the increase in homes if the rezoning were to be passed. Commissioner Liu shared her concerns over the area being developed as current infrastructure will not support it. Chairman Richards and Commissioner Liu discussed waiting for her concerns to be shared in general discussion. Bailey Patrick (Charlotte) spoke on behalf of MPV Properties. He introduced the site and explained that a meeting with the school district was planned and donating the full 25 acres if DA-2024-2259 was not approved. Lennar has met with fire and EMS and they have discussed moving the proposed site for them closer to 521, and MPV will also pledge the land needed if DA-2024-2259 were not to be approved. Commissioner Lui and Bailey Patrick discussed the vacant 2-acre site on the map. Commissioner Cavalier clarified for the upcoming motion that MPV properties were pledging the two acres. Commissioner Cureton and April Williams discussed the correct school district for this area. 5 Public Hearing: (See attachments: Sign-in Sheets) 1. Libby Sweat-Lambert (Lancaster) shared her concerns with loss of rural life and the dirt road to her home. She shared that there was already an increase in traffic and problems caused by this proposed development and rezoning. 2. Lauren Kirby (Kershaw) is the land manger specialist at Katawba Valley Land Trust. She shared that Cane Creek is a federally protected watershed due to the federally endangered Carolina Heelsplitter and erosion from construction may be detrimental to their health and habitat. Chairman Richards closed Public hearing and called for a motion on item DA-2024-1663 Meritage Homes. Sarah Shirley responded that they are adhering to the current UDO standards regarding the engendered Carolina Heelsplitter. They also have environmental scientists that advise on preserving the area buffers around those streams. Motion to approve with the added comments by Bailey Patrick to include the full 25 acres and 2 acres for the EMS and Fire by Jason Cavlier; 2 nd by Y. Cureton with the added language on buffers. County Attorney Merck-Dupont asks, for the record, “Commissioner Cavalier, are you willing to add Commissioner Cureton’s part about the [Carolina] Heelsplitter into your original motion as opposed to us making an amendment?” Commissioner Cavalier clarified if he needs to make an amendment or restate the previous one. County Attorney Merck-Dupont replied he can restate the motion. Commissioner Cavalier motions to approve to include the total acreage required by the school system for the development of a school, the acreage for EMS emergency services, fire, etc., and the buffering for the Carolina Heelsplitter protection. Chairman Richards, Commissioner Lui, and County Attorney Merck-Dupont discussed how the votes would be conducted as the items were presented together. Commissioner Cureton reiterated her comment on not having enough time to discuss DA- 2024-1663 Meritage Homes, she would like to amend this motion table this item until the next regular meeting. County Attorney Merck-Dupont explained that her motion needs a second and a vote. F. Liu seconded. Chairman Richards stated the motion to table and asked if anyone one like to have a discussion. Discussion: 6 Commissioner Cavalier stated that these items weren’t discussed as much due to less caveats being added, such as the impact fees. He also feels that due to these items being related projects, the discussion is much the same and tableing it would not make a difference. Chairman Richards and Commissioner Lui discussed how the amendments were added in with little discussion. Chairman Richards stated that the buffers added in the amendment were already in the site plan. Sarah Shirley confirmed. Bailey Patrick stated that the EMS and fire station on 521 is new information that they had learned about today. April Williams clarified that all recommendations will be forwarded to the ad hoc committee for this project. Commissioner Curton and April Williams discussed the ad hoc committee. Commissioner Cureton withdrew her motion. Commissioner Liu and County Attorney Merck-Dupont discussed the possibility of voting yes on one item and no on the other. Roll Called vote: 7:0. Motion is approved unanimously. The item will be referred to County Council for final decision, and applicants will be informed of time and date b. RZ-2024-1663 Meritage Homes Application by Tim Sheehy for Meritage Homes of the Carolinas to rezone approximately 355 acres located between Charlotte Highway and Activity Drive (p/o TM# 0044-00-0006.00) from Rural Residential (RR) to Medium Density Residential (MDR) District, to allow development of single-family residential development. Staff Presentation: Matthew Blaszyck presented the applications consistent with the staff report. Staff Recommendations: Approval Questions to staff: Please see DA-2024-1663. 7 Comment from applicant(s): Please see DA-2024-1663. Questions from Commissioners: Please see DA-2024-1663. Chairman Richards called for a motion on item RZ-2024-1663 Meritage Homes. Motion to approve by Jason Cavalier; 2 nd by L. Hinson. Discussion: Commissioner Lui shares that the public is begging for controlled growth. She stated the if the area was rezoned, 223 homes could be added. She also shared concerns over lack of funds for EMS and fire stations and schools being over capacity. Public Hearing: (See attachments: Sign-in Sheets) 1. Libby Sweat-Lambert (Lancaster) shares how she has been told repeatedly she is wasting her time. She pleads with the Planning Commissions help to plan Lancaster well. 2. Bill Dyke (Lancaster) shared his concerns over the proposed growth, loss of rural life, loss of dirt road, and higher taxes. 3. Lauren Kirby (Kershaw) reiterated the importance of protecting the Carolina Heelsplitter’s through preserving the wetlands along Cane Creek. Chairman Richards closed Public hearing. Discussion: County Attorney Merck-Dupont stated, for the record, “Commissioners, we did have the motion and the second to approve and you were in discussion. So you'd be back in discussion at this point.” Chairman Richards invited Commissioner Lui to finish her discussion. Commissioner Liu reiterated that voting no to rezone is not a vote against growth. It's a vote for controlled growth by leaving it in the rural neighborhood in a growth area. Chairman Richards invites the applicants to respond to Public Comments: Bailey Patrick stated he was a friend of the founder of Katawba Valley Land Trust and they plan to protect the wetland with a 200 ft buffer. He stated they will be planning it right, also be adding roads that will help Lancaster, as well as the businesses that will contribute to taxes. 8 Sarah Shirley stated that they are looking for plans that don’t just meet the UDO or meets zoning requirements, but that is well thought out. Commissioner Liu addressed Chairman Richards and inquired if this opportunity for to address the public comments was being taken as a rebuttal of the Planning Commission’s discussion. Commissioner Liu and County Attorney Merck-Dupont discussed the chairperson inviting the applicant to speak. Sarah Shirley clarified the public comments she was addressing. Discussion: Commissioner Lui stated this would be a quality development, but this does not justify an additional 223 homes with the rezoning. Commissioner Cureton inquired about the yearly updates on the Comprehensive plan for the Planning Commission to be able to see where proposed developments will be according to it. Also, the hosing tax study proposed in the workshop of November to see the feasibility of proposed home prices. Commissioner Cavalier, April Williams, and Commissioner Liu discussed the home density increase with the new proposed rezoning. Commissioner Cureton and April Williams discussed if the number of homes being built would affect the proposed commercial development. Roll called vote: 0:7. Motion is denied unanimously. The item will be referred to the County Council for final decision, and applicants will be informed of time and date. c. RZ-2025-1292 MPV Activity Road Application by Mike Bilodeau/ MPV Properties for 521 Lancaster LLC to rezone approximately 48.339 acres located at Charlotte Highway near Lewis McAteer Rd (TM# 0044-00-004.00 and p/o 0044-00-006.00) from Rural Residential (RN) to General Business (GB) District, to allow development as a commercial property. Staff Presentation: Corey Barnes presented the application consistent with the staff report. Staff Recommendations: Approval. Questions to staff: Planning Commission shared no questions or concerns. 9 Comment from applicant(s): Sarah Shirley (Fort Mill) explained that the site plan is generalized to present it to the Planning Commission. The overall site is 63 acres, but only 48 of those acres need to be rezoned. The property that's to the south is already currently zoned GB. Mike Bilodeau (Charlotte) introduced MPV Properties and other projects MPV Properties are responsible for in Lancaster. He stated this commercial area would serve more than just the community behind it. He stated that as more homes develop behind it, there will be more opportunity to develop a commercial project, and commercial growth needs to be planned in tandem with residential to see where commercial growth is needed. Questions from Commissioners: Commissioner Liu stated she lived near a project that was mentioned and commended it for traffic control. Public Hearing: (See attachments: Sign-in Sheets) 1. Libby Sweatt-Lambert (Lancaster) shared her concerns over the possible increase in crime and the loss of rural life. 2. Lauren Kirby (Heath Springs) shared the effect of impervious surfaces on environments, and the possible effect it will have on the nearby creek and endangered Carolina Heelsplitter. Chairman Richards closed Public hearing and called for a motion on item RZ-2025-1292 MPV Activity Road. Motion to approve by Y. Cureton; 2 nd by J. Cavalier. Discussion: Commissioner Liu addressed the concerns brought up by Lauren Kirby. Mike Bilodeau replied that the issues have been addressed in accordance with UDO requirements. Commissioner Liu and Sarah Shirley discussed the possibility of adding in Katawba Valley Land Trust as a reviewer for their plans. Commissioner Cavalier shared his concerns of flow off into the wetlands and addressed a previous project that included bio retention ponds with specific flora that are designed to pick up these chemicals and if this could be applied to this project. Sarah Shirley stated that along with storm water retention there is also a maintenance program. Commissioner L. Hinson shared her concern over the statement that the commercial project would not move forward if the rezoning was not approved. Mike Bilodeau stated that what he felt he said is commercial development is dependent on the number of homes a residential area has, the average income, and population. 10 Roll Called vote: 7:0. Motion is approved unanimously. The item will be referred to County Council for final decision, and applicant will be informed of time and date. Recess taken at 7:45pm. Meeting resumes at 7:51pm. 7. NON-HEARING ITEMS a. RN-2023-2016 Trinity School Lane Application by Sheila Shipman on behalf of Trinity Montessori School to name a driveway off the 2700 block of Lengers Way (at TM 0008-00-026.01) pursuant to Sec. 6.11.4.G of the Unified Development Ordinance. The proposed name of the private drive is Trinity School Lane. Staff Presentation: Jennifer Bryan, Planning Technician, presented the application consistent with the staff report. Staff Recommendation: Approval. Questions to Staff: Commissioner Liu and Jennifer Bryan discussed her concern over a business naming a road after itself. Jennifer Bryan clarified that this name change was proposed through civil plan rather than a direct application. Commissioner Cureton and Jennifer Bryan discussed this road being privately maintained. No public hearing is required. Chairman Richards called for a motion on item RN-2023-2016. Motion to approve by Y. Cureton; 2 nd by L. Hinson. Discussion: Planning Commission expressed no comments or concerns. Called vote: 6:1. Motion is approved. F. Lui opposed. The Planning Commission has final approval of new road names. Commissioner Lui clarified that her vote was to be consistent in voting against business that request a road named after them. 11 8. OTHER a. Review of Next Month’s Agenda April Williams explained that at next month’s meeting there will be training. Commissioner Tinklenberg requested a Comprehensive Plan update. April Williams and Commissioner Cureton discussed the proposed hosing study. Allison Hardin explained that there would be a Comprehensive Plan update every April. The state policy is to update every five years and to rewrite every 10, however, it was decided that yearly updates were warranted. The next update will be April 2026. 9. Status of Items Tabled, Recommitted, Deferred or Held a. SD-2023-0867 Catawba Ridge (Edgewater) Application by ESP Associates and Catawba Ridge Holdings LLC for a preliminary plat for 840 acres north of Great Falls Highway (TMs 0128-00-012.00 & 0126-00- 048.00), for a residential community of 1,438 lots. Applicant has requested indefinite hold while revisions and Traffic Impact Analysis are completed. April Williams explained the deferment of item SD-2023-0867. Chairman Richards and April Williams disused it’s connection to Edgewater. Commissioner Tinklenberg and April Williams discussed the status of the RFP study. Commissioner Cureton discussed wanting to see more information regarding Lancaster city planning, to help make decisions for Lancaster County planning. 10. ADJOURN Motion to adjourn by J. Cavalier; 2nd by Y. Cureton. Motion approved by unanimous consent. Meeting adjourned at 8:12 p.m.

Source: Lancaster County website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.