RecordWell Data

Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting — Agenda Packet

Lancaster County · Lancaster County · Board of Zoning Appeals · meeting of Nov 4, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Lancaster County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Board of Zoning Appeals Members Vacant Mark Boland Charles Deese James Faulkenberry Aaron Fender County Attorney Ginny L. Merck-Dupont Secretary to BZA Mara Mata Planning Director April Williams November 4, 2025 6:00 PM BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS County Council Chambers, County Administration Building, 101 North Main Street, Lancaster, SC 29720 AGENDA 1. Call to Order Regular Meeting 2. Approval of the Agenda 3. Approval of Minutes a. Minutes of October 7th, 2025 BZA Meeting 4. Public Hearing Items a. BZA-2025-2088 Nunns/Boron Application by Emily Brown Law LLC on behalf of David & Tamara Boron at 7940 Green Pond Rd (TM 0014-00-010.05) to appeal a Home Occupation Permit granted to adjacent property owners George & Jessica Nunns, 7965 Green Pond Road (TM 0014-00-010.04) 5. Adjournment Anyone requiring special services to attend this meeting should contact 285-1565 at least 24 hours in advance of this meeting. Lancaster County Board of Zoning Appeals agendas are posted at the Lancaster County Administration Building and are available on the Website: https://www.lancastercountysc.gov/ Meetings are livestreamed and can be found by using the following link: https://www.youtube.com/@LancasterCoSCGov/streams Page 1 of 100 MEMBERS OF LANCASTER COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS CHARLES . K. DEESE JAMES FAULKENBERRY MARK BOLAND AARON FENDER JOSHUA PANGLE 1 MINUTES OF THE LANCASTER COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS REGULAR MEETING October 7, 2025, at 6:00 PM 1. Roll Call/Call to Order Board Members present: Quorum is present (5 Board Members) Charles Deese; Mark Boland; Aaron Fender; James Faulkenberry; Joshua Pangle* *Joshua Pangle was sworn in prior to meeting. Staff: Allison Hardin, Development Services Director Mara Mata, Administrative Assistant Members of the press were notified in advance but were not present. All adjacent property owners were notified by mail. A notice of public hearing was published in the Lancaster News at least 15 days prior to the meeting. The agenda was posted on the County website and posted in the lobby of the administration Building one week prior to the meeting. A copy of the agenda is on file. THE FOLLOWING IS A SUMMARY ONLY; IT IS NOT A VERBATIM TRANSCRIPT. Chairman Deese called the meeting to order at 6:01 p.m. 2. Approval of Agenda J. Faulkenberry moved to Approve the Agenda; Second by J. Pangle. The motion was approved by unanimous consent. 3. Approval of Minutes a. Minutes of 8/5/2025 Meeting Call for a motion. Motion to approve as written by J. Faulkenberry; Second by A. Fender. Vote: 5:0 Minutes are approved Page 2 of 100 b. Minutes of 9/23/2025 Joint Training Meeting Chairman Deese states what he learned in the training. Board Member Boland asked for the title to add “Board of Zoning Appeals.” Call for a motion. Motion to approve by M. Boland; Second by J. Faulkenberry Vote: 5:0 Minutes are approved Chairman Deese asked for clarification on swearing in if there is no public meeting. Allison Hardin replied that he did not have to do that. 4. Other a. Review of Proposed Meeting Dates for 2026 Chairman Deese and Allison Hardin discussed moving motions or minutes if there is no case on the agenda. Chairman Deese discusses why the previous BZA was disbanded. The board members discussed changing the September meeting. Call for a motion. Motion to approve by M. Boland; Second by J. Faulkenberry Vote: 5:0 meeting dates are approved b. Review of Continuing Education Requirements Allison Hardin reminded the members that the board is required to complete 3 hours of training every year for continuing education. If the board members have required training from their own careers that relate to BZA, that will qualify towards those 3 hours. There will be a group viewing of the annual webinar from South Carolina Association of Counties on 11/13 from 9:30 a .m. to 12:30 p.m. that will qualify for the annual 3 hours education requirements. More information can be found on the SCAC website. c. Report of Joint Training Meeting: FOIA Presentations from the meeting are attached. Page 3 of 100 d. Packet regarding BZA-2025-2088 Chairman Deese cautions board members on interacting with the involved parties due to potential bias. Chairman Deese thanks the board members. 5. Adjournment: With there being no further business, motion to adjourn by J. Pangle; Second by A. Fender. The motion was approved by unanimous consent. Adjourned at 6:27 PM. Page 4 of 100 Page 5 of 100 Page 6 of 100 Page 7 of 100 Page 8 of 100 Page 9 of 100 Page 10 of 100 Page 11 of 100 Page 12 of 100 Page 13 of 100 Page 14 of 100 Page 15 of 100 Page 16 of 100 Page 17 of 100 Page 18 of 100 Page 19 of 100 Page 20 of 100 Page 21 of 100 Page 22 of 100 Page 23 of 100 Page 24 of 100 Page 25 of 100 Page 26 of 100 Page 27 of 100 Page 28 of 100 Page 29 of 100 Page 30 of 100 Page 31 of 100 Case No. BZA-2025-2088 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: November 4, 2025 BZA 2025-2088 Staff Report, Page 1 REQUEST: Application by David and Tamara Boron, 7940 Green Pond Rd, to appeal the issuance of a Home Occupation Permit to George and Jessica Nunns, 7965 Green Pond Rd. PROPERTY LOCATION: Subject property owned by George and Jessica Nunns has two address numbers: 7965 Green Pond Rd (residence) and 7961 Green Pond Rd (accessory structure). TAX MAP NUMBER: TM# 0014-00-010.04 ZONING DISTRICT: Rural Neighborhood (RN) BACKGROUND Administrative Decision Summary May 12, 2025: Code Enforcement staff received a complaint from Tammy Boron regarding a home business being operated on property owned by the Nunns. The complaint stated that the Nunns were “running a home manufacturing business in a rural neighborhood with an implied easement of our private driveway with heavy commercial delivery trucks daily, damaging our driveway, and property.” May 13, 2025: Code Enforcement staff performed a site visit and physically issued a Notice of Violation to the owners of 7965 Green Pond Rd (Nunns), instructing the owners to “come to the Zoning Department and get a home occupation permit.” Staff noted that there was an accessory structure on the site; records indicated that the structure had been on site since 2000. May 16, 2025: George Nunns went to the Zoning Department and applied for a home occupation permit. The address for the home occupation permit was changed from their residence (7965 Green Pond Rd) to the address for their accessory building (7961 Green Pond Rd). The description o f the home occupation was “Internet Golf Sales” as Mr. Nunns embellishes golf clubs through online transactions. As part of the application, sections of the Lancaster County Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) are provided on th e application form, and applicants are instructed to read and initial the sections. Code references on the application include General Standards, Additional Standards, Uses Prohibited as Home Occupations, and Grandfathered Home Occupations. The applicant initialed each section. The same day, Mrs. Boron called the Zoning Department and received an update on the violation. May 21-22, 2025: After reviewing the application, staff issued the Home Occupation Permit for 7961 Green Pond Rd, Indian Land to George Nunns. The Conditions included limits that the occupation “is for office use only. For online sales and paperwork.” Mr. Nunns paid the Home Occupation Permit fee of $75.00 and received the Home Occupation Permit. The complaint was marked “Resolved” on May 23. June 10-11, 2025: Mrs. Boron calls the Zoning Department to ask about the complaint and about road issues. Zoning and Code Enforcement staff left a message on June 11, 2025 updating Mrs. Boron and advising her that she could file a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request to receive copies of the files. July 10, 2025: FOIA request received from the Borons. August 1, 2025: All materials from the FOIA request were delivered to the Borons. September 5, 2025: David and Tamara Boron applied for an appeal to the decision to issue a Home Occupation Permit to George Nunns, 35 days after receipt of materials relating to the permit. Page 32 of 100 Case No. BZA-2025-2088 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: November 4, 2025 BZA 2025-2088 Staff Report, Page 2 SITE INFORMATION The subject property owned by the Nunns is approximately 2.35 acres in size and is zoned Rural Neighborhood (RN). It is located on the west side of Green Pond Rd. The E911 Department has issued two addresses to the property: one for the primary structure (a residence, listed as 7965 Green Pond Rd) and one for the accessory structure (a garage, listed as 7961 Green Pond Rd). RELEVANT CODE SECTIONS – HOME OCCUPATIONS Section 2.5.3 Use Table 5.4.2 HOME OCCUPATION [AR, RR, RN, MH, LDR, MDR, PB, RB, UR, HDR, RMX, MX, IMX] A. General Standards 1. Any internal or external modifications, either permanent or accessory, that will make the dwelling appear less residential, either in nature or function, are prohibited. The dwelling and site must remain residential in appearance and characteristics. 2. The home occupation must be conducted within the dwelling or permitted accessory structure. It shall not exceed 25 percent of the gross floor area of the dwelling or 500 square feet, whichever is greater. 3. The home occupation shall not be operated by any person other than residents living in the dwelling, and shall not employ more than one non-resident of the dwelling for employment at the dwelling. Page 33 of 100 Case No. BZA-2025-2088 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: November 4, 2025 BZA 2025-2088 Staff Report, Page 3 4. No equipment, material, or process shall be used in any such home occupation that produces or emits any additional noise; increased vibration; intensified lighting or glare; smoke, dust, or other particulate matter; excessive heat or humidity; blight or unsightliness; gas, fumes, or odor; increased electrical interference; or any other nuisances, hazards, or objectionable conditions detectable at the boundary of the lot, if the occupation is conducted in a detached dwelling unit, or outside the dwelling unit, if conducted in an attached dwelling unit. Explosive or highly flammable materials and toxic or hazardous waste are not permitted. 5. Hours of operation for deliveries, clients, and operation of mechanical or electrical equipment shall be limited to the hours between 7:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. 6. One non-illuminated sign of two square feet in area or smaller is allowed. The sign must be attached to the dwelling and must be compatible with the building architecture and materials. 7. Traffic, Parking, and Vehicles a. No vehicular traffic may be generated by the home occupation business in greater volumes than would reasonably be expected in the residential neighborhood, nor may it create unreasonable parking or traffic congestion for the residents of the immediate neighborhood. Any parking or traffic of such character, intensity, or continued duration that substantially interferes with the comfortable enjoyment of private homes by persons of ordinary sensibilities shall be considered unreasonable. b. Commercial vehicles and semi-tractor trailers shall not access a property from a shared driveway. If parked or stored within 100 feet of any property or right-of- way line, commercial vehicles or trailers shall be fully screened by a solid wood or vinyl fence, or masonry wall, berm, or opaque evergreen landscaping. c. Any parking associated with the home occupation shall occur on the premises and not within a public or private right-of-way. Any parking in the front yard shall be as per the requirements of Section 7.2.5.A.10, and screened in accordance with the requirements of Section 5.4.2.A.7.b, above, regardless of distance from any property or right-of-way line. Additional parking may be provided in the side and rear yards. B. Additional Standards for Specific Types of Home Occupations 1. Personal Services. Personal services, including cosmetic services, salons, barber shops, and non-permanent makeup services, but not including nail salons, may be permitted provided they comply with all of the following: a. Shall meet all applicable state requirements; b. Any exterior entrance/exit to an area of the principal building shall be on the side or rear of the building; Page 34 of 100 Case No. BZA-2025-2088 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: November 4, 2025 BZA 2025-2088 Staff Report, Page 4 c. Only incidental sales of cosmetic and hair products shall be allowed on the premises; d. No more than one barber/styling chair, and no more than two hair drying chairs shall be permitted; e. All barber/styling chairs and hair drying chairs shall be located together in either the main dwelling or within an accessory building, and shall not be split between said buildings; and f. All service professionals shall include copies of their State professional licenses (if applicable) in the home occupation application submittal. 2. Group Instruction Services . Group instruction services, including but not limited to teaching art, dance, music, and tutoring may be provided so long as the group does not exceed four persons at any time. Additionally, adequate parking must be provided onsite for both the residents of the dwelling and the maximum number of clients receiving instructional services; however said parking for clients is not required to be permanent. 3. Independent Contractors . Independent contractors include, but are not limited to, electric or plumbing contractors, landscapers and similar businesses that have employees and require the storage of commercial vehicles or equipment on the property. These businesses may be permitted provided that they comply with all of the following: a. The property upon which the home occupation will be located must be zoned either AR, RN, RR, LDR or MH District; b. When located within an accessory building(s), the floor area of the home occupation shall not cumulatively exceed 3,000 square feet or 75 percent of the gross floor area of the principal dwelling, whichever is greater; c. Any goods or materials, but not vehicles or equipment, associated with the home occupation shall be stored entirely within an enclosed structure on the premises, or screened from view of any street, public or private right -of-way, or adjacent property by an opaque evergreen screen or fence; 4. Retail Sales . Onsite retail sales conducted directly from the home (not including internet sales business) shall be limited to the sale of handmade items grown or produced on-site such as: arts and crafts, clothing, foodstuffs, furniture, and/or jewelry. C. Prohibited Home Occupations. The following are prohibited as home occupations due to the nature of their operation having the tendency to impair the use and value of surrounding properties in a residential district: 1. Automotive uses (Section 2.5.3); 2. Civic uses (Section 2.5.3); 3. Commercial/Entertainment uses (Section 2.5.3), except for those specific retail uses Page 35 of 100 Case No. BZA-2025-2088 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: November 4, 2025 BZA 2025-2088 Staff Report, Page 5 permitted by Section 5.4.3.B.; 4. Educational/Institutional uses (Section 2.5.3), except for Child/Adult Day Care Home (5 or fewer persons) and Studio; 5. Halfway Homes; 6. Industry/Wholesale/Storage uses (Section 2.5.3); 7. Infrastructure uses (Section 2.5.3), except for Artist Studio/Light Manufacturing Workshops; 8. Lodging uses (Section 2.5.3.); 9. Office/Services uses (Section 2.5.3), except for Personal Services permitted by Section 5.4.3.B., Business Support Services, and Professional Services; and, 10. Residential Care Facilities. D. Grandfathered Home Occupations 1. Home occupation permits issued prior to the effective date of this section shall be grandfathered. However, any subsequent home occupation permit issued at the same address must be in conformance with these standards. 2. Any expansion of a grandfathered home occupation shall be in compliance with the standards of Section 5.4.2. 3. Any change of a grandfathered home occupation to a different home occupation shall require that the new home occupation be in compliance with the standards of Section 5.4.2. (Ord. No. 2021-1715, 03-08-2021) 10.3 DEFINITIONS – USE TYPE HOME OCCUPATION An occupation or profession conducted within a dwelling unit by a resident that is incidental to the primary use of the dwelling as a residence. Home Occupations are small and quiet businesses generally invisible from the frontage requiring little parking , little or no signage, and having only one or two employees and provide services such as professional services, music instruction, and hair styling. For the purposes of this ordinance, telecommuting shall not constitute the establishment of a home occupation. PROFESSIONAL SERVICES Services provided that make available the knowledge and skills of their employees to sell expertise and perform professional, scientific, and technical services to others such as legal services; accounting, tax, bookkeeping, and payroll services; architectural, engineering, and related services; graphic, industrial, and interior design services; consulting services; research and development services; advertising, media, and photography services; real estate services; investment banking , Page 36 of 100 Case No. BZA-2025-2088 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: November 4, 2025 BZA 2025-2088 Staff Report, Page 6 securities, brokerages, and insurance-related services; and medical services such as physician and dentist offices. ARTIST STUDIO/LIGHT MAUFACTURING WORKSHOP The assembly, fabrication, production, or processing of goods and materials using processes that ordinarily do not create noise, smoke, fumes, odors, glare, or health or safety hazards outside of the building and are visually undifferentiated from an office building or a residentially-scaled garage. These typically involve the work of artisans or craftsman. RELEVANT CODE SECTIONS – ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL 9.2.14 APPEAL OF ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS A. APPLICABILITY This process is hereby established to provide an appeal process for parties aggrieved by any administrative order, requirement, decision or determination, made by an administrative officer charged with enforcing the provisions of this ordinance. B. FILING PROCEDURES 1. Process Type: Quasi-Judicial. 2. Filing Procedure: An appeal of an administrative decision may be taken by any person aggrieved (or by their authorized agent) or may be taken by any officer, department, board or bureau of the County. Such an appeal shall be made to the County within 30 days of the receipt of the written notice of decision from the County. 3. Stay of Proceedings: The filing of an appeal shall stay all proceedings in furtherance of the contested action unless the Administrator certifies that, in his/her opinion, by reason of facts stated in the certification, such a stay would cause imminent peril to life and property. In such a case, proceedings shall not be stayed except by restraining order granted by the Court of Common Pleas on notice to the administrative official from whom the appeal is taken with due cause shown. 4. Required Application Information: All information relevant to describing the applicant’s appeal to the Board of Zoning Appeals is required. The Administrator shall similarly prepare a report detailing the regulations and interpretation behind the matter being appealed and their reason for their decision. 5. Public Notification: Level 1 and 3. C. FORMAL REVIEW 1. Upon receiving the application, the Board shall conduct a public hearing on the matter. Any party may appear in person or be represented by an agent at the hearing. 2. After conducting the public hearing, the Board shall adopt an order reversing or affirming, wholly or in part, or modifying the order requirements, decision or determination in question. It shall take a 4/5ths vote of the Board to reverse or modify the contested action. Page 37 of 100 Case No. BZA-2025-2088 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: November 4, 2025 BZA 2025-2088 Staff Report, Page 7 3. The Board, in making its ruling, shall have all the powers of the Administrator from whom the appeal is taken, and may issue or direct the issuance of a permit. 4. The decision of the Board must be in writing and permanently filed in the minutes of that reviewing body as a public record. All findings of fact and conclusions of law must be separately stated in final decisions or orders of the Board, which must be delivered to parties of interest by certified mail. D. APPEALS Any appeal from a decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals may be made by an aggrieved party and shall be made to the Circuit Court of Lancaster County in the nature of certiorari. Any such petition shall be filed no later than 30 days after the applicant receives a written copy of the decision of the Board of Zoning Appeals. STAFF’S EVALUATION The applicant has filed a statement with their Appeal from Action of Zoning Official, which is attached to this report. Staff has summarized the complaint into the following points to be addressed: 1. Incorrect address on the application 2. Incorrect square footage listed on the home occupation application 3. Shared driveway/Green Pond Rd 4. Commercial traffic and speeds, and impact on the access point 5. Use of more square footage than allowed ISSUE 1: Incorrect address on the application APPLICANT’S CLAIM: George Nunns put an address on the permit application that “is not a valid address.” STAFF’S RESPONSE: The correct address was placed on the application. EXPLANATION: The Lancaster County E911 Coordinator is responsible for issuing addresses for structures in the County’s jurisdiction. At times, the E911 Coordinator will issue more than one address to a piece of property when the situation warrants. For the Nunns’ property, the residence is addressed as 7965 Green Pond Rd. The garage where the Nunns operate their home occupation was given a separate address of 7961 Green Pond Rd. These addresses are part of the data layers that are visible on the Assessor’s online GIS system: Page 38 of 100 Case No. BZA-2025-2088 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: November 4, 2025 BZA 2025-2088 Staff Report, Page 8 ISSUE 2: Incorrect square footage listed on the home occupation application APPLICANT’S CLAIM: Mr. Nunns “listed the gross floor area of the home occupation as 475 square feet, but his accessory building is approximately 1,178 square feet according to the Lancaster County Tax Assessor GIS information.” STAFF’S RESPONSE: Mr. Nunns correctly filled out the application. EXPLANATION: The Home Occupation permit contains multiple fields for applicants to fill out. Applicants must indicate both the square footage of the structure and the “total square footage dedicated for use by the home occupation” which may be in more than one structure. Mr. Nunns filled out both area calculations as required under Section 5.4.2 of the application (screen capture below of the application submitted on 5/16/25): Total Square Footage of Accessory Building: 1,178 [sq ft] Total Square Footage Dedicated for the Use: 475 [sq ft] Figure 1. Screen Capture of Current Parcel Data, Lancaster County Assessor’s Office. Accessed October 27, 2028. Figure 2. Close-up of Application for Home Occupation. Page 39 of 100 Case No. BZA-2025-2088 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: November 4, 2025 BZA 2025-2088 Staff Report, Page 9 ISSUE 3: Shared driveway/Green Pond Rd APPLICANT’S CLAIM: The Borons claim that the “shared driveway” that accesses the Nunns’ property is entirely located on their property. STAFF’S RESPONSE: Staff research shows the easement is located along the property line. EXPLANATION: Staff performed a title and plat search for the access point in question. The applicants claim that “the Nunns use a shared driveway located on the Boron’s property;” research indicates that the “shared driveway” is part of a 30-foot-wide easement that is located equally on either side of the property line for the four properties that have access to it. The easement was created by plat and deed in 1998 when the trust for Elizabeth Wilson Brown subdivided the 12 acres owned by Ms. Brown into four (4) separate parcels. The property deed that created the Nunns’ property (1998) states: “Beginning at a point in the center of Green Pond Road Extension…all of which is more accurately shown on a Plat of Property of Elizabeth Wilson Brown, Trustee prepared by David D. Shaw Land Surveying, Inc. on November 2, 1998 and recorded in the Office of the Clerk of Court for Lancaster County, South Carolina. Grantor grants unto grantee, his heirs and assigns, a right of way for egress and ingress to and from the above described property to Green Pond Road Extension as is more accurately shown on the above referenced plat.” (Source: Title to Real Estate, Deed Book 31, Page 286, et al.) Figure 3. Identification of the easement. Data accessed October 27, 2025 Page 40 of 100 Case No. BZA-2025-2088 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: November 4, 2025 BZA 2025-2088 Staff Report, Page 10 This plat has remained unchanged until the Borons filed a request for a minor subdivision of property on June 3, 2025. The plat was conditionally approved on June 12, 2025 and expands on the easement by adding another driveway off of it. Figure 4. Plat Instrument 9800-813 (Plat Book 9800, Page 813) Figure 5. Plat Instrument Plat Book 2025, Page 407 Page 41 of 100 Case No. BZA-2025-2088 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: November 4, 2025 BZA 2025-2088 Staff Report, Page 11 Regardless of where the actual graded path is located, deeds and plats show that the Borons and Nunns both equally share a 30 -ft-wide easement that is split by their shared property line. This easement was dedicated by deed from the Elizabeth White Brown Trust to future property owners via instruments found at Deed Book 31, Page 286 and Plat 9800-813, dated November 2, 1998. To add historical context: staff located multiple plats that showed the easement as a “ public road” and labeled it as “Green Pond Road Extension.” It appears that in the mid-1900s the road went across Tarkill Branch toward Vance Baker Rd; neighbors informally told staff that at some point, the bridge washed out, and the road went unused. Staff looked for evidence that the connection was indeed a public road but could not locate any record of the County accepting the road past the point of maintenance tha t exists today. ISSUE 4: Commercial traffic and speeds, and impact on the access point APPLICANT’S CLAIM: “[T]he Borons observe four to five commercial trucks driving at unsafe speeds down their driveway each day.” Additionally, “[t]he trucks also cause ruts in the driveway.” STAFF RESPONSE: Staff is unable to verify applicants’ claim. ISSUE 5: Use of more square footage than allowed APPLICANT’S CLAIM: “The Nunns use the entire accessory building to manufacture and sell golf clubs.” STAFF RESPONSE: Staff has not observed the Nunns using more than the allowable 500 sq ft for their home occupation, so staff is unable to verify applicants’ claim. STAFF NOTE ON ADMINISTRATIVE PROCESS Staff notes that the applicant submitted their appeal more than 30 days after receiving written notice of the action. According to our estimations, this puts the review outside of the window for appeal per Section 9.2.14.B.2: 9.2.14.B.2. Filing Procedure: An appeal of an administrative decision may be taken by any person aggrieved (or by their authorized agent) or may be taken by any officer, department, board or bureau of the County. Such an appeal shall be made to the County within 30 days of the receipt of the written notice of decision from the County. Like other by-right actions, the Home Occupation permit process does not include a notification step to send information regarding new permits issued to neighboring properties. Staff accepted the appeal when presented because “written notice of decision” is not provided for home occupation permits. Unlike other actions, the applicants requested and received copies of the permit and all related files under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). This written notice was completed and provided to the applicants on Friday, August 1, 2025. The applicants then uploaded the application for Appeal from Action of a Zoning Official on Friday, September 5, 2025. Had staff been aware of the FOIA request at the time of application, staff would have rejected the application due to receiving it 35 days after notice. Page 42 of 100 Case No. BZA-2025-2088 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: November 4, 2025 BZA 2025-2088 Staff Report, Page 12 ATTACHMENTS: 1. Appeal Application from Emily N Brown on behalf of David and Tamara Boron, dated September 4, 2025 2. Receipt of Appeal Application, dated September 5, 2025 3. Files from complaint filed by Tamara Boron, July 10, 2025 4. Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) Public Record Request #25-395 – Requester Tammy Boron, July 10, 2025 5. Chain of Title for Nunns property, TMS 0014-00-010.04 6. Copy of Plat 9800 – 0813, recorded November 13, 1998, subdividing 12.1 acres into four (4) lots, and showing 30-ft egress/ingress easement 7. Copy of Deed Book 31, Page 286 (conveyance from Elizabeth Wilson Brown Trust to John Whittemore, including easement language referencing 1998 plat), dated December 28, 1998 – parent of Nunns property, 0014-00-010.04 8. Copy of Deed Book 29, Page 314 (conveyance from Elizabeth Wilson Brown Trust to Dallas Ray Proctor, including easement language for 15 feet easement for 370 feet), dated December 2, 1998 – parent of Borons property, 0014-00-010.05 9. Copy of Plat 2019-488 for TMS 0014-00-010.04 (now owned by Nunns) 10. Copy of Plat 2025-407 for split of TMS 0014-00-010.05 (owned by Borons) 11. Supplemental Images - enlargements of images in staff report: a. Figure 1. Screen Capture of Current Parcel Data, Lancaster County Assessor’s Office. Accessed October 27, 2028 b. Figure 2. Close-up of Application for Home Occupation c. Figure 3. Identification of the easement. Data accessed October 27, 2025 d. Figure 4. Plat Instrument 9800-813 (Plat Book 9800, Page 813) e. Figure 5. Plat Instrument Plat Book 2025, Page 407 . STAFF CONTACT: Allison Hardin, Development Services Director ahardin@lancastercountysc.gov | 803-416-9422 October 28, 2025 Page 43 of 100 BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS APPEAL FROM ACTION OF ZONING OFFICIAL APPLICATION IF YOU REQUIRE ASSISTANCE WITH THIS APPLICATION, PLEASE CONTACT OUR OFFICE AT 803- 416-9777. THE COMPLETED APPLICATION, THE APPLICATION FEE OF $325.00, AND ALL ADDITIONAL MATERIALS ARE REQUIRED TO BE SUBMITTED. THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION MUST BE PROVIDED FOR THE REQUEST: PROPERTY INFORMATION: TAX MAP NUMBER: ______________________________________________________________________________________ STREET ADDRESS: ________________________________________________________________________________________ CITY/ STATE/ ZIP CODE: ___________________________________________________________________________________ LOT DIMENSIONS/ LOT AREA: ___________________PLAT BOOK/PAGE: ____________________________________________ CURRENT ZONING CLASSIFICATION: _________________________________________________________________________ PROPERTY OWNER OF RECORD: NAME: _________________________________________________________________________________________________ ADDRESS: ______________________________________________________________________________________________ CI TY/STATE/ZIP CODE: ____________________________TELEPHONE/FAX NUMBER: _ _________________ EM AIL ADDRESS: _ ______________________________________________________________ SI GNATURE OF OWNER/ DATE: _____________________________________________________________________________ I HAVE APPOINTED THE INDIVIDUAL OR FIRM LISTED BELOW AS MY REPRESENTATIVE IN CONJUNCTION WITH THIS MATTER RELATED TO THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS. AGENT OF OWNER: NAME: _________________________________________________________________________________________________ ADDRESS: ______________________________________________________________________________________________ CITY/STATE/ZIP CODE: ___________________________TELEPHONE/FAX NUMBER: ___________________________________ EM AIL ADDRESS: _ _____________________________________________________________ SI GNATURE OF AGENT/ DATE: ______________________________________________________________________________ SIGNATURE OF OWNER/ DATE: _____________________________________________________________________________ Indian Land, SC 29707 RN (803) 973-0490 0014-00-010.04 7965 Green Pond Road (owned by George and Jessica Nunns) David and Tamara Boron 7940 Green Pond Road Indian Land, SC 29707 P.O. Box 38113 Emily N. Brown Rock Hill, SC 29732 09/04/2025 Page 44 of 100 APPEAL FROM ACTION OF ZONING OFFICIAL APPLICATION Date Filed: Application No. 1. THE APPLICANT HEREBY APPEALS TO THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS FROM THE ACTION OF THE ZONING OFFICIAL AFFECTING THE PROPERTY DESCRIBED IN THE NOTICE OF APPEAL (FORM 1) ON THE GROUNDS THAT: ( ) GRANTING ( ) DENIAL OF AN APPLICATION FOR A PERMIT TO WAS ERRONEOUS AND CONTRARY TO PROVISIONS OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE IN SECTION: OR OTHER ACTION OR DECISION OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE WAS ERRONEOUS AS FOLLOWS: 2. APPLICANT IS AGGRIEVED BY THE ACTION OR DECISION IN THAT: 3. APPLICANT CONTENDS THAT THE CORRECT INTERPRETATION O F THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE AS AP PLIED TO THE PROPERTY IS: 4. APPLICANT REQUEST THE FOLLOWING RELIEF: Date: Applicant Signature: allow a home occupation permit at 7965 Green Pond Road. See attached information. Applicants request the Board find the Zoning Administrator improperly granted the home occupation permit and deny the home occupation permit to George and Jessica Nunns at 7965 Green Pond Road. This permit violates UDO 5.4.2(A)(7)(a) and (b) because it generates more traffic in reasonable volumes than would reasonably expected in a residential neighborhood, generates traffic that interferes with the quiet enjoyment of the Boron's home,and allows commercial vehicles to access the property from a shared driveway. See attached for more information. The Borons own 7940 Green Pond Road, which shares a driveway with 7965 Green Pond Road(owned by George and Jessica Nunns). The business produces traffic from four to five commercial delivery trucks down the shared gravel driveway each day. The driveway is located entirely on the Boron's property, and the trucks cause substantial damage. See attached for more information. The Lancaster Zoning Director should have denid the home occupation permit application because the business requires deliveries and pickups by commercial vehicles on a shared driveway that is not locate on the Nunns' property. Additionally, the daily commercial vehicle traffic generates more volume and intensity than reasonable expected. X Page 45 of 100 1 of 3 Appeal from Action of Zoning Official Applicants: David and Tamara Boron Appealing the Home Occupation Permit granted to 7965 Green Pond Road owned by George and Jessica Nunns David and Tamara Boron who live at 7940 Green Pond Road, Indian Land, South Carolina, appeal the grant of a Home Occupation Permit to their neighbors George and Jessica Nunns who live at 7965 Green Pond Road, Indian Land, South Carolina. The attached permit was issued for 7961 Green Pond Road. However, the Nunns' correct address is 7965 Green Pond Road. On the application, George Nunns provided an incorrect address. According to the Lancaster County GIS, 7961 Green Pond Road is not a valid address. The Borons believe 7961 may describe a vacant lot on Green Pond Road. Additionally, Mr. Nunns listed the gross floor area of the home occupation as 475 square feet, but his accessory building is approximately 1,178 square feet according to the Lancaster County Tax Assessor GIS information. A copy of the GIS report is attached. Currently, the Nunns use a shared driveway located on the Borons' property. A recent survey is attached showing the driveway on the Borons' property. The driveway runs next to the Borons' horse pasture. On May 22, 2025, Lancaster County Zoning granted the Nunns a Home Occupation Permit for an internet golf sales business. Since that time, four to five commercial trucks travel up and down the shared driveway each day at speeds too high for safe travel on gravel driveway. The trucks throw gravel into the horse pasture causing harm to the horses who step on it. Additionally, the trucks damage the driveway causing ruts and erosion where they throw the gravel of the driveway. The Nunns refuse to pay to repair the driveway or stop the commercial vehicles from traveling down the driveway. Page 46 of 100 2 of 3 UDO § 5.4.2(A)(7)(a) prohibits home occupation businesses from generating traffic "in greater volumes that would reasonably be expected in the residential neighborhood" and from generating "any traffic of such a character, intensity, or continued duration that substantially interferes with the comfortable enjoyment of private homes...." (emphasis added) UDO § 5.4.2(7)(b) states, "Commercial vehicles and semi-tractor trailers shall not access a property from a shared driveway." The permit includes a prohibition on traffic that produces greater vehicles volumes than would be reasonably expected in a residential neighborhood. By granting this permit, the zoning official allows the Nunns to operate a business that violates the UDO and substantially interferes with the Borons' enjoyment of their home. The Borons share a narrow, gravel driveway with the Nunns. The properties are zoned Rural Neighborhood, and the Borons purchased their property with the barn and horse pasture for the purpose of keeping horses on their property. The shared driveway leads to Green Pond Road, and only three houses currently access any portion of the shared driveway. The Borons and the Nunns own the only properties that access the majority of the driveway, which lies entirely on the Borons' property. Therefore, the Borons had a reasonable expectation that that few vehicles and no commercial trucks would regularly drive across the driveway. Since the zoning official granted the Nunns a Home Occupation Permit, the Borons observe four to five commercial trucks driving at unsafe speeds down their driveway each day. These trucks throw gravel from the driveway causing some to land in the horse pasture damaging the horses. Because the trucks loosen the gravel, erosion washes additional gravel into pasture during rainstorms. The trucks also cause ruts in the driveway, and the Nunns refuse to contribute to any repairs. The Lancaster County UDO prohibits home occupation businesses from generating traffic greater than the Borons would reasonably expect in this rural neighborhood with a shared driveway Page 47 of 100 3 of 3 used only by the Nunns. Reasonably, no one would expect four to five commercial trucks per day on a driveway that serves two homes. Additionally, the UDO prohibits commercial vehicles from accessing property from a shared driveway. The Borons asked the Nunns to consider alternatives, such as using an offsite delivery location. The Nunns have refused. Regardless, granting the Nunns the Home Occupation permit violates the UDO because the UDO prohibits commercial vehicles on a shared driveway. Furthermore, a home occupation "shall not exceed twenty-five percent of the gross floor area of the dwelling or five hundred square feet, whichever is greater." UDO § 5.4.2(3). The Nunns operate their business out of the accessory building that includes an area of 1,178 square feet. The Nunns use the entire accessory building to manufacture and sell golf clubs. By using a building that size, the George Nunns intentionally provided incorrect information on the home occupation permit and violates the UDO. Because this Home Occupation Permit violates the UDO, the Borons request that the Board of Zoning Appeals find the zoning official improperly granted the Home Occupation Permit and revoke the permit issued to George and Jessica Nunns at 7965 Green Pond Road. Page 48 of 100 Page 49 of 100 Page 50 of 100 Page 51 of 100 RECEIPT OF APPEAL APPLICATION – Screen Capture from Evolve software Downloaded October 27, 2025 Page 52 of 100 May 12, 2025: Complaint received regarding home business Complainant: Tammy Boron Accused: George and Jessica Nunns Page 53 of 100 Page 54 of 100 Page 55 of 100 Page 56 of 100 Page 57 of 100 Page 58 of 100 Page 59 of 100 Page 60 of 100 Page 61 of 100 Page 62 of 100 Page 63 of 100 Page 64 of 100 May 16, 2025: Accused applied for home occupation permit Complainant: Tammy Boron Accused: George and Jessica Nunns Page 65 of 100 Zoning Home Occupation Application Date: 5/16/2 5 Email Address: g_nunns@yahoo.com Applicant Name: ___ G_e_o_rg_e_N_u_n_n_s ___ _ Phone# __ 3_1_7_9 _3_7_1 _67_ 3 ____ _ ,\ Address: 7965 Green Pond Rd City: __ F_o_rt_M_ill __ State: __ s_c __ Zip:_29_7_0_7_ (\ \('{\� _.,.,l> Property owner: George Nunns Phone #_3_1_7_9_3_7_1_6 _ 7_3 __ _ l.) ';: ;b 'j �::,u,: 965 Green Pond Rd my Fort Mill ,:::::;- sio -:- : c��:_z_i_�_A_ 2 _ 9 _ 7 _ 0 _ 7 _ � x\' />t. Internet Golf Sales � ( • Description of Home Occupation: _____________________ _ V 475ft � Gross floor area of Home Occupation: '\V NOTE: COVENANT RESTRICTIONS MAY EXIST AND THE MOST RESTRICTIVE REGULATIONS SHALL APPLY. �\0.� . ,s THIS A PAST oe A HOMWW,rn �soo•;;:::: �::::: AP O PROVAL MU ; :TT:HED Tax Map Number(I)' 4:::: LlJ - U \ t 8 General Standard's checklist completed YES/NO Zoning Designation & other notes: z,,;,g Offidal � Date ___________ _ The undersigned acknowledge any information given incorrectly, erroneous or incomplete shall render this document, and therefore, any permit issued null and void. I further understand that the Lancaster County Zoning Department can not intervene in contract and /or liability disputes. Any information provided on this document may be subject to the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act and may be disclosed to third parties in accordance with applicable law. Page 66 of 100 Page 67 of 100 Page 68 of 100 Page 69 of 100 Page 70 of 100 Page 71 of 100 Page 72 of 100 Page 73 of 100 Page 74 of 100 Page 75 of 100 May 21-22, 2025: Accused received home occupation permit Complainant: Tammy Boron Accused: George and Jessica Nunns Page 76 of 100 Page 77 of 100 Page 78 of 100 Page 79 of 100 Page 80 of 100 Page 81 of 100 Page 82 of 100 Page 83 of 100 TITLE SEARCH – 7965 GREEN POND RD CURRENT TITLE: TMS 0014-00-010.04 George & Jessica Nunns Received from: Pavel Borisik & Yelizaveta Borisik November 25, 2019 Deed Book 1286 Page 172 PREVIOUS TITLE: Pavel Borisik & Yelizaveta Borisik Received from: John Whittemore April 22, 2015 Deed Book 870 Page 278 PREVIOUS TITLE: John Whittemore Received from: Elizabeth Wilson Brown Trust December 29, 1998 Deed Book 31 Page 286 PROPERTY SUBDIVIDED FROM 12.1 AC TO FOUR (4) LOTS Plat 9800-0813 Dated November 2, 1998 Recorded November 17, 1998 Page 84 of 100 Page 85 of 100 PREVIOUS TITLE: Elizabeth Wilson Brown Trust Received from: Elizabeth Wilson Brown 12.1 acres September 10, 1991 Deed Book C-10 Page 149 PREVIOUS TITLE: Elizabeth Wilson Brown (a.k.a. Elizabeth W. Holliday) Received from: Heirs of DS Wilson (Olin S. Wilson, Helen W. Davis, Nancy W. Tillman, Robert D. Wilson, Douglas M. Wilson, and Jesse Wilson) 12.1 acres Portion of lands conveyed from heirs of DS Wilson via will ~1943 Will Book G Page 398, Item 8 of will October 17, 1961 Deed Book D-5 Page 522 Page 86 of 100 Page 87 of 100 Page 88 of 100 Page 89 of 100 Page 90 of 100 Page 91 of 100 Page 92 of 100 Page 93 of 100 Page 94 of 100 Page 95 of 100 Case No. BZA-2025-2088 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals- Supplemental Images Meeting Date: November 4, 2025 Figure 1. Screen Capture of Current Parcel Data, Lancaster County Assessor’s Office. Accessed October 27, 2028 Page 96 of 100 Case No. BZA-2023-1201 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: August 29,2023 Figure 2. Close-up of Application for Home Occupation Page 97 of 100 Case No. BZA-2023-1201 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: August 29,2023 Figure 3. Identification of the easement. Data accessed October 27, 2025 Page 98 of 100 Case No. BZA-2023-1201 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: August 29,2023 Figure 4. Plat Instrument 9800-813 (Plat Book 9800, Page 813) Page 99 of 100 Case No. BZA-2023-1201 Staff Report to Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting Date: August 29,2023 Figure 5. Plat Instrument Plat Book 2025, Page 407 Page 100 of 100

Source: Lancaster County website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.