Town Council Meeting — Agenda Packet
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Town Council · meeting of Feb 4, 2025 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island
Town Council Meeting
Tuesday, February 4, 2025, 3:00 PM
1 Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, SC
Benjamin M. Racusin Council Chambers
The meeting can be viewed on the Town’s YouTube Channel, the Beaufort County
Channel, and Spectrum Channel 1304.
1. Call to Order
2. Pledge to the Flag
3. Invocation - Pastor Michael Carr, Central Church
4. Adoption of the Agenda
5. Approval of the Minutes
a. Workshop Meeting Minutes of January 9, 2025
b. Regular Meeting Minutes of January 14, 2025
6. Reports from Members of Town Council
a. General Reports from Town Council
7. Presentations and Recognitions
a. Report of the Greenspace Advisory Committee - Peter Kristian, Town of
Hilton Head Island Representative
8. Unfinished Business
a. Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island Granting
Easements to South Island Public Service Districts for Infrastructure
Installation - Second Reading - Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager
9. New Business
a. Consideration of Adoption of 2025 Meeting Schedules for Finance and
Administrative Committee and Community Services and Public Safety
REVISED AGENDA
Page 1 of 222
Committee - Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager
b. Consideration of an Ordinance to Amend Title 17 of the Municipal Code of the
Town of Hilton Head Island, to Amend Chapter 4, Noise Control, to add
Additional Requirements for Construction Hours - First Reading - Missy Luick,
Director of Planning
c. Consideration of a Resolution Authorizing the Town Manager to sign the
Permits Required to Execute the Beach Renourishment Project - Shawn Colin,
Assistant Town Manager
d. Consideration of an Ordinance to Amend Title 16 of the Municipal Code of the
Town of Hilton Head Island, the Land Management Ordinance, to amend
Chapter 16-4, Use Standards, to add a new Adaptive Re-Use Hotel/Motel
Conversion Program as Section 16-4-106 - First Reading - Missy Luick,
Director of Planning
10. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items
11. Executive Session
a. Discussion of Appointments to Boards, Commissions, and Committees
(Pursuant to the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act Section 30-4-
70[a], ) related to:
1. Lowcountry Area Transportation Study
2. Lowcountry Council of Governments
3. Beaufort County Airports Board
4. Southern Lowcountry Regional Board
5. Island Recreation Association Board
6. Northpoint Public- Private Partnership Housing Committee
7. Gullah Geechee Historic Neighborhoods Community Development
Corporation Board of Directors
8. South Carolina Flood Commission
9. Beaufort County Economic Development Corporation
10. Beaufort Housing Authority
11. Beaufort County Solid Waste and Recycling Board
12. Beaufort Jasper Housing Trust
13. Beaufort County Sales Tax Advisory Committee
14. Greenspace Advisory Committee
15. Design Review Board
16. Planning Commission
17. Board of Zoning Appeals
b. Discussion of Legal Advice from the Town Attorney on Matters Covered Under
the Attorney-Client Privilege (Pursuant to the South Carolina Freedom of
Information Act Section 30-4-70 [a]) related to:
1. Project located at 12 Main Street, also known as Diamond Cove
12. Action from Executive Session
Page 2 of 222
13. Adjournment
FOIA Compliance: Public notification of this meeting has been published, posted, and
distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act and the
requirements of the Town of Hilton Head Island.
In accordance with the requirements of Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of
1990 ("ADA"), the Town of Hilton Head Island will not discriminate against qualified
individuals with disabilities on the basis of disability in its services, programs, or
activities. Auditory accommodations are available. Any person requiring further
accommodation should contact the Town of Hilton Head Island ADA Coordinator as
soon as possible but no later than 48 hours before the scheduled event.
Municipal Association of South Carolina (MASC) Civility Pledge:
“I pledge to build a stronger and more prosperous community by advocating for civil
engagement, respecting others and their viewpoints, and finding solutions for the
betterment of my city or town.”
Page 3 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island
Town Council Meeting Minutes
01/09/2025 Page 1 of 7
Town of Hilton Head Island
TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
Thursday, January 9, 2025, 1:00 PM
Minutes
Call to Order
Mayor Perry called the meeting to order at 3:00 p.m.
Council Members present: Alan Perry, Mayor, Alex Brown, Ward 1, Mayor Pro-
Tempore; Patsy Brison, Ward 2; Steve DeSimone, Ward 3, Tammy Becker, Ward 4;
Steve Alfred, Ward 5; Melinda Tunner Ward 6.
Adoption of the Agenda
Mr. Alfred moved to approve. Ms. Brison seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
William Hilton Parkway Gateway Corridor Project Status
Mayor Perry welcomed the public and all dignitaries to the Workshop. He asked Marc
Orlando to start off the workshop.
Mr. Orlando welcome and thanked all in attendance. He also thanked everyone t hat
has been involved in the project from the beginning.
Mr. Orlando stated it is important to establish clear goals during the workshop. He
explained that Shawn Colin has been the point of contact as well as the Town’s project
lead and has been instrumental in keeping the project moving forward. He explained
Mr. Colin will provide a real-time update to Council and the public on the status of the
project since Town Council advanced the Memorandum of Agreement. He suggested
the following structure:1) update on the status; 2) discussion of funding source and
any gap implications, and 3) discussion of the design implications (if not today, soon),
which includes performance, a sense of place and cost , and how to balance those
factors. He noted that collaboration with the South Car olina Department
of Transportation (SCDOT) and Beaufort County is important. He stated the Town
has reviewed citizen feedback with the SCDOT and Beaufort County and will
keep exploring and advancing comments to the SCDOT and Beaufort County. Mr.
Orlando explained that staff is waiting for cost breakdowns from SCDOT and
anticipate receiving the information m id-January. Mr. Orlando called on Shawn
Colin to proceed with his presentation.
Mr. Colin reviewed timeline within the staff report and provided a timeline.
1. M
emorandum of Understanding (MOU) Approval:
Page 4 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island
Town Council Meeting Minutes
01/09/2025 Page 2 of 7
On June 28, 2024, the Town Council approved an MOU with Beaufort
County, granting municipal consent for the project. This MOU was sent to
Beaufort County with a request for their approval.
2. Beaufort County Response:
Beaufort County Administrator Michael Moore responded on November 27,
2024, with a proposal to bifurcate the MOU into two separate agreements:
one focusing on the Bridge and Corridor project, and the other addressing
community-related elements, particularl y in the Stoney Historic Community.
Curtis Coltrane's review of the proposed MOUs is also included.
3. SCSIB Funding Request:
Following the failure of the November 2024 Transportation Sales Tax
referendum, the South Carolina State Infrastructure Bank (SCSIB)
requested Beaufort County submit an updated funding plan by November
7, 2024, allowing 15 days for a response.
4. SCDOT Coordination and Deadline:
The South Carolina Department of Transportation (SCDOT) issued a
letter to Beaufort County on November 18, 2024, regarding the need for
coordination on addressing the deficient bridge. The letter set a March
31, 2025, deadline for a decision.
5. SCSIB Meeting:
On November 20, 2024, the SCSIB considered a request from Beaufort
County for an additional $90 million to support the project. The SCSIB did
not approve additional funding but granted an extension until March 31,
2025, for Beaufort County to develop an alternative funding strategy.
6. December 6, 2024, Meeting:
On December 6, 2024, a meeting was held at Beaufort County’s request to
discuss the SCSIB and SCDOT letters. The meeting included key
representatives from Beaufort County, the Town of Hilton Head Island, and
the South Carolina legislature. The outcome of the meeting was a
commitment from both Beaufort County and Hilton Head Island to evaluate
cost estimates, identify potential funding sources, and determine actionable
next steps.
Meeting Attendees:
o SC Senator Tom Davis
o Town of Hilton Head Island:
Alan Perry, Mayor
Alex Brown, Councilman
o Marc Orlando, Town Manager
Page 5 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island
Town Council Meeting Minutes
01/09/2025 Page 3 of 7
o Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager
o Beaufort County:
Joe Passiment, County Council Chairman
Larry McElynn, Councilman
Alice Howard, Councilwoman
Michael Moore, Administrator
Jared Fralix, Assistant Administrator
7. December 19, 2024, SCDOT Meeting:
A meeting was held at the SCDOT Administration building in Columbia,
South Carolina, on December 19, 2024, regarding the Gateway Corridor
project.
Representatives from SCDOT, Beaufort County, and the Town of Hilton Head
Island discussed the project's funding status, potential additional funding
sources, and options for addressing deficiencies based on available funds.
Meeting Attendees:
o SC Senator Tom Davis
o SCDOT:
Justin Powell, Secretary of Transportation
Rob Perry, PE, Deputy Secretary for Engineering
John Boylston, Chief Engineer for Program Delivery
Casey Lucas, PE, Regional Production Group Engineering
Maggie Hendry, Chief Administrative Officer
Craig Winn, PE, Lowcountry Program Manager
o Beaufort County:
Mike Moore, County Administrator
Jared Fralix, Assistant County Administrator
o Town of Hilton Head Island:
Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager
The group discussed the project's funding status, potential additional
funding sources, and options to address deficiencies based on available
funds. Key topics discussed were as follows:
o Funding Shortfall:
The group considered potential funding sources, including upcoming grants
and a future Beaufort County referendum, to address an approximate $190
million funding shortfall.
o Project Options Based on Available Funds:
Three options were presented:
Option A: Execute the current proposed project by securing
additional funding to bridge the $190 million gap.
Page 6 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island
Town Council Meeting Minutes
01/09/2025 Page 4 of 7
Option B: Proceed with a $300 million funding, adjusting the project scope
to match available funds.
Option C: Define a project within a reduced budget of approximately $180
million if the SIB withdraws its contribution.
o Project Elements Breakdown:
SCDOT will continue to itemize the project elements contributing to the total
cost of $490 million. These elements include bridge replacement, a
multipurpose pathway, roadway adjustments on Jenkins Island, and
improvements to the Stoney Community.
o Potential Project Adjustments:
Reductions in the project scope may require revisions to the
Environmental Assessment (NEPA review) and modifications to the
agreement with the SIB, potentially delaying the project by 9-12 months.
o Next Steps:
SCDOT will provide updated cost estimates in the coming weeks.
A follow-up meeting will likely occur in mid-January to review cost estimates
and further discuss options.
A meeting with the SIB is anticipated in February to explore next steps and
resolve funding issues.
Mayor Perry invited Senator Tom Davis to speak.
Senator Davis stated he met with SCDOT Secretary Powell and was provided with
updates to cost estimates regarding various components of the project. He referenced
a three page summary of a path forward which begins on the following page along
with correspondence from the State Infrastructure Bank and SCDOT. He noted that
with the failure of the referendum things have changed and other alternatives need to
be addressed. He pointed out the alternative keeps the spans separate and
the sense of mass would be av oided. Senator Davis proceeded to review his
proposal.
A copy of the letter and supporting documents begin on the following page.
Page 7 of 222
Page 8 of 222
Page 9 of 222
Page 10 of 222
Page 11 of 222
Page 12 of 222
Page 13 of 222
Page 14 of 222
Page 15 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island
Town Council Meeting Minutes
01/09/2025 Page 5 of 7
Mayor Perry introduced Beaufort County Council Chair, Alice Howard. Chair Howard
thanked Senator Davis for his comments and update. She stated her appreciation for
the presence of Beaufort County Council members and staff.
Mayor Perry asked if there were any T own Council m embers that are interested in
going after additional funding. There were none.
Ms. Becker stated her opposition to the project approved in June by Town Council.
She noted there was a tremendous amount of work to be done by the newly stated
March 31, 2025, deadline. She questioned the timeline of informing Town Council
regarding the December 6 meeting and requested that she and all of Council be
apprised of things when they are happening. She requested the date when the County
gave notice to the Town regarding the December 6 meeting. Mr. Orlando explained
that he received notice of the Friday, December 6 meeting regarding the status of
funding of the project from Beaufort County staff and accept ed the invitation on
December 4 at 12:58 p.m. He followed up with sending a summary of the meeting to
all of Council on Monday.
Members of Council had questions
, comments and discussion regarding: inquiry as
to where the County will find the additional funds needed; a sugges tion that one of
the proposed three lanes be a reversible lane or at the least a breakdown lane
that can also be used for evacuation; inquiry as to the reim bursement amount for
relocation of the underwater pipeline and the impact on it when r educing the scope
of the project; inquiry as to where the funding would c ome from for the $53.3
million dollars along with the $40.8 million dollars needed for the Hilton Head
Island components; confirmation the funds allocated are inclusive of ancillary
costs; the need for clarification on the Master Plan for Hilton Head Is land
costs; confirmation the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) sent to the County
was red-lined by staff and not reviewed by the entire County Council; inquiry
as to whether the State Infrastructure Bank will reduce funds due to s caling
down the scope of the projec t; a suggestion for the Town and County to have a
legal understanding that they are moving forward jointly ; c onfirmation the
Beaufort County Council will be holding a workshop on this subject on January 21,
2025; a suggestion that the County and Town work together creating a timeline for
the March 31, 2025 deadline; inquiry as to whether a westbound ramp is
included in the costs if the light at Windmill Harbour is eliminated; importance of
the Master Plan to address costs; the need for options and the cost of each option;
confirmation by Senator Davis that deference is given to the Town regarding plans
for the area between Windmill Harbour and the Cross Island Parkway;
confirmation we have completed some components needed for the Master Plan
and the need to fit them into the budget along with working with Beaufort County and
S
CDOT: a suggestion that with January 28 being held for a Council workshop that
Council continue this discus sion at that time; the need for cost estimates for
the elements for Council to review and evaluate; confirmation and inquiry as to the
width of the proposed bridge; inquir y and confirmation the causeways are being
addressed in the costs; confirmation that the funds c ommitted to Stoney
for additional
Page 16 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island
Town Council Meeting Minutes
01/09/2025 Page 6 of 7
enhancements are no longer included in the costs estimates; confirmation that
environmental assessments for the Stoney area will be a separate component; inquiry
as to phasing the bridge component and the S toney area improvements;
confirmation the S CDOT did not respond to the MOU and separate resolution the
Town wanted included in the project; confirmation of the need for a scaled back
approach using existing dollars submitted to the SCDOY; the need to define elements
and costs of the Windmill Harbour to Cr oss Island Bridge areas and where funds
will come from; clarifications that until suc h time the on-Is land piece of the pr oject is
finalized, the new three lane bridge will be s triped for two lanes s o as to not have
additional traffic until the project is completed; and clarification that due to the fact
Senator Davis’ proposal was just received, questions need prepar ed addressing
his proposal for the next workshop.
Mayor Perry asked for Public Comment.
D. J. DeLong addressed Council regarding the option of repair as opposed to
demolishing the entire bridge. He suggested seeking out companies who do pile
repairs. He provided information regarding a number of qualified companies.
Christopher Cliffe addressed Council regarding bridge safety and stated that Council
needs to get out of the way and let SCDOT take care of the project.
Peter Kristian addressed Council r egarding public safety, evacuation needs and the
need for a work force. He encouraged Council to move forward with the project.
Sherrie Mikrut addr essed Council r egarding her opp osition to the large bridge span
and stated the project needs to stay within the budgeted funds.
Richard Bisi addressed Council stating he is a member of the Technical Working
Group and referenced their request Council oppose the massive bridge project
noting they have shared data regarding plans that will r educe congestion without
the massive bridge pr oposed.
Skip Hoagland addressed Council st ating the Town is allowing too many tourists on
the Island which is causing the congestion.
Gray Smith addressed Council to thank the residents that worked with him in opposing
the project along with expressing his appreciation to Senator Davis and Council
Member Tammy Becker for working with all of them.
Frank Babel a ddressed Council requesting t hat t he cyclists not b e forgotten w hile
creating the Master Plan for the project.
Public Comment - Non Agenda Items
None.
Adjournment
The workshop adjourned at 3:15 p.m.
Page 17 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island
Town Council Meeting Minutes
01/09/2025 Page 7 of 7
__________________________
Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk
___________________________
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
Page 18 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
1/14/2025 Page 1 of 13
Town of Hilton Head Island
TOWN COUNCIL MEETING
Tuesday, January 14, 2025, 3:00 PM
Minutes
Call to Order
Mayor Perry called the meeting to order at 3:00 p.m.
Council Members present: Alan Perry, Mayor, Alex Brown, Ward 1, Mayor Pro-Tempore;
Patsy Brison, Ward 2; Steve DeSimone, Ward 3, Tammy Becker, Ward 4; Steve Alfred,
Ward 5; Melinda Tunner Ward 6.
Invocation - Reverend Michael Oenbrink, St. Francis by the Sea Catholic Church
Father Oenbrink delivered the invocation.
Adoption of the Agenda
Mr. Alfred moved to approve. Ms. Brison seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Approval of the Minutes
Regular Meeting Minutes of December 3, 2024
Ms. Brison moved to approve. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
General Reports from Town Council
Mayor Perry informed Council he would be attending the South Carolina Beach Advocates
Conference as he has been appointed to the Board.
Ms. Brison expressed her appreciation to Fire Rescue for the development of a warm
shelter during this cold weather and also thanked the Sea Turtle Patrol for their efforts
during the cold spell in protecting the sea turtles.
Report of the Town Manager
Town Manager Marc Orlando reported on the following items of interest.
Office of Cultural Affairs:
The Office of Cultural Affairs has recently installed a temporary exhibition of artwork from
the ‘Art Beyond Tradition’ Group here at Town Hall. These abstract artists have been
exhibiting together since 2006 and have each brought an example of their work to share
with our community. The exhibition is just outside the Council Chambers and is accessible
during any public meetings. Thank you to these local artists.
Technology & Innovation:
Page 19 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
1/14/2025 Page 2 of 13
The Technology & Innovation Department recently upgraded our network infrastructure by
replacing the existing Metro Ethernet (MetroE) connectivity between town buildings with
dark fiber.
This change allowed us to establish redundant connections for each town location, including
all fire stations, significantly improving network reliability.
The transition to dark fiber provides virtually unlimited bandwidth capacity between
buildings, with the only restriction being the capabilities of the equipment at each connection
point.
In contrast, MetroE offered limited bandwidth and only a single connection per building,
which constrained both scalability and redundancy.
This upgraded not only achieved redundancy but also a significant increase in bandwidth
speeds, enabling better support for critical applications and future growth.
The termination of the MetroE circuits resulted in substantial cost savings of $7,200 per
month, starting in November 2024. This translates to an annual savings of over $85,000.
Planning:
The Development Services implemented an electronic newsletter on a bimonthly frequency
to improve communication with the building and construction community.
A community clean-up volunteer event featuring a street sweep and a mobile recycling
center located at the Stables on Jonesville Road is scheduled on Saturday, January 18 from
9am until noon.
Community engagements for the District Plans project have been scheduled for all seven
district plans. The first meeting will be in the Skull Creek District on January 16 at the Boys
& Girls Club from 5pm until 7pm. A complete schedule can be found on the Town calendar
on the Town website. In addition to posting on the Town website and social media
channels, invitations for each meeting are being mailed to residents within the districts in
advance of the meeting and will include a link to an online survey to provide input.
Public hearings for the LMO Priority Amendments & Northpoint Property Zoning Map
Amendment will be held by the Planning Commission on February 19.
Staff Achievements
a. David Staigar and Kathryn Hickey joined the Building Division as provisional
inspectors.
b. Emma Racanello joined the Community Development Information Center as a
Community Development Services Coordinator.
c. Joseph Wheeler, Building Inspector III, passed the Certified Building Official exam
with the International Code Council.
d. Shea Farrar, Principal Planner, was named President of the South Carolina
Chapter of the American Planning Association (SCAPA) and will lead the
organization for a two-year term.
Page 20 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
1/14/2025 Page 3 of 13
e. Melissa Paul Leto, Principal Planner, presented a session entitled “Showcasing
Excellence: How Hilton Head Island’s Design Review Board Shapes Development
to Preserve Island Character” at the South Carolina Chapter of the American
Planning Association Fall Conference held in Spartanburg.
f. Brandy Scholl, Administrative Assistant, is an accomplished artist who has
recently been selected to create public art for the Town of Bluffton. The 4-foot-tall
sculpture will be located in Wright Family Park and represent the history and
ecology of the town of Bluffton through portraits of the Wright family, Gullah
Geechee culture, and a vignette of the coastal waterway.
New Business
Appointment of Town Council Membership to the Community Services and Public Safety
Committee - Mayor Alan Perry
Mayor Perry appointed the following Council members to the Community Services
and Public Safety Committee:
Tammy Becker, Chair
Steve Alfred
Steve DeSimone
Appointment of Town Council Membership to the Finance and Administrative Committee -
Mayor Alan Perry
Mayor Perry appointed the following Council members to the Finance and
Administrative Committee:
Alex Brown, Chair
Patsy Brison
Melinda Tunner
Consideration of Adoption of Town Council 2025 Workshop Schedule - Shawn Leininger,
Assistant Town Manager
Ms. Becker requested the proposed January 28 workshop be changed to January 27 as Ms.
Tunner has a scheduling conflict.
Ms. Brison moved to approve the Town Council 2025 Workshop Schedule with the
change requested by Ms. Becker changing the January 28 workshop to January 27.
Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Presentation of FY2024 Annual Comprehensive Financial Audit Report for the Town of
Hilton Head Island Presentation by Mauldin & Jenkins, CPAs - Adriana Burnett, Finance
Director
In compliance with South Carolina Code Section 5-7-240, the Town is required to conduct
an independent annual audit of its financial statements. These statements include the
financial position of governmental activities, business-type activities, each major fund, and
the aggregate remaining fund information as of June 30, 2024. They also detail the
respective changes in financial position and relevant disclosures.
Page 21 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
1/14/2025 Page 4 of 13
The purpose of the audit is to express an opinion on whether the financial statements are
fairly presented, in all material respects, in accordance with accounting principles generally
accepted in the United States of America (U.S. GAAP).
Mauldin & Jenkins CPA’s and Advisors conducted the audit to provide these services for the
Town. This marks the firm’s second year performing the audit for the Town.
Trey Scott, CPA partner at Mauldin & Jenkins CPA’s & Advisors has led the audit for the
Town. The financial statements are fairly presented in all material respects, in accordance
with GAAP. Mr. Scott conducted a detailed presentation regarding the audit.
Council members made comments, asked questions and had discussion regarding: inquiry
as to whether the Town should be looking for opportunities to conduct audits on internal
controls; inquiry as to the one finding and how to ensure it doesn’t happen in the future;
confirmation the finding was a result of a standard that should have been implemented 7
years ago and has now been corrected; a reference to the Annual Comprehensive Financial
Report noting it is well put together and a great tool; inquiry regarding incurring more debt
since the towns rating is so good; an inquiry and confirmation that Hilton Head Island rates
in the top ten in comparison to other similar municipalities; inquiry into the pension liability
and how it impacts the Town; and confirmation that Hiton Head Island has a positive
unrestricted net position..
Mayor Perry asked for public comment. There was none.
Consideration of an Ordinance of the Town of Hilton Head Island Granting Easements to
South Island Public Service Districts for Infrastructure Installation - First Reading - Shawn
Colin, Assistant Town Manager
Town Council is asked to consider four (4) utility easements on Town-owned property, as
requested by the South Island Public Service District (SIPSD) for the purpose of upgrading
their potable water source and distribution system.
On August 20, 2024, Town Council reviewed SIPSD’s request for easements during
Executive Session and requested additional information regarding tree impacts.
On November 12, 2024, Town Council further reviewed SIPSD’s request during Executive
Session and made the following comments:
Identify the affected properties on Attachment 1 as “Town-Owned Property;”
Require a project schedule and pathway detour plan;
Require live oak trees as mitigation for all tree removal; and
Require understory vegetation mitigation in the William Hilton Parkway and Dunnagan’s
Alley easement.
The Town’s development review team is working with SIPSD to ensure these conditions are
met through the Development Plan Review (DPR) application process. SIPSD has no
objection to these conditions.
Easement Requests:
1. Pope Avenue (R552 015 000 0395 0000):
Page 22 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
1/14/2025 Page 5 of 13
▪Description: This easement includes a 10-foot-wide strip along Town-owned
property adjacent to Pope Avenue, in front of St. Luke's Church.
▪Method of Installation: Directional boring, which will avoid impacting trees.
2. Corner of Arrow Road and William Hilton Parkway (R550 015 000 0007 0000):
▪Description: This easement includes a 10-foot-wide strip along Town-owned
property, along William Hilton Parkway.
▪Method of Installation: Directional boring, which will avoid impacting trees.
3. William Hilton Parkway (R550 015 000 0324 0000):
▪Description: This easement spans the entire William Hilton Parkway frontage of
the Town Hall property, with a consistent width of 10 feet.
▪Method of Installation: Directional boring, which will avoid impacting trees.
4. William Hilton Parkway and Dunnagan’s Alley (R550 015 000 0323 0000):
▪Description: This easement is located between the Village at Wexford and
Town Hall, with a varying width: 40 feet at William Hilton Parkway, narrowing to 20
feet through the property, and expanding to 60 feet at Dunnigan’s Alley.
Additionally, there is a 20-foot-wide temporary construction easement proposed
adjacent to the permanent easement.
▪Method of Installation: This portion of the project requires an open trench
installation, which will impact up to 23 trees and understory bushes.
▪Tree Impact:
✓3 live oak trees (largest being 20” in diameter)
✓9 gum trees (largest being 15” in diameter)
✓11 pine trees (largest being 24” in diameter)
▪Tree Mitigation: Town staff will continue working with SIPSD to minimize tree
removal and require tree mitigation.
The proposed easements will enable the upgrade of SIPSD’s potable water system. Three
of the four easements will avoid tree impacts through the use of directional boring, while the
fourth easement will require tree removal and mitigation.
Council members made comments, asked questions and had discussion regarding: inquiry
ad to the impact on the multi-use pathways; confirmation the impact will be minimal; a
request to have clear direction for alternative routes for pathway users; concern for the live
oaks and the need for a defined tree mitigation plan before approval; confirmation there are
no impacts on trees in the first three areas; and confirmation a mitigation plan for the fourth
area can be brought forward at the second reading on February 4.
Mayor Perry asked for public comment. There was none.
Mr. Brown moved to approve and to have a more detailed tree mitigation plan
presented at second reading. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 6-1 (Ms. Brison
Page 23 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
1/14/2025 Page 6 of 13
opposed).
Consideration of a Resolution of the Town of Hilton Head Island Approving the
Recommendation from the Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee for the Calendar Year
2024 Grants - Adriana Burnett, Finance Director
Mr. McGowan introduced Stephen Arnold, Chair of the Accommodations Ta Committee to
conduct his presentation.
On November 7, 2024, the Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee (ATAC) met to make
grant funding recommendations for 34 ATAC grant applications that were solicited from our
traditional 2025 grant cycle. As a result, the ATAC was pleased to make funding
recommendations on all 34 of the submitted ATAC grant applications.
Total Applicant Funding Requests $4,241,650 Total Available
Funding for Grants
(after required $50,000 reserve) $3,891,644
ATAC Funding Recommendations for Grants $4,186,065
As with past practice, the ATAC has worked to establish a consistent philosophy in how
applications are reviewed and prioritized. Over the past five years, the review and
recommendation approach of the ATAC has evolved through continuous improvement into
the following guiding principles:
Economic Growth Through Tourism - Does the applicant organization drive overnight
visitors to Hilton Head Island?
Creation of Sustainable Visitor Traffic - Does the applicant organization enhance or improve
the visitor experience on Hilton Head Island creating opportunities that would encourage
visitors to return to Hilton Head Island?
Collaboration Amongst Organizations - How well does the applicant organization collaborate
with other local organizations, especially fellow grant applicants? Where possible, do
applicants cross-promote each other to further enhance the visitor experience?
Organization Viability and Return on Investment - Does the organization possess a clear
vision and an achievable direction? Does the organization have other sources of public and
private support available? What is the organization's long-term dependency on ATAX
funding going to be? Do established applicant organizations have the financial means to
support themselves without an ATAX award for the upcoming year and/or beyond? Do
organizations with a strong balance sheet have a strategic plan for their cash reserves?
Operational Confidence - How well do the applicant organizations understand their
operations? Do they track and report metrics, do they provide sufficient transparency and
are they accountable for their results?
The Committee also strives to enhance the grant review process as it is important to evolve
our thinking to the strategic focuses of the Town, the best practices of other ATAX
municipalities and evaluate feedback solicited through the past year. To provide an
additional layer of summary with our recommendation, each application has been broken
Page 24 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
1/14/2025 Page 7 of 13
out into sections categorizing, at the highest level, the type of recommendation each
application received from the Committee this year. These two categories will group
applications together based on whether they received recommendations for full or for partial
funding. A spreadsheet was displayed during the meeting listing all applicants along with the
amount each applicant requested. The Committee Members discussed each individual
application and ultimately, the Accommodations Tax Advisory Committee decided upon the
following for funding:
The Committee was in a fortunate position to make several full-funding recommendations
again this year. The Committee felt that the twenty-five organizations that fell into this
category were thoughtful with their grant requests, demonstrated a reasonable financial
need, and were able to show a strong Return on Investment (ROI) with how they chose to
invest their financial resources to drive and enhance tourism on Hilton Head Island.
Furthermore, the Committee is cautious in recommending increases year over year funding
to ensure that a new benchmark would not be created that could adversely impact the
applicant in upcoming years if the same funding levels were not available in the future.
Request Committee Recommendation
Art League of Hilton Head $ 80,000 $ 80,000
Arts Center of Coastal Carolina $ 447,000 $ 447,000
David M. Carmines Memorial Foundation $ 185,000 $ 185,000
Gullah Museum of Hilton Head Island $ 180,000 $ 180,000
Harbour Town Merchants $ 29,000 $ 29,000
Hilton Head Concours d’Elegance $ 350,000 $ 350,000
Hilton Head Island Airport $ 150,000 $ 150,000
Hilton Head Island Rec Association $ 75,000 $ 75,000
HHI Wine & Food Inc. (Rhythm & Brews Fest) $ 30,000 $ 30,000
HHI Wine & Food Inc. (Wine & Food Fest) $ 130,000 $ 130,000
Hilton Head Symphony Orchestra $ 350,000 $ 350,000
Lean Ensemble Theatre $ 55,000 $ 55,000
Lowcountry Golf Course Owners Assoc. $ 200,000 $ 200,000
Lowcountry Gullah $ 100,000 $ 100,000
Mitchelville Preservation Project $ 190,000 $ 190,000
Native Island Business & Community Assoc. $ 225,000 $ 225,000
Rotary Club of Hilton Head Island $ 40,000 $ 40,000
Sea Turtle Patrol HHI $ 70,000 $ 70,000
Shelter Cove Harbour Company $ 293,800 $ 293,800
TEDx Hilton Head $ 10,000 $ 10,000
The Boys & Girls Club of Hilton Head $ 40,000 $ 40,000
The Coastal Discovery Museum $ 400,000 $ 400,000
The First Tee of the Lowcountry $ 50,000 $ 50,000
The Outside Foundation $ 72,000 $ 72,000
The Sandbox $ 64,000 $ 64,000
Total Full Funding $3,815,800
Nine organizations, despite being eligible, were not recommended for full funding. Three of
Page 25 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
1/14/2025 Page 8 of 13
these were limited by TERC-based funding caps. The remaining organizations faced funding
reductions due to the constrained budget available for awards this year. This was an
unavoidable outcome given the financial limitations.
The ATAC evaluated each application based on its individual merit, independent of the
overall funding pool. The Committee emphasizes that partial funding should not be
interpreted as a negative assessment of the organization. Recommendations adhered to
staff guidelines for partial funding, which were applied for budgetary considerations.
Additionally, the Committee was mindful of avoiding significant year-over-year increases in
funding. This approach was taken to prevent setting new benchmarks that might create
challenges for applicants in future years, should similar funding levels be unavailable.
A total variance of $55,585 was observed between the amounts requested and the
Committee's funding recommendations. The Committee remains confident that its
recommendations reflect the highest and best use of the available funds and are appropriate
for this year’s grant cycle.
Request Committee
Recommen
ds
Variance
Hilton Head Audubon Society $ 21,400 $ 15,000 ($ 6,400)
Hilton Head Choral Society $ 20,000 $ 15,000 ($ 5,000)
Hilton Head Dance Theater $23,000 $ 20,000 ($ 3,000)
Hilton Head Island Bridge Assoc $ 21,000 $ 15,000 ($ 6,000) TERC Based
Hilton Head Land Trust $ 47,000 $ 37,000 ($10,000)
Hilton Head Island St. Patrick’s Day
Parade
$ 80,000 $ 68,388 ($ 11,612)
Hilton Head MLK Committee for Justice $ 5,000 $ 2,980 ($ 2,020) TERC Based
Long Cove Club (Darius Rucker Intercollegiate) $ 65,450 $ 61,897 ($ 3,553) TERC Based
The Heritage Library $ 143,000 $ 135,000 ($ 8,000)
Total Partial Funding $ 425,850 $ 370,265 ($55,585)
Summary
Full Funding $ 3,815,800
Partial Funding $ 370,265
Total CY 2024 Grant Funding $ 4,186,065
At the conclusion of the meeting, a motion was made to approve the recommendations as
presented on the projected spreadsheet (summarized above). The motion was seconded,
and all Committee members voted unanimously to approve, except for specific line items
where individual members recused themselves during the meeting. The final roll call vote
was 7-0.
Mayor Perry asked for public comment. There was none.
Ms. Brison moved to approve the full funding recommended by the Accommodations
Tax Advisory Committee in the amount of $3,815,800 and to include full funding for
Page 26 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
1/14/2025 Page 9 of 13
those which the Committee recommended partial funding, with the exception of Hiton
Head Island Bridge Association, Hilton Head MLK Committee for Justice, and Long
Cove Club, which are TERC based reductions; and the reduction of Lowcountry Golf
Course Owners Association from the $200,000 recommendation to awarding
$150,000. Mr. Alfred seconded.
Ms. Becker moved to amend the motion to not fund the $200,000 requested from the
Lowcountry Golf Course Owners Association, the $40,000 requested from the Rotary
Club of Hilton Head (Quenchbuggy), reduce the Outside Foundation award by $10,000
to not fund the $100,000 Lowcountry Gullah request. Mr. DeSimone seconded.
Ms. Becker amended her motion to state that the applicants mentioned in her original
amendment be voted on separately to determine funding. (Lowcountry Golf Course
Owners Association, Rotary Club of Hilton Head (Quenchbuggy) and The Outside
Foundation). Mr. DeSimone, as the seconder to Ms. Becker’s original amendment to
the motion was in agreement and seconded her amendment to her motion. Motion
carried 4-3 (Brown, Alfred and Brown opposed).
Ms. Becker moved that for 2025 the Lowcountry Golf Course Owners Association
receive no funding or at least temporarily hold the funding for further conversation
with regard to the appropriateness of the funding. Mr. DeSimone seconded. Motion
failed 1-6 (Tunner, Alfred, Brown, Perry, Brison and DeSimone opposed.)
Ms. Tunner moved to fund the Lowcountry Golf Owners Association $100,000. Ms.
Becker seconded. Motion failed 2-5 (Alfred, Brown, Perry, Brison and DeSimone
opposed).
Ms. Brison moved to approve $150,000 to the Lowcountry Golf Owners Association.
Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 5-2 (Tunner and Becker opposed).
Ms. Becker moved that at this time there is not enough evidence or data provided to
approve funding the Rotary Club of Hilton Head (Quenchbuggy) request for 2025. Ms.
Tunner seconded. Motion failed 3-4 (Alfred, Brown, Brison, DiSimone opposed).
Ms. Brison moved to approve the Committee recommendation of $40,000 to the
Rotary Club of Hilton Head (Quenchbuggy). Mr. Brown seconded. The motion carried
4-3 (Tunner, Perry and Becker opposed).
Ms. Becker moved to approve $62,000 in funding to The Outside Foundation (a
reduction of $10,000 from the Committee recommendation). Mr. DeSimone seconded.
Motion failed 2-5 (Tunner, Alfred, Brown, Brison and Perry opposed).
Ms. Brison moved to approve the Committee recommendation of $72,000 to The
Outside Foundation. Mr. Brown seconded. Motion carried 5-2 (Becker and DeSimone
opposed).
Ms. Becker moved, based on Lowcountry Gullah being almost entirely internet based
and therefore leaving a question on return on investments, as required by TERC, that
there be no funding. Mr. DeSimone seconded. Motion failed 1-6 (Tunner, Alfred,
Brown, Perry, Brison and DeSimone opposed).
Page 27 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
1/14/2025 Page 10 of 13
Ms. Brison moved to approve the Committee recommendation of $100,000 to
Lowcountry Gullah. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion carried 6-1 (Becker opposed).
Mayor Perry called for a vote on the original motion. Motion carried 7-0.
Consideration of a Resolution of the Town of Hilton Head Island Approving a Sponsorship
Agreement with the Heritage Classic Foundation to Support the 2025 RBC Heritage Golf
Tournament - Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager
Mr. Colin stated the Town has historically been a sponsor of the RBC Golf Tournament.
With recent developments within the PGA TOUR, the 2025 Tournament has maintained its
designation as one of the Tour’s "Signature Events". Signature Events feature limited field
sizes and a $20 million purse, and the RBC Heritage is one of five Signature Events that will
not have a player cut. On December 16, 2024 the Heritage Classic foundation wrote to the
Town regarding a new Sponsorship Agreement for 2025. A copy of that correspondence is
enclosed as Attachment 1. In the 2025 Sponsorship Agreement, enclosed as part of
Attachment 2, the Heritage Classic Foundation is requesting the Town's maintain its
financial sponsorship level at $400,000 for this year's event, the same as in 2024. In
exchange for this sponsorship, the Town will continue to receive recognition as a sponsor in
many of the tournament's promotional materials. It has been estimated that the RBC Golf
Tournament generates approximately $134.5 million in economic impact each year. The
2024 Tournament also brought more than 100,000 event attendees to Hilton Head Island
over the course of the week.
Mayor Perry asked for public comment. There was none.
Following discussion, Ms. Brison moved to approve. Mr. Alfred seconded. Motion
carried 7-0.
Consideration of Approval of Rental Locations Proposed by Shore Beach Services for 2025
Beach Season - Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager
Shore Beach Services began providing lifeguarding services for the Town since its
incorporation in 1983. These services have always been provided through the execution of
non-exclusive Franchise Agreement. Over the years, this agreement has been renegotiated,
and the scope of services has varied from time to time. Shore Beach Services currently
provides lifeguards, beach rental equipment, and trash removal services to the Town under
a Franchise Agreement dated June 18, 2024.
Per Article 5 of the approved Shore Beach Services Non-Exclusive Franchise Agreement, the
Franchisee shall submit to the Town Council for approval a listing of rental locations
intended to be operated within the areas of operation during the next beach season.
5. APPROVAL PROCESS: On or before December 1st of each year, the Franchisee shall
submit to the Town Council for approval a listing of rental locations intended to be operated
within the areas of operation during the next beach season. This listing shall include the
product quantities for each rental location. For purposes of the first year of this Agreement,
the rental locations and product quantities shall be those that were approved by the Town in
Calendar Year 2024.The purpose of this approval process is to regulate the location and
quantities of rental equipment in use on the beach. Product quantities for each rental
Page 28 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
1/14/2025 Page 11 of 13
location shall not depart significantly from amounts approved during the previous year. Upon
the request of the Franchisee, the Town Council may approve product quantity increases in
areas of operation when circumstances such as new or expanded beach parks, other
developments or changes in demand warrant such increases.
Pursuant to Section 5 of the Franchise Agreement with the Town of Hilton Head Island,
Shore Beach Services submitted six schedules showing the rental locations that they intend
to operate during the 2025 season along with the product quantities for each rental location.
There is a separate schedule for each of the five Areas of Operation, as defined in Section 4
of the Franchise Agreement, as well as a summary for all franchise areas. For reference
purposes, the approved product quantities for 2024 season have been included on each of
these schedules (Exhibits C-1 to C-5).
4. AREAS OF OPERATION: By this Franchise Agreement, the Franchisee is hereby
authorized to operate and conduct commercial activities (as defined herein) and in Exhibit B-
1 in the following areas:
A. From the northern boundary of the Westin Hotel south to the southern boundary
of the designated swimming area at Driessen Beach Park. The portion of the beach
extending 300 feet from either side of the center of the boardwalk at Surf Watch. The
portion of the beach from the Burkes Beach access north 400 feet. The portion of the
beach from the northern boundary of Palmetto Dunes to Beach Emergency Marker
96 (Exhibit B-2).
B. From the northern boundary of the Palmetto Dunes “Dunes House” south to the
southern boundary of the Omni Resort in Palmetto Dunes (Exhibit B-3).
C. From the northern boundary of Hampton Place at Palmetto Dunes south to the
Southern Boundary of Shipyard Beach (Exhibit B-3).
D. From the northern boundary of the Sea Crest south to the southern boundary of
Alder Lane designated swim area. (Exhibit B-4)
E. From Emergency Marker 39 south to the Southern Boundary of Turtle Lane Club
and from Beach Emergency Marker 13 at Tower Beach Club westerly to Beach
Emergency Marker 11 and easterly 300 feet. (Exhibit B-5).
There was little change in peak demand for rentals during the season. Accordingly, the
quantity of equipment is mostly unchanged with some reallocations of equipment amongst
rental locations. Overall product quantities at rental locations for 2025 would be the same as
2024. There are the following changes within two Areas:
In Area C, four Umbrella/Cabanas and six Chairs/Lounges have been moved from
Barrington to Hampton.
In Area E, six Umbrellas/Cabanas have been moved from Tower Beach to Sea pines Beach
Club.
Council members made comments, asked questions and had discussion regarding: the need
to assure that all private beach entrances be clear for residents to access the beach; and the need to
work with Shore Beach Services for a beach warning system at all points of the beach.
Page 29 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
1/14/2025 Page 12 of 13
Mayor Perry asked for public comment. There was none.
Ms. Brison moved to approve. Mr. Brown seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Public Comment - Non Agenda Items
David Martin addressed Council regarding the status of paid parking in the Coligny Area.
Gray Smith addressed Council regarding the important of making the changes to the Land
Management Ordinance to limit condominiums and other high density construction.
Amber Kuehn addressed Council suggesting that the Wild Wings Property on Poe Avenue
be repurposed to house Sea Turtle Patrol, Shore Beach Services and c/ode Enforcement,
along with provided a visitor information center in the building.
Executive Session
Discussion of Contractual Arrangements Pertaining to Designated Marketing
Organization[Pursuant to the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act Section 30-4-70
(a)(2)]
Discussion of Legal Updates from the Town Attorney on Matters Covered Under the
Attorney- Client Privilege [Pursuant to the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act
Section 30-4- 70(a)(2)]
Discussion of Legal Advice from the Town Attorney on Matters Covered Under the Attorney-
Client Privilege Incident to Settlement Negotiations Concerning Pending Litigation
Captioned “County of Charleston, et al., v. AIRBNB, Inc., et al.,” Seeking Payment of
Accommodation Taxes and Business License Fees to the Town and Other Local
Governments in South Carolina [Pursuant to the South Carolina Freedom of Information Act
Section 30-4-70 (a)(2)] related to:
1. AirBnB
Discussion of Negotiations Incident to Proposed Contractual Arrangements and Discussions
for the Proposed Sale or Purchase of Property (Pursuant to South Carolina Freedom of
Information Act Section 30-4-70 (a)(2)] related to:
1. Pembroke Drive Area
2. William Hilton Parkway Area
3. Squire Pope Road Area
4. Pope Avenue Area
5. Mitchelville Area
6. Stoney Area
7. Jonesville Road Area
8. Beach City Road Area
9. Marshland Road Area
Mayor Perry asked the Town Manager if there was a need to enter Executive Session. Mr.
Orlando stated there was a need regarding the items listed above.
At 5:45 p.m. Mr. Alfred moved to enter into Executive Session for the reasons cited by
the Town Manager. Ms. Becker seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Page 30 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island Town Council
Meeting Minutes
1/14/2025 Page 13 of 13
At 8:05 p.m. Mr. Brown moved to come out of Executive Session. Ms. Brison
seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Action from Executive Session
Mr. Brown moved to authorize the Mayor and Town Manager to sign a Settlement
Agreement in Case 2021-CP-07-1650 as explained by the Town's Attorneys. Ms.
Brison seconded. Motion carried 7-0.
Adjournment
The meeting adjourned at 8:06 p.m.
Approved:
Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website
at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Page 31 of 222
Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex
One Town Center Court Hilton Head Island South Carolina 29928
www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
Town Council
TO: Mayor Alan R. Perry & Town Council Members
FROM: Ben Brown, Director of Strategic Initiatives
CC: Marc Orlando, ICMA-CM, Town Manager
Shawn Colin, Assistant Town Manager of Strategic Initiatives
Curtis Coltrane, Town Attorney
DATE: February 4, 2025
SUBJECT: Negotiations Incident to Proposed Contractual Arrangements and
Easement Requests by the South Island Public Service District
RECOMMENDATION:
Town Council is asked to consider four (4) utility easements on Town -owned property , as
requested by the South Island Public Service District (SIPSD), to facilitate the upgrading of
their potable water source and distribution system.
BACKGROUND:
On August 20, 2024, the Town Council reviewed SIPSD’s request for easements during
Executive Session and requested additional information regarding tree impacts.
On November 12, 2024, the Town Council further discussed SIPSD’s request for easements
during Executive Session and provided the following feedback:
1. Identify the affected properties on Attachment 1 as “Town-Owned Property.”
2. Require a project schedule and pathway detour plan.
3. Require live oak trees as mitigation for all tree removal.
4. Require mitigation for understory vegetation in the William Hilton Parkway and
Dunnagan’s Alley easement.
On January 14, 2025, the Town Council approved first reading of the requested easement s
with the condition that the following information be provided before second and final reading:
1. Tree removal and mitigation plans (Attachments 2 & 3).
2. An explanation of why open trench digging is proposed on the William Hilton
Parkway and Dunnagan’s Alley easement, as opposed to directional boring.
The Town’s development review team is working with SIPSD to ensure compliance with these
conditions through the Development Plan Review (DPR) process. SIPSD has indicated a
preference for open trench digging along the drainage canal in the William Hilton Parkway
and Dunnagan’s Alley easement, as the equipment necessary for directional boring is large
and would require additional tree removal to operate. Open trench digging requires a
Page 32 of 222
Page 2 of 2
Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex
One Town Center Court Hilton Head Island South Carolina 29928
www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
narrower construction footprint. SIPSD provided the attached tree removal and m itigation
plans, which include the removal of up to 23 trees (one of which is dead). The tree removal
plan details the removal of four oak trees, including two 15” water oaks (one of which is
diseased), an 8” water oak, and a 20” live oak. The tree mitigation plan outlines the planting
of 14 live oak trees, which are at least 4 caliper inches in diameter and approximately 10 feet
tall at installation.
Easement Requests:
1. Pope Avenue (R552 015 000 0395 0000):
Description: This easement includes a 10-foot-wide strip along Town- owned
property adjacent to Pope Avenue, in front of St. Luke's Church.
Method of Installation: Directional boring, which will avoid impacting trees.
2. Corner of Arrow Road and William Hilton Parkway (R550 015 000 0007 0000):
Description: This easement includes a 10-foot-wide strip along T own-owned
property, along William Hilton Parkway.
Method of Installation: Directional boring, which will avoid impacting trees.
3. William Hilton Parkway (R550 015 000 0324 0000):
Description: This easement spans the entire William Hilton Parkway frontage
of the Town Hall property, with a consistent width of 10 feet.
Method of Installation: Directional boring, which will avoid impacting trees.
4. William Hilton Parkway and Dunnagan’s Alley (R550 015 000 0323 0000):
Description: This easement is located between the Village at Wexford and
Town Hall, with a varying width: 40 feet at William Hilton Parkway, narrowing to
20 feet through the property, and expanding to 60 feet at Dunnigan’s Alley.
Additionally, there is a 20-foot-wide temporary construction easement proposed
adjacent to the permanent easement.
Method of Installation: This portion of the project requires an open trench
installation, which will impact trees and understory bushes.
Tree Mitigation: Town staff will continue working with SIPSD to minimize tree
removal and require tree mitigation.
CONCLUSION:
The proposed easements are necessary to facilitate the upgrade of SIPSD’s potable water
system. Three of the four easements will avoid tree impacts through the use of directional
boring, while the fourth easement will require tree removal and mitigation.
ATTACHMENTS:
1. SIPSD Easement Locations
2. Tree Removal Plan
3. Tree Mitigation Plan
4. Proposed Ordinance and Exhibits
Page 33 of 222
NEW ORLEANS ROAD
WILLIAM HILTON PARKWAY
POPE A
VE
NUE
PALMETTO BAY ROAD
CORDILLO
PARKWAY
ARROW ROAD
ARCHER R
OAD
SEA
PINES
CIRCLE
GREENW OOD
DRIV E
1
2
3
4
Town-Owned Property
Easement Location
Sea
Pines
Wexford
Shipyard
ONE TOWN CENTER COURT
HILTON HEAD ISLAND, S.C. 29928
PHONE (843) 341- 4600
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
F
The information on this map has been compiled from a variety of sources and is intended
to be used only as a guide. It is provided without any warranty or representation as to the
accuracy or completeness of the data shown. The Town of Hilton Head Island assumes no
liability for its accuracy or state of completion or for any losses arising from the use of the map.
Town of Hilton Head Island
SIPSD Easement Locations
January 2025
ATTACHMENT 1
Page 34 of 222
ENGINEER SEAL
DWG.
PROJ.
DATE
BAR IS ONE INCH ON
ORIGINAL DRAWING
VERIFY SCALE
FILESEE LEFT
JANUARY 2025
100391.02
DUNNAGANS / HWY 278
WATER DISTRIBUTION IMPROVEMENTS
FOR AGENCY APPROVAL
4000 FABER PLACE DRIVE, SUITE 330
NORTH CHARLESTON, SC 29405
(843)-628-3352
SOUTH CAROLINA
CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATIONARDURRA
GROUP
No. 6082
INC.
ATTACHMENT 2, TREE REMOVAL PLAN
Page 35 of 222
ENGINEER SEAL
DWG.
PROJ.
DATE
BAR IS ONE INCH ON
ORIGINAL DRAWING
VERIFY SCALE
FILESEE LEFT
JANUARY 2025
100391.02
DUNNAGANS / HWY 278
WATER DISTRIBUTION IMPROVEMENTS
FOR AGENCY APPROVAL
4000 FABER PLACE DRIVE, SUITE 330
NORTH CHARLESTON, SC 29405
(843)-628-3352
SOUTH CAROLINA
CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORIZATIONARDURRA
GROUP
No. 6082
INC.
ATTACHMENT 3, TREE MITIGATION PLAN
Page 36 of 222
Page 1 of 4
ORDI
NANCE NUMBER 2025-___
AN OR
DINANCE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA,
AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION AND DELIVERY OF EASEMENTS
ENCUMBERING REAL ESTATE OWNED BY THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND,
SOUTH CAROLINA, IN FAVOR OF THE SOUTH ISLAND PUBLIC SERVICE DISRICT
UNDER THE AUTHORITY OF S. C. CODE ANN. § 5-7-40 (SUPP. 2024) AND § 2-7-20,
MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA
(1983); AND PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
LEGIS
LATIVE FINDINGS
WHER
EAS, the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, owns parcels of real
property which are known and described as follows:
All that certain piece, parcel or lot of land, situate, ying and being on Hilton Head Island,
Beaufort County , South Carolina, consisting of 0.08 acres, more or less, shown and
described as “10’ Wide Acquisition” on a plat titled “Plat of Parcels 270, 283, 285, 337
Dist. 550, Map 15, Town of Hilton Head Island, Beaufort County, South Carolina,” dated
October 5, 2000, prepared by EMC Engineering Services, Inc., by Charles W. Tuten, S. C.
R. L. S. 13522, and recorded in the Office of The Register of Deeds for Beaufort County,
South Carolina, Plat Book 79 at Page 124.
AND
All t
hat certain piece, parcel or tract of land situate, lying and being in the Town of Hilton
Head Island, Beaufort County, South Carolina, and being more particularly shown and
described as “New Lot N,” containing 0.356 acres, on that certain Plat titled “A Boundary
Survey of Lots M, New Lot N, New Lot N-1 & Parcels A & C, A Portion of Palmetto Bay
Commercial Subdiv ision, Hilton Head Island, Beaufort County, South Carolina, ”
prepared by Coastal Surveying Co., I nc., for the Trust fo r Public Land, dated April 29,
2005, last revised May 12, 2005, and recorded in the Office of The Register of Deeds for
Beaufort County, South Carolina, in Plat Book 106 at Page 128.
AND
All t
hat certain piece, parcel or lot of land lying and being on Hilton Head Island, Beaufort
County, South Carolina, containing 3.63 acres, more or less, and being more particularly
shown and described on that certain Plat titled “A Plat of Tract “J” on U. S. Highway 278,”
prepared by Michael R. Dunnagan, SCRLS N o.: 11905, dated July 8, 1991, a nd recorded
in the Office of The Register of Deeds for Beaufort County, South Carolina, in Plat Book
41 at Page 193.
ATTACHMENT 4
Page 37 of 222
Page 2 of 4
AND
All that certain piece, parcel or lot of land, with improvements thereon, lying and being
on Hilton Head Is land, Beaufort County, South Carolina, containing which is more
particularly s hown on that certain Plat of Survey titled “An As -Built Survey Showing
Administrative and Sales Offices of the Hilton Head Company, Inc. , A Section of Long
Cove Plantation,” prepared by Michael R. Dunnigan, SCRLS No.: 11905, and being dated
July 8, 1991, and r ecorded in the Office of The Register of Deeds for Beaufort County,
South Carolina, in Plat Book 41 at Page 192.
(herein, collectively, the “Town Property”); and,
WHEREAS, the South Island Public Service District has requested that the Town
grant easements encumbering the Town Property to facilitate projects for the installation,
operation and maintenance of underground waterlines, electrical and other equipment
useful in the delivery of potable water in furtherance of the South I sland Public Service
District’s public purpose of delivering potable water to the citizens and residents in its
service area; and,
WHEREAS, the projects proposed by the South Island Public Service District will
improve the health, safety and welfare of the Town and its citizens, residents, and visitors;
and,
WHEREAS, S. C. Code Ann. § 5-7-40 (Supp. 2024) and § 2-7-20, Municipal Code
of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (1983), states that conveyance of real
property or property rights owned by the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina,
must be authorized by Ordinance; and,
WHEREAS, the Town Council for The Town of Hilton Head Island, South
Carolina, has determined that it is in the best interest of the Town and its citizens,
residents, and visitors to authorize the execution and delivery of the easements requested
by the South Island Public Service District.
Page 38 of 222
Page 3 of 4
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY THE TOWN
COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA; AND IT
IS ORDAINED BY THE AUTHORITY OF THE SAID TOWN COUNCIL, AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Execution of Easements.
(a) The Mayor and the Town Manager are hereby authorized to execute and deliver
easements to South Island Public Service District in a form and substance similar to the
proposed easements attached hereto as Exhibits “A,” “B,” “C” and “D;” and ,
(b) The Mayor and the Town Manager are authorized to take such other and further
actions as may be necessary to complete the transaction authorized by this Ordinance.
Section 2. Severability.
If any section, phrase, sentence, or portion of this Ordinance is, for any reason,
held or deemed to be invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction,
then such section, phrase, sentence, or portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct, and
independent provision and shall not affect the remaining portion thereof.
Section 3. Effective Date.
This Ordinance shall become effective upon its adoption by the Town Council for
the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina.
Page 39 of 222
Page 4 of 4
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL FOR THE
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, ON THIS ______ DAY OF
FEBRUARY, 2025.
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
ATTEST:
________________________________
Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk
First Reading: January 14, 2024
Second Reading:_____________________
Approved as to form: ______________________________
Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney
Introduced by Council Member:______________________
Page 40 of 222
EXHBIIT “A” TO ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE GRANTING OF EASEMENTS
TO THE SOUTH ISLAND PUBLIC SERVICE DISTRICT
Page 41 of 222
1
52528619 v1 2100048-0000121
Prepared by and after recording return to:
Burr & Forman LLP (WJN)
P.O. Drawer 3
Hilton Head Island, SC 29938
843-785-2171
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
)
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
WATER AND SEWER
UTILITY EASEMENT AGREEMENT
THIS WATER AND SEWER UTILITY EASEMENT AGREEMENT (the " Agreement") is
made this _____ day of ______________, 2024, by and between The Town of Hilton Head Island, South
Carolina, with an address of One Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928 (the "Grantor"), and
South Island Public Service District of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (the "District").
WHEREAS, Grantor owns certain real property located on the Hilton Head Island, Beaufort
County, South Carolina, which is more particularly described in Exhibit "A", attached hereto and made a
part hereof (the "Property"); and
WHEREAS, the District owns and operates water supply and wastewater treatment facilities,
including water and sewer infrastructure located or to be located on through or under the Property; and
WHEREAS, Grantor desires to grant to the District a non-exclusive utility easement upon certain
portions of the Property, which portions are more particularly shown and described in Exhibit "B",
attached hereto and made a part hereof (collectively, the "Easement Area").
NOW THEREFORE, KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that Grantor, for and in
consideration of Ten and No/100 Dollars ($10.00), and no other valuable consideration, in hand paid, the
receipt and legal sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, has bargained and sold, and by these
presents does bargain, sell, convey, transfer and deliver unto the District a permanent, non-exclusive
utility easement for water and sewer infrastructure, including the right to enter upon the Property to
construct, extend, inspect, operate, replace, relocate, repair, and maintain various water/sewer main and
service lines, manholes, hydrants, valves, meters, and other usual fixtures and appurtenances as may from
time to time be or become convenient for the provision of water and sewer services (collectively, the
"Utility Infrastructure") on, over, along, across, through, under and within the Easement Area, together
with the right of ingress, egress, and access to and from, and across and upon the Property as may be
reasonably necessary or convenient for the purposes connected therewith (the "Easement").
To have and to hold said Easement, subject to the terms and conditions herein, unto the District
forever.
Page 42 of 222
2
52528619 v1 2100048-0000121
Grantor hereby covenants with the District that it is lawfully seized and possessed of the Property,
that it has the good and lawful right to convey it, or any part thereof, and that it shall warrant and forever
defend the title thereto against the lawful claims of its successors and assigns.
Terms and Conditions:
a. The District may use the Easement conveyed herein only for the purpose of construction,
maintenance, and repair of the Utility Infrastructure for the purpose of conveying its services on, over,
along, across, through, under and within the Easement Area, together with the right to excavate and refill
ditches and/or trenches for the location of said Utility Infrastructure, and the further right to remove trees,
bushes, undergrowth, and other obstructions interfering with the location, construction, and maintenance
of said Utility Infrastructure.
b. The District agrees to cause all work contemplated herein to be performed in a
workmanlike fashion with such interference to Grantor, its successors and assigns, guests, invitees,
licensees, and agents only as is necessary to accomplish the purposes described herein.
c. The District further agrees that all debris, construction materials and equipment shall be
promptly removed from the Property upon completion of any work upon the Property undertaken
pursuant to this Agreement.
d. The District shall repair any alterations to the Property resulting from its use of this
Easement, normal wear and tear excepted, by providing sod, plantings and shrubbery, and shall patch and
repair asphalt and/or concrete pavement, in any and all trenches and/or holes wherever the same was
removed, damaged or destroyed by the District during use of the Easement conveyed herein.
e. The Easement conveyed herein is subject and subordinate to all other present and future
restrictions, easements, licenses, mortgages and conveyances of record, provided, however, that such
subordination shall not operate to extinguish the rights and privileges granted herein, and such
subordination shall not be inconsistent with the rights and privileges granted herein. The Easement
conveyed herein is further subject to the rights herein reserved to the Grantor, its successors and assigns,
to use the Property to the fullest extent possible, to grant additional underground utility easements over
said Property, so long as it does not diminish the rights herein granted and to make such improvements on
said Property, including landscaping and paving, as from time to time it elects which are not inconsistent
with the Easement.
f. The District shall ensure that all contractors, subcontractors, sub-subcontractors and all
others employed by the District to conduct any work on the Property granted herein shall have adequate
insurance coverage, which, at a minimum, shall protect the District and Grantor and all contractors from
claims under worker’s or workman’s compensation acts and other employee benefit acts, claims for
damages because of bodily injury, including death, and from claims for damages, to the work itself and to
the Property which may arise out of the District’s use of the Easement, whether such operations be by the
District or by any contractors, subcontractors, sub-subcontractors or anyone directly or indirectly
employed by any of them.
g. The District agrees to indemnify, save and hold harmless Grantor, its successors and
assigns, from and against any and all claims, causes of action, liability or losses of any nature, including
attorneys’ costs and fees incurred by Grantor in responding to or defending against any such claims,
Page 43 of 222
3
52528619 v1 2100048-0000121
arising from any acts or omissions of the District, or its officers, agents, employees and/or contractors in
the exercise of the rights granted hereunder.
To have and to hold said Easement unto the District, and unto its successors and assigns, forever.
[Remainder of page intentionally left blank]
Page 44 of 222
4
52528619 v1 2100048-0000121
WITNESS the hands and seals of the undersigned as of the date and year first above written.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
_______________________________________
Signature of Witness #1
_______________________________________
Signature of Notary Public
GRANTOR:
The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina
_______________________________________
_______________________________________
By: ___________________________________
Its: ____________________________________
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
I, the undersigned Notary Public, do hereby certify that ________________________________,
as _______________of The Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, personally appeared before me
this day and duly acknowledged the execution of the foregoing instrument.
Witness my hand and official seal this _____ day of _______________________, 2024.
___________________________________(SEAL)
Notary Public for South Carolina_________
My Commission Expires: _______________
Page 45 of 222
5
52528619 v1 2100048-0000121
WITNESS the hands and seals of the undersigned as of the date and year first above written.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
_______________________________________
Signature of Witness #1
_______________________________________
Signature of Notary Public
DISTRICT:
South Island Public Service District
_______________________________________
By:____________________________________
Its: ____________________________________
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
I, the undersigned Notary Public, do hereby certify that _________________________________,
as _____________________________ of South Island Public Service District, personally appeared
before me this day and duly acknowledged the execution of the foregoing instrument.
Witness my hand and official seal this _____ day of ____________________, 2024.
___________________________________(SEAL)
Notary Public for South Carolina
My Commission Expires: ______________
Page 46 of 222
Exhibit "A"
Legal Description of Property
ALL that certain piece, parcel or lot of land situate, lying and being on Hilton
Head Island, Beaufort County, South Carolina, consisting of 0.08 acres, more
or less, shown and described as "10' Wide Acquisition" on that certain plat
entitled "Plat of Parcels 270, 283, 285, 337 Dist. 550, Map 15, Town of Hilton
Head Island, Beaufort County, South Carolina" dated October 5, 2000,
prepared by EMC Engineering Services, Inc., by Charles W. Tuten,
S.C.R.L.S. No. 13522, and recorded in the Office of the Register of Deeds for
Beaufort County, South Carolina, in Plat Book 79 at Page 124.
PIN # R552 015 000 0395 0000
Page 47 of 222
Exhibit "B"
Easement Area
All that certain piece, parcel or tract of land, situate, lying and being on Hilton Head Island,
Beaufort County, South Carolina, consisting of a 10.00’ wide strip of land shown and designated as “N/F
Town of Hilton Head Island PIN: R552 015 000 0395 0000 (DB: 1408, PG: 1084) (EASE 2) on a
property easement exhibit entitled, "An Easement Exhibit of #44 Pope Avenue” for South Island Public
Service District, located on Hilton Head, South Carolina, dated November 21, 2023, prepared by Atlas
Surveying, Inc. and reviewed by Jeremy W. Reeder, S.C.P.L.S. No. 28139, which plat is attached hereto
to Exhibit "B-1".
Page 48 of 222
Exhibit "B-1"
Plat
Page 49 of 222
Page 50 of 222
EXHBIIT “B” TO ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE GRANTING OF EASEMENTS
TO THE SOUTH ISLAND PUBLIC SERVICE DISTRICT
Page 51 of 222
1
49674278 v1
Prepared by and after recording return to:
Burr & Forman LLP (WJN)
P.O. Drawer 3
Hilton Head Island, SC 29938
843-785-2171
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
)
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
WATER AND SEWER
UTILITY EASEMENT AGREEMENT
THIS WATER AND SEWER UTILITY EASEMENT AGREEMENT (the " Agreement") is
made this _____ day of ______________, 2024, by and between Town of Hilton Head Island with an
address of 1 Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, South Carolina 29928 (the " Grantor"), and South
Island Public Service District of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (the "District").
WHEREAS, Grantor owns certain real property located at 1030 William Hilton Parkway, Hilton
Head Island, South Carolina 29928, which is more particularly described in Exhibit "A", attached hereto
and made a part hereof (the "Property"); and
WHEREAS, the District owns and operates water supply and wastewater treatment facilities,
including water and sewer infrastructure located or to be located on through or under the Property; and
WHEREAS, Grantor desires to grant to the District a non-exclusive utility easement upon certain
portions of the Property, which portions are more particularly shown and described in Exhibit "B",
attached hereto and made a part hereof (collectively, the "Easement Area").
NOW THEREFORE, KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that Grantor, for and in
consideration of Ten and No/100 Dollars ($10.00), and no other valuable consideration, in hand paid, the
receipt and legal sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, has bargained and sold, and by these
presents does bargain, sell, convey, transfer and deliver unto the District a permanent, non-exclusive
utility easement for water and sewer infrastructure, including the right to enter upon the Property to
construct, extend, inspect, operate, replace, relocate, repair, and maintain various water/sewer main and
service lines, manholes, hydrants, valves, meters, and other usual fixtures and appurtenances as may from
time to time be or become convenient for the provision of water and sewer services (collectively, the
"Utility Infrastructure") on, over, along, across, through, under and within the Easement Area, together
with the right of ingress, egress, and access to and from, and across and upon the Property as may be
reasonably necessary or convenient for the purposes connected therewith (the "Easement").
To have and to hold said Easement, subject to the terms and conditions herein, unto the District
forever.
Page 52 of 222
2
49674278 v1
Grantor hereby covenants with the District that it is lawfully seized and possessed of the Property,
that it has the good and lawful right to convey it, or any part thereof, and that it shall warrant and forever
defend the title thereto against the lawful claims of its successors and assigns.
Terms and Conditions:
a. The District may use the Easement conveyed herein only for the purpose of construction,
maintenance, and repair of the Utility Infrastructure for the purpose of conveying its services on, over,
along, across, through, under and within the Easement Area, together with the right to excavate and refill
ditches and/or trenches for the location of said Utility Infrastructure, and the further right to remove trees,
bushes, undergrowth, and other obstructions interfering with the location, construction, and maintenance
of said Utility Infrastructure.
b. The District agrees to cause all work contemplated herein to be performed in a
workmanlike fashion with such interference to Grantor, its successors and assigns, guests, invitees,
licensees, and agents only as is necessary to accomplish the purposes described above.
c. The District further agrees that all debris, construction materials and equipment shall be
promptly removed from the Property upon completion of any work upon the Property undertaken
pursuant to this Agreement.
d. The District shall repair any alterations to the Property resulting from its use of this
Easement, normal wear and tear excepted, by providing sod, plantings and shrubbery, and shall patch and
repair asphalt and/or concrete pavement, in any and all trenches and/or holes wherever the same was
removed, damaged or destroyed by the District during use of the Easement conveyed herein.
e. The Easement conveyed herein is subject and subordinate to all other present and future
restrictions, easements, licenses, mortgages and conveyances of record, provided, however, that such
subordination shall not operate to extinguish the rights and privileges granted herein, and such
subordination shall not be inconsistent with the rights and privileges granted herein. The Easement
conveyed herein is further subject to the rights herein reserved to the Grantor, its successors and assigns,
to use the Property to the fullest extent possible, to grant additional underground utility easements over
said Property, so long as it does not diminish the rights herein granted and to make such improvements on
said Property, including landscaping and paving, as from time to time it elects which are not inconsistent
with the Easement.
f. The District shall ensure that all contractors, subcontractors, sub-subcontractors and all
others employed by the District to conduct any work on the Property granted herein shall have adequate
insurance coverage, which, at a minimum, shall protect the District and Grantor and all contractors from
claims under worker’s or workman’s compensation acts and other employee benefit acts, claims for
damages because of bodily injury, including death, and from claims for damages, to the work itself and to
the Property which may arise out of the District’s use of the Easement, whether such operations be by the
District or by any contractors, subcontractors, sub-subcontractors or anyone directly or indirectly
employed by any of them.
g. The District agrees to indemnify, save and hold harmless Grantor, its successors and
assigns, from and against any and all claims, causes of action, liability or losses of any nature, including
attorneys’ costs and fees incurred by Grantor in responding to or defending against any such claims,
Page 53 of 222
3
49674278 v1
arising from any acts or omissions of the District, or its officers, agents, employees and/or contractors in
the exercise of the rights granted hereunder.
To have and to hold said Easement unto the District, and unto its successors and assigns, forever.
[Remainder of page intentionally left blank]
Page 54 of 222
4
49674278 v1
WITNESS the hands and seals of the undersigned as of the date and year first above written.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
_______________________________________
Signature of Witness #1
_______________________________________
Signature of Notary Public
GRANTOR:
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
_______________________________________
By: ___________________________________
Its: ____________________________________
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
I, the undersigned Notary Public, do hereby certify that ________________________________,
as _______________of Town of Hilton Head Island, personally appeared before me this day and duly
acknowledged the execution of the foregoing instrument.
Witness my hand and official seal this _____ day of _______________________, 2024.
___________________________________(SEAL)
Notary Public for South Carolina
My Commission Expires: _______________
Page 55 of 222
5
49674278 v1
WITNESS the hands and seals of the undersigned as of the date and year first above written.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
_______________________________________
Signature of Witness #1
_______________________________________
Signature of Notary Public
DISTRICT:
SOUTH ISLAND PUBLIC SERVICE
DISTRICT
_______________________________________
By:____________________________________
Its: ____________________________________
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
I, the undersigned Notary Public, do hereby certify that _________________________________,
as _____________________________ of South Island Public Service District, personally appeared
before me this day and duly acknowledged the execution of the foregoing instrument.
Witness my hand and official seal this _____ day of ____________________, 2024.
___________________________________(SEAL)
Notary Public for South Carolina
My Commission Expires: _______________
Page 56 of 222
49674278 v1
Exhibit "A"
Legal Description of Property
All that certain piece, parcel or lot of land, situate, lying and being on Hilton Head Island, County of
Beaufort, State of South Carolina and being more particularly described and shown as New Lot 'N',
containing 0.356 acres, on that certain plat entitled "A Boundary Survey of Lots 'M', 'New Lot 'N', New
Lot 'N-1' & Parcels 'A' & 'C', A Portion of Palmetto Bay Commercial Subdivision, Hilton Head Island,
Beaufort County, South Carolina", prepared by Coastal Surveying Co., Inc., prepared for The Trust for
Public Land dated 4/29/05, and recorded in Plat Book 106, at Page 128 in the Office of the Register of
Deeds for Beaufort County, South Carolina.
Property Tax ID# R552 015 000 0007 0000
Page 57 of 222
49674278 v1
Exhibit "B"
Easement Area
All that certain lot, tract or parcel of land situate, lying and being in the Town of Hilton Head Island,
Beaufort County, South Carolina, and being shown and depicted on a plat entitled “Proposed Water Main
Easement on the Lands of Town of Hilton Head Island” prepared by dated November 17, 2022, which
plat is attached hereto as Exhibit "B-1" and being more particularly described as follows:
Permanent easement:
Beginning at a 1” pipe on the northern right-of-way of William Hilton Parkway (US 278) thence
proceeding along the property of MC & F Properties LLC in a direction of N35⁰53’32”W for a distance of
10.56’ to a point;
Thence turning and proceeding through the property of Town of Hilton Head Island in a direction of
N72⁰36’24”E fora distance of 105.36’ to a point on the western right-of-way of Arrow Road;
Thence turning and proceeding along the western right-of-way of Arrow Road in a direction of
S6⁰02’43”W for a distance of 10.92’ to a point on the northern right-of-way of William Hilton Parkway;
Thence turning and proceeding along the northern right-of-way of William Hilton Parkway in a direction
of S72⁰36’24”W for 97.67’ to a 1” pipe, this also being the point of beginning. This easement contains
0.023 acre or 1,017 square feet.
Temporary construction easement:
Beginning at a point on the eastern property line of MC & F Properties LLC and the western property line
of Town of Hilton Head Island and proceeding along said property line in a direction of N35⁰53’32”W for
a distance of 5.27’ to a point;
Thence turning and proceeding through the property of Town of Hilton Head Island in a direction of
N72⁰36’24”E for a distance of 109.20’ to a point on the western right-of-way of Arrow Road;
Thence turning and proceeding along the western right-of-way of Arrow Road in a direction of
S6⁰02’43”W for a distance of 5.45’ to a point; Thence turning and proceeding through the property of
Town of Hilton Head Island in a direction of S72⁰36’24”W for a distance of 105.36’ to a point, this being
the point of beginning. This easement contains 0.012 acre or 536 square feet.
Page 58 of 222
49674278 v1
Exhibit "B-1"
Plat
Page 59 of 222
Page 60 of 222
EXHBIIT “C” TO ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE GRANTING OF EASEMENTS
TO THE SOUTH ISLAND PUBLIC SERVICE DISTRICT
Page 61 of 222
1
50288576 v1
Prepared by and after recording return to:
Burr & Forman LLP (WJN)
P.O. Drawer 3
Hilton Head Island, SC 29938
843-785-2171
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
)
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
WATER AND SEWER
UTILITY EASEMENT AGREEMENT
THIS WATER AND SEWER UTILITY EASEMENT AGREEMENT (the " Agreement") is
made this _____ day of ______________, 2024, by and between Town of Hilton Head Island with an
address of 1 Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, South Carolina 29928 (the " Grantor"), and South
Island Public Service District of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (the "District").
WHEREAS, Grantor owns certain real property located on Hilton Head Island, Beaufort County,
South Carolina, which is more particularly described in Exhibit "A", attached hereto and made a part
hereof (the "Property"); and
WHEREAS, the District owns and operates water supply and wastewater treatment facilities,
including water and sewer infrastructure located or to be located on through or under the Property; and
WHEREAS, Grantor desires to grant to the District a non-exclusive utility easement upon certain
portions of the Property, which portions are more particularly shown and described in Exhibit "B",
attached hereto and made a part hereof (collectively, the "Easement Area").
NOW THEREFORE, KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that Grantor, for and in
consideration of Ten and No/100 Dollars ($10.00), and no other valuable consideration, in hand paid, the
receipt and legal sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, has bargained and sold, and by these
presents does bargain, sell, convey, transfer and deliver unto the District a permanent, non-exclusive
utility easement for water and sewer infrastructure, including the right to enter upon the Property to
construct, extend, inspect, operate, replace, relocate, repair, and maintain various water/sewer main and
service lines, manholes, hydrants, valves, meters, and other usual fixtures and appurtenances as may from
time to time be or become convenient for the provision of water and sewer services (collectively, the
"Utility Infrastructure") on, over, along, across, through, under and within the Easement Area, together
with the right of ingress, egress, and access to and from, and across and upon the Property as may be
reasonably necessary or convenient for the purposes connected therewith (the "Easement").
To have and to hold said Easement, subject to the terms and conditions herein, unto the District
forever.
Page 62 of 222
2
50288576 v1
Grantor hereby covenants with the District that it is lawfully seized and possessed of the Property,
that it has the good and lawful right to convey it, or any part thereof, and that it shall warrant and forever
defend the title thereto against the lawful claims of its successors and assigns.
Terms and Conditions:
a. The District may use the Easement conveyed herein only for the purpose of construction,
maintenance, and repair of the Utility Infrastructure for the purpose of conveying its services on, over,
along, across, through, under and within the Easement Area, together with the right to excavate and refill
ditches and/or trenches for the location of said Utility Infrastructure, and the further right to remove trees,
bushes, undergrowth, and other obstructions interfering with the location, construction, and maintenance
of said Utility Infrastructure.
b. The District agrees to cause all work contemplated herein to be performed in a
workmanlike fashion with such interference to Grantor, its successors and assigns, guests, invitees,
licensees, and agents only as is necessary to accomplish the purposes described above.
c. The District further agrees that all debris, construction materials and equipment shall be
promptly removed from the Property upon completion of any work upon the Property undertaken
pursuant to this Agreement.
d. The District shall repair any alterations to the Property resulting from its use of this
Easement, normal wear and tear excepted, by providing sod, plantings and shrubbery, and shall patch and
repair asphalt and/or concrete pavement, in any and all trenches and/or holes wherever the same was
removed, damaged or destroyed by the District during use of the Easement conveyed herein.
e. The Easement conveyed herein is subject and subordinate to all other present and future
restrictions, easements, licenses, mortgages and conveyances of record, provided, however, that such
subordination shall not operate to extinguish the rights and privileges granted herein, and such
subordination shall not be inconsistent with the rights and privileges granted herein. The Easement
conveyed herein is further subject to the rights herein reserved to the Grantor, its successors and assigns,
to use the Property to the fullest extent possible, to grant additional underground utility easements over
said Property, so long as it does not diminish the rights herein granted and to make such improvements on
said Property, including landscaping and paving, as from time to time it elects which are not inconsistent
with the Easement.
f. The District shall ensure that all contractors, subcontractors, sub-subcontractors and all
others employed by the District to conduct any work on the Property granted herein shall have adequate
insurance coverage, which, at a minimum, shall protect the District and Grantor and all contractors from
claims under worker’s or workman’s compensation acts and other employee benefit acts, claims for
damages because of bodily injury, including death, and from claims for damages, to the work itself and to
the Property which may arise out of the District’s use of the Easement, whether such operations be by the
District or by any contractors, subcontractors, sub-subcontractors or anyone directly or indirectly
employed by any of them.
g. The District agrees to indemnify, save and hold harmless Grantor, its successors and
assigns, from and against any and all claims, causes of action, liability or losses of any nature, including
attorneys’ costs and fees incurred by Grantor in responding to or defending against any such claims,
Page 63 of 222
3
50288576 v1
arising from any acts or omissions of the District, or its officers, agents, employees and/or contractors in
the exercise of the rights granted hereunder.
To have and to hold said Easement unto the District, and unto its successors and assigns, forever.
[Remainder of page intentionally left blank]
Page 64 of 222
4
50288576 v1
WITNESS the hands and seals of the undersigned as of the date and year first above written.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
_______________________________________
Signature of Witness #1
_______________________________________
Signature of Notary Public
GRANTOR:
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
_______________________________________
By: ___________________________________
Its: ____________________________________
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
I, the undersigned Notary Public, do hereby certify that ________________________________,
as _______________of Town of Hilton Head Island, personally appeared before me this day and duly
acknowledged the execution of the foregoing instrument.
Witness my hand and official seal this _____ day of _______________________, 2024.
___________________________________(SEAL)
Notary Public for South Carolina
My Commission Expires: _______________
Page 65 of 222
5
50288576 v1
WITNESS the hands and seals of the undersigned as of the date and year first above written.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
_______________________________________
Signature of Witness #1
_______________________________________
Signature of Notary Public
DISTRICT:
SOUTH ISLAND PUBLIC SERVICE
DISTRICT
_______________________________________
By:____________________________________
Its: ____________________________________
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
I, the undersigned Notary Public, do hereby certify that _________________________________,
as _____________________________ of South Island Public Service District, personally appeared
before me this day and duly acknowledged the execution of the foregoing instrument.
Witness my hand and official seal this _____ day of ____________________, 2024.
___________________________________(SEAL)
Notary Public for South Carolina
My Commission Expires: _______________
Page 66 of 222
50288576 v1
Exhibit "A"
Legal Description of Property
All that certain piece, parcel, or tract of land, lying and being on Hilton Head Island, Beaufort County,
South Carolina, containing 3.63 acres, more or less, and being more particularly shown and described on
that certain plat of survey entitled "a plat of tract "J" on U. S. Highway 278" with said plat being prepared
by Michael R. Dunnagan, SCRLS No: 11905, and being dated July 8, 1991, and being recorded in the
RMC Office for Beaufort County, South Carolina, in Plat Book 41, Page 193.
Property Tax ID# R550 015 000 0323 0000
Page 67 of 222
50288576 v1
Exhibit "B"
Easement Area
ALL that certain lot, tract or parcel of land situate, lying and being in the Town of Hilton Head Island,
Beaufort County, South Carolina, and being shown and depicted on a plat entitled “NEW PERMANENT
WATER LINE EASEMENT ACROSS THE PROPERTY OF TOWN OF HILTON HEAD TO BE
DEDICATED TO SOUTH ISLAND PSD BEING THE PROPERTY DESCRIBED IN: DEED BOOK
589 PAGE 779 PIN # R55-015-000-0323 HILTON HEAD ISLAND BEAUFORT COUNTY, SOUTH
CAROLINA AUGUST 15, 2022”, prepared Vaughn & Melton Consulting Engineers Inc., certified by
Randall L. Stepp, PLS (SC #27461), dated January 10, 2023, which plat is attached hereto as Exhibit "B-
1".
Page 68 of 222
50288576 v1
Exhibit "B-1"
Plat
Page 69 of 222
Page 70 of 222
EXHBIIT “D” TO ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE GRANTING OF EASEMENTS
TO THE SOUTH ISLAND PUBLIC SERVICE DISTRICT
Page 71 of 222
1
50289244 v1
Prepared by and after recording return to:
Burr & Forman LLP (WJN)
P.O. Drawer 3
Hilton Head Island, SC 29938
843-785-2171
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
)
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
WATER AND SEWER
UTILITY EASEMENT AGREEMENT
THIS WATER AND SEWER UTILITY EASEMENT AGREEMENT (the " Agreement") is
made this _____ day of ______________, 2024, by and between Town of Hilton Head Island with an
address of 1 Town Center Court, Hilton Head Island, South Carolina 29928 (the " Grantor"), and South
Island Public Service District of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (the "District").
WHEREAS, Grantor owns certain real property located at 1 Town Center Court, Hilton Head
Island, Beaufort County, South Carolina, which is more particularly described in Exhibit "A", attached
hereto and made a part hereof (the "Property"); and
WHEREAS, the District owns and operates water supply and wastewater treatment facilities,
including water and sewer infrastructure located or to be located on through or under the Property; and
WHEREAS, Grantor desires to grant to the District a non-exclusive utility easement upon certain
portions of the Property, which portions are more particularly shown and described in Exhibit "B",
attached hereto and made a part hereof (collectively, the "Easement Area").
NOW THEREFORE, KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS that Grantor, for and in
consideration of Ten and No/100 Dollars ($10.00), and no other valuable consideration, in hand paid, the
receipt and legal sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, has bargained and sold, and by these
presents does bargain, sell, convey, transfer and deliver unto the District a permanent, non-exclusive
utility easement for water and sewer infrastructure, including the right to enter upon the Property to
construct, extend, inspect, operate, replace, relocate, repair, and maintain various water/sewer main and
service lines, manholes, hydrants, valves, meters, and other usual fixtures and appurtenances as may from
time to time be or become convenient for the provision of water and sewer services (collectively, the
"Utility Infrastructure") on, over, along, across, through, under and within the Easement Area, together
with the right of ingress, egress, and access to and from, and across and upon the Property as may be
reasonably necessary or convenient for the purposes connected therewith (the "Easement").
To have and to hold said Easement, subject to the terms and conditions herein, unto the District
forever.
Page 72 of 222
2
50289244 v1
Grantor hereby covenants with the District that it is lawfully seized and possessed of the Property,
that it has the good and lawful right to convey it, or any part thereof, and that it shall warrant and forever
defend the title thereto against the lawful claims of its successors and assigns.
Terms and Conditions:
a. The District may use the Easement conveyed herein only for the purpose of construction,
maintenance, and repair of the Utility Infrastructure for the purpose of conveying its services on, over,
along, across, through, under and within the Easement Area, together with the right to excavate and refill
ditches and/or trenches for the location of said Utility Infrastructure, and the further right to remove trees,
bushes, undergrowth, and other obstructions interfering with the location, construction, and maintenance
of said Utility Infrastructure.
b. The District agrees to cause all work contemplated herein to be performed in a
workmanlike fashion with such interference to Grantor, its successors and assigns, guests, invitees,
licensees, and agents only as is necessary to accomplish the purposes described above.
c. The District further agrees that all debris, construction materials and equipment shall be
promptly removed from the Property upon completion of any work upon the Property undertaken
pursuant to this Agreement.
d. The District shall repair any alterations to the Property resulting from its use of this
Easement, normal wear and tear excepted, by providing sod, plantings and shrubbery, and shall patch and
repair asphalt and/or concrete pavement, in any and all trenches and/or holes wherever the same was
removed, damaged or destroyed by the District during use of the Easement conveyed herein.
e. The Easement conveyed herein is subject and subordinate to all other present and future
restrictions, easements, licenses, mortgages and conveyances of record, provided, however, that such
subordination shall not operate to extinguish the rights and privileges granted herein, and such
subordination shall not be inconsistent with the rights and privileges granted herein. The Easement
conveyed herein is further subject to the rights herein reserved to the Grantor, its successors and assigns,
to use the Property to the fullest extent possible, to grant additional underground utility easements over
said Property, so long as it does not diminish the rights herein granted and to make such improvements on
said Property, including landscaping and paving, as from time to time it elects which are not inconsistent
with the Easement.
f. The District shall ensure that all contractors, subcontractors, sub-subcontractors and all
others employed by the District to conduct any work on the Property granted herein shall have adequate
insurance coverage, which, at a minimum, shall protect the District and Grantor and all contractors from
claims under worker’s or workman’s compensation acts and other employee benefit acts, claims for
damages because of bodily injury, including death, and from claims for damages, to the work itself and to
the Property which may arise out of the District’s use of the Easement, whether such operations be by the
District or by any contractors, subcontractors, sub-subcontractors or anyone directly or indirectly
employed by any of them.
g. The District agrees to indemnify, save and hold harmless Grantor, its successors and
assigns, from and against any and all claims, causes of action, liability or losses of any nature, including
attorneys’ costs and fees incurred by Grantor in responding to or defending against any such claims,
Page 73 of 222
3
50289244 v1
arising from any acts or omissions of the District, or its officers, agents, employees and/or contractors in
the exercise of the rights granted hereunder.
To have and to hold said Easement unto the District, and unto its successors and assigns, forever.
[Remainder of page intentionally left blank]
Page 74 of 222
4
50289244 v1
WITNESS the hands and seals of the undersigned as of the date and year first above written.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
_______________________________________
Signature of Witness #1
_______________________________________
Signature of Notary Public
GRANTOR:
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
_______________________________________
By: ___________________________________
Its: ____________________________________
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
I, the undersigned Notary Public, do hereby certify that ________________________________,
as _______________of Town of Hilton Head Island, personally appeared before me this day and duly
acknowledged the execution of the foregoing instrument.
Witness my hand and official seal this _____ day of _______________________, 2024.
___________________________________(SEAL)
Notary Public for South Carolina
My Commission Expires: _______________
Page 75 of 222
5
50289244 v1
WITNESS the hands and seals of the undersigned as of the date and year first above written.
IN THE PRESENCE OF:
_______________________________________
Signature of Witness #1
_______________________________________
Signature of Notary Public
DISTRICT:
SOUTH ISLAND PUBLIC SERVICE
DISTRICT
_____________________________________
By:__________________________________
Its: _________________________________
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA )
) ACKNOWLEDGMENT
COUNTY OF BEAUFORT )
I, the undersigned Notary Public, do hereby certify that _________________________________,
as _____________________________ of South Island Public Service District, personally appeared
before me this day and duly acknowledged the execution of the foregoing instrument.
Witness my hand and official seal this _____ day of ____________________, 2024.
___________________________________(SEAL)
Notary Public for South Carolina
My Commission Expires: _______________
Page 76 of 222
50289244 v1
Exhibit "A"
Legal Description of Property
All that certain piece, parcel, or lot of land, with improvements thereon, located on Hilton Head Island,
Beaufort County, South Carolina, which is more particularly shown on that certain plat of survey entitled
"an as built survey showing administrative and sales offices of the Hilton Head Company, Inc., a section
of Long Cove Plantation, prepared by Michael R. Dunnagan, SCRLS No: 11905, and being dated July 8,
1991, and being recorded in the RMC Office for Beaufort County, South Carolina, in Plat Book 41, Page
192.
Property Tax ID# R550 015 000 0324 0000
Page 77 of 222
50289244 v1
Exhibit "B"
Easement Area
ALL that certain lot, tract or parcel of land situate, lying and being in the Town of Hilton Head Island,
Beaufort County, South Carolina, and being shown and depicted on a plat entitled “NEW PERMANENT
WATER LINE EASEMENT ACROSS THE PROPERTY OF TOWN OF HILTON HEAD TO BE
DEDICATED TO SOUTH ISLAND PSD BEING THE PROPERTY DESCRIBED IN: DEED BOOK
589 PAGE 782 PIN # R550-015-000-0324 HILTON HEAD ISLAND BEAUFORT COUNTY, SOUTH
CAROLINA AUGUST 15, 2022”, prepared Vaughn & Melton Consulting Engineers Inc., certified by
Randall L. Stepp, PLS (SC #27461), dated January 9, 2023, which plat is attached hereto as Exhibit "B-
1".
Page 78 of 222
50289244 v1
Exhibit "B-1"
Plat
Page 79 of 222
Page 80 of 222
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
Town Council
TO:
FROM:
VIA:
DATE:
SUBJECT:
Town Council
Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk
Marc Orlando, Town Manager
February 4, 2025
Consideration of 2025 Meeting Schedule for Community
Services and Public Safety Committee and Finance and
Administrative Committee
RECOMMENDATION:
Town Council approve the attached schedules for the Community Services and Public
Safety Committee and the Finance and Administrative Committee meetings for the
calendar year of 2025.
ATTACHMENTS:
1. Proposed 2025 Community Services and Public Safety Committee Meeting
Schedule
2. Proposed 2025 Finance and Administrative Committee Schedule
Page 81 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island
Community Services and Public
Safety Committee
2025 Meeting Schedule
MEETING DATES
February 10, 2025
March 17, 2025
April 21, 2025
May 19, 2025
June 16, 2025
July 21, 2025
August 18, 2025
September 15, 2025
October 20, 2025
November 17, 2025
December 15, 2025
Regular meetings are held at 10:00 A.M. on the third Monday of the month
unless otherwise noticed*.
FIOA Compliance: Public notification of all meetings will be published,
posted and distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of
Information Act and the requirements of the Town of Hilton Head Island.
Page 82 of 222
Town of Hilton Head Island
Finance and Administrative Committee
2025 Meeting Schedule
MEETING DATES
February 24, 2025
March 25, 2025
April 29, 2025
May 27, 2025
June 24, 2025
July 29, 2024
August 26, 2025
September 30, 2025
October 28, 2025
November 25, 2025
December 30, 2025
Regular meetings are held at 10:00 A.M. on the last Tuesday of the month
unless otherwise noticed*.
FIOA Compliance: Public notification of all meetings will be published,
posted and distributed in compliance with the South Carolina Freedom of
Information Act and the requirements of the Town of Hilton Head Island.
Page 83 of 222
Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex
One Town Center Court Hilton Head Island South Carolina 29928
www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
Town Council
TO: Town Council
FROM: Missy Luick, Director of Planning
VIA: Shawn Leininger, Assistant Town Manager
CC: Marc Orlando, Town Manager
DATE: February 4, 2025
SUBJECT: Consideration of an Ordinance to amend Title 17 of the Municipal
Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island, to Amend Chapter 4, Noise
Control, to add additional requirements for construction hours
RECOMMENDATION:
Town Council consider First Reading of an Ordinance to amend Title 17 of the
Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island, to Amend Chapter 4, Noise Control,
to add additional requirements for construction hours.
BACKGROUND:
The Town of Hilton Head Island has committed to implementing its Strategic Action Plan
of which a Land Management Ordinance (LMO) amendments project has been identified
as part of the Growth Management Strategy. The Town conducted a critical analysis of
the Land Management Ordinance and created an LMO Amendments Plan to incorporate
policy changes to bring the LMO into alignment with the comprehensive plan, Our Plan,
and to incorporate the future District Plan recommendations.
The effort has been divided into two separate projects, the full LMO Overhaul and the
Priority Amendments. The Priority Amendments include incremental changes to both the
LMO and portions of the Municipal Code related to land management that seek to address
important and urgent issues in advance of the full LMO Overhaul. These Priority
Amendments aim to address pressing community development issues with the best short-
term solution while minimizing unintended outcomes. Issues that require additional
analysis and research or are more complex are recommended to be further explored
during the full LMO Overhaul.
On September 24, 2024, Town Council held a workshop to review the LMO Amendments
Plan, including an amendment to add Construction Management Standards to the LMO.
Town Council discussion of this topic included direction to amend the Town’s Noise
Control Ordinance to add construction hours as part of the Priority Amendments.
SUMMARY:
Page 84 of 222
Page 2 of 4
The current regulations permit construction activity any day of the week during daytime,
which is defined as beginning at 7:00am and ending at 10:00pm. The proposed
amendment to Chapter 4, Noise Control, of Title 17 of the Municipal Code:
1. Aligns construction activity days and hours with those enforced by local Property
Owners Associations (POAs) and other best practices to provide a more
standardized schedule that minimizes disturbances to nearby properties;
2. Limits construction activity to Monday through Saturday, excluding listed major
Town holidays (New Year’s Day, Memorial Day, Independence Day, Labor Day,
Thanksgiving Day, and Christmas Day); and
3. When permitted, limits construction activity to 7:00am to 7:00pm.
The proposed amendment provides clarity to the Town’s permitted construction activity
hours and consistency with the private property regulations enforced in a majority of the
community.
TOWN COUNCIL WORKSHOP:
At the September 24, 2024 Town Council Workshop, Town staff was provided the
following comments and direction as it relates to this proposed Noise Ordinance
amendment.
•Construction projects often spill over into commercial and residential areas,
causing disruptions including noise, vibrations, dust, traffic congestion, parking
issues, and restricted access to properties.
•Construction impacts are frustrating and affect daily routines and operations.
•Construction projects create jobs and stimulate the local economy with new
developments that can result in positive impacts such as improved buildings, public
spaces, and infrastructure that can benefit the community.
•Change the hours of construction from 7:00am – 10:00pm every day of the week
to align with POAs and other best practices.
ANALYSIS:
Town staff evaluated the Island’s largest planned unit development communities to
analyze and compare those construction day and time standards and practices to the
existing Town Noise Control regulations. While there are variations, generally
construction activity is permitted Monday through Friday from 7:00am until 7:00pm.
Construction activity is permitted on Saturdays with pre-authorization. Construction is
prohibited on Sundays and major holidays.
Below is a summary of the planned unit development community’s construction activity
policies compared to what is being proposed in the Town’s Noise Ordinance
amendment:
Page 85 of 222
Page 3 of 4
PUD Town of Hilton Head Island Proposal
1. Hilton Head Plantation:
a) In general, it is expected that
during normal working hours
(7:00am to 7:00pm) certain
equipment such as lawnmowers,
leaf blowers, and construction
apparatus will generate noise as
part of their intended function.
b) Commercial Vendors/Contractors
are normally permitted entry to
work between the hours of 7:00am
and 7:00pm Monday through
Friday; Saturday hours are 8:00am
to 5:00pm; and work is not allowed
on Sunday. No work is permitted
on Christmas, New Year’s, and
Thanksgiving Day.
2. Sea Pines:
a) Hours for work on Sea Pines’
Properties are Monday through
Saturday from 7:00am to 7:00pm.
No nonemergency commercial
work will be performed on
Sundays.
3. Palmetto Dunes:
a) Commercial work is only allowed in
the community Monday through
Friday from 7:00am to 7:00pm. If
work is needed on Saturday, the
contractor must contact the ARB
before 12:00pm on Friday to obtain
approval.
4. Port Royal:
a) Construction work is permitted only
on weekdays (Monday to Friday)
that are not South Carolina legal
holidays, and only between the
hours of 7:00am and 7:00pm or
until dark, whichever comes first.
5. Shipyard
a) Construction work is only allowed \
Monday through Friday from
7:00am to 7:00pm. If work is
needed on Saturday, the owner
must contact Shipyard Security
Activities related to construction and
landscape maintenance are permitted
between the hours of 7:00am and
7:00pm, or sunset, whichever occurs first,
Monday through Saturday excluding
major holidays, (New Year’s Day,
Memorial Day, Independence Day, Labor
Day, Thanksgiving Day, and Christmas
Day).
Page 86 of 222
Page 4 of 4
PUD Town of Hilton Head Island Proposal
before the work begins and
complete the Authorization for
Weekend/After Hours Work Form
to obtain approval.
b) No work is permitted on Sundays,
Christmas, Thanksgiving, or
National & Observed Holidays.
6. Wexford
a) Construction hours are 7:00am to
6:00pm, Monday through Friday.
Permission to perform work on
Saturday or outside of normal work
hours must be requested, in
advance, and approved by the
ASC Administrator or their
designee.
b) Construction work may not be
performed on the following days:
Weekends, New Year’s Day,
Memorial Day, Fourth of July,
Labor Day, Thanksgiving Day and
Christmas Day.
Based on direction provided by Town Council, Town Staff review of these planned unit
development community’s construction regulations, Town staff has proposed an
amendment to Title 17 of the Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island, Chapter
4, Noise Control, to establish more consistent requirements for construction hours.
ATTACHMENTS:
1. Ordinance
2. Text Amendment
Page 87 of 222
Attachment 2 – Exhibit A Noise Ordinance Amendment
Page 1 of 2
AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
ORDINANCE NO.
AN ORDINANCE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND AMEND
TITLE 17 OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD
ISLAND, TO AMEND CHAPTER 4, NOISE CONTROL, TO ADD
ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS FOR CONSTRUCTION HOURS FOR THE
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA AND PROVIDING
FOR SEVERABILITY AND AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the Town Council for the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina, has
identified a continued need for the adoption of Municipal Code Amendments to address needs and
issues in the Town as such arise; and,
WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that noise created by construction, excavation,
demolition, alteration or repair work on buildings or other structures, the operation and the operation
tools or equipment used in construction, excavation, drilling, demolition, alteration or repair work
and landscape maintenance and the operation of tools and equipment used for landscape maintenance
has negative effects and lessens and impairs the peace, quiet and quality of life of those persons in
the vicinity of the activity creating the noise; and,
WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that the health, safety and welfare of citizens, residents
and visitors of and to the Town are promoted and improved by limiting the activities that create such
noise to the hours beginning at 7:00 AM and ending at 7:00 PM, or sunset, whichever comes first,
Monday through Saturday, except on major holidays observed by the Town, being New Year’s Day,
Memorial Day, Independence Day, Labor Day, Thanksgiving Day, and Christmas Day).
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY THE TOWN
COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA,
AND IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND ORDAINED BY AND UNDER AUTHORITY
OF SAID TOWN COUNCIL, AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Amendment. That the Municipal Code is amended as shown on Exhibit “A” to
this Ordinance. Newly added language is illustrated with double underline and deleted
language is illustrated with strikethrough .
Section 2. Severability. If any section, phrase, sentence, or portion of this Ordinance is for
any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such
portion shall be deemed a separate, distinct, and independent provision, and such holding shall
not affect the validity of the remaining portions thereof.
Page 88 of 222
Attachment 2 – Exhibit A Noise Ordinance Amendment
Page 2 of 2
Section 3. Effective Date. This Ordinance shall be effective upon its adoption by the Town
Council of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina.
PASSED, APPROVED, AND ADOPTED BY THE COUNCIL FOR THE
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND ON THIS _____ DAY OF __________ , 2025.
THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD
ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA
____________________________
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
ATTEST:
_____________________________________
Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk
First Reading:
Second Reading:
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
__________________________________
Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney
Page 89 of 222
Attachment 2 – Text Amendment Noise Control
LMO Priority Amendments: Municipal Code Noise Ordinance Page 1 of 4
TITLE 17 - GENERAL REGULATIONS
Chapter 4 - NOISE CONTROL
Sec. 17-4-114. Prohibited acts.
The following acts are declared to be nuisances hereunder and are hereby declared to be unlawful and in
violation of the provisions hereof:
(1) The willful creation or causing of any excessively loud sound. The creation or causing of any excessively
loud sound shall be deemed to be "willful" if upon notice to the emitter of any excessively loud sound,
the emitter fails or refuses to cease the creation or causing of the excessively loud sound.
(2) The erection, including construction, excavation, demolition, alteration or repair work, or the
permitting or causing thereof, of any building or other structure, or the operation or the permitting or
causing the operation of any tools or equipment used in construction, excavation, drilling, demolition,
alteration or repair work; or the performance of landscape maintenance and the operation of tools and
equipment customarily used in connection with landscape maintenance:
a. Other than during the daytime between the hours of 7:00 a.m. and 7:00 p.m., or sunset,
whichever comes first, Monday through Saturday excluding major holidays observed by the
Town, (New Year’s Day, Memorial Day, Independence Day, Labor Day, Thanksgiving Day, and
Christmas Day); or
b. In such a manner as to create noise levels greater than 95 dBA at the property line of the
property where such activity occurs.
c. This section shall not apply in cases of extreme and urgent necessity in the interest of public
safety and convenience, and then only by permit obtained from, and issued by, town manager.
(3) The operation of any automobile, motorcycle, boat, vehicle, machine, machinery or equipment with a
nonfunctioning or disabled muffler.
(4) a. On any property located within the following zones: RSF-3, RSF-5, RSF-6, RM-4, RM-8 and RM-12, as
defined in title 16, specifically section 16-3-104, Residential Base Zoning Districts, the making of any
noise during the daytime, wherein the sound level from any operation, use or occupancy exceeds the
sound level limits specified in the octave band or the A-scale measurement indicated in the following
table when measured from any other property under separate ownership.
Octave Band
Center Frequency
(Hertz)
63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 8000 A-
Scale
Sound Level
Limit
(dB re: 0.0002 microbar)
76 66 59 54 50 47 44 42 60
b. The daytime sound level limits are to be reduced by five (5) dB during the nighttime.
c. The sound level limits set forth in subsections (4)a. and (4)b. above are to be reduced by five (5)
dB in the case of impulsive sound.
(5) a. On any property located within the following zones: NC, PD-1, S, MF, WMU, CR, and RD, as defined in
title 16, specifically section 16-3-105, Mixed-Use and Business Districts, the making or allowing or
causing to be made of any noise, wherein the sound level from any operation, use or occupancy
Page 90 of 222
Attachment 2 – Text Amendment Noise Control
LMO Priority Amendments: Municipal Code Noise Ordinance Page 2 of 4
exceeds the sound level limits specified in the octave band indicated or the A -scale measurement
indicated in the following table when measured from any other property under separate ownership.
Octave Band
Center Frequency
(Hertz)
63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 8000 A-
Scale
Sound Level
Limit
(dB re: 0.0002 microbar)
81 71 66 61 57 54 52 49 67
b. The daytime sound level limits are to be reduced by five (5) dB during the nighttime.
c. The sound level limits set forth in subsections (5)a. and (5)b. above are to be reduced by five (5)
dB in the case of impulsive sound.
(6) a. On any property located within the following zones: LC, MS, MED, MV, SPC, CC, IL, and PR, as defined in
title 16, specifically [section] 16-3-105, Mixed-Use and Business Districts, and the Shelter Cove and
Harbour Town multiple use areas (as defined on the maps which are found at the end of this chapter),
the making or allowing or causing to be made of any noise, wherein the sound level from any
operation, use or occupancy exceeds the sound level limits specified in the octave band or the A -scale
measurement indicated in the following table when measured from any other property under separate
ownership.
Octave Band
Center Frequency
(Hertz)
63 125 250 500 1000 2000 4000 8000 A-
Scale
Sound Level
Limit
(dB re: 0.0002 microbar)
83 74 69 64 62 57 54 52 69
b. The daytime sound level limits are to be reduced by five (5) dB during the nighttime.
c. The sound level limits set forth in subsections (6)a. and (6)b. above are to be reduced by five (5)
dB in the case of impulsive sound.
(Ord. No. 94-22, § 1, 7-19-94; Ord. No. 95-25, § 1, 11-8-95; Ord. No. 04-42, § 1, 12-21-04; Ord. No. 2009-08, § 1, 3-
17-09; Ord. No. 2015-14, § 1(Exh. 1), 6-16-15)
Sec. 17-4-115. Exceptions.
(a) The provisions of this chapter shall not apply to:
(1) The sounding of an alarm, or the utilization of a siren or other emission of sound for the purpose of
alerting persons to the existence of an emergency or the approach of an emergency vehicle;
(2) Sound produced by an aircraft approaching, landing at, taking off from or utilizing the taxiways or
runways of the Hilton Head Airport;
(3) Sound produced by a vehicle (not including sound produced by an emitter within any such vehicle)
while the vehicle is moving on a public right-of-way or public waterway, or is otherwise being lawfully
operated;
(4) Sound produced by a governmental body in the performance of a governmental function; or
(5) Sound produced by church bells or chimes, whether produced by the striking of a church bell or chime,
or a recording thereof.
Page 91 of 222
Attachment 2 – Text Amendment Noise Control
LMO Priority Amendments: Municipal Code Noise Ordinance Page 3 of 4
(6) Sound produced by non-commercial persons and machinery engaged in landscape maintenance,
cleanup, grinding or chipping of tree trunks or branches, or tree shaping or removal, at the location
where the vegetative material was generated, during the daytime; and sound produced by commercial
persons and machinery engaged in landscape maintenance, cleanup, grinding or chipping of tree trunks
or branches, or tree shaping or removal, at the location where the vegetative material was generated,
between the hours of 7:00 am and 67:00 pm, or sunset, whichever comes first, on Monday through
Saturday excluding major holidays observed by the Town, (New Year’s Day, Memorial Day,
Independence Day, Labor Day, Thanksgiving Day, and Christmas Day), provided however that such
activity shall not create noise levels greater than 95 dba at the property line on the property that the
activity occurs.
(7) Sound produced by persons and machinery engaged in the lawful and permitted construction,
excavation, renovation or demolition of any structure, including the installation of utilities and paving ,
between the hours of 7:00 a.m. and 7:00 p.m., or sunset, whichever comes first, Monday through
Saturday excluding major holidays observed by the Town, (New Year’s Day, Memorial Day,
Independence Day, Labor Day, Thanksgiving Day, and Christmas Day) , provided however that such
activity shall not create noise levels greater than 95 dba at the property line on the property that the
activity occurs.
(8) Sounds produced by parades or athletic events, and permitted fireworks.
(9) Sounds produced by maintenance or repair activity within boat yards, during the daytime.
(10) Sounds produced by commercial persons and machinery engaged in sawing or grinding of tree trunks,
branches or other organic matter into mulch, at a location other than where the vegetative material
was generated (generated off site), between the hours of 9:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m. on Monday through
Friday, excluding federal and state holidays; and sounds produced by non -commercial persons and
machinery engaged in sawing or grinding of tree trunks, branches or other organic matter into mulch,
at a location other than where the vegetative material was generated (generated off site), during the
daytime on Monday through Saturday.
(11) Sounds produced by golf course or tennis maintenance or watering equipment.
(12) Sounds produced by the commercial persons and machinery engaged in loading or unloading of tree
trunks or branches between the hours of 9:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m. on Monday through Friday, excluding
federal and state holidays; and sounds produced by the non-commercial persons and machinery
engaged in loading and unloading of tree trunks or branches, during the daytime on Monday through
Saturday.
(b) Applications for a semi-annual permit for relief from the noise restrictions designated in this chapter on the
basis of undue hardship may be made to the town manager or his duly authorized representative. The relief
requested may be granted upon a good and sufficient showing:
(1) That additional time is necessary for the applicant to alter or modify his activity or operation to comply
with the provisions of this chapter;
(2) That the activity, operation or noise will be of temporary duration and cannot reasonably be done in a
manner that would comply with this chapter; or
(3) That no reasonable alternative is available to the applicant.
(c) The permit application shall be responded to conclusively within five (5) business days from the receipt of
the application. If granted, the permit shall be in writing and contain all conditions upon which such permit is
granted, including, but not limited to, the effective dates, and any time of day, location, sound pressure level
or equipment limitation. The town manager or his duly authorized representative may prescribe any
reasonable conditions or requirements deemed necessary to minimize adverse e ffects upon the community
or the surrounding area.
(Ord. No. 94-22, § 1, 7-19-94; Ord. No. 2019-07, § 1, 4-2-19)
Page 92 of 222
Attachment 2 – Text Amendment Noise Control
LMO Priority Amendments: Municipal Code Noise Ordinance Page 4 of 4
Page 93 of 222
Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex
One Town Center Court Hilton Head Island South Carolina 29928
www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
Town Council
TO: Town Council
FROM: Shawn Colin, AICP, Assistant Town Manager
CC: Marc Orlando, ICMA-CM, Town Manager
CC: Shawn Leininger, AICP, Assistant Town Manager
CC: Jeff Netzinger, PE, Engineering Director
DATE: February 4, 2025
SUBJECT: Consideration of a Resolution Authorizing the Town Manager to sign
the Permits Required to Execute the Beach Renourishment Project
Recommendation:
Consideration of a Resolution Authorizing the Town Manager to sign the Permits
Required to Execute the Beach Renourishment Project (Attachment 1).
Background:
The purpose of this report is to inform Town Council of the environmental permitting
condition mandated by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS), the U.S. Army
Corps of Engineers (USACOE) and the South Carolina Department of Environmental
services (SCDES) as part of the Town’s beach renourishment efforts, specifically the
requirement of a year-round dog ban on portions of public beach. This condition is being
applied to the Town’s permitting process for the beach renourishment project.
The Town of Hilton Head Island is in the process of permitting and executing its fourth
major Beach Renourishment project. In past projects, the Town and regulatory agencies
have been effective partners, balancing the necessary beach maintenance with wildlife
protection. As part of the permitting process, the United State Fish and Wildlife Service
(USFWS) is issuing a Biological Opinion (BO) under Section 7 of the Endangered
Species Act of 1973.
This year, for the first time, USFWS is mandating a year-round ban on dogs, with the
initial draft BO, dated August 8, 2024 and included as Attachment 2, imposing
restrictions at Fish Haul Beach Park, portions of Port Royal Plantation, and Pine Island
Beach, as illustrated on Attachment 3. The BO cites concerns about the potential
disturbance to birds from the presence of dogs, even when leashed. The applicable
sections of the Biological Opinion that require this restriction are outlined below under
Reasonable and Prudent Measure#4 as well as Terms and Condition#4.
Shorebirds – Reasonable and Prudent Measures:
RPM#4. The Town must implement the revised and approved Town of Hilton Head
Shorebird Conservation and Management Plan (Plan) from 2015 before project
Page 94 of 222
Page 2 of 3
Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex
One Town Center Court Hilton Head Island South Carolina 29928
www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
construction begins. The Plan will include beach management measures aimed at
reducing human recreational disturbance to offset the anticipated take resulting from the
proposed Action.
Shorebirds Terms and Conditions:
T&C#4. The Town will implement the revised and approved Town of Hilton Head
Shorebird Conservation and Management Plan (Plan) from 2015 before project
construction begins unless another written agreement between the Town, Service, and
Corps is reached in the interim. The Plan will include permanent, year-round dog
restricted access areas along Pine Island and the Fish Haul Creek area shorelines of
Port Royal Sound to minimize existing human recreational disturbance to piping plovers,
red knots, and other shorebirds. These areas fall within the Town’s jurisdiction and align
with beach access points. The Town or its contractor will install signage at beach
access points and above the spring high tide line to delineate where the restricted
area(s) begin. The Town will also install marked buoys at the mid-tide and low-tide lines
to delineate the area(s) when the tide is below the high-tide line.
While the Town supports conservation efforts, Town staff strongly objected to this
blanket dog ban, as it does not reflect the current needs or practices of our residents
and visitors, who frequently use these areas to walk their dogs. The Town staff
coordinated discussion and consideration of these requirements with a request to
remove or reduce the areas impacted, based on the actual presence of protected bird
species during migration periods, rather than imposing year-round restrictions.
As a result of these efforts, USFWS has issued an amended BO to the USACOE,
shown as Attachment 4. The amended BO includes revised language for Terms and
Condition #4 as outlined below which reduces the area where the restrictions must
apply by removing Pine Island Beach and reducing the area of restrictions near Fish
Haul Beach Park.
T&C#4. The Town will implement the revised and approved Town of Hilton Head
Shorebird Conservation and Management Plan (Plan) from 2015 before project
construction begins unless another written agreement between the Town, Service, and
Corps is reached in the interim. The Plan will include one permanent, year-round dog
restricted access area along the Fish Haul Creek shoreline of Port Royal Sound to
minimize existing and future human recreational disturbance to piping plovers, red
knots, and other shorebirds. The specific location will be finalized in coordination with
and approved by the Service. This area falls within the Town’s jurisdiction. The Town or
its contractor will install signage at nearby beach access points and above the spring
high tide line to delineate where the restricted area begins. The Town will also install
signage and/or marked buoys at the mid-tide and low-tide lines to delineate the area
when the tide is below the high-tide line.
This revised BO still maintains the Reasonable and Prudent Measure #4 which means
the Town will need to amend the Municipal Code before the construction activity for the
Beach Renourishment project begins. Therefore, an amendment to Section 8-1-211(8)
Page 95 of 222
Page 3 of 3
Stephen G. Riley Municipal Complex
One Town Center Court Hilton Head Island South Carolina 29928
www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
of the Town’s Municipal Code will be advanced to codify the required restrictions in the
coming months. The area where these new restrictions will apply are illustrated in
Attachment 5.
Requested Action:
It is recommended that the Town Council approve a Resolution authorizing the Town
Manager to sign the permits required for the Beach Renourishment project, ensuring
that the Town can accept the State and Federal permits for the project and ensure the
project can proceed while we draft and bring forward required amendments to the
Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island.
Attachments:
1. Resolution Authorizing the Town Manager to sign the Permits Required to Execute
the Beach Renourishment Project Letter from South Carolina
2. USFWS Draft Biological Opinion, dated August 2024
3. Illustration of Original Restricted Beach Areas per the BO Dated August 8, 2025
4. Letter from USFWS to the USACOE serving as an amendment to the BO
Amendments, dated January 15, 2025
5. Illustration of Revised Restricted Beach Areas per the BO, dated January 15, 2025
Page 96 of 222
Page 1 of 4
A RESOLUTION OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA,
AUTHORIZING THE TOWN MANAGER TO SIGN AND ACCEPT PERMITS ISSUED
BY THE UNITED STATES ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS AND THE SOUTH
CAROLINA DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES FOR THE 2025 TOWN
OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND BEACH NOURISHMENT PROJECT, AND TO TAKE
SUCH ACTIONS ARE NECESSARY TO COMPLY WITH THE PERMITS AND TO
BRING FORWARD AN AMENDMENT TO THE MUNCICIPAL CODE TO COMPLY
WITH A CONDITION OF THE PERMITS
W
HEREAS, the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (the “Town”), has an
adopted policy calling for the periodic nourishment and renourishment of the Atlantic
Beaches on Hilton Head Island; and
WHEREAS, the Town has permitted and completed three major beach
nourishment projects since 1990, and has scheduled the fourth major beach nourishment
project to be permitted and completed in 2025; and
WHEREAS, the Town’s beach nourishment projects have maintained the width of
the beaches on Hilton Head Island, providing a stable natural area for recreation and for
the protection of property; and
WHEREAS, the Town’s beach nourishment projects have also promoted the
formation of sand dunes which protect property and provide habitat for beach and beach
critical area flora and fauna; and
WHEREAS, the Town must obtain permits from the United States Army Corps of
Engineers and the South Carolina Department of Environmental Services in order to
commence and complete the 2025 beach nourishment project; and
WHEREAS, the Town has applied for the needed permits to authorize the 2025
Beach Nourishment Project; and
ATTACHMENT 1
Page 97 of 222
Page 2 of 4
WHEREAS, the United States Fish and Wildlife Service is a contributing agency
for the Unites States Army Corp of Engineers Permit, and it has issued a Biological
Opinion; and
WHEREAS, the United States Fish and Wildlife Service Biological Opinion is a part
of the permit to be issued by the United States Army Corps of Engineers and compliance
with the Biological Opinion is a condition of both the United States Army Corps of
Engineers permit and the South Carolina Department of Environmental Services permit;
and
WHEREAS, the United States Fish and Wildlife Service Biological Opinion
includes a mandate that dogs be banned year-round from certain places along the beaches
of Hilton Head Island due to the disturbance of shore birds caused by the presence of
dogs; and
WHEREAS, Town Staff ha s worked with the United States Fish and Wildlife
Service and has achieved a material reduction in the areas over which the ban must be
imposed; and
WHEREAS, the area where the ban is required is shown Illustration of Revised
Restricted Beach Areas dated January, 2025, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit
“A”; and
WHEREAS, in order to impose the required ban, an amendment to the text of § 8-
1-211, Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (1983), will be
required, and the Town Manager will bring forward a proposed amendment to implement
the ban that is a condition of the permit to be issued by the United States Army Corps of
Engineers and the South Carolina Department of Environmental Services; and
Page 98 of 222
Page 3 of 4
WHEREAS, a requirement of the permits to be issued by the United States Army
Corps of Engineers and the South Carolina Department of Environmental Services is that
on receipt the Town Manager must sign and accept the permits; and,
WHEREAS, on acceptance of the permits to be issued by the United States Army
Corps of Engineers and the South Carolina Department of Environmental Services the
conditions of the permits must be satisfied; and
WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that timely acceptance of the permits to be
issued by the United States Army Corps of Engineers and the South Carolina Department
of Environmental Services and compliance with the conditions stated in them is essential
to the timeline for the commencement and completion of the 2025 beach nourishment
project; and
WHEREAS, the Town Council finds that the timely the commencement and
completion of the 2025 beach nourishment project will promote the health, safety and
welfare of the citizens, residents, visitors, and property owners in the Town, and is in the
best interest of the citizens, residents, visitors, and property owners in the Town.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED AND IT HEREBY IS RESOLVED BY THE
TOWN COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA:
1. The Town Manager is hereby authorized to execute and accept the permits issued
by the United States Army Corps of Engineers and the South Carolina Department
of Environmental Services.
2. The Town Manager is hereby authorized to take all actions as may be necessary to
comply with any conditions set out in the permits issued by the United States Army
Corps of Engineers and the South Carolina Department of Environmental Services.
Page 99 of 222
Page 4 of 4
3. The Town Manager is directed to bring forward a text amendment to § 8 -1-211,
Municipal Code of the Town of Hilton Head Island, South Carolina (1983), for the
purpose of implementing a year -round ban on dogs in areas along the outfall of
Fish Haul Creek shown on the Illustration of Revised Restricted Beach Areas dated
January, 2025, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit “A”.
MOVED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN
OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SOUTH CAROLINA, ON THIS ___ DAY OF FEBRUARY,
2025.
________________________________
Alan R. Perry, Mayor
ATTEST:
________________________________
Kimberly Gammon, Town Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
Curtis L. Coltrane, Town Attorney
Introduced by Council Member: _________________________
Page 100 of 222
EXHIBIT A TO RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING SIGNING AND ACCEPTANCE OF
PERMITS FOR 2025 BEACH NOURISHMENT PROJECT
Page 101 of 222
Beach Areas Restricted as a Condition of the Beach Renourishment Permit
January 2025
Date Created: Wednesday, January 22, 2025
The information on this map has been compiled from a variety of sources and is intended
to be used only as a guide. It is provided without any warranty or representation as to the
accuracy or completeness of the data shown. The Town of Hilton Head Island assumes no
liability for its accuracy or state of completion or for any lo
sses arising from the use of the map.
TOWN OF HILTON HEAD ISLAND
ONE TOWN CENTER COURT
HILTON HEAD ISLAND, S.C. 29928
PHONE (843) 341- 4600
Town of Hilton Head Island
2,000 0 2,000 4,000 6,0001,000 Feet
Maxar, Microsoft
Fish Haul
Beach Park
Revised Area Proposed for Restrictions
¯
Page 102 of 222
Biological and Conference Opinion
Tow
n of Hilton Head Beach Renourishment Project
FWS Log # 2023-0091041
P
repared by:
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
South Carolina Ecological Services Field Office
176 Croghan Spur Road, Suite 200
Charleston, South Carolina 29407
___________________________________________
_______________________
Christy Johnson-Hughes, Project Leader Date
August 8, 2024
ATTACHMENT 2
Page 103 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. BACKGROUND ................................................................................................................................................ 1
1.1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................................ 1
1.2. Consultation History .................................................................................................................................. 1
1.3. Opinion Analytical Framework .................................................................................................................. 4
2. PROPOSED ACTION ....................................................................................................................................... 5
2.1. Description of the Proposed Action ............................................................................................................ 6
2.2. Term of the Action ...................................................................................................................................... 7
2.3. Other Activities Caused by the Action ........................................................................................................ 8
2.4. Proposed Conservation Measures .............................................................................................................. 8
2.5. Action Area ................................................................................................................................................. 9
3. STATUS OF THE SPECIES ............................................................................................................................. 9
3.1. Piping Plover .............................................................................................................................................. 9
3.2. Rufa Red Knot........................................................................................................................................... 25
3.3. Loggerhead Sea Turtle ............................................................................................................................. 36
4. STATUS OF CRITICAL HABITAT ............................................................................................................. 43
4.1. Critical Habitat for the Piping Plover ...................................................................................................... 43
4.2. Critical Habitat for the Rufa Red Knot (Proposed) .................................................................................. 44
5. ENVIRONMENTAL BASELINE .................................................................................................................. 45
5.1. Piping Plover ............................................................................................................................................ 45
5.2. Rufa Red Knot........................................................................................................................................... 47
5.3. Loggerhead Sea Turtle ............................................................................................................................. 48
5.4. Critical Habitat for the Piping Plover ...................................................................................................... 49
5.5. Critical Habitat for the Rufa Red Knot (Proposed) .................................................................................. 50
6. EFFECTS OF THE ACTION ......................................................................................................................... 52
6.1. Effects of Sand Placement ........................................................................................................................ 53
6.2. Effects of Breakwater Construction .......................................................................................................... 58
7. CUMULATIVE EFFECTS ............................................................................................................................. 59
8. CONCLUSION ................................................................................................................................................ 60
9. INCIDENTAL TAKE STATEMENT ............................................................................................................ 62
9.1. Form and Amount or Extent of Take Anticipated ..................................................................................... 62
9.2. Reasonable and Prudent Measures .......................................................................................................... 63
9.3. Terms and Conditions ............................................................................................................................... 64
9.4. Monitoring and Reporting Requirements ................................................................................................. 70
Page 104 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
iii
10. CONSERVATION RECOMMENDATIONS ............................................................................................... 72
11. REINITIATION NOTICE .............................................................................................................................. 73
12. LITERATURE CITED .................................................................................................................................... 73
13. APPENDICES .................................................................................................................................................. 84
13.1. APPENDIX A: Dog Restricted Access Areas ........................................................................................... 84
13.2. APPENDIX B: Sea Turtle Lighting Surveys ............................................................................................. 86
Page 105 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
1
1. BACKGROUND
1.1. Introduction
A biological opinion (BO) is the document that states the findings of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service (Service) required under section 7 of the Endangered Species Act of 1973, as amended
(16 USC 1531 et seq.; [ESA]), as to whether a federal action is likely to:
• jeopardize the continued existence of species listed as endangered or threatened; or
• result in the destruction or adverse modification of designated critical habitat.
This is a combined Biological and Conference Opinion (Opinion). A conference opinion (CO) is
equivalent to a BO but addresses species that are not yet listed under the ESA and/or proposed
critical habitats not yet designated. Therefore, the ESA prohibitions against jeopardizing species,
destroying critical habitat, and taking animals do not yet apply. The Service may adopt a
conference opinion as a biological opinion if and when the evaluated species is listed/designated
and while the action agency’s discretion and involvement in the action continue.
The federal action agency for this consultation is the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’ (Corps),
and the federal action addressed in this Opinion is the Town of Hilton Head’s (Town) Island-
wide project (SAC-2022-01660) and Town’s Pine Island project (SAC-2023-01324) (the
Action). This Opinion considers the effects of the Action on the piping plover (Charadrius
melodus) and its designated critical habitat, the rufa red knot (Calidris canutus rufa) and its
proposed critical habitat, and the loggerhead sea turtle (Caretta caretta).
Our analysis within this Opinion is primarily based on the information provided in the
applicant’s biological assessments (assessments) prepared by the Coastal Eco-Group entitled
“Biological Assessment: Town of Hilton Head Island Beach Renourishment Project” dated
September 2023 and “Final Biological Assessment: Pine Island Dune Restoration and
Stabilization Project” dated June 2024 (CEG 2023, 2024), and other sources of information cited
herein. The information provided in the Assessment is incorporated by reference in this Opinion.
The Service previously concurred with the Corps determination that the Action may affect but is
not likely to adversely affect the green sea turtle, Kemp’s ridley sea turtle, leatherback sea turtle,
and the West Indian manatee by letter and email dated June 8, 2023, and May 3, 2024. These
species are not further addressed in this Opinion.
1.2. Consultation History
This section lists key events and correspondence during the course of this consultation. A
complete administrative record of this consultation is on file in the U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service’s South Carolina Ecological Service’s Field Office (SCESFO).
2015-07-01 – The Service issued a revised biological opinion to the Corps for the Town of
Hilton Head’s (Town) recurring island-wide renourishment project. The Service included a
discretionary conservation recommendation, which was also included in our original February
Page 106 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
2
26, 2015, Opinion, regarding the Town’s existing ordinance (Ordinance No. 2013-11 § 8-1-211).
In the interest of section 7(a)(1) of the ESA, the Service recommended the ordinance be amended
to require dogs to be leashed at all times and the ordinance should be strictly enforced (USFWS
2015, p.134).
2017-01-31 – The Service sent a letter to Corps outlining our observations of the Town’s
recurring non-compliance with our July 1, 2015, Opinion’s Reasonable and Prudent Measures
(RPMs) and Terms and Conditions (T&Cs) outlining required monitoring and management. The
letter also noted that if the dog issue was not resolved prior to the next Town beach
renourishment permit application, we would require RPMs and T&Cs within the Town’s
authority to address the dog issue to minimize take and offset future project impacts.
2017-02-07 – The Corps sent a letter to the Town regarding their project being out of compliance
with the Town’s Department of the Army permit. The letter stated that the Corps would not
process any actions on current or future permit applications until all non-compliance issues were
resolved.
2023-05-09 – The Service received the Corps’ and South Carolina Department of Health and
Environmental Control – Office of Ocean and Coastal Resource Management’s (SCDHEC-
OCRM) joint public notice for a permit (SAC-2022-01660) to dredge in nearshore borrow areas
and place material on sections of Hilton Head Island. The Corps made a determination of may
affect, is not likely to adversely affect for the green sea turtle (Chelonia mydas), Kemp’s ridley
sea turtle (Lepidochelys kempii), leatherback sea turtle (Dermochelys coriacea), loggerhead sea
turtle (Caretta caretta) and the West Indian manatee (Trichechus manatus). The Corps made a
determination of may affect for the piping plover (Charadrius melodus) and its designated
critical habitat and the rufa red knot (Calidris canutus) and its proposed critical habitat.
2023-06-08 – The Service provided comments to the Corps regarding the proposed project and
recommended that the Corps request to initiate formal consultation on the loggerhead sea turtle,
piping plover and its designated critical habitat, and the rufa red knot and its proposed critical
habitat. The Service concurred with the Corps’ determination on the green sea turtle, Kemp’s
ridley sea turtle, leatherback sea turtle, and West Indian manatee. The Service did not concur
with the Corps’ determination of may affect, is not likely to adversely affect for the loggerhead
sea turtle. The Service also recommended that the Town of Hilton Head Island (Town) minimize
project direct and indirect impacts by including shorebird conservation practices (i.e. protecting
high tide roosts, creating “no dog areas” within important shorebird habitats, and supporting a
shorebird stewardship program) into the Town’s long-term beach management program.
2023-10-11 – The Service received a letter from the Corps requesting to initiate formal
consultation on the loggerhead sea turtle, piping plover and its designated critical habitat, and
rufa red knot and its proposed critical habitat.
2023-11-09 – The Service sent a letter to the Corps acknowledging receipt of all information
necessary to initiate the consultation and provided an expected date of March 22, 2024, for
completion of our Opinion.
Page 107 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
3
2024-03-08 – The Service sent an email to the Corps summarizing a phone conversation
regarding another permit application for beach renourishment on Hilton Head Island that was
about to go on public notice. We recommended pausing the island-wide consultation so we could
include the Town’s additional project in our Opinion.
2024-03-08 – The Service sent an email to the Town’s consultants about setting up a meeting to
discuss monitoring and management requirements for the Town’s island-wide project and the
proposed project about to go out on public notice.
2024-03-15 – The Service (Melissa Chaplin) attended a virtual meeting with the Corps (Chelsea
Fannin, Shawn Boone), and the Town’s consultants (Chris Creed, Zak Bedell, and Cheryl
Miller). The Service proposed pausing the island-wide consultation to issue one Opinion for both
permit applications. The Service proposed issuing the Opinion within 30 days of the date on the
public notice for Pine Island if the Town’s biological assessment was provided to the Service
within 7 days of the date on the public notice. The Service offered to provide proposed “no dog
areas” for the Town’s consideration and review the draft assessment before the final draft was
submitted to the Corps.
2024-03-20 – The Service provided the proposed “restricted dog areas” to the Town via email.
The Service proposed three areas in Burke’s Beach Park, Fish Haul Park (including a section of
beach along Port Royal Plantation), and Pine Island. These areas were proposed to create “safe
zones” in areas consistently used by piping plovers.
2024-04-05 – The Service received Corps and SCDHEC-OCRM’s joint public notice for a
permit (SAC-2023-01324) to renourish a beach and construct breakwaters along the Port Royal
Sound shoreline of Hilton Head Island. The Corps made a determination of may affect, is not
likely to adversely affect for the West Indian manatee (Trichechus manatus). The Corps made a
determination of may affect for the piping plover (Charadrius melodus) and rufa red knot
(Calidris canutus). The Corps did not make a determination for any of the sea turtles.
2024-04-15 – The Service received an email from the Town’s consultant providing an update on
the submittal of the assessment.
2024-04-23 – The Service sent an email to the Town’s consultant stating our concerns with the
vague language in the Conservation Measures section of the assessment. The proposed
“restricted dog areas” were not included in the assessment. The Service stated that we needed a
commitment from the Town to work on revising the Hilton Head Island Shorebird Conservation
Plan and the plan must be approved and implemented before project construction begins.
2024-04-24 – The Corps sent an email to the Town’s consultant reiterating the Service’s
concerns and the Corps’ concerns with the vague language in the assessment. The Corps
recommended a meeting with the Town to discuss the language in the assessment.
Page 108 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
4
2024-05-01 – The Service and the Corps met with the Town’s representative, the Town’s
consultants to discuss the proposed “restricted dog areas.” The Town’s representative did not
commit to establishing “restricted dog areas” during the meeting, but they did agree to continue
the conversation with the Service and Manomet.
2024-05-03 – The Service provided comments to the Corps regarding the additional proposed
project (SAC-2023-01324) and recommended that the Corps request to initiate formal
consultation on the loggerhead sea turtle, piping plover, and the rufa red knot. Although the
Corps did not make a determination for any of the sea turtles, the Service stated it would concur
with a may affect, is not likely to adversely affect the green sea turtle, Kemp’s ridley sea turtle,
and leatherback sea turtle. The Service concurred with the Corps’ determination of may affect, is
not likely to adversely affect on the West Indian manatee. The Service also recommended that
the Town no longer allow dogs in essential shorebird habitat.
2024-06-06 – The Town’s consultant provided the final assessment via email to the Corps and
the Service. The final assessment did not include the proposed “no dog areas” or acknowledge
dogs as an issue. The assessment did include language about the Town’s commitment to
coordinating with the Service and implementing the management measures outlined in the plan
prior to project construction.
2024-06-27 – The Service received a letter from the Corps requesting to initiate formal
consultation on the piping plover and rufa red knot.
2024-07-11 – The Service acknowledged receipt of the Corps’ request to initiate formal
consultation and provided an updated expected date of July 26, 2024, for completion of our
Opinion.
2024-07-26 – The Service requested an extension on the Opinion.
2024-07-30 – The Corps approved the extension.
1.3. Opinion Analytical Framework
An Opinion that concludes a proposed Federal action is not likely to jeopardize the continued
existence of listed species and is not likely to result in the destruction or adverse modification of
critical habitat fulfills the Federal agency’s responsibilities under §7(a)(2) of the ESA.
“Jeopardize the continued existence means to engage in an action that reasonably would
be expected, directly or indirectly, to reduce appreciably the likelihood of both the
survival and recovery of a listed species in the wild by reducing the reproduction,
numbers, or distribution of that species” (50 CFR §402.02).
“Destruction or adverse modification means a direct or indirect alteration that
appreciably diminishes the value of critical habitat as a whole for the conservation of a
listed species” (50 CFR §402.02).
Page 109 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
5
The Service determines in an Opinion whether we expect an action to satisfy these definitions
using the best available relevant data in the following analytical framework (see 50 CFR §402.02
for the regulatory definitions of action, action area, environmental baseline, effects of the action,
and cumulative effects).
a. Proposed Action. Review the proposed Federal action and describe the environmental
changes its implementation would cause, which defines the action area.
b. Status. Review and describe the current range-wide status of the species or critical
habitat.
c. Environmental Baseline. Describe the condition of the species or critical habitat in the
action area, without the consequences to the listed species caused by the proposed action.
The environmental baseline includes the past and present impacts of all Federal, State, or
private actions and other human activities in the action area, the anticipated impacts of all
proposed Federal projects in the action area that have already undergone formal or early
consultation, and the impacts of State or private actions which are contemporaneous with
the consultation.
d. Effects of the Action. Predict all consequences to species or critical habitat caused by the
proposed action, including the consequences of other activities caused by the proposed
action, which are reasonably certain to occur. Activities caused by the proposed action
would not occur but for the proposed action. Effects of the action may occur later in time
and may include consequences that occur outside the action area.
e. Cumulative Effects. Predict all consequences to listed species or critical habitat caused
by future non-Federal activities that are reasonably certain to occur within the action area.
f. Conclusion. Add the effects of the action and cumulative effects to the environmental
baseline, and in light of the status of the species, formulate the Service's opinion as to
whether the action is likely to jeopardize species or adversely modify critical habitat.
2. PROPOSED ACTION
This section describes the proposed federal Action, including any measures that may avoid or
minimize adverse effects to listed species and the extent of the geographic area affected by the
Action. The term “action” is defined in the implementing regulations for section 7 as “all
activities or programs of any kind authorized, funded, or carried out, in whole or in part, by
federal agencies in the United States or upon the high seas” (50 CFR 402.02).
There are two distinct components to the Action: the Island-wide project and the Pine Island
project, which are described in further detail in the following subsections.
Page 110 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
6
2.1. Description of the Proposed Action
2.1.1. Island-wide Project
The proposed Island-wide project (SAC-2022-01660) will add approximately two million cubic
yards (Mcy) of sand along 46,500 linear feet of beach along the Atlantic Coast and Port Royal
Sound shorelines as part of the Town’s continued beach maintenance and management program
(Figure 2-1). The first project was constructed in 1990 and the most recent project occurred in
2016. The purpose of the proposed project is to re-establish island-wide beach conditions and
sustain an eight to ten-year renourishment life. Sand will be dredged from four off-shore borrow
areas: Barret Shoals (two areas), Gaskin Banks, and Bay Point Shoals. The dredging will be
done by hydraulic cutter-suction pipeline dredge and pumped to the beach fill sites. The seaward
slope of the construction berm will have a uniform initial slope of 1V:20H (Vertical:Horizontal)
for all shoreline reaches. The four shoreline reaches are South Beach/South Island Shoreline,
Central Island Shoreline, The Heel Shoreline, and Fish Haul Creek Shoreline.
Applicant’s Proposed Construction Schedule:
South Beach No seasonal restrictions
Central Island 15 August 2025 to 15 April 2026
The Heel 15 April 2025 to 15 August 2025
Fish Haul Creek 15 April 2025 to 15 August 2025
Figure 2-1. Proposed project areas for the island-wide project (CEG 2023).
Page 111 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
7
2.1.2. Pine Island Project
The proposed Pine Island project (SAC-2023-01324) will be constructed between July 1, 2025
and October 31, 2025, in conjunction with the Island-wide project and will place approximately
190,000 cubic yards (cy) of sand from the Bay Point Shoals borrow area along 2,200 linear feet
(lf) of shoreline (Figure 2-2). The project will also include the construction of five detached
breakwaters (three with stems) and a spur to be attached to the existing revetment along 850 lf of
shoreline. The purpose of the proposed project is to address erosion along Pine Island’s barrier
beach. Over the past several decades, the Hilton Head Plantation Property Owners Association
(HHPPOA) has attempted to manage erosion problems and maintain beach access from Dolphin
Point to Pine Island. The Service issued an Opinion on March 5, 2024, for the HHPPOA’s most
recent project (PN# SAC-2023-00210, FWS Log # 2023-0093063). The Pine Island project is
anticipated to be constructed in addition to the HHPPOA project. In 2022, the Town expanded
the extent of the island’s managed beaches to include Pine Island and its associated barrier beach
along the Port Royal Sound shoreline within Hilton Head Plantation.
Sand will be dredged from the borrow area by hydraulic cutter-suction pipeline dredge to the
beach fill areas. The landward and seaward slopes of the construction berm will have a uniform
initial slope of 1V:10H. Beach fill will be placed prior to the construction of the breakwaters.
Figure 2-2. Proposed project area for the Pine Island project (CEG 2024).
2.2. Term of the Action
The described actions will occur over one to two years over 48,700 lf of shoreline on Hilton
Head Island. The projected life of the renourishment cycle is eight to ten years or until a severe
weather event shortens the life of the project. The breakwater construction portion of the Pine
Page 112 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
8
Island project is permanent and is intended to extend the life of the Pine Island renourishment.
Sand placement can temporarily (6 months to 2 years) impact foraging habitat quality by
suppressing the benthic community depending on the match of the sediment characteristics of the
dredged material placed on the beach with the existing beach material.
2.3. Other Activities Caused by the Action
An Opinion evaluates all consequences to species or critical habitat caused by the proposed
Federal action, including the consequences of other activities caused by the proposed action, that
are reasonably certain to occur (see definition of “effects of the action” at 50 CFR §402.02).
Additional regulations at 50 CFR §402.17(a) identify factors to consider when determining
whether activities caused by the proposed action (but not part of the proposed action) are
reasonably certain to occur. These factors include, but are not limited to:
(1) past experiences with activities that have resulted from actions that are similar in
scope, nature, and magnitude to the proposed action;
(2) existing plans for the activity; and
(3) any remaining economic, administrative, and legal requirements necessary for the
activity to go forward.
In its request for consultation, the Corps did not describe, and the Service is not aware of, any
additional activities caused by the Action that are not included in the previous description of the
proposed Action. Therefore, this Opinion does not address further the topic of “other activities”
caused by the Action.
2.4. Proposed Conservation Measures
Island-wide Project
The Town anticipates similar Terms and Conditions to those required in the February 26, 2015
and revised July 1, 2015, Opinions, with the exception of the macroinvertebrate monitoring. The
Town proposes to continue to maintain and display interpretive signs at key beach access points.
The Town also proposes to implement an educational program for residents and visitors in
conjunction with the Service and the South Carolina Department of Natural Resources
(SCDNR). The Town plans to continue shorebird surveys and posting high-tide roosts as
outlined in the 2015 Town of Hilton Head Shorebird Conservation and Management Plan.
Pine Island Project
The Town has agreed to update and implement the 2015 Town of Hilton Head Shorebird
Conservation and Management Plan (Plan). The Plan will include activities such as conducting
shorebird surveys, posting high-tide roosts, and community education. The Plan will be revised
and implemented prior to initiation of construction activities. The Town is expecting the Plan to
include beach management measures to reduce impacts on wintering plovers and red knots.
Page 113 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
9
2.5. Action Area
The action area is defined as “all areas to be affected directly or indirectly by the federal action
and not merely the immediate area involved in the action” (50 CFR §402.02). An action
includes activities or programs “directly or indirectly causing modifications to the land, water, or
air” (50 CFR §402.02). Indirect modifications include those caused by other activities that would
not occur but for the action under consultation.
The Action Area for this consultation includes the entire Port Royal Sound and Atlantic Ocean
shorelines of Hilton Head Island (Figure 2-1). Piping plovers and red knots may move to other
areas along the sound shoreline or the Atlantic shoreline side of the “heel” of the island during
project construction. Loggerhead sea turtles will likely nest in areas away from active nighttime
construction.
3. STATUS OF THE SPECIES
This section presents information about the regulatory, biological, and ecological status of the
piping plover, rufa red knot, and the loggerhead sea turtle at a range-wide scale that provides
context for evaluating the significance of probable effects caused by the proposed action. This
information provides the background for analyses in later sections of the Opinion.
3.1. Piping Plover
On January 10, 1986, the piping plover (Charadrius melodus) was listed under the ESA as
endangered in the Great Lakes watershed and threatened elsewhere within its range, including
migratory routes outside of the Great Lakes watershed and wintering grounds (USFWS 1985).
The preamble of this rule acknowledged the continuing recognition of two subspecies,
Charadrius melodus melodus (Atlantic Coast of North America) and Charadrius melodus
circumcinctus (Northern Great Plains of North America) in the American Ornithologist Union’s
most recent treatment of subspecies (AOU 1957). Subsequent ESA actions have consistently
recognized three separate breeding populations of piping plovers on the Atlantic Coast
(threatened), Great Lakes (endangered), and Northern Great Plains (NGP) (threatened). Piping
plovers that breed on the Atlantic Coast of the U.S. and Canada belong to the subspecies C. m.
melodus. The second subspecies, C. m. circumcinctus, is comprised of two Distinct Population
Segments (DPS). One DPS breeds on the Northern Great Plains of the U.S. and Canada, while
the other breeds on the Great Lakes. Each of these three entities is demographically
independent. Piping plovers from all three breeding populations winter in coastal areas of the
U.S. from North Carolina to Texas, and along the coast of eastern Mexico and on Caribbean
islands from Barbados to Cuba and the Bahamas (Elliott-Smith and Haig 2004) (Figure 3-1).
Page 114 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
10
Figure 3-1. Distribution and range of piping plovers (base map from Elliott-Smith and
Haig 2004). Conceptual presentation of subspecies and DPS ranges are not intended to
convey precise boundaries.
The best available scientific information continues to support recognition of two separate
subspecies of piping plover, and three separate entities consistent with the ESA definition of
“species.” Genetic analyses have shown that piping plovers that breed on the Atlantic Coast of
the U.S. and Canada belong to the subspecies C. m. melodus and plovers that breed on the
Northern Great Plains of the U.S. and Canada, as well as on the Great Lakes, belong to a second
subspecies, C. m. circumcinctus (Miller et al. 2010).
3.1.1. Species Description
The piping plover, named for its melodic call, is a small North American shorebird
approximately 17 centimeters (cm) (7 inches (in)) long with a wingspan of about 38 cm (15 in)
and weighing 40-65 grams (1.4-2.3 ounces) (Palmer 1967, Elliot-Smith and Haig 2004). Adult
piping plovers exhibit breeding and nonbreeding plumage. Plovers can arrive on wintering
grounds with partial breeding plumage remaining (a single black breastband, which is often
incomplete, and a black bar across the forehead). During the late summer or early autumn, the
birds lose the black bands, the legs fade from orange to pale yellow, and the bill turns from
orange and black to mostly black. Most adults begin their molt into breeding plumage before
northward migration and complete the molt before arrival on their breeding sites. Piping plover
subspecies are considered phenotypically indistinguishable, although slight clinal breeding
plumage variations between populations have been noted (Elliot-Smith and Haig 2004).
Page 115 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
11
3.1.2. Life History
Piping plovers migrate annually between the three populations’ breeding ranges in the U.S. and
Canada and their shared wintering range along the Atlantic and Gulf coasts of the Southeastern
U.S. and Mexico, and parts of the Caribbean. Plovers live an average of five years, although
studies have documented birds as old as 11 (Wilcox 1959) and 15 years. Breeding activity
begins in mid-March when birds begin returning to their nesting areas (Coutu et al. 1990, Cross
1990, Goldin et al. 1990, MacIvor 1990, Hake 1993). Plovers are known to begin breeding as
early as one year of age (MacIvor 1990, Haig 1992); however, the percentage of birds that breed
in their first adult year is unknown. Piping plovers generally fledge only a single brood per
season but may re-nest several times if previous nests are lost.
Habitat Use
NGP plovers primarily breed on open, sparsely vegetated sand and gravel areas associated with
four habitat types: alkali lakes and wetlands; large inland lakes; reservoirs; and rivers (USFWS
2020a). Great Lakes plovers breed on open, sparsely vegetated sandy or cobble Great Lake
shorelines. Atlantic Coast plovers breed on sparsely-vegetated beaches and washover areas
adjacent to moist foraging substrates (USFWS 1996, 2009, 2020a). Wintering piping plovers
utilize a mosaic of habitat patches and move among these patches in response to local weather
and tidal conditions (Nicholls and Baldassarre 1990a, Nicholls and Baldassarre 1990b, Drake et
al. 2001, Cohen et al. 2008). Preferred coastal habitats include sand spits, small islands, tidal
flats, shoals (usually flood tidal deltas), and sandbars that are often associated with inlets
(Nicholls and Baldassarre 1990b, Harrington 2008, Addison 2012, Tweel et al. 2023).
Phenology
Piping plovers spend up to 10 months of their life cycle on their migration and winter grounds,
generally July through May (Elliott-Smith and Haig 2004, Noel et al. 2007, Stucker et al. 2010).
Piping plovers migrate through and winter in coastal areas of the U.S. from North Carolina to
Texas and in portions of Mexico and the Caribbean. Migration routes and habitats overlap
breeding and wintering habitats, and, unless banded, migrants passing through a site usually are
indistinguishable from other breeding or wintering piping plovers. Piping plovers depart their
wintering grounds for their breeding grounds as early as March, but northbound migration can
extend into May. Plovers depart their breeding grounds for their wintering grounds as early as
July (Cohen et al. 2018, Weithman et al. 2018, Loring and Paton 2019), but southbound
migration can extend into November. Cohen et al. (2018) documented an entry probability of
~50% by the end of July for the fall migrant and wintering populations. The entry probability
increased to 95% for both populations by October indicating that the majority of plovers
wintering in South Carolina arrive by October (Cohen et al. 2018). These results are the basis
for the Service nonbreeding piping plover protocol that calls for using survey counts only from
the core winter months of December and January to estimate local winter population numbers
(Chaplin, pers. comm. 2019).
Page 116 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
12
Site Fidelity
Piping plovers exhibit a high degree of intra- and inter-annual fidelity to nesting and wintering
areas, which often encompass several relatively nearby sites (Wilcox 1959, MacIvor et al. 1987,
Loegering 1992, Drake et al. 2001, Cohen et al. 2006, Noel and Chandler 2008, Stucker et al.
2010, Cohen and Gratto-Trevor 2011, Gratto-Trevor et al. 2012, 2016, Catlin et al. 2015,
Friedrich et al. 2015, Anteau 2018, Gibson et al. 2017, 2018). Winter site fidelity does not
appear to be influenced by disturbance and is overall similar to breeding site fidelity. Individuals
are more likely to remain at a site, regardless of site quality or disturbance, than emigrate to a
new site thereby resulting in lower survival (Gibson et al. 2018). For example, during the
Deepwater Horizon oil spill, marked piping plovers rarely moved between sites, and researchers
observed high detection rates, even in oil-impacted sites that were heavily disturbed due to clean
up efforts (Gibson et al. 2017).
3.1.3. Numbers, Reproduction, and Distribution
The data from the International Piping Plover Breeding Censuses represent a minimum estimate
of the number of adult piping plovers and breeding pairs in all three breeding populations (Table
3-1). Although the effort is as comprehensive as possible, some populations and some areas are
able to be more intensively monitored than others outside of Census years. However, some
portions of populations are only monitored during Census years (NGP Prairie Canada), so this
data is currently the best way to get a rough estimate of the status of all three breeding
populations. The data from the 2016 Census has not been complied and the 2021 Census was
postponed due to COVID-19. The 2011 Piping Plover Breeding Census documented 2,391
breeding pairs with a total of 5,723 birds throughout Canada and U.S (Elliott-Smith et al. 2015)
(Table 3-1).
Table 3-1. Number of Adults Documented During the 1991, 1996, 2001, 2006, and 2011
International Piping Plover Breeding Census (Haig et al. 2005, Elliott-Smith et al. 2009,
Elliott-Smith et al. 2015).
Population Number of piping plovers
1991 1996 2001 2006 2011
NGP 3469 3286 2953 4662 3486
Canada 1437 1687 972 1703 2249
U.S. 2032 1599 1981 2959 1237
Great Lakes 40 48 72 110 112
Canada 0 1 1 1 14
U.S. 40 47 71 109 98
Atlantic Coast 1641 2591 2911 3312 3362
Canada 509 422 481 457 406
U.S. 1462 2169 2430 2855 2952
Total 5480 5925 5936 8084 5723
Page 117 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
13
Northern Great Plains Population
The NGP plover breeds from Alberta to Manitoba, Canada and south to Nebraska in the U.S.
(Figure 3-2). Within the U.S., the key breeding habitat occurs in Montana, North and South
Dakota, and Nebraska. Despite the significant level of effort invested in breeding surveys for
many years, there is currently no reliable means to estimate the current NGP range-wide
abundance nor population trends over time. Local population estimates within the three U.S.
GMRs (U.S. Alkali Lakes (ALMR), Northern Rivers (NRMR), and Southern Rivers (SRMR))
are a more manageable way to assess the status of portions of the NGP population, but the survey
effort varies between the GMRs (USFWS 2020a). The recovery goal for the NGP in Prairie
Canada is 2,500 breeding pairs and 1,300 breeding pairs in the U.S. distributed across Montana,
North Dakota, South Dakota, Nebraska, and Minnesota (USFWS 2020a). Annual breeding
censuses record the number of adults, not breeding pairs, which makes data interpretation more
difficult. Although the NGP in the U.S. may have come close to meeting the recovery goal in
2005, the numbers sharply declined from 2009 through 2011 (Figure 3-2) (USFWS 2020a).
While the population increase seen since 2011 demonstrates the possibility that the population
can rebound from low population numbers, ongoing efforts are needed to maintain and ensure
growth within the population (USFWS 2020a). In the 2020 status review, the Service concluded
that the NGP population remains vulnerable due to management of river systems throughout the
breeding range (USFWS 2020a).
Figure 3-2. The four Geographical Management Regions (GMRs) for breeding piping
plovers within the NGP.
Page 118 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
14
Figure 3-3. The estimated abundance of piping plover adults counted during the annual
June breeding census within ALMR compared to prairie Canada and compared to the
total estimated abundance summed from all the management regions in the U. S. from
1994–2013.
Great Lakes Population
The Great Lakes plovers historically nested on Great Lakes beaches in Illinois, Indiana,
Michigan, Minnesota, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, and Ontario, but they
currently nest on Great Lakes beaches in Wisconsin, Michigan, Ontario, and New York (Figure
3-4). This population is the smallest of the three breeding populations, which makes it the most
vulnerable; however, the population has shown significant growth, from 16 pairs at the time of
listing in 1986 to 81 pairs, the highest number of breeding pairs recorded to date, in 2024
(Figure 3-5). The recovery goal for the Great Lakes population is 150 breeding pairs, and thirty
years of intensive recovery efforts have brought the population to the halfway mark of the
recovery goal in some of the recent years (USFWS 2020a). Intensive management has also
contributed to the population meeting the productivity goals specified in the 2003 recovery plan
over the past five years. During this period, the average annual fledging rate has been 1.7, well
above the 1.5 fledglings per breeding pair recovery goal (USFWS 2020a). In the 2020 status
review, the Service concluded that the population remains susceptible to extinction (i.e., 12%
quasi-extinction [defined as ≤ 15 breeding pairs] probability within the next 10 years; Saunders
et al. 2018) due to its small size, limited distribution, and vulnerability to stochastic events, such
as disease outbreak.
Page 119 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
15
Figure 3-4. Piping plover nesting distribution in the Great Lakes.
Figure 3-5. Number of pairs of Great Lakes piping plovers from 1984-2023.
Atlantic Coast Population
The Atlantic Coast piping plover breeds on coastal beaches from Newfoundland and
southeastern Quebec to North Carolina. Intensive recovery efforts have contributed to
substantial population growth, from approximately 790 pairs in 1986 to 2,593 pairs in 2023
(USFWS 2024). In the 2020 status review, the Service concluded that the increased abundance
of Atlantic Coast piping plovers has reduced near-term vulnerability to extinction, but the
Page 120 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
16
population remains vulnerable to low numbers in three of its four recovery units (USFWS
2020a). The New England recovery unit has been able to reach and sustain its abundance target,
but the other three recovery units remain below target and two have declined since the 2009
status review (Figure 3-6) (USFWS 2020a).
Figure 3-6. Abundance of Atlantic Coast piping plover breeding pairs by recovery unit,
1986–2023. Bars denote the annual pair estimate. Dashed lines indicate abundance
objectives established in the 1996 revised recovery plan (USFWS 2024).
Nonbreeding (Winter and Migration) Range
Piping plovers from all three breeding populations overlap in the nonbreeding range and spend
up to 10 months of their annual cycle on their migration and winter grounds, typically from July
through May (Elliott-Smith and Haig 2004, Noel et al. 2007, Stucker et al. 2010). Resights of
uniquely marked piping plovers indicate that birds from all three breeding populations use these
sites, but most birds are from the Atlantic Coast and Great Lakes populations (Gratto-Trevor et
al. 2012, Maddock et al. 2013, USFWS 2020a). Gratto-Trevor et al. (2012) found distinct
patterns (but no exclusive partitioning) in winter distribution of banded piping plovers from four
breeding areas (Figure 3-7). Resightings of more than 700 uniquely marked birds from 2001 to
2008 were used to analyze winter distributions along the Atlantic and Gulf Coasts. Plovers from
eastern Canada and most Great Lakes birds wintered from North Carolina to Southwest Florida.
However, eastern Canada birds were more heavily concentrated in North Carolina, while a larger
proportion of Great Lakes piping plovers were found in South Carolina, Georgia, and Florida.
This pattern is consistent with analysis of band sightings of Great Lakes plovers from 1995-2005
by Stucker et al. (2010). Gratto-Trevor et al. (2012) also found that Northern Great Plains
populations were primarily seen farther west and south, especially on the Texas Gulf Coast.
Most birds from Prairie Canada portion of the NGP were observed in Texas (particularly
Page 121 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
17
southern Texas), while individuals from the U.S. portion of the NGP were more widely
distributed on the Gulf Coast from Texas to Florida. Based on band resights, Grato-Trevor et al.
(2016) were able to conclude that the Bahamas are home to at least 32% of the Atlantic Coast
breeding population in the winter, and as much as 19% of the global piping plover population for
up to 9 months of the year. Therefore, specific breeding populations will be disproportionately
affected by habitat and threats occurring where they are most concentrated in the winter.
Figure 3-7. The winter distribution in the continental U.S. of piping plovers from four
breeding locations (inset), including eastern Canada (white circle with central black dot),
Great Lakes (gray circle), U.S. Northern Great Plains (white circle), and Prairie Canada
(black circle). The wintering range is expanded to the right, divided into different
wintering regions. The size of the adjacent circles relative to the others represents the
percentage of individuals from a specific breeding area reported in that wintering region
(from Gratto-Trevor et al. 2012; reproduced by permission).
Plover abundance and distribution continues to be better documented throughout the coastal
migration and wintering range within and outside of the U.S. International Piping Plover Censuses
(Census), which began in 1991, have been conducted during mid-winter over a 2-week period at
five-year intervals across the species’ range (Table 3-2). It should be noted that sites may only
be surveyed once during the Census so poor weather conditions and the tidal cycle can
negatively influence survey results, which may underestimate site use and importance.
Therefore, the Census is considered a minimum estimate of abundance and may not reflect local
site use. For some parts of the wintering range; however, the Census is the only time that plovers
are surveyed and these efforts are particularly important outside of the U.S. The 2011 Census
helped confirm the importance of the Bahamas to piping plovers (Gratto-Trevor et al. 2016).
Individuals from the Great Lakes and Atlantic Coast populations use the Bahamas as a winter
site, but the vast majority are from the Atlantic Coast population (Gratto-Trevor et al. 2016,
2019). Twenty-seven percent of the total number of piping plovers counted during the 2011
Census were seen in the Bahamas. The 2016 Census was the largest effort in the Caribbean to
date to document piping plovers, which resulted in over 1,500 plovers counted (Elliott-Smith
Page 122 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
18
2016). The 2016 Census data for the entire winter range has not been completed and the 2021
Census was cancelled due to COVID-19. There are no plans for a 2026 Census effort.
Table 3-2. Results of the 1991, 1996, 2001, 2006, and 2011 international piping plover
winter censuses (Haig et al. 2005, Elliott-Smith et al. 2009, Elliott-Smith et al. 2015).
Location Number of piping plovers
1991 1996 2001 2006 2011
Virginia nsa Ns ns 1 1
North Carolina 20 50 87 84 43
South Carolina 51 78 78 100 86
Georgia 37 124 111 212 63
Florida 551 375 416 454 306
-Atlantic 70 31 111 133 83
-Gulf 481 344 305 321 223
Alabama 12 31 30 29 38
Mississippi 59 27 18 78 88
Louisiana 750 398 511 226 86
Texas 1,904 1,333 1,042 2,090 2,145
Puerto Rico 0 0 6 ns 2
U.S. Total 3,384 2,416 2,299 3,355 2,858
Mexico 27 16 ns 76 30
Bahamas 29 17 35 417 1066
Cuba 11 66 55 89 19
Other Caribbean
Islands 0 0 0 28 0
GRAND TOTAL 3,451 2,515 2,389 3,884 3,973
Survival
Demographic analyses have revealed wintering range effects on individual piping plover annual
survival. Analysis of data collected in the Carolinas and Georgia in 2010-2017 found that plovers
using recreationally disturbed habitats with significant modifications to their habitat have lower
survival rates (10% less) and lower body condition (7% lower mass) than birds that use less
disturbed habitat without modifications (Gibson et al. 2018). Further, birds that emigrated from
disturbed sites had higher survival (0.80) than birds that stayed (0.67); but because of their strong
site fidelity, birds were more likely to die than leave because of disturbance (Gibson et al. 2018).
The model used in Gibson et al. (2018) found little support that an individual’s breeding
population influenced annual survival. This study further supports findings in Roche et al.
(2010) that annual survival is influenced by where individuals overwinter rather than association
with a breeding population. Roche et al. (2010) found that after-hatch-year apparent survival
Page 123 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
19
declined in four of their seven study populations. They found evidence of correlated year-to-
year fluctuations in annual survival among populations wintering primarily along the
southeastern U.S. Atlantic Coast, as well as indications that shared overwintering or stopover
sites may influence annual variation in survival among geographically disparate breeding
populations.
3.1.4. Conservation Needs and Threats
Conservation Needs
Piping plovers depend on a mosaic of ephemeral habitats within their breeding and wintering
home ranges. Habitat availability and quality may shift seasonally, annually, or episodically due
to local environmental conditions (storm events, lunar and/or wind-driven tides, and extreme
temperatures), degree of development (need for shoreline stabilization to protect developed
shorelines, structures preventing or limiting natural coastal processes), and site use (degree of
disturbance from people and dogs). Since piping plovers exhibit such high site fidelity
regardless of habitat conditions, low disturbance levels are critical, especially at lower quality
sites (periods of limited food resources, nest sites or roosting areas far from foraging areas, and
frequent disturbances that limit nest or brood attendance and foraging time), to allow plovers to
maintain daily energetic requirements.
Threats
Piping plovers face many threats throughout their entire range, but some are more prevalent in
certain parts of the range. Therefore, the most prevalent threats within each of the three breeding
ranges and the nonbreeding range are summarized below. For a complete list of threats within
each breeding range and the nonbreeding range, refer to the recovery plans and status reviews
available at Species Profile for Piping Plover (Charadrius melodus) (fws.gov)
.
NGP Breeding Range
Destruction, Modification, and Loss of Habitat
Destruction, modification, and loss of habitat remains the largest threat within the NGP breeding
range. Nesting habitat within the NGP breeding range has been negatively impacted by the
construction of reservoirs, channelization of rivers, modification of river flows, commercial sand
and gravel mining, oil and gas development and production, agricultural practices, wind energy
production, and invasive vegetation growth. Modification of river flows in the U.S. is a major
threat to plovers nesting within the NRMR and SRMR, which can account for up to 45% of the
nests within the NGP (USFWS 2020a).
Human Recreational Disturbance
Recreational disturbance is not a range-wide threat, but it is a particular concern in river or
reservoir reaches near cities. An estimated 20-80% of the NGP plovers in the U.S. nest in
riverine sandbar habitat (Haig and Plissner 1992, Plissner and Haig 1997, Ferland and Haig
2002, USACE 2006, 2012, Elliott-Smith et al. 2009, Nelson 2011, Brown et al. 2012, Peyton
Page 124 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
20
and Wilson 2013). Sandbar habitat also often attracts human recreation, including sandbars on
the Missouri River, and reservoirs in Nebraska and Colorado (USFWS 2003a, Nelson 2012).
Great Lakes Breeding Range
Destruction, Modification, and Loss of Habitat
The 2003 recovery plan cites shoreline development as the leading cause of habitat destruction in
the Great Lakes, and it remains a major threat (USFWS 2003b). As of 2017, 13% of the U.S.
Great Lakes population’s nests occur on private lands that are particularly vulnerable to
development (Cuthbert and Saunders 2017). Vegetation encroachment and rising water levels
are additional factors effecting habitat availability.
Human Recreational Disturbance
Human activities such as illegal off-road vehicle use, unleashed dogs, bike riding, bonfires,
horseback riding, camping, and beach going continue to disturb nesting piping plovers (USFWS
2020a). Human disruption, and therefore pet disruption, of piping plovers is likely to increase,
as the shoreline of the Great Lakes is becoming an increasingly popular vacation destination.
Sleeping Bear Dunes National Seashore, which supports half of the Great Lakes breeding
population, had a 42% increase in park visitation between 2009 and 2018, concurrent with a 67%
increase in the number of pairs nesting at Sleeping Bear Dunes (USFWS 2020a).
Predation
Predation remains one of the most significant threats to the Great Lakes population in their
breeding range (USFWS 2020a). Merlins are suspected to have killed 40 adult plovers since
2005 (Cuthbert and Saunders 2017, Saunders et al. 2018). Roche et al. (2010) found annual
mortality of adults associated with disappearances averaged 5.7% from 2002 to 2007, and that
the disappearances were most frequently attributed to merlin predation. The authors mentioned
the frequency of these events has increased dramatically since 2002, and currently accounts for
approximately one fifth of annual adult mortality (Roche et al. 2010).
Atlantic Coast Breeding Range
Destruction, Modification, and Loss of Habitat
Sandy beach development and modification are continuing threats within the Atlantic Coast
breeding range. Rice (2017) found that 45 percent of the sandy beaches in the U.S. breeding
range of the Atlantic Coast piping plover were developed as of 2015. A comparison of the levels
of development modifying sandy beaches from Maine to Virginia in the 1970s (reported by the
Heritage Conservation and Research Service) and 2015, found substantial increases in every
state except Maine, Rhode Island, and New York (Rice 2017). Forty-two percent of overwash
that occurred between Connecticut and Maryland during Hurricane Sandy occurred on developed
shoreline where it could not create habitat; this includes 48 and 71 percent of the overwash that
occurred on the south shore of Long Island and New Jersey, respectively (Rice 2015). As of
Page 125 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
21
2015, only 31 percent of sandy beach habitat in the piping plover’s U.S. Atlantic Coast breeding
range remained unmodified (Rice, pers. comm. 2018).
Human Recreational Disturbance
Recreational disturbance remains a serious threat to Atlantic Coast plovers. The 2020 status
review summarized new information that provides additional insight into the mechanisms by
which disturbance affects piping plover breeding success (USFWS 2020a). Two recent studies
demonstrate recreational disturbance impacts to chick survival (DeRose-Wilson et al. 2018) and
habitat suitability (Maslo et al. 2018). DeRose-Wilson et al. (2018) document significantly
lower rates of survival to fledging for piping plover chicks hatched in areas with high
recreational use compared with chicks hatched in areas with low recreational use. Chicks
hatched in high use areas fledged at a later age, and chicks exposed to all levels of disturbance
had lower daily survival rates on weekends (when recreational activity was high) than on
weekdays. On weekends, chicks spent less time in habitats with higher prey abundance, less
time foraging, and made fewer foraging attempts per minute than they did on weekdays. Thus,
current management in some locations with medium and high human use may not assure
sufficient foraging opportunities for plover chicks. Maslo et al. (2018) demonstrate the
importance of managing human disturbance to prevent degradation of habitat suitability for
piping plovers and least terns in New Jersey. Absent the current conservation network, less than
three percent of nesting habitat would remain suitable for breeding piping plovers in New Jersey.
Predation
Predation remains a pervasive, persistent, and serious threat to breeding Atlantic Coast piping
plovers (USFWS 2009, 2020). Without predator management, piping plover productivity would
be substantially less (USFWS 2009). The 2020 status review highlighted a recent study at Cape
Hatteras National Seashore, North Carolina by Kwon et al. (2018) on ghost crab predation that
found daily survival rates of piping plover nests with evidence of ghost crab presence were
significantly lower than nests without ghost crabs. This suggests that an earlier study by Wolcott
and Wolcott (1999) may have underestimated ghost crab predation on piping plover nests.
Accelerating Sea Level Rise
Effects of accelerating sea level rise on future availability of Atlantic Coast piping plover
breeding habitats will largely depend on the response of barrier islands and barrier beaches.
With accelerating sea level rise, barrier islands that have historically retreated landward may
simply retreat faster; under more drastic sea level rise projections, they may also become reduced
in size (FitzGerald et al. 2008, Gutierrez et al. 2009). The dynamic nature of beach response to
sea level rise will be heavily influenced by a variety of site specific factors (e.g. sediment supply,
level of development, current elevation) (FitzGerald et al. 2008, Lentz et al. 2016), wherein
worst case or even most likely relative sea level rise projections (Sweet et al. 2017) have the
potential to outpace the rate at which barrier and mainland beaches are able to migrate laterally
to maintain width and elevation (FitzGerald et al. 2008; Gutierrez et al. 2009).
Page 126 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
22
Nonbreeding Range
Destruction, Modification, and Loss of Habitat
Developed shorelines within the piping plover coastal migration and wintering range have
caused and continue to cause most of the habitat loss, modification, and degradation due to the
perpetual maintenance of infrastructure as well as permanent structures previously placed on or
adjacent to shifting shorelines (USFWS 2009, 2012, 2020a). Shoreline stabilization projects
aimed at protecting existing development and infrastructure can cause temporary or lasting
effects depending on the type of project, location, timing, and quality of sand source. Sand
placement projects can have beneficial effects by creating unvegetated, open areas, which make
optimal roosting habitat, and create more space for birds on the beach, but these effects are short-
lived, often lasting only a few years before vegetation encroaches again (Chaplin, pers. comm.
2019). Sand placement projects and inlet relocation projects have more of an impact on foraging
habitat by directly impacting benthic invertebrates or altering substrates, which indirectly
influences the distribution and abundance of the benthic community (USFWS 2012, SCDNR
2015a, b, Wooldridge et al. 2016, SCDNR 2017). Wooldridge et al. (2016) found that
replenished sections of beach had half as many invertebrates as control sections after 15 months.
Polychaete density was also reduced to one third of control levels after 15 months. Although no
overall effect of total invertebrate abundance was detected, Wooldridge et al. (2016) indicated
that replenishment affects taxon within the community differently, such as polychaete worms,
which are the preferred prey item of piping plovers.
Human Recreational Disturbance
The Service’s Comprehensive Conservation Strategy for the Piping Plover in its Coastal
Migration and Wintering Range in the Continental United States (CCS) identified human
recreational disturbance as a major threat to piping plovers in their coastal migration and
wintering range (USFWS 2012). The Atlantic Flyway Shorebird Initiative (AFSI) has also
identified human recreational disturbance at stopover sites as a major threat to migrating
shorebirds (Mengak et al. 2019, Hunt et al. 2019). Additional studies have documented the
effects of disturbance since the CCS was completed in 2012 (Burger and Niles 2013, Lafferty et
al. 2013, McLeod et al. 2013, Schlacher et al. 2013, Burger and Niles 2014, Koch and Paton
2014, Weston et al. 2014, Cestari 2015, Glover et al. 2015, Martin et al. 2015, Vas et al. 2015,
Allport 2016, Drever et al. 2016, McEvoy et al. 2016, Murchison et al. 2016, Stigner et al. 2016,
Ramli and Norazlimi 2017, Watts 2017, Gibson et al. 2018, DeRose-Wilson et al. 2018, Hunt et
al. 2019). A 2017-2018 literature review documented 632 citations published between 1974 and
2018 on disturbances to shorebirds, their habitats, and their prey base in addition to management
recommendations for reducing disturbance (Comber et al. 2019). This literature review
highlights that this threat is well documented, but not well managed.
Human disturbance is often associated with developed shorelines (Bimbi 2016) and 40% of the
shoreline within the coastal migration and wintering range is developed (Rice 2012). Human
disturbance can be functionally equivalent to habitat loss if the disturbance prevents birds from
using the area or extends the time and energy needed to feed and rest (Goss-Custard et al. 2006).
The presence of people has been documented to displace shorebirds and influence habitat use
Page 127 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
23
(Pfister et al. 1992, Fitzpatrick and Bouchez 1998, McCrary and Pierson 2000, Cornelius et al.
2001, Mizrahi 2002, Hvenegaard and Barbieri 2010, Forys 2011, Burger and Niles 2013,
Lafferty et al. 2013, Burger and Niles 2014, Cestari 2015, Martín et al. 2015, Drever et al. 2016,
Watts 2017, Hunt et al. 2019, Mengak et al. 2019). Gibson et al. (2018) found piping plovers
using disturbed sites across North Carolina, South Carolina, and Georgia had lower true annual
survival rates than those using undisturbed sites. The study also found that plovers using more
disturbed sites weighed an average of seven percent less than those using less disturbed sites
(Gibson et al. 2018). Due to their strong site fidelity, plovers that have previously used disturbed
habitat are likely to return to that same location instead of finding more suitable habitat
elsewhere (Gibson et al. 2018). Plovers foraging in disturbed areas spend less time foraging, and
more time alert, than those in undisturbed areas. This leads to lower body condition, due to the
plover’s increased stress levels and reduced time feeding (Rutter 2016).
Dogs on Beaches
Interactions between dogs, particularly dogs running off leash, and shorebirds elicit the strongest
response from shorebirds. Shorebirds are more likely to flush from the presence of dogs than
people, and breeding and nonbreeding shorebirds react to dogs from distances farther than the
distance to people (USFWS 2012, Murchison et al. 2016, Stigner et al. 2016, Ramli and
Norazlimi 2017, Mengak et al. 2019). Unleashed dogs often chase birds and can elevate a piping
plover’s stress enough to impact individual survival (Rutter 2016).
Predation
In 2012, the CCS concluded that the extent of predation on nonbreeding piping plovers is
unknown, but it could be a potential threat (USFWS 2012). Predation is often difficult to
document, but between December 2012 and September 2017, five mortalities likely due to avian
predation were reported along the Texas Coast. In the Florida panhandle, higher counts of
raptors coincided with the piping plover nonbreeding season as well as with sites with high
piping plover use (Tuma, pers. comm. 2018).
Accelerating Sea Level Rise
The CCS concluded that accelerating sea level rise (SLR) poses a threat to piping plovers within
their coastal migration and wintering range. The CCS also noted that the magnitude of threats
from SLR is closely linked to threats from developed coastlines because sites that are able to
adapt to SLR are likely to become more important to plovers as habitat at developed or stabilized
sites degrades. Von Holle et al. (2019) investigated the effect of local and eustatic SLR on
important sea turtle, seabird, and shorebird habitat across the South Atlantic Bight (SAB) and
found a substantial increase in the coastal erosion vulnerability under a modest increase in SLR
by 2030. Fifty percent of the winter piping plover habitat within the SAB will have an increased
vulnerability by 2030 as compared to year 2000 vulnerability levels (Von Holle et al. 2019).
Habitat within the SAB with high piping plover wintering densities is projected to have an even
higher (66%) increased vulnerability due to accelerating SLR as compared to the 2000 levels
(Von Holle et al. 2019). This is significant since 40% of the coastal migration and wintering
range beaches is already developed (Rice 2012) and developed beaches are predicted to be more
Page 128 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
24
vulnerable to SLR due to their limited ability to adapt. The remaining 60% of undeveloped
beaches within the coastal migration and wintering range is also vulnerable to SLR. Von Holle
et al. (2019) suggests that available piping plover habitat could become much more vulnerable to
SLR impacts in the next ten years.
Storms and Storm Response
Storms are a component of the natural processes that form coastal habitats and can benefit or
adversely affect piping plovers at all life stages (Saunders et al. 2014, Bourque et al. 2015).
Storms can eliminate local roost sites, lead to decreases in food supply within foraging habitat,
and even directly kill birds (Saunders et al. 2014). Saunders et al. (2014) found that adult piping
plover survival was negatively correlated with hurricane frequency. Some birds may have
resiliency to storms and move to unaffected areas without harm, while other reports suggest birds
may perish from storm events. In 2014, Hurricane Arthur was responsible for the loss of 15
chicks (63%) along Cape Lookout National Seashore in North Carolina (NPS 2014). Between
2011 and 2016, 25% of all nest losses were due to flooding or high winds (NPS 2011, 2012,
2013, 2014, 2015, 2016). In 2017, following Hurricane Mathew, all known banded piping
plovers observed before the storm at regularly surveyed sites in South Carolina were observed
during surveys following the storm (Chaplin pers. comm. 2019).
Other storm-induced adverse effects include post-storm acceleration of human activities such as
beach nourishment, sand scraping, and berm and seawall construction. Storms can accelerate
these activities because coastal habitat is especially vulnerable to degradation from natural
erosion, sea level rise, recreation, and coastal development (USGS 2018). The Atlantic Coast
breeding range has had close to 80 km of sediment placement projects permitted to modify beach
habitat following Hurricane Sandy. This was a 15% increase in the amount of modified
shoreline prior to Hurricane Sandy (Rice 2017).
Severe Cold Weather
Several sources suggest the potential for adverse effects of severe winter cold on survival of
piping plovers. Cold weather can directly lead to reductions in survival, as seen in a population
of piping plovers in Georgia that declined by 52% concurrent with a 4-week period of cold
weather (Gibson et al. 2017). Unusually cold temperatures can also affect survival indirectly by
reducing the amount of food available. Reduced food availability causes piping plovers to
expend valuable energy foraging and results in lower body conditions that reduce chances of
survival (Saunders et al. 2014).
Summary of Threats
The 2020 status review concludes that losses and degradation of habitat continues and that levels
of recreational disturbance are increasing (USFWS 2020a). As a result, cumulative losses of
habitat and habitat function throughout the coastal migration and wintering range continues to be
the primary threat. Oil spills, predation, storms, and severe cold weather are of concern, but they
remain lower threats when considered independently. Cumulatively, oil spills, due to the
associated clean-up response, and storms, due to the shoreline stabilization efforts that tend to
Page 129 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
25
follow, have the potential to exacerbate ongoing threats from habitat loss and disturbance locally
and regionally. This is particularly significant for the Great Lakes population because the
population is already more vulnerable due to low numbers; therefore, affected areas where Great
Lakes birds occur could have population level effects. Accelerating SLR is a growing concern
because the magnitude of threats from SLR is closely linked to threats from developed coastlines
since those shorelines have less adaptability. Shoreline stabilization efforts in response to SLR
and the increase in storm frequency are likely to compound ongoing habitat losses throughout the
coastal migration and wintering range. Cumulatively, all these threats will likely limit the
recovery potential of all three breeding populations, particularly the Great Lakes population,
unless habitat within the coastal migration and winter range is effectively managed to minimize
recreational disturbance and habitat loss and degradation.
3.1.5. Summary of the Status of the Piping Plover
The 2020 status review recommended retaining the Atlantic Coast and NGP populations of the
piping plover as threatened throughout their ranges and recommended revising the current listing
of the Great Lakes population to endangered throughout its current breeding, migration, and
wintering range (USFWS 2020a). Even though intensive management of the Great Lakes,
Atlantic Coast, and portions of the NGP populations has resulted in population increases, none of
the breeding populations have fully attained each population’s recovery goals. Therefore, both
the Atlantic Coast and NGP populations remain likely to become endangered within the
foreseeable future within their entire range. The Great Lakes population remains in danger of
extinction due to its low abundance, limited distribution, and persistent threats from habitat
degradation, human disturbance, and predation. In addition to the considerations pertinent to
each breeding population, all piping plovers remain at risk due to continuing habitat loss and
increasing human disturbance during the two-thirds of their annual cycle spent in the migration
and wintering range. Research continues to demonstrate the importance of migration and
wintering range habitat conditions on the adult survival rates of all three breeding populations,
particularly the Great Lakes population due to its low numbers (Gibson et al. 2018).
For a more detailed account of the species description, life history, population dynamics,
conservation needs, and threats, refer to
Species Profile for Piping Plover (Charadrius melodus)
(fws.gov).
3.2. Rufa Red Knot
On December 11, 2014, the Service published the final rule to list the rufa red knot (Calidris
canutus rufa) as a threatened subspecies under the ESA (79 Federal Register [FR] 73706). Four
genetically distinct groups of Calidris canutus have been identified. Three of the groups
correspond to recognized subspecies: C. canutus canutus, C.c. piersma, C.c. rogersi. The fourth
is a North American group containing the other three recognized subspecies (C.c. rufa, C.c.
roselaari and C.c. islandica), which are not fully distinct at the genetic level based on analyses
conducted to date (Buehler and Baker 2005). Calidris canutus canutus, C.c. piersma, and C.c.
rogersi do not occur in North America. Figure 3-8 shows the worldwide range and distribution
of the six subspecies.
Page 130 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
26
Figure 3-8. Range and distribution of the six subspecies of Calidris canutus. Map drawn by
Dick Visser, provided by Jan van Gils, and reproduced by permission.
3.2.1. Species Description
The rufa red knot is a medium-sized shorebird about 9 to 11 inches (23 to 28 centimeters) in
length. The red knot is easily recognized during the breeding season by its distinctive reddish
feathers. The face, prominent stripe above the eye, breast, and upper belly are a deep red,
sometimes with a few scattered light feathers mixed in. The feathers of the lower belly and
under the tail are whitish with dark flecks. Upperparts are dark brown with white and reddish
feather edges; outer primary feathers are dark brown to black. Females are similar in color to
males, though the reddish colors are typically less intense, with more buff or light gray on the
back parts. Nonbreeding plumage is dusky gray above and whitish below. Juveniles resemble
nonbreeding adults, but the feathers of the scapulars (shoulders) and wing coverts (small feathers
covering base of larger feathers) are edged with white and have narrow, dark bands, giving the
upperparts a scalloped appearance (Davis 1983).
3.2.2. Life History
The rufa red knot migrates annually between its breeding grounds in the central Canadian Arctic
and several wintering regions, including the Southeastern U.S./Caribbean, the Western Gulf of
Mexico/Central America, Northern Coast of South America, and Tierra del Fuego at the southern
tip of South America. Knots wintering in Tierra del Fuego make one of the longest distance
migrations known in the animal kingdom, traveling up to 19,000 mi (30,000 km) annually. The
rufa red knot’s typical life span is at least 7 years (Niles et al. 2008), with the oldest known wild
bird at least 21 years old as of 2014 (Bauers 2014, Jordan 2014). Age of first breeding is at least
2 years (Harrington 2001). Female rufa red knots lay only one clutch per season and as far as is
known, do not lay a replacement clutch if the first is lost (Niles et al. 2008).
Page 131 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
27
Habitat Use
Red knots generally nest in dry, slightly elevated tundra locations, often on windswept slopes
with little vegetation in the central Canadian Arctic and stopover and winter in coastal marine
and estuarine habitats with large areas of exposed intertidal sediments. Migration and wintering
habitats include both high-energy ocean- or bay-front areas, as well as tidal flats in more
sheltered bays and lagoons. Preferred roosting habitat in wintering and stopover areas includes
areas with the following qualities: close to feeding areas; protected from predators; have
sufficient space during the highest tides; and free from excessive human disturbance.
Phenology
Red knots spend about 60% of the calendar year along the U.S. Atlantic Coast on their way to
and from breeding and wintering areas (USFWS 2020b). Red knots arrive on their breeding
grounds in late May or early June and remain intact until shortly after the eggs hatch (Niles et al.
2008, Harrington 2001). Departure from the breeding grounds (fall migration) begins in mid-
July and continues through August. Females are thought to leave first, followed by males and
then juveniles. Adult Calidris canutus pass through stopover sites along the migratory route
earlier in years with low reproductive success than in years with high reproductive success.
Southbound red knots start arriving in July along the U.S. Atlantic coast. Numbers of adults
peak in mid-August and most depart by late September, although geolocators and resighting have
shown some birds (especially northern-wintering knots) stay through November. Depending on
the wintering region location, the main red knot movement north from Tierra del Fuego occurs in
February. Birds moving north from Argentina may make several stops along the coast, and
typically arrive in northern Brazil in April. Departure from Brazil tends to occur in the first half
of May. Many knots marked in Argentina and Chile are seen on the Atlantic coasts of Florida,
Georgia, South Carolina, and North Carolina during, but not before, May (USFWS 2020b).
Site Fidelity
Red knots show very high fidelity to each of the four wintering regions (Southern, Northern
Coast of South America, Western Gulf of Mexico/Central America, and the Southeastern
U.S./Caribbean (USFWS 2014). Minimal intra- and inter-annual movement of birds among
wintering regions has been reported, but intra- and inter-annual regional movements within
wintering regions has been documented in the Texas Laguna Madre and the Southeast (Niles et
al. 2008, Newstead et al. 2013).
3.2.3. Numbers, Reproduction, and Distribution
For the red knot, population size is best measured on the wintering grounds due to the difficulty
of regularly accessing remote breeding areas in the Canadian Arctic. Counts on the wintering
grounds are particularly useful in estimating red knot populations and trends because the birds
generally remain within a given wintering area for a longer period of time compared to migration
stopover areas. This minimizes errors associated with turnover or double counting that can occur
during migration counts (USFWS 2014).
Page 132 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
28
Wintering Regions within the Nonbreeding Range
The 2020 SSA concluded that the four red knot wintering regions (Figure 3-9) support separate
populations. Evidence suggests that at least three of the wintering populations are genetically
distinct (Baker et al. 2013, Baker et al. 2011), which would indicate some degree of behavioral
and/or geographic breeding segregation. Stable isotope, tracking, and genetic analyses suggest
that red knots from different wintering regions partially segregate (in time and/or space) in
migration areas (Kazyak et al. 2018, USFWS 2014). Birds from different wintering populations
show marked differences in migration strategy (e.g., timing, routes, long “jumps” versus shorter
“hops,” timing of feather molt, degree of reliance on particular staging areas) and also show, on
average, morphological differences (USFWS 2014).
The sharp decline of the Southern wintering population that occurred in the 2000s (likely due to
horseshoe crab overharvest in Delaware Bay) and its stabilization since 2011 are corroborated by
declining counts at certain stopover areas and by analyses of other data sets. The decline of the
Southern population drove a decline of the subspecies as a whole (USFWS 2014). Although less
reliant on Delaware Bay, the Western Gulf of Mexico/Central American wintering population is
also thought to have declined in recent decades, while the Northern Coast of South America and
the Southeastern U.S./Caribbean wintering populations are considered stable (Table 3-3)
(USFWS 2020b).
Figure 3-9. Rufa Red Knot Wintering Regions.
Page 133 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
29
Table 3-3. Current Estimates of Rufa Red Knot Abundance by Wintering Region.
Migration Staging and Stopover Areas
Warnock (2010) defines stopover habitat as places where migrant birds stop to rest, drink, and
eat, while staging areas (a subset of stopover habitats) are defined as those stopover sites with
abundant, predictable food resources where birds prepare for an energetic challenge (usually a
long flight over a barrier such as an ocean or a desert) requiring substantial fuel stores and
physiological changes without which significant fitness costs are incurred. Warnock (2010)
gives three conditions that staging areas must meet for birds to overcome these energetic
challenges: (1) the site must provide predictable, abundant, accessible fuel, especially in the face
of time constraints during spring migration or during molting when mobility is limited; (2) the
site must provide other critical resources (such as water and resting places) to accommodate
birds (often many thousands of birds) for longer periods of time (often weeks); and (3) the site
must have low levels of disturbance (predators or human-induced disturbance). Distinctions
between staging areas and other stopover habitats are given in Table 3-4.
Table 3-4. Comparison of staging areas and other stopover habitats (Warnock 2010).
Page 134 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
30
Spring (Northbound) Migration
Well-known spring stopover areas along the Atlantic coast of the Americas include Río
Gallegos, Península Valdés, San Antonio Oeste, Bahía Blanca, Punta Rasa, and Bahía
Samborombón (Patagonia, Argentina); Lagoa do Peixe (eastern Brazil, State of
Rio Grande do Sul); Maranhão (northern Brazil); the Southeast United States (i.e., the Carolinas
to Florida); the Virginia barrier islands (United States); and Delaware Bay (Delaware and New
Jersey, United States). However, large, and small groups of red knots, sometimes numbering in
the thousands, may occur in suitable habitats all along the Atlantic and Gulf coasts of South and
North America. Available data indicate that red knots wintering in the Southeast use at least two
distinct spring migration routes—coastal (moving north along the coast to the mid-Atlantic
before departing for the Arctic) and inland (departing overland for the Arctic directly from the
Southeast coast).
Fall (Southbound) Migration
Well-known fall stopover sites include southwest Hudson Bay (including the Nelson River
delta), James Bay, and the Mingan Archipelago in Canada; the coasts of Massachusetts and New
Jersey and the mouth of the Altamaha River in Georgia in the United States; the Caribbean
(especially Cuba); and the northern coast of South America from Brazil to Guyana (USFWS
2014).
During both the northbound (spring) and southbound (fall) migrations, red knots use key staging
and stopover areas to rest and feed (Figure 3-10).
Figure 3-10. Important rufa red knot spring and fall migration stopover areas.
Page 135 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
31
Breeding Range
The red knot breeds in the central Canadian Arctic, from the islands of northern Hudson Bay to
the Foxe Basin shoreline of Baffin Island, and west to Victoria Island (Niles et al. 2008,
Morrison and Harrington 1992). Potential breeding habitat extends farther north the southern
Queen Elizabeth Islands (Niles et al. 2008) (Figure 3-11). Due to the vast size and remoteness
of the region and the fact that red knots are solitary nesters, however, only the basics of breeding
biology are known, and many presumptions are extrapolated from other subspecies. Smith (pers.
comm. 2019) estimates that only about 50 to 75 rufa red knot nests have been directly
documented to date, with 80 to 90 percent of those on just one island (USFWS 2014).
Preliminary analysis suggests that an average reproductive rate in the range of 1.5 to 2 chicks per
pair may be necessary for a stable population (Wilson and Morrison 2018), but further work is
needed to refine this estimate. Productivity trends cannot be determined by direct observation,
though attempts are made to infer “good” and “bad” breeding years from the timing and relative
abundance of adult males, adult females, and juveniles observed during fall migration surveys.
Figure 3-11. Known and potential breeding range of the rufa red knot.
Page 136 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
32
Survival
Studies have shown red knot survival rates are influenced by the condition (weight) of birds
leaving the Delaware Bay staging area in spring. Insufficient horseshoe crab eggs are the best
supported explanation for the decline in the early 2000s of the Southern wintering population,
which is more reliant on Delaware Bay relative to other wintering populations.
Conditions in nonbreeding areas influence survival of juvenile birds as well as adults. Because
juveniles do not breed until at least age 2, the recruitment rate into the breeding population
depends largely on the food and habitat conditions these young birds encounter in nonbreeding
areas during the first 2 years. Modeling by Schwarzer (2011) involving birds banded from 2005
through 2010 found that, across multiple years, the red knot population in Florida (part of the
larger Southeast/Caribbean population) was stable at around 8.75 percent juveniles among
wintering birds; the population increased with 13 percent juveniles. Other modeling suggests
that a higher percentage of juveniles may be needed for population growth (Wilson and Morrison
2018) and may further elucidate whether the prevalence of juveniles is an indicator of population
trend.
3.2.4. Conservation Needs and Threats
Conservation Needs
The needs of individual rufa red knots are described above in terms of habitat and food
requirements. The timing of food resources (e.g., insect prey on the breeding grounds, horseshoe
crab eggs or mollusks at stopover areas) is a critical need for this highly migratory subspecies,
and across all habitats red knots require sparse vegetation because open vistas are considered a
key element in predator defense. The degree to which juveniles segregate from adults during
wintering and migration is poorly known. Although juvenile habitats and diets are thought to be
similar to adults, certain nonbreeding areas may be disproportionately important to juvenile birds
(USFWS 2020b). Table 3-5 summarizes the rufa red knot’s needs based on the detailed
information in the supplemental listing document (USFWS 2014).
Page 137 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
33
Table 3-5. Red knot resource needs.
Threats
The rufa red knot faces numerous threats across its range on multiple geographic and temporal
scales. These threats are affecting the red knot now and will continue to have subspecies-level
effects into the future (79 FR 73705). A framework for classifying threats, and a summary
assessment of threats to the red knot, are presented below (Tables 3-6 and 3-7) from the 2020
SSA (USFWS 2020). For a complete list of threats within each wintering region and the
breeding range, refer to the documents available at
Species Profile for Red knot (Calidris
canutus rufa) (fws.gov).
In the final listing rule, the Service determined that the rufa red knot is threatened under the ESA
due to the following primary threats: loss of breeding and nonbreeding habitat (including sea
level rise, coastal engineering, coastal development, and arctic ecosystem change); likely effects
related to disruption of natural predator cycles on the breeding grounds; reduced prey availability
throughout the nonbreeding range; and increasing frequency and severity of asynchronies
(mismatches) in the timing of the birds’ annual migratory cycle relative to favorable food and
Page 138 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
34
weather conditions. These threats that are driving the red knot’s status as a threatened species
under the ESA are classified as High Severity in Table 3-7.
Table 3-6. Threat classification categories (USFWS 2020b)
Page 139 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
35
Table 3-7. Classification of threats to the red knot (USFWS 2020b)
3.2.5. Summary of the Status of the Rufa Red Knot
The 2020 SSA concluded that the Southern wintering population, which had been the largest and
disproportionately reliant on Delaware Bay, has since stabilized but shows no sign of recovery to
Page 140 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
36
date (USFWS 2020b). Overharvest of the horseshoe crab in Delaware Bay is considered the key
causal factor in this decline, though numerous other past, ongoing, and emerging threats have
also been identified (USFWS 2014). Although less reliant on Delaware Bay, the Western Gulf
of Mexico/Central American wintering population is also thought to have declined in recent
decades. Two additional wintering populations, one on the northern coast of South America and
another in the Southeast U.S. and the Caribbean, are considered stable relative to the 1980s
(USFWS 2014, 2020b). Birds from all four wintering populations face threats from habitat loss
and from several pervasive, climate-driven ecosystem changes. Additional threats include
hunting, increased predation pressure, harmful algal blooms, human disturbance, oil spills, and
wind energy development. Cumulatively, these threats are believed to be impairing the Southern
and the Western Gulf of Mexico/Central American wintering populations.
For a more detailed account of the species description, life history, population dynamics,
conservation needs, and threats, refer to
Species Profile for Red knot (Calidris canutus rufa)
(fws.gov).
3.3. Loggerhead Sea Turtle
The Service and National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) share Federal jurisdiction for sea
turtles under the ESA. The Service has responsibility for sea turtles on the nesting beach. The
NMFS has jurisdiction for sea turtles in the marine environment. In accordance with the ESA,
the Service completes consultations with all Federal agencies for actions that may adversely
affect sea turtles on the nesting beach. The Service’s analysis only addresses activities that may
impact nesting sea turtles, their nests and eggs, and hatchlings as they emerge from the nest and
crawl to the sea. NMFS assesses and consults with Federal agencies concerning potential
impacts to sea turtles in the marine environment, including updrift and downdrift nearshore areas
affected by sand placement projects on the beach.
The Service published its decision to list the loggerhead sea turtle as threatened on July 28, 1978
(43 FR 32800). On September 22, 2011, the loggerhead sea turtle’s listing under the ESA was
revised from a single threatened species to nine distinct population segments (DPS) listed as
either threatened or endangered (76 FR 58868). The nine DPSs and their statuses are: Northwest
Atlantic Ocean DPS (threatened); Northeast Atlantic Ocean (endangered); Mediterranean Sea
DPS (endangered); South Atlantic Ocean DPS (threatened); North Pacific Ocean DPS
(endangered); South Pacific Ocean DPS (endangered); North Indian Ocean DPS (endangered);
Southwest Indian Ocean (threatened); and Southeast Indo-Pacific Ocean DPS (threatened). The
geographic delineations given below for each discrete population segment were determined
primarily based on nesting beach locations, genetic evidence, oceanographic features, thermal
tolerance, fishery bycatch data, and information on loggerhead distribution and migrations from
satellite telemetry and flipper tagging studies (Figure 3-12).
Page 141 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
37
Figure 3-12. Map of Loggerhead Sea Turtle DPS Boundaries.
The loggerhead occurs throughout the temperate and tropical regions of the Atlantic, Pacific, and
Indian Oceans (Dodd 1988) (Figure 3-12). In the North Atlantic, the loggerhead is commonly
found in the Gulf of Mexico, the northern Caribbean, the Bahamas archipelago, and eastward to
West Africa, the western Mediterranean, and the west coast of Europe. In the Northwest
Atlantic, the majority of loggerhead nesting is concentrated along the coasts of the U.S. from
southern Virginia through Alabama. Additional nesting beaches are found along the northern and
western Gulf of Mexico, eastern Yucatan Peninsula, at Cay Sal Bank in the eastern Bahamas
(Addison and Morford, 1996; Addison, 1997), on the southwestern coast of Cuba (F. Moncada-
Gavilan, personal communication, cited in Ehrhart et al., 2003), and along the coasts of Central
America, Colombia, Venezuela, and the eastern Caribbean Islands. Five recovery units have
been identified within the Northwest Atlantic based on genetic differences and a combination of
geographic distribution of nesting densities, geographic separation, and geopolitical boundaries
(NMFS and USFWS 2008). Recovery units (RU) are subunits of a listed species that are
geographically or otherwise identifiable and essential to the recovery of the species. Recovery
units are individually necessary to conserve genetic robustness, demographic robustness,
important life history stages, or some other feature necessary for long-term sustainability of the
species. The five recovery units identified in the Northwest Atlantic are: (1) Northern Recovery
Unit (NRU); (2) Peninsula Florida Recovery Unit (PFRU); (3) Dry Tortugas Recovery Unit
(DTRU); (4) Northern Gulf of Mexico Recovery Unit (NGMRU); and (5) Greater Caribbean
Recovery Unit (GCRU).
Although none of the RUs have been monitored for more than 50 years, none of them have met
the target annual rate of increase (Table 3-8) (NMFS and USFWS 2023). Nest trends of the
PFRU, which hosts the majority of nesting within the DPS, have not increased over 30 years of
monitoring (NMFS and USFWS 2023). The much smaller NRU has demonstrated some
Page 142 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
38
progress toward its goal, with a statistically significant 1.7% rate of increase over 37 years;
genetic analyses of all nests laid in the NRU indicated that the number of annual nests since 2010
significantly correlates (p = 0.004) to the number of annual nesting females (Shamblin et al.
2017; Georgia Department of Natural Resources and University of Georgia, unpublished data
2021). Nesting rates from the NGMRU were not significantly different from zero. Data were
insufficient or unavailable from the DTRU and GCRUs (NMFS and USFWS 2023).
Table 3-8. Recovery Plan demographic recovery criteria (i.e., nest trend criteria)
Comparison of the 2008 demographic recovery criteria (NMFS and USFWS 2008) and
recent nesting data at index beaches (Bolten et al. 2019). The p-value indicates statistical
significance, and only the Northern Recovery Unit data shows a significant positive trend
(NMFS and USFWS 2023).
3.3.1. Species Description
The loggerhead sea turtle grows to an average weight of about 200 pounds and is characterized
by a large head with blunt jaws. Adults and juveniles have a reddish-brown carapace. Scales on
the top of the head and top of the flippers are also reddish-brown with yellow on the borders.
Hatchlings are a dull brown color (NMFS 2009).
3.3.2. Life History
Loggerheads are long-lived, slow-growing animals that use multiple habitats across entire ocean
basins throughout their life history. The loggerhead may be found hundreds of miles out to sea,
as well as in inshore areas such as bays, lagoons, salt marshes, creeks, ship channels, and the
mouths of large rivers. Coral reefs, rocky places, and shipwrecks are often used as feeding areas
and loggerheads feed on mollusks, crustaceans, fish, and other marine animals.
This complex life history encompasses terrestrial, nearshore, and open ocean habitats. The three
basic ecosystems in which loggerheads live are the:
1. Terrestrial zone (supralittoral) - the nesting beach where oviposition (egg laying) and
embryonic development and hatching occur.
2. Neritic zone - the inshore marine environment (from the surface to the sea floor) where
water depths do not exceed 656 feet. The neritic zone generally includes the continental
Page 143 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
39
shelf, but in areas where the continental shelf is very narrow or nonexistent, the neritic
zone conventionally extends to areas where water depths are less than 656 feet.
3. Oceanic zone - the vast open ocean environment (from the surface to the sea floor) where
water depths are greater than 656 feet.
The generalized life history of Atlantic loggerheads is shown in Figure 3-13.
Figure 3-13. Life history stages of a loggerhead turtle. The boxes represent life stages and
the corresponding ecosystems, solid lines represent movements between life stages and
ecosystems, and dotted lines are speculative (Bolten 2003).
Within the Northwest Atlantic, the majority of nesting activity occurs from April through
September, with a peak in June and July (Williams-Walls et al. 1983, Dodd 1988, Weishampel et
al. 2006). Nesting occurs along the coasts of North America, Central America, northern South
America, the Antilles, Bahamas, and Bermuda, but is concentrated in the southeastern U.S. and
on the Yucatán Peninsula in Mexico on open beaches or along narrow bays having suitable sand
(Sternberg 1981, Ehrhart 1989, Ehrhart et al. 2003, NMFS and USFWS 2008). Numbers of
nests and nesting females are often highly variable from year to year due to a number of factors
including environmental stochasticity, periodicity in ocean conditions, anthropogenic effects, and
density-dependent and density-independent factors affecting survival, somatic growth, and
reproduction (Meylan 1982, Hays 2000, Chaloupka 2001, Solow et al. 2002). Despite these
sources of variation, a nesting beach survey can provide a valuable assessment of changes in the
adult female population. Since female turtles exhibit strong nest site fidelity, nesting beach
surveys can track trends over time as long as the study is sufficiently long and effort and
methods are standardized (Meylan 1982, Gerrodette and Brandon 2000, Reina et al. 2002).
Page 144 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
40
Table 3-10 summarizes key life history characteristics for loggerheads nesting in the U.S.
Table 3-10. Life history parameters for loggerheads nesting in the U.S. (NMFS and Service
2023).
Page 145 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
41
3.3.3. Numbers, Reproduction, and Distribution
Northern Recovery Unit (NRU)
The geographic boundary is defined as loggerheads originating from nesting beaches from the
Florida-Georgia border through southern Virginia (the northern extent of the nesting range).
The NRU is the second largest nesting assemblage in the Northwest Atlantic and has an annual
rate of increase in number of nests of 1.3% (p = 0.04) based on a log-linear regression model for
37 years of nesting data (1983-2019) (Figure 3-14) (NMFS and USFWS 2019, 2023). This
annual rate of increase is below the 2% criterion for achieving recovery. Although there has
been an observed increase in the number of nests for the past decade (total nests exceeded 14,000
for the first time in 2019), looking at short term trends in nesting abundance can be misleading
and needs to be considered in the context of one generation (= 50 years for loggerhead sea
turtles) as specified in the Demographic Recovery Criteria. Based on genetic analyses of all
nests laid in the NRU, the number of annual nests since 2010 significantly correlates to the
number of annual nesting females (Shamblin et al. 2017) meaning when annual nest numbers
increase so do the number of annual nesting females (Bolton et al. 2019, NMFS and USFWS
2023). Excluding southern Virginia, South Carolina comprised 52-60% of nests laid within the
NRU between 2018 and 2023 (https://seaturtle.org/nestdb/
).
Figure 3-14. Log of annual loggerhead nest counts from NRU beaches, 1983-2019 (Bolton et
al. 2019, NMFS and USFWS 2023).
3.3.4. Conservation Needs and Threats
Conservation Needs for Nesting Beaches
Loggerhead sea turtles need suitable nesting beach habitat that provides: (1) Relatively
unimpeded nearshore access from the ocean to the beach for nesting females and from the beach
to the ocean for both post-nesting females and hatchlings; (2) Nesting areas above mean high
water to avoid frequent inundation by high tides; (3) Sand that allows for suitable nest
construction; (4) Sand that is suitable for facilitating gas diffusion conducive to embryo
development; (5) Sand that is able to develop and maintain temperatures and a moisture content
conducive to embryo development; (6) Sufficient darkness to ensure nesting turtles are not
deterred from emerging onto the beach and hatchlings and post nesting females orient to the sea;
Page 146 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
42
and (7) Natural coastal processes or artificially created or maintained habitat mimicking natural
conditions.
Threats to Nesting Beaches
Threats to nesting beaches include beach erosion, armoring and nourishment; artificial lighting;
beach cleaning; increased human presence; recreational beach equipment; beach driving; coastal
construction and fishing piers; exotic dune and beach vegetation; and poaching (NMFS and
USFWS 2008). The most prevalent threats to nesting beaches within the NRU are summarized
below. For a complete list of threats, refer to the recovery plan and status reviews available at
https://ecos.fws.gov/ecp/species/1110
.
Erosion of beaches is a result of anthropogenic and natural processes. Erosion is often worsened
when man-made coastal and in water structures interfere with natural coastal processes (Von
Holle et al. 2019). Beach erosion is also one of the most significant threats to loggerheads at the
egg life stage (Bolten et al. 2011). High tides and tidal washouts can flood and erode nesting
beaches, washing eggs into the sea or lethally inundating developing embryos (Brost et al. 2015;
Butler et al. 2020).
Beach renourishment is often used to manage beach erosion by adding or redistributing sand;
however, renourishment often results in diminished nesting success (Long et al. 2011; Hays
2012). Designed to stabilize shorelines and prevent erosion, beach armoring structures (e.g.,
revetments and seawalls) decrease nesting activity by preventing females from accessing suitable
nesting sites (Rizkalla and Savage 2011). Lamont and Houser (2014) found that alterations to
the nearshore environment (e.g., jetties, dredging, or installation of pilings) also alter sea turtle
nest distribution. Thus, beach renourishment may result in reduced nesting or force turtles to
nest at suboptimal locations.
Coastal development alters nesting habitat, making it less suitable for nesting females, egg
incubation, and hatchling emergence. Sella and Fuentes (2019) found that 100% of very high
(i.e., top three) and high (i.e., top 25%) loggerhead density nesting beaches were exposed to
cumulative coastal modification and construction. Artificial lighting deters females from nesting
(Witherington et al. 2014), resulting in reduced nest densities (Bonner 2015; Weishampel et al.
2016; Hu et al. 2018; Linz 2018; Price et al. 2018; Windle 2018). Artificial lighting can disrupt
or delay hatchlings’ sea-orienting ability, which increases nest-to-sea mortality as a result of
dehydration, exhaustion, or predation (Witherington et al. 2014; Erb and Wyneken 2019;
Vindiola 2019; Stanley et al. 2020).
Nesting habitat can also be degraded by the presence of humans and recreational equipment
(e.g., tents and furniture). Equipment left on beaches and other beach debris can also deter,
impede, and/or entrap nesting females and hatchlings, reducing nesting, and interfering with
hatchling emergence and transit to the sea (Martin et al. 2019).
3.3.5. Summary of the status of the loggerhead sea turtle
The 2023 status review for the loggerhead sea turtle (NW Atlantic DPS) determined the DPS’
status remains unchanged. The DPS continues to be at risk from intense, numerous, and
Page 147 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
43
increasing threats, which have prevented population growth in recent decades. The DPS is
subdivided into five recovery units (RUs). Increased nesting in the NRU may have helped
stabilize the overall trend, which is largely driven by the PFRU.
For a more detailed account of the species description, life history, population dynamics,
conservation needs, and threats, refer to
Species Profile for Loggerhead sea turtle(Caretta caretta)
(fws.gov).
4. STATUS OF CRITICAL HABITAT
4.1. Critical Habitat for the Piping Plover
The Service has designated critical habitat for the piping plover on three occasions. Two of
these designations protected different breeding populations. Critical habitat for the Great Lakes
breeding population was designated May 7, 2001, (66 FR 22938, USFWS 2001a), and critical
habitat for the northern Great Plains breeding population was designated September 11, 2002,
(67 FR 57637, USFWS 2002). No critical habitat has been proposed or designated for the
Atlantic Coast breeding population, but the needs of all three breeding populations were
considered in the 2001 critical habitat designation for wintering piping plovers (66 FR 36038,
USFWS 2001b) and subsequent redesignations (USFWS 2008d, 2009d). Wintering piping
plovers may include individuals from the Great Lakes and northern Great Plains breeding
populations as well as birds that nest along the Atlantic coast.
4.1.1. Description
Critical habitat for wintering piping plovers currently comprises 141 units totaling 256,513 acres
along the coasts of North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, Florida, Alabama, Mississippi,
Louisiana, and Texas. The original designation included 142 areas (the rule erroneously states
137 units) encompassing approximately 1,798 miles of mapped shoreline and 165,211 acres of
mapped areas (USFWS 2001b). A revised designation for four North Carolina units was
published in 2008 (USFWS 2008d). Eighteen revised Texas critical habitat units were
designated in 2009, replacing 19 units that were vacated and remanded by a 2006 court order
(USFWS 2009c). Designated areas include habitats that support roosting, foraging, and
sheltering activities of piping plovers.
Critical habitat designation for nonbreeding piping plovers used the term "primary constituent
elements" (PCEs) to identify the key components of critical habitat that are essential to its
conservation and may require special management considerations or protection. Revisions to the
critical habitat regulations in 2016 (81 FR 7214, 50 CFR §4.24) discontinue use of the term
PCEs and rely exclusively on the term “physical and biological features” (PBFs) to refer to these
key components, because the latter term is the one used in the statute. This shift in terminology
does not change how the Service conducts a “destruction or adverse modification” analysis. In
this BO, we use the term PBFs to label the key components of critical habitat that provide for the
conservation of the nonbreeding piping plover that were identified in its critical habitat
designation rule as PCEs.
Page 148 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
44
The PBFs of nonbreeding piping plover critical habitat are sand or mud flats or both with no or
sparse emergent vegetation for foraging piping plovers and adjacent unvegetated or sparsely
vegetated sand, mud, or algal flats above high tide for roosting piping plovers (66 FR 36038).
Important components of the beach/dune ecosystem include surf-cast algae, sparsely vegetated
back beach and salterns, spits, and washover areas. Washover areas are broad, unvegetated
zones, with little or no topographic relief, that are formed and maintained by the action of
hurricanes, storm surge, or other extreme wave action.
4.1.2. Conservation Value
Designation of critical habitat can help focus conservation activities for a listed species by
identifying areas that contain PBFs that are essential for the conservation of that species.
Recovery of piping plovers is dependent upon available habitat throughout the range of the
species.
4.1.3. Conservation Needs
All critical habitat units were occupied at the time of designation. Due to the dynamic nature of
these ephemeral habitats, all units are needed for the recovery of the species. Natural coastal
processes are also necessary to ensure the existence and functionality of these units in the future.
When these processes are limited or altered, habitat quality diminishes.
4.2. Critical Habitat for the Rufa Red Knot (Proposed)
The Service proposed to designate critical habitat for the rufa red knot on July 15, 2021 and
proposed revisions on April 13, 2023 (86 FR 37410, 88 FR 22530). The revised proposed
designation includes 127 units encompassing approximately 683,405 acres along the shorelines
of Massachusetts, New York, New Jersey, Delaware, Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina,
Georgia, Florida, Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana, and Texas. The designation has not been
finalized.
4.2.1. Description
The PBFs for the rufa red knot include: (1) Beaches and tidal flats used for foraging; (2) Upper
beach areas used for roosting, preening, resting, or sheltering; (3) Ephemeral and/or dynamic
coastal features used for foraging or roosting; (4) Ocean vegetation deposits or surf-cast wrack
used for foraging and roosting; (5) Intertidal peat banks used for foraging and roosting; (6)
Features landward of the beach that support foraging or roosting; and (7) Artificial habitat
mimicking natural conditions or maintaining the physical or biological features 1-6 (86 FR
37418, 88 FR 22530).
4.2.2. Conservation Value
Designation of critical habitat can help focus conservation activities for a listed species by
identifying areas that contain PBFs that are essential for the conservation of that species.
Recovery of rufa red knots is dependent upon available habitat throughout the range of the
species.
Page 149 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
45
4.2.3. Conservation Needs
All critical habitat units were occupied at the time of the proposed rule to designate critical
habitat for the rufa red knot. Due to the dynamic nature of these ephemeral habitats, all units are
needed for the recovery of the species. Natural coastal processes are also necessary to ensure the
existence and functionality of these units in the future. When these processes are limited or
altered, habitat quality diminishes.
5. ENVIRONMENTAL BASELINE
This section describes the best available data about the condition of the species in the Action
Area without the consequences caused by the proposed Action.
South Carolina barrier beaches are part of a complex and dynamic coastal system that
continually respond to inlets, tides, waves, erosion and deposition, longshore sediment transport,
and depletion, fluctuations in sea level, and weather events. The location and shape of the
coastline perpetually adjusts to these physical forces. Winds move sediment across the dry
beach forming dunes and the island interior landscape. The natural communities contain plants
and animals that are subject to shoreline erosion and deposition, salt spray, wind, drought
conditions, and sandy soils. Vegetative communities include foredunes, primary, and secondary
dunes, interdunal swales, sand pine scrub, and maritime forests. However, the protection or
persistence of these important natural landforms, processes, and wildlife resources is often in
conflict with long-term beach stabilization projects and their indirect effects, i.e., increases in
residential development, infrastructure, and public recreational uses.
South Carolina has approximately 182 miles of coastline and approximately 51% (93/182 miles)
of the coastline is developed (SCDHEC 2010). Approximately 37% (67.6/182 miles) of the
state’s coastline has received sand placement via beach nourishment or dredge disposal
placement (Rice 2012a). South Carolina currently has 47 tidal inlets open and 36% (17/47
inlets) have been stabilized with some type of hard structure(s) along at least one shoreline (Rice
2012b). Hilton Head Island is managed by the Town of Hilton Head Island and the island is
subject to dynamic coastal processes that influence and shape the shoreline.
5.1. Piping Plover
5.1.1. Action Area Numbers and Distribution
Shorebirds, including piping plovers, are known to use a mosaic of habitats associated with inlet
complexes. Piping plovers have been observed in the Action Area since the 1990s. The migrant
population is typically much larger than the winter population. Piping plovers that overwinter,
meaning they spend most of their nonbreeding season at one location, can arrive at their winter
site in South Carolina as early as August and depart as late as April (Maddock et al. 2013), but
the best local winter population estimate cannot be determined until the core winter season
(November 15 – February 15). Results of a band re-sighting analysis for birds documented at
sites in South Carolina showed zero immigration or emigration during the months of December
and January (Cohen et al. 2018); therefore, the Service determines the local winter population by
Page 150 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
46
using the single highest count of birds during surveys conducted between December 1 and
January 31.
The highest count recorded on Hilton Head Island during the winter was 32 birds observed in
December of 2021, which included the Folly in the survey area in addition to the heel of the
island and Fish Haul Creek (USFWS unpublished data). Winter survey numbers conducted
along an established survey route along the Atlantic and Port Royal Sound shorelines of the heel
of the island and Fish Haul Creek ranged between 12 to 18 birds between 2010 and January of
2021 (Figure 5-1). Gibson et al. (2018) documented a lot of turnover within the local population
and that these are not necessarily the same individuals returning each season, which is reflected
in the lower survival rates for Hilton Head Island.
The highest count recorded on the island during migration is 46 birds (USFWS unpublished
data), but this does not necessarily reflect the true number of plovers using the island. Banded
piping plovers are not consistently resighted and reported so the number of migrants as well as
the passage population (the total number of birds that use a site during the entire nonbreeding
season) for the Action Area is currently unknown. Resights of uniquely marked piping plovers
indicate that birds from all three breeding populations use the island, but most birds are from the
Atlantic Coast (USFWS unpublished data). The proportions of each breeding population
wintering on the island varies each season. Birds from the Atlantic Coast population comprise
the largest proportion of previously banded and unbanded birds on the island (USFWS
unpublished data). The Service’s assumption that most unbanded birds are from the Atlantic
Coast population is based on the resights of birds banded on their wintering grounds that were re-
sighted the following breeding season within the Atlantic Coast breeding range (USFWS
unpublished data). Birds from the Great Lakes and Northern Great Plains comprise a much
smaller proportion of banded birds on the island. The vast majority of Great Lakes birds are
banded, but only a small portion of Northern Great Plains birds are banded so some unbanded
birds could be from the Northern Great Plains population. Over one wintering season on Hilton
Head Island, four is the highest number of wintering birds observed from the Great Lakes
population and three is the highest number of wintering birds from the Northern Great Plains
population (USFWS unpublished data).
Figure 5-1. Winter piping plover population numbers on Hilton Head Island from 2010 to
2021 along the heel of the island and Fish Haul Creek. The local winter population is
determined conservatively by using the single highest count of birds during surveys
conducted between December 1 and January 31 (Cohen et al. 2018).
Page 151 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
47
5.1.2. Action Area Conservation Needs and Threats
Habitat loss, human recreational disturbance (especially off-leash dogs), predation, accelerated
sea level rise, storms, and severe cold weather, which are the six most prevalent threats to piping
plovers within their nonbreeding range, are present or possible on Hilton Head Island. Chronic
human recreational disturbance, which is the most widespread and serious threat in South
Carolina, exacerbates physiological effects on body condition that are difficult to offset
particularly in lower quality habitats. When birds must eat more, which requires more time and
effort, and move more to find food and/or respond to a disturbance, weight is harder to gain and
maintain. Gibson et al. (2018) found that birds wintering at more disturbed sites were seven
percent lighter than birds wintering at less disturbed sites. Hilton Head Island, one of eight sites
in the study between 2012 and 2016, had the 3
rd lowest piping plover true survival rate
(0.62±0.07) (Gibson et al. 2018), which is concerning because Hilton Head Island has the largest
known wintering population of piping plovers in South Carolina. In addition, Gibson et al.
(2018) found evidence of a greater influence of human disturbance on survival than on fidelity,
which suggested that plovers were more likely to die than move to another winter site.
Human recreational disturbance is the most prevalent threat to piping plovers on Hilton Head
Island. The Service has had multiple discussions with the Town over the years regarding human
recreational disturbance, particularly regarding off-leash dogs. The Service and Town
employees have repeatedly witnessed dogs chasing piping plovers on multiple occasions during
shorebird surveys. Since Hilton Head Island hosts the largest known winter population of piping
plovers and individuals are more likely to die than move to another wintering site on another
island, existing human recreational disturbance that is already resulting in lower survival rates
should be minimized to help offset added project-related impacts to piping plovers. The most
effective way to minimize existing threats that have survival-related impacts is for the Town to
establish and enforce areas under their jurisdiction that permanently restrict dogs year-round.
5.2. Rufa Red Knot
5.2.1. Action Area Numbers and Distribution
Red knots have been documented in the Action Area since 1992 during migration and winter.
The migrant population is typically larger than the winter population. Banded red knots are not
consistently resighted and reported from this area so the number of migrants as well as the
passage population (the total number of birds that use a site during the entire nonbreeding
season) for the Action Area is currently unknown. Based on South Carolina band resight data,
red knots using the Action Area during the winter and/or during spring migration before May
would be from the Southeast U.S./Caribbean population (SCDNR 2013, 2019). Birds seen in
May could be from the Southeast U.S./Caribbean population, Northern South American Coast
population, or the Southern population. The only way to know for sure would be to resight a
banded bird.
Birds have been documented on the island during the winter season (November 16 – February
15) since 2006 (USFWS unpublished data). The highest count recorded in winter was 344 birds
in 2011. Birds have also been documented on the island during spring migration (February 16 –
Page 152 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
48
June 1). The highest count recently recorded during migration was 400 birds on April 18, 2022
(eBird.org 2024).
Foraging birds have been documented in the Fish Haul Creek and Pine Island areas (CEG 2023,
2024). The Hilton Head Island international shorebird survey (ISS) team counted 320 knots
along the Port Royal Plantation shoreline on May 8, 2024, which also coincided with horseshoe
crab (Limulus polyphemus) spawning activity (A. Biggs, pers. comm. 2024, A. Kuehn, pers.
comm. 2024). Documented red knot use on Hilton Head Island suggests the Fish Haul and Pine
Island project areas within the Action Area are used by small flocks of knots during the winter
and larger flocks during spring migration although flock numbers vary.
5.2.2. Action Area Conservation Needs and Threats
Habitat loss, recreational disturbance, predation, accelerated sea level rise, storms, and severe
cold, which are the six most prevalent threats to red knots within their nonbreeding range, are
present or possible in the Action Area. Chronic recreational disturbance, which is the most
widespread and serious threat in South Carolina, is still present within the Action Area despite
conservation efforts. Red knots rest at the water’s edge during daytime high tides and flocks can
be found foraging on coquina clams (Donax variabilis) in the swash zone, particularly on falling
tides. During the spring, horseshoe crabs spawn along the Port Royal Sound shoreline on Hilton
Head Island. Red knots feed on horseshoe crab eggs available within the top 5 cm of sand when
they are available during spring migration. These birds need to feed and rest undisturbed
particularly during spring migration when they need to build fat reserves.
5.3. Loggerhead Sea Turtle
5.3.1. Action Area Numbers, Reproduction, and Distribution
Hilton Head Island has a nest protection project permitted through SCDNR to conduct daily
nesting surveys, nest relocations, predator control measures, and nest inventories. Nest numbers
ranged from 178 to 460 between 2018 to 2023 (Table 5-1). The annual nesting density for
Hilton Head Island over the last 6 years comprises approximately 0.05 to 0.06% of the annual
statewide nesting totals and 0.03% of the NRU nesting totals excluding southern Virginia. Based
on the clutch frequency of loggerhead sea turtles nesting within the NRU (Table 3-10), 40 to 103
turtles have nested within the Action Area from 2018 – 2023, 620-1,971 turtles have nested
within South Carolina, and 1,191-3,273 have nested within the NRU (excluding Virginia) during
the same timeframe.
Hilton Head Island has “hot spots” of sea turtle nesting density that also depend on habitat
conditions. Of all the project areas within the Action Area, Pine Island has the lowest density of
nests. Although the nesting density tends to be higher along the “toe” (south end) and “heel” of
the island during some nesting seasons, the central project area spans the longest section of
shoreline.
Table 5-1. Loggerhead sea turtle nests within the Action Area from 2018 -2023
(Seaturtle.org 2024).
Page 153 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
49
2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
Hilton Head
Island
(% of
Statewide)
(% of NRU)
178
(0.06%)
(0.03%)
460
(0.05%)
(0.03%)
291
(0.05%)
(0.03%)
282
(0.05%)
(0.03%)
422
(0.05%)
(0.03%)
353
(0.05%)
(0.03%)
South Carolina
(% of NRU)
2,761
(0.52%)
8,772
(0.60%)
5,551
(0.57%)
5,628
(0.58%)
7,965
(0.57%)
6,618
(0.56%)
NRU1 5302 14,566 9,731 9,625 14,012 11,820
1NRU numbers do not include Virginia.
5.3.2. Action Area Conservation Needs and Threats
Sea turtle nests are subject to severe erosion, tidal inundation, storms, and predation. Sea turtle
hatchlings are subject to disorientations caused by artificial lighting, predation, and entrapment.
Nesting sea turtles are subject to disorientations due to artificial lighting and entrapment. The
SCDNR nest protection projects within the Action Area address some of these threats by
relocating and screening nests and promoting lights out for sea turtles. Despite these threats,
nesting within the Action Area follows the increasing trend of nesting within the NRU.
5.4. Critical Habitat for the Piping Plover
5.4.1. Action Area Conservation Value
The Action Area consistently hosts the largest wintering population of piping plovers in South
Carolina. Piping plovers are distributed along the Port Royal Sound shoreline of Hilton Head
Island and along the Heel of the island on the Atlantic Ocean shoreline. The Heel project area
within the Action Area overlaps designated critical habitat unit SC-15 (Figure 5-2), which
currently contain all PBFs. Available data suggests the Action Area supports 12 – 32 wintering
piping plovers. Resights of uniquely marked piping plovers indicate that birds from all three
breeding populations use the area, but most birds are from the Atlantic Coast and Great Lakes
populations (Gratto-Trevor et al. 2012, USFWS 2020a). Each unit within the nonbreeding
piping plover designation is essential to the recovery of the species. The text description of the
unit is as follows:
Unit SC-15: Hilton Head
43 ha (106 ac) in Beaufort County
The majority of this unit is State-owned. This unit includes the northeastern tip (Atlantic Ocean
side) of Hilton Head Island and all of Joiner Bank. It begins at the shoreline east of northern
Planters Row and ends at the shoreline east of Donax Road. It includes the MLLW of Port
Royal Sound and the Atlantic Ocean to where densely vegetated habitat, not used by the piping
plover, begins and where the constituent elements no longer occur. All of Joiner Bank to MLLW
in included.
Page 154 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
50
Figure 5-2. Map of piping plover designated critical habitat units SC-12 to 15.
5.4.2. Action Area Conservation Needs
Minimizing Human Recreational Disturbance
Intense human disturbance in winter habitat can be functionally equivalent to habitat loss. If the
disturbance prevents birds from using an area (Goss-Custard et al. 1996), this can lead to roost
abandonment and population declines (Burton et al. 1996). Disturbance from human and pet
presence alters plover behavior and often negatively influences distribution (Hunt et al. 2019).
5.5. Critical Habitat for the Rufa Red Knot (Proposed)
5.5.1. Action Area Conservation Value
The Action Area overlaps critical habitat units SC-22 proposed for designation (Figure 5-3),
which currently contains all PBFs. Each unit within the rufa red knot proposed designation is
essential to the recovery of the species. The Action Area currently supports low numbers of both
overwintering and migrant rufa red knots. The text descriptions of the proposed units are as
follows:
Page 155 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
51
Unit SC–22: Hilton Head Island Beach
Unit SC–22 consists of 1,682 ac (681 ha) of the heel of Hilton Head Island, a barrier island off
the coast, in Beaufort County, South Carolina. The unit boundary begins on the Port Royal
Sound shoreline beginning at Oyster Shell Lane, continues southeast then turns southwest along
the Atlantic Ocean shoreline, and continues to the undeveloped portion of Singleton Beach
southwest of the Folly. The unit includes all emergent land from MLLW to the toe of the dunes
or where densely vegetated habitat (not used by the red knot) begins (i.e., the highly dynamic
shoreline and the sandy intertidal zone that are covered at high tide and uncovered at low tide).
This dynamic habitat also includes the ephemeral emergent shoals (sand bars) within the flood-
tidal and ebb-tidal deltas associated with Fish Haul Creek and unnamed inlets within the unit
boundary. Lands within this unit include approximately 1,015 ac (411 ha; 60 percent) in State
ownership and 667 ac (270 ha; 40 percent) in private/other ownership. General land use within
this unit includes residential/commercial development within the town limits of municipality of
the Town of Hilton Head, tourism, and outdoor recreational use (e.g. beachgoing, boating,
fishing, birdwatching).
Unit SC–22 is occupied by the species and contains one or more of the physical or biological
features essential to the conservation of the species. This unit is essential to the conservation of
the species because it supports the species’ wintering population in South Carolina and the
Southeast and serves as an important spring and fall migration stopover site (exceeding threshold
numbers five out of the last ten years). This unit is one of only three units in South Carolina that
supports high concentrations of red knots (exceeding threshold numbers) throughout the entire
nonbreeding season (fall, winter, and spring). Approximately 73 ac (29 ha) of this unit overlaps
with designated critical habitat for the federally threatened piping plover (66 FR 36038; July 10,
2001).
Threats identified within Unit SC-22 include: (1) Disturbance of foraging and roosting red knots
by humans and human activities (e.g., off leash dogs, walking/running/biking through or too
close to flocks of red knots, powered boats); (2) depredation by native and nonnative predators;
(3) modification or loss of habitat or both due to uncontrolled recreational access, erosion and
sea level rise; and (4) disturbance associated with response to natural and human-caused
disasters (e.g., hurricanes, oil spills). Special management considerations or protection measures
to reduce or alleviate the threats may include minimizing disturbance to wintering and migrating
red knots (e.g., managing recreational access to key rufa red knot foraging and roosting habitat
during migration through restrictions on timing, locations, and types of activities) and managing
the collection of spawning horseshoe crabs for biomedical use (e.g. limiting location and timing
of collection). Private/other lands within this unit are managed under the 2017 Town of Hilton
Head Island Local Comprehensive Beach Management Plan.
Page 156 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
52
Figure 5-3. Map of rufa red knot proposed designated critical habitat units SC-22.
5.5.2. Action Area Conservation Needs
Minimize Recreational Disturbance
Intense human disturbance in winter habitat can be functionally equivalent to habitat loss. If the
disturbance prevents birds from using an area (Goss-Custard et al. 1996), this can lead to roost
abandonment and population declines (Burton et al. 1996). Disturbance from human and pet
presence alters plover behavior and often negatively influences distribution (Hunt et al. 2019).
6. EFFECTS OF THE ACTION
Implementing regulations define “effects of the action” as “all consequences to listed species or
critical habitat that are caused by the proposed action, including the consequences of other
Page 157 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
53
activities that are caused by the proposed action. A consequence is caused by the proposed
action if it would not occur but for the proposed action and it is reasonably certain to occur.
Effects of the action may occur later in time and may include consequences occurring outside the
immediate area involved in the action” (50 CFR 402.02).
6.1. Effects of Sand Placement
6.1.1. Piping Plover
Beneficial Effects
Sand placement projects can have beneficial effects by creating unvegetated, open areas, which
make optimal roosting habitat, and create more space for birds on the beach, but these effects are
short-lived, often lasting only a few years before vegetation encroaches again (Chaplin 2019).
Adverse Effects
Wintering piping plovers depend on the availability and abundance of benthic invertebrates such
as polychaete worms and amphipods as their primary food source (Tweel et al. 2023).
Polychaete worms comprise most of the shorebird diet (Kalejta 1992, Mercier and McNeil 1994,
Tsipoura and Burger 1999, Verkuil et al. 2006); and are preferred by piping plovers (Hoopes
1993, Nicholls 1989, Zonick and Ryan 1996, Tweel et al. 2023). Burial of benthic invertebrates,
delayed recovery of benthic invertebrates, or changes in their community composition due to
physical habitat changes may affect the quality of piping plover foraging habitat. Disturbance
from project construction, lower quality foraging habitats, and facilitated human recreational
access can adversely affect piping plovers by further lowering their survival (Gibson et al. 2018).
The Heel, Fish Haul Creek, and Pine Island project areas contain sheltered flats and runnels
known to provide higher quality foraging habitat due to the benthic community composition of
these microhabitats (Tweel et al. 2023). Benthic recruitment and community composition
following project construction will be dependent on sediment characteristics. Timeframes
projected for benthic recruitment and re-establishment following typical beach nourishment
projects can range between six months to two years (Thrush et al. 1996, Peterson et al. 2000,
Zajac and Whitlatch 2003, Bishop et al. 2006, Peterson et al. 2006) depending on sediment
composition and timing of construction. Benthic recruitment is expected to take a minimum of
six months to occur and may be delayed further depending on the construction timing of a
separately permitted project (PN# SAC-2023-00210). Even after benthic recruitment occurs, the
benthic community composition and abundance may vary due to microhabitat changes, which
could lower foraging habitat quality.
Piping plovers wintering in the Action Area may be displaced to lower quality foraging areas
resulting in lower survival. Less sheltered beach flats without runnels are considered a lower
quality foraging habitat for piping plovers compared to sheltered flats with runnels (Tweel et al.
2023). Plovers wintering on Hilton Head Island are subjected to chronic human recreational
disturbance so additional project-related disturbance is anticipated to negatively impact baseline
survival rates. Survival rates at Hilton Head are already the 3
rd lowest survival rates compared to
birds’ survival rates wintering at less disturbed sites (Gibson et al. 2018). Plovers may be pushed
Page 158 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
54
to lower quality foraging habitats during and after project construction, which may exacerbate
impacts to birds with a lower body condition rising to the level of harm instead of harassment.
6.1.2. Rufa Red Knot
The Service anticipates similar effects to wintering red knots, if present, and their primary prey
items, coquina clams (Donax variabilis), in the project area, as described for piping plovers.
Effects to coquinas can be minimized by scheduling project construction outside of spawning
and recruitment windows that occur in late winter and early spring (Ruppert and Fox 1988).
Sand placement will cover relict march habitat that supports false angelwings (Petriccolaria
pholadiformis) and scorched mussels (Brachidontes exustus), which are preferred prey items.
Sand placement could also effect spawning horseshoe crabs that spawn along the Port Royal
Sound shoreline. Horseshoe crab eggs provide food for red knots during their spring migration
when the eggs are available within the top 5 cm of sand. In South Carolina, most spawning
activity occurs in May and June. The construction window for Fish Haul Creek and Pine Island
will be limited to June 1 – October 15 to minimize impacts to food resources when larger flocks
of red knots are present.
6.1.3. Loggerhead Sea Turtle
Beneficial Effects
The placement of sand on a beach with reduced dry foredune habitat may increase sea turtle
nesting habitat if the placed sand is highly compatible (i.e., grain size, shape, color, etc.) with
naturally occurring beach sediments in the area, and compaction and escarpment remediation
measures are incorporated into the project. In addition, a nourished beach that is designed and
constructed to mimic a natural beach system may benefit sea turtles more than an eroding beach
it replaces.
Adverse Effects
Potential adverse effects during the project construction phase include disturbance of existing
nests, which may have been missed by surveyors and thus not marked for avoidance, disturbance
of females attempting to nest, and disorientation of emerging hatchlings. In addition, heavy
equipment will be required to construct the beach profile. This equipment will have to traverse
the beach portion of the Action Area, which could result in harm to nesting sea turtles, their
nests, and emerging hatchlings.
Equipment During Construction
The use of heavy machinery on beaches during a construction project may also have adverse
effects on sea turtles. Equipment left on the nesting beach overnight can create barriers to
nesting females emerging from the surf and crawling up the beach, causing a higher incidence of
false crawls and unnecessary energy expenditure.
The operation of motor vehicles or equipment on the beach to complete the project work at night
affects sea turtle nesting by interrupting or colliding with a nesting turtle on the beach, headlights
Page 159 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
55
disorienting or misorienting emergent hatchlings, vehicles running over hatchlings attempting to
reach the ocean, and vehicle ruts on the beach interfering with hatchlings crawling to the ocean.
Apparently, hatchlings become diverted not because they cannot physically climb out of a rut
(Hughes and Caine 1994), but because the sides of the track cast a shadow and the hatchlings
lose their line of sight to the ocean horizon (Mann 1977). The extended period of travel required
to negotiate tire ruts may increase the susceptibility of hatchlings to dehydration and depredation
during migration to the ocean (Hosier et al. 1981). Driving directly above or over incubating egg
clutches or on the beach can cause sand compaction, which may result in adverse impacts on nest
site selection, digging behavior, clutch viability, and emergence by hatchlings, as well as directly
kill pre-emergent hatchlings (Mann 1977, Nelson and Dickerson 1987, Nelson 1988).
The physical changes and loss of plant cover caused by vehicles on vegetated areas or dunes can
lead to various degrees of instability and cause dune migration. As vehicles move over the sand,
sand is displaced downward, lowering the substrate. Since the vehicles also inhibit plant growth,
and open the area to wind erosion, the beach and dunes may become unstable. Vehicular traffic
on the beach or through dune breaches or low dunes may cause acceleration of overwash and
erosion (Godfrey et al. 1978). Driving along the beachfront should be between the low and high
tide water lines. To minimize the impacts to the beach, dunes, and dune vegetation, transport
and access to the construction sites should be from the road to the maximum extent possible.
However, if vehicular access to the beach is necessary, the areas for vehicle and equipment usage
should be limited to intertidal areas below the most recent high tide line to minimize impacts to
dune vegetation and sand compaction.
Missed Nests
During construction, direct mortality of the developing embryos in nests within the project area
may occur for nests that are missed and not relocated. The exact number of these missed nests is
not known. However, in two separate monitoring programs on the east coast of Florida where
hand digging was performed to confirm the presence of nests and thus reduce the chance of
missing nests through misinterpretation, trained observers still missed about six to eight percent
of the nests because of natural elements (Martin 1992, Ernest and Martin 1993). This must be
considered a conservative number because missed nests are not always accounted for. In another
study, Schroeder (1994) found that even under the best of conditions, about seven percent of
nests can be misidentified as false crawls by highly experienced sea turtle nest surveyors.
Missed nests are usually identified by signs of hatchling emergences in areas where no nest was
previously documented. Signs of hatchling emergence are very easily obliterated by the same
elements that interfere with detection of nests.
Nest Relocation
Besides the potential for missing nests during surveys, there is a potential for eggs to be damaged
by nest relocation, particularly if eggs are not relocated within 12 hours of deposition (Limpus et
al. 1979). Relocated nests can incubate at different temperatures than nests left to incubate in
place (in situ) (Mrosovosky and Yntema 1980, Hoekert et al. 1998, Başkale and Kaska 2005,
Tuttle 2007, Bimbi 2009, Tuttle and Rostal 2010, Pintus et al. 2009) and cause skewed sex ratios
(Morreale et al. 1982, Godfrey et al. 1997). Relocated nests can also have higher or lower hatch
Page 160 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
56
success and hatchling emergence than in situ nests (Wyneken et al. 1988, Hoekert et al. 1998,
García et al. 2003, Moody 2000, Kornaraki et al. 2006, Tuttle 2007, McElroy 2009, Pintus et al.
2009) depending on relocation technique and environmental conditions.
Nest relocation can have adverse impacts on gas exchange parameters and the hydric
environment of nests (Limpus et al. 1979, Ackerman 1980, Parmenter 1980, Spotila et al. 1983,
McGehee 1990). Nests relocated into sands deficient in oxygen or moisture can result in
mortality, morbidity, and reduced behavioral competence of hatchlings. Water availability is
known to influence the incubation environment of the embryos and hatchlings of turtles with
flexible-shelled eggs, which has been shown to affect nitrogen excretion (Packard et al. 1984),
mobilization of calcium (Packard and Packard 1986), mobilization of yolk nutrients (Packard et
al. 1985), hatchling size (Packard et al. 1981, McGehee 1990), energy reserves in the yolk at
hatching (Packard et al. 1988), and locomotory ability of hatchlings (Miller et al. 1987).
Increased Susceptibility to Catastrophic Events
Nest relocation within a nesting season may concentrate eggs in an area making them more
susceptible to catastrophic events. Hatchlings released from concentrated areas also may be
subject to greater predation rates from both land and marine predators because the predators
learn where to concentrate their efforts (Glenn 1998, Wyneken et al. 1998).
Changes in the Physical Environment
Poor quality material can alter nest success by altering moisture content and gas exchange
(Limpus et al. 1979, Ackerman 1980, Parmenter 1980, Spotila et al. 1983, McGehee 1990).
Additionally, the use of heavy machinery can cause sand compaction (Nelson et al. 1987, Nelson
and Dickerson 1988a). Significant reductions in nesting success (i.e., false crawls occurred more
frequently) have been documented on severely compacted beaches (Fletemeyer 1980, Raymond
1984, Nelson and Dickerson 1987, Nelson et al. 1987), and increased false crawls may result in
increased physiological stress to nesting females.
Escarpment Formation
Escarpments may develop on beaches between groins as the beaches equilibrate to their final
profiles. Escarpments can hamper or prevent access to nesting sites (Nelson and Blihovde 1998)
and can cause adult females to choose unsuitable nesting areas, such as seaward of an
escarpment. These nest sites commonly receive prolonged tidal inundation and erosion, which
results in nest failure.
6.1.4. Critical Habitat for the Piping Plover
The Heel project area, which overlaps with Unit SC-15 (Figure 6-1), contains sheltered flats and
runnels known to provide higher quality foraging habitat due to the benthic community
composition of these microhabitats (Tweel et al. 2023). Benthic recruitment and community
composition following project construction will be dependent on sediment characteristics.
Timeframes projected for benthic recruitment and re-establishment following typical beach
Page 161 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
57
nourishment projects can range between six months to two years (Thrush et al. 1996, Peterson et
al. 2000, Zajac and Whitlatch 2003, Bishop et al. 2006, Peterson et al. 2006) depending on
sediment composition and timing of construction. Benthic recruitment is expected to take a
minimum of six months to occur. Even after benthic recruitment occurs, the benthic community
composition and abundance may vary due to microhabitat changes, which could lower foraging
habitat quality.
The project is anticipated to temporarily create roosting habitat above the high tide line and
impact foraging habitat below the high tide line along 3,000 linear feet of shoreline by reducing
the quality of PBFs within the project footprint overlapping Unit SC-15. This Opinion includes
reasonable and prudent measures that minimize the incidental take of piping plovers.
Figure 6-1. Piping plover critical habitat boundary and eBird database hot spot locations
with maximum observation numbers as of August 4, 2023 (CEG 2023).
6.1.5. Critical Habitat for the Rufa Red Knot (Proposed)
The Heel and Fish Haul project areas overlap with Unit SC-22 (Figure 6-2) and construction
activities will temporarily impact foraging habitat by reducing the quality of some of the PBFs.
Benthic recruitment and community composition following project construction will be
dependent on sediment characteristics. Timeframes projected for benthic recruitment and re-
establishment following typical beach nourishment projects can range between six months to two
years (Thrush et al. 1996, Peterson et al. 2000, Zajac and Whitlatch 2003, Bishop et al. 2006,
Peterson et al. 2006) depending on sediment composition and timing of construction. Benthic
recruitment is expected to take a minimum of six months to occur. Even after benthic
Page 162 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
58
recruitment occurs, the benthic community composition and abundance may vary due to
microhabitat changes, which could lower foraging habitat quality.
The project is anticipated to temporarily create roosting habitat above the high tide line and
impact foraging habitat below the high tide line along 7,410 linear feet of shoreline by reducing
the quality of PBFs within the project footprint overlapping Unit SC-22. This Opinion includes
reasonable and prudent measures that minimize the incidental take of rufa red knots.
Figure 6-2. Rufa red knot proposed critical habitat boundary and eBird database hot spot
locations with maximum observation numbers as of August 4, 2023 (CEG 2023).
6.2. Effects of Breakwater Construction
6.2.1. Piping Plover
Beneficial Effects
Breakwater construction is anticipated to extend the life of the sand placement project and is
anticipated to create sheltered foraging habitat conducive to piping plover preferred prey items
(Tweel et al. 2023).
Adverse Effects
In addition to the adverse effects described in Section 6.1.1., breakwater construction will
destroy 1.1 acres of foraging habitat and result in high mortality of benthic infauna during
construction (CEG 2024).
Page 163 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
59
6.2.2. Rufa Red Knot
In addition to the adverse effects described in Section 6.2.1., breakwater construction will
destroy 1.1 acres of foraging habitat and result in high mortality of benthic infauna during
construction (CEG 2024).
6.2.3. Loggerhead Sea Turtle
Beneficial Effects
Breakwater construction in conjunction with sand placement that is designed to extend the life of
the sand placement project may benefit sea turtles more than an eroding beach it replaces.
Adverse Effects
Potential adverse effects during the breakwater construction phase include disturbance of
existing nests, which may have been missed by surveyors and thus not marked for avoidance,
disturbance of females attempting to nest, and disorientation of emerging hatchlings. In addition,
heavy equipment will be required to construct the breakwaters. This equipment will have to
traverse the beach portion of the Action Area, which could result in harm to nesting sea turtles,
their nests, and emerging hatchlings.
Many of the direct effects of shoreline stabilization projects may persist over time and become
indirect impacts. These indirect effects include increased susceptibility of relocated nests to
catastrophic events, changes in the physical characteristics of the beach, and the formation of
escarpments.
6.2.4. Critical Habitat for the Piping Plover
Breakwater construction will occur outside of designated critical habitat. Therefore, no adverse
effects are anticipated.
6.2.5. Critical Habitat for the Rufa Red Knot (Proposed)
Breakwater construction along the shoreline of Pine Island is outside of proposed critical habitat
unit. Therefore, no adverse effects are anticipated.
7. CUMULATIVE EFFECTS
The implementing regulations for section 7 define cumulative effects to include the effects of
future State or private activities that are reasonably certain to occur within the action area of the
federal action subject to consultation (50 CFR 402.02). Future federal actions that are unrelated
to the proposed action are not considered in this section because they require separate
consultation pursuant to section 7 of the Act.
“Cumulative effects are those effects of future State or private activities, not involving federal
activities, that are reasonably certain to occur within the action area of the federal action subject
Page 164 of 222
Chelsea Fannin, Project Manager
Hilton Head Island-wide and Pine Island Beach Renourishment Project 2023-0091041
60
to consultation” (50 CFR §402.02). Additional regulations at 50 CFR §402.17(a) identify factors
to consider when determining whether activities are reasonably certain to occur. These factors
include, but are not limited to: existing plans for the activity; and any remaining economic,
administrative, and legal requirements necessary for the activity to go forward.
In its request for consultation, the Corps did not describe, and the Service is not aware of, any
future non-federal activities that were not already considered and that are reasonably certain to
occur within the Action Area. Therefore, we anticipate no cumulative effects that we must
consider in formulating our opinion for the Action.
8. CONCLUSION
The Service concludes that the proposed
Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.