Design Review Board Meeting — Minutes
Town of Hilton Head Island · Beaufort County · Design Review Board · meeting of Nov 12, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Hilton Head Island
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
11/12/2024 Page | 1
Town of Hilton Head Island
DESIGN REVIEW BOARD MEETING
Tuesday, November 12, 2024, 2:30 PM
Minutes
1. Call to Order
This meeting was called to order at 2:30 p.m. All members were present.
2. Adoption of the Agenda
Ms. Lippert moved to change the order of the Agenda to review Board business first. Ms.
Fitzpatrick seconded. The Motion was approved unanimously.
3. Approval of the Minutes
a. Regular Meeting Minutes of October 22, 2024.
Ms. Lippert moved to approve the meeting minutes of October 22, 2024. Ms. Pastor
seconded. The meeting minutes were approved unanimously.
4. Unfinished Business
a. DRB-001466-2024 - 59 Pope Avenue - The Pavilion at The Bank - Final
Chair Carstens handed the gavel to Ms. Lippert, recused himself, and left the dais. Trey
Lowe, Development Services Manager gave an update and answered questions from the
Board. The discussion centered on the proposed pavilions designed to provide shelter
from rain in the whiskey bar area. Staff recommended approval with the condition that the
pavilion colors match the existing entry and that any additional information required by the
Board be provided.
Sarah Kepple of Pearce Scott Architects presented updates to the original design. A key
change involved reducing the number of sides of the pavilion from ten to eight. Board
members discussed various aspects of the proposal. Ms. Fitzpatrick requested that cable
boxes for the mounted televisions in the bar area be concealed and raised questions
about lighting options. Ms. Pastor noted that the large-screen televisions were not
approved during the previous meeting and emphasized that any approval today would not
include them without further staff review. Additional discussions between Ms. Lippert and
Mr. Theodore addressed the building’s revised rotation and other design details, including
the prohibition of neon signage.
Ms. Pastor made a Motion to approve the project with conditions: the approval does not
include the large-screen televisions or neon lighting; the existing televisions should be
relocated to interior posts; the pavilion should be rotated to align with the entry if feasible;
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
11/12/2024 Page | 2
and all cable boxes and conduits must be concealed. Ms. Fitzpatrick seconded the
Motion, which was approved unanimously.
b. DRB-001479-2024 - 40 Harriet Tubman Way - Archeology Research Facility - Final
Chair Carstens returned to the Dias. Mr. Lippert returned the gavel to Chair Carstens.
Trey Lowe, Development Services Manager, introduced the proposal for a new
archeology research facility, presenting it for final review. Staff recommended approval
with conditions, including providing the case manager with the approved Design Review
Board (DRB) plans and any additional information required by the Board. Following the
initial concept presentation and the Board's recommendations, the applicant made
several updates, including adding a mechanical roof screen at the rear flat roof, extending
the bracket detail to the side porch columns, refining the site lighting, and providing a
color front elevation. The applicant is also exploring a water collection system for the
gutters. The exterior colors are shades inspired by Mitchelville’s brand palette.
Sarah Kepple of Pearce Scott Architects presented the updated design. The Board
members raised questions and concerns about several elements, including the color
palette (particularly the bright blue), the parking lot, monument signage, roof and roof
screen, irrigation and rain collection system, gutters, porch design, sidewalks and their
lighting, porch lighting, landscaping plans, plant sizes, potential wing walls for the
condensers, facade options, buffer materials, and the need for a physical material and
color board. The Board also requested a full lighting cut sheet with details on lighting
color, a material color board, a solution for exposed conduits, and specifics on the wall
material and trim.
After an extensive discussion, the Board decided to table the application until the
December 10th meeting, or until the applicant can provide additional details.
5. New Business
a. DRB-001465-2024 - 75 Dillon Road - Fire & Rescue Headquarters Classroom
Building - Conceptual
Trey Lowe, Development Services Manager, introduced the conceptual proposal for a
Fire Rescue Headquarters classroom building. The facility is designed to provide
firefighters with a dedicated training space for firefighting, medical emergencies, and
technical or hazardous materials training. The proposed structure is a pre-engineered
building. Staff recommended approval of the conceptual submission with conditions,
including providing dimensional details and sections, a utility plan with screened utilities
shown on the site plan, an exterior lighting plan, an updated landscape plan to enhance
the property, an 11x17 material and color board, and any additional information required
by the Board.
During the meeting, applicant Dale Strecker responded to questions from the Board. The
Board raised concerns about the building’s color palette and the proposed landscape
plan. Following the discussion, Ms. Lippert made a Motion to approve the project with
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
11/12/2024 Page | 3
several conditions: the exterior lighting plan must be included, a study should determine if
a tree can be added for screening from the recycling facility, the color palette should be
revised (excluding white), perimeter landscaping is not required for this project,
overhangs should be added above the main doors, and the north facade should be
activated with potential windows. Mr. Parker seconded. The Motion was approved
unanimously.
b. DRB-001481-2024 - 1014 William Hilton Parkway - Local Legend - Mural
Chair Carstens handed the gavel to Ms. Lippert before he and Mr. Parker recused
themselves and left the dais. Trey Lowe, Development Services Manager, introduced the
Local Legend Mural for final approval. Staff recommended approval on the condition that
paint samples be provided along with any additional information required by the Board.
Alan Wold from Serg Group, the applicant, presented the mural’s historical, cultural, and
local significance, highlighting changes made since the previous Design Review Board
(DRB) meeting. He also shared examples of other murals and public art with text from
around the island.
A lengthy discussion ensued between the Board and Mr. Wold regarding whether the text
on the mural classified it as a sign rather than a mural. Using the Land Management
Ordinance (LMO) as a reference, the Board concluded that the project fell into a "grey
zone" due to the lack of a clear definition for murals within the LMO. While the Town had
previously determined that the project was not a sign, the absence of a formal definition
left the issue unresolved. The Board asked the applicant to consider shrinking or
removing the text from the mural, but after further discussion, the applicant chose to
withdraw the application to consult internally and with the Town.
The Board suggested that Town staff seek guidance from the Town Attorney to interpret
and clarify the definition of a mural under the LMO.
6. Public Comment - Non Agenda Items
None.
7. Board Business
Ms. Lippert raised questions and concerns regarding quorum requirements when recusals are
involved and the process for making a Motion. For a quorum, at least four out of the six Board
members must be present and actively voting. If there is a tie in voting, the Motion is
automatically disapproved. In cases where a tie is anticipated, the applicant has the option to
either withdraw their application before the vote or return to present the application again after
six months. However, the applicant may re-present their application sooner if there are
significant changes to the project.
It was clarified that for any Motion to be approved, at least three Board members must vote in
favor.
The Board requested clarification from staff on whether the Board member who initially makes
Town of Hilton Head Island Design Review Board
Meeting Minutes
11/12/2024 Page | 4
a Motion (with or without conditions) must vote to approve the Motion, or if they may make a
Motion for denial. They also asked for clarification on whether a Board member's original
Motion can be modified if new information arises during discussions about conditions in the
final approval process.
8. Staff Reports
None.
9. Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 6:05 p.m.
Approved: November 26, 2024
The recording of this Meeting can be found on the Town’s website
at www.hiltonheadislandsc.gov
Source: Town of Hilton Head Island website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.