August 1 (PDF, 15.33 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PERSONNEL COMMITTEE
9:00 a.m., Thursday, August 1, 2013
The regular meeting of the Personnel Committee was held at 9:00 a.m., Thursday, August 1,
2013 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmember Bette lli and Stone, Chair Thomas, Assistant to the
Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Thomas called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meetings’ Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of May 7, 2013 and the Special Meeting of July 22, 2013 as submitted;
Councilmember Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Old Business – None
5. New Business
A. Commendation for Fire Department Personnel
Fire Chief Ann Graham read into the minutes the circumstances of June 30, 2013 that led to the
commendations being awarded today; a copy of her comments is attached to the historical
record of the meeting. She further explained that recognition for their actions is being made at
the Personnel Committee today because today is the last day of IOP employment for one (1)
recipient. The Fire Department personnel who were recognized received a standing ovation
from the members of the Committee and fellow firefighters who were present. Captain Roger
Eagle, Firefighters Dana McLoughlin and Tyler Richardson, Engineers Dana Burnette, Chris
Puckhaber, Trevor Speelman and Chris Fassos and Paramedic Greg Samuelson were awarded
Meritorious Team Commendations for their actions, and, additionally, Dana McLoughlin and
Tyler Richardson were awarded Meritorious Act of Valor plaques for their actions.
Councilmember Stone thanked not only the personnel who were recognized at the meeting, but
all of the fire personnel who were present for the job they do to protect the residents and visitors
of the Isle of Palms.
B. Discussion of Staffing in the Fire Department
Assistant Dziuban explained that this subject was initially discussed in the Public Safety
Committee and that Chief Graham had been urged to make a presentation to the Personnel
Committee to begin the process to effect changes.
Chief Graham recalled that, when the presentation was made on the Quick Response Vehicle
(QRV), she had pointed out that a shift for the Isle of Palms is made up of nine (9) personnel –
four (4) at Station 2 and five (5) at Station 1. The Chief reported that a strain in placed on
personnel at Station 2 who are required to multi-task more than Station 1 personnel; the level of
Personnel Committee
August 1, 2013
Page 2 of 3
multi-tasking has led to a sense that personnel are less safe than those at Station 1. Personnel
at larger departments, like the City of Charle ston, North Charleston and West Ashley, are highly
specialized in their job responsibilities, i.e. Hazmat, firefighter, water rescuer, EMT, etc; the IOP
personnel have to serve in whatever capacity th e call requires. According to NFPA standards,
the IOP Fire Department is understaffed, but Chief Graham does not believe that staffing at
those maximum levels would improve the safety of the island’s residents or visitors. The Chief
stated that she would like to see three (3) additional firefighters, one (1) per shift, to be hired for
Station 2; in her opinion, that addition will take much of the strain off Station 2.
Councilmember Stone noted that the residents of the island get an insurance rate reduction
based on the Fire Department’s ISO rating; he asked if adding personnel would improve the
island’s ISO rating. He indicated that the residents would favorably view the additional
personnel costs if they were to see their insurance rates decrease as a result. Chief Graham
stated that she does not see that happening based on increasing personnel; the City’s current
rating is three (3) on a scale of one to ten (1-10) with one (1) being the best.
According to the Chief, the wear-and-tear on the ladder truck at Station 2 would be reduced,
because the Captain could now ride in the pickup truck to assist with a medical call, and the
added safety factor for personnel would also reduce the amount of time lost from work if
someone is injured.
According to national standards, fifteen (15) personnel should respond to a J.C. Long-type
structure fire; Isle of Palms’ fire responds with nine (9). With the elevated houses on the island,
there is an excessive overhead hazard which increases the number of firefighters expected to
respond; excessive square footage increases the number needed even more.
Chief Graham stated, “We have some exceptional personnel which we are losing at a very rapid
rate.” She indicated that one (1) reason the Department is not keeping personnel is the safety
factor, and, as the surrounding departments become more and more safe, IOP personnel are
being drawn away.
The second issue that is causing fire personnel to seek employment elsewhere is the fact that
the City’s pay scale is not keeping up with surrounding local governments, and, where in the
past the City could attract personnel from other local departments, those local departments are
now recruiting our trained personnel with higher wages. Captain Jason Smith reported that
City’s entry level pay for a firefighter today is the same as the hourly wage of a firefighter that
was hired eighteen (18) months ago and has seven (7) years of field experience. Chief Graham
noted that, in many cases, the merit increase may not be equal to the increase in the cost of
living for any given year.
Councilmember Stone noted that Council has approved a merit pool of three percent (3%) for
the past several years and was under the impression that all employees were getting a three
percent (3%) increase. Assistant Dziuban explained that Treasurer Suggs calculates three per-
cent (3%) of a department’s salary budget; the figure is communicated to the department mana-
ger, who then distributes that amount to the department’s personnel as he/she deems appropri-
ate.
Personnel Committee
August 1, 2013
Page 3 of 3
The fiscal impact of adding three (3) firefighters, one (1) per shift, for Station 2 will be one
hundred twenty-two thousand dollars ($122,000) including benefits and an additional nine
thousand dollars ($9,000) for their gear for a total of one hundred thirty-one thousand dollars
($131,000). To fully train a firefighter fresh out of the fire academy in real life firefighting,
medical training and water rescues takes about thr ee (3) years according to Captain Smith; at
this moment, the City does not have a firefighter than has hit that three-year (3 yr.) benchmark.
Chief Graham stated that she believes that the City has been very fortunate with the new fire-
fighters that have been hired; the concern now is how to keep them here.
Assistant Dziuban summarized the discussion by stating that the Fire Department has
presented two (2) issues to the Committee; they are the need for one (1) additional firefighter
per shift for Station 2 and the need for wage equity with neighboring municipalities. They will be
coming before the Committee in future months with specific requests.
C. Discussion of 2014 Appointments to Boards and Commissions
Assistant Dziuban reported that the advertisement for 2014 appointments to boards and
commissions has appeared in both The Island Eye and The Moultrie News, and the notice has
been added to the City’s website. Included in the meeting packet was the list of boards and
commissions members with the expiring terms noted in red; the ATAX Committee has four (4)
expiring terms, the Board of Zoning Appeals and Code Board of Appeals each have two (2) ex-
piring terms and the Planning Commission has three (3) expiring terms. The Assistant noted
that all members with expiring terms have been a sked whether they are willing to be considered
for reappointment, and the people who are in the candidate pool have been asked whether they
want to remain in the pool for consideration for 2014. Applications will be accepted through the
month of August; if the response is less than desired, the time can be extended. Dates for
interviews with new applicants will be discussed at the September meeting.
6. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 9:00 a.m., Thursday, September 5, 2013 in the Conference Room.
7. Executive Session – not needed
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to adjourn the meeting at 10:01 a.m.;
Councilmember Stone seconded and the MOTION PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie B. Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.