November 4 (PDF, 20.91 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PERSONNEL COMMITTEE
9:00 a.m., Monday, November 4, 2013
The regular meeting of the Personnel Committee was held at 9:00 a.m. on Monday, November
4, 2013 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmember Stone and Bettelli, Chair Thomas, Administrator
Tucker, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present
to conduct business.
1. Chair Thomas called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of October 3, 2013 as submitted; Councilmember Stone seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Old Business
Further analysis of regional Fire Department salary and benefit comparisons
As the discussions began, Administrator Tucker distributed again the salary comparison data
that was presented at the October meeting, and Chief Graham distributed a more detailed
analysis prepared for this meeting; copies of the handouts are attached to the historical record
of the meeting. In the new handout, the schedule on the first page compared Isle of Palms’
entry level wages for firefighter, engineer, captain and battalion chief with the City of Charleston,
St. John’s Fire District, Sullivan’s Island, North Charleston, Mount Pleasant and Charleston
County EMTs; it also indicated whether the local governments give cost of living, merit and/or
longevity increases. Since both Mount Pleasant and North Charleston offer EMT bonuses and
since most IOP firefighters are EMTs as well, the bonuses were added into the starting wage for
those two (2) local departments. Administrator Tucker noted that efforts had been made to
make this comparison as equitable as possible, for example all wages have been converted to
reflect the two thousand nine hundred twenty hours (2,920 hrs.) that IOP personnel work in a
year. Chief Graham stated that, of the local governments that pay a cost of living (COLA)
increase “sometimes,” the decision is made on a year-to-year basis; the last cost of living
increase at the Isle of Palms was in 2009. When the IOP entry level firefighter pay is compared
to the average for other departments in the area, the City’s wage for a firefighter is ten percent
(10%) less.
In the subsequent pages of the handout, each municipality that was contacted is individually
compared to the Isle of Palms and the health insurance benefit is added to the equation. The
City of Isle of Palms pays one hundred percent (100%) of the health insurance premium for
employees and fifty percent (50%) for dependents.
In the comparison to the City of Charleston, Administrator Tucker pointed out that Charleston
provides seven (7) annual five percent (5%) “step” raises that occur on an employee’s
anniversary date and are not merit based; in addition, the “steps” follow an employee if they are
Personnel Committee
November 4, 2013
Page 2 of 4
promoted, i.e. a firefighter with three (3) steps promoted to engineer would be paid the starting
salary for an engineer plus three (3) five percent (5%) steps. Although the insurance plans
offered are comparable in benefits offered, Isle of Palms’ fire personnel pay more for depen-
dent health insurance than City of Charleston fire personnel because the City of Charleston
makes a larger contribution toward dependent health insurance coverage than the Isle of Palms.
At the moment, St. John’s Fire District is not only paying its fire personnel higher wages, but it
also offers COLA, merit and longevity increases. A firefighter at the Isle of Palms will contribute
approximately twenty-one hundred dollars ($2,100) more for family health insurance coverage
than employees of St. John’s Fire District.
Starting firefighter salary at Sullivan’s Island is more than four thousand dollars ($4,000) per
year higher than the Isle of Palms; Sullivan’s Island also has both COLA and merit increases.
Sullivan’s Island also provides its employees wi th a wellness benefit of three hundred dollars
($300) for an individual and six hundred dollars ($600) for a family; although few employees
take advantage of the program, employees do like having the benefit.
The City of North Charleston’s entry level wages exceed those of the Isle of Palms from thirty-
two hundred dollars ($3,200) for a firefighter to eight thousand dollars ($8,000) for a battalion
chief. Isle of Palms’ fire personnel pay eight hundred dollars ($800) per year more for
employee/spouse health insurance and two thousand do llars ($2,000) per year for family health
insurance than employees of the North Charleston Fire Department.
Items of note for Mount Pleasant include the fact that employees receive a three percent (3%)
increase upon the successful completion of the six (6) month probationary period; entry level
wages are very comparable to those of the Is le of Palms and only family health insurance
coverage is considerably less than that of the Isle of Palms. Administrator Tucker commented
that the City does not often lose personnel to Mount Pleasant.
Since the majority of Isle of Palms’ firefighters are also EMTs, the starting salary for Charleston
County EMTs was determined to be relevant to the discussion. Of note at Charleston County is
the fact that they provide a longevity increase of three percent (3%) in years one (1), three (3),
five (5), seven (7) and ten (10); the longevity increase moves to six percent (6%) every five (5)
years after ten (10). Isle of Palms’ fire department personnel pay less for health insurance
coverage at every level except family where there is a difference of only one hundred sixty-three
dollars ($163).
The last page of the handout is, in the Administrator’s opinion, the most telling of all; it is here
that a firefighter’s wages are projected out five (5) years in each local government identified and
the average is compared to the Isle of Palms. The assumptions on which this data is based are
as follows:
• Employer starts 1/1/13 as a firefighter.
• Employee works for 3 years as a firefighter and is then promoted to engineer for years 4
and 5.
• Employee performs at a high level.
Personnel Committee
November 4, 2013
Page 3 of 4
• Wage ranges are the amount listed on page 1 with no increase in ranges over the 5-year
period.
• For agencies that give merits, the merits are 3% per year.
• For agencies that give COLAs, the COLAs are 2% per year in years 1, 3 and 5.
• For agencies that give longevity increases, these are included in the computations.
After one (1) year, the Isle of Palms firefighter is making an average of twelve percent (12%)
less than his or her counterpart across the area; the difference increases to fourteen percent
(14%) after three (3) years.
Administrator Tucker pointed out that the merit pool is not large enough to compensate for the
loss of the COLA and for the increases employees are seeing in retirement contributions, taxes
and insurance premiums.
There was some discussion on morale issues in the department, and Chief Graham expressed
the opinion that some of the causes of poor morale have been resolved. One component of the
morale concerns relates directly to the lack of training and experience that Department now has;
Battalion Chief Smith stated that he feels much more anxiety when responding to a call with his
crew of inexperienced firefighters – Is everyone safe? Is someone going to make a mistake? Is
someone going to get injured?
Chief Graham added that the move to Consolidated Dispatch has brought its own set of issues
as personnel become more acquainted with and accustomed to the new operations. At this
time, a call is received and immediately transferred to another channel; the senior person on the
call must go to that new channel in order to get the details of the call while still listening for the
possibility of another call coming in. The Police Department is not required to do this level of
multi-tasking with the radios in the performance of their jobs. Administrator Tucker stated that
the City is working with Consolidated Dispatch and hopes to have a couple of dedicated
channels for all IOP calls before the season begins in 2014.
One (1) additional schedule was distributed that lis ted, by position, Fire Department personnel
who have left beginning in 2010; a copy is attached to the historical record of the meeting.
Included are the dates of hire and termination, salary progression over most current five (5)
years and the reason for leaving.
Councilmember Stone suggested that good information to provide to members of the Ways and
Means Committee would be the dollars spent by the City on training for an employee who has
been with the City five (5), ten (10) or more years, attained rank and then left for another
department. Councilmember Stone added that there are also the “soft” costs associated with
the supervision required for the training. He concluded his comments by voicing his deep
concern that the island will suffer a serious incident due to Council’s inaction on this matter.
5. New Business
Personnel Committee
November 4, 2013
Page 4 of 4
Consideration of 2014 Floating Holiday
Administrator Tucker reported that all Departments had been polled on what the 2014 floating
holiday should be, and the date with the highest vote total was Friday, December 26, 2014.
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to name Friday, December 26, 2014
as the 2014 floating holiday; Councilmember Stone seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
6. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 9:00 a.m., Thursday, January 9, 2014 in the Conference Room.
7. Executive Session – not needed
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Bettelli moved to adjourn the meeting at 10:05 a.m.;
Councilmember Stone seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.