January 8 (PDF, 22.24 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE
5:00 p.m., Tuesday, January 8, 2013
City Hall Conference Room
The regular meeting of the Public Safety Committee was held at 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, January 8,
2013 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Bergwerf and Bettelli, Mayor Cronin, City
Administrator Tucker, Fire Chief Graham, Police Chief Buckhannon, Attorney Halversen,
Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to
conduct business.
1. Administrator Tucker called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and
public had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Election of Chair and Vice Chair
Mayor Cronin nominated Councilmember Bette lli for Chair and Councilmember Bergwerf as
Vice Chair; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the nomination passed unanimously.
3. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve the minutes of the regular meeting
of November 7, 2012 as submitted; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Citizens’ Comments
Turtle Lessons Project Presented by Members of the Turtle Team
Ann Bauer and Catherine Malloy represented the Turtle Team to describe this initiative by the
Isle of Palms/Sullivan’s Island Turtle Team. The goal of the program is to educate island
children ten (10) years of age and younger on the nesting habits of the loggerhead turtles and
beach environmental issues. The details of the ev ent are in the literature submitted to the
Committee and attached to the historical record of the meeting.
Mayor Cronin asked if this program had been offered in the past; Mrs. Bauer responded that
Folly Beach Turtle Team has held very successful events over the past couple of years.
Councilmember Bergwerf indicated that this event would have no impact on police and/or fire
departments.
Chair Bettelli commented that the Turtle Team did not plan to advertise this event too widely;
they were seeking to educate primarily the children of Isle of Palms and Sullivan’s Island
through the school and the Recreation Department e-newsletter.
5. Old Business
A. Status of Consultant’s Work on Beach Access Parking
Rick Day of Stantec was present to inform the Committee of their progress.
Public Safety Committee
January 8, 2013
Page 2 of 6
Mr. Day reminded the Committee that Stantec is working on two (2) different, but related, issues
for the City; they are wayfinding signs and beach access parking. On the issue of signage, Mr.
Day reported that they have inventoried the island’s signs and developed a plan of the elements
to be included in the island-wide wayfinding program. They have also been provided positive
guidance on parking in the core Front Beach area; this concept has been submitted to SCDOT
for review and permitting. Stantec anticipates the placement of signage before the coming
tourist season.
Stantec personnel have also reviewed Planning Commission minutes, Council minutes and the
minutes of citizens’ forums on the topic of parking on the island in the tourist season. They
have come up with a list of ideas – some new, some old and some tweaked – to present to City
staff and Council for consideration; Mr. Day added that none of the ideas are going to be easy.
Stantec staff will present their ideas to staff to ensure they are on the right path prior to
presenting to this Committee or City Council.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked how soon Stantec would be proceeding with meetings with
staff on parking; Mr. Day responded that he hopes to have the wayfinding signs in place before
the season begins. Administrator Tucker remarked that the installation of signs is dependent
upon how quickly SCDOT approves the plan.
On the subject of parking, Mr. Day indicated that Stantec wants to have several viable strategies
to present to City Council for consideration and debate; whatever approaches are deemed
worthy of consideration by the City’s leadership will then be presented to the citizenry for input.
B. Update on Consolidated Dispatch
Administrator Tucker reported that a ribbon cutting for the new building will take place later in
the month; in addition, the City has begun to use the same system that is used at the
Consolidated Dispatch Center (CDC). In doing so, some of the reasons for the difficulties other
users have pointed to have been seen firsthand.
Mayor Cronin distributed a handout that, to his understanding, was provided to Mount Pleasant
by the Consolidated Dispatch staff; the information is an illustration of how calls are routed
through the dispatch center depending on the seriousness of the call. The route of the call is
determined by the CDC call taker, and the call is only passed to the actual dispatcher when the
call taker has gotten all of the information he/she is required to get.
Administrator Tucker informed the Committee that she had gotten real-life experience with the
CDC when she and her husband were recently involv ed in a minor traffic accident in North
Charleston. Due to her expressed concern over the impending transition, she requested and
has received a copy of the recording of the call between her and the CDC to educate residents
about the changes that are to come. The Administrator explained that the call taker has a pre-
determined set of questions, which adhere to a national standard, that must be answered and
must be answered in order – no questions can be skipped, and they cannot be taken out of
order. The Administrator was not told assistance was on the way until all of the information was
gathered and that took six (6) minutes. Administrator Tucker did note that she had told the call
taker immediately that the accident was minor and that no one appeared to be injured.
Public Safety Committee
January 8, 2013
Page 3 of 6
Chief Buckhannon explained that, since the Administrator had stated that the accident was
minor, the call may have been assigned a less urgent call type resulting in other, more critical
calls being responded to first, or the call volume may have been so great that the response was
delayed. Councilmember Bergwerf stated that she was under the impression that, once the
address was confirmed, assistance was dispatched to the scene; Chief Buckhannon reiterated
that calls with the highest priority were responded to first.
Administrator Tucker voiced the opinion that an important message to both residents and visi-
tors was to be as calm and patient as possible when calling 911; the call takers have a protocol
they must follow exactly – frustration on the par t of the caller will only serve to slow the
response.
Chair Bettelli reiterated the need for every house on the island to have house numbers both
inside near the telephone and outside easily seen from the street.
Mayor Cronin indicated that listening to the Administrator’s 911 call has served to generate
more questions, and he would like to have repr esentatives of the Charleston County Consoli-
dated Dispatch Center come to a meeting soon to respond.
Chief Buckhannon stated that the ribbon-cutting will be Thursday, January 24
th and that Mount
Pleasant will be transitioning in February 2013.
6. New Business
Discussion of SCDOT Documentation Related to 52
nd Avenue and Other Roads
Administrator Tucker introduced Robert Clark, District Engineering Administrator, and Beacham
Brooker, Jr., Assistant Chief Counsel, with SCDOT; the Administrator asked that they explain
how the determination is made that a road belongs to IOP, SCDOT or otherwise, specifically the
situation with 52
nd Avenue.
Mr. Brooker unrolled three (3) maps that show the Isle of Palms and its roads. He explained
that secondary highways in the state come from various acts in the 1940s and 1950s that tell
SCDOT to take in roads from the county road systems; counties got the roads through dedica-
tions or long-time public use, referred to as “prescriptive public rights.” According to Mr.
Brooker, 52
nd Avenue was originally constructed by The Beach Company and platted as a road;
SCDOT has not seen any documentation from the Beach Company dedicating it to Charleston
County as a public road and asking them to maintain it. SCDOT has maintained 52 nd Avenue
for the past twenty (20) years; therefore, they are not required to find an express dedication, but
have a prescriptive right. He indicated that Mr . Clark’s staff has an extensive stack of regular
maintenance reports for 52nd Avenue, which will be vital should residents try to litigate that it is a
private road.
Responding to Mayor Cronin’s question about number of years of maintenance history that
exists, Mr. Clark stated that maintenance records are kept for seven (7) years.
Public Safety Committee
January 8, 2013
Page 4 of 6
Administrator Tucker explained that the 52nd Avenue HOA has obtained a quitclaim deed for the
road and signage has been installed indicating the road is private. She inquired about what the
next step for SCDOT would be.
Mr. Clark commented that the PRIVATE ROAD signs are down and SCDOT maintains that 52
nd
Avenue is part of the state road system; he indicated that it is unlawful to place signs in the
public right-of-way without permission.
On the subject of the quitclaim deed, Mr. Brooker stated that a deed is relative to the land under
the road and that the road encumbers the land; he noted that deeding and the status of the
public road are separate issues.
In the Administrator’s opinion, the deed should refer to both the land under the road and the
road itself; she expressed the opinion that the quitclaim could carry more weight than the
possible existence of maintenance records on the road.
Mr. Brooker said that it was 1968 before SCDOT began to condemn and buy land for roads.
Mayor Cronin asked whether the City had the right to construct a stormwater system under the
road through land that SCDOT does not own; according to Mr. Brooker public utilities are
allowed as a matter of right-to-locate in the public right-of-way being considered a public use for
a public road.
On the subject of the quitclaim deed, Chief Buckhannon questioned how it affected the land
along the side of the road where people park. Mr. Brooker remarked that the extent of a right-
of-way or public easement for roadside parking is a use that the City needs; therefore, public
rights extend to that use. In addition, Mr. Brooker stated that town and cities in the state have
the right to regulate parking on public highways within their boundaries.
Attorney Halversen asked for a clarification on SCDOT’s stance on the abandonment of roads,
under what circumstances would an abandonment occu r, and whether or not the City would be
notified if an abandonment were contemplated by SCDOT.
Mr. Brooker indicated that SCDOT does not abandon roads at all; SCDOT will only remove a
road from the state highway system and the road automatically falls, as a matter of law, under
the jurisdiction of the local municipality.
Attorney Halversen followed up by asking, if SCDOT chose not maintain a road and take it out
of the state road system, whether or not the City would be notified. In that case, the road would
be turned over to the City.
Mayor Cronin noted that there are many roads on the island that are not in the SCDOT system,
but the County paves them for the City and the Isle of Palms maintains them. Despite these
facts, the residents of these streets contend they are private.
Public Safety Committee
January 8, 2013
Page 5 of 6
On a related subject, Administrator Tucker recalled a discussion she had with Mr. Clark relative
to the differences in the treatment of encroachments in the right-of-way based on when roads
were accepted into the system.
Mr. Clark stated that, when SCDOT builds or im proves a road, it frequently gets a municipal
agreement that indicates the municipality wants the work done and the municipality will assist
SCDOT to ensure that no unpermitted encroachments are placed in the right-of-way. For
instance, when Palm Boulevard was widened, a municipal agreement was signed between the
City and SCDOT, but the same is likely not the case for many of the secondary roads on the
island which may have been constructed before there was a city. The Administrator
summarized that for the roads covered by a municipal agreement, the City can enforce
unpermitted encroachments, but, on the secondary roads, enforcement falls to SCDOT. The
Mayor asked if would be possible to get a municipal agreement to cover the secondary roads on
the island, and Mr. Brooker expressed the belief that it could. Mr. Clark suggested generating a
document that would delegate or ask for assistance in policing unpermitted encroachments in
the rights-of-way to the City.
Councilmember Bergwerf repeated that SCDOT maintains that 52
nd Avenue is not a private
road; therefore, the IOP Police Department can ticket illegally parked cars and that PRIVATE
ROAD and NO PARKING signs cannot be placed along 52
nd Avenue.
7. Highlights of Departmental Reports
Fire Department – Chief Graham
Due to time constraints, Chief Graham concentrated her report on the month of December.
Included in the report for the first time was the response time report using the CAD system that
ties into the CDC; the Chief explained that the ca lls are prioritized using Alpha, least serious, to
Bravo, Charlie and Delta, most serious. Personnel responded to fifty-five (55) total calls in
December; thirty-four (34) calls were for EM S. For the year, personnel responded to nine
hundred sixty (960) calls, responded to five hundred twenty-five (525) medical calls and treated
five hundred eighty-five (585) patients. Engineer Puckhaber completed the Basic EMS course.
Fire Inspector Ryan Kunitzer has joined the Lowcountry Investigation Team that will afford him
experience in fire investigations that he would not get on the Isle of Palms.
Mayor Cronin commended the Fire Department for the work with the helicopter/aquatic rescue
team training that took place on the island over the weekend involving volunteers from all over
the state. Chief Graham stated that she has gotten only positive feedback on the event,
including indications from the County Park and the participating agencies that they would like to
repeat the exercise at IOP.
The Mayor noted that Chief Graham will be attending the 2013 National Hurricane Conference
and suggested that questions be fed to her for answers at the conference.
Police Department – Chief Buckhannon
Public Safety Committee
January 8, 2013
Page 6 of 6
Chief Buckhannon indicated that December had been a rough month for the Department related
to burglaries and larcenies; on one (1) evening there were four (4) petit larcenies on boats, six
(6) thefts from vehicles, and four (4) burglaries - a total of nine (9) burglaries for the month. On
the night this occurred, officers developed a suspect, who has since been charged with, at least,
one (1) of the car break-ins; officers also have suspects in the burglaries that occurred, particu-
larly those on Palm Boulevard. Dispatchers responded to thirty-five hundred forty-four (3,544)
calls; twenty-nine hundred eighty-six (2,986) were for the Police Department. For 2012,
dispatchers responded to fifty-two thousand two hundred twenty-seven calls (52,227); forty-one
thousand three hundred twenty (41,320) for the Police Department, an increase of ten percent
(10%) over 2011.
The Chief noted that one (1) officer has completed three (3) weeks at the academy, and a
second officer will begin in March; the Department is also down two (2) dispatchers.
8. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 5:00 p.m., Tuesday, February 12, 2013 in the Conference Room.
9. Executive Session to receive legal advice relating to potential legal claims – not held
10. Adjourn
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to adjourn the meeting at 6:02 p.m.;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.