July 9 (PDF, 26.05 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Public Safety Committee
5:00 p.m., Tuesday, July 9, 2013
The regular meeting of the Public Safety Committee was held at 5:00 p.m. on Tuesday, July 9,
2013 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmember Bergwerf, Mayor Cronin, Chair Bettelli, City
Administrator Tucker, Fire Chief Graham, Police Chief Buckhannon, Assistant to the
Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Bettelli called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public
had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to approve the minutes of the regular meeting
of June 5, 2013 as submitted; Councilmember Bergwerf seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comment
Mary Thomas asked if the issue of residents keeping chickens as pets had ended; Chair Bettelli
stated that the topic was to be on the agenda for the next Public Works Committee meeting.
Mayor Cronin stated that she could attend that meeting in person or send the members an email
with her comments.
Mrs. Thomas said that she has an allergy called histoplasmosis that means she is allergic to
bird droppings; she said that if she lived around them all the time, she would be in the hospital
and could suffer lung damage.
4. Old Business
Recap of July 4
th Activities
Chief Buckhannon reported that the Police Departm ent was fully staffed for the day which
started off with traffic direction for the golf cart parade about 11:00 a.m.; the parade of eighty to
one hundred (80-100) golf carts ended about 11:40 a.m. This year a couple of security guards
were hired for the Sea Cabins to protect the entrance and exit from being overwhelmed with
non-resident traffic per their request; the Chief expressed the opinion that the results were
positive and that the practice should be continued in the future. In addition to City personnel, a
Highway Patrolman on motorcycle assisted with golf cart parade; six (6) Charleston County
deputies were on the island helping with traffic and crowd control. Following the fireworks
display, cars were off the island by 11:15 p.m., and traffic lights were functioning without
manipulation from officers. The Chief estimates that the crowd this year was smaller than in
previous years, but he believes that the same number of cars were on the island. Traffic counts
for vehicles accessing the island via the Connector were within a thousand (1,000) cars per day
of previous years, but the counts for Breach In let were down considerably. The assistance from
Mount Pleasant in directing traffic on the other side of the Connector has made a significant
difference in traffic flow over the past five (5) weeks.
Public Safety Committee
July 9, 2013
Page 2 of 7
Chief Graham stated that the Fire Department also had additional personnel on hand, as well as
the presence of Charleston County Rescue. Personnel were divided between the beach and
the trucks. There were no reported injuries resulting from the wind carrying debris from the
fireworks.
Administrator Tucker stated that good additions this year were the Highway Patrol motorcyclists,
the security guards at Sea Cabins, the City’s ability to be flexible with the County personnel here
then moving to Mount Pleasant, and the last minute decision to station people on the roof at
Sea Cabins to diminish anxiety of fire from t he fireworks display. The City has received one (1)
insurance claim for a damaged vehicle from firewo rks debris landing on a vehicle in the County
Park, which is minor considering the huge risk factors involved. One (1) challenge that occurred
was a lost child in the vicinity of 3
rd Avenue in the early part of the fireworks show that pulled
resources that had been staged for the show. In her opinion, the City’s resources were more
challenged with crowd management on Friday, Saturday and Sunday than on July 4
th.
Chief Buckhannon stated that on July 4 th, 5th and 6 th, there were issues with the light at Rifle
Range; it actually went out on Friday. The outage was followed by a wreck on the Connector
about twenty minutes (20 min.) later, and, within another half hour, there was a heavy rain
storm.
5. New Business
A. Battery2Beach Signage
Administrator Tucker reported that the City has received correspondence from Battery2Beach
relative to signage for the Battery2Beach; they are requesting that the City finalize its route and
to prepare a map of the route denoting the plac es where signs would be placed on existing
poles. The City will supply this information to Battery2Beach for their approval; after that
approval is received, the information is submitted to SCDOT for an encroachment permit.
With the City’s wayfinding sign endeavor, the Administrator expressed the opinion that any
signage would need Stantec’s involvement for sign placement design; she has waited for
Committee approval before approaching Stantec for this task.
Mayor Cronin refreshed the Committee’ memory about the route selected on the island for
Battery2Beach, which is to enter the island from Breach Inlet, turn right onto Charleston to
Ocean Boulevard, Ocean Boulevard to 14
th Avenue, 14 th to Palm Boulevard, a left onto 21 st
Avenue to Waterway Boulevard, Waterway to t he marina, where a cyclist would turn around to
again travel Waterway to 21 st Avenue to Palm Boulevard and on to Breach Inlet. The Mayor
recalled that Battery2Beach has been given one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) for signs,
and it will be distributed on a first-come-first-served basis.
The Mayor noted that Battery2Beach had made a presentation to Council and Council had
agreed to the route at that time. The Administrator stated that she would get pricing from
Stantec for the work related to the signs.
Public Safety Committee
July 9, 2013
Page 3 of 7
B. Intergovernmental Agreement related to CCDD between IOP and
Charleston County
The City needs to enter into this agreement with Charleston County that includes at what point
the City’s employees will physically relocate to the County and under what conditions they will
become employees of the Director of the Charleston County Dispatch, what employee
conditions carry forward, the carry forward of leave earned by these empl oyees, what services
they will provide for the City and at what price. The details in this agreement are consistent with
the numbers the City has seen before and for which the City has planned. Both legal counsel
for Charleston County and the Isle of Palms have reviewed the agreement; Charleston County
agreed to all of the changes asked for by the City except changes in language for mediation.
MOTION: Mayor Cronin moved to recommend to City Council that the City
enter into this intergovernmental agreement with Charleston County;
Councilmember Bergwerf seconded.
Administrator Tucker noted that, if Sullivan’s Island does not pay its portion of the fees, the City
will be liable for their share because the City is the public safety answering point for Sullivan’s
Island; the Administrator stated that the risk of that happening is very small, especially since that
would leave them without 911 emergency services.
Chair Bettelli voiced concern over the statement “Annual leave carryover payment from the
former employer. . .”, meaning that the City will pay to Charleston County for the transitioning
employees. Administrator Tucker reported that staff had looked at that group of employees and
determined that this is an immaterial amount of money.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Bandit Boats at the Marina
Administrator Tucker explained that these bandit boats are parking in the slips designated for
restaurant customers; this subject is also bei ng discussed by the Real Property Committee that
has purview over the marina. It is being discussed in the Public Safety Committee in order for
Chief Buckhannon to detail out what the City can and cannot do in terms of enforcement for
these bandit vessels that belong to people who park in these slips but do not go into Morgan
Creek Grill for a meal. The idea has been floated that the Police Department should be able to
ticket these boats for trespassing, and the owners should be required to appear at Livability
Court to pay a fine. Chief Buckhannon will explain why that cannot happen, as well the
limitations under which the City must act.
Chief Buckhannon noted that the docks are included in the City’s lease agreement with Morgan
Creek Grill, so they are the property of Morgan Creek Grill; therefore, Morgan Creek Grill has to
monitor it. If there is a boat there that does not belong, they must call the Police Department to
report it. Since it is a trespass type of issue, the City cannot issue a citation and leave it on the
boat as is done with a parking citation. The Police Department has to actually serve the
trespass notice to the individual who owns the boat; when that is done, the party is also put on
Public Safety Committee
July 9, 2013
Page 4 of 7
notice – not just given a ticket. Most often, the City does not issue a ticket for a trespass
charge, the person is just put on notice.
This issue has been discussed with restaurant management in the past, and they are aware that
they must be an active participant – they must take the lead. Part of the problem is that they
want leeway in enforcement; for instance, if a patron drives his/her boat to the restaurant for
dinner, has too much to drink and chooses alternate transportation home, the restaurant
encourages that action and agrees for the customer’s boat to stay overnight to be removed the
next day. This makes enforcement difficult.
For several boats whose owners were identified, officers did put these people on notice that
they were not to park their boat in those slips again.
There was also discussion about towing these boats, but that is quite expensive and there are a
limited number of businesses who do that type of work. A company named SeaTow has said
that, if they are called, the charge is six hundred dollars ($600) for them to come, two hundred
dollars ($200) an hour of their time and one hundred dollars ($100) for storage; this nine
hundred dollars ($900) must be paid upfront and can be recovered civilly.
Councilmember Bergwerf asked if Morgan Creek Grill has complained, but Administrator Tucker
replied that they have not complained recently. The issue was brought up by people who see
these boats parked there for exceedingly long periods of time and call the City asking for
something to be done. Typically these people are paying customers at the marina, and they
see these other people cheating and want the City to act.
In the Administrator’s opinion, the important things to be learned from this discussion are that
the City is limited in what it can do and the restaurant must initiate any action.
Chair Bettelli recalled that originally the City had more leeway because the dock space was not
included in the Morgan Creek lease as it is today.
Chief Buckhannon stated that the restaurant management was told that they could hire an off-
duty officer to monitor the boat slips when traffic is heavy as a short-term fix; in his opinion, the
only long-term cure is to manage the slips like they do the restaurant and put someone outside
overseeing who parks in those slips.
Administrator Tucker stated that another option to consider when the lease is re-negotiated is to
take those slips away from the restaurant and put them under the purview of the marina
manager. Mayor Cronin thought that this was the most viable solution; the restaurant could
then work out an arrangement with the marina manager for some number of slips.
D. “No Parking” Signs for Palm Boulevard between 40
th and 41st Avenues
Chair Bettelli stated that he had put this on the agenda because one (1) property owner has
stated that where the street widens into two (2) lanes, parking by beach-goers is very
dangerous; in addition, the property owners find it very difficult to enter the traffic when cars are
parked along that stretch.
Public Safety Committee
July 9, 2013
Page 5 of 7
Chief Buckhannon said that the City would refer the matter to SCDOT to determine whether a
safety issue exists, and he will make the request.
E. Discussion of Staffing in the Fire Department
Chief Graham referred to the discussion of Quick Response Vehicles (QRVs) which dealt with
personnel issues in the Department and stated that the turnover in the Department is high,
which means that experienced people are leaving and inexperienced people are replacing them.
The Chief explained that an Isle of Palms firefighter is not like a City of Charleston or North
Charleston firefighter; in the larger departments, the personnel are specialized, but here the
firefighters are also water rescuers, technicians, HazMat, EMTs, etc. When an employee with
five (5) years’ experience leaves, the City loses more than a firefighter. In the past, the City has
attracted firefighters from other local municipalities, but the City’s pay scale has fallen below
other local departments that Isle of Palms cannot compete. Chief Graham stated that the new
hires have great potential and the future of the department looks good – if the City can keep
these people once they are trained.
In addition to the pay issue, the stations are understaffed; currently there are five (5) people at
Station 1 and four (4) people at Station 2. Personnel are too frequently working beyond
capacity to make sure that everyone is safe; the Department is calling for mutual aid more fre-
quently, but there is a delay in their getting on the island. Despite national standards, the Chief
knows that the Department will never staff to those levels, but to equalize the stations now
would be a great help.
Chief Graham voiced her opinion that the City lost its hiring edge financially when the cost of
living raises were eliminated. She stated that the firefighters being hired at the Isle of Palms
have Firefighter 1 and Firefighter 2 training and some type of experience; there are other local
departments that hire people off the street, send them to training, and pay them more than new
hires here. Firefighters from these other departments are coming here to work part-time, and it
isn’t long before everyone is talking pay rates.
The Chief said that her goal is to make a presentation to the Personnel Committee to get
consideration for some kind of pay adjustment.
Chief Graham reported that in 2011 the Department lost six (6) firefighters, and so far this year,
six (6) people have resigned, and she is expecting to receive several more from people who
have applied to and been interviewed by the City of Charleston. In addition to higher pay, the
Chief reported that some of the firefighters have said that they do not feel safe on all of their
calls because they are being asked to do things bey ond their abilities; they fell that, if they were
in a larger department, they would be safer when responding to calls.
Both Mayor Cronin and Chair Bettelli encouraged the Chief to make a presentation to the
Personnel Committee; Mayor Cronin encouraged Chief Buckhannon to determine whether the
Police Department was also losing experienced personnel due to differences in pay. As Mayor,
he does not want the City’s personnel to be underpaid for their efforts on behalf of the City.
Public Safety Committee
July 9, 2013
Page 6 of 7
Councilmember Bergwerf reminded the Committee that the Chief also needs another firefighter
at Station 2.
F. Contracts in Excess of $10,000
1. Award of a contract to Safe Industries in the amount of $27,161.53
for 5 air packs and accessories included in the FY14 budget.
2. Award of a contract to T2 Systems for 3 Casio IT-9000E Handheld
Ticket Writers in the amount of $12, 822.00 included in the FY14 budget.
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to award a contract to Safe Industries and to T2
Systems as detailed above; Mayor Cronin seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
6. Highlights of Department Reports
Fire Department – Chief Graham
Chief Graham reported that on June 1, personnel responded to two (2) swimmers in distress
near Breach Inlet; upon arrival, crews found a female victim that had already been pulled out of
the water. A jet ski was launched to rescue a male victim still in the water; the female was
turned over the Charleston County and transported. Personnel also responded to several
weather related incidents involving trees and debris removal. Along with Charleston County
EMS, personnel responded to Dewees Island for a patient experiencing an allergic reaction; due
to radio channel issues, response took forty-five (45) minutes and is being reviewed. On July
16, personnel responded to a motor vehicle accident at the intersection of Palm Boulevard and
4
th Avenue; the male victim had lost control of his motorcycle running from the police; he was
transported by Charleston County EMS. The Chief gave a detailed report of the June 30 th
drowning and the efforts on behalf of Fire Department personnel to save the man involved; the
personnel involved will receive a written commendation for their actions. In June, Fire
Department personnel responded to one hundred thirty-s ix (136) calls (a 10-year record), and
fifty-seven (57) calls were EMS calls. Two (2) fire inspections were performed in the month, and
no violations were found. Vehicle maintenance was higher than usual due to replacing the main
boom hydraulic cylinder for Tower 1002 at approximately forty-eight hundred dollars ($4,800).
Chief Graham and Engineers Bolen and Puckhaber were involved with the U.S. Coast Guard as
they performed swimmer training off the coast of the island; this was training that IOP personnel
have not had the opportunity to get in the past.
Police Department – Chief Buckhannon
The Chief reported that, on June 28
th, there was a burglary in the 400 block on Carolina
Boulevard; through extensive investigation, evidence was collected that led to the identification
of suspects in this case. The stolen property was recovered, as well as a significant amount of
property that had been reported stolen in a number of other cases in multiple jurisdictions. As a
result of the work done by IOP officers, the City of North Charleston, the City of Charleston and
the Dorchester County Sheriff’s Office were able to clear a number of their outstanding burglary
Public Safety Committee
July 9, 2013
Page 7 of 7
cases. Other agencies are currently in the process of determining whether any of the recovered
stolen property is related to their open cases; as of this date, fifteen (15) burglary cases have
been cleared throughout the tri-county area. In June, dispatchers responded to forty-five
hundred four (4,504) calls; of those calls, three thousand four hundred thirty-seven (3,437) were
for the Isle of Palms Police Department. Of four hundred forty-four (444) traffic stops, one
hundred thirty-three (133) tickets were issued; eleven hundred thirteen (1,113) parking tickets
were issued. Officers wrote one hundred seventy-seven (177) reports in the month of June.
There were fifty-four (54) arrests in the month; thirty-nine (39) of the tickets were for alcohol
violations. Three (3) citations were written for noise violations. Two (2) officers completed
Bicycle Officer Certification.
7. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 5:00 p.m., Monday, August 5
th in the Conference Room.
8. Executive Session
MOTION: Chair Bettelli moved to go into Executive Session at 6:08 p.m. to
discuss disciplinary action in the Police Department; Councilmember Bergwerf
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
The Committee returned to regular session at 6:22 p.m. having not taken a vote or any action in
Executive Session.
9. Adjourn
Motion: Mayor Cronin moved to adjourn the meeting at 6:23 p.m.; Chair
Bettelli seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.