May 6 (PDF, 25.52 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE
5:30 p.m., Monday, May 6, 2013
The regular meeting of the Public Works Committee was held at 5:30 p.m. on Monday, May 6,
2013 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South Carolina.
Attending the meeting were Councilmember Ward, Chair Buckhannon, Administrator Tucker,
Public Works Director Pitts and City Cler k Copeland; Councilmember Loftus’ absence was
excused, but a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Buckhannon called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and
public had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of April 3, 2012 as submitted; Chair Buckhannon seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizens’ Comments – None
4. Departmental Reports for April 2013 – Director Pitts
Maintenance and Trash Collection Tracking Reports
Director Pitts noted that the Department had incurred sixteen (16) hours of overtime due to
pumping flood waters from 46
th and 49th through 52nd Avenues. With the beginning of the tourist
season, personnel did beach sweeps twice during the month of April; they also mowed the
rights-of-way between 21
st and 42 nd Avenues. The implementation of single-stream recycling
continues to impact the volume of garbage collected; for the second consecutive month,
garbage collections are down approximately thirty ( 30) tons. On the other hand, yard debris set
a three-year (3 yr.) record at two hundred fifty-seven tons (257 T.). Vehicle maintenance was
about eight thousand dollars ($8,000) and remains under-budget year-to-date; twelve (12) sets
of tires were purchased in April.
Chair Buckhannon asked about the “Special Project” referred to in the Director’s report; this was
a water main break at the marina that was repaired by B&C Utilities. According to the Director,
Marina Manager Berrigan accepted the work without reservation, and, from a site visit, the area
has recovered.
5. Old Business
A. Update on Phase II Drainage Project and Discussion of Solutions for
Trouble Spots in Phase I from Dave Stevens, CSE
Since Dick and Cathy Audi of #7 56
th Avenue were present, the Committee took up the
problems from Phase I first. Mr. Stevens used diagrams from the Phase I drainage project to
illustrate the area where water does not drain properly; he noted that the Audi’s driveway and
lawn are lower than the roadway. He recommends installing junction boxes and tying them in to
the drainage system; he also proposes additional piping and a grate to address the standing
water on the other side of the road. Mr. Stevens indicated that he has presented the
Public Works Committee
May 6, 2013
Page 2 of 7
Administrator with a proposal for preliminary surveying and routing for this area and Lot 7 on
56
th Avenue totaling sixty-five hundred dollars ($6,500).
Administrator Tucker invited the Audis to come forward to see the drainage project “as-builts”
and what Mr. Stevens is proposing to eliminate t heir flooding problems. He thinks that he can
drop into the side of the junction box, sink an eighteen inch (18 in.) pipe in the Audi’s yard with
the grate lower than the dirt. Mr. Stevens offered to meet the Audis at their home later in the
evening to determine if what he is suggesting is possible.
Administrator Tucker noted that there were funds in the drainage contingency to cover the
surveying and routing expensive; Chair Bu ckhannon added that there was a small balance in
the budget from Phase I of the drainage project.
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to approve $6,500 for CSE to do the
preliminary surveying and routing for drainage problems at 56
th and 57th Avenues;
Chair Buckhannon seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Mr. Stevens displayed an aerial map of the northern end of the island that showed the Phase I
drainage project in blue and Phase II in yellow; Phase II will provide flooding relief for 45 th
through 52nd Avenue, omitting private streets 47 th and 48th Avenues, and route into Wild Dunes
for outfalls. The plan is to run a header pipe along Palm Boulevard and then to run smaller
pipes down the streets; he plans to submit for SCDOT permits in two to three (2-3) weeks, and
he estimates the project to cost in the neighborhood of one million dollars ($1,000,000).
Administrator Tucker asked if this project coul d be phased for submission for funding from the
Charleston Transportation Committee (CTC) or t he Transportation Sales Tax (TST) and, if so,
how it would be done. Mr. Stevens said that it could easily be phased and suggested starting at
the outfall in Wild Dunes, working out to Palm Boulevard as Part A, possibly including the forty-
eight inch (48 in.) header pipe along Palm. The pipes down the avenues could be done as
funds became available.
The Administrator then asked Mr. Stevens if there was capacity at the outfall should the Citadel
Beach House and property owners of 47
th and 48 th Avenues want access to the system in the
future, at their expense. Mr. Stevens responded that he had designed the system with that
possibility of the avenues joining in mind, but the Citadel may need a retention pond. Since
these streets are private, Mr. Stevens cautioned the Committee that the City must ensure that
they are included in the warranty and cleaning and their impact down the line.
To allow Mr. Stevens to complete his business with the Committee, Administrator Tucker asked
that Item D under Old Business be discussed next; the Committee agreed.
D. Update on Activities Related to Sparrow Drive
The Administrator recounted the history related to Sparrow Drive drainage for the Committee
which goes back to 2005 when a petition was submitted to Council requesting relief from
flooding. Various activities followed over the course of five years, and in November 2011,
Public Works Committee
May 6, 2013
Page 3 of 7
based on the City’s request for TST funding, drainage improvements were made by Charleston
County. In March 2013 two (2) flooding issues were again brought to the City’s attention
regarding a flapper valve when a massive rain occurred with a high tide. The area that is
seeking relief today has not had any drainage infrastructure improvements and, what was once
an open swale, has now been landscaped over.
The Administrator informed the Committee that she has queried Charleston County about
looking at the area again to gain some insight into what can be done to eliminate or alleviate the
flooding problem, but they have not yet responded. Mr. Stevens has also agreed to look at the
area.
Director Pitts said that there is a box inlet in the side yard of the resident on the south corner of
Sparrow Drive and Duck Lane, and the fact that the ditch has been filled in prevents water from
getting to the collection box.
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to approve up to $1,000 for CSE to
survey the Sparrow Drive drainage problem; Chair Buckhannon seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Councilmember Ward asked Administrator Tucker to contact Mr. Whitt to tell him that the City is
pursuing a solution to his problem at 112 Sparrow Drive.
B. Discussion of Deploying Yellow Barrels on Land-side of Palm Boulevard
Chair Buckhannon recalled that he had asked to know what kind of financial impact placing
yellow barrels on the land-side of Palm across from the beach access paths.
Director Pitts reported that the yellow barrels cost thirty-five dollars ($35) each, and he then
suggested a trial of placing the barrels at crosswalks at 25
th, 28th 34th and 37th Avenues at a cost
of one hundred forty dollars ($140). He informed the Committee that Mr. Schupp had agreed to
service these barrels at no charge to the City. The Director voiced his opinion that these yellow
barrels will not need servicing, and he will prov ide photographic proof of the amount of garbage
they contain.
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to proceed with the trial as proposed
by Director Pitts at a cost of $140; Chair Buckhannon seconded and the motion
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Discussion of Amendment to the Roll-out Cart/Recycling Cart Ordinance
Administrator Tucker stated that the goal of this amendment was to have the same regulations
for both garbage roll-out carts and recycling bins; from that discussion two (2) additional issues
came to light, i.e. (1) public spaces where the bins are visible and (2) corrals in the rights-of-way
have outlived their usefulness. A red-lined version of the ordinance was included in meeting
packets addressing all of these issues; the amendment encourages either not visible or a
suitable screening, but discourages corrals in the right-of-way.
Public Works Committee
May 6, 2013
Page 4 of 7
Director Pitts has compiled a list of properties in residential areas that have large container-like
spaces to house roll-out carts; they are Dunescape and other locations inside the gates of Wild
Dunes, for instance Marsh Island, Pelican Bay and Grand Pavilion, which have single family
residences; Fairway Village and Back Court, whic h have enclosures attached to the homes;
Lagoon Villas, which has large room-like enclosures where the carts are not visible; Links Side,
Seagrove, Marinas Walk, Beach Club Villas and Yacht Harbor, which have room-like
enclosures. These properties in Wild Dunes are not public rights-of-way; therefore, being
private, they fall outside the ordinance.
Administrator Tucker re-read the ordinance to determine if that was the language; the phrase
“garbage carts and recycling containers are not readily visible from a street, road or right-of-
way” does not specify private or public. The Ad ministrator continued reading “corrals . . . shall
not be located in the right-of-way of a street or road,” which again does not indicate public or
private. As written, the ordinance would apply to properties inside the gates; Director Pitts
noted that Marsh Island, Pelican Bay and Grand Pavilion are all at the street.
Chair Buckhannon asked what agency determines the corrals’ appearance; Director Pitts
thought that the Building Department would approve and permit construction.
Responding to Councilmember Ward’s question, Administrator Tucker explained that the goal of
this discussion was to get input from the Committee about the amendment, i.e. does it still need
to be tweaked or does it meet the purposes for which it is intended? The Administrator then
asked for the Committee’s feedback on the following statement in the amendment:
“Garbage carts and recycling containers located on publicly owned areas, including, but
not limited to, public parking lots, public parks, public beach and recreational areas, or
any City-owned property, are exempt from the requirements of this section.”
Councilmember Ward stated that he was totall y against the amendment when the City exempts
itself from the ordinance; in his opinion, the City can also build enclosures for roll-out carts and
recycling containers. He said that such an exem ption would “not play well with the public;” he
indicated that he has been opposed to the ordinance since its inception. The reason that he is
opposed to the amendment is based on comments from Director Pitts and the general public
that, if this amendment is passed, people will stop using the recycling containers and put
everything into the roll-out carts. The Councilmember commented that residents have problems
keeping up with the schedule for recycling pickups and visitors will have no way of knowing
when the next recycling day will be. He stated that some rental agencies have told him that
they will not participate in the recycling program. Additionally, he recalled during discussion at
the City Council meeting the statement being made that the ordinance will not be enforced; he
then asked why laws were passed that will not be enforced, and he was strongly opposed to the
fact that the City was exempting itself.
Chair Buckhannon suggested that these structures being built for house garbage carts/recycling
containers could be considered to be accessory structure, meaning they must be six feet (6 ft.)
off the property line.
Public Works Committee
May 6, 2013
Page 5 of 7
Director Pitts expressed a concern that, if the City passes an ordinance with restrictions to an
enclosure and the City tries to promote that enc losure, property owners will perceive that Public
Works staff will go onto private property to service those enclosures, and that is not the case. It
is the Director’s feeling that he is protecting the property owner by not allowing the temporary
Public Works staff to go onto private property.
Administrator Tucker summarized the discussion by stating that the Committee prefers to leave
the roll-out cart ordinance as is and not be concerned about recycling containers or containers
that exist in certain areas that are not being concealed.
E. Discussion of Progress on Assigned Work Task for 1801 Palm Boulevard
Although staff is working on the project, little progress has been made; Director Pitts has been
trying to get pricing for cleaning up the lot, but the Administrator is concerned about preserving
the species named in the Greenbelt application as necessary for the habitat and drought
conditions. Hardy Services, an arborist, walked the property with Director Pitts last week and
needs a list of the plant species before generating a proposal. Yard Works, which maintains the
accreted land that must be cut by hand, will walk the property this week.
Councilmember Ward related a dialogue with Ma rge Swanson, a former Councilmember, who
had suggested naming the park the Carmen R. Bunch Park to honor her service of sixteen
years (16 yrs.) as Mayor and four years (4 yrs.) on Council. Mayor Cronin reportedly said that
the City needs to decide what it is going to do with the space before naming it; Councilmember
Ward asked for the reasoning behind those comments. The Administrator responded that the
space looks shabby now and needs to be cleaned up; she added that she has not heard any
resistance to the name.
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to name the Greenbelt property at 1801
Palm Boulevard the Mayor Carmen R. Bunch Park; Chair Buckhannon seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
F. Review of FY14 Public Works Budget
Councilmember Ward reiterated his concern over the reductions in fund balances in the FY14
budget. He noted that he wholeheartedly agrees with the City’s initiative to avoid debt, but the
City may have to enter into a capital lease to keep the fund balances at healthy levels.
Administrator Tucker commented that the fund balances and reserves will have to be carefully
monitored each year to ensure that the debt avoidance schedule is kept on schedule.
6. New Business
A. Consideration of Resident’s Request to Pipe Open Ditch at 2408 Palm
Boulevard
Kelly Messier, a landscape architect, stated that she was representing John and Mandy Grimes,
owners of 2408 Palm Boulevard; they are intere sted in piping the ditch because they have seen
snakes and are concerned for their children. They have gone to DOT to pipe the ditch; the pipe
Public Works Committee
May 6, 2013
Page 6 of 7
would be approximately twenty (20) linear feet, but ten (10) of that distance is City property.
Therefore, DOT is requiring that the Grimes get the City’s permission to pipe the City’s ditch.
They will pay for the work to be done, using fifteen inch (15 in.) re-enforced concrete pipe with a
drain inlet and junction box on their property.
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to approve the Grimes’ request; Chair
Buckhannon seconded.
Director Pitts noted that, in the event of a twenty or twenty-five (20-25) year storm, a closed
ditch system will put more water on road, rather than the open ditch, resulting in flooding on the
street.
Chair Buckhannon cautioned Ms. Messier that, once the ditch is installed, landscape
improvements cannot be placed beyond the property line into the right-of-way. According to Ms.
Messier, plantings in the right-of-way were part of the encroachment permit, but Administrator
Tucker indicated that the City is trying to elim inate all encroachments into the rights-of-way and
to prevent any new ones.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Award of a Contract to Paragon Sitework Constructors, Inc. in the amount
of $8,945 for improvement to the City Hall parking lot
This bid is for the improvements to the surface of the City Hall parking lot that includes new
surface, remove and install new parking stops, remove twenty (20) of the best parking stops and
relocate to 1301 Palm lot and to provide gravel to form an entrance apron to 1301 Palm.
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to recommend to Ways and Means the
award of a contract to Paragon Sitework Constructors, Inc. for $8,945; Chair
Buckhannon seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Contracts in Excess of $10,000
Award of a contract for City-wide Landscaping to Lawns Done Right for $45,800
annually, plus an estimated $4,000 for repairs to Front Beach irrigation system
Administrator Tucker reminded the Committee that the City had received a lot of bids in a wide
spread for this contract; to ensure that the City was getting the best deal, Director Pitts made
site visits to work sites for the four (4) lowest bidders. Based on those visits, the determination
is that Lawns Done Right will do a good job and is well within the fifty-six thousand dollars
($56,000) budgeted for the service.
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to recommend to Ways and Means to
award the City-wide landscaping contract to Lawns Done Right for $45,800
annually plus $4,000 for Front Beach irrigation repairs; Chair Buckhannon
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Public Works Committee
May 6, 2013
Page 7 of 7
7. Miscellaneous Business
Next Meeting Date: 5:30 p.m., Tuesday, June 11, 2013
8. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Ward moved to adjourn the meeting at 6:50 p.m.;
Chair Buckhannon seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.