January 10 (PDF, 24.29 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
REAL PROPERTY COMMITTEE
5:00 p.m., Thursday, January 10, 2013
The regular meeting of the Real Property Committee was held at 5:00 p.m. on Thursday,
January 10, 2013 in the City Hall Conference Room, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmembers Buckhannon, Loftus and Stone, City
Administrator Tucker and City Clerk Copeland; a quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Administrator Tucker called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and
public were duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Election of Chair and Vice Chair
Councilmember Buckhannon nominated Councilm ember Stone to serve as Chair;
Councilmember Loftus seconded, and the Commi ttee unanimously elected Councilmember
Stone Chair.
Councilmember Loftus nominated Councilmember Buckhannon as Vice Chair; Chair Stone
seconded and the Committee unanimously elected Councilmember Buckhannon Vice Chair.
3. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Buckhannon moved to approve the minutes of the
regular meeting of November 13, 2012 as submitted; Councilmember Loftus
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
4. Citizens’ Comments – Jonathan Yates of Hellman Yates
Mr. Yates introduced Bill Jenkins, Special Projects Administrator for the IOP Water and Sewer
Commission, and Don Slowek of AT&T; Mr. Yates stated that they were attending the meeting
seeking approval to go before the Board of Zoning Appeals for a variance to erect a one
hundred sixty (160) foot monopole that would replace the water tower and support
communication antennae that are currently on the water tower. The carriers that currently have
antenna on the tower are AT&T, T-Mobile, Sprint, Cricket and Conterra ultra-broadband. As he
spoke, he displayed larger versions of the photographs that were in the meeting packets that
showed the site as it appears today and the site as it is proposed to look with the monopole. If
the proposed monopole is approved, the existing water tank will be removed, and, since the
monopole would be under two hundred (200) feet, it will not have to be lighted at night, so it will
be virtually invisible after dark. Mr. Yates stated that equipment on the ground will not be
effected by the monopole.
According to Mr. Yates, the advantages for AT&T are the ability to pick up a signal loss that they
presently have and an easier platform for modifications and servicing the equipment.
Mr. Blowek described AT&T as twenty-first centur y infrastructure providers; as use increases,
the need to increase the ability to provide infrastructure becomes more critical. The water tank
site addresses the core use from people coming onto the island from Sullivan’s Island and
Mount Pleasant to the heart of activity on the island at Front Beach. The monopole has been
designed to add Verizon in the future if they so choose, as well as provide space for equipment
for the Water and Sewer Commission, the City or other emergency services.
Real Property Committee
January 10, 2013
Page 2 of 7
Mr. Yates reported that this type of monopole was duly wind-tested during Hurricane Katrina;
the only pole they lost was hit by a projectile and severed.
In order for AT&T to apply to the Board of Zoning Appeals for a Special Exception to erect the
tower at one hundred sixty (160) feet, the City must provide an executed Property Owner’s
Authorization since the water tank sits on City-owned property.
MOTION: Councilmember Buckhannon moved to re-order the Agenda to
discuss item A under New Business; Councilmember Loftus seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
7. New Business
A. Consideration of Monopole-style Communications Facility to Replace
Existing Water Tower at 1300 Palm Boulevard
Responding to Chair Stone’s questions about project for the water tank previously approved by
the City, Mr. Jenkins explained that the original project had been to erect two (2) temporary
poles to host the communications antennae in order to sandblast and paint the water tower.
Before that project got started, the Water and Sewer Commission was approached by AT&T
about the construction of a monopole to replace the water tank. If the monopole is approved,
the water tower will be torn down; if the monopole is not approved, the water tower will undergo
the maintenance originally approved and remain standing. Mr. Jenkins confirmed that, if the
tower is to remain standing, it must undergo the maintenance early in 2013 as planned. In
addition, Mr. Jenkins stated that the tank does not provide anything for the Water and Sewer
Commission since water for the island comes fr om Charleston Water Systems; presently the
tank is filled as pressures dictate and then water is pumped out of the tank.
Administrator Tucker inquired whether the loss of the tower would impact the City’s ISO rating
for fire premiums; Mr. Jenkins assured her that it would not.
Mr. Jenkins stated that the Water and Sewer Commission would bear the cost of removal and
that the demolition would not require an increase in charges to customers.
Councilmember Buckhannon stated his understanding that the Water and Sewer Commission
Board has agreed to remove the water tank in favor of the monopole due to ongoing
maintenance costs of the tank; Mr. Jenkins agreed.
Administrator Tucker reported that the revenues generated by the antennae now go to the
Water and Sewer Commission because they are mounted on Water and Sewer Commission
equipment. Councilmember Loftus questioned the recipient of revenue from the antennae on
the monopole since the communications tower would not be Water and Sewer equipment; he
asked that the Administrator learn what the annual revenues from the antennae are for the
Ways & Means Committee meeting.
Chair Stone asked whether service would be enhanced with the monopole; Mr. Yates answered
that it would be.
Real Property Committee
January 10, 2013
Page 3 of 7
Councilmember Loftus asked why areas of the is land have no cell service, particularly along the
beach and golf courses in Wild Dunes. Mr. Yates indicated that there was a need for a full-
service facility in Wild Dunes; this tower will not have an impact on service in that area.
Mr. Browek stated that he has a master plan for Charleston, and this monopole is one piece; he
stated that he is in talks with Wild Dunes now. He indicated that this tower plays an integral role
in the master plan in order to make the coverage seamless on the island.
Responding to Chair Stone’s question, Mr. Browek said the tower was to become the property
of the Water and Sewer Commission in a like-for-like trade, i.e. the water tank for the monopole.
With that established, Chair Stone queried that the Water and Sewer Commission Board would
be the decision makers if another carrier were to be added; Mr. Jenkins agreed.
Councilmember Buckhannon stated that there are many on the island that look at the water
tower as an iconic structure, while others consider it an eyesore, and everything has a life span.
He stated that it becomes functional value versus sentimental value.
Mr. Yates countered that the salt water atmosphere of the coast contributes mightily to the
deterioration of the steel tank.
When asked what kind of push-back there will be from the community, Administrator Tucker
remarked that many residents feel possessive of the water tank, but many will be glad to have
the view unobstructed, while many will be sensitive to a pole.
The Administrator asked Mr. Browek if there was better location on the island for the monopole
rather than in the vista coming over the Connector; Mr. Browek stated that “this site was at the
heart of a major core” and that “moving this site would disrupt an entire network throughout
Charleston.”
The Administrator stated that she would like to know the steps and how they fall, as well as a
site drawing showing the existing water tank and the proposed monopole tower; Mr. Yates had
such a site drawing for the Committee to review. The monopole will be closer to the ground
equipment; it will be constructed, the antennae will be moved and then the water tank will be
removed.
Administrator Tucker voiced her opinion that, assuming that the Committee believes this to be a
good idea, the discussion should take place at Ways and Means; she repeated her thought that,
as a water tower, it is a Water and Sewer Commission asset that sits on City-owned property,
but she wondered if the same would be true for a communications tower.
MOTION: Councilmember Buckhannon moved to recommend to Ways and
Means that the City Administrator be authorized to sign the Property Owner’s
Authorization that will allow AT&T to proceed with a request for a Special Excep-
tion from the Board of Zoning Appeals; Councilmember Loftus seconded and the
motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Real Property Committee
January 10, 2013
Page 4 of 7
As the discussion ended, Administrator Tucker asked what kind of a timeline was in play with
this decision; Mr. Jenkins said that a final decision had to be made by the end of January in
case the tank maintenance was to take place as planned.
5. Comments from Marina Tenants - None
6. Old Business
A. Discussion of RFP and Proposals Received for Municipal Parking Lots
Administrator Tucker reported that the City received four (4) bids for the municipal parking lots
lease; they were Bret Jones, Bill Schupp, Jeff Evans and Palmetto Parking. The bids ranged
from one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000), which was the stipulated minimum, to one
hundred seventeen thousand five hundred dollars ($117,500). The proposals have all been
reviewed, and the staff level recommendation is to throw out all of the bids, modify the RFP and
re-bid the contract on a compressed timeline. The Administrator related that some of the
bidders did not adequately respond to certain areas of the RFP, and the thought of adding an
alternate to the bid, perhaps extended hours, seems appropriate. If the RFP is modified and re-
bid, the City may get new bidders and some bidders may drop out.
If the RFP were to be re-bid, Councilmember Loftus asked if anything would be changed radi-
cally from the original; the Administrator said that one (1) thing the bid package emphasized
was that the award would not necessarily be based on the financial aspect. The Administrator
stated that she would like to put more emphasis on the creativity associated with getting
vehicles into the lots, important in light of the parking issues on the island and the controversy
on the island related to beach access parking. As stated, she would like to put forth the
alternate for extended hours, and the RFP would emphasize the point that all bidders are
expected to respond to everything that has been asked for.
Relative to the extended hours for the parking lots, Councilmember Loftus asked what impact
that would have on street parking at Front Beach. Administrator Tucker repeated her theory
that the City is losing parking revenue from visitors who wait to come to the island when the
parking is free, but she did not think the lots had to have the same hours as the meters.
Chair Stone invited the two (2) bidders who were present to speak at this time.
Mark Dobson of Palmetto Parking stated that he was aware that the contract award would not
be based on the bid dollars, but his company was the highest bidder; if the contract were to be
re-bid, their best offer is available for any other bidder to meet or beat. Referring to the
Administrator’s comments about the fact that some bidders did not respond fully to the RFP, he
stated that he understood the RFP to say that, if the bid is incomplete, the City has the right not
to consider the bid. He continued that Palmetto Parking is a professional parking company with
a huge infrastructure in downtown, Folly Beach and Mount Pleasant Waterfront Park; they have
resources and people to be on the island for the residents and visitors.
Administrator Tucker asked Mr. Dobson to classify the roles that Palmetto Parking plays at each
location. Mr. Dobson stated that, at Mount Pleasant Waterfront Park, Palmetto only collects
Real Property Committee
January 10, 2013
Page 5 of 7
from the kiosks; at Folly Beach, Palmetto did ticketing, enforcement, collections, revenue
deposits, and they lost that contract on Tuesday evening after seven (7) years servicing twenty-
two (22) lots with approximately five hundred (500) spaces. Downtown, Palmetto has over
sixty-five (65) lots, ranging from five (5) to one hundred twenty (120) spaces; they also have two
(2) parking garages that they handle full time and another two (2) where they do enforcement on
nights and weekends. At the busier lots downtown, Palmetto staffs multiple ingresses and
egresses with uniformed attendants with flags who know how to direct traffic; in the past,
Palmetto has done parking for Spoleto and the Cooper Bridge Run. In the downtown area,
Palmetto’s parking lots are both staffed and use honor boxes.
Responding to Councilmember Loftus’ question, Mr. Dobson stated that their staff is composed
of both full-time and part-time employees; at the Isle of Palms, staffing would depend upon day
of the week and seasonality. In the proposal, Palmetto stated that its plan was to fill one (1) lot
and to move staff to the second lot to full it. On a summer weekend, Palmetto would have
several people here – directing traffic, collecting money and issuing tickets.
Jeff Evans stated that he and his partner, who make up Isle of Palms Beach Club, would be
taking a different approach; they are looking into way to incentivize people to the municipal lots.
He stated that they will focus on the facilities themselves and to have people want to be there;
he indicated that he does not bring the level of experience of Palmetto Parking. On the subject
of staffing, Mr. Evans explained that he will focus on hiring island and Mount Pleasant young
people; he intends to be on site in the busy times. If the City decides to re-bid the contract, he
assured the Committee that he would submit a bid.
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to go into Executive Session at 6:05
p.m. to discuss negotiations incident to proposed contractual agreements;
Councilmember Buckhannon seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
The Committee returned to regular session at 6:18 p.m.; Chair Stone stated that the Committee
had not taken a vote or any action while in Executive Session.
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to reject the bids, modify the RFP and
re-bid the RFP for the municipal parking lots; Chair Stone seconded.
Councilmember Buckhannon stated that it was good that the City received four (4) bids for the
project, but one (1) vendor met all of the criteria, and, therefore, he was reluctant to reject all
bids.
VOTE: The motion FAILED on a vote of 1 to 2; Chair Stone and Councilmember
Buckhannon cast the dissenting votes.
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to have the four (4) bidders make a
presentation to the Ways and Means Committee on Tuesday, February 15;
Councilmember Buckhannon seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Real Property Committee
January 10, 2013
Page 6 of 7
B. Discussion of Tidal Wave Dock Replacement and Reconfiguration of
Balance of Docks
Administrator Tucker related that she had read the minutes of the previous meeting when the
long range plans for the marina were discussed and the meeting when the replacement of the
Tidal Wave dock was discussed and found them to be somewhat contradictory; in addition, the
FY13 budget includes funds for the replacement of the Tidal Wave dock and the design and
engineering for the reconfiguration of the other marina docks. As the Administrator was trying to
write the RFP for the work, she recognized that there is a task that needs immediate attention,
the Tidal Wave dock, and there is a long-range project of renovating the marina docks which
could include reconfiguration of the docks to maximize profits. In addition, with only five (5)
months remaining in the fiscal year, the most rea listic plan is the replacement of the Tidal Wave
dock with the plan to re-budget the funds for the design and engineering for the marina docks.
Chair Stone noted that the Tidal Wave dock in its current condition is a safety hazard that must
be addressed.
Councilmember Loftus expressed the opinion that the reconfiguration of the marina docks
seems to be a multi-year project.
MOTION: Councilmember Buckhannon moved for the Administrator to
produce an RFP to replace the Tidal Wave dock; Councilmember Loftus seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Status of Permit Modification – Shoal Management Project
The City Administrator reported that OCRM has contacted Coastal Science and Engineering
(CSE), who has been dialoguing with the Corps of Engineers, indicating that there will not be
problems with what the City was proposing on the permit modification; the permit modification
should be out on the fifteen (15) day public comment period. On the request for the time
extension to have the two (2) permits coincide, CSE was reminded that legislation was passed a
couple of years ago that all permits obtained in a certain window of time would be extended to
allow for people to do their projects once the economy had recovered from the down-turn. The
City’s permit falls into that window and has been automatically extended. The City Attorney is
currently investigating whether the City can re-open the contract with the original vendor for the
shoal management contract; Baker Infrastructure Group did a good job at a fair price.
8. Miscellaneous Business
Marina Rents Report
Administrator Tucker reported that marina tenants are current, except for Morgan Creek Grill;
they are past due on the December rent and will be past due on January if no payment is
received tomorrow. Councilmember Loftus asked that the Ways and Means Committee be
updated with the status of Morgan Creek Grill’s rent.
Real Property Committee
January 10, 2013
Page 7 of 7
Next Meeting Date: 5:30 p.m., Thursday, February 7, 2013 in the Conference Room.
9. Executive Session – held earlier in the meeting
10. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to adjourn the meeting at 6:35 p.m.;
Chair Stone seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.