March 6 (PDF, 73.52 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
REAL PROPERTY COMMITTEE
5:30 p.m., Wednesday, March 6, 2013
The regular meeting of the Real Property Committee was held at 5:30 p.m. on Wednesday,
March 6, 2013 in the City Hall Conference Room, 12307 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms, South
Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmember Buckhannon and Loftus, Chair Stone,
City Administrator Tucker, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban and City Clerk Copeland; a
quorum was present to conduct business.
1. Chair Stone called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and public had
been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Approval of Previous Meeting’s Minutes
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to approve the minutes of the regular
meeting of February 7, 2013 as submitted; Councilmember Buckhannon seconded
and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
3. Citizen’s Comments – None
4. Comments from Marina Tenants – None
5. Old Business
A. Discussion of Boating Infrastructure Grant Application and Budget
Brian Berrigan, Marina Manager, and John Shaffer were present for this discussion, and Mr.
Shaffer displayed a conceptual drawing of the improvements to be done with the Boating Infra-
structure Grant. The drawing was different from the drawings of the Master Plan Mr. Berrigan
had presented in the past; this drawing does not relocate the boat ramp. The floating dock has
been moved as far into the creek as possible without interfering with traffic; this side-tie dock is
straight and four hundred eighty feet (480 ft.) long. Mr. Shaffer presented a preliminary budget
for the marina redevelopment that would be done in two (2) phases (a copy is attached to the
historical record of the meeting); Phase I includes the soft costs of engineering and design,
floating dock, several docks in the area of the restaurant and fuel system that totals just over
two million dollars ($2,000,000), of which just over eight hundred thousand dollars ($800,000)
would be paid from the grant. Phase II includes the dock behind the store, staging docks for the
dry stack storage and floating restroom and office; this cost for this phase is over one million
dollars ($1,000,000) with less than two hundred thousand dollars ($200,000) grant eligible. The
City’s expense for Phase I is approx imately one million two hundred thousand dollars
($1,200,000) and approximately nine hundred thousand dollars ($900,000) for Phase II; the fuel
tank replacement must be done before 2017 at a cost of one hundred fifty thousand dollars
($150,000).
In an aside note, Administrator Tucker informed the Committee that, if the City were to receive
and eight hundred thousand dollar ($800,000) boating infrastructure grant, it would trigger the
Single Audit Act, which is required when an entity receives more than six hundred thousand
dollars ($600,000) in federal funds. The audit would be more extensive and, therefore, more
expensive than the audit the City now has annually, but the Administrator thought the added
expense well worthwhile for the savings on the marina project.
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 2 of 9
The Administrator reminded the Committee that the DNR representative, who attended the
February meeting, will be holding a workshop of March 20
th at the DNR facility on Fort Johnson
Road. Administrator Tucker stated that staff does not want to go forward with generating and
submitting an application unless the Committee was certain that the City was ready to move
forward with the actual work.
Councilmember Loftus asked where the money w ould come from for the one point two million
dollar ($1,200,000) needed from the City. The Administrator responded that some would come
from the Marina Fund and some from tourism funds; it would be tight, but she believed it was
doable. The City also has the option of bondi ng the money, but that goes against Council’s
desire to avoid debt whenever possible. Replac ing the fuel system and reconfiguring the docks
are expenditures that were on the horizon for the City, and the grant would eliminate eight
hundred dollars ($800,000) of the cost.
Councilmember Loftus commented that what is being proposed is much larger in scope than
has been discussed in the past; Administrator Tucker stated that the City was looking at taking
smaller steps. She pointed out that two million dollars ($2,000,000) is in the long-range capital
plan for the reconfiguration of the docks.
Chair Stone asked if the City’s portion had to be in the bank if the grant is awarded.
Administrator Tucker explained that the City would need to pay up front and be reimbursed from
the grant. On the subject of timing, the Administrator noted that applications are due July 1,
2013 with the award coming in March of 2014; therefore, the City would not look to spend any
money until the FY15 budget year. The Chair thought that it would be eighteen to twenty-four
(18-24) months before breaking ground.
The Administrator voiced her understanding that any money spent on the project before the
grant is awarded is not eligible for reimbursement; Mr. Shaffer said she was correct.
Mr. Shaffer suggested beginning the regulatory permitting after submitting the grant since it
could take a year to receive the permit; once the grant is awarded, the City would begin the
engineering and design work. The City can then extend the grant until it has gathered the
necessary funding.
Chair Stone said he would like to have a tentative budget and timeline to present to City Council
because he wanted to move forward.
Councilmember Loftus agreed and stated that he wanted to see various funding scenarios; he
thought that it would take three (3) years to break ground.
Administrator Tucker remarked that the first decision was for the City to commit to the project
and that funding scenarios were dependent on budget decisions City-wide. She voiced confi-
dence that the funding could be pulled together by the time it was needed. In addition, informal
dialogue has been initiated with bond attorneys regarding re-financing the City’s bonds which
may produce savings that would free up money to be used toward this endeavor. At this time,
Administrator Tucker thought is was too preliminary to try to put together a budget.
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 3 of 9
The Administrator also noted that the asset base at the marina was going to increase based on
the value of the docks.
MOTION: Councilmember Buckhannon moved for staff to work with the
marina staff and consultant to pursue a Boating Infrastructure Grant;
Councilmember Loftus seconded.
Councilmember Loftus express concern that the City could move forward with the project with
multiple streams of money and without a tax increase for the citizens of the island.
VOTE: The motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
B. Review of FY14 Capital Budget and Long-range Capital Plan
Capital Purchases
Replace ice machine in store 6,000
Replace non-functioning store wa lk-in freezer 10,000
Replace HVAC in store 25,000
Replace store Point-of-Sale cash receipts system 30,000
Replace store coolers 90,000
Replace fuel dispensers – store 30,000
Replace fuel dispensers – docks 35,000
Special Projects
Design/permitting of new watersports/waverunner dock 50,000
Construction of new watersports/waverunner dock 329,000
Design/permit for new docks 100,000
Administrator Tucker explained that the design and permitting of the watersports dock will begin
very soon, but a portion of the project will bleed over into the FY14 budget; the budget will be
adjusted down as actions occur. Assistant Dziuban added that the FY13 budget had included
twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for this project, but the bids that came in were
considerably higher. The Administrator reported t hat the construction of that dock has also
been tweaked based on the design/build bids that were received.
The Administrator noted that the capital purchases listed were either in the store or the opera-
tions of the store; therefore, it needs to be reconciled to the lease to determine what elements
might be covered in the lease and what are not. Most of them are listed as assets of the City,
but the confusion arises as to who is responsible for the replacement; although, according to the
Administrator, in a true triple net lease, the responsibility for replacement falls to the tenant. The
Administrator interprets the listing of assets at the marina as an inventory that is in place with
the change of tenants, not a statement of responsibility for replacement by the City.
Both the Administrator and Chair Stone recalled that the tenant came to the Committee in the
fall of 2012 asking for assistance; he was told by the Committee to bring these items back
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 4 of 9
before the Committee during the budgeting process, which he has done. If the City is going to
replace these items, the lease needs to be amended to reflect who is responsible for what.
Administrator Tucker recalled that some work had been done on the coolers in the early 2000s;
the Administrator agreed to research the details.
Since the plan is to replace the docks and fuel system in a couple of years, the decision was
reached to remove the replacement cost from the FY14 budget. The canopy costs are dictated
by the price of steel and the height that the canopy must be to accommodate the various types
of boats at the marina. Other decisions reached were to change the language for the ice
machine and HVAC to indicate they will be replaced if they fail; the walk-in freezer, point-of-sale
system, canopy and store fuel dispensers will be replaced by the City after the lease is
amended to reflect the anticipated action.
As for a funding source, Chair Stone suggested that an argument could be made to use one of
the tourism funds to assist with the cost of the canopy.
Chair Stone summarized the discussion by stating that the tenant has requested an amendment
to the lease to include the City’s assuming replacement responsibility for the assets on the list.
Councilmember Buckhannon noted that these items will need to be added to the long-range
capital plan for future replacement timing.
In addition, based on the discussion about the boating infrastructure grant, the amount being
budgeted for design and permitting for new docks may be lowered to reflect only permitting
since the design element is grant eligible.
MOTION: Councilmember Buckhannon moved for the Administrator to work
with legal counsel to amend the marina store lease to include the assets the City
is willing to replace; Councilmember Loftus seconded and the motion PASSED
UNANIMOUSLY.
Beach Restoration and Monitoring
Potential Focused Erosion Project in FY14 600,000
Money would be capitalized from fund balance on-hand
Post-project surveys and monitoring, 2012 Shoal Mgmt Project 23,261
Ongoing monitoring of shoreline 49,646
FY14 is Yr2 of 3Yr contract
C. Discussion of Estimated Reserve Requirements
This large schedule has nothing to do with the Real Property Committee, but the Administrator
noted that she has been anxious to make sure that Councilmembers know what staff has done
to address the change in policy to save funds for the purchase of large capital assets, thereby
avoiding future indebtedness. The schedule addresses large fire apparatus for the Fire
Department and garbage packers in the Public Works Department and the savings needed to
be budgeted each year to purchase these pieces of equipment when the time comes.
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 5 of 9
Administrator Tucker explained that Option 1, the lines highlighted in yellow, represents the pure
method that is spreading the replacement cost of each vehicle equally over the year remaining
until the scheduled purchase; this method results in huge peaks and valleys in cash on-hand. In
Option 2, the lines highlighted in peach, the amount of annual savings is more level year-to-
year, eliminating the extreme peaks and valle ys. The numbers in blue represent the annual
reserve to be budgeted each year for each department and combined; for FY14 for the Fire
Department, the budgeted reserve needs to be three hundred fifty thousand dollars ($350,000).
The red numbers represent the years when money needs to be spent on those assets.
Factors not considered in the schedule are the interest earned on money held, the proceeds
from the sale of assets as they are replaced and the savings in interest paid on equipment
leases. The schedule does include a two percent (2%) annual inflation rate on replacement
costs.
Councilmember Buckhannon asked how the replacement values had been calculated, and
Administrator Tucker said that she would get that information from Treasurer Suggs.
Councilmember Loftus was interested in how the useful life had been determined; the
Administrator said that the useful life was taken from the long-range capital plan. The
Councilmember stated that he had read recently that the City of Charleston uses twenty years
(20 yrs.) as the useful life of their fire equipment. Councilmember Buckhannon thought twenty
years (20 yrs.) was high, but he did think that eighteen years (18 yrs.) was reasonable for equip-
ment that is well maintained. The Administrator explained that, when a piece of equipment
comes up for replacement, it is carefully evaluat ed, and, if it is still in good condition, the
replacement is postponed for a year to be re-evaluated. The worst case scenario would be for a
piece of equipment to fail in less time than anticipated, requiring a purchase when sufficient
funds had not yet been set aside.
In terms of what other municipalities are doing, Administrator Tucker commented that the Isle of
Palms is very fortunate to have the flexibility to try to avoid incurring debt when purchasing large
pieces of equipment. The Administrator noted that many interior local governments in the state
are struggling to provide basic needs for their constituents; many of the larger local govern-
ments are rolling the purchases into long-term financing or funding out of fund balance, if they
have the fund balance to do so.
6. New Business
A. Review of Operating Budgets for FY14
Only line items with a change will be noted, and copies of all budget discussed are attached to
the historical record of the meeting.
Front Beach Area
Printing and office supplies 3,200
Increased by $200; supplies for pa rking meter kiosks and ticketing devices
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 6 of 9
Telephone and Cable 1,000
Service to ER call boxes; reduced based on actual
Non-capital tools and equipment 11,100
Replace 3 handheld ticket writers purchased in 2006
Maintenance and service contracts 31,450
Reduced by $700
Machinery and equipment repair 7,500
Increased based on actual; includes part for repairs on aging kiosks
BSO uniforms 2,000
Outfitting 6 BSOs vs. 4 in FY13
Insurance 1,171
Property and liability on parking meters, lights, fixtures
Professional services 11,300
Reduced by $200 based on actual
Responding to Councilmember Loftus’ question about the large increase in “actual” for FY13,
Administrator Tucker said that she thought this was the line item from which Stantec was being
paid, but she would confirm with the Treasurer.
Councilmember Buckhannon questioned the increased number of BSOs; the Administrator
explained that the City had gotten the grant from Charleston County last year for additional
BSOs. The City hopes to keep six (6) because it worked well with increased presence and
increased enforcement. Councilmember Loftus asked whether the City had an increase in
revenue based on additional BSOs; Administrator Tucker responded that she would have to
confirm that with Treasurer Suggs and have the information for Ways and Means. Chair Stone
asked that the Administrator also ask Chief Buckhannon whether the added presence had
reduced crimes on the beach.
Public Restrooms/Front Beach Area
Cleaning and sanitary supplies 5,800
Increased $300 based on actual
Insurance 2,868
Property, liability and flood with an estimated 5% rate increase
On the subject of the contract to fill holes on the beach, Assistant Dziuban explained that the
City is billed for work done, but the contract has a cap of six thousand dollars ($6,000).
Beach Restoration Fund Revenue
Donations of Cash 630,000
Expected residual from private contributions to 2008 project, includes accumulated interest
Interest income 642
Annualized actual
Transfer in from Municipal Accommodations Fee Fund 315,482
Beach Restoration Fund Expenditure
Debt service principal 305,818
Final payment 6/10/14; 100% funded from Muni ATAX Fund
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 7 of 9
Debt service interest 9,664
Bank service charges 150
Professional services 23,261
Post-project requirements on FY12 shoal management project
Beach nourishment 600,000
Potential focused erosion project FY14
Beach Maintenance Fund Revenue (Island-wide)
Interest income 662
Annualized actual
Transfer in from State ATAX 49,646
Yr2 of 3Yr monitoring contract for entire coastline
Beach Maintenance Fund Expenditures (Island-wide)
Professional services 49,646
Yr2 of 3Yr monitoring contract for entire coastline
Marina Fund Revenue
Interest income 1,832
Marina store lease income 71,280
Current rent $5,940/month
Marina operations lease 160,500
Current annual base rent
Marina restaurant lease 81,710
Current annual base rent
Marina waverunner lease 20,496
Current base rent is $1,708/month
Marina Fund Transfers
Transfer in from State ATAX 178,157
⅓ of total marina debt service
Administrator Tucker noted that staff is in preliminary dialogue about re-financing certain City
debt, and the marina taxable bond is one (1) of these debts; as talks progress, the Committee
will be kept informed.
Marina Fund Expenditures
Debt service – interest 109,471
Total interest on Marina GO bond and Marina bulkhead GO bond
Insurance – marina store 2,088
Property, liability and flood; City pays underground tank premium
Insurance – marina operations 81,639
Includes a portion of dock coverage and property, liability and underground tanks for docks
Insurance – marina restaurant 20,556
Includes a portion of dock coverage; property, liability and flood premiums
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 8 of 9
Total marina expenses show a decrease of three percent (3%) from FY13.
B. Update on Design/Engineering Bid for Watersports Dock
Assistant Dziuban distributed the bid tabulation from the bid opening of February 20
th, and a
copy is attached to the historical record of this meeting.
Assistant Dziuban noted that the City had hoped to complete this project before the tourist
season began, but, when the bids were opened, staff realized that this was not realistic;
construction will take place in the fall.
The bids were fairly complicated – they were proposals, rather than bids, and some had
different task elements; the proposals had to be reviewed in depth in order to make just compar-
isons between them. The geo-technical refers to kind of sediment that is under and around the
dock to know how long the piles need to be and how hard they have to be driven down; some
firms said the City may already have the data, some said it might be necessary and other said it
was absolutely necessary. In reviewing the bid tabulation, if the company addressed geo-
technical, the amount attributed to it is under the bid for design and engineering and would need
to be added in for the bid total if deemed necessary.
Two (2) of the six (6) bids were for design/build, rather than a design/bid/build number, and
those were the numbers that influenced changes in the capital budget.
The apparent low bidder, Ocean and Coastal Consultants, has an asterisk next to their bid; in
the cover letter, they expressed concern with the contract language in that their insurance
carrier has said to them that they would deny some of the coverage levels that are included in
the contract. The City includes the contract with the bid package and indicates that one should
not bid if unable to sign it upon award.
Ocean and Coastal Consultants sent to Assistant Dziuban the specific language they are
objecting to in the contract, who then discussed thei r concerns with City Attorney Halversen. In
the attorney’s opinion, the City and the vendor could meet in the middle on some things,
concede on some things, but not concede outright to items, such as indemnification. In terms of
a motion, Assistant Dziuban suggested that, if the Committee were considering the lowest
bidder, the award be contingent upon successful contract negotiations.
The Assistant stated that she had also contacted the second low bidder, who did not include
geo-technical in their bid, but did acknowledge the need verbally and did not offer a cost for the
work. Their bid would be impacted by the fact that the City does not a valid OCRM critical line
permit, of which they were unaware. They stated that they have not issues with the contract.
Councilmember Loftus asked whether the City had history of working with any of the bidders;
the City does have history with GEL Engineering, Coastal Science and Engineering and Jon,
Guerry, Taylor and Associates. When asked about the City’s satisfaction with each, Assistant
Dziuban stated that there had been difficulties with Jon, Guerry, Taylor and Associates, but any
of the others could do the work.
Real Property Committee
March 6, 2013
Page 9 of 9
Chair Stone voiced the opinion that the Committee needs to make a decision; obtaining a permit
may take six (6) months.
MOTION: Councilmember Loftus moved to award a contract to Ocean &
Coastal Consultants Inc. contingent upon successful contract negotiations; Chair
Stone seconded.
Amendment: Chair Stone amended the motion to award the contract to the
second low bidder, Applied Technology and Management, if a contract cannot be
negotiated with Ocean & Coastal Consultants; Councilmember Loftus seconded
and the amendment PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
VOTE on Amended Motion: The amended motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Consideration of Contracts in Excess of $10,000 – None
7. Miscellaneous Business
Marina Rents Report
All marina tenants are current, and Morgan Creek Grill has paid a month in advance.
Next Meeting Date: 5:30 p.m., Tuesday, April 2, 2013 in the Conference Room.
8. Executive Session – not needed
9. Adjourn
MOTION: Councilmember Buckhannon moved to adjourn the meeting at 7:48
p.m.; Councilmember Loftus seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.