Special Meeting, September 19 (PDF, 15.34 KB)
City of Isle of Palms · Charleston County · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Isle of Palms
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
REAL PROPERTY COMMITTEE
SPECIAL MEETING
4:00 p.m., Thursday, September 19, 2013
A Special Meeting of the Real Property Committee was held at 4:00 p.m. on Thursday,
September 19, 2013 in the City Hall Conference R oom, 1207 Palm Boulevard, Isle of Palms,
South Carolina. Attending the meeting were Councilmember Loftus and Stone, Chair
Buckhannon, City Administrator Tucker, Assistant to the Administrator Dziuban, City Clerk
Copeland and John Shaffer, Ocean and Coastal Consultants. A quorum was present to
conduct business.
1. Chair Buckhannon called the meeting to order and acknowledged that the press and
public had been duly notified of the meeting in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act.
2. Discussion of Tidal Wave Dock Replacement
A. Design Options
Assistant Dziuban reported that there is still no consensus among the parties in dispute, but
they have met. The results of that meeting are the new sketches included in the meeting
packet, but there are still objections. Assistant Dziuban stated that she had received an e-mail
from Phillip Smith stating that he wants Tidal Wave to use the existing footprint of the building
and to re-use the pilings where they are.
In response to Councilmember Loftus’s desire to re-use materials when possible to save costs,
Mr. Shaffer stated that he does not recommend re-using the pilings in this case because they
are of an indeterminate age and are not spaced properly.
Assistant Dziuban stated that she had received no communication from the Fiem brothers, but
added that the City is becoming anxious about the timeline.
Mr. Shaffer reported that his original scope of work had been to work with the tenants and the
City to replace the Tidal Wave Watersports dock. He stated that he had done a visual
observation of the existing dock and made certain determinations including that the repairs done
last year were done properly, the pilings appear to be in good condition, but the he was unsure
about the older part of the structure. The handrails are unsafe and the pilings were re-used by
R.L. Morrison in an emergency repair. The existing thirty-five foot (35 ft.) pilings were never
expected to be permanent. He reiterated that they are of indeterminate age and should actually
be forty-five to fifty feet (45-50 ft.) in length. Re-using them would require new pilings in
between them since they are improperly spaced and they complicate the length of the gangway.
Councilmember Stone noted that the structure is needed to protect the employees from the sun
and to make the experience more pleasurable for their guests. The existing structure is too
small to accommodate guests.
Mr. Shaffer stated that the pier head as originally drawn was twenty-four feet by twenty-four feet
(24 ft. X 24 ft.); the Fiem brothers have determined that they need a minimum of twenty feet by
twenty feet (20 ft. X 20 ft.), which is a reduction of one hundred seventy-six feet (176 ft.). Mr.
Shaffer was confident that such a change would not require a permit modification, but a letter of
explanation would suffice with the regulating agencies.
Special Real Property Committee
September 19, 2013
Page 2 of 4
Of the new sketches, Alternate 3 is closest to the existing pier head, but would require
extending the gangway and a permit modification with public notice. Mr. Shaffer pointed out
that maneuvering behind the dock in this sketch would be difficult to do safely because the
distance between the Tidal Wave dock and the Morgan Creek docks is only fifteen feet (15 ft.)
Councilmember Loftus expressed concern over the cost of the project and asked whether the
floating dock could be re-used. Mr. Shaffer responded that the dock was not worth re-using, but
that it could be included in the bid as an alternate. Councilmember Loftus remarked that the
area in the design allowing for picnic tables and an observation deck may need to be removed
from the final project to keep costs low.
Administrator Tucker noted that the budget for the project is three hundred twenty-nine
thousand dollars ($329,000), and Alternate 3 is estimated to cost three hundred fifteen thousand
dollars ($315,000). The Administrator also advised the Committee that they approved
everything in the drawings and the permit prior to permit application. Additionally, the City can
bid the construction with alternates to allow flexibility depending on the actual costs.
Mr. Shaffer explained that the Fiem brothers are going to construct the center island in the
structure; he is only involved with the pier-head, cover and the utilities
Kathy Smith, 8 Intracoastal Court, asked if they could enclose that structure in the future and
Mr. Shaffer assured her they could not. Administrator Tucker said she understood that they
would have pull-down shutters to protect the electronics on the island.
Mr. Shaffer stated that he did not fully support either Alternate 2 or Alternate 3, which were
generated based on the meeting of the Fiem brothers and Phillip Smith and which he did not
attend. Neither Alternate 2 nor Alternate 3 meet industry standard guidelines; there should be
a distance of thirty-five feet (35 ft.) between the Tidal Wave floating dock and the nearest docks.
He noted that, when the Fiem brothers and Mr. Smith had met, he was not present to give any
input to their suggestions.
Mrs. Smith stated that she and her husband interpret this new dock as a way for the Fiems to
grow their business and asked if their doing so would require a modification to their lease. Mr.
Shaffer indicated that that issue was between the City and Tidal Wave Watersports.
Mr. Shaffer noted that the floating dock is only two feet (2 ft.) longer than the current floating
dock, but it is in a space with a lower shoaling rate, which is a better use of City funds regarding
future dredging projects.
Councilmember Loftus called the Committee’s attention to the Fund Balance Roll Forward
schedule distributed at the last Ways and Means Committee meeting and noted that the Marina
Fund balance will be reduced in FY14 due to this project. Councilmember Loftus questioned
why the City had spent eighty thousand dollars ($80,000) repairing the dock last season if only
to face a costly replacement project this seas on. Councilmember Loftus’s primary concern is a
cost-effective project. Councilmember Stone recalled that the dollar figure for last year’s repairs,
as a result of the dredging project, cost less than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) and were
unavoidable.
Special Real Property Committee
September 19, 2013
Page 3 of 4
Mr. Shaffer stated that Alternate 2 was a compromise and, of the two (2), the one (1) he would
recommend; this option should get regulatory approval with only a letter and possibly delay the
project only a month. (This option is not the preference of the Smiths.) Alternate 3 would
require another public notice period, but Mr. Shaffer indicated that he did not want to take
anything to a regulatory agency until a final decision has been reached.
The Committee wondered if another meeting of the affected parties with “pen and paper” was
warranted. Councilmember Buckhannon remarked that such a meeting had already taken
place. Assistant Dziuban stated that another meeting could occur, but that John Schaffer’s
presence at the meeting would result in an expense to the City.
Marina Manager Berrigan joined the discussion and voiced opposition to both Alternates 2 and
3 presented because they were too close to marina docks. He suggested that the dock be
moved close to the land-side fence and head straight out, rather than at an angle.
Councilmember Loftus pointed out that this moved everything closer to the Smith’s property,
and Administrator Tucker noted that SCE&G has an under-water line and an easement in that
area.
Discussions continued and Councilmember Loftus suggested pulling back from the project and
simply dealing with the safety issues now. Councilmember Buckhannon stated that, if the two
(2) parties could not reach an agreement, the Committee would make a final decision at the
October meeting.
B. Expanded Scope of Ocean and Coastal Consultants Contract
Assistant Dziuban explained that the additional work, i.e. sketches, Ocean and Coastal
Consultants has been asked to do puts them beyond the scope of their original contract. They
have submitted a change order to their contract totaling five thousand four hundred fifty dollars
($5,450); Task 1 is for additional technical assistance for twenty-eight hundred dollars ($2,800)
and Task 2 is for two thousand six hundred fifty dollars ($2,650) for work if the permit must be
modified. The total budget for design and engineering was thirty-two thousand six hundred
dollars ($32,600); Ocean and Coastal Consultants original contract was for twenty-six thousand
six hundred dollars ($26,600), leaving a balance of six thousand dollars ($6,000) to
accommodate the total of five thousand four hundred fifty dollars ($5,450) for the change order.
MOTION: Chair Buckhannon moved to approve up to $5,450 for a change
order to the contract for Ocean and Coastal Consultants; Councilmember Loftus
seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
C. Potential to Submit Permit Amendment
The possible need to submit a permit amendment has been discussed along with the design
options.
3. Adjourn
Special Real Property Committee
September 19, 2013
Page 4 of 4
MOTION: Councilmember Stone moved to adjourn the meeting at 5:02 p.m.;
Councilmember Loftus seconded and the motion PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Respectfully submitted:
Marie Copeland
City Clerk
Source: City of Isle of Palms website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.