RecordWell Data

building codes agenda_2022-08-01_final

City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Jul 29, 2022 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Mauldin

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE MEETING MONDAY , AUGUST 1 , 202 2 | 6 PM 4th committee meeting Please note that members of the public may attend this meeting in-person but are encouraged to participate remotely. The meeting will be available remotely through Zoom. Please visit the City’s website at https://cityofmauldin.org/your-government/meeting- minutes-agendas/ to access the meeting via audio and videoconferencing. A quorum of Council will be present. The Committee will meet in the Mauldin City Hall at 5 East Butler Road in the Council Chambers at 6 p.m. Building Codes (BDS) Committee AGENDA August 1, 2022 Committee Members: Diane Kuzniar (Chair), Taft Matney, Frank Allgood The Honorable Diane Kuzniar The Honorable Diane Kuzniar The Honorable Diane Kuzniar The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 1. Call to Order 2. Public Comment 3. Reading and Approval of Minutes a. Building Codes Committee Meeting: July 5, 2022 (Pages 3-4) 4. Reports or Communications from City Officers a. BDS Director David Dyrhaug 5. Unfinished Business None The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 6. New Business a. An ordinance to rezone property consisting of approximately 23 acres located at North Main Street (portion of tax map parcel: #M008.04-01-004.00) and providing an effective date (Pages 5-15) b. An ordinance to rezone property consisting of approximately 5 acres located at West Butler Road and Laurel Meadows Parkway (tax map parcel: #M008.02-01-003.00) and providing an effective date (Pages 16-27) c. An ordinance to provide for the annexation of property owned by W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones, and located at 30 Tanner Road (tax map parcel: 0547.03-01-043.01 & 0547.03-0 1-043.02) by one hundred percent petition method; and to establish a zoning classification of PD, Planned Development, for said property (Pages 28-97) d. An ordinance to provide for the annexation of property owned by C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. The Honorable Diane Kuzniar Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 1 Ayscue, and located at 50 Tanner Road (tax map parcel: 0547.03-01-043.00) by one hundred percent petition method; and to establish a zoning classification of PD, Planned Development for said property (Pages 28-97) 7. Public Comment The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 8. Committee Concerns The Honorable Diane Kuzniar 9. Adjourn The Honorable Diane Kuzniar Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 2 Minutes Building Codes (BDS) Committee July 5, 2022 5th Committee Meeting Committee Members: Diane Kuzniar (Chair), Taft Matney, Frank Allgood Others present: City Administrator Brandon Madden 1. Call to Order- Chairwoman Kuzniar 2. Public Comment Clay Aldobal: I live at 103 Braddock Drive in Knollwood. I want to talk about as a concerned citizen, I wanted to put a voice to my concerns. My concerns are about the degrading of Knollwood and probably pertain to other neighborhoods in Mauldin as well. I would like to specifically address two major issues. The first is codes that protect the appearance of properties. I am aware that some people have had visits for code infractions to keep their grass from getting too high and I am also aware that people have been alerted to not keep trucks and trailers in their front yards, yet there seems to be no solution for keeping down the number of cars in a yard or streets. I assume the provisions are to keep our neighborhood looking nice and protect property values. I must say there are several cars parked in yards. The second issue I want to address piggybacks on the first. This concerns the zoning of single family homes. In these times of high costs, you are seeing multiple families move in and split the cost of a house. In my mind, it is not a single-family home. In some cases, there are rooms being rented out by the occupants. These two circumstances could cause codes issues as previously stated. They could also cause multiple cars to be parked on the streets in some cases. A neighbor has a car parked in the street almost constantly and it is not theirs, nor a guest. I looked through the zoning ordinance and there are more restrictions for businesses regarding parking than there are for single family homes. Again, I am not saying the restrictions are not necessary for businesses, because I believe they are, but it lets businesses know what the expectations are. I believe similar expectations should be afforded to homeowners. With that said, I am wondering what it means to have single family home zoning if it doesn’t enforce single families. I understand it is not unusual to have an older child move back in for a short time, for many reasons, even so, there must be a solution that will protect the appearance of property. I am not saying this is an easy issue to resolve, but I am saying it will require the City to step up to eliminate these issues that are eroding our neighborhoods. I am saying that zoning for single family homes must mean something. I am asking for an alignment of section 1-1 of your zoning ordinance document that states that the zoning regulations “have been made with reasonable consideration, among other things, to the character of each district and peculiar suitability for particular uses, and with a view to conserving the value of buildings and encouraging the most appropriate use of land throughout the City of Mauldin. “ That is exactly what I am looking for. That we have something protecting our property values as we see these cars in yards, it is degrading the value of our property. Thank you for hearing my concerns. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 3 3. Reading and Approval of Minutes a. Building Codes Committee Meeting: June 6, 2022 Motion: Councilman Allgood made a motion to accept the minutes with Councilman Matney seconding. Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0). 4. Reports or Communications from City Officers a. BDS Director David Dyrhaug Budget Review- No report 5. Unfinished Business- There is no unfinished business. 6. New Business- There is no new business. 7. Public Comment- None 8. Committee Concerns- None 9. Adjournment- Chairwoman Kuzniar adjourned the meeting at 6:18 p.m. Respectfully Submitted, Cindy Miller Municipal Clerk Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 4 BUILDING CODES COMMITEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: August 1, 2022 AGENDA ITEM: 6a TO: Building Codes Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Rezoning at N Main Street REQUEST The City of Mauldin has received a signed petition requesting the rezoning of a tract of land pursuant to Section 4:2 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance. This petition includes approximately 23 acres located along N. Main Street between Kellett’s Korner/Tommy’s Snack Bar at 602 N. Main Street and the C.F. Sauer manufacturing facility at 728 N. Main Street. Specifically, this rezoning includes the portion of the property on the east side of the railroad tracks. The applicant ha s requested that this tract be rezoned from I-1, Industrial, to R-M, Multi-Family Residential. The applicant is planning to develop a townhome community described below. HISTORY/BACKGROUND This tract is currently undeveloped and is heavily wooded. Several groups have examined this property for development in recent years. However, providing access to this property, particularly for industrial development, has been extremely challenging. Existing railroad tracks cut off access to N. Main Street and the railroad company has not granted permission to cross the tracks. OWNER(S): TJA, LLC – Robert Tommy Kellett AUTHORIZED REP(S): Barrett Wood  Parker Group Services TAX MAP NUMBER(S): p/o #M008.04-01-004.00 LOCATION: Property along N. Main Street between 602 N. Main St. and 728 N. Main St. CURRENT ZONING: I-1, Industrial REQUESTED ZONING: R-M, Multi-Family Residential SIZE OF PROPERTY: Approx. 23 acres Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 5 PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT At present, a company called Parker Group is proposing to d evelop a 99-unit townhome community on approximately 15 acres of this tract. This community would consist of high-end townhomes with projected price points around $320,000 to $340,000. The community would also include a half -acre central community area. Access. Access to this proposed development project will be via Green Street at the end of Murray Drive. The developer has purchased a nearly 1-acre tract at 9 Green Street where he plans to demolish the existing home and construct a new street through the property which will provide access to the proposed development. According to the Mauldin’s development regulations, 99 homes are the most homes that can be developed with a single access (provided that the access is at least 26 feet wide to the first intersection). Buffering. The developer has indicated that he would like to install an attractive buffer between this proposed development project and the adjacent Whispering Oaks townhome community. He is considering tree preservation, heavy shrubbery, and/or fencing for the buffer. Dedicated land for park and trail development. On the rema ining portion of the 23-acre tract, the developer is proposing to dedicate approximately 6.7 acres for a future park constructed by the City of Mauldin and an additional 1.5 acres for an entrance road into the future park. Additionally, the developer is proposing to reserve a 21-foot easement along the edge of the property next to the railroad right-of-way for future pedestrian and bicycle trail construction. About Parker Group On their website, Parker Group summarizes their mission as: “We value people over profit.” They describe their approach to real estate as “caring about people and empowering them to begin the next phase of their lives. It’s about being visionary, seeing a need and creating the solution proactively. It’s about impacting lives. Our team does it all with professionalism, unbridled intelligence, and a tenacious curiosity that keeps us moving forward.” The Parker Group has undertaken development projects across Greenville including the Hub (14 modern Scandinavian-inspired townhomes), the Commons (commercial adaptive reuse development) , Custom House Condos (luxury condos on South Main Street), Burdette Street Cottages (7 homes in the Village of West Greenville’s Arts District), and West Park & Townes (6 townhome units in downtown Greenville). In addition, the Parker Group is redeveloping the former site of Family Dollar/Rite Aid/Eckerd’s in Mauldin at the corner of N. Main Street and E. Butler Road. NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING In accordance with Section 4:3.3 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance, the applicant held a neighborhood meeting on June 8, 2022. Based on the sign-in sheet, it appears that approximately 15 neighbors attended the meeting, most of whom were from the Whispering Oaks townhome community. According to the meeting summary provided by the applicant, questions and concerns covered topics including: traffic, tree preservation, stormwater runoff, landscape buffering and screening, townhome size and price points. Attached is the applicant’s summary of the neighborhood meeting. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 6 PUBLIC HEARING The Planning Commission held a public hearing on July 26, 2022. One non-resident citizen spoke at the public hearing. • Sam Davis, with Upstate Greenways & Trails Alliance, spoke in support of the project highlighting that the proposed establishment of a trail easement along this property will help in the expansion of the Swamp Rabbit Trail from CU-ICAR to Mauldin. ZONING EVALUATION Existing Zoning Classification The I-1 district is established to accommodate manufacturing, assembly, warehousing, and distribution operations. It is the intent of the district that such operations do not produce harmful noise, odor, smoke, dust, glare, or pollution. Proposed Zoning Classification The R -M zoning designation i s a multi -family residential district intended to provide a full range of medium- to high-density multi-family housing types in addition to detached and attached single -family homes recreational, religious, and educational facilities. This district is int ended to provide a transition between single-family districts and commercial districts. Development standards associated with the R-M zoning district include: • Maximum density: 16 units per acre • Maximum building height: 45 feet • Minimum perimeter setbacks: 25 feet • Buffer required next to Whispering Oaks community: none required by ordinance • Minimum open space: 15 percent of development area • Minimum parking: 1.5 parking spaces per multi-family dwelling unit; 2 parking spaces per single- family dwelling unit Surrounding Development/Zoning These properties are surrounded by the following zoning and land uses: Direction Zoning District(s) Existing Use(s) North I-1 (City) C.F. Sauer and other industrial facilities South R-M (City) Whispering Oaks townhome community East I-1 (City) Various industrial businesses West C-2 (City) Landscape strip between railroad tracks and N. Main Street Comprehensive Plan Vision This property is designated as an “employment center” in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan. Employment Center areas are intended for industrial parks and office parks. However, this designation in the Comprehensive Plan does not account for the constrained access to this property. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 7 REVIEW CRITERIA The Mauldin Zoning Ordinance does not contain any specified criteria that should be considered by the Planning Commission when reviewing requests for rezoning. However, the following criteria are typical of those used by other jurisdictions. A. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed since the Comprehensive Plan was adopted, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area; B. Suitability of the site’s ph ysical, geological, hydrological and other environmental features to support the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed in the proposed zoning district; C. Compatibility of all the potential uses allowed in the proposed zoning district with sur rounding uses and zoning districts in terms of suitability of location, impacts on the environment, noise, density, nature of use, traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop adjacent properties under existing zoning, and potential influence on property values; D. Capacity of public infrastructure and services to sufficiently accommodate all potential uses allowed in the proposed district without compromising public health, safety or welfare; and E. Public need for the potential uses permitted in the requested zoning district. STAFF FINDINGS The analysis below includes staff findings pertaining to each criterion. CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 1. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area; This property is designated as a n “employment center” in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan. Employment Center areas are intended for industrial parks and office parks. However, the failed attempts in recent years to design the type of access required for an employment center, it would appear that the conditions for this property have changed. Considering that Green Street appears to be the only viable solution for acc ess at this time, the proposed development of a townhome community at this tract seems to be more consistent with the general character of the other properties along Green Street. The Planning Commission and the City Council may or may not judge that the proposed rezoning is consistent with the intent of the comprehensive plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area. 2. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological, hydrological and other environmental features to support the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed There is a small area (approximately one-half acre) along the easternmost corner of the property located in a floodplain. To staff’s knowledge, there are no other apparent floodplains, wetlands, or topographic constraints on the site. Staff is not aware of any features at this site that would make it unsuitable for development. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 8 CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 3. Compatibility of the potential uses allowed with surrounding uses and zoning districts in terms of suitability of location, impacts on the environment, noise, density, nature of u se, traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop adjacent properties under existing zoning, and potential influence on property values The tract is located in a transitional area between railroads tracks, industrial properties on the backside, and townh omes and detached homes to the south. Considering that the property will be accessed via Green Street, it would seem that a residential development would be better suited for this site than would an industrial or office park development, in terms of traff ic, noise, aesthetics, and other potential impacts . The Planning Commission and the City Council may or may not judge that this rezoning is compatible with the surrounding uses. 4. Capacity of public infrastructure and services to sufficiently accommodate p otential uses allowed without compromising public health, safety, or welfare Staff is not aware of any utilities, including water and sewer, that would not be available at this tract. This project is expected to connect to the existing ReWa sewer line along the southern edge of the property. If the project will generate more than 100 peak hour trips, the applicant will be required to provide a traffic impact study (TIS) before the development plans can be approved. It does not appear at this time that t his project will generate more than 100 peak hour trips. Therefore, a traffic impact study is not likely to be required for this development project prior to preliminary plat. 5. Public need for the potential uses permitted The Comprehensive Plan forecasts that an aging population, shrinking household sizes, and affordability will continue to increase the demand for smaller, low-maintenance housing. The current conceptual development proposal would provide additional living options that support this forecas t in the Comprehensive Plan. Additionally, t his rezoning also helps to meet the high demand for housing around this area. TIMELINE On June 8, 2022, the applicant met with interested neighbors to review their proposal and to seek questions and comments. On June 17, 2022, staff received the request to rezone this tract. On July 26, 2022, the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing. At this meeting, the Planning Commission voted 5-0 to recommend approval of the rezoning. STAFF RECOMMENDATION In staff’s opinion, it appears that the conceptual residential community at this tract has the potential to introduce lesser impacts in terms of noise, traffic, aesthetics, and similar impacts in comparison to the type Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 9 of development that would otherwise be allowed by the current zoning of the property. For these reasons, it appears that the conceptual residential community may be more compatible to the adjacent Whispering Oaks townhome community than the current zoning for industrial development . Furthermore, the dedication of land for public park and trail development may be a worthwhile endeavor for the City of Mauldin as it seeks to expand pedestrian and bicycle facilities within the City. Ultimately, the Planning Commission and the City Council will need to make a judgment on whether (1) this rezoning is consistent with the vision for the future of this area, (2) the rezoning is compatible with the surrounding uses, and (3) any other factors that they deem pertinent. PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION On July 26, 2022, the Planning Commission voted 5-0 to recommend approval of the rezoning. ATTACHMENTS Proposed ordinance (maps included therein) Neighborhood meeting information Conceptual drawing(s) Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 10 ORDINANCE # __________ AN ORDINANCE TO REZONE PROPERTY CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY 23 ACRES LOCATED AT NORTH MAIN STREET (PORTION OF TAX MAP PARCEL: #M008.04-01-004.00) AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE WHEREAS, TJA LLC, has petitioned the City of Mauldin to rezone +/- 23 acres from the I-1, Industrial District, to the R-M, Multi-family Residential District; and WHEREAS, a rezoning of the parcel is in keeping with the City of Mauldin 2014 Comprehensive Plan Update; and WHEREAS, the site is suitable for the types of uses that could be developed under the new zoning district; and WHEREAS, the potential uses permitted in the new zoning district meet a public need and are not detrimental to the public health, safety, and welfare; and WHEREAS, the Mauldin Planning Commission has given favorable recommendation to the zoning application; and NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the mayor and City Council of the City of Mauldin, South Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof Section 1. That the property described in zoning docket PC-2022-09-RZ and Greenville County Tax Map Parcel M008.04-01-004.00 be rezoned from I-1 to R-M, Multi-family Residential. The property is further identified on the attached exhibit that is hereby incorporated into this ordinance, including Exhibit 1, Zoning & Property Map. Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage. Passed on First Reading ________________________________ Passed on Second Reading ______________________________ CITY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA ATTEST: BY: ________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ___________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: ___________________________________ John Duggan, City Attorney Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 11 EXHIBIT 1 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 12 Neighborhood Meeting Notes Property: 23 acres at N. Main Street and 9 Green Street – Rezoning Meeting Date: June 8, 2022 Meeting Time: 6 PM Meeting Location: Mauldin Library Summary: We are looking to rezone 23 acres from Industrial to Residential. The property has some access challenges. We have spoken with everyone surrounding the property regarding access. We purchased a residential home (9 Green Street) to obtain access to the property off Green Street. It seems the highest and best use for this property is residential. We do not feel anyone would want commercial or industrial traffic accessing the property off of Green Street. One entrance does offer the ability for 99 townhomes. With it being 23 acres and a lot of property for the number of units we wanted to provide land for the swamp rabbit trail as well as a city park. We feel this could be a nice park for walking trails, bike trails, picnic tables or whatever the city feels would be best. It is 23 acres in a great location so we want to create a win-win for the community and us. Questions from the attendees along with my answers: 1) How do we plan to buffer the community from Whispering Oaks? We plan to do heavy landscaping, save as many existing trees as possible and possibly add a fence if needed. 2) What does this look like from a traffic standpoint? Based on a preliminary study by, Matt Short @ Short Engineering and Consulting out of Columbia, SC – He stated that the trip generation falls under the 100 trip threshold. I also stated, I am in the process of getting a more in depth study performed and will be more than happy to share that information once I receive it. 3) What about water run off – will it come onto Whispering Oaks property? The low-lying area of the property tends to be towards the detention pond shown in the drawing. We plan to work with our civil engineers to certainly make sure that no additional water is sent towards Whispering Oaks. 4) One person referenced a previous wreck on Green Street and had some traffic concerns. It also was asked or brought up about the entrance and if Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 13 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 13 that could potentially be shifted and be more of a straight drive into the entrance. - We can look into a straighter entrance but we need to look into the setbacks required by the Railroad. Regarding accidents, it is my understanding that we are looking to have railroad crossing arms in the future off Murray Street and also there is hope for a Traffic Light at the Intersection of Main and Murray. I thought perhaps these additional units could assist with the requirements for the traffic light. 5) What size will the townhomes be? Somewhere in the 2000 sqft range. 6) What price point will the townhomes be? Projecting in the $300’s 7) How many stories will the townhomes be? Most likely 2 stories The majority of the questions & comments centered on as 1 attendee kept stating the “ 2 T’s” – Traffic and Trees. Most attendees were from Whispering Oaks and wanted reassurance of nice landscaping and an overall nice community. The overall reception seemed positive as most folks understood that at some point the land would probably get developed and felt that residential was the best use. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 14 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 14 MAIL KIOSK DETENTION LANDSCAPE AREA 25' LANDSCAPE AREA LANDSCAPE AREA 21' FUTURE SWAMP RABBIT TRAIL EASEMENT 21' FUTURE SWAMP RABBIT TRAIL EASMENT COMMUNITY AREA PROPOSED future park (by city) +/- 6.7 ACRE (+ 1.5 ACRE ENTRANCE ROAD) 1 4 MILE TRAIL LOOP INTERCONNECTIVITY TO PARK 50' PARK MONUMENT PARK ACCESS ROAD (BY CITY) 25' LANDSCAPE AREA LANDSCAPE AREA 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 7273 74 757677 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 26' 26' 24' 15' R40 R50 84' 84' 84.75' STAKEOUT PLAN A - - - - - - - CV-1 7/20/22 Allston Townes-P7.dwg N S W E Feet 0 100 200 ' 1" =100 132 PILGRIM ROAD · GREENVILLE, SC 29607PH: (864) 297-3027 · FAX: (864) 729-8747 WWW.GRAYENGINEERING.COM · SC C.O.A.# C00060 · NC C.O.A.# C-1217 · GA C.O.A.# PEF001941 · TN C.O.A.# 0410819 · REVISIONNO. DATE BY AUTHORIZED BY GRAY ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS, INC. IN WRITING. AND SHALL NOT BE USED OR REPRODUCED IN ANY WAY OTHER THAN SERVICE AND THE PROPERTY OF GRAY ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS, INC. THIS DRAWING AND ASSOCIATED CAD FILES ARE AN INSTRUMENT OF Gray Engineering PROJECT MANAGER: DRAWN BY: PROJECT DATE: SCALE: JOB No.: PLOT DATE: D C B A 1 2 3 4 5 6 SHEET ALLSTON TOWNES MAIN STREET CITY OF MAULDIN, SC REG CJR 1/26/22 2022XXX SITE DATA: CURRENT ZONING: I-1* NEW TOWNS: 99 TOWN SIZE: 24' WIDE (THORNWOOD) NEW ROAD: 2,490 L.F. GUEST PARKING: 50 SPACES * SITE NEEDS TO BE REZONED TO SUPPORT TOWNHOMES Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 15 BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: August 1, 2022 AGENDA ITEM: 6b TO: Building Codes Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Rezoning at W Butler Road and Laurel Meadows Pkwy REQUEST The City of Mauldin has received a signed petition requesting the rezoning of a tract of land pursuant to Section 4:2 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance. This petition includes approximately 5 acres located along W. Butler Road between Taylor Road and Laurel Meadows Parkway. The applicant has requested that this tract be rezoned from C-2, Commercial, to R-M, Multi-Family Residential. The applicant is planning to develop a townhome community described below. HISTORY/BACKGROUND This tract is currently undeveloped and is heavily wooded. This property has been listed as available for commercial development for the last few years. PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT At present, Arbor Land Design is proposing to develop a 57-unit townhome community on this 5-acre tract. This community would consist of townhomes with projected price points starting at $300,000 . The conceptual drawings for the proposed development do n ot depict any amenities but do include just under one acre of open space. OWNER(S): Abby & Matt, LLC AUTHORIZED REP(S): Austin Allen  Arbor Land Design TAX MAP NUMBER(S): #M008.02-01-003.00 LOCATION: Property along W. Butler Rd. between Taylor Rd. and Laurel Meadows Pkwy. CURRENT ZONING: C-2, Commercial REQUESTED ZONING: R-M, Multi-Family Residential SIZE OF PROPERTY: Approx. 5 acres Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 16 Access. Access to this proposed development project will be via two separate drives along Laurel Meadows Parkway. One drive will line up with Waterbrook Dr and the other drive will be slightly offset from the second driveway into the Mauldin Library parking lot. The intersection of W. Butler Road and Laurel Meadows Parkway is currently signalized which aids access at this intersection. Buffering. The developer has not provided information about buffering adjacent to the Laurel Meadows community but the conceptual drawings depict a storm water detention pond and open space adjacent to the Laurel Meadows community. About Arbor Land Design On their website, Arbor Land Design, also known as Arbor Engineering, describes its company as “actively engaged in all aspects of landscape architecture and design, including residential and commercial; urban planning; land use planning; parks and recreational development; and civil engineering.” Arbor Land Design has been involved with projects all across the Greenville area. They are currently involved with providing civil engin eering for Riley Trace, Hawk Haven, Bethel Townes, Madison Park, Miller Park, Holly Ridge, and Alston Chase, among others. NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING In accordance with Section 4:3.3 of the Mauldin Zoning Ordinance, the applicant held a neighborhood meeting on June 20, 2022. Based on the sign-in sheet, it appears that approximately 12 neighbors attended the meeting, most of whom were from the Laurel Meadows community and the Laurel Heights community. According to the meeting summary provided by the applicant, questions and concerns covered topics including: traffic, insufficiencies at the intersection of W Butler Road and Laurel Meadows Parkway, amenities, open space, tree preservation, stormwater run off, landscape buffering and screening, target demographic, price points, building façade materials, and rental homes . Attached is the applicant’s summary of the neighborhood meeting. PUBLIC HEARING The Planning Commission held a public on July 26, 2022. The following citizens spoke at the public hearing. • Joe Hanson, 512 Laurel Meadows Parkway, expressed support for rezoning this property from commercial but also shared some concerns about the proposed development of the site. His concerns included: (1) traffic at the intersection of Laurel Meadows Parkway and W. Butler Road and the lack of a dedicated left -turn arrow at the traffic signal for drivers on Laurel Meadows Parkway, (2) the challenge that Laurel Meadows has of other uninvited communities using the Laurel Meadows community pool, and (3) the displacement of wildlife. • Jane Triplett*, 3 Kalmia Creek Drive, indicated that she does not believe that the property and location is viable for commercial development. She commented that there is a curve along W. Butler Road that causes visibility issues at t he intersection of Laurel Meadows Parkway and W. Butler Road. She also commented that the additional development along Ashmore Bridge Road has resulted in increased traffic along Fowler Circle placing additional pressure on the signalized intersection at Laurel Meadows Parkway and W. Butler Road. * Please note that Ms. Triplett spoke after the floor had been closed to public comments but her comments are shared here anyway. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 17 ZONING EVALUATION Existing Zoning Classification The C-2 district is established to promote accessible and central concentrations of business activities and commercial establishments offering both retail goods and services to people from throughout the community. This district is intended to serve both pedestrians as well as people who travel by automobile. Therefore, this district is located along major roadways, and businesses are encouraged to locate in close proximity to one another. Where necessary, adjacent residential areas are protected through landscaping and site design. Proposed Zoning Classification The R -M zoning designation is a multi -family residential district intended to provide a full range of medium- to high-density multi-family housing types in addition to detached and attached single -family homes recreational, religious, and educational facilities. This district is intended to provide a transition between single-family districts and commercial districts. Development standards associated with the R-M zoning district include: • Maximum density: 16 units per acre • Maximum building height: 45 feet • Minimum perimeter setbacks: 25 feet • Buffer required next to Laurel Meadows community: none required by ordinance • Minimum open space: 15 percent of development area • Minimum parking: 1.5 parking spaces per multi-family dwelling unit; 2 parking spaces per single- family dwelling unit Surrounding Development/Zoning These properties are surrounded by the following zoning and land uses: Direction Zoning District(s) Existing Use(s) North PD (City) Laurel Meadows community South C-1 (City) Undeveloped commercial property East R-20 (City) Undeveloped residential property West C-2 (City)/ PD (City) Mauldin Library Laurel Heights community Comprehensive Plan Vision This property is designated as a “multifamily residential” and also as part of a “regional corridor” in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan. Multifamily residential areas are intended to include apartments, townhomes, and duplexes. They should have good access to major roads as well as parks and open space. A Regional Corridor is envisioned to include intense commercial uses, including “big box” retail, drive-through restaurants, large shopping centers, and automotive service centers. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 18 REVIEW CRITERIA The Mauldin Zoning Ord inance does not contain any specified criteria that should be considered by the Planning Commission when reviewing requests for rezoning. However, the following criteria are typical of those used by other jurisdictions. A. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed since the Comprehensive Plan was adopted, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area; B. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological, hydrological and other environmental features to support the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed in the proposed zoning district; C. Compatibility of all the potential uses allowed in the proposed zoning district with surrounding uses and zoning districts in terms of suitability of location, impacts on the environment, noise, density, nature of use, traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop adjacent properties under existing zoning, and potential influence on property values; D. Capacity of public infrastructure and services to sufficiently accommodate all potential uses allowed in the proposed district without compromising public health, safety or welfare; and E. Public need for the potential uses permitted in the requested zoning district. STAFF FINDINGS The analysis below includes staff findings pertaining to each criterion. CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 1. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area; This property is designated as “multifamily residential” and also as part of a “regional corridor” in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan. Multifamily residential areas are intended to include apartments, townhomes, and duplexes. A regional corridor is envisioned to include intense commercial uses, including “big box” retail, drive- through restaurants, large shopping centers, and automotive service centers. Consistent with the “regional corridor” designation along W. Butler Road and in the interest of expanding commercial opportunities along W. Butler Road, staff has commented to the applicant about preserving a commercial area along the front of this property. However, the applicant would rather rezone the entire property to multifamily residential. The Planning Commission and the City Council may or may not judge that the proposed rezoning is consistent with the intent of the comprehensive plan, recent development trends, and the gener al character of the area. 2. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological, hydrological and other environmental features to support the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed To staff’s knowledge, there are no apparent floodplains, wetlands, or topographic constraints on the site. Staff is not aware of any features at this site that would make it unsuitable for development. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 19 CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 3. Compatibility of the potential uses allowed with surrounding uses and zoning districts in terms of suitability of location, impacts on the environment, noise, density, nature of use, traffic impacts, aesth etics, ability to develop adjacent properties under existing zoning, and potential influence on property values The tract is located in a transitional area between the Laurel Meadows and Laurel Heights residential communities and commercial uses along W. Butler Road, albeit this section of W. Butler Road is currently underdeveloped in comparison to other sections of W. Butler Road to the east. It appears that the proposed residential development of this property is consistent with the residential communities along Laurel Meadows Parkway . However, the extension of this proposed residential development along the front of the property is less consistent with the general commercial development along W. Butler Road. The Planning Commission and the City Council may or may not judge that this rezoning is compatible with the surrounding uses. 4. Capacity of public infrastructure and services to sufficiently accommodate potential uses allowed without compromising public health, safety, or welfare Staff is not aware of any utilities, including water and sewer, that would not be available at this tract. This project is expected to connect to the existing City sewer line along Laurel Meadows Parkway. If the project will generate more than 100 peak hour trips, the applicant will be required to provide a traffic impact study (TIS) before the development plans can be approved. It does not appear at this time that this project will generate more than 100 peak hour trips . Therefore, a traffic impact study is not likely to be required for this development project prior to preliminary plat. Notwithstanding, some of the citizens that have commented on this project have indicated that there are some deficiencies at the intersection of Laurel Meadows Parkway and W. Butler Road. 5. Public need for the potential uses permitted The Comprehensive Plan forecasts that an aging population, shrinking household sizes, and affordability will continue to increase the demand for smaller, low-maintenance housing. The current conceptual development proposal would provide additional living options that support this forecast in the Comprehensive Plan. Additionally, t his rezoning also helps to meet the high demand for housing around this area. However, the Comprehensive Plan also has a stated goal to ensure an adequate supply of non -residential land to support future economic development. This rezoning of the front of this property away from commercial decreases the commercial growth opportunities along W. Butler Road. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 20 TIMELINE On June 20, 2022, the applicant met with interested neighbors to review their proposal and to seek questions and comments. On June 27, 2022, staff received the request to rezone this tract. On July 26, 2022, the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing. At this meeting, the Planning Commission voted 6-0 to recommend approval of the rezoning. STAFF RECOMMENDATION In staff’s opinion, the rezoning of the back part of this property for a townhome community appears consistent and compatible with the adjacent Laurel Meadows and Laurel Heights communities. Conversely, the presence of the proposed residential community along the front of W. Butler Road will introduce the first and only residential community that front W. Butler Road between Main Street and Plant Street/Hollyridge Court (notwithstanding th e main office for the Ashmore Bridge Estates apartment community fronts on W. Butler Road). It should be noted, however, that at Plant Street and Hollyridge Court, approximately one-quarter mile west of this site, the Gleneagle apartment community and the Holly Ridge subdivision both front along W. Butler Road. Additionally, the members of the surrounding community that have spoken about this project have expressed that they do not support commercial development at this property. Ultimately, the Planning Commission and the City Council will need to make a judgment on whether (1) this rezoning is consistent with the vision for the future of this area, (2) the rezoning is compatible with the surrounding uses, and (3) any other factors that they deem pertinent. PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION On July 26, 2022, the Planning Commission voted 6-0 to recommend approval of the rezoning. Please note that during their discussion, the Planning Commission expressed concern about the lack of amenities being planned for the development project and have encouraged the applicant to consider to include some amenities in this project. ATTACHMENTS Proposed ordinance (maps included therein) Neighborhood meeting information Conceptual drawing(s) Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 21 ORDINANCE # __________ AN ORDINANCE TO REZONE PROPERTY CONSISTING OF APPROXIMATELY 5 ACRES LOCATED AT WEST BUTLER ROAD AND LAUREL MEADOWS PARKWAY (TAX MAP PARCEL: #M008.02-01-003.00) AND PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE WHEREAS, Abby & Matt LLC, has petitioned the City of Mauldin to rezone +/- 5 acres from the C-2, Commercial District, to the R-M, Multi-family Residential District; and WHEREAS, a rezoning of the parcel is in keeping with the City of Mauldin 2014 Comprehensive Plan Update; and WHEREAS, the site is suitable for the types of uses that could be developed under the new zoning district; and WHEREAS, the potential uses permitted in the new zoning district meet a public need and are not detrimental to the public health, safety, and welfare; and WHEREAS, the Mauldin Planning Commission has given favorable recommendation to the zoning application; and NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED by the mayor and City Council of the City of Mauldin, South Carolina, in council assembled and by the authority thereof Section 1. That the property described in zoning docket PC-2022-10-RZ and Greenville County Tax Map Parcel M008.02-01-003.00 be rezoned from C-2 to R-M, Multi-family Residential. The property is further identified on the attached exhibit that is hereby incorporated into this ordinance, including Exhibit 1, Zoning & Property Map. Section 2. This ordinance shall become effective upon and after its final passage. Passed on First Reading ________________________________ Passed on Second Reading ______________________________ CITY OF MAULDIN, SOUTH CAROLINA ATTEST: BY: ________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ___________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: ___________________________________ John Duggan, City Attorney Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 22 EXHIBIT 1 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 23 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 24 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 25 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 26 ã 2005 Arbor Engineering, Inc. DRAWN: DESIGN: APPROVED: DATE: FILE: JOB NO. NO. OF MILES OF NO. OF ACRES: NEW ROAD: LOTS: DEVELOPER ENGINEER LOCATION MAP ( NOT TO SCALE) NO. R E V I S I O N S DESCRIPTIONDATE BY RECREATIONAL PLANNERS - LAND PLANNERS ARBOR LAND DESIGN, LLC Box 263 Greenville, S.C. 29602 Telephone: (864) 495-4446 Fax: (864) 233-6274 Email: postmaster@aldllc.net LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS - CIVIL ENGINEERS - LAND SURVEYORS 1 JULY 21, 2022 SUBMITTED TO THE CITY OF MAULDINAMA PRELIMINARY PLAT (DEVELOPMENT NAME) ZENITH REAL ESTATE 8 SYCAMORE DR, GREENVILLE, SC ARBOR LAND DESIGN PO BOX 268 GREENVILLE, SC 5.52 0.26 (PUBLIC) 57 AMA AMA AMA JULY 21, 2022 22130 - PLM 22130 SITE Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 27 BUILDING CODES COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM MEETING DATE: August 1, 2022 AGENDA ITEM: 6ca & 6d TO: Building Codes Committee FROM: Business & Development Services Director, David C. Dyrhaug SUBJECT: Annexation of Property at 30 Tanner Rd and 50 Tanner Rd REQUEST The City of Mauldin has received signed petitions requesting the annexation of two tracts of land consisting of three parcels pursuant to South Carolina Code of Laws Section 5 -3-150. Th ese petitions include approximately 13 acres owned by Lynn Farmer and Elaine Ayscue located at 50 Tanner Road, and approximately 7.6 acres owned by Earl Jones and Nancy Jones located at 30 Tanner Road. The applicant has requested that these tracts be zoned PD, Planned Development upon annexat ion into the City of Mauldin. Flournoy Development Group is planning to develop a planned development described below. TRACT #1 (30 Tanner Rd) TRACT #2 (50 Tanner Rd) AUTHORIZED REP(S): Flournoy Development Group Gray Engineering Fluornoy Development Group Gray Engineering OWNER(S): W. Earl Jones Nancy L. Jones C. Lynn Farmer Elaine F. Ayscue TAX MAP NUMBER(S): 0547.03-01-043.01 0547.03-01-043.02 0547.03-01-043.00 LOCATION: 30 Tanner Rd 50 Tanner Rd CURRENT ZONING: R-S (County) R-S (County) REQUESTED ZONING: PD, Planned Development PD, Planned Development SIZE OF PROPERTY: Approx. 7.6 acres Approx. 13 acres CONTIGUITY: These tracts are directly contiguous to the Maple Brook Terrace Retirement Community at 150 Verdin Rd, the backside of 701 Brookfield Pkwy, and the Sonic Drive-In at 1534 Woodruff Rd. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 28 HISTORY/BACKGROUND Each of these two tracts are currently occupied by a single -family residence. These tracts have attracted various development interests over the years. PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT About Flournoy Development Group Flournoy is described on their website as “a distinguished member in the multifamily real estate industry.” They state they “[lead] the planning, development, and construction of luxury, Class A multifamily communities across the Sunbelt.” They claim to have developed and managed over 40,000 multi -family units. They indicate that they have successfully purchased and developed or are in the process of developing 5 other properties in Greenville. This includes District West at 101 Reedy View Dr (365 units) , The Aventine Greenville at 97 Market Point Dr (346 units) , Carolina Point Apartments at 201 Carolina Point Pkwy (346 units), and The Paddock Club Greenville at 50 Rocky Creek Rd (208 units). Overview of Proposed Development At present, Flournoy Development Group is proposed a planned development consisting of the following: • 4-story apartment buildings consisting of up to 365 apartment units • 2- and 3-story townhomes consisting of up to 100 townhome units • 2-story carriage homes consisting of up to 8 units • Ground floor work space units consisting of up to 14 units (these units will be connected to the residential units above the work space creating a live/work environment) • Accessory garages and amenities In total, this proposal includes up to 473 residential units, approximately 16,000 square feet of work space, 548 parking spaces (24 garage spaces and 524 surface parking spaces), a 12,000-square foot clubhouse, and 950-square foot maintenance/dog wash space. All work spaces and residential units, including apartments, townhome units, and carriage homes, will be for rent only. The entire project will be owned and managed as one property. Live/Work Units. The live/work units will consist of a ground floor work space connected to a upper floor apartment unit. The work spaces are intended to be used for small office spaces or small -scale neighborhood retail uses. The target market for these work spaces will be entrepreneurs, small businesses, and professionals. The size of each work space will generally range between 700 and 1,200 square feet. Examples of businesses that may occupy these work spaces may include accountant, architect, artist/artisan, attorney, computer software and multimedia related professional, consultant, engineer, coffee shop, fashion designer, clothing boutique, graphic designer, interior designer, hair stylist, home -based office worker, insurance agent, real estate or travel agent, one-on-one instructor, photographer, and other similar occupations. The following uses are not intended for these work spaces: vehicle repair or maintenance, adult businesses, massage parlors, large commercial restaurants utilizing a commercial kitchen, and uses that create excessive noise, dust, heat, smoke, and odors that create a nuisance or other safety concerns. It is the intent of the applicant that if market does not demonstrate a demand for these work spaces that the owner may convert the work spaces into apartment units. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 29 Apartments. The apartments will consist of 1-, 2-, and 3-bedroom units. Units will vary in size between 600 and 1,600 square feet. The buildings may vary in height between 2 and 4 stories. The exterior façade materials will consist primarily of masonry and fiber cementitious board. Amenities. Amenities planned for this project include, but are not limited to, upscale clubhouse space, meeting rooms for residents who work from home, co -working space, fitness and wellness rooms , a dog park, mail kiosk and package lockers, a swimming pool courtyard, and outdoor spaces providing grills, firepits, and other amenities. Access. The applicant is proposing three access points, subject to review and approval by SCDOT. This will include one driveway at Tanner Road and two driveways at Verdin Road. Sidewalks will be installed along Tanner Road and Verdin Road in order to promote walkability and connectivity. Parking. In total, 766 parking spaces are proposed for this development project. This includes 524 surface parking spaces for the apartments, 24 garage spaces for the apartments, 200 garage and driveway parking spaces for the townhomes, and 18 garage spaces for the carriage homes . This is c onsistent with the minimum parking requirements for the City of Mauldin which is presently 1.5 parking spaces for each multi-family dwelling unit and 2.0 parking spaces for other dwellings. It appears that the parking being proposed is consistent with the requirements for the City of Mauldin. Traffic. A traffic impact study has been completed for the proposed development project. This study was performed by Allen J. Reid with Impact Designs, Inc. This study was based on a slightly lower number of units (471) than the number of units included in the planned development submission (473). The report acknowledges that the northbound traffic on Verdin Road at the Woodruff Road intersection and the southbound traffic on Feaster Road at the Woodruff Road intersection both currently operate at a level F during both morning and evening peak hours. The conditions at this signalized intersection are expected to worsen with this project. The traffic impact study recommends that the traffic signal be adjusted to allow longer green lights for Verdin Road and Feaster Road. Even with this adjustment, Verdin Road and Feaster Road would still operate at a level F at this intersection, albeit the conditions won’t worsen nearly as much. The traffic impact study also ind icates that this project will impact the overall level of service at the intersection of Verdin Road, E. Butler Road, and Holland Road. This intersection presently operates at a level C during both morning and evening peak hours. The morning peak hour level of service is projected to deteriorate to a level D by 2025. With this project, the evening peak hour level of service would also deteriorate to a level D. The traffic impact study recommends that a right turn overlap be installed on Verdin Road at this intersection to facilitate the high number of right turns from Verdin Road onto E. Butler Road. This would improve the evening peak hour level of service back to a level C for this intersection. In summary, the traffic impact study recommends the following improvements to the current traffic system: 1. Modify the parameters of the adaptive signal system at the intersection of Woodruff Road/Verdin Road/Feaster to allow for longer splits for Verdin Road and Feaster Road. 2. Install a right turn overlap on the southbound approach of Verdin Road at East Butler Road. Even without the addition of this proposed development project, conditions at these intersections are expected to worsen by 2025. The improvements recommended above by the traffi c impact study would soften the blunt of the traffic added by the proposed development. Utilities. All utilities are available including water and sewer. The applicant has provided letters of capacity and availability from the various utility providers. MetroConnects has a sewer line at Verdin Road that the developer is expected to tie into. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 30 NEIGHBORHOOD MEETING The applicant held a neighborhood meeting on July 11, 2022. Based on the sign -in sheet, it appears that nearly 30 neighbors attended the meeting. It appears that most of the attendees were from the Towns at Woodruff Crossing townhome community on Tanner Road just outside the City of Mauldin and next door to the proposed planned development. According to the meeting summary provided by the applicant, questions and concerns covered topics including: traffic, amenities, tree preservation, stormwater runoff, landscape buffering and screening, light pollution, trespassing by pedestrians, property values, and the capacity of infrastructure. A ttached is the applicant’s summary of the neighborhood meeting. PLANNING AND ZONING About the PD District The PD district is established to encourage innovative and creative design of residential and/or commercial developments and to permit a greater amount of flexibility by removing some of the restrictions of conventional zoning. The procedures for a PD provide a mechanism to evaluate each application on its own merit. Surrounding Development/Zoning These properties are surrounded by the following zoning and land uses: Direction Zoning District(s) Existing Use(s) North C-1/C-2 (County) C-1 (City) Express Oil Change, La Petite Academy, Sonic Drive-In, Greenville Car Wash, Master’s Mark Dry Cleaners, The Flat South S-1 (City) Maple Brook Terrace Retirement Community East S-1/C-1 (County) Kids ‘R’ Kids Learning Academy West C-2/R-M10 (County) AAA auto repair shop, strip shopping center including various tenants, Towns at Woodruff Crossing townhome community Comprehensive Plan Vision This property is designated as an “employment center” in the future land use map of the comprehensiv e plan. Employment Center areas are intended for industrial parks and office parks. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 31 STAFF FINDINGS Staff has reviewed this request as follows. CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 1. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan or, if conditions have changed, consistency with the overall intent of the Plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area; This property is designated as an “employment center” in the future land use map of the comprehensive plan. Employment Center areas are intended for industrial parks and office parks. However, with the number of vacancies in the adjacent Brookfield Corporate Office Park, it is not unreasonable to conclude that recent trends may suggest that office park development is not as viable as it once was pre-COVID. The City Council may or may not judge that the proposed planned development is consistent with the intent of the comprehensive plan, recent development trends, and the general character of the area. 2. Suitability of the site’s physical, geological, hydrological and other environmental features to support the breadth and intensity of uses that could be developed To staff’s knowledge, there are no apparent floodplains, wetlands, or topographic constraints on the site. Staff is not aware of any features at this site that would make it unsuitable for development. 3. Compatibility of the potential uses allowed with surrounding uses and zoning districts in terms of suitability of location, impacts on the environment, noise, density, nat ure of use, traffic impacts, aesthetics, ability to develop adjacent properties under existing zoning, and potential influence on property values The tract is located in a transitional area between commercial uses to the north, west, and east, an office pa rk to the south, a retirement apartment community to the south, and a townhome community to the west. The mix of apartments and work spaces appears to represent a blend of some of the surrounding uses, albeit the work space aspect of the proposed planned development is a relatively minor component. As evident in the traffic impact study, this proposed planned development would impact traffic at a couple of the nearby intersections. However, the traffic study recommend s improvements to the traffic system that would ease the impact of this traffic. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 32 CRITERIA STAFF FINDINGS 4. Capacity of public infrastructure and services to sufficiently accommodate potential uses allowed without compromising public health, safety, or welfare Staff is not aware of any utilities, including water and sewer, that would not be available at this tract. This project is expected to connect to the existing MetroConnects sewer line along Verdin Road. There is some concern about the road infrastructure to be able to accommodate the additional traffic generated by this proposed planned development. This concern was expressed at the neighborhood meeting. During peak hours, Verdin Road and Feaster Road already experience breakdown flow (LOS F) at the intersection of Woodruff Road. Additionally, Verdin Road is currently approaching unstable flow (LOS D) at East Butler Road during peak hours. The traffic study contains recommendations that will attempt to mitigate the impact of traffic generated by this planned development. However, Verdin Road at Woodruff Road will continue to experience breakdown flow (LOS F) and Verdin Road at East Butler Road will continue to approach unstable flow even with these improvements to the traffic system. 5. Public need for the potential uses permitted The Comprehensive Plan forecasts changing lifestyles, such as young adults delaying marriage and parenthood, will continue to increase the demand fo r apartments and townhomes. Additionally, the growing number of single-parent households may also create mo re demand for apartments and townhomes. This planned development proposal would provide additional living options that support this forecast in the Comprehensive Plan. TIMELINE On July 11, 2022, the applicant met with interested neighbors to review their proposal and to seek questions and comments. On July 18, 2022, staff received the petition and accompanying documents to annex these tracts and established a Planned Development (PD) district. STAFF RECOMMENDATION The incorporation of multi -family dwelling units together with workspaces that could be used for neighborhood retail and offices has great potential and could become a very desirable destination . The layout for the project has been thoughtfully designed. The presence of neighborhoo d retail and office together with angled parking lining the principal drive off of Verdin Road provide a “Main Street” feel. It’s nice that t he parking along Tanner Road is placed behind buildings. (It would be even better if the parking along Verdin Road was also placed behind buildings.) Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 33 In the opinion of staff, the review for this request comes down to a few key considerations: 1. Does the trend of rising vacancies in office parks and similar employment centers justify the divergence from the designation and vision of “Employment Center” for this site in the Comprehensive Plan? 2. Will the existing traffic issues on Verdin Road be detrimental to safety of motorists and pedestrians and to the overall success and desirability of this development project? Ultimately, the City Council will need to make a judgment on these considerations and any other factors that they deem pertinent. ATTACHMENTS Annexation Ordinances (maps and petitions attached therein) Planned Development documents Neighborhood Meeting documents Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 34 ORDINANCE -2022 AN ORDINANCE TO PROVIDE FOR THE ANNEXATION OF PROPERTY OWNED BY W. EARL JONES AND NANCY L. JONES, AND LOCATED AT 30 TANNER ROAD (TAX MAP PARCEL: 0547.03-01-043.01 & 0547.03 -01-043.02) BY ONE HUNDRED PERCENT PETITION METHOD; AND TO ESTABLISH A ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, FOR SAID PROPERTY WHEREAS, W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones , are the sole owners of record title of two parcels of real property containing 7.6 acres, more or less, located at 30 Tanner Road, which property is contiguous to the City of Mauldin and is more particularly illustrated in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, an Annexation Petition, attached hereto as Exhibit 2, has been filed with the City of Mauldin by W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones, requesting that the aforementioned property be annexed into the City of Mauldin; and, WHEREAS, the property to be a nnexed is contiguous to the City of Mauldin, and is more particularly depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones , constitute one hundred (100%) percent of freeholders owning one hundred (100%) of the real property depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, the proposed zoning of PD, Planned Development , is compatible with the surrounding property uses in the area; and, WHEREAS, the Mayor and Council conclude that the annexation is in the best interest of the property owner and the City; NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the Mayor and Council of the City of Mauldin that: 1. ANNEXATION: The real property owned by W. Earl Jones and Nancy L. Jones, and more particularly depicted in the map attached hereto marked as Exhibit 1, is hereby annexed into the corporate city limits of the City of Mauldin effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 35 2. ANNEXATION OF A PORTION OF ADJACENT RIGHT S-OF- WAY: All of that portion of Tanner Road along the edge of and adjoined to the annexed property shown on the attached Exhibit to the centerline of the afore-mentioned right-of-way is also hereby annexed into the corporate limits of the City of Mauldin effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance. 3. ZONING ASSIGNMENT: The above referenced property owned is hereby zoned PD, Planned Development, as detailed in Exhibit 3 attached hereto. ____________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ATTEST: ________________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk First Reading: _________________________ Second Reading: ______________________ Approved as to Form: ________________________________________ City Attorney Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 36 EXHIBIT 1 – ANNEXATION MAP Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 37 EXHIBIT 2 – PETITION Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 38 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 39 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 40 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 41 ORDINANCE -2022 AN ORDINANCE TO PROVIDE FOR THE ANNEXATION OF PROPERTY OWNED BY C. LYNN FARMER AND ELAINE F. AYSCUE, AND LOCATED AT 50 TANNER ROAD (TAX MAP PARCEL: 0547.03-01-043.00) BY ONE HUNDRED PERCENT PETITION METHOD; AND TO ESTABLISH A ZONING CLASSIFICATION OF PD, PLANNED DEVELOPMENT, FOR SAID PROPERTY WHEREAS, C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue , are the sole owners of record title of a parcel of real property containing 13 acres, more or less, located at 50 Tanner Road, which property is contiguous to the City of Mauldin and is more particularly illustrated in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, an Annexation Petition, attached hereto as Exhibit 2, has been filed with the City of Mauldin by C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue, requesting that the aforementioned property be annexed into the City of Mauldin; and, WHEREAS, the property to be annexed is contiguous to the City of Mauldin, and is more particularly depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue , constitute one hundred (100%) percent of freeholders owning one hundred (100%) of the real property depicted in Exhibit 1 attached hereto; and, WHEREAS, the proposed zoning of PD, Planned Development , is compatible with the surrounding property uses in the area; and, WHEREAS, the Mayor and Council conclude that the annexation is in the best interest of the property owner and the City; NOW, THEREFORE, be it ordained by the Mayor and Council of the City of Mauldin that: 1. ANNEXATION: The real property owned by C. Lynn Farmer and Elaine F. Ayscue , and more particularly depicted in the map attached hereto marked as Exhibit 1, is hereby annexed into the corporate city limits of the City of Mauldin effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 42 2. ANNEXATION OF A PORTION OF ADJACENT RIGHT S-OF- WAY: All of that portion of Tanner Road and Verdin Road along the edge of and adjoined to the annexed property shown on the attached Exhibit to the centerline of the afore-mentioned right-of-way is also hereby annexed into the corporate limits of the City of Mauldin effective immediately upon second reading of this ordinance. 3. ZONING ASSIGNMENT: The above referenced property owned is hereby zoned PD, Planned Development, as detailed in Exhibit 3 attached hereto. ____________________________________ Terry Merritt, Mayor ATTEST: ________________________________________ Cindy Miller, Municipal Clerk First Reading: _________________________ Second Reading: ______________________ Approved as to Form: ________________________________________ City Attorney Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 43 EXHIBIT 1 – ANNEXATION MAP Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 44 EXHIBIT 2 – PETITION Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 45 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 46 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 47 1 Tanner Road Mixed Use Community Statement of Intent City of Mauldin, SC July 2022 Table of Contents G e n e r a l O v e r v i e w 2 - 3 Multifamily Residential Units 3 W o r k S p a c e 3 P r o p e r t y M a i n t e n a n c e 4 D e v e l o p m e n t S c h e d u l e 4 Roadways and Interconnectivity 4 Impact on Public Facilities 5 G a r b a g e C o l l e c t i o n 5 F i r e P r o t e c t i o n 5 Design Style 6 Landscape and Screening 6 - 7 S i g n a g e 7 S i t e L i g h t i n g 7 - 8 E x a m p l e R e f e r e n c e P h o t o s 9 - 1 6 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 48 2 General Overview This Statement of Intent describes in detail a proposed mixed u se community, at the intersection of Verdin Road and Tanner Road. The site is appro ximately 20.99-acres and will be described in this Statement of Intent as the Tanner Road Mixed Use Community. The site has approximately 1,000 feet of frontage on Tanner Road which is th e northern boundary of the site, and approximately 725 feet of frontage on Verdin Road which is the eastern boundary of the site. The site consists of three parcels currently zoned R-S in Greenville County, TMS 0547030104300, 0547030104301, and 0547030104302 and are currently owned by the Ayscue and Farmer (0547030104300) and Jones (0547030104301 and 0547030104302) fam ilies. Combined, these three parcels comprise the ~20.99-acre site discussed herein. The existing property is currently surrounded by or is in close proximity to a mixture of uses including an office park, heavy commercial, neighborhood retail, assisted living development, a carwash, self-storage, attached single family, a bank, and other heavy commercial uses like a gas station. The property is currently in Greenville County and is used for agricultural though surrounded by commercial and office uses. Flournoy Development Group, who has successfully purchased and developed or is in- process of developing 5 other properties in Greenville, will be the master developer of the Tanner Road Mixed Use Community. This site was chosen due to its cent ralized location in the region with convenient proximity to an abundance of employment opportu nities, shopping, services, entertainment options, a robust roadway network, and the opport unity for this development’s future residents to support and be part of the surrounding community. The site is truly a location where its residents can live, work, and play within an activated environment. The Tanner Road Mixed Use Community will encompass a mix of use s including both multifamily residences and townhomes, along with live/work units integrated into select buildings that front the main drive accessing the community from Verdin R oad. The development will include no more than 365 multifamily residences, 100 townhomes, 8 carriage homes, and 14 work spaces. These work spaces will be physically connected to the residential unit above to allow the tenant to combine the work space with the residential unit above to become what we describe as a live/work unit. For clarity in this Statement of Intent, when describing density or number of units, we will divide these live/work units into live space (i.e., an apartment unit) and work space(s). By way of example, if we describe having 14 live/work units, this would equate to 14 apartment units and 14 work spaces. As outlined above, the development will have no more than 14 work spaces which can be combined with their associated living space above. The work portion of these units will generally range from approximately 700 square feet to approximately 1,200 square feet or larger. The work spaces are intended to be used for small office spaces or small-scale neighborhood retail uses and are primarily geared towards entrepreneurs, small businesses, and professionals. Examples of uses that may be seen in a live/work unit are an accountant, architect, artist/artisan, attorney, computer software and multimedia related professional, consultant, engin eer, a coffee shop, fashion designer, clothing boutique, graphic designer, interior designer, hair stylist, home-based office worker, insurance agent, real estate or travel agent, one-on-one instructor, photographer, and other Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 49 3 similar occupations. Uses that are not intended for this type of space include, for example, vehicle repair or maintenance, adult businesses, massage parlors, large commercial restaurants utilizing a commercial kitchen, and uses tha t create excessive noise, dust, heat, smoke, and odors that are considered a nuisance or are unsafe for other residents or employees. Lastly, and in order to protect against changes in marketplace demand, the work spaces may allow for future conversion over to standard apartment units should the space sit vacant due to changing marketplace conditions. It is the desire of Flournoy Development Group for the subject property to be rezoned to Planned Development (PD), to allow for a development that is innovative in its land planning and site design concepts to create a high quality of life for its residents. We intend for the development to achieve a high level of aesthetics and be a development that exemplifies quality while promoting community, connectivity, and walkability across a variety of dynamic uses and residential product types. Multifamily Residential Units The total acreage of the site is approximately 20.99-acres and we are proposing no more than 473 multifamily residential units including the townhomes and carriage homes. The units will have a mixture of sizes, including 1, 2, and 3 bedroom dwellings. Units will vary in size from approximately 600 square feet up to approximately 1,600 square feet or more across the various product types previously described. Buildings will range from 2 stories to 4 stories in height. The exteriors will be constructed with a variety of materials but will consist primarily of masonry and fiber cementitious board. In addition to the multifamily units, residents will also have access to a plethora of amenities which are proposed to include but not be limited to upscale club space, meeting rooms for residents who work from home, co-working space, fitness and wellness rooms, a dog park, mail kiosk, package lockers, a swimming pool courty ard, and other courtyards containing outdoor entertainment spaces, grills, firepits, and other amenities. Work Space The work spaces previously described are also a part of the app roximate 20.99-acre site. These spaces will not be separate buildings and are designed to be vertically incorporated into several of the main buildings located along the main drive entering the community on the ground level of the buildings, with the intention to create an activat ed “main street” feel at this primary community entry. Work spaces will range in size from approxima tely 700 square feet to 1,200 square feet or larger. Due to these spaces being incorporated into the main multifamily buildings, the building heights are the same as the multifamily residential buildings. Parking for these units will be available in front of the buildings along the main entry drive as well as around the side and behind the buildings. Due to the nature of the work space, we anticipate that almost all the spaces will be occupied during normal working hours. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 50 4 Property Maintenance Due to the nature of this devel opment, the property will remai n one parcel and is not intended to be subdivided or sold to separate owners. As a result, no property owner’s association will be needed, as all maintenance for this community will be p erformed by the owner or their property management company. This includes private drive aisles, parking, storm water systems, sidewalks, landscaping, trash pickup, and all other aspects of the community needing maintenance. There will also be a single automobile wash area for resident u se only as well as a maintenance building and trash compactor. Development Schedule Planning and due diligence are currently in progress for the subject site and will continue until the property is fully rezoned. Once rezoning is complete , construction documents will be developed and submitted for permitting. Once permits are recei ved and the property is closed, it is anticipated that construction will begin. We anticipate this to occur during the first quarter of 2023. The project will be completed in one phase with each bui lding turning over at different times in a planned sequence. We anticipate our first building to open around the third or fourth quarter of 2024 and construction to be complete by late 2024 or early 2025. Roadways and Interconnectivity The Tanner Road Mixed Use Community currently has three proposed main points of ingress and egress. One is from Tanner Road and two from Verdi n Road. All roadway improvements will be internal to the development and will be pr ivate. A traffic impact study has been completed by a South Carolina licensed engineer and is currently under review by SCDOT. Based upon this traffic impact st udy, any increased traffic is expected to be spread out amongst driveways and road systems, and outside of potential traffic si gnal optimization at the Woodruff Road/Verdin Road intersection, no additional roadway improvemen ts or traffic mitigation measures are recommended or warranted (per the traffic impact s tudy). Sidewalks (5’) will be installed along Tanner Road as well as Verdin Road in order to promote walkability and connectivity to the surrounding community and larger public sidewalk system. In addition to this sidewalk, the internal sidewalk system within this development is designed to connect to the sidewalks along Tanner Road and Verdin Road, which creates convenient permanent connectivity to the vacant adjacent parcel. Relative to parking: the current design meets or exceeds the C ity of Mauldin minimum parking requirements for multiple-family dwellings (multifamily units and townhomes) and live/work units. The parking spaces will typically be 9’ x 18’ for all parking spaces whether back- to-back or adjacent to a curb or sidewalk. Handicap spaces will also be 9’x 18’. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 51 5 Impact on Public Facilities Sanitary Sewer New sewer lines will be installe d within the community itself by the developer and dedicated to the appropriate Sewer Sub-district. Sewer service is available and capacity analysis and sanitary sewer connections are currently being studied and reviewed. Water Water service is available from Greenville Water, and all nece ssary lines and connections will be installed by the developer as a private water main syst em to serve the project for water supply and fire service. Electricity Electricity is available from Laurens Electric, and undergroun d p o w e r l i n e s w i l l b e installed within the community. Storm Drainage Stormwater Management for the p roject will provide a permanent on-site storm drainage system and stormwater detention facility which will serve both water quality and water quantity. These systems will be designed to meet or exceed all local, state and federal regulations involving stormwater flows as well as an extensive erosion and sedimentation control plan for construction. Stormwater will continue to be released onto adjacent properties and will be designed to maintain the current existing flow pattern and direction without any adverse impact on downstream features. The stormwater system, including the detention ponds, will be maintained by the developer/owner. Garbage Collection Garbage collection will be by private contract carrier. All garbage will be collected in an enclosed trash compactor which will serve the entire community and can also be accessed by all residents and work space tenants. The compactor will be enclos ed and hidden by an opaque building material which will complement the materials used within the development. Fire Protection Mauldin Fire District will prov ide fire protection within the community. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 52 6 Design Style T he design style of the Tanner Road Mixed Use Community begins first with the site plan, which was intentionally designed to account for the relationship between the buildings within the site as well as the relationship between the buildings on-site and the surrounding properties, views, and roadways. As reflected on the site plan, the main leasing office as well as the live/work units all front the main entry drive entering the site from Verdin Ro ad. This was done intentionally in order to create a more active, public, and engaging streetscape by tapping into a “main street” style look for residents and visitors as they enter the community. T he use of L-shaped and U-shaped buildings also allows for more interesting spaces between buildings, creating a slightly more urban feel and allowing for the integration of courtyards throughout the site to produce more relaxed spaces for residents to enjoy. The architec ture of the project is also highly intentional and complimentary to the site plan as well. Since much of the surrounding land around the site is developed, our intention is to create a development that goes above-a nd-beyond a standard apartment c ommunity. With the addition of an architectural style that ties more traditional suburban q ualities with a slightly more modern urban design, we have successfully designed a more transitional community that is not only compatible with, but also adds a fresh look to the surrounding community. The architectural style of all the buildings and amenities is intended to bridge the more historic residential warmth of the city with the more commercialized feel of the area surrounding the site. Traditional exterior materials of brick and cementitious siding are creatively combi ned for a more modern look, blending seamlessly with the commercial storefronts, retail can opies or awnings, and signage at the live/work units along the main entry drive. Masonry and detailing at the street level will create a more pedestrian scale and interest, inviting the surrounding community into the development. Landscaping and Screening The Tanner Road Mixed Use Community will have a large array of different types of landscape depending upon the site area in question. Frontage along Tanner Road and Verdin Road will co nsist of street trees and other decorative landscaping around monument signs and the site entrances while a 10’ landscape buffer is maintained on these road frontages. In addition, and in response to feedback from the adjacent neighborhood, we have agreed to provide a minimum 10’ existing vegetative buffer yard along the western property line that will only be accessed and disturbed in order to construct an opaque privacy fence along the property. We are also responding to the neighboring community’s concerns by agreeing to also install a 6’ privacy fence as a buffer in order to prevent foot traffic through the adjacent neighborhood. In addition to the privacy fence and existing vegetative buffer along the western property line, in areas where the existing vegetative buffer is non-existent, we will supplement the existing vegetation with evergreen shrubs which will be of a variety that will grow a minimum of 14’ tall. These will be installed approximately 15’ apart. The detention pond, which will also serve as a natural deterrent to foot traffic entering the neighboring community to the west, as well as the dog park will be surrounded by a 4-rail wooden fence with horse wire, similar to the one in the example photos enclosed within this Statement of Intent. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 53 7 In addition to the landscaping and buffers, the interior of the property will follow the below landscaping guidelines:  Plant material will be installed in parking lot islands, around all building foundations, in courtyards, and along all public roadways.   Where powerlines are present and large canopy trees cannot be p lanted, lower understory trees will be selected from Duke Energy’s approved plant list.    A mixture of deciduous canopy trees and evergreen trees will be planted throughout the community in tree islands and courtyards to create different sp aces throughout the community for residents and visitors to enjoy. Grasses and gro und covers will be used throughout the community to reduce heat, prevent erosion, and c reate an aesthetically pleasing landscape for the residents and the public. Mulch will also be used throughout to promote healthy plants, reduce erosion, and to help reduce water consumption.    All landscaping will be maintained regularly, and an irrigation system will be used to assist in keeping plant material vibrant and healthy. For water conservation, rain sensors and soil moisture sensors will be utilized in the community as well.   Hardscape material will also be utilized in certain areas of th e site to promote an aesthetically pleasing community and to delineate spaces that are more public in nature and spaces that are more socially active. A mixture of pavers, concrete, and other materials will be utilized to this end. Signage Signage will meet the City of Mauldin Sign Ordinance. Monumen t signs or a blade sign will be used at the main entrances. Monument signage (if utili zed) along Verdin Road will not exceed 10’ in height, and one smaller single faced monument sign along Tanner Road that will not exceed 8’ in height. The monument sign will include our property name and may also include the name of the work space tenants. Materials shall be the same or similar in nature to the main building materials and the design will complement the architect ure of the community. The sign will be either internally lit, back-lit, or lighted with a grou nd mounted light. No neon or scrolling/moving text shall be used. There may also be signage in front of or above the main entry of each work space in order to identify each individual busines s. This signage will either be part of an awning over each entry or a sign that is hung perpendicular on the side of the building. See example photos enclosed on later pages of this Statement of Int ent for additional reference. The leasing office will also have signage in front of the space or above the entry in order for visitors to identify the main entry point into that space. Directional si gnage will also be incorporated throughout the development to assist visitors and emergency veh icles in navigating the property efficiently. Site Lighting Lighting for the Tanner Road Mixed Use Community will vary depending on the application it is being used for. Along interior streets and parking, where buildings are nearby, and pedestrian activity is highest, decorative lantern type streetlights with a mounting height of Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 54 8 no more than 18’ will be used to light the community. Due to feedback from the neighboring community, we are also minimizing lighting along the western property line and where present and within 50’ of the western property line, will reduce the height of those light poles to 12’. In limited areas where we have more than one row of parking, or near property lines, downlight shoebox type fixtures will be used to light these more open areas and will have a mounting height of no more than 20’ in height. Specialty areas on-site, like courtyards and around the pool, may possibly incorporate roughly 4’ high bollards for more localized lighting. Bollard lights will be full cutoff. Building lighting will also be incorporated into select areas of the buildings to introduce lighting to patios, balconies, and entry points into the buildings. All lighting near property lines will be full cut-off fixtures to prevent light from bleeding onto the adjacent properties. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 55 9 Example Reference Photos Example of 4 rail wooden fence with horse wire. Also, an example of “lantern” type light poles. Example of “lantern” lighting and ground level bollard light ing (full cutoff). Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 56 10 Examples of courtyard design. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 57 11 Example of courtyard amenities. Example of Live/Work space. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 58 12 Examples of Live/Work space. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 59 13 Examples of Monument Signs. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 60 14 Example of Monument Sign. Example of Live/Work Space signage. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 61 15 Example of Live/Work Space signage. Example of full cutoff Shoebox Light. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 62 16 Example of full cutoff Lantern Pole Light. Example of wooden fencing/privacy fence. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 63 TANNER ROAD DEVELOPMENT GREENVILLE COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA PRELIMINARY DEVELOPMENT PLAN • 07-15-2022 © COPYRIGHT 2022 DYNAMIK DESIGN PONDPOND PONDPOND PONDPOND VERDIN ROADVERDIN ROAD TANNER ROADTANNER ROAD WOODRUFF ROADWOODRUFF ROAD TANNER ROADTANNER ROAD VERDIN ROADVERDIN ROAD SITE TH TOWNHOMES 2 & 3 STORY TOWNHOMES : 100 UNITS (MAXIMUM) AVG. NUMBER OF BEDS PER UNIT : 2.2 - 2.4 (APPROX.) SERVED BY 1 CAR GARAGE & TANDEM SPACE W WORK SPACE GROUND FLOOR WORK SPACE : 14 UNITS (MAXIMUM) TOTAL : 16,000 SF (APPROX.) LW LW LW LW TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH TH G GARAGES 6 BAY GARAGES NO. OF GARAGES : 4 TOTAL GARAGE PARKING : 24 SPACES G G G G ENTRY / ENTRY / EXITEXIT ENTRY / ENTRY / EXITEXIT AN ON-SITE STORMWATER MANAGEMENT FACILITY WILL BE DESIGNED TO MEET GREENVILLE COUNTY STANDARDS AND SHALL ATTENUATE PEAK FLOW RATES FROM THE DEVELOPMENT TO LESS THAN PRE-DEVELOPMENT CONDITIONS. ENTRY / ENTRY / EXITEXIT POOLPOOL COURTYARDCOURTYARD TRASHTRASH DOG DOG RUNRUN 6’-0” FENCE6’-0” FENCE UNDISTURBED BUFFERUNDISTURBED BUFFER UNDISTURBED BUFFERUNDISTURBED BUFFER UNDISTURBED BUFFERUNDISTURBED BUFFER 10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER 10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER 10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER 10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER 10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER10’-0” LANDSCAPE BUFFER 6’-0” FENCE6’-0” FENCE 6’-0” FENCE6’-0” FENCE SITE INFORMATION VICINITY MAP LEGEND C1 AMENITIES PROPOSED MULTIFAMILY CLUB / LEASING TOTAL : 12,000 SF (APPROX.) C2 C1 C1 C2 TOTAL SITE AREA (APPROX.) : PROPOSED ZONING : 20.9 AC PD M MULTIFAMILY 4 STORY (TYPE VA) TOTAL UNITS : 365 (MAXIMUM) AVG. NUMBER OF BEDS PER UNIT : 1.4 - 1.5 (APPROX.) TOTAL PARKING : 548 SPACES (INCLUDING GARAGES) M M M M M CH CARRIAGE HOMES 2 STORY UNITS ABOVE 6 BAY GARAGES : 8 UNITS (MAXIMUM) AVG. NUMBER OF BEDS PER UNIT : 1.0 (APPROX.) TOTAL GARAGE PARKING : 18 SPACES CH CH CH TOTAL UNITS : 473 (MAXIMUM) PROPOSED MAINTENANCE / DOG WASH TOTAL : 950 SF (APPROX.) Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 64 TANNER ROAD GREENVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA RENDERING • 07-18-2022 FDC2022-02 © COPYRIGHT 2022 DYNAMIK DESIGN Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 65 07 /13/2022 VIA EMAIL: ddyrhaug@mauldincitysc.com Mr. David Dyrhaug Planning Director City of Mauldin 5 E. Butler Road Mauldin, SC 29662 Phone: 864-289-8979 RE: Community Meeting Summary Tanner Road Mixed Use Development City of Mauldin, Greenville County, South Carolina Dear Mr. Dyrhaug: The community meeting for the subject project was held on July 11 th, 2022 from 5pm to 7 pm at the Mauldin Library on 800 W Butler Road in Mauldin. The meeting was hosted by the development team which included Tom Burr with Flournoy Development Group, David Graffius with Gray Engineering Consultants, Inc. and Allen Reid with Impact Designs, Inc who is the traffic consultant. More than 25 members of the community were present to view the site plan and architectural rendering and to discuss their comments, questions and concerns. Attached please find the sign-in sheet, question/ response cards, visual boards used at the meeting and a copy of the mailed/received notices and mailing list. The format of the meeting was an open informal discussion where members of the development team discussed the project with the community individually. Then, the development team made a short presentation of the project to the group with an introduction of the development team and highlighted the overview of the project. The meeting discussions continued and the meeting lasted all 2 hours and the following subject questions were raised during the discussion. The development team answered these questions. Refer to questions/response cards for specific questions/responses. • Nearly all the members of the community present were from Woodruff Crossing condos, adjacent to the west of the project site. The owner of the Greenville Car Wash was present along with the owners of the subject property. • Questions about the existing vegetation between the condos and the subject property would be impacted. • Questions about traffic and how this project would impact traffic in the area. The community was concerned that the intersections now operate poorly and this will be worse. • Questions about stormwater. The community noted that they are under contract now for over hundred thousand dollars for stormwater remediation to their pond. They also pointed out that the existing apartments between them and Verizon next to their pond, have their foundations exposed due to the erosion for their pond. They worry the stormwater from this project will make it worse. Gray Engineering Consultants, Inc. Office: (864) 297-3027 132 Pilgrim Road Greenville, SC 29607 www.grayengineering.com G ra y E n g i n e e r i n g Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 66 • Questions about existing storm runoff immediately behind the condos next to the property were raised. These owners said that there is a shallow ditch that captures runoff from the subject property and inundates this low area with rainwater. • Questions were raised about the potential of foot traffic from the new apartments going through the Woodruff Crossing property to get to QT, KFC or Walmart. They requested some type of barrier to deter this from happening. • Questions were raised about site lighting and ambient light pollution. • Questions were raised about the type of project, whether it is apartments or homes, what type of buildings they are, how high they are. • Questions were raised about how the new development would affect their home values. • Questions were raised about existing infrastructure such as available existing sewer capacity. A list of the main concerns discussed in bold below and the main responses to address them provided: 1. Stormwater. The development will provide an on-site detention pond that will be sized to handle large storm events and attenuate peak flows to at or below current conditions. 2. Traffic. While traffic impacts are being seriously considered, based upon the analysis performed by Design Impacts, Inc., increased traffic is expected to be spread out amongst driveways and road system with no major mitigation recommended. There is a potential for the signal at Woodruff/Verdin to be modified to ease congestion on Verdin/Tanner. The traffic study will be subject to the review and approval by the SCDOT. 3. Existing Vegetation. An attempt will be made to maintain as much existing vegetation as possible and to provide new plantings where possible. 4. Property Security. This development will consider new fencing and/or measures to keep pedestrians from this development out of their property. These considerations are all seriously being considered by the owner and engineer and internal discussions are on-going as to how the comments received can be best addressed and incorporated into the project to make it the best project possible for the community. Should you have any questions or comments or if further detail is needed, please do not hesitate to contact me direct at 864-297-3027 ext 124 or by my email below. Very truly yours, GRAY ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS, INC. David J. Graffius, P.E. Project Manager dgraffius@grayengineering.com - 2 – Gray Engineering Consultants, Inc. Office: (864) 297-3027 132 Pilgrim Road Greenville, SC 29607 www.grayengineering.com Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 67 Name:"i'\_ � 1· ,) O\J ,, 0 0 C,'y' ··-························· ... · ............................... �---••><••··: .... ...... . �:s��.��:�� �Attll§C.:'"!l? 4�Y. �e:ri..\�Y. V$. g,,4.� AB§v=f' .S:t�f':'.'.'..� J���.?.'. ..... b.����(Af.'.".#) �� .�,�� PE:?/(.� 1Jt1=.: 't?PNt:> � .. ':::1-Y::IT . �£��:r..� ..... . . ......... 12 .. � ... �t->$.t�� •............. t .. lM.Fr.'4.:-:-..... ih>..\.µ,< .. J�.l:::�'."-.�� .... J?.� .......... 5.f..f:2'.e�f> .� ... . .............................. �.�!�.� ... PP::':.�.J ..... �.l::IP ........ &r.�Q$ .. ........ "!.� .... ��� ... %1f..1.�.t4. ... � --..._) .. �I?..�.ll!.�12 .. � ..... Responses: Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 68 Responses: 'i<l+¥-Fu .... (.,Jlu..... Be 5f''('-5"'6 ��":. f:>ll-1'1-.:S ,A� ·�·,•---1 1----- Sl!2t:>.AJ .. l:!f". �'?�£lv.±>-.i.-o,"1 1vio�Lf:,1::c-o r�• li?ASE ...... ___ ·---• ·----�l&?_� �E?C� � r,) 'VJ;",{Jd)J�/ E.fi.t.:,$.T� �1/.:r:;_.u_��'�..s ____ JION� -�tv-� ... �1�1- $ 1'u.�.) ...... 1: . .lf./� ...... E0f':::-r.,f,� �14> �S,Jl;>t:!YL-:- T cH_,cl:S"'------1 --�ti:! 7J{� .. $7'.� �$lbi'h" craj .... :S../:1':� ..... . Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 69 Name: � S, ····························••·••···1 .9.db"kt:::,-.,, ........ � .. � ...... ... c_o_m_m_en_t_s: __ �<:,��J :-J-Pi..A/+o,.-1- ¾v-<:....Bc.. wo.JJ. 1...-?�-�0_....._... _____ _ 1----------"'--<>'--,. il>-'{..�1,�.,,,�'l:J.9,;,� '*,r�� ,,\,_, t..cc;,,-, S5 Q_'f_,___o=v-�_7�/ _1. '�------1 Responses: N f3 f/./t 1.-1.-- A)) C!l-'<2S.:, -rrl tf . .$)TV /l-t-o-Al A �t:,Jb /,/J-&�S:"t�i?_n-_,i)�---- ____ , o,.6!!£f�-r7 g,-,,yf,J .. B.0.:'j. ... , .. .... 1/±s Ki;;: c:,E :PoA.J/), Tfl-€.f:.S :,! .. · ··'------1 •-----�F�-f;'Y-'t.-/,u&.. Al'5i... E::R.AT�_). r.:. l./2p ..... As DSTr$..���--------I ______ ,✓:::}�t.J�sr r11,s. � �rivs. CAA?c& �<,f>J:!&.. T.f>J.J1,11=J!'::. T6 J-b¥.•,:E._•_ .... Name: Address: ..... f '7' Comments: 1) ... VLA-� � � _� .� 1.J!�t/,,0. ldf�� Cl.d � ..... �.,{ ' ,, #;; 'fi,_ � (}_ � . ���L � f/.A , , ���'�I- -ffiv · · , Y,ud2,�/Ufl; Q,;4� �I+, ' !; Responses: TlfANl,t_ '10-V. vo NLI-U..rtv r; bfl.oW p /2-W't, i>t:!1> ......... , .................. ···································Eew 1?,,A.CIL ,A,<./'/:> I S;,ve'� ro /1-<.Ai<:e /3e-r-n:vL...... .. bPcllt Pf><iJ' -,,,.-,;:;, ' Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 70 Comments: �l:;��r;l=;;f:t};,f£J:::1f<.c .. ,,."t.,,Lf:'"''r &,IAJd'c1 __ ___ i.::��� f;' ��;::1o":t:�'�_;;;;,:'i,l;�i��""tl ------······tJfklL ..... --�------ = L�h�k; r�\ :�:tt: L1L� r, l �b�I C1 ,.i-P, ··-�-- Respo nses:i'.1,,,ffl,ee���� t' Cli::'cjJ G <}'@:�-., ........ . ,£.... .... <oo,o(I.Jf\'P ----�V,d� TPJ; V> /'VZ,LJ1-.J't'4,,,/ A� !:l:::.l?.5tt t/£1"�'11>oJ ,':I 1./.J::>�C�/'I_N __ • _____ ___,, - l.>l'-1., ��1l'>e'l"l- -r,./).< Pff.,t,!:�'?'Sfn!,A-M J;../ ()�24.� ,:,l'l/ __ s:1_1_i:;: __ _ ---1:J$,<J �Lf:,-/,1' ),./ 6 7'0 � i;- 19.'!:. .. f:?:!J =----- ___ i,_�F·FJ': .. 5T<.rA-, ;i,c:,.,_;5 /JO ,M.ITlf.::::1>_,.,,J Esvr $/w,,JIPL- 7/N'/� __________ >"_f'._111'�'/ /'?> .. &C -/4:.VJ-.,.Wb{) '137 '])o 7 . Responses: 112-,t,P,'Fl L- T.!> i?c � F:>/Jt--e-sseD. /!.-tc_�lj/:fp_>.'t',1=,T1..,_,,µt, A, Ft:r1'.st'/:'..,}�t>11.J ---�Irv,,-· c:s9..� ... 1 ........ $J1f? .. •,-t-ori.--. P?,, .. � P>eSJ,.,1,,/_ P,. �S,J"-"I:::'±= ..... ____ ___,, __ ,/;:)_��f/l&_l"s!l/4c �S.�·L .. � JS€ .. ;=- F!�, &;.t1::.C-.'e ;1 1�S . ---·--T?! Pf'.:i�'f:l':->�$!':'P=s'-'.- Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 71 ... ............. ··��z.::::1�:���=•••�•�������;:=i?;31 1��� ��.�••• ••···· ••••••••·•••• tdE�:i?i!:��i!:::i��:=�V;,� ... k.4 , �:.:�fliL�� �:f��l��:� &;lli?!iiI!5i!i�:1,1;,; fi $, .. .. ... .. ........ ... . . -:- .. ....... rl! 1� ....... �J� ...... l!§ .... T?ictf�t:t ....... f':!t ... �.... � '!-r:p!�'ID��········ (l·H)······· ... ����;!:�:��: �::.:���:;7;;;;f;::�:���;":;;;J��.t'1>�s .. ...... E..?:.t .. � .. � ......... � .... r.'!11:::.�1;;:;:�... .. �4,!.:[��. e, "-l�Y · ........ P�'S,�1"E.� .. E��/� .. � ....... . �/�1,,, R.t:,.,1::>.��� ... �ffl✓-\: .. W,U� ..... Name:\ 1 /1 ••·••••••••·••••••• '.!�?� ��11�=1:�C):l�lAddress: Comments: ::: :: 1\5-_�� <�. �>i{��c:<�::::: �;::i: :���\ �b�;�ff ( �: · .. ·······························(\\� ····�·��C(.f�;=; ••ci£2;.:\c;�;,:� ..... ............ . Responses:...... e��•·· .'.":'.��1.= b�P.� .. P..JHl . >..'fi'1F�"t:-:: .A�� . ...... ............... ?:�l::'.§�.J>J-1-)$. ·······�t-!9 ... ·······�····"'l't.�t� .... '. ..... ...... ,�.�·�········�l.� .. t! . .1. ...... � ..... ,'\:( ........ ........................... ···········�·�······1(;5. ····�""-·S·e.·· ....... �.�.lt... ...... -:r .. .t..N...?!..� ......... 1ft?.�.9�Y-ff., .... . ... . . . . '?TIM �1� ...... e: ... � t?>N �,c� ,-z, z.:s.,.-;-,:?� t?Q��:1:�kZ:'. . . ·············· .... ���§, Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 72 Comments: Responses: (,f' t-l- � Dt>/..c!:»5, F ::; f.JC.,,/1') 6 . � /Ni) no1 r<.J l'-1 ,0 I ..JI'"" ,..J . .. A-s MPA-1':f c?r'� rfl,£1,;,.S ,4S Poss I BL-6 �,..._)t . /.JD ./J . l"/e� / .fJh;� ,S Name:_,...- , ("'\ - i y�j kZ) .. i) or�'( Comments: tJ/4; i$ J.l. / roc�->S tr tY h f-uin,c. � � tu.,�(� fl �wu 1-i n-,_ (s) of +fv. �1c,in11� proptv-C j / . ... .. .. .... .. . L ifu-,-t "l w':-'1 6-o a.dJ a ... Ll?USS r°::!)nnn f/e,Jvc',X vr. cd . LotA.t's,v;llt t?f.1-c:,v< l� +tu._ d-tv.d(;F ... ? - .. . Responses: iN� .AY2-l£ . $-r'vpY ;;de. 5e�� lAPA�1 T7 A� t:,aW/V�CTVO"".f. Ale, II I; /-J 1 C. L � tf)'2_ .s mew ,0 L-1-1-< ;lk .. c t .C' � p 1-;tJ l'V" V9 p. L <51.F JS V 71....,:t,:k!G 0...-. 1-1,-6,� )�. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 73 1 JUNE 22, 2022 IMPACT DESIGNS, INC. Prepared by: Allen J. Reid, PE TRAFFIC IMPACT STUDY Tanner Road Multifamily Greenville County, South Carolina Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 74 TRAFFIC IMPACT STUDY Tanner Road Multifamily GREENVIL LE COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA REPORT PREPARED FOR: Flournoy Development Group PO Box 6566 Columbus, GA 31917 REPORT PREPARED BY Impact Designs Inc. 172 Williamson Road, Unit 3728 Mooresville, NC 28117 nick@impactdesignsinc.com Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 75 Tanner Road Multifamily | i  Table of Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................................. iii  1. INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................... 1  1.1.  Project Summary .............................................................................................................. 1  1.2.  Existing Roadway Conditions .......................................................................................... 1  1.3.  Driveway Locations .......................................................................................................... 2  2. TRAFFIC VOLUME DEVELOPMENT..................................................................................... 6  2.1.  Existing Traffic Volumes .................................................................................................. 6  2.2.  Projected Traffic Volumes ............................................................................................... 6  2.3.  Proposed Development Traffic Volumes ........................................................................ 6  2.4.  Future Build Traffic Volumes ......................................................................................... 7  3. TRAFFIC IMPACT ANALYSIS ............................................................................................... 13  3.1.  Turn Lane Analysis ........................................................................................................ 13  3.2.  Intersection LOS Analysis .............................................................................................. 13  3.3.  Queuing Analysis ............................................................................................................ 16  4. MULTIMODAL ANALYSIS ..................................................................................................... 18  4.1.  Pedestrian Connectivity ................................................................................................. 18  4.2.  Bicycle Connectivity ....................................................................................................... 18  5. SUMMARY OF FINDINGS ....................................................................................................... 19  Tables Table 1 – Study Area Summary .................................................................................................................... 1  Table 2 – Trip Generation ............................................................................................................................. 6  Table 3 – HCM 6th Edition LOS Criteria for Signalized & Unsignalized Intersections ............................. 13  Table 4 – Unsignalized Intersection Analysis Results ................................................................................ 14  Table 5 – Signalized Intersection Analysis Results .................................................................................... 15  Table 6 – Build Improved (2025) Results ................................................................................................... 16  Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 76 Tanner Road Multifamily | ii  Figures Figure 1 – Project Location ........................................................................................................................... 3  Figure 2 – Conceptual Site Plan .................................................................................................................... 4  Figure 3 – Existing Lane Configuration ....................................................................................................... 5  Figure 4 – Existing (2022) Traffic Volumes ................................................................................................. 8  Figure 5 – No-Build (2025) Traffic Volumes ............................................................................................... 9  Figure 6 – Trip Distributions ...................................................................................................................... 10  Figure 7 – Trip Assignment ........................................................................................................................ 11  Figure 8 – Build (2025) Traffic Volumes ................................................................................................... 12  Figure 9 – Recommended Lane Configuration ........................................................................................... 17  Appendices A) Traffic Count Data B) Turn Lane Analysis C) Synchro Analysis Reports D) SimTraffic Analysis Reports E) Existing Signal Plans and Timings Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 77 Tanner Road Multifamily | iii  EXECUTIVE SUMMARY A traffic impact study was conducted for the proposed Tanner Road multifamily development in accordance SCDOT and Greenville County guidelines. The proposed development is located on the southwest corner of Tanner Road and Verdin Road in Greenville County, South Carolina. The development is expected to consist of 90 townhome units, 36 carriage house rental units, and 345 apartment units. The project is anticipated to be constructed by the end of 2025. A turn lane analysis was conducted utilizing the Build (2025) volumes. Based on build out volumes, no turn lanes are warranted at site access points. The capacity analysis indicates that all approaches at the unsignalized intersections are expected to operate at LOS C or better under existing and future condi tions. No improvements are recommended at these locations. The capacity analysis indicates that, under Build conditions, the operations at the traffic signal at Verdin Road and Tanner Road is expected to be similar to No-Build conditions. At the traffic signal at Woodruff Road and Verdin Road/Feaster Road, the side street delay, which would be high under No-Build, is expected to increase under Build conditions with the addition of site traffic. By allocating time from the mainline to the side streets, the side street delay is anticipated to improve. The traffic signal is currently operating as a part of an adaptive system. As such, it is recommended that SCDOT adjust the parameters of the system to allow for longer side street splits during peak times. At the intersection of East Butler Road and Verdin Road, the southbound approach is not expected to drop in level of service from the No-Build to the Build conditions, but delay is expected to increase by nearly 21% in the AM peak hour and by nearly 25% in the PM peak hour. To mitigate the added delay, it is recommended that a right turn overlap be installed on the southbound approach to facilitate the high number of right turns. The improvement is anticipated to improve the southbound approach to LOS D in the PM peak hour. Recommendations:  Modify parameters of the adaptive signal system to allow for longer side street splits at Woodruff Road and Verdin Road/Feaster Road.  Install a right turn overlap on the southbound approach of Verdin Road at East Butler Road. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 78 Tanner Road Multifamily | 1  1. INTRODUCTION The purpose of this report is to summarize the traffi c impact study that was completed for Tanner Road multifamily site in Greenville County, South Carolina. The study was developed in accordance with SCDOT and Greenville County guidelines. This report summarizes the procedures and findings of the traffic impact study. 1.1. Project Summary The proposed development is located on the northeast corner of The Parkway and Parkway East in Greenville County, South Carolina. The development is expected to consist of 90 townhome units, 36 carriage house rental units, and 345 apartment units. The project is antic ipated to be constructed by the end of 2025. This traffic impact study analyzes the effects of the additi onal traffic associated with the proposed development during the weekday AM (7:00 AM - 9:00 AM) and the weekday PM (4:00 PM - 6:00 PM) peak periods. The study area for the purpose of the analysis includes:  Woodruff Road and Tanner Road  Woodruff Road and Verdin Road/Feaster Road  Verdin Road and Tanner Road  East Butler Road and Verdin Road/Holland Road  Tanner Road and Sonic driveway/Site Access A  Verdin Road and Site Access B  Verdin Road and daycare driveway/Site Acce ss C The proposed development is expected to be built out by the end of 2025. Therefore, 2025 w as considered as the future year for the purpose of this analysis. Refer to Figures 1 and 2 for the site location and the conceptual site plan. 1.2. Existing Roadway Conditions The primary roadways within the study area include Woodruff Road, Verdin Road, Tanner Road, and East Butler Road. A summary of their existing characteristics is shown in Table 1. Table 1 – Study Area Summary Facility Name Route # Typical Cross Section Posted Speed Limit Maintained By 2019 AADT Woodruff Road SC-146 5-lane undivided 45 MPH SCDOT 40,100 Verdin Road S-333 5-lane undivided 35 MPH SCDOT 8,300 Tanner Road S-655 2-lane undivided 30 MPH SCDOT N/A East Butler Road S-107 5-lane undivided 35 MPH SCDOT 24,400 Refer to Figure 3 for an illustration of the existing geometry and traffic control at the study intersections. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 79 Tanner Road Multifamily | 2  1.3. Driveway Locations Direct access to the Tanner Road multifamily development is proposed to be provided via one full movement access on Tanner Road opposite the Sonic driveway, a ri ght-in/right-out access on Verdin Road, and a full movement access on Verdin Road opposite the daycare driveway. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 80 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 81 S.C. GRID (NAD 83) TANNER ROAD (S-655) R/W VARIES (SEE R/W NOTES) SCDOT FILE NOS. 23.328A & 23.466A (EXISTING PAVED ROAD) TRACT 3 13.35+/- ACRESPIN 0547030104300 LYNN C. FARMER & ELAINE F. AYSCUE DB 1260, PAGE 550DB 1255, PAGE 455PB 5-J, PAGE 4250 TANNER ROAD TRACT 2 6.63+/- ACRES PIN 0547030104302WILTON E. JONESDB 1187, PAGE 272PB 5-J, PAGE 4230 TANNER ROAD TRACT 1 1.01+/- ACRES PIN 0547030104303TWO TANNER ROAD, LLC DB 2273, PAGE 1920PB 1011, PAGE 4 PIN 0547030104304JALIABAPA AND RADHADB 2452, PAGE 4216PB 49-S, PAGE 53 PIN 0547120108100 WOODRUFF CROSSING ASSOCIATION, INC. DB 2626, PAGE 3729PB 50-R, PAGE 21 & 22 PIN 0547150100700 WOODRUFF CROSSING VILLAS ASSOCIATION, INC.DB 2247, PAGE 369PB 1101, PAGE 20 PIN 0547030105019 BROOKFIELD REALTY II, LLC DB 2495, PAGE 4667PB 43-M, PAGE 38 PIN 0547030105023 GREENVILLE SENIOR LIVING, LLC DB 2538, PAGE 5569PB 1304, PAGE 94 S18°39'04"W 45426.58' (GRID) N61°42'43"E 33.43' (TIE) N20°59'15"E 633.56' (TOTAL) N21°02'06"E 472.15' (TOTAL) N69°41'12"W 629.01' N69°30'20"W 151.45' N69°39'21"W S61°57'39"W 216.72' S43°31'09"E212.15' (TIE) L1 L2 S23°35'48"E 65.68' S18°14'58"W 563.59' S65°39'17"E 698.55' (TOTAL) C1 C2 C3 S27°00'19"W 839.39' (TOTAL) 183.83' 630.33' N65°43'17"W N26°58'43"E 221.00' (TOTAL) N84°23'02"W 136.05' (TIE ONLY) X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X 14.8' 2.0'21.8' 2.0'12.0' 5.3'15.7' 9.2'1.8'5.4'1.7'10.3' 44.7' 2.0' 16.1'32.1' EXCEPTION 2(c) (COMM.# 3-02446(A)POSSIBLE ENCROACHMENT.POND OWNERSHIP UNKNOWN. VERDIN ROAD (S-333) R/W VARIES (SEE R/W NOTES) SCDOT FILE NOS. 23.328A & 23.466A (EXISTING PAVED ROAD) EXCEPTION 2(c) (COMM.# 3-02446(A)POSSIBLE ENCROACHMENT. CORNER OF BOX IS 0.32' OVER LINE. TRAFFICLIGHT WIREPOLE (TYP.) INV.:951.4'INV.: 951.7' 15"RCP GASTANK TRAFFICSIGNALBOX CURB INLETTOP: 955.6'INV.: 950.9' CURB INLETTOP: 954.4'INV.: 950.0' INV.:950.6' 18"RCP CURB INLETTOP: 960.4' CURB INLETTOP: 960.4' CURB INLETTOP: 961.6' STORMWATER MANHOLETOP: 956.0' STORMWATER MANHOLETOP: 959.0' CURB INLETTOP: 958.5' CURB INLETTOP: 961.7' PIN 0547030104301 WILTON E. &NANCY L. JONESDB 2453, PAGE 3260PB 5-J, PAGE 4230 TANNER ROAD 25.23' 208.70' 181.46' UTILITY POLE (TYP.) GUY WIRE (TYP.) SITE PLAN CV-1 6/8/22 2022045-P4.dwg N S W E Feet 060120 ' 1" =60 132 PILGRIM ROAD · GREENVILLE, SC 29607PH: (864) 297-3027 · FAX: (864) 729-8747 WWW.GRAYENGINEERING.COM · SC C.O.A.# C00060 · NC C.O.A.# C-1217 · GA C.O.A.# PEF001941 · TN C.O.A.# 0410819 · REVISIONNO. DATE BY AUTHORIZED BY GRAY ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS, INC. IN WRITING. AND SHALL NOT BE USED OR REPRODUCED IN ANY WAY OTHER THAN SERVICE AND THE PROPERTY OF GRAY ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS, INC. THIS DRAWING AND ASSOCIATED CAD FILES ARE AN INSTRUMENT OF Gray Engineering PROJECT MANAGER: DRAWN BY: PROJECT DATE: SCALE: JOB No.: PLOT DATE: D C B A 123456 SHEET TANNER-VERDIN APTS AT TANNER ROAD TANNER ROAD CITY OF MAULDIN, GREENVILLE COUNTY, SC DJG CJR 9/14/21 2021083 TYPE OF DEVELOPMENT: MULTI-FAMILY APARTMENTS NO. OF LOTS/UNITS: NO. OF ACRES: 11/05/2021 NEW ROAD: DATE: 376 APT UNITS 700± LF 27.5± ACRES TAX MAP #S: T028000101100, T028000101102, T028000101101 ENGINEER GRAY ENGINEERING RODNEY GRAY, P.E. 132 PILGRIM ROAD GREENVILLE, SC 29607 864-297-3027 SURVEYOR PRECISION LAND SURVEYING, INC. BRUCE COOK 439 BEULAH CHURCH ROAD ABBEVILLE, SC 29620 864-627-8067 DEVELOPER/APPLICANT LOCATION MAP (N.T.S.) TANNER-VERDIN APTS (PRELIMINARY SITE PLAN) PROPERTY BOUNDARY EXISTING DOT RIGHT-OF-WAY LOT LINES DRAINAGE/UTILITY EASEMENTS EXISTING/PROPOSED WATERLINE EXISTING/PROPOSED SEWER SETBACK MAIL KIOSK FIRE HYDRANT LINE TABLE LABEL BEARING DISTANCE L1 N89°36'24"E 31.50' L2 S29°44'52"E 109.34' L3 N58°27'12"W 86.18' L4 N29°48'15"W 131.48' L5 N17°53'41"W 292.26' L6 N83°11'16"W 32.54' CURVE TABLE LABEL RADIUS ARC CHORD CHORD BEARING DELTA C1 1062.27' 282.68' 281.85' N50°39'15"W 15°14'49" C2 966.34' 219.03' 218.56' N36°04'18"W 12°59'11" WHEELWRIGHT, LLC DAVID MILLER 100 HICKORY HILL LANE GREENVILLE, SC 29609 864-590-5958 Know what'sbelow. before you dig.Call R SAFETY NOTE TO CONTRACTOR THE CONTRACTOR SHALL SHORE TRENCH EXCAVATION AND USE PIPE BOX TO COMPLY WITH ALL OSHA SAFETY REGULATIONS. IT IS THE CONTRACTOR'S SOLE RESPONSIBILITY TO PROVIDE JOB SITE SAFETY AND COMPLY WITH ALL SAFETY REQUIREMENTS. THE CONTRACTOR IS RESPONSIBLE FOR HIS MEANS AND METHODS OF CONSTRUCTION. UTILITY NOTE TO CONTRACTOR THE UTILITIES SHOWN ARE FOR THE CONTRACTOR'S CONVENIENCE ONLY. THERE MAY BE OTHER UTILITIES NOT SHOWN ON THESE PLANS. THE ENGINEER ASSUMES NO RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE LOCATIONS SHOWN AND IT SHALL BE THE CONTRACTOR'S RESPONSIBILITY TO VERIFY THE LOCATIONS OF ALL UTILITIES WITHIN THE LIMITS OF THE WORK. ALL DAMAGE MADE TO EXISTING UTILITIES BY THE CONTRACTOR SHALL BE THE SOLE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE CONTRACTOR. ZONING: R-M20 A 11-05-21 DJG ISSUED TO BZA FOR PROPOSED LIFT STATION B 11-22-21 DJG UPDATED SITE PLAN PER SCDOT REVIEW C 02-07-22 DJG ISSUED TO TAYLORS SEWER FOR REVIEW D 02-28-22 DJG PRICING SET ISSUED TO PROJECT TEAM E 03-17-22 DJG ISSUED TO GREENVILLE COUNTY FOR REVIEW Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 82 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 83 Tanner Road Multifamily | 6  2. TRAFFIC VOLUME DEVELOPMENT 2.1. Existing Traffic Volumes Existing turning movement counts were conducted at the study intersecti ons in May 2022, during the AM (7:00 AM to 9:00 AM) peak period and the PM (4:00 PM to 6:00 PM) peak period. The 2022 traffic volumes are illustrated in Figure 4. 2.2. Projected Traffic Volumes Based on SCDOT Average Annual Daily Traffic (AADT) volumes, daily traffic volumes on Woodruff Road have increased at an average rate of 4% per year from 2016 to 2019, while volumes on East Butler Road have remained stagnant in that same time. To be conservative, a 3% annual growth was applied to the 2022 counts to develop the No-Build (2025) volumes. This growth rate was applied to account for all background growth in the area without any adjacent and/or the proposed de velopments. The calculations for this factor can be found in Appendix A. Refer to Figure 5 for an illustration of the No-Build (2025) traffic volumes at the study intersections. 2.3. Proposed Development Traffic Volumes As mentioned previously, the proposed development is expected to consist of 90 townhome units, 36 carriage house rental units, and 345 apartment units. The trip generation potential for the proposed development was estimated utilizing methodology contained within the ITE’s Trip Generation Manual, 11th Edition. For the purposes of this analysis, the carriage house units were classified as Low-Rise Multifamily (ITE Code 220) while the apartment units were classified as Mid-Rise Multifamily (ITE Code 221) . Utilizing ITE data for ITE Code 215, ITE Code 220, and ITE Code 221, traffic volumes were generated for the weekday daily, the weekday AM peak hour, and the weekday PM peak hour . Refer to Table 2 for a summary of the trip generation potential of the proposed development. Table 2 – Trip Generation ITE Land Use (Code) Density Independent Variable Daily Traffic AM Peak PM Peak Enter Exit Enter Exit Single Family Attached Housing (ITE Code 215) 90 Dwelling Units 635 13 28 28 22 Multifamily Housing (Low-Rise) (ITE Code 220) 36 Dwelling Units 306 8 26 23 13 Multifamily Housing (Mid-Rise) (ITE Code 221) 345 Dwelling Units 1,599 32 108 72 53 Total New Trips: 2,540 53 162 133 88 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 84 Tanner Road Multifamily | 7  Traffic associated with the proposed development was distributed and assigned to the roadway network based upon existing travel patterns and are summarized below:  10% to/from the north via Feaster Road  25% to/from the west via Woodruff Road  20% to/from the east via Woodruff Road  5% to/from the east via Tanner Road  10% to/from the south via Holland Road  35% to/from the west via East Butler Road Refer to Figures 6 and 7 for the site trip distributions and assignments. 2.4. Future Build Traffic Volumes The site generated traffic volumes were added to the No-Build (2025) traffic volumes to determine the Build (2025) volumes. The Build (2025) volumes are illustrated in Figure 8. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 85 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 86 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 87 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 88 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 89 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 90 Tanner Road Multifamily | 13  3. TRAFFIC IMPACT ANALYSIS 3.1. Turn Lane Analysis A turn lane analysis was conducted utilizing the Build (2025) volumes. Based on build out volumes, no turn lanes are warranted at the site access points. Refer to Appendix B for the turn lane warrants with volumes graphed. 3.2. Intersection LOS Analysis Using the existing, no-build, and build traffic volum es, intersection analyses were conducted for the study intersections under Existing (2022) conditions, No-Build (2025) conditions, and Build (2025) conditions. This analysis was conducted using th e Transportation Research Board’s Highway Capacity Manual (HCM 6th Edition) methodologies of the Synchro, Version 11 software. Intersection level of service (LOS) grades range from LOS A to LOS F, which are directly related to the level of control delay at the intersection and characterize the operational conditions of the intersection traffic flow. LOS A operations typically represent ideal, free-flow conditions where vehicles experience little to no delays, and LOS F operations typically re present poor, forced-flow (bumper-t o-bumper) conditions with high vehicular delays, and are generally considered undesirable. Table 3 summarizes the HCM 6th Edition control delay thresholds associated with each LOS grade for signalized and unsignalized intersections. Table 3 – HCM 6th Edition LOS Criteria for Signalized & Unsignalized Intersections Signalized Intersections Unsignalized Intersections LOS Control Delay per Vehicle (seconds) LOS Control Delay per Vehicle (seconds) A ≤ 10 A ≤ 10 B > 10 and ≤ 20 B > 10 and ≤ 15 C > 20 and ≤ 35 C > 15 and ≤ 25 D > 35 and ≤ 55 D > 25 and ≤ 35 E > 55 and ≤ 80 E > 35 and ≤ 50 F > 85 F > 50 The results of the capacity analysis for the study intersections under existing traffic control are summarized in Tables 4 a nd 5. Refer to Appendix C for the deta iled capacity analysis reports and Appendix D for the queuing analysis results. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 91 Tanner Road Multifamily | 14  Table 4 – Unsignalized Intersection Analysis Results Intersection Approach LOS (Delay in seconds per vehicle) Existing (2022) Conditions No-Build (2025) Conditions Build (2025) Conditions AM PM AM PM AM PM Woodruff Road and Tanner Road EB - - - - - - WB - - - - - - NB B (14.2) C (19.7) C (15.1) C (22.2) C (15.8) C (23.7) Tanner Road and Sonic Driveway/ Site Access A EB A (7.3) A (0.0) A (7.3) A (0.0) A (7.3) A (0.0) WB - - - - A (7.7) A (8.1) NB Analyzed under Build conditions ONLY B (10.3) B (11.2) SB A (9.7) B (10.2) A (9.8) B (10.4) B (10.7) B (11.7) Verdin Road and Site Access B EB Analyzed under Build conditions ONLY A (9.9) B (10.2) NB - - SB - - Verdin Road and Daycare Driveway/ Site Access C EB Analyzed under Build conditions ONLY C (17.8) C (21.1) WB B (12.4) B (14.1) B (13.1) C (15.2) C (15.4) C (20.9) NB - - - - A (8.3) A (8.8) SB A (8.2) A (8.3) A (8.3) A (8.4) A (8.3) A (8.4) The capacity analysis indicates that all approaches at the unsignalized intersections are expected to operate at LOS C or better under existing and future condi tions. No improvements are recommended at these locations. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 92 Tanner Road Multifamily | 15  Table 5 – Signalized Intersection Analysis Results Intersection Approach LOS (Delay in seconds per vehicle) Existing (2022) Conditions No-Build (2025) Conditions Build (2025) Conditions AM PM AM PM AM PM Woodruff Road and Verdin Road/ Feaster Road EB C (22.3) C (30.0) C (29.3) D (35.8) C (29.6) D (36.0) WB C (29.8) C (30.1) D (35.9) D (37.5) D (35.8) D (44.5) NB F (118.9) F (131.1) F (133.7) F (154.8) F (188.9) F (177.3) SB F (128.8) F (123.6) F (141.0) F (139.3) F (147.2) F (147.9) Overall D (45.8) D (54.2) D (53.7) E (64.1) E (62.7) E (71.6) Verdin Road and Tanner Road EB B (10.5) B (17.5) B (12.3) B (17.2) B (15.3) B (16.6) WB A (7.5) A (9.4) A (8.0) A (9.8) A (7.3) A (9.9) NB A (9.4) B (18.1) A (9.2) B (20.0) B (10.8) C (22.7) SB B (11.7) B (14.2) B (13.3) B (15.6) B (14.8) B (17.4) Overall A (9.9) B (15.6) B (10.8) B (16.6) B (12.4) B (17.8) East Butler Road and Verdin Road/ Holland Road EB C (29.2) C (20.5) D (37.3) C (26.2) D (39.6) C (28.9) WB C (32.5) B (16.2) D (38.9) B (18.1) D (39.3) B (18.3) NB C (34.8) C (32.8) D (37.4) C (32.1) D (37.6) C (32.3) SB D (37.9) D (41.8) D (39.4) E (55.7) D (47.6) E (69.6) Overall C (32.4) C (25.3) D (38.0) C (31.0) D (40.0) D (35.4) The capacity analysis indicates that, under Build conditions, the operations at the traffic signal at Verdin Road and Tanner Road is expected to be similar to No-Build conditions. At the traffic signal at Woodruff Road and Verdin Road/Feaster Road, the side street delay, which would be high under No-Build, is expected to increase under Build conditions with the addition of site traffic. By allocating time from the mainline to the side streets, the side street delay is anticipated to improve as shown below in Table 6. The traffic signal is currently operating as a part of an adaptive system. As such, it is recommended that SCDOT adjust the parameters of the system to allow for longer side street splits during peak times. At the intersection of East Butler Road and Verdin Road, the southbound approach is not expected to drop in level of service from the No-Build to the Build conditions, but delay is expected to increase by nearly 21% in the AM peak hour and by nearly 25% in the PM peak hour. To mitigate the added delay, it is recommended that a right turn overlap be installed on the southbound approach to facilitate the high number of right turns. As shown below in Table 6, the improvement is anticipated to improve the southbound approach to LOS D in the PM peak hour. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 93 Tanner Road Multifamily | 16  Table 6 – Build Improved (2025) Results Intersection Approach LOS (Delay in seconds per vehicle) AM PM Woodruff Road and Verdin Road/ Feaster Road EB C (29.9) D (50.7) WB D (45.4) D (53.6) NB F (138.1) F (120.2) SB F (138.4) F (123.0) Overall E (60.4) E (69.8) East Butler Road and Verdin Road/ Holland Road EB D (39.9) C (28.9) WB D (39.8) B (18.3) NB D (37.4) C (32.3) SB D (47.4) D (46.9) Overall D (40.0) C (30.6) 3.3. Queuing Analysis A queuing analysis was performed for the No-Build and the Build Improved scenarios. Without the addition of site traffic, queuing on the northbound approach of Verdin Road at Woodruff Road is expected to be a concern due to the short length of the block between Tanner Road and Woodruff Road. Queuing under the Build Improved scenarios is expected to be similar. Increased side street splits should more adequately clear the queue, allowing for more opportunity for turning traffic from Tanner Road to proceed north towards Woodruff Road. Figure 9 shows the proposed lane configurations and traffic control for the Build (2025) conditions. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 94 Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 95 Tanner Road Multifamily | 18  4. MULTIMODAL ANALYSIS 4.1. Pedestrian Connectivity Currently there are sidewalks on both sides of Verdin Road between Woodruff Road and Tanner Road, and there is a sidewalk only on the eastside of Verdin Road between Tanner Road and East Butler Road. There are currently no sidewalks along the development’s property frontage. The traffic signal at Woodruff Road and Verdin Road has pedestrian features (crosswalks, pedestrian signal heads, and push buttons) on each corner. However, the traffic signal at Verdin Road and Tanner Road has no pedestrian features. As an improvement, the proposed development should consider the addition of sidewalk on its property frontage and the installation of pedestrian signals at the intersection of Verdin Road and Tanner Road. 4.2. Bicycle Connectivity Currently there are bike lanes on both sides of Verdin Road between Tanner Road and East Butler Road, but they do not connect to another bicycle facility at either end. Without widening the existing roads, there are no feasible bicycle infrastructure improvements that would increase the connectivity of the proposed development and the existing infrastructure. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 96 Tanner Road Multifamily | 19  5. SUMMARY OF FINDINGS A traffic impact study was conducted for the proposed Tanner Road multifamily development in accordance SCDOT and Greenville County guidelines. The proposed development is located on the southwest corner of Tanner Road and Verdin Road in Greenville County, South Carolina. The development is expected to consist of 90 townhome units, 36 carriage house rental units, and 345 apartment units. The project is anticipated to be constructed by the end of 2025. A turn lane analysis was conducted utilizing the Build (2025) volumes. Based on build out volumes, no turn lanes are warranted at site access points. The capacity analysis indicates that all approaches at the unsignalized intersections are expected to operate at LOS C or better under existing and future condi tions. No improvements are recommended at these locations. The capacity analysis indicates that, under Build conditions, the operations at the traffic signal at Verdin Road and Tanner Road is expected to be similar to No-Build conditions. At the traffic signal at Woodruff Road and Verdin Road/Feaster Road, the side street delay, which would be high under No-Build, is expected to increase under Build conditions with the addition of site traffic. By allocating time from the mainline to the side streets, the side street delay is anticipated to improve. The traffic signal is currently operating as a part of an adaptive system. As such, it is recommended that SCDOT adjust the parameters of the system to allow for longer side street splits during peak times. At the intersection of East Butler Road and Verdin Road, the southbound approach is not expected to drop in level of service from the No-Build to the Build conditions, but delay is expected to increase by nearly 21% in the AM peak hour and by nearly 25% in the PM peak hour. To mitigate the added delay, it is recommended that a right turn overlap be installed on the southbound approach to facilitate the high number of right turns. The improvement is anticipated to improve the southbound approach to LOS D in the PM peak hour. Recommendations:  Modify parameters of the adaptive signal system to allow for longer side street splits at Woodruff Road and Verdin Road/Feaster Road.  Install a right turn overlap on the southbound approach of Verdin Road at East Butler Road. Building Codes Committee Meeting *** Page 97

Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.