Rec Agenda February 2022 FINAL COUNCIL
City of Mauldin · Greenville County · meeting of Feb 4, 2022 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Mauldin
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
RECREATION
COMMITTEE MEETING
MONDAY, FEBRUARY 7, 2022 | 6 PM
5th committee meeting
The Committee will meet in Mauldin City Hall at 5 East
Butler Road in the Council Chambers
at 6 p.m.
The meeting will be available remotely through Zoom. Please visit the City’s website at
https://cityofmauldin.org/your-government/meeting-minutes-agendas/ to access the
meeting via audio and videoconferencing.
1
RECREATION COMMITTEE MEETING
FEBRUARY 7,2022 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5 E. BUTLER ROAD
Committee Members: Frank Allgood (Chair), Taft Matney, and Michael Reynolds
1. Call to Order The Honorable Frank Allgood
2. Public Comment The Honorable Frank Allgood
3. Reading and Approval of Minutes
a.Recreation Committee Meeting: October 4, 2021
[Pages 3-5]
The Honorable Frank Allgood
4. Reports or Communications from City Officers
a. Recreation Director Bart Cumalander
i. Budget Review
The Honorable Frank Allgood
5. Unfinished Business
There is no unfinished business.
The Honorable Frank Allgood
6. New Business
a.Springfield Park Parking Lot Paving Project [Pages 6-12]
The Honorable Frank Allgood
7. Public Comment The Honorable Frank Allgood
8. Committee Concerns The Honorable Frank Allgood
9. Adjournment
2
MINUTES
RECREATION COMMITTEE MEETING
OCTOBER 4, 2021, 6PM
CITY HALL - COUNCIL CHAMBERS
5 E. BUTLER ROAD
3rd committee meeting
C
ommittee Members: Dale Black (Chair), Taft Matney, and Michael Reynolds
Others present: Recreation Director Bart Cumalander and City Administrator Brandon Madden
1
. C
all to Order- Chairman Black
2
. Public Comment - None
3. R
eading and Approval of Minutes
a. Recreation Committee Meeting: September 7, 2021
Motion: Councilman Matney made a motion to approve the minutes with Councilman Reynolds
seconding.
Vote: The vote was unanimous (3-0).
4.
Reports or Communications from City Officers
a. Recreation Director Bart Cumalander
i. Budget Review- The budget looks good.
Mr. Cumalander reported the Marketing Director is getting out in the community and bringing in
new memberships. Greg Beaman is doing well as the new Senior Center Coordinator.
Mr. Cumalander advised Council the Senior Center parking lot is being closed at certain times of
the day to help alleviate the problem of high school parents parking in the Senior Center and
taking spots away from the seniors.
Councilman Matney said not only is this an inconvenience for the Seniors, but a safety issue for
the students. He thanked Mr. Cumalander for closing the gates.
5
. U
nfinished Business- There is no unfinished business.
6.
New Business
a. Renaming Pineforest Park- This request came from a young man who lives in the neighborhood.
Chairman Black said the people who live there should give their opinion on a park renaming.
Councilman Reynolds said this item could be connected with the shelter that will be put in the
park.
Councilman Matney said he would like to hear the neighborhood sentiment before we go much
further in the process. Mr. Madden said staff can survey each resident to find out if there is
interest in renaming the park. This item will need no further action until additional information is
gathered. Councilman Reynolds suggested getting the young man whose idea this was to help
3
gather information.
b. Springfield Park Parking Lot Paving
C
ouncil budgeted $125,000 in its Capital Improvement Plan for repaving the parking lot with new
asphalt at Springfield Park. The bid from Panagokos is $198,337 for the older section of the
parking lot and $76,840 for the newer section of the parking lot that was repaved approximately 5
years ago. Asphalt costs have increased significantly since staff obtained quotes for this project
during the FY2022 budget development process.
Funding is available in the Capital Project Fund balance to cover the additional funds, or the RFP
can be reposted. Staff recommends proceeding with repaving the older section of the parking lot.
Motion: Councilman Matney made a motion to send this item to Council.
Councilman Reynolds asked if this would be a good time to look at expanding the lot. Mr.
Cumalander said he asked the contractor and the contractor said there is really not a way to put
more parking spaces in as the lot is now. Councilman Reynolds asked if the shed could be
relocated to allow for more spaces. Chairman Black said the older parking lot at least needs to be
brought up to code. Councilman Reynolds asked the size of the shed. Mr. Fleahman said
probably around 40’x60’. Councilman Reynolds said he has no problem with repaving the lots, but
wants to think about expansion as well.
C
ouncilman Matney said he doesn’t ever remember the parking lot being repaved. There is a
sa
fety issue and a functionality component of this project. He does agree with Councilman
Reynolds regarding the shed. We just purchased a new public works facility, and it could be
moved. Parking is a premium at Springfield.
M
r. Madden said the quotes do not include replacing the curbing and the price could increase if
additional curbing is needed or if bad soil is encountered. Committee may want to consider
p
lacing a not to exceed amount.
C
hairman Black said Panagakos did the paving at the Senior Center and there was a way to
reconstruct if bad soil was present.
C
ouncilman Matney said we are making improvements at the other parks and the Senior Center
p
arking lot was just done. Springfield Park should get the same improvement.
C
ouncilman Matney rescinded his original motion and added a not to exceed number of $225,000.
Councilman Reynolds seconded the motion.
Vo
te: The vote was unanimous (3-0).
4
c. P ARD Grant Amendment
Th
e Recreation Department was awarded a PARD grant in the amount of $68,843.18, with a 20%
match of $13,768.64 to reimburse the costs associated with improvements to the City Park walking
trail. The improvements to the walking trail are slated to occur this fiscal year as a component of
the City’s FY2022 Capital Improvement Plan. The FY2022 Recreation Department budget will need
to be amended in the amount of $13,768.64 to cover the full match amount of the Park and
Recreation Development Fund (PARD) Grant.
Motion: Councilman Reynolds made a motion to send this item to Council with Councilman
Matney seconding.
V
ote: The vote was unanimous (3-0).
7.
Public Comment- None
8.
Committee Concerns- Councilman Matney asked that cost estimates related to Springfield Park be
brought to Council this month.
9
. A
djournment- Chairman Black adjourned the meeting at 7:15 p.m.
R
espectfully Submitted,
Cindy Miller
Municipal Clerk
5
RECREATION COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
ME
ETING DATE: February 7, 2022
AGENDA ITEM: 6a
TO: R
ecreation Committee
FROM: Recreation Director Bart Cumalander
SUBJECT: Springfield Park Parking Lot Paving Project
REQUEST
Approval of a change order for the Springfield Park Parking Lot Paving Project in the amount of $268,620.
HISTORY/BACKGROUND
The City issued a solicitation for Request for Proposals (RFP) from qualified contractors to repave the
parking lot with new asphalt at Springfield Park. The RFP was issued on August 26, 2021 and closed on
September 26, 2021.
During it s October 18, 2 022 meeting, C ity Council approved awarding t he Springfield Park parking lot
paving project to Panagakos Asphalt Paving, Inc in the amount of $225,000.
ANALYSIS or STAFF FINDINGS
Panagakos commenced the project on January 26, 2022. After removing the existing asphalt,
Panagakos observed that the condition of the subgrade was extremely poor. Panagakos, in
coordination with the City’s Public Works Department, conducted a proof roll of the parking lot.
A
proof roll is an assessment of the subgrade layer prior to installing overlying pavement layers. The
subgrade proof roll is a visual assessment to determine if it will enable the construction of the
subsequent pavement layers. The assessment is conducted using a tandem axle dump truck, and the
impact of the truck rolling over the subgrade provides visual evidence of the condition of the subgrade.
The result of the proof roll of the current subgrade of the parking lot was unsuccessful. This means that
the subgrade is not stable enough to allow for asphalt to be laid over it to be warranted by Panagakos
and would result in cracking, relatively soon, in high traffic areas.
As a result, an independent geotechnical firm inspected the subgrade, and recommended options for
stabilizing the subgrade so that it would pass the proof roll prior to being paved. Attached is their
assessment.
The poor condition of the subgrade is likely a result of:
• Age of the parking lot which, was originally paved in 1970s
• Deferred maintenance on the lot as the last time the lot was repaved was in 1978-79
• Infiltration of surface stormwater through the cracks in the asphalt
6
FISCAL IMPACT
If approved, the change order provided by Panagakos is $268,620. Funding is available to cover the cost
of this change order in the Hospitality & Accommodations Tax Fund Balance.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends approval of the change order which is commensurate with option #1 from the BLE
assessment. Contributing to this recommendation are the following factors:
• The City has made significant investments to the playgrounds at Springfield Park in the last two
fiscal years, totaling over $500K.
• The City resurfaced the Springfield Park basketball court and added new fencing around the park
last year, totaling approximately $10K
• The City recently completed a major stormwater project for the lower section of Springfield
Park, totaling approximately $30K.
Given the foregoing investments at Springfield Park, improving the subgrade of the parking lot to
properly resurface the parking lot continues the City’s ongoing investments into its parks.
ATTACHMENTS
Panakagos original proposal
Panakagos change order
BLE assessment report
7
DATE: 2/1/2022
Item Amount
1.
2.
3.
4.
Estimated Total: $268,620.00
* Panagakos will work at the direction of Owner's Rep. / Soils Engineer
* Actual change order amount will be determined by total amount of material installed.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Sincerely: ACCEPTANCE:
Panagakos Asphalt Paving, Inc.
Travis Spain COMPANY:
BY:
DATE:
PANAGAKOS ASPHALT PAVING, INC.
P.O. Box 25187, Greenville, S.C. 29616
Phone: 864-277-7860: Fax: 864-422-8749
CHANGE ORDER REQUEST
To:
Public utilities
will be located by appropriate service provider. Owner is to locate all owner owned utilities. Any work to relocate or repair
utilities must be
done by others and paid for by the owner.
Only the work and
materials listed above are included in this proposal.
NOTES, TERMS, AND CONDITIONS
Signature (Title)
All work in this pr
oposal will be completed in one (1) mobilization & during normal business hours.
Dewatering of any fo
rm is NOT included in this proposal.
Soil testing is not
included.
Unless there is at least a 1% fall on the areas to be paved we do not guarantee that water will drain from pavement.
Panagakos will not be re
sponsible for any fees or permits that are required for this work.
Full payment is due at
completion of project.
This proposal may be with
drawn if not accepted within 30 days.
Upon acceptance, thi
s proposal becomes a binding contract between Panagakos Asphalt Paving, Inc. and City of Mauldin. In the event of a
disagreement between any other contract documents and this proposal then this proposal will govern.
The above offer is hereby accepted, and Panagakos Asphalt Paving is authorized
to do the work as
specified.
Panagakos Asphalt Paving, Inc. propose
s to furnish all equipment, labor, and materials to accomplish the following work in accordance with your inquiry.
Description
Undercut of Existing Soft & Yielding Soils - BLE Recommendation #1
Project:
City of Mauldin
Springfield Park Parking Lo
t Improvements
Remove existing to a d
epth of 12" and haul off site.
Install 8" of Surge Stone - 2,904 to
ns @ $65.00 per ton
Install 4" of Crusher R
un Stone - 1,452 tons @ $55.00 per ton
Proof roll base mater
ial with Owner/Owners Rep. prior to paving
8
PROJECT:
LOCATION:
CLIENT:
CONTRACTOR:
BLE PROJECT NO.:
DEFICIENCY NOTED: REINSPECTION REQUIRED:
DATE: INSPECTOR:
STANDBY TIME:
City of Mauldin 1.25
Panagakos
TOTAL TIME:
0
DAILY FIELD REPORT
Springfield Park 0.50
Mauldin, SC
TRAVEL TIME:
TIME ON SITE: 0.75
REPORT DATE
1/27/2022
BUNNELL LAMMONS ENGINEERING, INC.
GREENVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA · PHONE: (864) 288-1265 · FAX: (864) 288-4430
REVIEWED BY: D Nease 01/31/22 Daniel Brown
CORRECTED:
BLE representative visited the site to observe subgrade conditions and a proofroll for the Springfield
Park parking lot. Subgrade soils were probed and observed using a hand auger in addition to a
proofroll performed using a tandem axle dump truck. Soft/unstable subgrade soils were observe
throughout the parking area with ruts reaching 2 inches in depth in the most severe locations. Damp
soils were observed underneath the existing stone base. Areas of the stone base were observed to be
cracking during the proofroll which indicates movement within the underlying soils. Depending on the
direction on repairs, BLE can re-visit to help try and provide quantities along with Panakagos of
repairs. Depending upon the City's budget, there are several options to partially or fully stabilize the
subgrade:
1) Isolate and stabilize the areas where pumping and rutting are most severe. Undercut and remove
approximately 12 inches of subgrade and replace with 6 to 8 inches of surge stone, capped off with 4
to 6 inches of crushed stone base. This option must weigh the risk of destabilizing additional areas of
the parking lot under construction equipment loads during export and import activities. The contractor
would need to try and keep construction traffic within same travel areas to help minimize additional
damage. This method would only address the significant areas of pumping and would not address all
areas in order to help with the project costs. The owner would more than likely need to take
responsibility of the asphalt pavement warranty.
2) Isolate and stabilize only the driving lanes where pumping and rutting are most severe. This again
would involve undercutting up to 12 inches of subgrade and replacing with 6 to 8 inches of surge,
capped off with 4 to 6 inches of crushed stone base. The paving contractor will most likely not warranty
the asphalt if this option is selected. Again, this option could be considered if budgeting is a concern.
3) The final options would be to either remove the upper stone base (where present), undercut the wet
soils, and then backfill with the existing stone and new stone base. In addition, the parking lot could
be stabilized by soil cementing. This option will provide a uniform, weather-sensative, reliable paving
surface. This operation minimizes the risk of destabilizing additional areas of the parking lot while also
having weather resistant qualities once in place. BLE can provide further recommendations on depth
and quantity of cement should Mauldin choose this option.
WEATHER: SITE CONDITIONS:
TYPE OF INSPECTION (S):
PARTLY CLOUDY DRY PROOFROLLING
9
PROJECT:
LOCATION:
CLIENT:
BLE PROJECT NO.:
REPORT DATE
1/27/2022
DAILY FIELD REPORT
BUNNELL LAMMONS ENGINEERING, INC.
GREENVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA · PHONE: (864) 288-1265 · FAX: (864) 288-4430
Springfield Park
0
City of Mauldin
Mauldin, SC
10
PROJECT:
LOCATION:
CLIENT:
BLE PROJECT NO.:
DAILY FIELD REPORT
REPORT DATE
1/27/2022
GREENVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA · PHONE: (864) 288-1265 · FAX: (864) 288-4430
Springfield Park
Mauldin, SC
City of Mauldin
0
BUNNELL LAMMONS ENGINEERING, INC.
11
BLE
repre
Springfield Park 01/27/22 TEST LOCATION PLANCity of Mauldin 0
12
Source: City of Mauldin website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.