RecordWell Data

_02192026-10700

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Feb 19, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

HUMAN RESOURCES COMMITTEE February 19, 2026 A meeting of the Human Resources Committee was held this date 4:00 p.m. virtually. Notice of this meeting was sent to all local news media. PRESENT Councilmember Stephen Bowden, Chair, Councilmember Karl L. Brady, Jr., Vice Chair, Councilmember Boyd Gregg, Councilmember William Tinkler , Councilmember Leslie S Skardon, and Mayor William S. Cogswell, Jr. . STAFF : Tammy O ’Berry, Director, Human Resources Director, Elizabeth Dieck, Chief of Staff, Lindsay Mazell, Talent Acquisition Manager, Isabel Quattlebaum, HR Analyst, and Jennifer Strickland, Compensation A meeting of the Human Resources Committee was held this date at 4:00 p.m. virtually. The meeting was opened with a moment of silence. Approval of November 13, 2025 minutes Councilmember Tinkler moved for approval of the minutes . Councilmember Skardon seconded the motion. The minutes were approved unanimously. New Business A . Updated HR Organization Chart Ms. Strickland noted they had gone through a lot of changes in the past six months. Until now the presentations shown to their predecessors were basically the same presentation s that had been offered from HR from the past five or six years. They were going to change it up throughout the rest of 2026 as one of their goals during 2026 was to find valuable, meaningful metrics and measurements to share with the Commission. One of the things she noticed when she came on board was a lot of what was shared was only about employment . For those who were on the committee before they might see things that look different today. She said they were going to start with the HR Organization Chart. Ms. Stickland noted teams were divided up into “pods ”. They had a team dedicated to employee relations and employee development handling training, performance management, which was new for the the City, employee relations and employee recognition. They had another team dedicated to talent requisition and onboarding , another team dedicated to efficiency, effectiveness and operations, which was a new HR compensation , and knowledge management group. Most of those rules were new for the City. There was also a team dedicated to benefits and wellness. Ms. Strickland said each manager would introduce the metrics for their group. Recruiting and Onboarding Update Lindsay Mazell, Talent Acquisition and Onboarding Quarter 4 Sworn Staffing Levels – Historical Comparison While waiting for Ms. Mazell to respond, Ms. Strickland noted these were some of the traditional numbers they shared in the past looking at the quarter 4 turnover. In t he turnover since 2022, there was a strong decrease in the fire turnover. Police turnover looked like it went up some in 2025. Nonsworn was 3.21% in quarter four. They were looking at the comparisons quarter over quarter. This was comparing it to prior fourth quarters. This was the City ’s current turnover situation . The numbers were looking very good over all. Committee on Human Resources February 19, 2026 Page 2 In reference to 2025 Total Turnover as a whole, Ms. Strickland noted while COVID did some really weird things to the City but if you ignored that 2021 frame work, the City looked really good on all of it ’s turnover numbers, steadily overall in a much better place than it was couple years ago . The highest turnover being in the nonsworn category at 12.35%. Standard turnover, if you were below 15% typically you were doing well. That was the way industry looked at turnover. Councilmember Bowden asked Ms. Strickland if she would prefer to get through this, or would she entertain some questions while going through it. Ms. Strickland noted that Ms. Mazell ’s microphone wasn ’t working earlier but was working now and she would turn the discussion over to Ms. Mazell. Councilmember Gregg asked in reference to the turnover rate, what was an expected turnover rate for municipalities like Charleston? Was Charleston doing better or worse than other municipalities in these departments? Were we doing any better than other municipalities or worse in this department? He thought this would give them an indication of where the City stood competitively in trying to hire municipal employees. He asked if that was correct. Ms. O ’Berry said yes. What they were saying nationwide turnover at 15% was pretty much that if you start seeing 15%, you would start to worry. Between 10% and 12% was considered good. You look at some police departments and you see turnover rates of 50% . Y ou look at a few and you might see a turnover rate of 5%. It depended on the city and where you were . D uring the 2021-2022 COVID era where you saw a lot of turnover in police and fire , Charleston ’s number looked great compared to what was happening nationally. But it was difficult to lose a policeman or fire employee because it took longer to train them to get them back up and running . She said they would make a note on the next presentation to bring national turnover numbers to see what that looks like. T he fire department sworn staffing was currently at 98% . The police department was at 92%. The police department was preparing to bring in another big class so that number would go up to about 98%. But since at times they would bring employees in big groups, that number might drop down closer to the 90 th percentile. Then you will see them bring in a big class all at one time so that number would sit pretty high for a moment. Then attrition would occur and one would see another class come in the fall. Councilmember Tinkler asked if they had any idea what would have led to that uptick in turnover for the firemen or was it retirements on the prior slide. Ms. O ’Berry said what happened was they might not have done a class in 2024. 2023 had turnover of about 10% and a dip in 2024. They were averaging about 10% in the fire department in the past many years but for some reason there was a large dip in 2024. She said she would try to find out why it dipped so low last year, and she will also add that to the follow up list as well. Under the Non-Sworn Vacancy Rates, Ms. O ’Berry asked them to remember when they were looking at this was the small departments, such as HR, 10% turnover could be one person. Some of the numbers under small departments weren ’t a s relevant such as the 13% under Clerk of Council was probably one person. W hat one wanted to look for was any major changes in turnover or any large numbers in the small departments . They saw a decrease in a few of the larger department s in turnovers such as Public Service and Planning and Preservation. Ms. Strickland added she noticed that the City tended to run high per quarter in the vacancy rates . Some of the departments ran 30%. Whenever she looked at this table she always looked to see that the City was at 30% or below , she knew the City was doing well. Employee Relations and Organizational Development – Lee Wilder Ms. O ’Berry said Mr. Wilder was on vacation and she would do the presentation. Quarter 4 – Overview  Local Government Advanced Supervisory Training Ms. O ’Berry said they offered their first local government advanced supervisory training. They put seven supervisors through an intensive six day training course. That training was partnered with the College of Committee on Human Resources February 19, 2026 Page 3 Charleston Riley Center and offered that to the seven supervisor s last quarter. They also had 13 employee related investigations and 14 involuntary terminations last quarter. Chair Bowden said 14 seemed like a high number. Ms. O ’Berry said these were numbers they never showed before so you didn ’t have a history or trend on this. This was some of the new stuff they just added. She said if one looked at 14, if you looked back over the two quarters she had been here, quarter three and four of last year, it was running about that each quarter. She believed that they would continue to run between 10 and 15 per quarter. That was a lot of terminations. The City had a zero tolerance drug testing policy that affected many of those terminations. And there were many supervisors who had done a good job of starting to bringing forward to them issues or concerns they had for the performance isn ’t where it needs to be. This team does a good job of trying to first develop employees to be able to perform. If they aren ’t able to perform, they help manage them out into other opportunities for them somewhere else. This was a big part of the team ’s role – try to rehabilitate, try to get things up and running but if not, work towards moving in this direction. She thought they were going to see that number stay above 10 every quarter based on some of the stuff that came through the office and some of the things their employees chose to do while they were working at the City. Mrs. Dieck said they had a one strike zero tolerance rule for the City ’s drug policy. She noted she spoke to Ms. O ’Berry about many other jurisdictions have an opportunity for individuals to get help and return to the city for employment or wherever they were employed. She thought they should look into this at some point because it was very harsh and the way it has resulted in a lot of involuntary terminations. She didn ’t know what the per centage was but it was very high, probably 80% based upon what she knew. She felt that was something they should look into and she wanted their feedback. Chair Bowden said in addition to it having a harsh consequence for the person being terminated, the City might be shooting itself in the foot on that if someone was just going through a tough time or many other explanations that the public wouldn ’t expect would result in termination. The accountability part they talked about was great. It was terrible when you had to terminate anybody. Nobody ever want ed to be in that situation but sometimes it had to be done. But they had to make sure the City ’s policies were aligned with what was in the best interest of the City. Mrs. Dieck said the City lost some good people through this policy . Because of that, she felt t hey really needed to reevaluate and figure out where they wanted to go from here on out. Ms. O ’Berry said they did have that on their review list for next quarter. Councilmember Tinkler asked it that was a policy that a previous Council had put into plac e. Ms. O ’Berry said being new, she wasn ’t sure where the history was regarding that. She did know quite a few other agencies didn ’t have zero tolerance. They had a process where one could get help and be allowed to come back. She noted having worked at some places with that process, on average if 10 people failed a drug test , all would be requested to some sort of program to be able to come back to work. Usually about a half would choose to leave and the other half would attend the program to get back to work . It was an effective program if you weren ’t zero tolerant but they would have to change what Charleston had always done and look at things differently. Chair Bowden said he would expect there was some difference between positions. He thought insurance would require that some positions were completely drug-free and have zero tolerance. Ms. O ’Berry remarked there were different rules for Commercial Driver Licenses and safety sensitive positions that they would have to follow that as well. At this time Charleston was zero tolerant but they were actively looking to whether or not if this was something they could change and it would be a positive change for the City. Inaugural Local Government Advanced Supervisory Training This was done last quarter in September, 2025 . Committee on Human Resources February 19, 2026 Page 4 One of the big pushes of this team in HR was more training for supervisors, managers and employees. Seven have participated in partnership with the College of Charleston Riley Center . They have started their second group of 10 supervisors going through this program. Ms. O ’Berry said they thought it was an extremely valuable program and were excited to offer it. To her knowledge, this was the first time anything like this was done in the City for a few years. Benefit and Wellness – April Slinkard Ms. Slinkard thought this was the first time that benefits and wellness had been part of this presentation. Some of the things they had on here over time will evolve and will have more meaningful or really great metrics to show how they were supporting the employees through benefits and wellness. They felt benefits and wellness were primarily to care of the employee to make sure there is a good work/life balance, and make sure they felt supported in their job roles. The other part of that was to support retention and recruitment to make sure they were keeping people and finding the best qualified people because of the programs and benefits they offered. One of the things they have started looking at was mental and physical health items. They launched the Calm Health App this year. The app, which was free to employees, was designed to help mental health. They were going to start tracking registered users by using numbers but no data. It would be aggregate information but it would give them a picture of employee usage and how they were responding to mental health needs. The other piece they would be tracking would be MDLIVE app. It was a virtual tele health service through Cigna. It provided dermatology, primary care, urgent care and mental health services to employees. They have dropped the copay to $10 this year to encourage use of this so that employees felt they had a resource . They had health care when they needed it and it was a convenience. They hoped to encourage use because of those items. It was also good for the City if they could prevent people from utilizing services like ER or urgent care visits when it wasn ’t necessary. They were hoping to get them another resource they could use to get help and they could help support them. There was a nother feature they were proud of because one of the challenges that they had was that technology for some of the employees was less used than by other members of their teams. Some people really love technology and some don ’t. They were trying to make sure they were providing resources, education, communication and help so that people could utilize technology, learn about it and see what was out there. The Cigna app and Cigna coverage had a great deal of resources for the employees. They wanted to make sure they gave the employees the tools to access that and understand what was available to them. They felt the important part of their benefit package was to know all of the different things they had access to. The number in particular they look at is the My Cigna Registration Number. This was what percentage of the employees have registered on the My Cigna App. They were two years of service at 89% . Cigna noted frequently that was a very high number. Typically people were at 75% with much longer years of service. In reference to MD live registrations by quarter, this was something they were going to track because they wanted to see what the amount of usage was if people were utilizing this to assure they knew they had access to this. Currently staff was seeing a jump. They began communicating and marketing this at the end of last year in a more intentional manner. They did see the registrations go up from 20 to 59 in that one quarter. They felt that with communication and education they could encourage people to utilize the service. They felt it was a good alternative for people , especially traffic wise, getting places, not having to take full days off to get to a primary care or urgent care appointment. They felt it was a good fit for some of the conditions that maybe they had with their team members in their area. So they were going to track it. Efficiency, Effectiveness and Operations – Jennifer Strickland Committee on Human Resources February 19, 2026 Page 5 Ms. Strickland said first they were going to focus more on the system that they started in September, 2024 and went live with Workday. In the system there was something called PEX (People Experience) . It was a place where employees could use to open a ticket in regards to anything they had an issue they had with the system or how to do something. If they couldn ’t find it in any of the knowledge based articles in the system, they could open this ticket. It went to her team , a team in finance and payroll, and a team in IT. This was an all encompassing number. It wasn ’t necessarily just HR, but in Q4 they had a total of 67 tickets within Workday. Usually those tickets in PEX were going to be more like Tier 1, very lower level tier ed issues in the system. Something that anyone who helped build the system could go in and help a user. They have CVS, a vendor they have contracted in connection with Workday. They were consultants and experts in the system very focused on specific areas. It might be differen t components like in HR, payroll or finance . They have that ticketing system for more of reconfiguration s of the system. So if a bigger issue was going to need support outside of their skillset and team, they would open up a ticket and correlate with them or collaborate with them. In Q4, they did a total of 286 hours. That was the citywide total , not just HR. She felt that was something they wanted to start looking at. Going back to the PEX tickets and breaking that down a little bit, the 2025 ticket volume by each quarter showed that three months in and they had just gone live. Q1 had a total of 223 and it went down to 165 in Q2. In Q4 they had a total of 67 tickets. That was what one would expect in a system with tickets. It would be high in the beginning and one would see that slow decline throughout the year. Under Quarter Four Tickets by Type, Ms. Strickland said the totals they brought in were citywide. It gave a breakdown of what areas the majority of the tickets were coming in for PEX. Time entry and payroll had about 24 tickets. Benefits, General, Recruitment, some of the leave, some of the s ecurity, HR confidential and Configuration changes were all going to be HR related. Quarter Four CVS Tickets Hours was a breakdown of the total given on the previous slide. The total was 286 hours but that was citywide that they used. HCM, which was really HR, used 163 hours. Ms. Strickland noted that seemed extreme compared to what everyone else was doing, but they did do a lot of changes in the system in regards to compensation study. They were starting to build performance management in the system , the d ifferent components and kind of getting in that stabilization mode. Quarter 4 Project Highlights Ms. O ’Berry said she was going to do a quick recap of what they did in quarter 4 last year. They completed open enrollment with 95% participation in Workday on the benefit side. She noted that was amazing because many of the employees were going through Workday to complete their open enrollment. They also had record attendance at the health fair and record biometric screenings. They were going to continue to try to get people into biometric screenings so that they know their numbers. If you knew you r biometric numbers , you knew where to work to stay healthier. The first advanced supervisor class graduated. They also started the executive leadership training program once a quarter with the executive leadership team. They finalized the Job Analysis Questionnaire (JAQ), which was part of the citywide complete revamp of the job descriptions. Active Projects Under active projects, Ms. O ’Berry said 1) 3% of the COLA has been paid out in this quarter, 2) they were developing the new performance review process for this year, which would be the city ’s firs performance review process and 3) they just finished finalizing the data entry for the new market -based grades and moving employees to the minimum new grades. If one looked at the comp study that had been going on for about a year and a half, there were two pieces of it. The first was get the job descriptions right. They were about 95% done with that to include input on every job description for each employee, their supervisor and executive team. The second piece was the comp study phase one – moving employees into deciding what their new grades were, getting those grades loaded into the system, moving those employees into those grades Committee on Human Resources February 19, 2026 Page 6 and making sure if they were below the minimum of the new grade that they moved up to the minimum of that new grade. This was a major lift for the HR department over the past three months and those were completed. Future Projects Ms. O ’Berry said what everyone could expect to see next quarter was the finalizing of the job descriptions with the vendor. That should be wrapped soon. They had 300 supervisors to put through performance management training before they actually start doing their citywide first performance reviews. It was a day long training for the supervisors in March and April. They were actively working on disseminating the city ’s new mission, vision and values in all kind of unique different ways , sharing that and getting some focus on what it is the executive team developed there. They were implementing the benefits and wellness strategic plan. Everyone will start seeing more benefits and wellness change s. It was about how to make the employees healthier and save the City money on the benefits plan at the same time. Another big focus was the optimization of Workday. They spent the past year and a half in a stabilization mode. Now that it was more stabilized the numbers were going down , how do they optimize the software the City bought? Councilmember Brady said he ran into a City of Charleston and he asked about the health plan. He tried to direct the officer but he had a question about how one went about using the health plan to use medicines like Zepbound and Marjaro to lose weight. The City used to do it but it has now become more complicated. He wanted to be able to give the officer and other people in the City who live in his district the property process for that? Ms. O ’Berry said if they needed help they could contact Ms. Slinkard about different options. The City no long covered GLP1 ’s for weight loss. It was still covered diabetes but not weight loss. They had other programs put in place that weren ’t GLP-1 related. She didn ’t know who were on those calls last year when they made that tough decision to make that change. The sheer cost of those medicines was over a million dollars for non-diabetic employees and they had to make a tough call last year. But they did have programs in place where if they were on that medicine, they could put them on program Ms. Slinkard set up to help them continue to lose and manage their weight. Chair Bowden said that was the best report he had seen not only to get a sense of what had been happening but also what was to come. He appreciated everyone ’s work. Councilmember Brady asked the HR team did they completely eliminate even if there were contributing factors that would require the GLP-1s so they weren ’t paying for it at all. He wanted to tell this police officer. Ms. O ’Berry said if they were diabetic, it was covered. If they weren ’t, it wasn ’t covered. However, they had options to help them and there were many new things on the market they were watching very closely . They were actively engaged in trying to find new ways. She suggested they contact Ms. Slinkard. she helped many people who were taking GLP-1 to find options to continue their weight loss journey. Chair Bowden said he was excited for where this department was going. He was looking forward to seeing progress on some of the things they spoke about. The one thing he would love to know more about. This might be something to discuss with they Mayor and might have to go before City Council, but the big thing that was on employees ’ mind in America was Artificial Intelligence (AI). It had become a big part of his workday causing him the same anxiety that was causing everyone else. Maybe in the future they could get an update on where the City was on AI usage and adaptation . He thought that would be helpful for them looking at it from a much higher level than they were. Ms. O ’Berry said she heard what he was saying about AI. She felt that would be an excellent opportunity for HR to partner with IT. Now that they had an AI policy and try to get some training to help people to see Committee on Human Resources February 19, 2026 Page 7 what good and bad it could do , as well as while it could a lot of good, it could also do a lot of bad. She felt they could definitely work that into their training group. Councilmember Skardon asked if at their next meeting would it be possible to get an overview of the city ’s paid family leave policies and any related child care support the City ’s offered or had considered offering in the past. And i f there had been any comparison done to other municipalities, not only local ly of other best-in-class cities across the country. Benefits was an important part of that recruitment and retention of staff. Ms. O ’Berry said for the past six months they have been laying out and updating “Project Stork ”. They have been updating their policy to make things cleaner, easier to understand. They had a booklet they were almost ready to publish. It was going through QC right now. They should be done within the next wo to three weeks to publication. It spoke through the leave process, specifically the parental leave policy and how it reacted with regular leave, disability and FMLA. Councilmember Gregg said they spoke last year about how they might be able to reduce health care costs and some thoughts on direct contracting. He continued to have issues with Cigna and MUSC. Going for primary care visit every year was becoming more and more challenging that things that were supposed to be covered weren ’t being covered because MUSC seemed to be more interested in billing patients and employees as much as humanly possible rather than serving the patient. He asked if they progressed those discussions any further and was that something they could start talking about. Ms. O ’Berry said they have been meeting with their broker and a couple vendors. They ’ve have been through 10 vendor demos in the past month. They also had budget included in on this process. They ’ve been in a lot of meetings with them to look at what they could actually do this year , what they could afford to do, and what they were able to move forward with. They moved forward with a list of about 50 items , which sh e had shared at least 25 of those with the Committee in that letter from awhile ago. They had a letter of about 40 items. They ’ve narrowed it down to their top 12. They had a list of about 10 things they have already done and the next list of 12 things they thought they could accomplish this year. That was when they talked about moving forward with the benefits and wellness strategy on the last slide. It was taking that wish list of all the things they wanted to do and boil it down to what they could actually accomplish this year and how were they going to see some changes. Ms. O ’Berry said one of the biggest cost drivers was MSK, muscular skeletal such as back problems. Ther was a lot of physical therapy and surgery in that. Many people would argue a lot of unnecessary surgery in that . Things that PT could solve if they could get people to PT, but you couldn ’t often get people to PT. Committee on Human Resources February 19, 2026 Page 8 d. Benefits and Wellness Update e. Compensation & HRIS Update f. Q4 Finalized HR Projects g. Current HR Projects h. Upcoming HR Projects 5. Adjournment Cc: Councilmember Stephen Bowden, Chair

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.