RecordWell Data

BAR-S Meeting Results

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Feb 12, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL MEETING RESULTS FEBRUARY 12, 2026 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Lindsay Van Slambrook, Fillmore Wilson, William Bill Turner, Becky Fenno, Darryl Cobb STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: Frankie Pinto, Travis Galli A. Minutes 1. Review of Minutes from the January 22, 2026 Meeting DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approval with Van Slambrook edits MADE BY: Van Slambrook SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 B. Applications 1. 178 Sans Souci Street BAR2026-002356 | TMS# 463-07-02-056 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1935 | Historic Materials Demolition District (OPT-IN REVIEW) Requesting OPT-IN REVIEW for demolition of existing exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way AND conceptual approval for proposed addition. Owner: 128 Cannon St LLC Applicant: AJ Architects Site visit on 02/12/2026 at 8:30 a.m. DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approval of demolition and conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Proposed is subordinate to the existing structure and follows the standard staff conditions for approval. Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 12, 2026 Page 2 2. Applicant has met with staff to coordinate Opt-In review process and owner signed the Opt-In affidavit. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of demolition and conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents BOARD QUESTIONS: • Windows look picture framed on drawings, should have sill PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • What’s proposed is compatible with existing structure, doesn’t overshadow • Thumbnail siding on left siding, approved for removal on rear addition • Changes in request is mostly about eaves being removed 2. 61 Maple Street BAR2025-002336 | TMS# 463-12-01-098 | North Central | Council District 4 Category 4 (Group 1) | c. 1925 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting after-the-fact approval for partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way. Owner: Parker Stiles / Banington Home Buyers Applicant: Rob Johnson Construction DECISION: DEFERRED MOTION: Deferral for more information MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. After the fact request for changing single front door into double doors. 2. Board has previously denied these requests when requested. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Submit permit to return to original configuration within 30 business days. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial of after-the-fact request with staff condition. BOARD QUESTIONS: • Have existing sills being modified, exterior trim. Staff to look into PUBLIC COMMENT: • PSC o Multiple features have been removed including: rafter tails, brackets • HCF o Not in support o Scope is unclear, additional information needed Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 12, 2026 Page 3 BOARD COMMENTS: • More has been changed than just the door. Rafter tails removed, window detail changed, brackets removed, side trim (window) doesn’t rest on sill • Need drawings showing changes 3. 7 Payne Court BAR2025-002325 | TMS# 460-08-04-032 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough Council District 4 | Category 4 | c. 1852 | Old City District Requesting conceptual approval for new addition. Owner: Cozy 7 Payne Court LLC Applicant: Cozy Studio DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board condition with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 Recused: Wilson BOARD CONDITIONS: • Height of hyphen be reduced by a minimum of 8” • Siding on addition should have narrower profile STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Previous staff comments have been addressed. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents BOARD QUESTIONS: • How far is addition setback, 2” at rear, 6” at front • Issues with flashing on proposed hyphen PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Improvement over previous proposal • In previous design the original small house got lost in the addition • Window composition has improved, shutters should be applied consistently or removed. (3 original shutters) • Balusters should be simple, small • Better than previous but still big addition to little building • Window sills, skirt board below should be removed • Mass and length on second floor is longer than original • Does mass of original house get lost • Doubling length of the building on second floor • Still not a big building even with addition • Narrow profile on addition would help Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 12, 2026 Page 4 • Taking one story shed straight up and making it the hyphen • Length and height of hyphen is what’s throwing it off • Question if hyphen could be lowered • Connection on second floor only detail concerned about • Would feel more comfortable if we knew it could come down 4. 130 Romney Street BAR2025-002361 | TMS#463-12-03-113 | North Central | Council District 4 Category 3 (Group 2) | c. 1935 | Historic Corridor District Requesting conceptual approval for second story rear addition, window replacement, and hardscape. Owner: Cannon Lynch Applicant: Cannon Lynch DECISION: DEFERRED MOTION: Deferral for restudy with Board and staff comments MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Drawing are confusing and missing detail. Materials are not shown, chimney is missing from elevations. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. All existing windows and doors should remain in place. 2. Addition should be subordinate to existing house, new roof should be lower than existing ridge and tucked under the eave of existing roof. 3. Per BAR policy statement for hardscaping: Metal fences are to be hot rolled steel or wrought iron with welded joints and concealed fasteners. Premanufactured aluminum fences are generally not acceptable for use in a historic district. 4. Drawings should be clearly drawn and labeled. Per submittal requirements, existing and proposed should be on the same page. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Deferral for restudy with Board and staff comments 1, 2 and 4 BOARD QUESTIONS: • none PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Cannot support without additional drawings and elevations o Not opposed, just want to understand the overall massing • PSC o Lack of drawings made difficult to evaluate o Should be subordinate in mass and differentiated Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 12, 2026 Page 5 BOARD COMMENTS: • Need additional drawings to meet submittal requirements • Should fenestration details • Need to differentiate addition from main house • Should relationship of structures, need to understand relationship of garden shed • Differentiate and subordinate 5. 15 Bedons Aly BAR2025-002347 | TMS# 458-0-90-3087 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | New Construction | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for rear addition. Owner: Elizabeth Simmons Applicant: Sebastian von Marshall Architect DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Structure approved by BAR-S on 4/14/2022. 2. Since this is new construction the new addition does not need to be stepped in to differentiate. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents BOARD QUESTIONS: • none PUBLIC COMMENT: • none BOARD COMMENTS: • in keeping with what’s already been established 6. 80 South Battery Street BAR2025-002348 | TMS# 457-11-02-037 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 1953 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for one-story addition and garage shed roof. Owner: Teresa J. Tarrant Trust Applicant: Sebastian von Marshall Architect Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 12, 2026 Page 6 DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual with Board conditions and preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Study Hyphenation of rear corner • Drop the roofline above the farthest most bathroom • Study some type of fenestration on south wall of addition STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Additions should step in from existing structure and telescope down toward the rear. Further portion of the addition has the tallest section of roof. 2. While not rated in the previous survey, this structure is now over 50 years old and would be considered historic. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Include fenestration on street elevation. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Deferral for restudy BOARD QUESTIONS: • none PUBLIC COMMENT: • PSC o Would not be highly visible o Lesson impact on historic structure, maintain corner • Guy Tarrant, owner o Lived in house 42 years o Aging in place BOARD COMMENTS: • The requirement of telescoping down is for a different type of house. The larger mass should be centered on the pool. Roof could be dropped on rearmost end • Not much of structure will be visible • Existing corner should be articulated • Some form of fenestration should be included on front façade • Would help to see garage in elevation with addition to understand relationship • Less concerned about fenestration due to distance from street, could be softened with landscaping • Clearly subordinate, don’t have issue with larger mass to the rear • Very possible to hyphenate the corner, just a framing conundrum • A window on front face would help the street presence, very visible from street, but not a deal breaker 7. 14 Greenhill Street BAR2025-002333 | TMS# 457-11-04-154 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 12, 2026 Page 7 Not Surveyed | c. 1991 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for new garage and exterior alterations to the central bay. Owner: Gregory R. Whitehead Applicant: Sebastian von Marshall DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff observations 2 & 3 and Board conditions and preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents MADE BY: Fenno SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Set garage doors be recessed, at least 2’ STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. While staff is not opposed to changing the garage from the rear to a side entrance, the garage doors should be set in from the façade like the existing ground floor windows, behind the arcade. 2. Garage doors should be in a in style with the existing structure. 3. Main floor porch roof, balustrade should remain. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Include full elevations for all sides and complete plans for all floors per submittal requirements. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial with staff observations and conditions BOARD QUESTIONS: • New pediment over door, in elevation looks like ends at central window PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Do not object as proposed BOARD COMMENTS: • Not opposed to garage doors, would be inclined not to change rest of structure. let garage doors fade • Think is driven by pool, appreciate removal of hardscape • House built in 1990s • Arches create nice little vista • Board has approved multiple side load garages, but have required to be set in. needs some type of reveal • Landscaping plan is well done 8. 106 Murray Boulevard BAR2025-002323 | TMS# 457-11-01-015 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 2001 | Old & Historic District Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 12, 2026 Page 8 Requesting conceptual approval for full window and door replacement, addition, dormer, and other exterior alterations. Owner: Claire Batten / Jim McGivern Applicant: Julie O’Connor – American Vernacular, Inc DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board conditions and preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents MADE BY: Fenno SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Restudy of doors at upper level, west elevation, to match rest of house • Restudy scale of overhang • Restudy or eliminate overhangs on east elevation STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. While staff typically does not support wholesale replacement of windows, we are not opposed to the change in fenestration due to the age of the structure. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents BOARD QUESTIONS: • none PUBLIC COMMENT: • none BOARD COMMENTS: • Only things that give pause, doors on upper elevation lite pattern don’t match others, overhang is awkward • If top doors were brought in overhang could be reduced • Overhangs over garage doors seem awkward • Don’t think overhangs are needed on east elevation 9. 74 Drake Street BAR2026-002366 | TMS# 459-06-04-034 | East Side | Council District 4 Category 4 | c. 1890 | Old City District Requesting conceptual approval for rear two-story addition, dormer, and window replacement. Owner: Justin Syms Applicant: Rockwell Construction DECISION: DEFERRED MOTION: Deferral with Board and staff discussion MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 12, 2026 Page 9 BOARD CONDITIONS: • See discussion STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. If there is any evidence of a window in the front gable, staff can support this change. 2. Addition should be subordinate to existing house, step in from existing structure and telescope down toward the rear. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. New roof should be lower than existing ridge and tucked under the eave of existing roof. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with staff conditions and preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents BOARD QUESTIONS: • The bay on the west elevation, unknown if original, believe is addition PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Appreciate the height will be lowered, think can be lowered further to differentiate • PSC o Proposed addition should be tucked in on both sides, retain corner boards, brought down more in height, and differentiated in material • Josh Gooden o Changing pattern of wood, nice feature. Not called out as being changed BOARD COMMENTS: • Needs more differentiation, difficult to tell apart • Walls need to step in to define corners • Front window can be added if evidence • Pattern of wood should be retained, unique • Dormer is a little awkward, maybe another gable instead • North elevation, rear of addition, should be separation of windows and doors • Appreciate cleanup of facade 10. 38 State Street BAR2025-002330 | TMS# 458-09-01-111 | French Quarter | Council District 8 Category 2 | c. 1815 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval to enclose rear portion of piazza and changes and additions to gates. Owner: Chris Jones Applicant: Brian Crouch Architect DECISION: Split Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 12, 2026 Page 10 MOTION: Denial of porch infill, deferral of modification of gates and piers for more information MADE BY: Wilson SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • See motion STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Since this is a category 2 in the architecture inventory, staff can only approve repairs in kind. 2. Staff is concerned about the age of the existing driveway gate, it is shown in provided 1950s photo. 3. Follows BAR policy statement for piazza enclosures: The location of the piazza enclosure shall be to the rear of the piazza, be minimal in size, and not alter the conceptual relationship between the house and the piazza. 4. Due to the location of a parking lot behind the structure, the proposed piazza enclosure will be visible from East Bay Street. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. Existing gate should remain intact. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with staff conditions and preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents BOARD QUESTIONS: • History of the gates, believe to be Philip Simons • Existing width of opening (gates), 8’ to piers • Added panels to gates would be wrought iron, tacked on • Date of piers on either side of gates, at least 1941 PUBLIC COMMENT: • PSC o Not supportive of infill, category 2 building o Intact piazza should be preserved • HCF o Policy recommends preserving piazzas BOARD COMMENTS: • Not in support of piazza infill, is a category 2 house • Porch configuration is typical of grand historic houses • Taking away from original architecture is bad decision • Understand issue with gates, needs to be more research done to identify maker, if Philips Simons need to be very careful 11. 244 Ashley Avenue BAR2026-002370 | TMS# 460-11-02-036 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough Council District 6 | Not Surveyed | c. 1930 | Old City District Requesting conceptual approval for front addition. Owner: Harrison Malpass Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 12, 2026 Page 11 Applicant: Coastal Creek Design – Joel Adrian DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board comment and preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents MADE BY: Fenno SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 Recused: Wilson BOARD CONDITIONS: • Consider eliminating front railing STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Addition has been reduced per previous Board discussion, new proposal is less visible from public ROW. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Did as was asked, improvement • Much more sensitive • Length of deck, maybe extend to porch and remove handrail 12. 1227 King Street BAR2026-002365 | TMS#463-08-02-001 | East Central | Council District 4 Not Surveyed | c. 1985 | Historic Corridor District Requesting conceptual approval for exterior renovations to existing structure including signage. Owner: Sunhouse Petroleum Applicant: Tungsten Corporation, James Rice DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board conditions and preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents MADE BY: Fenno SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Color scheme of gas canopies must be compatible with that of building, can work with staff STAFF OBSERVATIONS: Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 12, 2026 Page 12 1. Would be easier to review if layout followed the submittal requirements and had the previous submittal and proposed on same page. 2. Applicant has met with staff, and staff believe the Board motion has been addressed. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents BOARD QUESTIONS: • Other than changing the panel system, what has been changed. Same colors / pattern PUBLIC COMMENT: • none BOARD COMMENTS: • Previously had suggestion that would look better if roof bump out was removed, part of truss system • 41 year old Exxon station, unique , entering historic district • Is there material/cultural authenticity? Adaptive reuse of existing building, no change in use • A conundrum • Can’t do anything about color, corporate branding • No change to canopies proposed (currently red) • Canopies should be compatible in color, can work with staff 13. 52 Hasell Street BAR2026-002354 | TMS# 458-05-01-048 | Ansonborough | Council District 8 Category 2 | c. 1843 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for a pool. Owner: Stephen Hopkins Applicant: Land Studio DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Since this is a category 2 in the architecture inventory, staff can only approve repairs in kind. 2. Any equipment should be screened from view. BOARD QUESTIONS: Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 12, 2026 Page 13 • No grade change • No decking • Equipment not visible PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Oppose pools that are visible from public ROW BOARD COMMENTS: • Minimally visible • Don’t have issue unless equipment is visible 14. 52 ½ Hasell Street BAR2026-002360 | TMS# 458-05-01-048 | Ansonborough | Council District 8 Category 2 | c. 1843 | Old & Historic District Requesting appeal of staff denial to paint unpainted masonry. Owner: Stephen L. Hopkins Applicant: Louie Hopkins DECISION: DENIED MOTION: Uphold staff decision MADE BY: Wilson SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 1 Opposed: Van Slambrook BOARD CONDITIONS: • Staff has authority to approve an appropriate, clear, breathable barrier for historic masonry STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. The Secretary of the Interior Standards recommends against painting masonry that has historically been unpainted or uncoated. 2. The requested area is part of a category 2 property. BOARD QUESTIONS: • Paint to match color on main house, with Kime • 1990s brick PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Opposed to painting unpainted masonry BOARD COMMENTS: • Believe building was damaged in Hugo, wouldn’t be surprised if was repaired with new brick. Has new windows. Structure is old. Building itself has never been painted • Desire to paint to match house. Portions of main house painted prior to Hugo • Would support a Kime breathable coating/moisture barrier. Wouldn’t support a color • Was originally the kitchen building Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | February 12, 2026 Page 14 • Cultural authenticity, slippery slope • Painting of brick on main house was a mistake, why continue a mistake • Not sure how much brick is old/salvaged • 15. 331 King Street BAR2025-002350 | TMS# 457-04-02-041 | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1975 | Old & Historic District Requesting final approval to paint unpainted masonry. Owner: 331 King LLC Applicant: CB Elrod Co LLC WITHDRAWN BY STAFF

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.