RecordWell Data

BAR-L Meeting Results

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Feb 11, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE MEETING RE SULTS FEBRUARY 11, 2026 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Trey Watkins, Seaton Brown, James Meadors, Luda Sobchuk, Joel Trantham STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: B.D. Wortham-Galvin, Lawrence Courtney, Brad Thomas A. MINUTES 1. Review of Minutes from January 14, 2026 Meeting DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approval of Minutes MADE BY: Meadors SECOND: Brown VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 B. APPLICATIONS 1. 320 Huger Street BAR2026-002377 | TMS #4631601001 | North Central | Council District 4 New Construction | Height District 2.5 | Historic Corridor District Requesting Approval of a mockup panel. Owner: City of Charleston Applicant: SJ Hamill Construction NOTE: The Board will convene at this address on Tuesday, February 10, 2026, at 8:30 a.m. for a site visit. DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions MADE BY: Meadors SECOND: Trantham VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 Sobchuk recused. STAFF COMMENTS: • This project previously received Final Review by the Board on 14 September 2022 (previously addressed as 900 King Street) and Final Review by Staff of For Permit Drawings on 9 April 2024. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | February 11, 2026 Page 2 • The drawing set accompanying this application contains numerous notes in red, indicating which things were not constructed the way in which they will be on the actual structure, in order to provide information on how they will be achieved differently. • Board discussion regarding whether or not the color should match Enston Homes was opened ended. Final Review Applicant discussed color with Staff and an approach for the brick to be monochrome with the Corten was decided in Fall 2025. The Final Review Applicant picked out the brick at US brick with Mockup Applicant. Mockup Applicant was unable to obtain solid Madrid brick from US Brick for mockup and the modular brick as shown in drawings is no longer available, but queen is. Staff are comfortable with the switch from modular to queen. The brick is perhaps redder than a true monochrome match. It is required that any exposed brick will be solid. • Applicant shows 2 versions of the perimeter fencing as 10 gauge is only available in the unpainted galvanized version; 9-gauge is available in the black vinyl coated wire. The original specification was for 10 -gauge black vinyl coated wire. Staff prefer th e black perimeter fencing and find the 9-gauge acceptable. • The exposed concrete is shown as a brushed finish. While the Board posed the question of it having color, it was not conditioned or definitively stated at the Final Review by Board or as a comment by Staff in the Permit. • The Corten HSS members of the Ipe panel will not have holes for anchorage at the bottom (note on E1/second A100), rather there will be a continuous angle to span inside face of Corten HSS members. Staff require a field inspection of an early sample to confirm workmanship. • The non-shrink grout pads under the baseplates are not the correct slope due to the minimal edge distance at the mockup. It is required that the proper slope of grout pads be used in final construction. • Metal guardrail has a nice appearance. If the bolts at the base are exposed on the building, then a cleaner solution is preferred than what is shown (e.g. clipping, using acorn nuts, etc.). • The standing seam galvalume roof is a lighter grey than as shown in the render, but the intent by the Applicant was to match the pergola roof in the garden at Enston Homes (which Staff confirms that it does). No comments on roof color were made in Board Final Review. • While workmanship appears generally acceptable, it is difficult to tell what it might be like with some conditions not aligning with what is anticipated on the structure. Staff require field inspections early in construction to confirm the conditions not a vailable on the mockup. • It is understood that the stair shown on sheet E14 is only for reference and were never intended to be shown on the mockup. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Exposed brick is required to be solid. 2. Use of angle to span inside face of Corten HSS members is required. 3. Proper slope of grout pads is required. 4. Restudy of finished condition on bolts at base of guardrail is required if they are visible to the public right of way when installed. 5. Early field inspections by Staff to confirm workmanship on elements not shown on mockup. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | February 11, 2026 Page 3 BOARD COMMENTS: • Agree with Staffs comments and conditions Further Board discussion can be found at the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. 2. 25 Courtenay Drive (30 Courtenay Drive, 67 President Street, 68 President Street) BAR2026-002363 | TMS #4601400025, 460150100, 4601501017, 4601501043 Medical Complex | Council District 6 | New Construction | Height District 85/200, 85/125 Old City District/Peninsula Medical University District Overlay Zone Requesting Conceptual Approval of a sky bridge spanning four (4) MUSC buildings. Owner: Medical University of South Carolina (MUSC) Applicant: Jay White (Liollio Architecture) DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions MADE BY: Sobchuk SECOND: Trantham VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • This application is part of the newly formed Peninsula Medical University District, MD Overlay Zone (Sec. 54-229.10.) that was ratified on 14 October 2025. “The Board of Architectural Review (BAR). Any new structure proposed within the MD Overlay Zone which is visible from a public right-of-way shall not b e issued a building permit until after an application for a permit has been submitted to and approved by the Board of Architectural Review. ( Sec. 54 -229.10.h).” This project as proposed meets zoning requirements that exist in the overlay. • As demonstrated in the submittal, the elevated walkway is a response to real flooding issues that occur on a regular basis in this area. • The pedestrian connector primarily runs down Doughty Street, finishing on President and connecting to 4 buildings directly: the Ashley River Tower, the Thurmand/Gazes Research Building, the Psych. Institute, and the Bioengineering Building. These buildings were built at distinct times and with assorted architectural expressions and differing exterior and interior (floor) heights. • Given the varied context, Staff support the proposal having a consistent height, mass and architectural expression so that this addition to the built environment has its own authentic response as a contemporary piece of infrastructure. • Staff understand that the height, scale, and mass are predicated on pragmatic and utilitarian necessities related to: connecting to buildings with disparate floor heights, accommodating mechanical infrastructure across the site and within the connector, concrete structure depth, as well as clearance over the public right of way. To that end, staff support the height, scale, and mass of the project. • Staff appreciate how the structure becomes a porch or loggia as it engages buildings in varying conditions. Staff also support the material palette in general as well as the rhythmic approach to the placement of the aluminum louvers providing both visual interest and sun shading over the curtain wall system. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Bring sample materials to the Preliminary Review. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | February 11, 2026 Page 4 STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions BOARD COMMENTS: • Height, scale and mass is no problem. It’s right on. The multiple use of the structure for pedestrians and mechanicals and infrastructure is good planning. • The tie to the Ashley River tower is exceptional. As you move away from the Ashley River tower, is there an opportunity to use materials or details to tie the structure into each of the buildings it connects to? The general Architectural direction is understood, but is there a way to break it up as it connects to each building? • The new ordinance (MUSC District overlay) allows for a structure like this to be built and this is a fine piece of contemporary architecture that is excellently executed at the Ashley River tower but also serves as a beautiful thru line for the rest of campus and will serve as the basis for future architecture on the campus. It stands on its own architecturally. It ties in well and is visually interesting for the pedestrian. It engages the pedestrian experience on the Greenway. When it comes to height, scale and mass it fits in with a campus that has significant height and massing. Additionally the height off the ground is a matter of resiliency in a district that is constantly flooding. • It is an ambitious stand alone project. Something like this you could see in other parts of the world. It is well executed with a wonderful rhythm and materials. This is strictly pedestrian and you have nodes where you come to a building, can they be projected and used for something else to enhance the pedestrian experience and engage the walk? • This connector is an architectural element. It’s also a utilitarian element and it is an urban design feature. Being able to integrate all three of those into an element that has its own language and refined level of detail is quite successful. • It is tying together a series of buildings that have their own material and architectural expression and there is an ability to see the architecture through the window space of the connectors. Plugging into the buildings with its own elements and allow the building languages to appear through it (through the “window”) is a successful approach. What you have designed is better than your precedent images. • What is the engagement at the buildings? The details of those engagements is what will define the critical success of this project as it ties into all these different structures. The connection between this project and the existing buildings is a critical design feature as it moves forward. • The wood panels make sense underneath the structure when it’s 18 feet tall but concerned about the use around the windows. When you are standing at that window looking out that will be right in the immediate view of the users. Want to make sure those details get developed. • Where the towers land are a different language than the piers. As this project develops and these exterior integration strategies are brought together, are those an element that need to be simplified to match some of the other languages that are there so they can be as beautiful as the connector is. • Fully on board with height, scale, mass and architectural direction of what is being presented here. • Connection to the existing buildings needs to be part of detailed study and shouldn’t necessarily mimic anything on the buildings particularly. Further Board discussion can be found at the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | February 11, 2026 Page 5 3. 115 Calhoun Street BAR2026-002372 | TMS #4580101038 | Downtown | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1830s | Height District 4 | Old and Historic District Requesting Conceptual Approval to enclose a second-story piazza. Owner: David Howard Applicant: Clark Batchelder (Goff D’Antonio Associates) WITHDRAWN BY APPLICANT 4. 560 King Street BAR2026-002385 | TMS #4600804052 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough Council District 4 | Not Rated | c. 2015 | Height Districts 4, 8 | Old and Historic District Requesting Approval for an illuminated, 614 sq ft facade sign. Owner: HOSP CHASC HD, LLC Applicant: Barry Simon DECISION: DENIED MOTION: Denial of façade sign as proposed with Board and Staff Comments MADE BY: Brown SECOND: Trantham VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • The following Zoning Ordinance clauses and BAR policy statements are relevant to this application. o Art. 4, Part 3, Sec. 54-415(b. Façade Signs) ▪ Sign faces shall not occupy more than ten (10) percent per façade of the building. o BAR Signage Policy Statement (King Street) ▪ 1. Each sign shall be evaluated on a case -by-case basis. Generally, a façade sign shall be appropriately proportioned to the storefront, and its design shall be compatible with the architectural style of the façade. ▪ 3a. External or internal illumination generally will not be permitted. Exceptions may be made on a case-by-case basis. • There is an existing freestanding sign at the entry drive on King Street that will be refaced with the current tenant’s branding. This sign is not a part of BAR's purview, as it is in the public right-of-way (ROW), which is under the Design Review Committee (DRC). • Staff support the overall graphic design of the sign, as the colors and typography are professional, lack extraneous information, and are compatible with the building’s architecture. However, Staff do not find the sign’s scale, method of illumination, or t he lack of clarity regarding its brightness to be approvable. • As proposed, the façade sign is over 600 sqft. Although this technically complies with the maximum size allowance permitted by the Zoning Ordinance, the BAR retains discretion to reduce the sign if it is determined to be inappropriate in scale/design related to the building and its immediate surroundings. • The building is located at the corner of King and Spring Streets and varies in height. It begins at three stories along King Street (consistent with the adjacent building), then steps up to six stories as it travels east along Spring Street, and ultimately reaches ten stories. The building is L -shaped and includes an interior motor court, with its driveway located on King Street just south of Spring Street. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | February 11, 2026 Page 6 • Staff viewed the building at various points on King Street. Based on Staff’s observations, the proposed location of the facade sign, located on the ten -story portion of the building, would only be visible when looking down the entry driveway. This is due to the building’s setback from King Street to accommodate the motor court, as well as the presence of existing two- to three-story buildings along King Street. • Because of these two factors, the full size/scale of the building is screened and is not visible from pedestrian or vehicular viewpoints, and as a result, the façade used to calculate the sign area appears significantly smaller relative to the proposed siz e of the facade sign. • With respect to illumination, the applicant proposes individual illuminated channel letters. Staff recommend an alternative illumination method, such as halo-lit letters, which would result in a less visually prominent sign, particularly at this scale. Staff also request clarification on the proposed Kelvin temperature and lumen levels, which were not provided. • While the sign must remain legible, Staff find that both the overall size and the illumination method of the sign should be reduced and refined to better relate to the visible portions of the façade and to be more compatible within the context of King Street. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. If the overall design of the sign is approvable by the Board, but the size and illumination are not, Staff requests that the Board provide a general range on sign size (e.g., one - third of the current size, limited to three stories in height, etc.) and lighting specifications that they feel would be acceptable with final details and review to Staff. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial of the façade sign as proposed. BOARD COMMENTS: • We don’t have anything like the size of this sign in the City, and we shouldn’t have anything this size in the City. Regardless of the Ordinance percentage of façade allowance, the size of this sign does not make sense. The size is not appropriate. • The size is a concern. We must take the overall context of the City into consideration. It needs to be smaller. • Agree with staff comments regarding illumination. It needs to be halo lit. And we need to know what those lumens are and how bright it would be to approve it. It can be done appropriately, but also not lighting everything up through the night. Further Board discussion can be found at the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel.

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.