BAR-S Public Comment
City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jan 22, 2026 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Charleston
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
PUBLIC COMMENT
JANUARY 22, 2026
A meeting of the Board of Architectural Review – Small (BAR-S) will be held on Thursday,
January 22, 2026 at 4:30 p.m. in the Public Meeting Room, First Floor, 2 George Street.
The following written comments will be provided to the board members 24 hours in advance of
the meeting. The comments will also be acknowledged into the record and summarized. The public
is encouraged to attend the meeting in person to speak in order for comments to be fully heard.
Application information is available at www.charleston-sc.gov/bar. Please check the website on
the meeting date to view any withdrawn or deferred agenda items.
For additional information, please contact:
Department of Planning & Preservation | 843-724-3781
B. APPLICATIONS
1. 8 Magnolia Avenue
BAR2026-002355 | TMS# 463-08-03-031 | North Central | Council District 4
Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1940 | Historic Materials Demolition District (OPT-IN REVIEW)
Requesting OPT-IN REVIEW for demolition of existing exterior elements visible from the
public right-of-way AND conceptual approval for proposed addition.
Owner: Joel Caldwell & Hailey Wist
Applicant: Schuyler Clogston
Site visit on 01/22/2026 at 8:30 a.m.
No Comments Submitted
2. 9 Magnolia Avenue
BAR2025-002312 | TMS# 463-08-03-026 | North Central | Council District 4
Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1935 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting approval of partial demolition from exterior elements visible from the public
right-of-way.
Owner: 9 Magnolia LLC
Applicant: Matthew Sanford
Site visit on 01/22/2026 at 8:45 a.m.
No Comments Submitted
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Public Comment | January 22, 2026 Page 2
3. 90 Gordon Street
BAR2025-002316 | TMS# 463-10-04-087 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6
Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1950 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting approval for partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public
right-of-way.
Owner: Thuane Fielding
Applicant: Coastal Creek Design
Site visit on 01/22/2026 at 9:00 a.m.
1 Comment Submitted:
• Jarett Nicholson, Wagener Terrace Neighborhood Association
Submitted to Staff
I'm writing in regard to the BAR-S demo request at 90 Gordon Street. The owners,
Thuane and Mark fielding, along with their architect, Fredy at Coastal Creek Design,
reached out to me to present to the WTNA at our December meeting. Unfortunately
we don't meet in December and our next meeting in January is after their anticipated
date to present the BAR in early January. With that, they provided their plans to me
and I personally don't have a problem with them and think they are reasonable and
within the designs of the neighborhood. I cannot provide a letter of support from
WTNA but wanted to at least communicate that the owners attempted to meet with the
neighborhood association. Feel free to reach out with any questions or concerns. Jarett
Nicholson, WTNA President
4. 304 Ashley Avenue
BAR2025-002300 | TMS# 460-07-02-035 | Westside | Council District 6
Not Surveyed | c. 1930 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting approval for full demolition of existing structure.
Owner: Diana B. Reynolds, Jocelyn R. Young, & Kanton T. Reynolds
Applicant: Joceyln R. Young & Kanton T. Reynolds
Site visit on 01/22/2026 at 9:20 a.m.
19 Comments Submitted:
• 19 Comments in Opposition
Submitted to Innovate Site
See attached comments.
5. 232 Rutledge Avenue
BAR2025-002308 | TMS# 460-08-03-006 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough
Council District 6 | Category 4 | c. 1885 | Old City District
Requesting appeal of after-the-fact staff denial for fence.
Owner: Toby Fugate
Applicant: Maner Builders Supply
Site visit on 01/22/2026 at 9:50 a.m.
No Comments Submitted
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Public Comment | January 22, 2026 Page 3
6. 157 Tradd Street
BAR2025-002338 | TMS# 457-11-04-031 | Charlestowne | Council District 8
Category 4 | c. 1890 | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval exterior alterations including re-opening porch,
fenestration changes, and demolition of addition.
Owner: Michael Furlong and Eric Larson
Applicant: Sebastian von Marschall
Site visit on 1/22/2026 at 10:10 a.m.
No Comments Submitted
7. 122 Logan Street
BAR2025-002327 | TMS# 457-08-02-085 | Harleston Village | Council District 8
Category 3 | c. 1791 | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval for rear addition.
Owner: 122 Logan Street, LLC
Applicant: e e fava architects
Site visit on 1/22/2026 at 10:30 a.m.
2 Comments Submitted:
• Zoe Stephens, 39 Meeting Street, Charleston, SC 29401
Submitted to Innovate Site on Jan. 21, 2026 8:38 AM
I am writing to express my full support for the beautiful proposed restoration and
renovation of 122 Logan Street. The project represents a preservation-focused
adaptation of a historically important structure, committed to preserving what is
historically significant about the building, while allowing for changes made to the non-
historical elements for an appropriate and important civic use for Charleston Day
School (a 90 year old school in downtown Charleston).
• Jon Meredith, 8 Ford Court, Charleston, SC 29401
Submitted to Staff
I am writing to express my full support for the proposed plans for the sensitive
restoration and renovation of 122 Logan Street. The project represents a thoughtful
preservation effort and a welcome improvement to the surrounding streetscape.
Charleston and, specifically, the Harleston Village community, will benefit from
reviving an important city landmark into a vibrant building that is used daily by
children, adults and the surrounding neighborhood. Thank you for your consideration.
8. 8 Riverside Drive
BAR2025-002307 | TMS# 46307-02-001 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6
Not Surveyed (Group 2) | c. 1938 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting approval for partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public
right-of-way.
Owner: Richard Callari
Applicant: Schuyler Clogston
No Comments Submitted
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Public Comment | January 22, 2026 Page 4
9. 21 Council Street
BAR2025-002319 | TMS# 457-11-02-018 | Charlestowne | Council District 8
Not Surveyed | c. 1928 | Old & Historic District
Requesting conceptual approval for dormers and additions.
Owner: Ned & Lauren Dupont
Applicant: Tyler A Smyth Architects
No Comments Submitted
10. 220 King Street
BAR2025-002318 | TMS# 457-08-02-025 | Council District 8
Category 2 | c. 1835 | Old & Historic District
Requesting final approval for signage.
Owner: 220 King Street LLC
Applicant: Image 360 Charleston
1 Comment Submitted:
• Preservation Society of Charleston
Submitted to Staff
See attached letter.
11. 31 Cypress Street
BAR2025-002309 | TMS# 463-12-01-039 | North Central | Council District 4
Category 3 (Group 1) | c. 1935 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting appeal of staff denial to replace windows.
Owner: Sophronia Holmes
Applicant: Raquel Swanner
2 Comments Submitted:
• Preservation Society of Charleston
Submitted to Staff
See attached letter.
• Historic Charleston Foundation
Submitted to Staff
See attached letter.
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Public Comment | January 22, 2026 Page 5
12. 9 Harleston Place
BAR2025-002315 | TMS# 457-03-03-126 | Harleston Village | Council District 8
Not Surveyed | c. 1984 | Old & Historic District
Requesting appeal of staff denial to replace windows.
Owner: Dobbins Living Trust
Applicant: Raquel Swanner
2 Comments Submitted:
• Derek McKenzie, 2455 Paces Ferry Rd. C11 Atlanta, GA 33039
Submitted to Innovate Site on Jan. 21, 2026 9:19 AM
1. house was built in 1984. It is not a historic home 2. townhome has existing original
vinyl clad Andersen windows 3. Customer is replacing like for like 4. customer
obtained HOA approval to install the Andersen 400 series impact According to
customer, this window has been installed by other residents. She also stated that
several other units have installed all vinyl units 5. customer was unaware of needing
bar approval since her house was not considered historic
• Historic Charleston Foundation
Submitted to Staff
See attached letter.
13. 21 Marlow Drive
BAR2025-002302 | TMS# 463-07-04-044 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6
Not Surveyed | c. 1969 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting appeal of staff denial for window replacement on sides of house.
Owner: Kathleen Dolaman
Applicant: Stephen Nicholson
2 Comments Submitted:
• Preservation Society of Charleston
Submitted to Staff
See attached letter.
• Historic Charleston Foundation
Submitted to Staff
See attached letter.
Board of Architectural Review – Small
Public Comment | January 22, 2026 Page 6
14. 2 Hanover Street
BAR2025-002303 | TMS# 459-09-03-036 | East Side | Council District 4
Category 4 | c. 1852 | Old City District
Requesting appeal of staff decision for full siding and window replacement.
Owner: Tony Celia
Applicant: Rob Johnson Construction
2 Comments Submitted:
• Preservation Society of Charleston
Submitted to Staff
See attached letter.
• Historic Charleston Foundation
Submitted to Staff
See attached letter.
15. 3 Hanover Street
BAR2025-002306 | TMS# 459-09-03-041 | East Side | Council District 4
Category 4 | c. 1900 | Old City District
Requesting appeal of staff decision for full siding and window replacement.
Owner: Tony Celia
Applicant: Rob Johnson Construction
2 Comments Submitted:
• Preservation Society of Charleston
Submitted to Staff
See attached letter.
• Historic Charleston Foundation
Submitted to Staff
See attached letter.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
304 Ashley Avenue
BAR2025-002300 | TMS# 460-07-02-035 | Westside | Council District 6
Not Surveyed | c. 1930 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting approval for full demolition of existing structure.
Owner: Diana B. Reynolds, Jocelyn R. Young, & Kanton T. Reynolds
Applicant: Joceyln R. Young & Kanton T. Reynolds
Site visit on 01/22/2026 at 9:20 a.m.
304 Ashley Avenue
19 Comments in Opposition | Submitted to Innovate Site
First
Name Last Name Address Submitted Comment Date/Time
Submitted
Harrison Little 178
Fishburne
Street
As a neighbor to this property and homeowner in
Westside neighborhood, I oppose the demolition of 304
Ashley Ave. Freedman’s cottages are a significant part
of Charleston's architectural history and are becoming
less prevalent in our community as demolition seems to be
the preferred method, rather than restoration, when it
comes historic homes. I hope this home is restored while
keeping the original Freedman’s cottage structure,
character, and historic materials.
Jan 18
2026
2:02PM
Jennifer A Baker 356
Clayton Dr
Please please don't ruin Charleston with another ugly
high house. The small house is beautiful, historical, and
someone would treasure it easily. Please do not take our
past from us and the feeling of living someplace not
under attack by big builders.
Jan 18
2026
7:46PM
Meghan Lee 512 Sarah
Street,
Charleston,
SC 29407
Please do not demolish this historic 1912 building! There
are few of this style left and are an important reminder
of Charleston’s history and evolution.
Jan 18
2026
9:42PM
Lucy Orton 1019 five
oaks ct
Charleston
sc
Please don’t let this historic building be demolished. It’s
such a treasure to consider the smaller way of life that
the Charleston we know was built upon. We need these
landmarks!
Jan 18
2026
11:36AM
Brittany Little 178
Fishburne
Street
I am the owner and current occupant of 178 Fishburne
Street, which is the house located directly behind 304
Ashley Ave. I firstly want to flag that the applicants’
indicated 304 Ashley was built in 1930; however,
historical records seem to indicate it was actually built in
1912 - alongside another cottage next door at 302
Ashley, which was unfortunately given approval for
demolition a decade ago and was replaced by a new
construction single family home. As a member of this
neighborhood and community, I do not want to see
another cottage fall victim to this same trend of
demolition nor watch as historic (circa 1912 - not 1930)
materials are destroyed along with it. As direct
neighbors to this historic home, I would love to see it
renovated, given new life, and restored to its former
glory, but strongly believe that the owners should do so
within its existing structure and preserve all historic
materials. Thank you
Jan 18
2026
11:58AM
Elizabeth Marlowe Charleston Leave historic property intact. Say no to out of scale tear
downs.
Jan 19
2026
8:13AM
Samantha Morrison 8 Perry St I do not support the demolition request for this historic
building. The existing structure contributes to the
architectural and cultural fabric of the area and retains
significant value in its current form. Demolition is not the
only path forward, nor is it the most responsible one in
this case. The building can be thoughtfully improved,
Jan 19
2026
10:10AM
rehabilitated, and adapted while preserving its
character and historical integrity. Adaptive reuse and
sensitive updates would allow the property to meet
modern needs without erasing an important piece of our
shared history. Preservation and progress are not
mutually exclusive, and this building presents an
opportunity to demonstrate that balance. For these
reasons, I respectfully oppose the demolition request and
encourage the Board to consider alternatives that
prioritize preservation and improvement of the existing
structure rather than its removal and replacing, likely
with a structure that is too dense for the area.
Sarah Spangler 395
Sumter St
Dear Members of the Board of Architectural Review, My
name is Sarah Spangler, and I am the President of the
Westside Neighborhood Association. I am writing to
formally express concerns regarding the application
requesting full demolition of the structure at 304 Ashley
Avenue, currently scheduled for review. Historical
context and accuracy: Based on available records and
long-standing neighborhood history, the home at 304
Ashley Avenue was constructed in 1912, not in the 1930s
as stated in the application materials. The structure
represents a Freedman’s Cottage typology, the
historically recognized term in Charleston for this housing
form, rather than the “single house” classification cited in
the consultant report. Within the Westside
neighborhood, we are experiencing a significant and
accelerating loss of generational homes. Properties that
have remained in families for decades are increasingly
being sold. In many cases, these homes are either
demolished or substantially altered to maximize financial
return, resulting in larger, modern structures that are
incompatible with the historic scale, form, and character
of the neighborhood. This pattern represents a continued
erosion of both the architectural integrity and the living
cultural history of the Westside. Neighbors are deeply
concerned that this demolition would result in yet another
large, multi-story structure (likely due to the small lot
size), which would be inconsistent with the historic scale
and character of the area. These concerns are amplified
by the recent history of this very site: the sister
Freedman’s cottage adjacent to this home was
demolished in 2012 and replaced with a three-story
building. The cumulative loss of these historically and
culturally significant structures has already materially
altered the neighborhood's character, and residents
strongly oppose further erosion of what remains. While
the application states that the structure is not
architecturally similar to surrounding homes, this
assessment fails to acknowledge that many nearby
historic structures were demolished prior to the
establishment of modern preservation protections. This
property is believed to be one of the last remaining
Freedman’s cottages in this portion of the Upper
Jan 20
2026
7:45PM
Peninsula, historically one of approximately 106 such
homes located north of Septima P. Clark Parkway. The
application further misidentifies the property as being
located within the Elliottborough–Cannonborough
neighborhood. To my knowledge, this area has never
been historically recognized as Elliottborough–
Cannonborough. Rather, the land's history reflects a
progression from Pick Pocket Plantation during the
colonial era and more recently, to what is now known as
Westside neighborhood. This mischaracterization reflects
a broader unfamiliarity with the site’s historical context
and raises concerns regarding the applicant’s sensitivity
to and respect for the cultural history of this property.
Concerns regarding professional representation I am also
compelled to raise a serious concern regarding the
application’s professional representations. The architect
listed on the cover sheet, Patrick Orefice, contacted me,
after emailing the contacts on the cover sheet for
additional information, to clarify that while he was
approached regarding the project, he explicitly advised
the owner/client not to pursue full demolition of this
structure and does not support demolition of this
property. He claimed to have no relationship or
communication with the owner/client, nor had he
requested or supported demolition in any form. Given
this, I was deeply concerned to see Mr. Orefice listed as
the architect of record on an application that directly
contradicts his stated professional guidance. Consultant
Report Concerns Additionally, I have concerns regarding
the consultant report prepared by Dr. Aimy Steele,
particularly due to multiple factual inaccuracies, including
the construction date, neighborhood designation, and
typological classification. These errors materially affect
the conclusions presented and, in my view, undermine the
reliability of the report as submitted. Request to the
Board Given the historical significance of this structure,
the factual inconsistencies within the application
materials, and concerns regarding professional
attribution, I respectfully request that the Board deny this
demolition request.
Emily Storrow 40 Saint
Margaret
Street
I'm writing to oppose the full demolition of this ca. 1912
Freedman's Cottage. This specific structure is vital to the
cultural heritage of the Westside neighborhood, and its
historic form and character-defining features are still
intact. The application materials provided do note
provide sufficient structural evaluation to justify the
demolition request. The culture and character of
Charleston's upper peninsula matter. We can't let
historically significant homes be bulldozed to
accommodate generic, modern behemoths. The house
immediately next door is an unfortunate example of this
having already taken place, and to allow this demolition
sets an increasingly dangerous precedent that threatens
the soul of Westside.
Jan 21
2026
9:17AM
Concerned
neighbor
Concerned
neighbor
N/a Freedman cottages are historic structures often built by
freed slaves shortly after the Civil War. It is one of the
few styles of homes exclusively associated with African
Americans in the USA. These homes are very important to
Charleston and its rich architectural history. Please do
not allow this structure to be demolished. It can be
restored.
Jan 21
2026
9:19AM
Jake Griner 99
Westedge
St
As a Westside resident I oppose the demolition of this
freedmans cottage, an important part of this
neighborhood's history. There are far too many structures
in disrepair in this neighborhood to justify destruction of
another. I would far prefer to see this structure preserved
like 19 Ashton St was.
Jan 21
2026
9:24AM
Allison Owings 14
Elmwood
Street
Please stop removing these beautiful houses that make
Charleston unique. As a Charleston native, too much of
our city has been torn down, only to be replaced with
buildings you’ll see all over the country. These historic
houses are essential to honor our amazing city’s culture. I
vehemently oppose this demolition.
Jan 21
2026
9:25AM
Krista McColl 81 Maple
St.
Charleston,
SC 29403
I used to own a home a few houses down from 304
Ashley, and it’s homes like this cottage that give the block
its character and a feeling that only Charleston can claim
as its own. The Westside is defined by these historic,
structures, and demolishing this residence would diminish
the neighborhood’s cultural heritage, especially the
African American and Gullah/Geechee roots that have
shaped this community for generations. The application
materials do not provide a sufficient structural evaluation
to justify demolition. The building’s historic form and
character-defining features appear largely intact, and it
contributes to the diverse mix of architectural styles and
scales that make this streetscape feel authentic and
lived-in. I’m also deeply concerned about flooding
impacts. Past projects on this street have clearly made
flooding worse, and this section of Ashley floods more
severely than almost anywhere nearby. Any approval
should require a serious, site-specific stormwater and
drainage plan—not more demolition and redevelopment
that intensifies an already dangerous problem. I
respectfully urge the Board to deny this request and
require a thorough, independent structural assessment
and preservation-minded alternatives that keep this
contributing historic cottage, and the Westside’s fabric
standing.
Jan 21
2026
9:51AM
Anna Simmons 157 Line
Street
Freedman’s cottages have been under fire the past two
years, and there are plenty of examples demonstrating
that full demolition is completely unnecessary. In this
particular instance, there is a lack of supporting materials
that demonstrate a lack of structural integrity.
Regardless, the form and structure of the building are
unique to the Westside, as well as contributing diversity
to the streetscape’s architectural styles. Recently, there
have been many success stories of restoring freedman’s
cottages. The beautiful Denmark Vesey House at 56 Bull
Jan 21
2026
10:21AM
Street, or a more drastic example including flood
mitigation at 19 Ashton St. My own freedman cottage at
157 Line Street, was restored over 2025 while
maintaining all indoor and outdoor facades, and
remaining almost identical to its sister cottage at 151
Line Street. There are plenty of success stories indicating
restoration over demolition is possible, and without any
evidence of structural instability, this seems to be the
necessary path.
Shellie Horgan 2251 N
Marsh Dr.
Mount
Pleasant,
SC 29466
Please keep this home to be preserved and remembered
by generations to come. These homes are what makes
Charleston so unique and special to everyone.
Jan 21
2026
10:51AM
Celia Piemontese 321
Sumter
Street
Full demolition of this property would decrease charm
and history to the westside. Rebuilding a new building on
the lot will increase traffic, flood damage and noise
pollution. Propose rehabilitation to the property for
housing for locals in the community!!
Jan 21
2026
11:04AM
Dan Xeller 2534
Etiwan
Ave.
Charleston,
SC 29414
It is wholly and completely unnecesary to consider the
complete demoltion of 304 Ashley Ave. It has already
undergone a restoration in 2019. This area also floods
frequently and any new costruction will only exascerbate
this more. Please consider these comments and I AM NOT
IN FAVOR of demolition of this property. Enough is
enough. Thank you.
Jan 21
2026
11:30AM
John Doe Line As the current owner and resident of a Freedmans
cottage, it worries me to see the continual destruction of
these important pieces of history. Charleston’s heritage is
not defined by the single house, but rather by the vastly
more abundant Freedmans cottages. Continually
destroying these homes in favor of building modern
recreations of a history that did not exist does nothing
but harm to the true heritage of our historic city.
Preservation of not only the wealthy properties, but also
those that represent all residents of Charleston is
paramount to ensure our history remains true.
Jan 21
2026
11:43AM
Max Kuller 2nd Bend
Rd
Harleyville
SC
I am firmly against this application. 304 Ashley is a
charming centenarian of a bungalow! It is representative
of the historic lots that lend character and an airy beauty
to the Westside and Hampton Park area. It is also
extremely useful housing stock now, as it has for many
generations, presenting a lovely aspirational option for a
first time homebuyer or those limited to one floor for
mobility purposes. It is exactly these bungalows, and the
often long term residents within, that help create the
fabric of the city. Allowing them to be replaced with
anonymous density and profit seeking multiplexes
destroys the historic character and charm of the
neighborhoods and cities that has attracted the interest
that has led to the new development requests. I have
seen this board stick to their preservationist guns when it
comes to saving failing much younger backfacing eaves
in less conspicuous places, further up the neck. Surely it
Jan 21
2026
11:52AM
shouldn’t be much of a conversation about whether this
114 year old piece of history, on a main boulevard in a
booming neighborhood should be saved. But that is
exactly why I’m so worried- please do not let this
building and lot become victim to developers. Heavens
forbid it is one day to become another version of what
happened to it's twin, lost in 2013 at 302 Ashley. Please
do your job and preserve what’s left of our history.
Thank you.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
220 King Street
BAR2025-002318 | TMS# 457-08-02-025 | Council District 8
Category 2 | c. 1835 | Old & Historic District
Requesting final approval for signage.
Owner: 220 King Street LLC
Applicant: Image 360 Charleston
Position Statement Board of Architectural Review – Small January 22, 2026 220 King Street Dear Board Members, While we are not opposed to signage on this Category 2 building, the location of the proposed façade sign creates a condition atypical along King Street and impacts the historic masonry. We suggest utilizing other sign options, like window decals on the ground level, in accordance with the BAR’s policy statement on signage. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely,
Flannery Antinoro Preservation Specialist
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
31 Cypress Street
BAR2025-002309 | TMS# 463-12-01-039 | North Central | Council District 4
Category 3 (Group 1) | c. 1935 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting appeal of staff denial to replace windows.
Owner: Sophronia Holmes
Applicant: Raquel Swanner
Position Statement Board of Architectural Review – Small January 22, 2026 31 Cypress Street Dear Board Members, The PSC upholds City Staff’s decision to deny the removal of wood windows to install vinyl windows, which are not an appropriate replacement material in the Historic Materials Demolition Purview District. We encourage the applicant to work with Staff to choose from the appropriate replacement window options outlined in the Policy Statement for Historic Materials Demolition Purview. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely,
Flannery Antinoro Preservation Specialist
Post Office Box 1120 ∙ Charleston, SC 29402 ∙ (843) 723-1623 ∙ Fax (843) 577-2067 ∙ www.historiccharleston.org
To: Members of the Board of Architectural Review-Small
From: Kate Dutilly, Preservation Planner
Date: January 22, 2026
Re: 31 Cypress Street
Historic Charleston Foundation has reviewed the appeal of the staff decision regarding window
replacement at 31 Cypress Street. HCF does not believe that vinyl is an appropriate replacement
material and respectfully requests that the staff decision be upheld.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
9 Harleston Place
BAR2025-002315 | TMS# 457-03-03-126 | Harleston Village | Council District 8
Not Surveyed | c. 1984 | Old & Historic District
Requesting appeal of staff denial to replace windows.
Owner: Dobbins Living Trust
Applicant: Raquel Swanner
Post Office Box 1120 ∙ Charleston, SC 29402 ∙ (843) 723-1623 ∙ Fax (843) 577-2067 ∙ www.historiccharleston.org
T
o: Members of the Board of Architectural Review-Small
From: Kate Dutilly, Preservation Planner
Date: January 22, 2026
Re: 9 Harleston Place
Historic Charleston Foundation has reviewed the appeal of the staff decision regarding window
replacement at 9 Harleston Place. HCF does not believe that vinyl is an appropriate replacement
material and respectfully requests that the staff decision be upheld.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
21 Marlow Drive
BAR2025-002302 | TMS# 463-07-04-044 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6
Not Surveyed | c. 1969 | Historic Materials Demolition District
Requesting appeal of staff denial for window replacement on sides of house.
Owner: Kathleen Dolaman
Applicant: Stephen Nicholson
Position Statement Board of Architectural Review – Small January 22, 2026 21 Marlow Drive Dear Board Members, The PSC upholds City Staff’s decision to deny the removal of wood windows to install vinyl windows, which are not an appropriate replacement material in the Historic Materials Demolition Purview District. We encourage the applicant to work with Staff to choose from the appropriate replacement window options outlined in the Policy Statement for Historic Materials Demolition Purview. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely,
Flannery Antinoro Preservation Specialist
Post Office Box 1120 ∙ Charleston, SC 29402 ∙ (843) 723-1623 ∙ Fax (843) 577-2067 ∙ www.historiccharleston.org
To: Members of the Board of Architectural Review-Small
From: Kate Dutilly, Preservation Planner
Date: January 22, 2026
Re: 21 Marlow
Historic Charleston Foundation has reviewed the appeal of the staff decision regarding window
replacement at 21 Marlow Street. HCF does not believe that vinyl is an appropriate replacement
material and respectfully requests that the staff decision be upheld.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
2 Hanover Street
BAR2025-002303 | TMS# 459-09-03-036 | East Side | Council District 4
Category 4 | c. 1852 | Old City District
Requesting appeal of staff decision for full siding and window replacement.
Owner: Tony Celia
Applicant: Rob Johnson Construction
Position Statement Board of Architectural Review – Small January 22, 2026 2 Hanover Street Dear Board Members, The PSC upholds City Staff’s decision to deny wholesale replacement of this property’s historic wood windows and siding. We encourage the applicant to work with Staff to pursue in-kind repair of deteriorated materials and ask that selective replacement in-kind be limited only to elements beyond repair. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely,
Flannery Antinoro Preservation Specialist
Post Office Box 1120 ∙ Charleston, SC 29402 ∙ (843) 723-1623 ∙ Fax (843) 577-2067 ∙ www.historiccharleston.org
To: Members of the Board of Architectural Review-Small
From: Kate Dutilly, Preservation Planner
Date: January 22, 2026
Re: 2 Hanover
Historic Charleston Foundation has reviewed the appeal of the staff decision regarding full siding
and window replacement at 2 Hanover Street. HCF recommends that the existing windows be
repaired rather than replaced. If window replacement is deemed necessary, the new windows
should be wood, true divided-lite windows that match the historic character of the building.
Regarding the siding, HCF again recommends that as much of the existing historic material as
possible be salvaged and retained, with replacement limited only to areas that are beyond repair.
CITY OF CHARLESTON
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL
3 Hanover Street
BAR2025-002306 | TMS# 459-09-03-041 | East Side | Council District 4
Category 4 | c. 1900 | Old City District
Requesting appeal of staff decision for full siding and window replacement.
Owner: Tony Celia
Applicant: Rob Johnson Construction
Position Statement Board of Architectural Review – Small January 22, 2026 3 Hanover Street Dear Board Members, The PSC upholds City Staff’s decision to deny wholesale replacement of this property’s historic wood windows and siding. We encourage the applicant to work with Staff to pursue in-kind repair of deteriorated materials and ask that selective replacement in-kind be limited only to elements beyond repair. Thank you for considering our position in this matter. Sincerely,
Flannery Antinoro Preservation Specialist
Post Office Box 1120 ∙ Charleston, SC 29402 ∙ (843) 723-1623 ∙ Fax (843) 577-2067 ∙ www.historiccharleston.org
To: Members of the Board of Architectural Review-Small
From: Kate Dutilly, Preservation Planner
Date: January 22, 2026
Re: 3 Hanover
Historic Charleston Foundation has reviewed the appeal of the staff decision regarding full siding
and window replacement at 3 Hanover Street. HCF recommends that the existing windows be
repaired rather than replaced. If window replacement is deemed necessary, the new windows
should be wood, true divided-lite windows that match the historic character of the building.
Regarding the siding, HCF again recommends that as much of the existing historic material as
possible be salvaged and retained, with replacement limited only to areas that are beyond repair.
Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.