RecordWell Data

BAR-S Meeting Results

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jan 22, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL MEETING RESULTS JANUARY 22, 2026 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Lindsay Van Slambrook, Fillmore Wilson, William Bill Turner, Darryl Cobb STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: Frankie Pinto, Travis Galli A. Minutes 1. Review of Minutes from the January 8, 2026 Meeting DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approval with Van Slambrook conditions MADE BY: Van Slambrook SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 B. Applications 1. 8 Magnolia Avenue BAR2026-002355 | TMS# 463-08-03-031 | North Central | Council District 4 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1940 | Historic Materials Demolition District (OPT-IN REVIEW) Requesting OPT-IN REVIEW for demolition of existing exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way AND conceptual approval for proposed addition. Owner: Joel Caldwell & Hailey Wist Applicant: Schuyler Clogston Site visit on 01/22/2026 at 8:30 a.m. DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approval of demolition as submitted, conceptual approval of plans, with Board comment to investigate visually retaining chimney above ridge, with preliminary and final review by staff MADE BY: Wilson SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Applicant previously submitted for a different demolition only request under the standard Historic Materials Demolition District purview and was denied 5/8/25. Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 22, 2026 Page 2 2. Applicant has met with staff to coordinate Opt-In review process and owner signed the Opt-In affidavit. 3. Proposed dormers are toward the rear of the structure and pulled away from the eaves. 4. While staff is typically opposed to the removal of a chimney, the existing chimney is a small flue, placed to the rear of the structure, and not character defining to the structure. 5. This is an Opt-In application and if approved, this parcel will be in Opt-In Purview. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. Retain half round window in gable. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of demolition and conceptual with staff condition. BOARD QUESTIONS: • none PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Pleased to see opt-in process utilized o Modest pitch, avoids camel back o Does not oppose • PSC o Appreciate coordination o Unconventional, but set back minimizing visibility BOARD COMMENTS: • Questions if front window is for egress, is sized for egress • Pleased with proposal, thoughtful of existing height, scale, and mass. Dormers aren’t overly large • Don’t have issue with window in gable • Would love to see half round window, understand egress is important • Would recommend adding chimney back to roof but would not make condition. Is set back from street • Good example of first opt-in option, could not approve as demo 2. 9 Magnolia Avenue BAR2025-002312 | TMS# 463-08-03-026 | North Central | Council District 4 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1935 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval of partial demolition from exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way. Owner: 9 Magnolia LLC Applicant: Matthew Sanford Site visit on 01/22/2026 at 8:45 a.m. DECISION: DEFERRED MOTION: Defer for clarification of drawings MADE BY: Wilson SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 22, 2026 Page 3 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Requesting removal of chimney, exterior wall, carport, rear abutment, and asbestos siding. 2. Removal of asbestos siding can be approved due to the Policy Statement for Historic Materials Demolition Purview. 3. Structure is a vernacular building that tells the vehicular history of the peninsula which includes its location on the site. 4. The chimney is a character defining feature, prominent on the structure and highly visible from the public right of way. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial of demolition of chimney, carport, and exterior wall. Staff does not oppose demolition of rear addition. BOARD QUESTIONS: • No demolition of rear portions of roof • Questions to staff, siding and roof would be considered repairs PUBLIC COMMENT: • PSC o Plans difficult to evaluate, need additional information on demo vs repair o Not supportive of demolition of chimney o Request deferral for more information • HCF o Proposed demolition is extensive o Drawings confusing o Request deferral BOARD COMMENTS: • Believe carport is original, would be a character defining feature • Drawings very confusing, approving what is before us. Need to be very clear on what is being removed • Drawings say demo roof, but sounds like simply repairing and reroofing structure. different scenarios • Drawings very vague, west elevation concerning. Note “windows to remain where possible” • Bump out on sanborns looks different proportions than existing, but structure is detailed like house • If house is to grow would prefer on the side than a camel back, but have no control over what it looks like • Different than when carport is extension of the roof • Could defer until drawings improved, clarified what is being approved • Don’t think rear addition is visible, not under purview • Need for clarity in drawings. Need for window survey, repair vs replacement. If replaced in kind wouldn’t come back to Board • Only chimney, wall, carport would be coming back Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 22, 2026 Page 4 3. 90 Gordon Street BAR2025-002316 | TMS# 463-10-04-087 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1950 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way. Owner: Thuane Fielding Applicant: Coastal Creek Design Site visit on 01/22/2026 at 9:00 a.m. DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approve demolition as submitted MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0 Recused: Fillmore BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Request includes demolition of rear additions. 2. Structure is on a corner, making the rear highly visible from the public ROW. 3. Rear addition was constructed pre-1964 per Sanborn map. 4. Existing demolition does not contain character defining features. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff does not oppose demolition. BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • View the additions as original as they were so close to original construction date • Amount of roof removal visible from the street • Proposed demolition area is awkward and unattractive, no defining features • By preserving this are we preserving an architectural gem, no 4. 304 Ashley Avenue BAR2025-002300 | TMS# 460-07-02-035 | Westside | Council District 6 Not Surveyed | c. 1930 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for full demolition of existing structure. Owner: Diana B. Reynolds, Jocelyn R. Young, & Kanton T. Reynolds Applicant: Joceyln R. Young & Kanton T. Reynolds Site visit on 01/22/2026 at 9:20 a.m. DECISION: DENIED MOTION: Denial of demolition as submitted Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 22, 2026 Page 5 MADE BY: Wilson SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Image overview incorrectly listed Patrick Orefice as the architect of record. He is not affiliated with this project. 2. Staff has received documentation that structure is older than posted date, c. 1912. 3. Freedman’s cottages are vernacular architecture, distinct to Charleston, primarily associated with Charleston’s African American community. 4. The 2004 Upper Peninsula Architectural Inventory listed 106 Freedman's Cottages, it is currently unknown how many of these structures remain standing. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Stabilization plan to be submitted to staff within 60 business days 2. If any demolition is approved, project must wait 30 day appeal period required per Ordinance prior to permit approval STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Denial as submitted with staff condition BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Cannot support the demolition of historic structure o Based on information in submittal cannot support • Sarah Spangler, Westside Neighborhood Association o Did not send recommendations, stated they were currently planning to oppose demolition o Lack of basic research concerning, information and typology incorrect o Concerns about engineering report and lack of information o Study of rehabilitation o Listed architect is not associated with project o Demolition of sister houses o Informed applicant of Opt-In purview o Full demolition should be last resort • PSC o Legacy ownership o Tremendous loss of streetscape o Cannot consider hardship o Have seen structures in worse conditions rehabilitated o Would be happy to offer guidance on rehabilitation o Recommend pursuing partial demolition and alteration • Aurthur Lawrence, 210 Fishburne o Previous demolitions in neighborhood o History of house, Baxter family, and neighborhood o Shouldn’t demolish our houses and demolish our history o People that developed these houses should be remembered o Loss of 190 Line Street Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 22, 2026 Page 6 • Kevin Eberle, 367 President o No means testing in BAR, do not request more or less depending on income o Not charged with maximizing income, finances should not be included BOARD COMMENTS: • Question regarding date, 1912 for original structure, rear addition 1964 • House is in very good condition. Structural reports are taken with a grain of salt, they are stating it’s going to be costly to repair. • There used to be 3 freedman’s cottages in a row here and this is the last one left • If rear additions can be dated, would not be opposed to removal of rear kitchen or the bathroom bump out • Cannot support total demolition • Will need to be elevated, but not so high that it will destroy integrity • If original portion retained, some sort of sensitive addition could go on back • Freedman’s cottages where they’ve survived should be retained • Further study on evolution of structure 5. 232 Rutledge Avenue BAR2025-002308 | TMS# 460-08-03-006 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough Council District 6 | Category 4 | c. 1885 | Old City District Requesting appeal of after-the-fact staff denial for fence. Owner: Toby Fugate Applicant: Maner Builders Supply Site visit on 01/22/2026 at 9:50 a.m. DECISION: DENIED • MOTION: Uphold staff denial. Allow staff to review new fence with Board conditions MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Cannot be over 4’ in height • Cannot be opaque STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. 12/9/25 – Denied by staff due to creating awkward condition and fortress like condition at street. 2. Note that fence is taller than provided drawing. BOARD QUESTIONS: • Constructed fence does not match drawings, different design PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Request clarification to staff on process Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 22, 2026 Page 7 • For that area most fences are around 4’ tall, so this is entirely too tall. Placement is also odd • Primarily height and opacity are the issue • Incongruous with streetscape, most fences are iron work • Typically don’t approve stockade fence • Issue with contractor. Doesn’t align with any of the design criteria for BAR • Fence on corner of Bogard and Rutledge, example of wood fence that is appropriate 6. 157 Tradd Street BAR2025-002338 | TMS# 457-11-04-031 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Category 4 | c. 1890 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval exterior alterations including re-opening porch, fenestration changes, and demolition of addition. Owner: Michael Furlong and Eric Larson Applicant: Sebastian von Marschall Site visit on 1/22/2026 at 10:10 a.m. DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Conceptual approval addressing Board discussion with preliminary / final review by staff in permit documents. MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • See discussion STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Proposed location of the front door is more appropriate. 2. Provided photos show evidence of existing shutter dogs. 3. Staff appreciates the reopening of a portion of the piazza. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff in permit documents. BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Encouraged by opening of first floor piazza o In full support • PSC o Excited to see harmony and rhythm of streetscape restored o In support BOARD COMMENTS: • A lot of good things happening here, always glad to see piazzas reopened • Putting door and window back where they go Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 22, 2026 Page 8 • Would prefer to see pilaster returned as well as door surround moved • Continue details under porch • Cleaning up and bringing order • Awkwardness of mass over porch 7. 122 Logan Street BAR2025-002327 | TMS# 457-08-02-085 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Category 3 | c. 1791 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for rear addition. Owner: 122 Logan Street, LLC Applicant: e e fava architects Site visit on 1/22/2026 at 10:30 a.m. DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board conditions (return for preliminary) MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 0 Abstain: Wilson BOARD CONDITIONS: • Very rear addition incorporate a plane change in both the roof and north wall • Allow historic rear corner to read as such STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Addition is subordinate and complimentary to the existing. 2. Applicant has provided additional information per previous Board motion. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff in permit documents. BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • PSC o Appreciate lighter touch, especially the roof o Request further differentiation on rear of dependency • HCF o Appreciate sensitive changes, lowering the roof o In full support BOARD COMMENTS: • Overall nice design, respectful of existing building, not impacting a lot of historic material • On differentiation, maybe something subtle like a shutter pattern change, don’t want to make too busy • Appreciate the adaptive reuse, plan for the front building is very good • This portion of structure more complicated, less historic material remaining. Historic roof form is retained, original form of structure. This is fundamentally an addition. Meets Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 22, 2026 Page 9 height, scale, mass. Differentiated from original structure. Struggle with compatibility of original architecture. Back north corner of addition should be saved, as well as roof form • Architectural direction of addition not compatible with original historic architecture • Really like the interior of the addition with glass enclosure but not compatible • Contemporary design difficult to do well enough to be compatible • Would have questions on how the glass box is going to be detailed 8. 8 Riverside Drive BAR2025-002307 | TMS# 46307-02-001 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 Not Surveyed (Group 2) | c. 1938 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right-of-way. Owner: Richard Callari Applicant: Schuyler Clogston DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: approval of demolition of roof areas and approval of demolition of rear gable, with retention of eave below roof line MADE BY: Wilson SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • See motion STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Request includes demolition of portions of rear roof and wall. 2. Proposed areas of demolition are pulled in from the eaves and down from the ridge. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. Rear eaves should be retained, demolition area should tuck under the eave. (perspective shows saved STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff does not oppose with staff condition #1. BOARD QUESTIONS: • none PUBLIC COMMENT: • none BOARD COMMENTS: • have followed what we asked for, under 30% • Off ridge and eaves, not sure about rear gable. Roof plane not being demolished but eave is Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 22, 2026 Page 10 9. 21 Council Street BAR2025-002319 | TMS# 457-11-02-018 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 1928 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for dormers and additions. Owner: Ned & Lauren Dupont Applicant: Tyler A Smyth Architects DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff in permit documents. MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Previous shed dormer has been reduced in size. 2. Lite pattern and fenestration have been restudied on the south and west elevation. 3. Previous Board comments have been addressed. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with Board conditions and preliminary / final review by staff in permit documents. BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Appreciate shrinking the HVAC stand and reducing dormer size • Wish previous and proposed were on same page 10. 220 King Street BAR2025-002318 | TMS# 457-08-02-025 | Council District 8 Category 2 | c. 1835 | Old & Historic District Requesting final approval for signage. Owner: 220 King Street LLC Applicant: Image 360 Charleston DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approval of right angle sign, mounted on pilaster with staff observation 1)d. Denial of façade sign MADE BY: Wilson SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 22, 2026 Page 11 BOARD CONDITIONS: • See motion STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. 11/21/25 – Denied by staff due to not meeting the following a. Only 2 sign types allowed, renderings show window graphics, right angle sign, and façade sign b. Façade sign not approvable between 2nd and 3rd floors by staff c. No faux wood grain d. No sandblasted HDU e. Renderings must show attachment methods. Signs are not to be attached to the brick, but instead the mortar joints BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • none Applicant response: • Window graphics have been removed, from previous tenants • Will attach to mortar joints BOARD COMMENTS: • Board has been very consistent about not approving façade sign above first floor, King Street very pedestrian oriented • Policy against sandblasted signs. Can be dimensional • Blade sign should be mounted to pilaster • Nature of the building, with building detailing may not be able to have façade sign 11. 31 Cypress Street BAR2025-002309 | TMS# 463-12-01-039 | North Central | Council District 4 Category 3 (Group 1) | c. 1935 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting appeal of staff denial to replace windows. Owner: Sophronia Holmes Applicant: Raquel Swanner DECISION: DENIED MOTION: Uphold staff decision MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. 12/8/25 - Vinyl windows denied by staff. Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 22, 2026 Page 12 BOARD QUESTIONS: • Solid vinyl window PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Board has policy again solid vinyl windows • This would be repeating mistakes made on front of the house • Per photos, windows being replaced are original • This is demo purview, would be demo approval • Can be replaced per replacement policy 12. 9 Harleston Place BAR2025-002315 | TMS# 457-03-03-126 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 1984 | Old & Historic District Requesting appeal of staff denial to replace windows. Owner: Dobbins Living Trust Applicant: Raquel Swanner DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Overturn staff denial MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. 12/10/25 - Vinyl windows denied by staff. BOARD QUESTIONS: • Existing windows are vinyl clad, just not impact PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Don’t have a problem, good looking window. Near water is harsher environment Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 22, 2026 Page 13 13. 21 Marlow Drive BAR2025-002302 | TMS# 463-07-04-044 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 Not Surveyed | c. 1969 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting appeal of staff denial for window replacement on sides of house. Owner: Kathleen Dolaman Applicant: Stephen Nicholson DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Overturn staff denial and approve demolition of windows MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. 2022 - Front windows determined by staff to be non-original, replacement windows not under BAR jurisdiction 2. 10/21/25 - Vinyl windows denied by staff. BOARD QUESTIONS: • Brand of windows on front, Protect Sure • Windows approved for back Wincor or similar PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Wish front hadn’t been approved, light pattern already changed • Don’t have problem with a good clad window, but don’t know what proposed window will be • Side windows should be same windows as front (or back) • Building only from 1969 • (staff clarified, property is in demo purview) 14. 2 Hanover Street BAR2025-002303 | TMS# 459-09-03-036 | East Side | Council District 4 Category 4 | c. 1852 | Old City District Requesting appeal of staff decision for full siding and window replacement. Owner: Tony Celia Applicant: Rob Johnson Construction DECISION: DENIED MOTION: Uphold staff denial MADE BY: Wilson SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 22, 2026 Page 14 BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. 8/27/25 - Staff requested photos of areas with wood rot and specifications on replacement windows. BOARD QUESTIONS: • Some of siding has been replaced. Unknown amount of original siding remaining • Rail is 30’, historic height, should remain that height PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Would approve replacing bad siding in kind, but think a lot of siding is salvageable • Not comfortable replacing all the windows • Siding under porch is in pretty good shape • Not total replacement, but replacement where required • Applicant states all siding and trim has been removed 15. 3 Hanover Street BAR2025-002306 | TMS# 459-09-03-041 | East Side | Council District 4 Category 4 | c. 1900 | Old City District Requesting appeal of staff decision for full siding and window replacement. Owner: Tony Celia Applicant: Rob Johnson Construction DECISION: DENIED MOTION: Uphold staff decision with Board comment that any replacement of vinyl windows can be approved MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. 10/29/25 - Staff denied wholesale replacement of siding. BOARD QUESTIONS: • Need to see what’s underneath vinyl and evaluate it first PUBLIC COMMENT: • None Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 22, 2026 Page 15 BOARD COMMENTS: • Need window survey • Places in photos where siding is exposed, vinyl may have protected wood • No issue with vinyl windows being replaced • Staff can approve removing vinyl • Staff can approve repairs

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.