RecordWell Data

BAR-L Meeting Results

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jan 14, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – LARGE MEETING RE SULTS JANUARY 14, 2026 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Seaton Brown, James Meadors, Joel Trantham, Steve Ramos (Chair), Jay White STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: B.D. Wortham-Galvin, Lawrence Courtney, Brad Thomas A. MINUTES 1. Review of Minutes from the December 12, 2025, Meeting DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approval of Minutes MADE BY: Meadors SECOND: Brown VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 Jay White abstains B. APPLICATIONS 1. 635 King Street BAR2025-002342 | TMS #460-08-02-007 | Cannonborough/Elliottborough Council District 4 | New Construction | Height Districts 3.5, 6, 7 Old and Historic District, Old City District Requesting Approval of a mockup panel. Owner: Ron Owen, Evening Post Publishing Company Applicant: Christian Sottile, FAIA NOTE: The Board will convene on the parcel directly west of 47 Line Street on January 13, 2026, at 8:30 a.m. for a site visit. DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approval of Mockup with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions and Final Review By Staff MADE BY: White SECOND: Meadors VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • This is a relatively large and complex mockup which shows workmanship on a variety of conditions. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | January 14, 2026 Page 2 • An additional submittal was prepared by the Applicant showing where conditions occurred on the mockup that would not actually occur on the building - these conditions are limited and should not lead to confusion. This clarification has been transmitted to Board members. • Different sealant colors may be required at varying conditions. Care will need to be exercised in their application. Despite some unfortunate placement of sealants on the mockup, Staff is assured based on discussions with GC and Applicant that everyone is treating this seriously and that these conditions will be effectively handled. • It is understood that the Applicant is showing two mortar conditions on the mockup with the lighter mortar being at the top of the structure. • The copper seaming was uneven and will need more attention to workmanship during construction. The Applicant may want to discuss potential staining of copper elements onto materials below with the Board. • While the overall workmanship shown on the mockup is good, translating this level to a large building may be challenging and yet the involved parties appear very committed to attaining that goal. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. A thorough, building-wide examination of sealants required will be needed to address the many conditions requiring them. 2. Attention to the workmanship of the copper seaming during construction is required. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of Mockup with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions BOARD COMMENTS: • Slight offsets in the moldings are a detail that needs to be adjusted. • The railing system that’s between the two columns there’s a piece of wood on the bottom of it that the right side of it is much lower than the left side; not sure what that is. • Caulking/sealants have been mentioned by staff and applicant and need to be taken care of. • The transitions of copper and molding to the brick: the gaps that were there were significant. • There needs to be acceptable copper seaming and consistency in how it is rolled. • The copper sheet metal work needs attention and if the workers are curious how to do the compound curvature have them go see the roof of the gazebo in Hampton Park; it’s ridge seam is perfect, so it is achievable. • There’s a varying gap in the big arch between the brickwork and the metal. It feels like the accuracy could be tightened on that. • Where the trim at the lower part of the balcony met the brick there needs to be a solution to turn the brick back so that could meet rather than being scribed to the brick. • To be the exemplar that HCF and PSC are talking about the execution needs to be flawless. • What we often target is the joints; where things meet up needs care and attention. For full Board discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | January 14, 2026 Page 3 2. 989 Morrison Drive | WITHDRAWN BY STAFF BAR2025-002340 | TMS #459-01-01-001 | East Central | Council District 4 New Construction | Height District 4-12 | Historic Corridor District Requesting Conceptual Approval of a new multi-family building. Owner: Scott Fuller (representative) Applicant: Brad Brown NOTE: Withdrawn by staff prior to meeting. 3. 474 Meeting Street BAR2025-002335 | TMS #459-05-03-071 | Eastside | Council District 4 New Construction | Height Districts 2.5-3 | Height District 4 Old and Historic District, Old City District Requesting Conceptual Approval for a mixed-use, affordable housing building. Owner: Star Gospel Mission Applicant: Bryanna Dering-Weyrich (LS3P) DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual Approval with Staff Comments and Conditions and Board Condition to restudy the form and elevations and materials to reinforce the massing as presented MADE BY: Trantham SECOND: White VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • This project involves the construction of 3 new structures across the site (P.04/P.05). The two other structures on Nassau Street have already received Preliminary Approval by the Board. The extent of the entire project is over two height districts, but this specific submittal is in Height District 4. • City Council passed a Resolution on 24 January 2023 establishing The Priority Status Affordable Housing Program that provides special benefits and advantages during the development review process to residential and mixed-used developments that make certain impactful contributions toward the City’s supply of affordable housing. This project comes under the auspices of this program. Thus, while in general the Board does not consider cost when deliberating on projects, the BAR must balance the Priority Status Affordable Housing Program with maintaining quality design for all residents in all types of housing situations. • The context of the site varies in height, mass and building typologies (p. 19) and this project sits mid-block between Meeting and Nassau Streets making it less visible, particularly from Meeting Street. Staff support height, scale and mass of the proposal. • Staff support the metal fence with stucco knee wall and posts as shown as well as the hardscape/landscape material board. • Staff appreciate the alignment of the chapel with the site line to the structure from Meeting Street, terminating with a garden at the rear. • Staff support the distinction made in the gable roof form to highlight the chapel portion of the structure as well as the differentiation in ground level materials and the playful yet purposeful arranged window pattern in the chapel mass drawing from Charleston precedents (P.13). Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | January 14, 2026 Page 4 • The residential mass and elevation are less visible from Meeting Street. Staff appreciate the attempt to break down the mass and provide a vertical rhythm through recessed drains. While the Applicant is unable to provide windows in all potential fenestration moments, the articulation of the blank wall where one might expect windows is appreciated and provides visual relief on the wall surface. • Staff support the material detail precedents shown (P. 14/15) and note that workmanship and craft will be key in the success of this modest architectural direction. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Bring physical samples of materials to the Preliminary review. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions BOARD COMMENTS: • The precedent photos for details/materials were good. • The roof feels imbalanced with the staggering of the windows. • Staggering of the windows on the southside feels awkward because the wall is divided into three sections by the downspouts. • Appreciate the modern look set back from the public right of way. • The precedents in the city where you showed the fenestration is unbalanced are all on non-primary facades; they are not on the streetscape side. The fenestration on the chapel/west side does look unbalanced. The secondary and tertiary sides are not as much of a bother. • Have a different take. There is a beauty in the simplicity of the design. It does have a clear and restrained language. There’s a little bit of play in it but there’s also a gathering of certain elements in a rhythm that is easily read. The windows where they are brought together and bridge the different levels are successful. • Where there’s a concern is in the massing of these elements. Page 12 diagram 1 shows the 4 elements and diagram 2 shows how the fenestration rhythm works with those elements in the 1, 2, 3, 4 set up. But with the applied gutter and scupper it’s probably going to read more like the diagram on page 11 where it reads as two separate masses. The window strategy is reinforcing the two separate masses with playful windows on one and not on the other. The two strategies of how you are trying to break down this building are conflicting with each other. The form is possibly more successful but then it’s the fenestration and materials and/or offset needing to break up those masses. The way that this building sits (pg. 19), especially on Nassau Street, it’s the vertical breaking up of it that is going to help that mass sit in a different context (the use of siding is not enough to do that). Having a better resolution on that would help at this stage. • There needs to be some resolution between the materials and form. The playfulness of the window and the offset aren’t a problem because they correspond to how the recess at the first level works; but it’s working against your strategy to break down the mass. • For a mid-block building that is so deeply imbedded within one of the city’s larger blocks, the logic and the strategy is understandable. When you strip a building down to its bones, the bones and the detailing have to shine. Economy is in everybody’s mind Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | January 14, 2026 Page 5 as you proceed to detailing and construction, but what you have here will require a lot of precision to achieve it well. That is not impossible, but it will be a challenge. • Agree that given the mid-block placement, there’s a little more artistic freedom. Understanding that it has a civic presence (it’s a chapel) and if it had a more symmetrical gable, it would have a more domestic or residential appearance. That being the special part of the site, can get on board with it. Wonder if the playful windows could be more playful on the chapel piece to really highlight it as this unique part of the project. • Agree that contemporary details can be hard to pull off. Anytime there’s no rake on a roof, that’s a concern. Be wary that when you try to be overly inventive with details, there might be a reason they were done a certain way for a long time. • Some of these comments are about restudy of the specific material pattern and the way that it’s being treated. For full Board discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. 4. 162 Ashley Avenue BAR2025-002334 | TMS #460-15-04-061 | Medical Complex | Council District 6 New Construction | Height District 85/30 | Old City District Requesting Preliminary Approval of an apartment building with ground-level retail. Owner: Evan Marko & John Marko Applicant: Jeffrey Rengering DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Preliminary Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions with Final Review by Staff MADE BY: White SECOND: Trantham VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • This project received Conceptual Approval by the Board on 14 May 2025. • Board and Staff Comments included: - Study a more volumetric shift and/or an increase in the change of depth that occurs on the elevation at material transitions. - Explore other higher-end, contemporary and more context-sensitive material as an alternative to fiber-cement siding (such as nickel or channel gap) and provide samples at Preliminary review. • Applicant did not make a volumetric shift but, as noted, the metal panel face is offset 6” from the channel gap finish and they have contrasted the lighter metal panel with the darker channel gap to accentuate this dimensional change. Staff is satisfied with these approaches. • The applicant has substituted the previous Charleston Green fiber cement board with painted 5/8” channel gap siding. Staff support this substitution. • Staff support modifications and details as shown in this submittal. STAFF CONDITIONS: No staff conditions Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | January 14, 2026 Page 6 STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Preliminary Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions with Final Review by Staff BOARD COMMENTS: • Appreciate the level of detail in this drawing set because it did satisfy a lot of the questions related to a potential volumetric shift mentioned last time. The differentiation of the metal panels and the siding are going to create that varied façade that we are looking for. It really addresses that previous comment. • There’s a nice play in the patterns in both the masonry and the siding type materials that are here and it leads to a nicely balanced façade and it emphasizes all the principles we would want it to at this point. • In the mockup proposal, most of the building conditions were met in there, but the elements that feel like their missing are the porch elements, which are the ones that really engage the public space. The underside of the porch, the way the terrace is being met, how the materials are all transitioning as they meet at the porch, the mockup panel would need to be adjusted to include those elements For full Board discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. 5. 31 George Street / 84 Society Street BAR2025-002339 | TMS #457-04-04-112/008/007/017/113/025 | Downtown Council District 8 | New Construction | Height District 6 | Old and Historic District Requesting Final Approval for the construction of two new buildings. Owner: GS Acquisitions LLC Applicant: Goff D'Antonio Associates DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Final Approval with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions and returning balconies to the original depth with Final Review By Staff MADE BY: White SECOND: Meadors VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • This project received Preliminary Approval by the Board on 13 December 2023. There are two buildings, labeled A & B, as part of this submission. The Applicant has met all TRC requirements in multiple rounds during 2024 and 2025. • For Building A, staff had no comments at Preliminary and Board Discussion centered around confirming with Applicant that the 3D material is for profile display only; that no 3D printed materials are proposed for use on the building. Applicant confirmed they were for representation only. • For Building B, Board had no comments/discussion at Preliminary and Staff Condition was as follows: - “Society is a narrow and quiet street, and street trees are desired. However, please confirm their locations through zoning as they appear to encroach 10’ sidewalk minimum, but the sidewalk depth is determined by the location of the existing building.: Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | January 14, 2026 Page 7 - The Applicant has addressed all street tree issues to the satisfaction of TRC and received their approval. • While Applicant did not set up a preview meeting with Staff, given that this project is at Final and based on the application at hand, Staff are comfortable with the packages for Buildings A and B as submitted. Staff noted in the meeting extemporaneously that we were not aware of the changes to the balconies (which a preview meeting would have helped clarify). STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. Any modifications to approved drawings required for code or fire department compliance, or contemplated during construction, must be approved by the BAR prior to undertaking the changes. Any modifications/substitutions to the materials or elements approved at the Final BAR Hearing must be specifically noted, reviewed and approved on the Mockup sample panel. 2. Deviations from previously approved submissions, if determined by the BAR Staff during or after completion of construction to be a downgrade of the quality of the project and inconsistent with previous approvals, are not approved, whether noted or not by Staff during our review of “For Permit” drawings. 3. All construction work is to consider adjacent or nearby structures and the protection and monitoring thereof. If any work involving significant vibration may be reasonably suspected to be a threat to historic or new adjacent or nearby structures, a program must be in place addressing how these structures are to be protected and monitored. A copy of this protection and monitoring plan is to be transmitted to Staff for review prior to work. 4. A separate signage package will need to be submitted for all words and graphics to be placed on the building, as these are not considered part of any approvals or motions for this Board discussion. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Final Approval for both Buildings A and B with Final Review by Staff of For Permit Drawings. BOARD COMMENTS: • Multiple Board members not expecting changes in the balconies in this submittal noting they are character defining features and want the balcony configuration returned to that approved at Preliminary as key elements of the elevations (regardless of whether they are accessible). The design (particularly the depth) of the balconies needs to be in line with that which was previously approved. • This is not the first time with this project where there is a discrepancy from one hearing to the next. For full Board discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | January 14, 2026 Page 8 6. 126 Coming Street BAR2025-002337 | TMS #460-16-01-078 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 4 Category 1 | c. 1816 | Height District 2.5-3 | Old and Historic District Requesting Final Approval of exterior color changes and stucco on a Category 1 building. Owner: Cathedral of St. Luke and St. Paul Applicant: Meadors Inc. DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Final Approval with FRBS in the Permit. MADE BY: White SECOND: Trantham VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 James Meadors recused. STAFF COMMENTS: • 126 Coming Street is a Category 1 building which necessitates Board review. • Based on the Applicant’s thorough stucco and paint analysis, staff support the color selections as shown in the micrographic studies of the original stucco and paint. STAFF CONDITIONS: No staff conditions STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Final Approval with FRBS in the Permit. For full Board discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. 7. 134 Saint Philip Street BAR2025-002328 | TMS #460-12-02-038 | Radcliffeborough | Council District 4 Category 3 | c. 1887 | Height Districts 2.5-3, 4 | Old City District Requesting an appeal of Staff’s decision to deny a roofing material change from slate to copper. Owner: Diocese of Charleston Applicant: Chris Berwick DECISION: DENIED MOTION: Appeal of Staff’s decision is denied with Board and Staff Comments and Conditions MADE BY: White SECOND: Meadors VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • The requested Appeal stems from an in-person interaction with Staff at the City’s Permit Center in December 2025. • The Applicant sought approval to change the steeple roofing material on the southwestern portion of the church from slate shingles to copper. • While copper is not considered a material downgrade from a BAR perspective, the proposed change would alter a character-defining feature of the building and differ from the original roofing material used at the time of construction in 1887. Board of Architectural Review – Large Meeting Results | January 14, 2026 Page 9 • Additionally, a copper roof would not replicate the existing overlapping and diamond-shaped shingle patterns characteristic of the current slate installation. • For these reasons, Staff denied the proposed change in material at the administrative level and advised the Applicant to seek Board review and approval. STAFF CONDITIONS: 1. If the Appeal is upheld by the Board, the existing shingle pattern and configuration found on the existing steeple shall be replicated on the proposed steeple. 2. Regardless of the roof material, the applicant must apply for a building permit to begin construction. 3. Any additional repairs to the steeple not outlined in this application shall be “in-kind”. BOARD COMMENTS: • In cases like this everybody is sensitive to the fact that it’s a small parish. It’s a 140- year-old roof. Staff made the right call because we are preservation guidelines in our Ordinance. Staff is just looking at the Ordinance and they are applying it. You’ve heard the phrase character defining a couple of times and the steeple of that church really is and the detailing on the slate is a big part of that. Sometimes the preservation of our historic architecture can be a challenge for small institutions and the small institutions are often the stewards of our most important buildings. We just can’t go messing around with the steeples of historic Charleston. • The longevity of the slate roof shows the success of the slate roof. The condition your roof is in now is dangerous and it should be removed as quickly as possible. But the final solution should be install of slate. You don’t nail slate, you hang it and it’s not intended to be tight, it’s intended to move in the wind. If it’s installed correctly, you can have another very long-lasting roof. For full Board discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel. 8. Update to BAR Policies See emails with attachments of policies. Physical copies will be provided at the meeting. DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approval of BAR Policies MADE BY: White SECOND: Trantham VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 STAFF COMMENTS: • Opt-In Policy was adopted by BAR-S 8 January 2026. • Bar Policy Statement for Alternative Energy was originally adopted by BAR-L on 10 December 2025. BAR-S passed the policy on 11 December 2025 with the addition of “unless appropriately concealed” to the end of the 3rd paragraph. For full Board discussion go to the City of Charleston’s YouTube channel.

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.