RecordWell Data

BAR-S Meeting Results

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jan 8, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF CHARLESTON BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW – SMALL MEETING RESULTS JANUARY 8, 2026 4:30 P.M. 2 GEORGE STREET BOARD MEMBERS PRESENT: Lindsay Van Slambrook, Fillmore Wilson, William Bill Turner, Becky Fenno, Darryl Cobb STAFF MEMBERS PRESENT: Frankie Pinto, Travis Galli A. Minutes 1. Review of Minutes from the December 11, 2025 Meeting DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approved with Lindsay Van Slambrook edits MADE BY: Van Slambrook SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 B. Applications 1. 1010 Ashley Avenue BAR2025-002288 | TMS# 463-08-01-109 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1938 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for a partial demolition including portions of the rear roof. Per BZA-Z motion 5/20/25, Board of Architecture Review approval is required for exterior alterations. Requesting conceptual approval for new second-story addition. Owner: Mandi Walters Applicant: Abigail WR Brennan Site visit on 01/08/2026 at 8:30 a.m. DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approve of demolition and conceptual approval and preliminary / final by staff MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 3 AGAINST: 2 Opposed: Wilson, Fenno BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Area of roof demo has been reduced. Staff would be more comfortable if area requested was less than 50% of roof. 2. Staff recommend adding windows on the north side. Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 8, 2026 Page 2 3. Fenestration on the south elevation is much improved. 4. Overall height has been reduced, previously proposed dormers have been removed. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. Reduce roof demo area 2. Additional fenestration on north elevation STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of demolition and conceptual with Board and staff conditions and preliminary / final review by staff in permit documents BOARD QUESTIONS: • none PUBLIC COMMENT: • PSC o Revised design has improved proportions and reduced demo o Concerns have been addressed • HCF o Demo of historic material inappropriate o Massing and scale not subordinate BOARD COMMENTS: • Improved a great deal, second floor mass better relates • Biggest improvement was removing the clearstory • Square foot wise is more than Board likes, but is such a small house • Appreciate demo area reduced and height has come down • Still an architectural concept that greatly alters the streetscape • Overwhelms the original bungalow • When buying such a small house it is a dilemma • Very tight lot, but may be avenues to think more creatively for solutions • Architectural concept is incongruous with height / scale / mass • Neighborhood has so much precedent for these additions • Struggle to continue a bad concept, even if there is precedent • Being next door to two story, next door adding a second floor. This house is now shorter than its neighbors • Appreciate reducing demolition to less than 50% • Using precedent which was done before purview, some is not the best approach 2. 932 Rutledge Avenue BAR2025-002277 | TMS# 463-08-01-052 | North Central | Council District 4 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1939 | Historic Corridor District Requesting approval for partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right- of-way. Owner: Palmetto Equity Solutions Applicant: John Sullivan – S Arch Studio Site visit on 01/08/2026 at 8:50 a.m. DECISION: APPROVED Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 8, 2026 Page 3 MOTION: Approval of demolition as submitted MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Rear demolition very minimal. 2. Front metal roof appears to be later addition. 3. Since this is in the Historic Corridor District, front roof replacement and any rear addition will require BAR review but could potentially be reviewed by staff. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of demolition with staff observation #3 BOARD QUESTIONS: • none PUBLIC COMMENT: • PSC o Existing 3/1 windows should be salvaged and reused BOARD COMMENTS: • Rear is almost not visible • No issue of removal of front canopy 3. 188 Grove Street BAR2025-002271 | TMS# 463-10-04-002 | Wagener Terrace | Council District 6 Category 4 (Group 2) | c. 1950 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right- of-way. Owner: Jonathan Oakman Applicant: Jonathan Oakman Site visit on 01/08/2026 at 9:10 a.m. DECISION: WITHDRAWN Withdrawn per Board site visit 4. 23 Parkwood Avenue BAR2025-002270 | TMS# 460-02-04-112 | Hampton Park Terrace | Council District 6 Category 4 (Group 1) | c. 1920 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for partial demolition of exterior elements visible from the public right- of-way. Owner: Plunkett, Endia and Andrew Applicant: Bobby Newman Site visit on 01/08/2026 at 9:30 a.m. DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 8, 2026 Page 4 MOTION: Approve with Board condition MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Exception of eave and eave return • Retain window and trim STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Request includes handrail, second floor deck, fascia, soffit, corner trim, gable window, side door and trim 2. Proposed area is highly visible. 3. The purpose of roof demolition is unclear. Per the permit request, demolition area doesn’t match 4. Applicant description at site visit includes the encapsulation of entire wall, which BAR would consider demolition. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval of deck and door demolition, denial of all else. BOARD QUESTIONS: • Clarification on demolition area PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Request that original eave and eave return be retained • PSC o Request that original eave, eave return, circular window be retained BOARD COMMENTS: • Don’t have issue with deck and rail, gable and eave return should not be demolished or covered • Opposed to gable, eave, or window being covered • Any addition could easily be tucked under eave 5. 192 Nassau Street BAR2025-002278 | TMS# 459-05-01-059 | East Side | Council District 4 Not Surveyed | c. 1973 | Historic Materials Demolition District Requesting approval for full demolition of structure. Owner: Stagger Lee LLC Applicant: b Studio Architecture Site visit on 01/08/2026 at 9:50 a.m. DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approval of demolition MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 8, 2026 Page 5 STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Staff does not oppose demolition BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Not a high quality building, not good representation of time period, not good fit for neighborhood 6. 211 Rutledge Avenue BAR2025-002267 | TMS# 460-11-02-015 | Cannonborough / Elliottborough Council District 6 | Category 3 | c. 1950 | Old City District Requesting demolition of additions. Owner: NK Partners Applicant: Anthony J. Cissell Site visit on 01/08/2026 at 10:10 a.m. DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approval of demolition with Board conditions MADE BY: Wilson SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Any removal should not destroy any original historic fabric or historic form • Where removal leaves voids in original form, the original form should be appropriately replicated STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Staff does not object to the demolition of non-historic additions. BOARD QUESTIONS: • Approach is to save historic building, removing modern additions is in line • Restore original part that were exposed PUBLIC COMMENT: • Max Cutler, owner Estadio, 122 Spring o Concerned about alterations o Great example of art moderne o Glass block addition appropriate to original period o Requesting demolition of original features in back • Andrew Gould, CENA o CENA is support Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 8, 2026 Page 6 BOARD COMMENTS: • If proposed demolition is to return to original appearance, then have no issue • Areas of demos should replicate historic structure 7. 211 Rutledge Avenue BAR2025-002268 | TMS# 460-11-02-015 | Cannonborough / Elliottborough Council District 6 | Category 3 | c. 1950 | Old City District Requesting conceptual approval for the relocation of the building. Owner: NK Partners Applicant: Anthony J. Cissell DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approval with staff condition MADE BY: Fenno SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 1 Opposed: Wilson BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Staff would not oppose relocation of the entire historic structure assuming all exterior materials can be protected and moved intact, then restored. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. Relocation plan, including complete engineers report, to return to BAR-S for review. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Approval with Board and staff conditions BOARD QUESTIONS: • none PUBLIC COMMENT: • Andrew Gould o Part of neighborhood fabric for 200 years o Neighborhood development o Not destroying something from 1950, but restoring neighborhood fabric o Neighborhood supported several variances to increase density, especially at corner o Supportive of proposal as a whole o Don’t see site context as important. Gas stations work same now as then • Jonathon Poston, Progress Preservation o Adaptive reuse that was fine 20 years ago might not be fine today o Not allowing alteration who • Bill Shandell, lives in neighborhood o Place on site, was the thing o Placement “takes me back” o More than just the concrete block o Additional benefit of providing parking • Glen Maddox, owns business on Rutledge Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 8, 2026 Page 7 o Supportive of previous proposal, still supportive o Prohibits use of site • Max Cutler, 122 Spring o Board job is not to analyze past zoning failures o Saying is not usable in location is untrue o Others in neighborhood have been required to be restored in place o Homage to original use o Usable outdoor space, proposed reduces parking onsite. Parking issues in neighborhood o Not for locals, for rich to come stay o Fuel would not have been in business for 17 years if wasn’t viable o Parking in front was originally required by city o Could be repurposed as green space o Aware of developer’s plan o Neighborhood does not need more density o Architectural history is not just for the beautiful • PSC o Previous proposal was non-starter o Relocation should not be first options o Retention of original form, features o Appreciate that second floor addition is no longer included o Request condition that any redevelopment take form into consideration • HCF o Oppose relocation o Strong example of adaptive reuse o Represent mid-century development o Preservation standards require consideration of placement o List of structures redeveloped without relocation o Will lose integrity of setting o Disney-ification o Sanitized version of history o Concerns will encourage similar requests • Simons Young, architect, office at 3 Morris o Would be nice for business to occupy corner environment rather than parking lot • Applicant o Retaining orientation to street BOARD COMMENTS: • Complex project • Modest 1950s building, architectural typology recognizable of period. But still very modest • First question, why save it: o Materials, then relocating doesn’t matter o Architecture, unique style. Maybe location doesn’t matter. Could put in museum and would preserve architecture o Relationship to community culture, neighborhood, representation of historic and cultural change • Represents something significant. Worth considering whether placement matters • Representation of 1950s gas station. Even though lost sign and pumps, not sure that matters Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 8, 2026 Page 8 • Shift in society, pattern of change. Socioeconomic and cultural significance • History of it is significant. That building, in that location • Site has had a lot of different things on it • Material and architecture has value. But it has more value than that • If goal is to save the building, and only building and material significant than location doesn’t matter • Maybe evolution should be saved, then additions should be kept • Leaving where it is, is stopping evolution of site. Not bothered by relocation. Allows to keep evolving • For site is appropriate argument, not for building • Appreciate that applicant is keeping building and restoring • Is location important enough to be worthy, or more important to right a wrong • Would you rather see a parking lot or a building anchoring a corner • Neighborhood association has supported project twice, need to listen to that as well • Not about urban planning, about historic building • Since building has been used almost the same amount of time as something different than gas station, significance of structure. Part of different story now • Site better served moving to corner and engaging • Would it be better to have buildings built in front of it • Sometimes it’s better to reposition a building • Secretary of Interior Standards state building should remain in situ 8. 17 Pinckney Street BAR2025-002287 | TMS# 458-05-03-024 | Council District 8 Category 4 | c. 1870 | Old & Historic District Requesting approval for demolition of rear most structure on property. Owner: 14 Anson, LLC Applicant: Dan Sweeney Site visit on 01/08/2026 at 10:30 a.m. DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approval as submitted MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • None STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Staff does not oppose demolition BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • None Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 8, 2026 Page 9 BOARD COMMENTS: • Questions on date of front structure • Reasonable that could be contemporary to front building • Not very visible • Was probably little ancillary building • Back side is new siding • Not much original material remaining 9. 237 King Street BAR2025-002332 | TMS# 457-08-01-059 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Category 2 | c. 1870 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for structural, masonry, and stucco repairs, including paint. Owner: 237 King Street Corporation Applicant: Simons Young DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Approval as submitted with Board conditions and preliminary / final by staff MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • No synthetic material substitutions on building STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Since this is a Category 2, the material change cannot be approved by staff 2. Proposed changes are for emergency repairs BOARD QUESTIONS: • Original cast iron corbel, replace with • Where wood can’t be preserved, replace with GFRC PUBLIC COMMENT: • PSC o Appreciate restoration project o Encourage in kind replacement o If GFRC is approved, should be limited to upper levels BOARD COMMENTS: • Precedent for replacement materials, higher up on building • Generally not in favor of alternative material • Anxiety about replacing cast iron corbel with GFRC, should be replaced in kind • If no compelling reason, would rather go back to match. Have approved before when there is a weight issue • If there is a legitimate structural issue, then all corbels should be analyzed • Detailing of patris plates, location • If structural issue with weight (corbels), come back to Board Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 8, 2026 Page 10 10. 80 Smith Street BAR2025-002275 | TMS# 457-03-02-064 | Harleston Village | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1890 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for rear addition. Owner: Cozy 80 Smith Street LLC Applicant: Cozy Studio LLC DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with board conditions and preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Fenno VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 Recused: Wilson BOARD CONDITIONS: • South elevation, vertical member east of the double doors be eliminated • Corner board be introduced on north elevation separating new from old • Siding profile on addition should differ in profile STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Change to fenestration in existing addition creates a nice rhythm. 2. Proposed addition will be minimally visible. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents BOARD QUESTIONS: • None PUBLIC COMMENT: • HCF o Easement holder, is compliant with easement BOARD COMMENTS: • Understand reasons for not having hyphen, width • Encourage some form of differentiation • South elevation, vertical board introduced, reads as addition. Should be removed • North elevation, lacking a corner board that should be there. Differentiate 11. 105 King Street BAR2025-002296 | TMS# 457-12-04-055 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Rated | c. 1945 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for second story addition and fenestration changes. Owner: Harrison Malpass Applicant: Coastal Creek Design DECISION: DEFERRED MOTION: Deferral for restudy per Board comments Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 8, 2026 Page 11 MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 4 AGAINST: 0 Recused: Wilson BOARD CONDITIONS: • See comments STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Parapet style roof creates awkward conditions. Staff prefer entire roof to be below the eave STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Deferral for restudy per previous Board motion BOARD QUESTIONS: • Visibility of alteration PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Think might be able to get roof below front eave, but not below rear eave • Roof shows hyphen but rest of structure doesn’t • Dislike control joint • Windows on south side much improved • What to do with roof, don’t have an answer • Two masses that don’t relate • Maybe cross gable, could allow eave to be the same height. Die into back roof 12. 19 Ashley Avenue BAR2025-002272 | TMS# 457-07-04-042 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c. 1975 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for fenestration changes. Owner: Ashley Severance Applicant: Scott Parker DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with staff condition and preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents MADE BY: Turner SECOND: Cobb VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Half glass door with existing sidelights would be more appropriate. STAFF CONDITIONS FOR APPROVAL: 1. Half glass door with existing sidelights would be more appropriate. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with Board and staff condition and preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 8, 2026 Page 12 BOARD QUESTIONS: • Are existing windows insulated glass, unknown • New windows will be insulated • Restucco entire house, is window size compensating for that PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Only concern is because it’s a matched townhouse, other side will no longer match • Similar to sister houses, “they’re sisters, not twins” 13. 17 Wentworth Street BAR2025-002274 | TMS# 458-05-01-020 | Ansonborough | Council District 8 Category 2 | c. 1840 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for fenestration changes, new exterior stair, hardscape changes, and roof deck screening. Owner: 17 Wentworth Street LLC Applicant: Julie O’Connor – American Vernacular, Inc. DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • none STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Proposed changes are minimal and improvements to the architectural direction of the structure STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents BOARD QUESTIONS: • Railing on knee wall, on top of deck, material, metal • Shutters on either side of the door, bifold. Existing PUBLIC COMMENT: • none BOARD COMMENTS: • Overall positive changes • Cleans up Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 8, 2026 Page 13 14. 35 Broad Street BAR2025-002266 | TMS# 458-09-03-122 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Category 3 | c. 1792 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for renovations and addition. Owner: 35 Broad LLC Applicant: AJ Architects WITHDRAWN BY STAFF 15. 149 South Battery Street BAR2025-002286 | TMS#457-11-01-018 | Charlestowne | Council District 8 Not Surveyed | c.1938 | Old & Historic District Requesting conceptual approval for fenestration changes to rear façade. Owner: Julia Buthman & Ken Kirsch Applicant: Lauren Sanchez DECISION: APPROVED WITH CONDITIONS MOTION: Conceptual approval with Board condition and preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents MADE BY: Cobb SECOND: Wilson VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 BOARD CONDITIONS: • Rear entry door will be steel STAFF OBSERVATIONS: 1. Proposed changes are minimally visible and appropriate for the structure. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Conceptual approval with preliminary / final review by staff of permit documents BOARD QUESTIONS: • Note #7, steel window, on drawing says aluminum. Proposing steel PUBLIC COMMENT: • None BOARD COMMENTS: • Proposed is improvement to current composition 16. Update to BAR Policies DECISION: APPROVED MOTION: Approve as submitted MADE BY: Van Slambrook SECOND: Turner VOTE: FOR: 5 AGAINST: 0 Board of Architectural Review – Small Meeting Results | January 8, 2026 Page 14 BOARD QUESTIONS: •

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.