RecordWell Data

_01072026-10597

City of Charleston · Berkeley County · meeting of Jan 7, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Charleston

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City of Charleston Commission on History January 7 , 202 6 , P age 1 City of Charleston History Commission January 7 , 2 0 2 6 A meeting of the History Commission was held this date beginning at 4 :0 2 p.m. at City Hall, 80 Broad Street. Notice of this meeting was sent to all local news m e d ia . Present: Harlan Greene, Chair, Elizabeth Chew, Peg Eastman, Wilmot Fraser, Angela Mack, David McCormack, Ken Scarlett, and Dale Theiling. L in k to m eetin g : https://w w w .youtube.com /w atch?v= gkA U P 8IB Q M w & t= 4876s A. Call to Order Chair Greene called the meeting to order . B. Minutes 1. November 5 , 202 5 On a motion of Da vid McCormack , seconded by Peg Eastman, the Commission voted unanimously to approve item B1, as amended. C. Old Business 1. Protect and Respect the Bodies Under the YWCA (106 Coming Street) Update and Discussion Chair Greene gave an update on the item and gave information on upcoming meetings related to the item. The full update can be viewed using the link above. D. Mary Utsey Playground Marker Discussion was held on the item. On a motion of Commissioner Elizabeth Chew, seconded by Commissioner David McCormack, the Commission voted unanimously to approve the below language, as amended. Mary Salvo Utsey October 8, 1920 - July 31, 1969 Mother, homemaker, civic leader and successful business woman, Mary Salvo Utsey loved the City of Charleston and cared deeply for all its citizens. She was happy to serve and did so proudly. City of Charleston Commission on History January 7 , 202 6 , P age 2 First elected in 1959 along with Mayor J . Palmer Gaillard, Jr., Alderman Utsey served two terms, becoming the third woman ever to do so. During her tenure, she served on numerous committees and rose to chair the Board of Playgrounds and the Committee on Public Charities. In 1966, she became the first woman to ever serve as Mayor Pro Tem of the City of Charleston. E. Gadsden Green Marker Discussion was held on the item. Commissioner McCormack said that , by and large, it was a good marker, but that he had a problem with lines 15 and 16 and with the phrase “prolific slave trader. ” He said that the marker was about Gadsden Green, not about Mr. Gadsden, and that such language was irrelevant and denigrated a prominent antebellum Charlestonian. Whether he was a good guy or a bad guy, a doctor, a lawyer, or a slave trader was irrelevant to the marker. Dr . Blake Scott , a resident of the neighborhood and a historian, said that the language was not meant as a denigration , but as an empirical fact. Commissioner McCormack said he did not say it was not factual, but that it was irrelevant to the marker. Dr . Scott said that it was relevant to the marker because the wealth that he generated, in large part, was tied to slavery, and the land which became Gadsden Green, which was owned by him, was tied to the financial capital generated through that process. Commissioner McCormack said that he did not think anyone on the Commission or in the audience would want the only thing people would read about them personally to be one negative aspect of one ’s life. He did not think it was proper. Chair Greene said that to him, it was the irony of the fact that it later became a mostly B lack community that made the history interesting. Commissioner McCormack said he saw it that way, too, but felt that his point was a more important way to look at it. Further discussion was held between the Commission and with members from the public. Commissioner Fraser said that including the line “prolific slave trader ” was important in order to note progress and development from that time to the present, and to explain how he accumulated the property. Chair Greene said that the language was suggested by the South Carolina Department of Archives and History. Dr . Scott confirmed that the words came from the State archives. He said that he wanted it on the record that they had included a description of Thomas N. Gadsden because the creek and the neighborhood were named after him and because it was relevant to know someone ’s primary profession to understand their biography. He was a landowner and a slave trader. He said that if Thomas N. Gadsden had been a lawyer or a doctor, that would have been included. Commissioner Theiling said that the location of the marker should be closer to Spring Street, the school, or a parking lot. It was out of the way. He further said that instead of a marker, an electronic board someplace protected from weather and vandalism with a QR code would be City of Charleston Commission on History January 7 , 202 6 , P age 3 better. It could explain in greater detail and include far more information. Ms. Laurel Fay , of the Preservation Society of Charleston, said that the position which was chosen was recommended by Dr. Edwin Breeden after a number of options were discussed. It was a public park and was adjacent to the neighborhood and Gadsden Creek. Commissioner Scarlett asked if Dr. Nic Butler had been consulted. He also asked if the property deeds had been researched regarding whether the owners were freed or enslaved. Ms. Fay said they did not research individual parcels in great detail for the marker, but the packet included details about individuals, families, and businesses that were there. She said that she had informed Dr. Butler that the marker was in progress and that he had shared some of his research about the earlier history of the site. She said they were limited in character count on the marker, but it was their goal to be able to place a QR code on a marker like this to link to their website where they could provide more context. Further discussion was held. On a motion of David McCormack, seconded by Peg Eastman, the Commission voted on whether to strike “and prolific slave trader ” from the language. The motion faile d . The vote was not unanimous. Chair Greene, Elizabeth Chew, Wilmot Fraser, and Angela Mack voted against. Commissioner Mack suggested moving to Side 2. The Commission agreed by acclamation. Ms. Mack said she wanted to know more information regarding the transition to being “a popular fishing and swimming spot. ” She felt that it eventually getting filled in and becoming a dump site was more important than the origin. It was a thriving community, and she wanted to know what happened to make it disappear. Dr. Scott said the marker was meant to show change over time, and that they only had about a sentence per generation. There were municipal records stating that it was a designated spot for African American children to swim. Ms. Mack asked why that information was not on there. Dr. Scott said that was in “a popular fishing and swimming spot, ” and they only had 27 characters per line. Chair Greene said there was so much information submitted with the application . He said the requesters could ask the SCDAH and request more. Further discussion was held. Chair Greene asked the submitters if they were happy with the language. Ms. Fay said they were. They were interested in sharing more information with the public through QR codes, but they felt they had achieved a balanced narrative that explained the history of the site through the marker. Commissioner Theiling suggested changing “generally bounded by ” to “currently bounded by ” on Side 1. Ms. Fay said “currently bounded by ” would be accurate. Further discussion was held on Side 2. On a motion of Wilmot Fraser, seconded by Elizabeth Chew, the Commission voted to approve Side 2. The vote was not unanimous. David McCormack abstained. Further discussion was held on Side 1. City of Charleston Commission on History January 7 , 202 6 , P age 4 On a motion of Wilmot Fraser, seconded by Dale Theiling, the Commission voted to approve Side 1 as amended. The vote was not unanimous. David McCormack and Peg Eastman voted against. Side 1 GADSDEN GREEN |T1 The neighborhood of Gadsden|1 Green, also called Fiddlers|2 Green or Back da Green, |3 began around 1852. In that |4 year, landowner and prolific|5 slave trader Thomas N. |6 Gadsden subdivided a tract |7 currently bounded by Cannon|8 St., President St., and |9 Gadsden Creek. The marsh at|10 that time extended several |11 blocks further inland along|12 Line St. By 1900 the area |13 was a racially diverse but |14 mostly Black community with|15 1- and 2-story homes, small|16 grocery stores, a shipyard,|17 wharf, and sawmill. |18 (continued on next side) SPONSORED BY PRESERVATION SOCIETY OF CHARLESTON AND FRIENDS OF GADSDEN CREEK, 2026 Side 2 GADSDEN GREEN |T1 (continued from other side) In 1938 the neighborhood |1 was damaged by tornadoes. |2 Over the protest of local |3 residents, the City of |4 Charleston subsequently |5 demolished much of the |6 neighborhood to build |7 Gadsden Green Homes, |8 a segregated public housing|9 complex opened in 1942 and |10 expanded in 1968. From 1954|11 to 1970, the City filled |12 Gadsden Creek and 100 acres|13 of saltmarsh with municipal|14 waste and soil for a City | 15 dump and urban development,|16 City of Charleston Commission on History January 7 , 202 6 , P age 5 in what had been a popular |17 fishing and swimming spot. |18 SPONSORED BY PRESERVATION SOCIETY OF CHARLESTON AND FRIENDS OF GADSDEN CREEK, 2026 F. Update on 1947 Robert E. Lee Memorial Highway Roadside Marker (Commissioner Dale Theiling) Commissioner Theiling gave an update regarding the placement of the 1947 Robert E. Lee Memorial Highway Roadside Marker in Marion Square. The full update can be viewed using the link above at 1:21:08. The marker was originally installed in 1947 within city limits on the grounds of Rivers High School on upper King Street, placed by the United Daughters of the Confederacy and the City to identify the Highway. The marker was reestablished in Marion Square on December 11. Discussion on the update was held. Mr. Andy Brack said he wanted to know by what process the City released the marker. Chair Greene said it was information he was unaware of. Commissioner Theiling said the UDC had let the Board of Field Officers of the Fourth Brigade know that the City would release the marker to the UDC if they had a place to put it. The Board was not a party to that agreement. Chair Greene said the UDC would have that information. Commissioner Theiling said the City would, also. Commissioner Fraser said he was “unpleasantly surprised ” to see that the marker had been put back up without any public commentary. He said there had been major changes since 1947. He said it was the kind of thing that made one believe that the change and decency that Charleston usually stood for was absent in current times. He said it was an insulting monument meant to resurrect the Lost Cause argument. He thought it was very important for the City , which had already gone on record apologizing for the crimes of slavery, to stand on its word and remove the monument that it had allowed to reappear on a major thoroughfare. He encouraged Commissioner Theiling to help remove the monument because it was divisive . Mr. Jerome Harris said the City needed advice regarding the divisiveness of monuments and their placement. He recommended to the Commission the History and Culture Subcommittee ’s report in the report by the Commission on Equity, Inclusion, and Racial Conciliation. Commissioner Theiling said he did not know people who were trying to resurrect the Confederacy. Commissioner Fraser said that someone was, because someone resurrected the monument. Commissioner Theiling said that was not the goal, purpose, or impetus for the monument ’s placement. He quoted the Board ’s guiding precept is that “any addition to its historic property would represent Charleston ’s place in military service and history or would further the public understanding of Marion Square. ” The monument was a part of history not only from the Civil War, but also from 1947. It was offered to the Board under the precept that the Board considered it important and that they were there to protect South Carolina and Charleston ’s military history. He said he did not know anyone who was trying to resurrect the Confederacy. Commissioner Fraser said that the people who created the monument were. Asking the City of Charleston to support that effort was not a tenable position. He said the UDC existed to City of Charleston Commission on History January 7 , 202 6 , P age 6 perpetuate and memorialize the Confederacy, despite people like Robert E. Lee, who said that would be divisive. There had been many problems as a result. G. Miscellaneous Business None. H. Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 5 :4 4 p .m . Philip E . C la p p e r Assistant Clerk of Council

Source: City of Charleston website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.