RecordWell Data

_01292026-2104

Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Jan 29, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

TREE TASK FORCE Thursday, January 29, 2026 8:00 a.m. Municipal Complex, Committee Meeting Room 100 Ann Edwards Lane, Mount Pleasant, SC 29464 MI NUTES Click here to listen to the recording Discussion Topics 1. Call to Order Chair James McKee called the meeting to order at 8:02 a.m. David Quick, Michelle Mansour, Shanna Harris, Deidre Kennedy and George Grice were all present. Edward Oswald was absent. 2. Approval of Agenda A motion to approve the agenda was made by Mr. Quick and seconded by Ms. Kennedy. The motion carried unanimously. 3. Approval of Minutes from December 4, 2025 Meeting Chair McKee asked for a motion to approve the minutes from December 4, 2025. Ms. Mansour made a motion to approve the minutes. Mr. Quick seconded the motion with a note about revisions that were sent regarding comments. Christiane Farrell explained that Ms. Barrett had reviewed the recording and confirmed that what was recorded was accurate. She suggested that rather than amending the minutes, they could acknowledge Mr. Quick's email clarification on the record. The clarification related to comments made by Filippo from the South Carolina Environmental Law Center at the previous meeting. Filippo had made a suggestion about tying the number of trees to population. He meant to tie it to the whole population but actually said new population or new people. The committee agreed to acknowledge this clarification without formally amending the minutes. The motion to approve the minutes passed unanimously. Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 2 of 21 4. Public Comment Chair McKee opened the floor for public comment. Seeing no members of the public wishing to speak, he moved on to the next agenda item. 5. Review of Guide/Outline for Development of Final Report The committee discussed the structure for organizing their final report. Mr. O’Neill presented a framework that categorized the issues raised into several topics: assessing existing programs and activities (what is working and what is not), encouraging protection, planting, maintenance, regulation enforcement, process procedures, education and partnerships. Mr. O’Neill explained that as the committee works through conversations and reaches conclusions, they could organize findings into these categories, making the final report easier to compile and deliver. The approach would allow them to capture discussions systematically and translate them into the final report format. Mr. Quick suggested adding staffing as a separate category, noting that sufficient staffing would be crucial to accomplishing their goals. The committee agreed that staffing and resources should be explicitly included as a category that would touch on all other areas. When discussing education and partnerships, Mr. Quick asked whether outreach should be added to that category or if it was already implied. Final Report Outline • Assessing the existing programs and activities: what is working-what is not. • Encouraging protection. • Planting. • Maintenance. • Regulation and enforcement. • Processes and procedures. • Education and partnership. Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 3 of 21 He explained that outreach represents a more active effort compared to passive education. The committee agreed to add outreach to the education and partnerships category. Ms. Mansour asked about including funding under the education category. Chair McKee clarified that funding would be covered under the staffing and resources category, which encompasses funding, grants, and financial aspects. Ms. Mansour noted that funding would also naturally arise in discussions about partnerships and how different elements work together. The committee discussed where to place the goal and purpose section. Mr. O’Neill suggested leading with it at the beginning and concluding with it at the end, emphasizing not burying the lead. Chair McKee agreed that starting with the goal and purpose would establish why the council created the task force and what they aim to accomplish. This theme would then be reinforced throughout each section of the report. The committee reached consensus on this organizational structure for the final report. 6. Work Plan TTF 2026 Work Plan a. Continued Discussion of Overarching Goals Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 4 of 21 Ms. Farrell presented slides showing the outline approved at the last meeting and what the committee had requested in their minutes. She organized the presentation into three sections: canopy goals, plantings, and public education, with some overlap between topics. Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 5 of 21 Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 6 of 21 The next slides, prepared by Ms. Kennedy, compared canopy coverage data from nearby municipalities. Ms. Kennedy explained that the data showed current canopy coverage, potential canopy goals, and whether communities planned to maintain or grow their canopy. She noted that many communities were only aiming to maintain their current canopy, as growing even one percent requires significant work and time. Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 7 of 21 Chair McKee reported on his conversation with the Green Infrastructure Center about standards for calculating canopy percentage. Their guidance was to exclude marsh and large bodies of water from calculations, which would result in using the 38 percent figure rather than 27 percent for Mount Pleasant. This standard would allow consistent regional comparisons across coastal towns. The committee reviewed several data sources: the comprehensive plan showing 38 percent canopy coverage when excluding marsh, the master plan showing 27 percent including marsh, and district-by-district breakdowns. Ms. Farrell noted that while the data was somewhat dated, with Carolina Park likely showing the most change, other areas had probably not changed as significantly. Mr. Grice expressed concern about setting a percentage goal, given that it takes 15 to 20 years to change the canopy by one percent. He felt a more meaningful goal would be planting a specific number of trees rather than targeting a percentage that would take decades to verify. Mr. Quick suggested excluding certain areas like Laurel Hill County Park from calculations since they represent natural areas not subject to urban infrastructure pressures. He noted the challenge of determining what to count, when to count it, and how recent clear-cutting in areas like Carolina Park would affect numbers. Ms. Kennedy suggested that while percentage numbers might be important for the town to track internally, the public would be more interested in tangible information about residential areas - how much has been lost and how it will be regained. She felt that showing comparative images from 20 years ago to now would evoke more emotional response and engagement from residents. Ms. Mansour proposed using both approaches - a percentage goal that accounts for future development and redevelopment, combined with a specific tree planting number. This would address both long-term canopy goals and immediate action items. The committee discussed whether to aim for maintaining current canopy or increasing it. While Mr. Grice would be satisfied with sustaining current levels, Mr. Quick suggested targeting 40 percent as an achievable goal. Ms. Mansour emphasized the importance of both reaching and maintaining that level over time. After extensive discussion, the committee reached consensus on setting a goal of 40 percent canopy coverage over 20 years, with reviews every five years aligned with comprehensive plan updates. They also agreed Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 8 of 21 to target 20,000 net new trees over 20 years, equating to 1,000 trees annually. Mr. Quick moved to adopt a goal of 40 percent canopy coverage with 20,000 net new trees over the next 20 years. Chair McKee seconded the motion. The motion passed unanimously. Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 9 of 21 Canopy Goal Canopy Increase A 2% canopy increase requires 20,000 new trees planted at a rough estimate of $6.7 million (the 20,000 trees assumes a 5% attrition rate). *See later slides regarding price per tree . TreesPer Acre No rule of thumb • 42 trees/ acre (1980s study) • 30 feet on center to 50-60 feet on center for street trees= 16 to 40 trees/ acre Source: CFMP and TTF member Jamie McKee; Staff arborists Mapping Planting Locations • Town owned properties to include public tree inventory, infrastructure (pipes) • Current tree density • Identify plantable spaces; With input from Recreation and Public Services to remove areas that are not plantable (current field use, irrigation availability, etc.) • Develop plans in appropriate spaces; With input from Town arborists to develop planting plans to include species, spacing, soils Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 10 of 21 58.8 acres 555 trees 9.42 trees/ acre 5460 inches 92.73 inches/ acre 20.36 acres 248 trees 12.18 trees/ acre 2682 inches 131.73 inches/ acre Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 11 of 21 Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 12 of 21 28’ 28’ 48’ 48’ Live Oaks at Mt Pleasant Memorial Garden entrance drive ~30 trees to acre Live Oaks - median Wakendaw Blvd 38’-42’o.c. If a grid would be ~26 trees to acre Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 13 of 21 36’ Pecan orchard at Rifle Range Rd/ Venning Roundabout 40’ ~30 trees to acre Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 14 of 21 Plantings versus payments (what is the strategy) • How to achieve canopy goals • Current program assessments showing existing tree planting quantities Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 15 of 21 Cost Per Tree Canopy Restoration/ Tree Planting Projects 2024= $12,000 (9 trees) Average Cost= approx. $1200/ tree Planting versus Payments Source Town Staff Purchasing Records Cost Per Tree • $125.00 per tree purchase • $20.00 for a watering bag • $10.00 for tree stakes • $210.00 in labor to plant, prune and water the tree for the first 2 years (these only cover establishment of the tree) Planting versus Payments Source Matthew Lee Green Infrastructure Center email to TTF member Jamie McKee Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 16 of 21 Participation and Community Education Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 17 of 21 The committee then discussed the importance of improving tracking systems for tree gains and losses. Currently, residential tree permits are well-tracked, but commercial and engineering department removals are not systematically recorded in databases, though the information exists on plan sheets. The committee agreed that recommendations should include improving systematic tracking across all departments to monitor progress toward their goals. Ms. Farrell presented information on plantable areas and tree planting considerations. She explained that staff had been analyzing public properties using GIS data and the public tree inventory. The analysis showed existing tree locations, infrastructure constraints, and potential planting opportunities. Mr. Bernard had photographed several town properties to illustrate different planting densities and purposes. Examples ranged from 30 trees per acre at some locations to very dense plantings at others. The committee discussed how planting purpose - whether for shade, stormwater management, or habitat - would influence species selection, spacing, and ultimately cost. The public tree inventory had already identified 249 stumps and 1,054 vacant sites, totaling approximately 1,200 immediate planting opportunities on town property. This did not include additional open space areas that might accommodate more trees. CFMP Goals – and Short Term Actions to Achieve Goal 5: Foster Community Advocacy and Participation in Community Forest Efforts      Participation and Community Education Source October 2025 TTF meeting Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 18 of 21 Cost analysis showed that recent restoration programs averaged $1,200 per tree, with trees themselves representing only half the cost. Water was identified as the largest expense component. Mr. Quick noted that these costs reflected contracted work using larger instant-gratification trees requiring extensive watering. He suggested that using smaller 3 to 5 gallon trees and improving planting efficiency could reduce costs. Mr. Grice found pricing of $26 per tree for 3-gallon native species, emphasizing that labor and maintenance represented the larger cost components. The committee discussed focusing initial efforts on public and institutional areas as low-hanging fruit, providing time to develop strategies for engaging private property owners including churches, schools, and homeowners associations. When discussing the purpose and prioritization for tree planting, the committee identified multiple benefits: shade and livability, stormwater management, wildlife habitat, economic value through property values and energy savings, and quality of life improvements including safety along streets and recreational areas. Chair McKee emphasized prioritizing shade for livability and stormwater management as the primary justifications that would resonate most with the public and justify town expenditures. While acknowledging other benefits like carbon sequestration and wildlife habitat, he noted these were less compelling arguments for public funding compared to tangible benefits like flood prevention and comfortable walking areas. The committee agreed that their first priority should be planting in public and institutional areas where the town already has control, using the existing inventory of 1,200 identified planting sites as a starting point. They recognized that achieving their goals would require engaging private property, which represents 90 percent of potential planting area. b. Begin Discussion of Structure and Management of Tree Program and Outline Information Needed for February Meeting Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 19 of 21 Working Well • Programs • Education and Outreach through Take Root and similar efforts (invasive species, Arbor Day, etc.) • New initiatives for canopy restoration using tree bank funds • Public Tree Inventory- Final Report= 17,076 trees, 249 stumps, 1054 vacant sites • Ordinance • Ordinance framework and policies generally strong • New permit fee • New requirement to plant at least one 2 ½ inch tree • New provisions for illegally removed trees , discretion with hazard trees, etc. • Qualified staff • Four certified arborists plus two more in training • Experienced in land development , site work, drainage, and ordinances Participation and Community Education Source October 2025 TTF meeting Challenges/ Needs Improvement • Programs • Tree Bank Grant- underutilized • Ordinance • New Tree Protection Zone • Increased BOZA applications • Discretion leads to inconsistencies and uncertainties for homeowners • Appears to be encouraging removal over encroachment • More restrictive for residential than commercial • No consideration of existing canopy, "one size fits all approach" can be excessive in some cases • Enforcement • Compliance with mitigation- payments and/ or plantings • Maintaining tree protection during construction • Boundary trees or trees on adjacent properties • Software program- not intuitive for tree applications and processes Participation and Community Education Source October 2025 TTF meeting Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 20 of 21 Mr. O’Neill outlined the approach for the February meeting, which would focus on assessing the strengths and weaknesses of existing programs. The committee would evaluate what is working well, what needs improvement, identify gaps, and develop recommendations for program improvements. The assessment would cover various program elements including planting programs, maintenance, regulations, enforcement, and partnerships. For each element, the committee would determine what to keep, what to modify, and what new initiatives to add. This would naturally lead to discussions about staffing, funding, and equipment needs to support the recommended programs. Ms. Farrell showed slides highlighting programs that need improvement, including underutilized grant programs and challenges with private property tree requirements. She confirmed that staff, including an arborist, would be available at the February meeting to answer questions about these programs. The committee confirmed they had received the materials needed for the February discussion and would review previous presentations to prepare for the assessment of existing programs. 7. Discuss Next Agenda Other Tree Projects/ Other Funding Sources • Community Forest Master Plan Grant • Grant funded with 20% Town match from General Fund at $15K • Tree Inventory Grant • Grant funded with 20% To wn ma tch fromGeneral Fund at $33K • Tree Plantings and maintenance by Public Services= • $230K in FY25 (General Fund, not Tree Bank) • Capital Projects (Project cost, not Tree Bank) • Example: All American Blvd= • Partnership initiatives • Bradford/ Tallow Bounty= $0 costs to Town Landscaping Design$ 19,400.00 Landscaping Installation$ 259,786.51 Irrigation Installation$ 254,247.22 Tree Mitigation$ 160,000.00 Anticipated Annual Water Bill$ 12,000.00 Anticipated Annual Maintenance$ 45,000.00 Participation and Community Education Source October 2025 TTF meeting Tree Task Force January 29, 2026 Page 21 of 21 The committee confirmed the agenda for the February meeting would focus on assessing existing tree programs, identifying what works well and what needs improvement, and beginning to develop specific recommendations for program enhancements. 8. Adjourn There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 9:48 a.m. Respectfully submitted, Christine Barrett Clerk of Council January 29, 2026 Begin discussion of Structure and Management of Tree Program and outline information needed for February meeting • Staffing and leadership- current and future • See also under Funding • Decision making (ordinance/ funding/ programs) • Define management of planting program • Assess existing programs • Processes • Efficiency

Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.