_01052026-2091
Town of Mount Pleasant · Charleston County · meeting of Jan 5, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Mount Pleasant
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
TOWN OF MOUNT PLEASANT, SOUTH CAROLINA
POLICE, JUDICIAL & LEGAL COMMITTEE
Monday, January 5, 2026
11:30 a.m.
Municipal Complex, Council Chambers
100 Ann Edwards Lane, Mount Pleasant, SC 29464
Minutes
Click here to listen to the recording.
1. Call to Order
Mayor Haynie called the Police, Judicial & Legal Committee meeting
was to order on Monday, January 5, 2026, at 11:43 AM in Mount
Pleasant, SC. Council Members Alex Crosby, Mike Tinkey and Howard
Chapman were all present.
The Chair opened with holiday greetings and expressed gratitude to first
responders and public service workers who had been on duty during the
holiday season.
2. Approval of Minutes from the December 1, 2025 Meeting
The committee reviewed the minutes from the December 1, 2025,
meeting.
A motion to approve the minutes from the December 1, 2025, meeting
was made by Mr. Chapman. The motion was seconded by Ms. Crosby.
The motion was approved unanimously.
3. Public Comments
Mr. Craig Tozzolino of 1431 Glencoe Drive addressed the committee
regarding challenges he has faced with the enforcement of the town's
noise ordinance. He detailed a two-and-a-half-year dispute with Publix
Supermarket regarding noise violations. Mr. Tozzolino explained that the
current ordinance is designed to hold business owners rather than
employees responsible for violations, which creates enforcement
difficulties when dealing with large corporations like Publix.
Mr. Tozzolino shared his experiences with the court system, noting that
the Town Prosecutor (Mr. Grossman) had expressed concerns about
whether tickets were being issued to the correct parties. He indicated
that police officers had told him they were reluctant to write tickets that
Police, Judicial, Legal Committee
January 5, 2026
Page 2 of 3
might not hold up in court and that many officers seemed unclear about
aspects of the law.
He also mentioned problems with amplified music from a business called
"My Father's Mustache," stating that police had told him they must be
able to hear the noise inside his home to issue a citation, even at 1:00
AM. Mr. Tozzolino noted confusion about whether windows should be
open or closed when police assess noise levels and questioned his right
to have windows open without hearing music from the bar after 9:00 PM.
4. Police Matters
a. Employee Years of Service
The Police Chief Mark Arnold reported that Officer German had reached
5 years of service with the department. The Chief described Officer
German as a fantastic employee who is a member of the training cadre,
instructs new officers, and serves on the harbor unit. Officer German
had recently met all requirements to be promoted to Senior Police
Officer. The committee expressed their appreciation for Officer German's
service and asked that their recognition be conveyed to her.
5. Judicial Matters
a. Discussion and Possible Action Regarding Procedures for
Municipal Judge Reappointment Process
The Chair introduced the topic, explaining that the current process
requires advertising judicial positions when terms expire, even when
sitting judges are seeking reappointment. He noted that in his 8 years of
experience, every sitting judge who applied for reappointment had been
reappointed, and while many qualified applicants submit applications,
having a history of good service as a judge is the strongest qualification.
The Town Clerk clarified that judges serve 2-year terms with
appointments staggered between June/July and November/December.
Currently, when terms expire, the town reaches out to judges to confirm
their interest in continuing to serve, and those wishing to be reappointed
submit a letter of interest before being considered by Council.
The Town Attorney confirmed that there is no interview process required
by ordinance or state law, and the committee and Council have flexibility
in how they manage appointments. He explained that the committee
could choose to simply reappoint sitting judges without advertising
Police, Judicial, Legal Committee
January 5, 2026
Page 3 of 3
positions or holding interviews, or they could open positions to
applications as they have done in the past.
The committee discussed a potential process where:
● When judges' terms expire, the committee would review their
performance in executive session (as it involves personnel
matters)
● If the committee sees no reason not to reappoint sitting judges,
they would recommend reappointment to full Council
● If there is a vacancy, the position would be advertised and
interviews would be conducted
One committee member raised a concern about the potential unintended
consequences if the committee decided to seek applications for one
judge position but not others that were up for reappointment at the same
time, which might appear unfair or non-transparent.
The committee agreed to proceed with the more streamlined approach
while ensuring fairness and transparency in the process. No formal
action was required as the current ordinance was deemed flexible
enough to accommodate this approach.
6. Legal Matters
a. No Agenda Items
There were no legal matters to discuss.
7. Adjourn
The meeting was adjourned at 11:59 am.
Respectfully submitted,
Nancy Hanf
1/5/2026
Source: Town of Mount Pleasant website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.